Targeted expression of a dominant-negative FGF receptor mutant in the epidermis of transgenic mice reveals a role of FGF in keratinocyte organization and differentiation.

In this study we used a dominant-negative FGF receptor mutant to block FGF function in a specific tissue of transgenic mice. The mutant receptor, which is known to block signal transduction in cells when co-expressed with wild-type receptors, was targeted to suprabasal keratinocytes using a keratin 10 promoter. The transgene was expressed specifically in the skin and highest expression levels were found in the tail. Expression of the mutant receptor disrupted the organization of epidermal keratinocytes, induced epidermal hyperthickening and resulted in an aberrant expression of keratin 6. This suggests that FGF is essential for the morphogenesis of suprabasal keratinocytes and for the establishment of the normal program of keratinocyte differentiation. Our study demonstrates that dominant-negative growth factor receptors can be used to block selectively the action of a growth factor in specific tissues of transgenic mice.     

Transforming growth factor-beta-activated kinase 1 is essential for differentiation and the prevention of apoptosis in epidermis

Transforming growth factor-beta-activated kinase 1 (TAK1) is a member of the mitogen-activated protein (MAP) kinase family and is an upstream signaling molecule of nuclear factor-kappaB (NF-kappaB). Given that NF-kappaB regulates keratinocyte differentiation and apoptosis, TAK1 may be essential for epidermal functions. To test this, we generated keratinocyte-specific TAK1-deficient mice from Map3k7(flox/flox) mice and K5-Cre mice. The keratinocyte-specific TAK1-deficient mice were macroscopically indistinguishable from their littermates until postnatal day 2 or 3, when the skin started to roughen and wrinkle. This phenotype progressed, and the mice died by postnatal day 7. Histological analysis showed thickening of the epidermis with foci of keratinocyte apoptosis and intra-epidermal micro-abscesses. Immunohistochemical analysis showed that the suprabasal keratinocytes of the TAK1-deficient epidermis expressed keratin 5 and keratin 14, which are normally confined to the basal layer. The expression of keratin 1, keratin 10, and loricrin, which are markers for the suprabasal and late phase differentiation of the epidermis, was absent from the TAK1-deficient epidermis. Furthermore, the TAK1-deficient epidermis expressed keratin 16 and had an increased number of Ki67-positive cells. These data indicate that TAK1 deficiency in keratinocytes results in abnormal differentiation, increased proliferation, and apoptosis in the epidermis. However, the keratinocytes from the TAK1-deficient epidermis induced keratin 1 in suspension culture, indicating that the TAK1-deficient keratinocytes retain the ability to differentiate. Moreover, the removal of TAK1 from cultured keratinocytes of Map3k7(flox/flox) mice resulted in apoptosis, indicating that TAK1 is essential for preventing apoptosis. In conclusion, TAK1 is essential in the regulation of keratinocyte growth, differentiation, and apoptosis.     

Cortactin involvement in the keratinocyte growth factor and fibroblast growth factor 10 promotion of migration and cortical actin assembly in human keratinocytes

Keratinocyte growth factor (KGF/FGF7) and fibroblast growth factor 10 (FGF10/KGF2) regulate keratinocyte proliferation and differentiation by binding to the tyrosine kinase KGF receptor (KGFR). KGF induces keratinocyte motility and cytoskeletal rearrangement, whereas a direct role of FGF10 on keratinocyte migration is not clearly established. Here we analyzed the motogenic activity of FGF10 and KGF on human keratinocytes. Migration assays and immunofluorescence of actin cytoskeleton revealed that FGF10 is less efficient than KGF in promoting migration and exerts a delayed effect in inducing lamellipodia and ruffles formation. Both growth factors promoted phosphorylation and subsequent membrane translocation of cortactin, an F-actin binding protein involved in cell migration; however, FGF10-induced cortactin phosphorylation was reduced, more transient and delayed with respect to that promoted by KGF. Cortactin phosphorylation induced by both growth factors was Src-dependent, while its membrane translocation and cell migration were blocked by either Src and PI3K inhibitors, suggesting that both pathways are involved in KGF- and FGF10-dependent motility. Furthermore, siRNA-mediated downregulation of cortactin inhibited KGF- and FGF10-induced migration. These results indicate that cortactin is involved in keratinocyte migration promoted by both KGF and FGF10.     

Suppression of keratin 15 expression by transforming growth factor beta in vitro and by cutaneous injury in vivo

Transforming growth factor beta (TGF-beta) is a multifunctional cytokine which plays an important role in cutaneous wound repair. To gain insight into the mechanisms of action of this growth and differentiation factor in the skin, we searched for genes which are regulated by TGF-beta1 in cultured HaCaT keratinocytes. Using the differential display RT-PCR technology we identified a gene which was strongly downregulated by TGF-beta1. The identified cDNA includes sequences of the keratin 15 (K15) gene which encodes a component of the cytoskeleton of basal cells in stratified epithelia. Surprisingly, our cDNA also included an unknown sequence. Since this cDNA lacks an open reading frame, the corresponding mRNA is likely to be nonfunctional. However, we also demonstrate a strong negative regulation of the expression of the published, functional K15 variant. Expression of K15 was also suppressed by tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNF-alpha) and to a lesser extent by epidermal growth factor (EGF) and keratinocyte growth factor (KGF). By contrast, the major basal type I keratin, K14, was upregulated by TGF-beta1, whereas TNF-alpha, EGF, and KGF had no effect. Consistent with the in vitro data, we found a significant reduction of the K15 mRNA levels after skin injury, whereas K14 expression increased during the wound healing process. Immunostaining revealed the presence of K15 in all basal cells of the epidermis adjacent to the wound, but not in the hyperproliferative epithelium above the granulation tissue. These data demonstrate that K15 is excluded from the activated keratinocytes of the hyperthickened wound epidermis, possibly as a result of increased growth factor expression in injured skin.     

Keratinocyte growth factor stimulates migration and hyaluronan synthesis in the epidermis by activation of keratinocyte hyaluronan synthases 2 and 3

Keratinocyte growth factor (KGF) activates keratinocyte migration and stimulates wound healing. Hyaluronan, an extracellular matrix glycosaminoglycan that accumulates in wounded epidermis, is known to promote cell migration, suggesting that increased synthesis of hyaluronan might be associated with the KGF response in keratinocytes. Treatment of monolayer cultures of rat epidermal keratinocytes led to an elongated and lifted cell shape, increased filopodial protrusions, enhanced cell migration, accumulation of intermediate size hyaluronan in the culture medium and within keratinocytes, and a rapid increase of hyaluronan synthase 2 (Has2) mRNA, suggesting a direct influence on this gene. In stratified, organotypic cultures of the same cell line, both Has2 and Has3 with the hyaluronan receptor CD44 were up-regulated and hyaluronan accumulated in the epidermis, the spinous cell layer in particular. At the same time the expression of the early differentiation marker keratin 10 was inhibited, whereas filaggrin expression and epidermal permeability were less affected. The data indicate that Has2 and Has3 belong to the targets of KGF in keratinocytes, and support the idea that enhanced hyaluronan synthesis acts an effector for the migratory response of keratinocytes in wound healing, whereas it may delay keratinocyte terminal differentiation.     

The ink4a/arf tumor suppressors cooperate with p21cip1/waf in the processes of mouse epidermal differentiation, senescence, and carcinogenesis

In mammalian cells, cell cycle withdrawal is a prerequisite for terminal differentiation. Accordingly, in most tissues, including epidermis, the expression of the cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitors increases during differentiation. However, the actual role of cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitors is unclear. Different aspects of epidermal growth and differentiation in ink4a(Delta2,3)-null, p21-null, and ink4a(Delta2,3)/p21-doubly deficient mice were studied. Altered differentiation and decreased age-related senescence were found in the epidermis of ink4a(Delta2,3)/p21-null mice and, to a lesser extent, in ink4a(Delta2,3)- and p21-null mice. ink4a(Delta2,3)/p21-null primary keratinocytes underwent cell cycle arrest upon calcium or transforming growth factor-beta treatment, but failed to differentiate. This differentiation deficiency was not observed in p21- or ink4a(Delta2,3)-deficient keratinocytes. Upon infection with a v-Ha-ras-coding retrovirus, wild-type keratinocytes displayed features indicative of premature cell senescence. In p21- or ink4a(Delta2,3)-deficient keratinocytes, only a partial response was observed. ink4a(Delta2,3)/p21-deficient keratinocytes did not display senescent features, but showed increased tumorigenic potential upon injection into nude mice. These results indicate that ink4a/arf and cip1/waf genes cooperate to allow normal keratinocyte differentiation and that the absence of both favors malignant transformation.     

In vitro differentiation of murine embryonic stem cells into keratinocyte-like cells

Embryonic stem (ES) cells are omnipotent; they can differentiate into every cell type of the body. The development of culture conditions that allow their differentiation has made it conceivable to produce large numbers of cells with lineage-specific characteristics in vitro. Here, we describe a method by which murine ES cells can be differentiated into cells with characteristics of epidermal keratinocytes. Keratinocyte-like cells were isolated from embryoid bodies and grown in culture. Potential applications of this method are the in vitro differentiation of cells of interest from ES cells of mice with lethal phenotypes during embryonic development and the production of genetically modified epidermal keratinocytes that could be used as temporary wound dressing or as carriers of genes of interest in gene therapeutic treatments.     

Cholesteatoma-associated fibroblasts modulate epithelial growth and differentiation through KGF/FGF7 secretion

The keratinocyte growth factor (KGF/FGF7), produced by stromal cells, is a key paracrine mediator of epithelial proliferation, differentiation and migration. Expression of the growth factor is increased in wound healing and in hyperproliferative epithelial diseases, as a consequence of the activation of dermal fibroblasts by the inflammatory microenvironment. The middle ear cholesteatoma, an aural epidermal pathology characterized by keratinocyte hyperproliferation and chronic inflammation, may represent a model condition to study the epithelial-mesenchymal interactions. To develop an in vitro model for this disease, we isolated and characterized human primary cultures of fibroblasts associated with the cholesteatoma lesion, analyzing their secretory behaviour and degree of differentiation or activation. Compared to the perilesional or control normal fibroblasts, all cultures derived from cholesteatoma tissues were less proliferating and more differentiated and their highly variable activated phenotype correlated with the secretion of KGF as well as of metalloproteases 2 and 9. Culture supernatants collected from the cholesteatoma-associated fibroblasts were able to increase the proliferation and differentiation of human keratinocytes assessed by the expression of Ki67 and keratin-1 markers. The single crucial contribution of the KGF released by fibroblasts on the keratinocyte biological response was shown by the specific, although partial, block induced by inhibiting the KGF receptor or by immunoneutralizing the growth factor. Altogether, these results suggest that the activation of the stromal fibroblasts present in the pathological tissue, and the consequent increased secretion of KGF, play a crucial role in the deregulation of the epidermal proliferation and differentiation.     

The role of cathepsin E in terminal differentiation of keratinocytes

Cathepsin E (CatE) is predominantly expressed in the rapidly regenerating gastric mucosal cells and epidermal keratinocytes, in addition to the immune system cells. However, the role of CatE in these cells remains unclear. Here we report a crucial role of CatE in keratinocyte terminal differentiation. CatE deficiency in mice induces abnormal keratinocyte differentiation in the epidermis and hair follicle, characterized by the significant expansion of corium and the reduction of subcutaneous tissue and hair follicle. In a model of skin papillomas formed in three different genotypes of syngeneic mice, CatE deficiency results in significantly reduced expression and altered localization of the keratinocyte differentiation induced proteins, keratin 1 and loricrin. Involvement of CatE in the regulation of the expression of epidermal differentiation specific proteins was corroborated by in vitro studies with primary cultures of keratinocytes from the three different genotypes of mice. In wild-type keratinocytes after differentiation inducing stimuli, the CatE expression profile was compatible to those of the terminal differentiation marker genes tested. Overexpression of CatE in mice enhances the keratinocyte terminal differentiation process, whereas CatE deficiency results in delayed differentiation accompanying the reduced expression or the ectopic localization of the differentiation markers. Our findings suggest that in keratinocytes CatE is functionally linked to the expression of terminal differentiation markers, thereby regulating epidermis formation and homeostasis.     

Vitamin D enhances mitogenesis mediated by keratinocyte growth factor receptor in keratinocytes

The hormonally active vitamin D metabolite, 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D(3) (1,25(OH)(2)D(3)), and keratinocyte growth factor (KGF) belong to the network of autocrine and paracrine mediators in the skin. Both were shown to modulate keratinocyte proliferation, to reverse epidermal atrophy, to increase wound healing, and to reduce chemotherapy-induced alopecia. The overlap between their activities may suggest that vitamin D exerts some of its actions by modulation of KGF activities in the skin. This notion was examined by using HaCaT keratinocytes cultured in serum-free medium in the absence of exogenous growth factors and in the presence of the EGF receptor tyrosine kinase inhibitor AG 1478 that blocks their autonomous proliferation. These cells could be stimulated to proliferate by different fibroblast growth factors (FGFs). The relative mitogenic efficacy of basic FGF, acidic FGF, or KGF was in correlation with their affinities for the KGF receptor (KGFR). Forty-eight hour co-treatment with 1,25(OH)(2)D(3) enhanced KGFR-mediated cell proliferation in a dose dependent manner. Both ERK1/2 and c-Jun N-terminal kinase (JNK) were activated by the FGFs. Treatment with 1,25(OH)(2)D(3) increased the activation of ERK but reduced the activation of JNK. Treatment with 1,25(OH)(2)D(3) increased the levels of KGFR in the presence but not in the absence of KGF, probably due to inhibition of ligand-induced receptor degradation. Inhibition of protein kinase C with bisindolylmaleimide did not interfere with the effect of 1,25(OH)(2)D(3) on KGFR-mediated ERK activation. Our results support the notion that the paracrine KGF-KGFR system in the skin can act in concert with the autocrine vitamin D system in keratinocytes to promote keratinocyte proliferation and survival under situations of stress and injury.     

Phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase is a key regulator of early phase differentiation in keratinocytes

The survival and growth of epithelial cells depend on adhesion to the extracellular matrix. Because epidermal keratinocytes differentiate as they leave the basement membrane, an adhesion signal may regulate the initiation of differentiation. Phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase (PI3K) is a fundamental signaling molecule that regulates the adhesion signal. Transfection of a dominant negative form of PI3K into keratinocytes using an adenovirus vector resulted in significant morphological changes comparable to differentiation and the induction of differentiation markers, keratin (K) 1 and K10. In turn, transfection with the constitutively active form of PI3K almost completely abolished the induction of K1 and K10 by differentiation in suspension cultures using polyhydroxyethylmethacrylate-coated dishes. PI3K activity was lost in suspension culture, except by cells bearing the constitutively active form of PI3K. These data demonstrate that blockade of PI3K results in differentiation and that activation of PI3K prevents differentiation. Furthermore, expression of the dominant negative form of PI3K significantly inhibited keratinocyte adhesion to the extracellular matrix and reduced the surface expression of alpha(6) and beta(1) integrins in suspension culture. Moreover, expression of the active form of PI3K restored the mRNA levels of adhesion molecules that were reduced in suspension culture, including alpha(3), alpha(6), and beta(1) integrins, BP180, and BP230. In conclusion, loss of PI3K activity results in keratinocytes leaving the basement membrane and the initiation of a "default" differentiation mechanism.     

Targeting expression of keratinocyte growth factor to keratinocytes elicits striking changes in epithelial differentiation in transgenic mice.

Keratinocyte growth factor (KGF) is a member of the fibroblast growth factor (FGF) family. Synthesized by cells of the dermal component of skin, KGF's potent mitogenic activity is on the epidermal component, which harbors the receptors for this factor. To explore the possible role of KGF in mesenchymal-epithelial interactions in skin, we used a human keratin 14 promoter to target expression of human KGF cDNA to the stratified squamous epithelia of transgenic mice. Mice expressing KGF in their epidermis typically appeared frail and weak, and often had grossly wrinkled skin. These mice exhibited a gross increase in epidermal thickness accompanied by alterations in epidermal growth and differentiation. Most remarkably, animals displayed several striking and unexpected changes, including a marked suppression of hair follicle morphogenesis and suppression of adipogenesis. With age, some animals developed gross transformations in the tongue epithelium and in epidermis. In addition, they exhibited elevated salivation and their salivary glands showed signs of altered differentiation. Collectively, our findings provide new and important insights into the roles of KGF, implicating this potent growth factor in eliciting global effects not only on growth, but also on development and differentiation, of skin and other tissues. In particular, KGF seems to interfere with signalling of some mesenchymal-epithelial interactions.     

Polarized endocytosis of the keratinocyte growth factor receptor in migrating cells: role of SRC-signaling and cortactin

Cell migration is a physiological process that requires endocytic trafficking and polarization of adhesion molecules and receptor tyrosine kinases (RTKs) to the leading edge. Many growth factors are able to induce motility by binding to specific RTK on target cells. Among them, keratinocyte growth factor (KGF or FGF7) and fibroblast growth factor 10 (FGF10), members of the FGF family, are motogenic for keratinocytes, and exert their action by binding to the keratinocyte growth factor receptor (KGFR), a splicing variant of FGFR2, exclusively expressed on epithelial cells. Here we analyzed the possible role of cortactin, an F-actin binding protein which is tyrosine phosphorylated by Src and is involved in KGFR-mediated cell migration, in the KGFR endocytosis and polarization to the leading edge of migrating cells upon ligand-induced stimulation. Biochemical phosphorylation study revealed that both KGF and FGF10 were able to induce tyrosine phosphorylation of Src and in turn of cortactin, as demonstrated by using the specific pharmacological Src-inhibitor SU6656, although FGF10 effect was delayed with respect to that promoted by KGF. Immunofluorescence analysis demonstrated the polarized localization of KGFR upon ligand stimulation to the leading edge of migrating keratinocytes, process that was regulated by Src. Moreover, we showed that the colocalization of cortactin with KGFR at the plasma membrane protrusions and on early endosomes after KGF and FGF10 treatment was Src-dependent. Further, by using a RNA interference approach through microinjection, we showed that cortactin is required for KGFR endocytosis and that the clathrin-dependent internalization of the receptor is a critical event for its polarization. Finally, KGFR expression and polarization enhanced cell migration in a scratch assay. Our results indicate that both Src and cortactin play a key role in the KGFR endocytosis and polarization at the leading edge of migrating keratinocytes, supporting the crucial involvement of RTK trafficking in cell motility.     

Modulation of sarcomere organization during embryonic stem cell-derived cardiomyocyte differentiation

Myofibrillogenesis - sarcomeres - mouse embryonic stem cells - cardiomyocytes - beta1 integrin Mouse embryonic stem (ES) cells, when cultivated as embryoid bodies, differentiate in vitro into cardiomyocytes of ventricle-, atrium- and pacemaker-like cell types characterized by developmentally controlled expression of cardiac-specific genes, structural proteins and ion channels. Using this model system, we show here, (I) that during cardiac myofibrillogenesis sarcomeric proteins are organized in a developmentally regulated manner following the order: titin (Z-disk), alpha-actinin, myomesin, titin (M-band), myosin heavy chain, alpha-actin, cardiac troponin T and M-protein, recapitulating the sarcomeric organization in the chicken embryonal heart in vivo. Our data support the view that the formation of I-Z-I complexes is developmentally delayed with respect to A-band assembly. We show (2) that the process of cardiogenic differentiation in vitro is influenced by medium components: Using a culture medium supplemented with glucose, amino acids, vitamins and selenium ions, we were able to increase the efficiency of cardiac differentiation of wild-type, as well as of beta1 integrin-deficient (beta1-/-) ES cells, and to improve the degree of organization of sarcomeric structures in wild-type and in beta1-/- cardiac cells. The data demonstrate the plasticity of cardiogenesis during the differentiation of wild-type and of genetically modified ES cells.     

Immunogold labeling of keratin filaments in normal human epidermal cells with two anti-keratin monoclonal antibodies

We report on application of the highly sensitive and specific immunogold labeling method for ultrastructural investigation of keratin intermediate filament antigens in human epidermal cell suspensions. Triton X-100 pretreated cells proved accessible to the colloidal gold conjugate, thus enabling keratin filament bundles to be labeled. Anti-keratin KL1 and KL2 monoclonal antibodies were raised in mice after immunization with either human stratum corneum-isolated keratins or keratins extracted from human epidermal cells suspensions, respectively. Immunoelectron microscopy confirmed immunofluorescence and immunoperoxidase results of epidermal keratinocyte staining, and revealed two different antibody reactivity patterns: KL2 reacted with keratin filaments in keratinocytes of all epidermal layers, whereas antigen to KL1 was detected only on keratin of the suprabasal layers, not on the basal keratinocyte tonofilaments. The monoclonal antibody-recognized epitopes were specific for the keratin filaments. Vimentin-rich cells (melanocytes) were not stained in the same epidermal cell suspensions. Additionally, two distinct ultrastructural patterns of keratin filament epitope labeling were observed. KL1 and KL2 monoclonal antibodies react with two different antigenic determinants, depending on the stage of keratinocyte differentiation, and may therefore be used for immunohistochemical studies of various keratin-containing cells in normal and pathologic conditions.     

The role of fibroblast growth factors on the differentiation of vaginal epithelium of neonatal mice

The uterus and upper 3/5 of the vagina originate from the Müllerian duct; however, these organs show quite distinct characteristics in morphology and function. To investigate factors controlling vaginal epithelial cell differentiation from a single layer of pseudostratified epithelium to a multi-layered stratified epithelium with keratin, we focused on fibroblast growth factors (Fgfs). Transformation related protein 63 (Trp63) expression, a marker of stratified epithelium, increased in the Müllerian vaginal epithelial cells from days 0 to 5, and keratin 14 (Krt14) was expressed from day 5, suggesting that Trp63-negative vaginal epithelial cells can differentiate into Trp63-positive cells after birth. Fgf7 and Fgf10 were localized in the vaginal stroma but their receptor, Fgf receptor 2IIIb (Fgfr2IIIb), was localized in the vaginal epithelium. Both Fgf9 and its receptor, Fgfr2IIIc, were localized in the vaginal epithelium. Vaginae cultured with FGF10 or anti-FGF9 antibody showed stratified epithelium with an intense Krt14 expression; however, an inhibitor of phosphorylation of mitogen-activated protein kinase 1/3 (MAPK1/3) canceled the effect of FGF10 and anti-FGF9 antibody. Thus, Fgf10 stimulates the differentiation of pseudostratified epithelial cells into stratified cells via MAPK1/3 pathway, and Fgf9 inhibits this differentiation in the neonatal mouse vagina.     

Human keratinocyte growth factor activity on proliferation and differentiation of human keratinocytes: differentiation response distinguishes KGF from EGF family.

Human keratinocyte growth factor (KGF) is an epithelial cell specific mitogen which is secreted by normal stromal fibroblasts. In the present studies, we demonstrate that KGF is as potent as EGF in stimulating proliferation of primary or secondary human keratinocytes in tissue culture. Exposure of KGF- or EGF-stimulated keratinocytes to 1.0 mM calcium, an inducer of differentiation, led to cessation of cell growth. However, immunologic analysis of early and late markers of terminal differentiation, K1 and filaggrin, respectively, revealed striking differences in keratinocytes propagated in the presence of these growth factors. With KGF, the differentiation response was associated with expression of both markers whereas their appearance was retarded or blocked by EGF. TGF alpha, which also interacts with the EGF receptor, gave a similar response to that observed with EGF. These findings functionally distinguish KGF from the EGF family and support the role of KGF in the normal proliferation and differentiation of human epithelial cells.     

Interdependent fibroblast growth factor and activin A signaling promotes the expression of endodermal genes in differentiating mouse embryonic stem cells expressing Src Homology 2-domain inactive Shb

Abstract The mechanisms controlling endodermal development during stem cell differentiation have been only partly elucidated, although previous studies have suggested the participation of fibroblast growth factor (FGF) and activin A in these processes. Shb is a Src homology 2 (SH2) domain-containing adapter protein that has been implicated in FGF receptor 1 (FGFR1) signaling. To study the putative crosstalk between activin A and Shb-dependent FGF signaling in the differentiation of endoderm from embryonic stem (ES) cells, embryoid bodies (EBs) derived from mouse ES cells overexpressing wild-type Shb or Shb with a mutated SH2 domain (R522K-Shb) were cultured in the presence of activin A. We show that expression of R522K-Shb results in up-regulation of FGFR1 and FGF2 in EBs. Addition of activin A to the cultures enhances the expression of endodermal genes primarily in EBs expressing mutant Shb. Inhibition of FGF signaling by the addition of the FGFR1 inhibitor SU5402 completely counteracts the synergistic effects of R522K-Shb and activin A. In conclusion, the present results suggest that expression of R522K-Shb enhances certain signaling pathways downstream of FGF and that an interplay between FGF and activin A participates in ES cell differentiation to endoderm.