Sister-chromatid exchanges and gene mutations are induced by the replication of 5-bromo- and 5-chloro-deoxyuridine substituted DNA

The thymidine (dT) analogue 5-chlorodeoxyuridine (CldU) induces 7–8-fold more sister-chromatid exchanges (SCE) than does 5-bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) at equal substitution for dT in Chinese hamster ovary cells in culture. This difference facilitates study of the mechanism of induction of SCE by these analoques. Cultures were incubated with either BrdU or CldU for one cell cycle, followed by incubation in the presence of dT alone or BrdU or CldU for the second cell cycle and the SCE frequency determined in M2 cells. The results suggest that the induction of SCE is dependent only on the replication of the analogue-substituted DNA during the second cell cycle. Additional studies employed cultures grown in the presence of BrdU or CldU for 7 days to obtain mainly bifilarly substituted DNA, followed by 2 rounds of replication in the presence of dT alone. The SCE frequencies were approximately twice those found in cultures which had undergone the usual 2 rounds in the presence of the analogue; this is consistent with the replication of twice the amount of analogue-substituted DNA. Furthermore, such long-term growth in the presence of BrdU or CldU also results in concentration-dependent increases in the frequency of 6-thioguanine-resistant mutants, suggesting that gene mutations also result from the replication of analogue-substituted DNA.     

Sister chromatid differentiation after in situ detection of ultraviolet-induced DNA breaks under electron microscopy

Summary— Chinese hamster DON cells with 5-bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU)-substituted chromosomes were ultraviolet (UV)-exposed and processed for in situ detection of induced DNA breaks under electron microscopy. For this purpose, UV-induced breaks were amplified by an exonuclease III digestion to obtain single stranded DNA motifs which could hybridize with oligonucleotides of random sequences. These reannealed motifs could be used as primers which were extended by the Klenow polymerase, incorporating biotinylated-dUTP that was detected by a gold-tagged streptavidin. After processing, the chromatid whose DNA was BrdU-substituted in one strand showed a higher electron density than the chromatid substituted in both strands. In contrast, the unifilarly substituted chromatid showed about twice the labelling of DNA breaks as the bifilarly substituted one. This result could be the consequence of a greater loss of chromatin tracts in the bifilarly substituted chromatid, as implied by an X-ray microanalysis which showed that the amount of phosphorous lost by the bifilarly substituted chromatid was higher than that of the unifilarly substituted chromatid.     

SCEs are induced by replication of BrdU-substituted DNA templates, but not by incorporation of BrdU into nascent DNA

After 3 rounds of DNA replication in the presence of BrdU, third-division metaphase cells can be scored for the frequencies of SCEs that occurred during cycles 1 and 2, and also for the frequency of SCE during cycle 3. This procedure was used to resolve the issue of SCE induction by replication of BrdU-substituted DNA templates versus induction by BrdU incorporation into nascent DNA. It was observed that third-cycle SCE frequencies in CHO are dependent upon the amount of BrdU that was present during cycles 1 and 2 and are independent of the BrdU concentration during the third cycle. It is therefore BrdU serving as a template, rather than BrdU being incorporated, that initiates the SCE event. A model is proposed that produces reasonable fits to the observed data. It also predicts a true background or spontaneous SCE frequency of 3 per cell per cycle as previously reported by Heartlein et al. (Mutation Res., 107 (1983) (103-109). The predicted single twin ratio is higher than that reported by Wolff and Perry (Exp. Cell Res., 93 (1975) 23-30), and possible explanations for this discrepancy are discussed.     

Radiosensitization of Chinese hamster V79 cells by bromodeoxyuridine substitution of thymidine: enhancement of radiation-induced toxicity and DNA strand break production by monofilar and bifilar substitution

Bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) competes with thymidine (TdR) for incorporation into DNA of exponentially growing V79-171 cells. Such cells show an enhancement of the radiation response as determined by clonogenic survival and DNA damage measured by filter elution techniques after doses up to 15 Gy. The degree of radiosensitization for both survival and rates of alkaline and neutral elution are dependent on percentage BrdU substitution and independent of whether BrdU is in one strand only (monofilar) or both strands (bifilar) of the DNA duplex: e.g., for 16% BrdU substitution distributed either monofilarly or partially bifilarly, there is an enhancement factor for Do of 1.55. At this percentage substitution, the enhancement factor for the rate of alkaline elution is 1.75 and that for the rate of neutral elution is 1.54. The greater the percentage BrdU substitution, the larger was the enhancement ratio for survival and radiation-induced strand breaks in both monofilarly and bifilarly substituted cells. The increase in cell radiosensitivity caused by BrdU substitution shows a better correlation with the increase in radiation-induced double-strand breaks than with the increase in radiation-induced single-strand breaks.     

Dotted chromosomes produced in sodium phosphate solution supersaturated with NaHCO3

Dotted chromosomes were consistently produced in both BrdU and non-BrdU substituted Chinese hamster cells after treatment with 1.0 M Na-phosphate solution, adjusted to pH 9.0 with a supersaturating amount of NaHCO₃, and at a temperature of 80–95° C. — A series of changes in chromosome morphology was produced as the temperature of the solution was progressively increased. In BrdU-treated cells, G-banding and differentially stained sister chromatids were sequentially produced prior to the appearance of dots. In non-BrdU treated cells, only G-banding was produced before dot formation. In general, the patterns of dots correspond to the G-banding patterns. — Chromatids, with uni- or bifilarly BrdU substituted DNA or with normal DNA, required differential temperatures for the production of dots. Since the temperature required for dot formation was always slightly higher than that required for producing differentially stained chromatids, this phenomenon can be used as an important indicator for determining the optimal temperature required for revealing differentially stained chromatids.     

Induction of the fragile X on BrdU-substituted chromosomes with direct visualization of sister chromatid exchanges on banded chromosomes

Summary After incorporation of BrdU for one or more replication cycles, the fragile site at Xq27 [fra(X)] was induced by a late pulse with excess thymidine (dT), resulting in the simultaneous visualization of G bands and differentially stained sister chromatids. The degree of BrdU substitution (uni- vs bifilarly substituted DNA) did not affect the expression of the fra(X). Without addition of dT, expression was the same in M1, M2, and M3 cells. With the addition of dT, expression was reduced in M1 cells and increased in M2 and M3 cells. One way to explain this fact would be an increased repair of the fragile site in M1 cells by illegitimate G:BrdU pairing under dCTP-deficient conditions. A preferential depletion of M3 cells, and to a lesser extent also M2 cells, could suggest a synergistic toxic effect of BrdU substitution and dCTP depletion. With this technique, sister chromatid exchanges (SCEs) could be directly localized at band level, facilitating a more detailed study of SCEs at the Xq27 fragile site.     

Reverse differential staining of sister chromatids induced by Hoechst plus black light and endonuclease

A differential Giemsa staining between sister chromatids was obtained by treating chromosomes replicated twice in medium containing 5-bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) with Hoechst 33258 plus black light at 55 degrees C (HB pretreatment) and deoxyribonuclease (DNase) I, II, or micrococcal nuclease. In this staining pattern the BrdU bifilarly substituted chromatids were darkly and the unifilarly substituted chromatids lightly stained. This staining pattern was obtained only by staining the HB-DNase I-treated chromosomes with Giemsa and methylene blue, not by several other dyes tested. Relatively more DNA labelling was removed from the non-BrdU-substituted than the BrdU-substituted chromosomes, when the HB-pretreated chromosomes were digested with DNase I. But the protein labelling was not removed appreciably in the same treatment. The differential DNase I sensitivity between the non-BrdU-substituted and BrdU-substituted chromosomes disappeared when the HB-pretreated chromosomes were incubated with proteinase K before The DNase I digestion. Moreover, no differential DNase I sensitivity was found between the HB-pretreated isolated DNA containing and not containing BrdU. We propose that during the HB pretreatment, more DNA-protein cross-linkings are induced in BrdU bifilarly substituted than the unifilarly substituted chromatids. This structure protects the chromosomal DNA against the DNase I digestion. Thus, a reverse differential Giemsa staining between sister chromatids is obtained by the HB-DNase I treatment.     

Influence of low doses of BrdU and estimation of spontaneous SCE in CHO chromosomes: three-way differential staining and an immunoperoxidase method

The influence of low doses of 5-bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) on the occurrence of sister chromatid exchanges (SCEs) during the first cell cycle, when unsubstituted DNA templates replicate in the presence of the halogenated nucleoside (SCE1) has been assessed in third mitosis (M3) Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells showing three-way differential (TWD) staining. In addition, lower concentrations of BrdU, not detectable by Giemsa staining, have been tested by a high resolution immunoperoxidase method (anti-BrdU monoclonal antibody) and SCEs were scored in second mitosis (M2) cells. Our findings was a dose-response curve for SCE1 that allows an estimated mean spontaneous yield of 1.32/cell per cell cycle by extrapolation to zero concentration of BrdU. On the other hand, when the total SCE frequency corresponding to the first and second rounds of replication (SCE1+SCE2) found in M3 chromosomes was compared with the yield of SCEs scored in M2 cells grown in BrdU at doses lower than 1 M no further reduction was achieved. This seems to indicate that SCEs can occur spontaneously in this cell line, though the estimated frequency is higher than that reported in vivo.by S. Wolff     

Opposite staining effect of two silver-staining techniques on sister chromatids

Opposite differential staining between sister chromatids was obtained by two silver-staining techniques on chromosomes replicated twice in medium containing 5-bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) and pretreated with Hoechst plus black light. Both silver-nitrate and silver-carbonate staining were affected by chemical extraction and enzyme digestion of chromosomal proteins. Prestaining of silver nitrate or silver carbonate also blocked the fluorescences of protein dyes. However, removal of chromosomal DNA affected the silver-carbonate but not the silver-nitrate staining; the fluorescences of DNA dyes were blocked by the prestaining of silver carbonate but not silver nitrate. Chromosomal protein labelling was released only slightly and its relative amount between BrdU bifilarly substituted and unifilarly substituted chromatids was unchanged during pretreatment of Hoechst plus black light. We speculate that chromosomal non-histones are the targets for silver-nitrate stain, and DNA-non-histone complexes for silver-carbonate stain.     

In vivo repair during G1 of DNA lesions eliciting sister chromatid exchanges induced by methylnitrosourea or ethylnitrosourea in BrdU substituted or unsubstituted DNA in murine salivary gland cells

The difference in efficiency of methylnitrosourea (MNU) and ethylnitrosourea (ENU) to induce SCE in early or late G1 was determined in synchronized murine salivary gland cells in vivo, as a measure of the capacity of this tissue to repair the lesions involved in SCE formation during G1. The repair during G1 was determined by treating the cells in early or late G1. Treatment was in the first cycle (G1 before incorporation of 5-bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU)) or in G1 of the second cycle (after a single round of BrdU incorporation). It was observed that 50% of the lesions induced by MNU that elicit SCE are repaired during G1. BrdU incorporation into DNA increases the sensitivity of the cell to SCE induction by MNU nearly 40%; however under this circumstance a slightly lower SCE frequency was observed in the cells exposed to MNU at early G1, indicating that during G1 only few lesions are repaired. The ENU-induced DNA-lesions involved in SCE production are nearly 100% persistent along G1; besides, a slight but significantly higher SCE frequency was observed in cells exposed at early G1, suggesting the formation of SCE-inducing lesions during G1. BrdU incorporation to DNA sensitizes the cell to SCE induction by ENU, increasing the SCE frequency to nearly to a 40%, although these additional lesions involved in SCE induction seem to be susceptible to repair during G1.     

Reduced N-methyl-N′-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine sister chromatid exchange induction in chinese hamster V79 cells pre-exposed to 5-bromodeoxyuridine

The sequence in which N-methyl-N-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine (MNNG) and 5-bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) are added to cell cultures affects the number of sister chromatid exchanges (SCE) induced by MNNG. When V79 Chinese hamster cell monolayer cultures were treated with MNNG for 2 h prior to addition of BrdUrd, approximately a 4–5-fold increase in SCE was observed at the second division metaphases compared to controls exposed to BrdU alone. This effect was independent of whether one or three DNA strands had been substituted as a result of incubating the cells through one or two DNA synthesis periods in the presence of BrdU. This increase in SCE also occurred after MNNG exposure and BrdU incubation was extended for three division cycles. In contrast, when BrdU incorporation preceded MNNG treatment, the average number of SCE/metaphase was reduced 70–80% at the second division cycle and 60% relative to the total number found in three division cycles. SCE induction by MNNG does not involve a caffeine sensitive step since caffeine had no effect on the SCE frequency regardless of the treatment protocol. The conditions in which BrdU preceded MNNG exposure may be responsible for either reducing the number of DNA sites available for interaction with MNNG or preventing the expression of SCE.     

Effects of 3-aminobenzamide on DNA synthesis and cell cycle progression in Chinese hamster ovary cells

3-Aminobenzamide (3AB), an inhibitor of poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase, is a potent inducer of sister chromatid exchanges (SCEs). Because of the possible relation between SCEs and DNA synthesis, the effects of 3AB on DNA synthesis and cell cycle progression in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells were examined. Unlike all other SCE-inducing agents whose effects on DNA synthesis have been studied, short term exposures (30–120 min) of 3AB did not inhibit the overall rate of DNA synthesis and this result was independent of the amount of bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) in the DNA. Longer exposure times (>24 h) did result in an extended S phase, but this was not due to an effect on the rate of DNA chain elongation. 3AB also delayed the entry of cells into S phase. The overall cell cycle delay was dose dependent, approaching 9 h after a 54 h exposure to 10 mM 3AB. Earlier reports that 3AB is neither mutagenic nor cytotoxic were confirmed. Thus 3AB acts to increase SCE frequency by a mechanism distinct from that which causes cytotoxicity and mutagenicity, and does not involve any inhibition in the rate of DNA chain growth.     

Effect of 5-bromodeoxyuridine substitution on sister chromatid exchange induction by chemicals

The fluorescence-plus-Giemsa (FPG) technique for analysis of sister chromatid exchange (SCE) is widely used as an assay for mutagenic carcinogens. There is very little information, however, on whether incorporation of the bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) necessary for visualization of SCEs affects the sensitivity of the SCE test system to different chemical agents. We have investigated the effect of BrdU incorporation on SCE induction by labeling cells with BrdU for either the first cell cycle or the first and second cell cycles. The cells were then treated with bleomycin, which produces DNA strand breakage; proflavine, which intercalates into DNA; mitomycin C, which produces monoadducts and DNA crosslinks; or aphidicolin, which inhibits DNA polymerase . Chemicals were added before BrdU exposure or during the first, second, or both cell cycles. Only mitomycin C, which induces long-lived lesions, elevated the SCE frequency when cells were treated before BrdU labeling. When bleomycin, proflavine, or mitomycin C was present concurrently with BrdU, the frequency of SCEs was increased independently of the BrdU labeling protocol. Aphidicolin, on the other hand, induced more SCEs when present for the second cell cycle, when DNA replicates on a template DNA strand containing BrdU. We also examined the induction of SCEs in the first cell cycle (twins) and in the second cell cycle (singles) after continuous treatment of cells with BrdU and the test chemicals. Only aphidicolin increased SCE frequency in the second cell cycle. These results indicate that aphidicolin, but not bleomycin, proflavine, or mitomycin C, affects BrdU-substituted DNA and unsubstituted DNA differently. This type of interaction should be taken into consideration when the SCE test is used as an assay system.     

Differences in sensitivity of murine spermatogonia and somatic cells in vivo to sister-chromatid exchange induction by nitrosoureas

Previously published data indicate that spermatogonia (SPG) are less sensitive to a sister-chromatid exchange (SCE) induction for different mutagens. In an earlier study, we have observed that bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) substituted murine SPG are less sensitive to SCE induction by gamma ray in cells, than bone marrow (BM) and salivary gland (SG) cells in vivo. This was interpreted to mean that SPG are more efficient in DNA repair or are less prone to SCE induction. That the lower induction of SCE could be due to a reduced accessibility of mutagens to the SPG by virtue of a physiological barrier, was discarded by using gamma radiation. The aim of the present study was to establish whether or not there are differences in SCE induction by nitrosoureas among SPG, SG and BM cells with BrdU substituted or unsubstituted DNA. It was observed that SCE induction by methylnitrosourea (MNU) or by ethylnitrosourea (ENU) in SPG was, respectively, five and two times lower than in SG, and ten and three times lower than in BM. In SPG after BrdU incorporation, there was no increase in efficiency of SCE induction; in fact, there was even a slight decrease by exposure to MNU or ENU. BM and SG cells showed an increased efficiency in SCE induction after BrdU incorporation. This implies that SPG are also less sensitive to SCE induction by nitrosoureas, which cause a different kind of damage from previously assayed mutagens.     

Frequency of sister-chromatid exchanges depending on the amount of 5-bromodeoxyuridine incorporated into parental DNA

Chinese hamster D-6 cells were grown for two cell cycles. The effect of 5-bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) on the frequencies of sister-chromatid exchanges (SCEs) in these cells was investigated by the BrdU-labeling method. A low concentration (5 μM) of BrdU was inoculated in the first cell cycle for SCE counting. When excess concentrations (100–1000 μM) of BrdU were added subsequently in the second cell cycle, a 1–2-fold increase of SCE frequencies was observed. When excess thymidine (dT) (100–1000 μM) was supplied instead of BrdU, the incidence of SCE also increased. When cells were exposed to high concentrations (50–200 μM) of BrdU in the first cell cycle, a 1–4-fold increase in SCE frequencies was observed. This incidence of SCE was largely dependent on the concentration of BrdU and dT used in the second cell cycle. These results suggest that efficient SCE induction by BrdU is related to the BrdU residue incorporated into parental DNA strands.     

Effect of exogenous thymidine on sister-chromatid exchange frequency in Chinese hamster ovary cells with bromodeoxyuridine- and chlorodeoxyuridine-substituted chromosomes

There are conflicting reports on the effect of exogenous thymidine (dThd) on the frequency of sister-chromatid exchanges (SCEs) in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. Thymidine has been reported either to increase or to have no effect on SCE frequency under similar experimental conditions. To resolve this controversy, we have carried out a series of experiments to examine the effect of dThd on CHO cells cultured with 5-bromodeoxyuridine (BrdUrd). In addition, we have examined the effect of dThd on CHO cells cultured with 5-chlorodeoxyuridine (CldUrd), a much more potent inducer of SCEs than BrdUrd. The addition of 100 microM dThd to the culture medium caused a consistent decrease in the yield of SCEs in cells grown in BrdUrd for two cell cycles. The decrease was even greater when cells were grown in dThd and CldUrd. Analysis of twin and single SCEs indicated that dThd must be present during the first cell cycle to reduce the frequency of SCEs. Because excess dThd is thought to have an effect when DNA replicates on a template substituted with a halogenated nucleoside, dThd at concentrations from 100 microM to 9 mM was added to cultures for the second cell cycle after a first cell cycle in BrdUrd. In this experiment, the presence of dThd increased SCE frequency in a dose-dependent manner. The results suggest that if dThd competes with halogenated nucleosides and thus decreases their incorporation into DNA, SCEs are suppressed in the subsequent cell cycle, whereas if excess dThd creates a dNTP pool imbalance, SCEs can be increased.     

Methyl methane-sulphonate (MMS) induced SCEs are reduced by the BrdU used to visualise them

SCE induction in synchronised CHO cells treated with methyl methane sulphonate (MMS) in G₁ was studied over successive pairs of cell cycles by introducing bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) at consecutive G₁ stages. When individual cell cycle SCE values were calculated from the data, anomalous results were obtained with ratios of 1.01.82.1 for the first three cycles but a negative value for the fourth cycle. Further studies using different BrdU concentrations showed that MMS induced SCEs were reduced by values exceeding 50% in DNA containing high levels of incorporated BrdU. This reduction was dose dependent and accounted for the anomalous results obtained over successive cycles. Lesions leading to chromatid exchanges were also reduced by the same mechanism. SCEs induced by UV irradiation were also decreased but those induced by the cross-linking agent nitrogen mustard (HN₂) remained unaffected. The results indicate that not only are SCE lesions induced by MMS, UV or HN₂ expressed independently of the spontaneous SCEs induced by BrdU but that SCE lesions are multiple in nature. Mechanisms by which SCE lesions could be repaired in BrdU containing DNA are discussed. SCE lesions in MMS treated cells arrested in G₁ with arginine deprived medium (ADM) are repaired without the presence of BrdU in the DNA. An opposite effect is seen however in the control cells, where SCEs are increased with time spent in ADM arrest. These interactions between the effects of MMS, BrdU and ADM arrest are discussed.     

Restriction endonucleases do not induce sister-chromatid exchanges in Chinese hamster ovary cells

Bacterial restriction enzymes offer the unique opportunity to determine the biological and cytogenetic consequences of DNA double-strand breakage. To examine the role of various types of breaks in sister-chromatid exchange (SCE) formation, we used restriction enzymes with different recognition sequences and different cutting frequencies to generate DNA double-strand breaks in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. The restriction enzymes were introduced by electroporation into exponentially growing cells during the second replication cycle in bromodeoxyuridine, and SCEs were analyzed at mitosis. Contrary to results reported by others, we found no increase in SCE frequency in cells exposed to restriction enzymes despite the presence of numerous cells with chromatid aberrations. These data suggest that DNA double-strand breaks do not lead to SCE formation.     

5-Bromodeoxyuridine-dependent increase in sister chromatid exchange formation in Bloom's syndrome is associated with reduction in topoisomerase II activity

Bloom's syndrome is characterized by a high sister chromatid exchange (SCE) frequency, the basis for which is not yet understood. Immunofluorescent detection of SCE formation in dermal fibroblasts was employed over a wide range of 5-bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) substitution into template DNA to show that this SCE elevation reflects both an increased baseline SCE frequency and an exaggerated increment in SCE formation as BrdU substitution increases. The impact of BrdU on SCE formation in Bloom's syndrome is paralleled by its ability to reduce the activity in nuclear extracts of topoisomerase II, an enzyme important for DNA replication and interchange. The extractable topoisomerase II activity of Bloom's syndrome fibroblasts, as measured by unknotting of page P4 DNA, is much more strongly inhibited by cell growth in medium containing BrdU than is that of normal fibroblasts. The results are consistent with the hypothesis that much of the BrdU-dependent component of SCE formation in Bloom's syndrome may be mediated by an effect of BrdU substitution of template DNA on topoisomerase II activity.     

Spontaneous and mitomycin-C induced sister-chromatid exchanges : Comparison of in vivo and in vitro systems

Frequencies of sister-chromatid exchanges (SCE) were measured in vitro in mouse fibroblasts and in vivo in mouse bone-marrow cells. SCE levels in these cell systems were measured in response to varying concentrations of bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) and mitomycin-C (MMC). Although BrdU was found to induce SCE in both cellular systems, baseline SCE levels were 2- to 3-fold higher in vitro than in vivo. SCE induction was found to be a linear function of MMC concentration in vivo and in vitro; however the slope of the in vivo curve was 5-fold higher. The interaction of BrdU substituted DNA and MMC was examined by administering a fixed dose of MMC with increasing concentrations of BrdU. The induced SCE frequencies appeared to be additive. In addition to measuring drug-induced SCE, the BrdU differential staining technique allows concomitant measurement of the inhibition of cellular replication by the test drugs.