Understanding the role of hydrogen bonds in water dynamics and protein stability

The mechanisms of cold and pressure denaturation of proteins are a matter of debate, but it is commonly accepted that water plays a fundamental role in the process. It has been proposed that the denaturation process is related to an increase of hydrogen bonds among hydration water molecules. Other theories suggest that the causes of denaturation are the density fluctuations of surface water, or the destabilization of hydrophobic contacts as a consequence of water molecule inclusions inside the protein, especially at high pressures. We review some theories that have been proposed to give insight into this problem, and we describe a coarse-grained model of water that compares well with experiments for proteins’ hydration water. We introduce its extension for a homopolymer in contact with the water monolayer and study it by Monte Carlo simulations in an attempt to understand how the interplay of water cooperativity and interfacial hydrogen bonds affects protein stability.     

Highly anomalous energetics of protein cold denaturation linked to folding-unfolding kinetics

Despite several careful experimental analyses, it is not yet clear whether protein cold-denaturation is just a "mirror image" of heat denaturation or whether it shows unique structural and energetic features. Here we report that, for a well-characterized small protein, heat denaturation and cold denaturation show dramatically different experimental energetic patterns. Specifically, while heat denaturation is endothermic, the cold transition (studied in the folding direction) occurs with negligible heat effect, in a manner seemingly akin to a gradual, second-order-like transition. We show that this highly anomalous energetics is actually an apparent effect associated to a large folding/unfolding free energy barrier and that it ultimately reflects kinetic stability, a naturally-selected trait in many protein systems. Kinetics thus emerges as an important factor linked to differential features of cold denaturation. We speculate that kinetic stabilization against cold denaturation may play a role in cold adaptation of psychrophilic organisms. Furthermore, we suggest that folding-unfolding kinetics should be taken into account when analyzing in vitro cold-denaturation experiments, in particular those carried out in the absence of destabilizing conditions.     

The Hydrophobic Effect: A New Insight from Cold Denaturation and a Two-State Water Structure

Herein we provide a new insight into the hydrophobic effect in protein folding. Our proposition explains the molecular basis of cold denaturation, and of intermediate states in heat and their absence in cold denaturation. The exposure of non-polar surface reduces the entropy and enthalpy of the system, at low and at high temperatures. At low temperatures the favorable reduction in enthalpy overcomes the unfavorable reduction in entropy, leading to cold denaturation. At high temperatures, folding/unfolding is a two-step process: in the first, the entropy gain leads to hydrophobic collapse, in the second, the reduction in enthalpy due to protein-protein interactions leads to the native state. The different entropy and enthalpy contributions to the Gibbs energy change at each step at high, and at low, temperatures can be conveniently explained by a two-state model of the water structure. The model provides a clear view of the dominant factors in protein folding and stability. Consequently, it appears to provide a microscopic view of the hydrophobic effect and is consistently linked to macroscopic thermodynamic parameters.     

Yeast Frataxin Is Stabilized by Low Salt Concentrations: Cold Denaturation Disentangles Ionic Strength Effects from Specific Interactions

Frataxins are a family of metal binding proteins associated with the human Friedreich''s ataxia disease. Here, we have addressed the effect of non-specifically binding salts on the stability of the yeast ortholog Yfh1. This protein is a sensitive model since its stability is strongly dependent on the environment, in particular on ionic strength. Yfh1 also offers the unique advantage that its cold denaturation can be observed above the freezing point of water, thus allowing the facile construction of the whole protein stability curve and hence the measurement of accurate thermodynamic parameters for unfolding. We systematically measured the effect of several cations and, as a control, of different anions. We show that, while strongly susceptible to ionic strength, as it would be in the cellular environment, Yfh1 stability is sensitive not only to divalent cations, which bind specifically, but also to monovalent cations. We pinpoint the structural bases of the stability and hypothesize that the destabilization induced by an unusual cluster of negatively charged residues favours the entrance of water molecules into the hydrophobic core, consistent with the generally accepted mechanism of cold denaturation.     

The hydrophobic effect: a new insight from cold denaturation and a two-state water structure

Herein we provide a new insight into the hydrophobic effect in protein folding. Our proposition explains the molecular basis of cold denaturation, and of intermediate states in heat and their absence in cold denaturation. The exposure of non-polar surface reduces the entropy and enthalpy of the system, at low and at high temperatures. At low temperatures the favorable reduction in enthalpy overcomes the unfavorable reduction in entropy, leading to cold denaturation. At high temperatures, folding/unfolding is a two-step process: in the first, the entropy gain leads to hydrophobic collapse, in the second, the reduction in enthalpy due to protein-protein interactions leads to the native state. The different entropy and enthalpy contributions to the Gibbs energy change at each step at high, and at low, temperatures can be conveniently explained by a two-state model of the water structure. The model provides a clear view of the dominant factors in protein folding and stability. Consequently, it appears to provide a microscopic view of the hydrophobic effect and is consistently linked to macroscopic thermodynamic parameters.     

Essential dynamics of the cold denaturation: pressure and temperature effects in yeast frataxin

The cold denaturation of globular proteins is a process that can be caused by increasing pressure or decreasing the temperature. Currently, the action mechanism of this process has not been clearly understood, raising an interesting debate on the matter. We have studied the process of cold denaturation using molecular dynamics simulations of the frataxin system Yfh1, which has a dynamic experimental characterization of unfolding at low and high temperatures. The frataxin model here studied allows a comparative analysis using experimental data. Furthermore, we monitored the cold denaturation process of frataxin and also investigated the effect under the high‐pressure regime. For a better understanding of the dynamics and structural properties of the cold denaturation, we also analyzed the MD trajectories using essentials dynamic. The results indicate that changes in the structure of water by the effect of pressure and low temperatures destabilize the hydrophobic interaction modifying the solvation and the system volume leading to protein denaturation. Proteins 2016; 85:125–136. © 2016 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

A water-explicit lattice model of heat-, cold-, and pressure-induced protein unfolding

We investigate the effect of temperature and pressure on polypeptide conformational stability using a two-dimensional square lattice model in which water is represented explicitly. The model captures many aspects of water thermodynamics, including the existence of density anomalies, and we consider here the simplest representation of a protein: a hydrophobic homopolymer. We show that an explicit treatment of hydrophobic hydration is sufficient to produce cold, pressure, and thermal denaturation. We investigate the effects of the enthalpic and entropic components of the water-protein interactions on the overall folding phase diagram, and show that even a schematic model such as the one we consider yields reasonable values for the temperature and pressure ranges within which highly compact homopolymer configurations are thermodynamically stable.     

The Correlation of Cold Denaturation Temperature with Surface Stability Factor of Proteins

Cold denaturation is an intriguing phenomenon in protein denaturation for elucidating protein accessible surface area (ASA). Compared to the impact of protein surface, the importance of protein-water interactions in cold denaturation may be ruled out significantly. Here, based on the ASA, we have defined a new factor, the surface stability factor (SSF). From the SSF, in combination with the cold denaturation temperature (T(g')) or temperature at DeltaS = 0 (T(s)) of a given protein, one can predict the percent of hydrophobic surface area (H), percent of total surface there on positive and negative charge sum (effective charge) be zero (C), percent of patches hydrophobicity (HP) and others critical surface parameters without any need to the crystallographic data.     

Temperature range of thermodynamic stability for the native state of reversible two-state proteins

The difference between the heat (T(G)) and the cold (T(G)') denaturation temperatures defines the temperature range (T(Range)) over which the native state of a reversible two-state protein is thermodynamically stable. We have performed a correlation analysis for thermodynamic parameters in a selected data set of structurally nonhomologous single-domain reversible two-state proteins. We find that the temperature range is negatively correlated with the protein size and with the heat capacity change (DeltaC(p)) but is positively correlated with the maximal protein stability [DeltaG(T(S))]. The correlation between the temperature range and maximal protein stability becomes highly significant upon normalization of the maximal protein stability with protein size. The melting temperature (T(G)) also shows a negative correlation with protein size. Consistently, T(G) and T(G)' show opposite correlations with DeltaC(p), indicating a dependence of the T(Range) on the curvature of the protein stability curve. Substitution of proteins in our data set with their homologues and arbitrary addition or removal of a protein in the data set do not affect the outcome of our analysis. Simulations of the thermodynamic data further indicate that T(Range) is more sensitive to variations in curvature than to the slope of the protein stability curve. The hydrophobic effect in single domains is the principal reason for these observations. Our results imply that larger proteins may be stable over narrower temperature ranges and that smaller proteins may have higher melting temperatures, suggesting why protein structures often differentiate into multiple substructures with different hydrophobic cores. Our results have interesting implications for protein thermostability.     

Pressure versus heat-induced unfolding of ribonuclease A: the case of hydrophobic interactions within a chain-folding initiation site

To investigate the characteristics of the postulated carboxy terminal chain-folding initiation site in bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (RNase A) (residues 106-118), important in the early stages of the folding pathway, we have engineered by site-directed mutagenesis a set of 14 predominantly conservative hydrophobic variants of the protein. The stability of each variant has been compared by pressure and temperature-induced unfolding, monitored by fourth derivative UV absorbance spectroscopy. Apparently simple two-state, reversible unfolding transitions are observed, suggesting that the disruption of tertiary structure of each protein at high pressure or temperature is strongly cooperative. Within the limits of the technique, we are unable to detect significant differences between the two processes of denaturation. Both steady-state kinetic parameters for the enzyme reaction and UV CD spectra of each RNase A variant indicate that truncation of hydrophobic side chains in this region has, in general, little or no effect on the native structure and function of the enzyme. Furthermore, the decreases in free energy of unfolding upon pressure and thermal denaturation of all the variants, particularly those modified at residues 106 and 108, suggest that the hydrophobic residues and side chain packing interactions of this region play an important role in maintaining the conformational stability of RNase A. We also demonstrate the potential of Tyr115 replacement by Trp as a non-destabilizing fluorescence probe of conformational changes local to the region.     

Cold denaturation of proteins

This article summarizes all experimental facts concerning the cold denaturation of single-domain, multi-domain, and multimeric globular proteins in aqueous solutions with and without urea and guanidine hydrochloride. The facts obtained by various experimental techniques are analyzed thermodynamically and it is shown that the cold denaturation is a general phenomenon caused by the very specific and strongly temperature-dependent interaction of protein nonpolar groups with water. Hydration of these groups, in contrast to expectations, is favorable thermodynamically, i.e., the Gibbs energy of hydration is negative and increases in magnitude at a temperature decrease. As a result, the polypeptide chain, tightly packed in a compact native structure, unfolds at a sufficiently low temperature, exposing internal nonpolar groups to water. The reevaluation of the hydration effect on the base of direct calorimetric studies of protein denaturation and of transfer of non-polar compounds into water leads to revision of the conventional conception on the mechanism of hydrophobic interaction. The last appears to be a complex effect in which the positive contributor is van der Waals interactions between the nonpolar groups and not the hydration of these groups as it was usually supposed.     

Oxidation of tryptophans in an interhelical hydrophobic cluster of myoglobin alters the thermodynamics of the denaturation transition

Model folding studies of sperm whale myoglobin have illustrated the presence of hydrophobic interfacial regions between elements of secondary structure. The specific oxidation of two tryptophan residues, in the A-H helix contact of sperm whale myoglobin, to the less hydrophobic oxindolylalanine residues is utilized to probe the contribution of hydrophobic packing density in this contact region. The acid denaturation of the modified protein is no longer a simple two-state process exhibiting the presence of stable intermediates. The relative stability of the intermediate is shown to be +5.3 kcal/mol less stable than native myoglobin. This value is consistent with the predicted relative stability, based upon electrostatic model calculations, of the docking of the A helix with a des-A helix myoglobin. The presence of stable intermediate structures in the denaturation pathway of the modified protein is consistent with the proposed role of hydrophobic interactions in damping structural fluctuations and statistical mechanical models of noncooperative protein unfolding. These results demonstrate the relationship between large-scale fluctuations and the frictional forces governing small-scale motions within the protein core.     

Cold Denaturation of Protein

Abstract

This article summarizes all experimental facts concerning the cold denaturation of single-domain, multi-domain, and multimeric globular proteins in aqueous solutions with and without urea and guanidine hydrochloride. The facts obtained by various experimental techniques are analyzed thermodynamically and it is shown that the cold denaturation is a general phenomenon caused by the very specific and strongly termperature-dependent interaction of protein nonpolar groups with water. Hydration of these groups, in contrast to expectations, is favorable thermodynamically, i.e., the Gibbs energy of hydration is negative and increases in magnitude at a temperature! decrease. As a result, the polypeptide chain, tightly packed in a compact native structure, unfolds at a sufficiently low temperature, exposing internal nonpolar groups to water. The reevaluation of the hydration effect on the base of direct calorimetric studies of protein denaturation and of transfer of non-polar compounds into water leads to revision of the conventional conception on the mechanism of hydrophobic interaction. The last appears to be a complex effect in which the positive con- tributor is van der Waals interactions between the nonpolar groups and not the hydration of these groups as it was usually supposed.     

The Mechanism of N-Terminal Acetylation of Protein

Abstract

This article summarizes all experimental facts concerning the cold denaturation of single-domain, multi-domain, and multimeric globular proteins in aqueous solutions with and without urea and guanidine hydrochloride. The facts obtained by various experimental techniques are analyzed thermodynamically and it is shown that the cold denaturation is a general phenomenon caused by the very specific and strongly termperature-dependent interaction of protein nonpolar groups with water. Hydration of these groups, in contrast to expectations, is favorable thermodynamically, i.e., the Gibbs energy of hydration is negative and increases in magnitude at a temperature decrease. As a result, the polypeptide chain, tightly packed in a compact native structure, unfolds at a sufficiently low temperature, exposing internal nonpolar groups to water. The reev-aluation of the hydration effect on the base of direct calorimetric studies of protein denaturation and of transfer of non-polar compounds into water leads to revision of the conventional conception on the mechanism of hydrophobic interaction. The last appears to be a complex effect in which the positive contributor is van der Waals interactions between the nonpolar groups and not the hydration of these groups as it was usually supposed.     

The unusually stable coiled-coil domain of COMP exhibits cold and heat denaturation in 4-6 M guanidinium chloride

A high thermal stability is observed for the five-stranded alpha-helical coiled-coil domain of cartilage oligomeric matrix protein COMP. It does not unfold in non-denaturing buffer between 0 and 100 degrees C and thermal denaturation is only achieved at high concentrations of guanidinium chloride (4-6 M). In these solutions the protein structure is lost at decreasing (cold denaturation) and increasing temperatures (heat denaturation). In the cold denaturation region, the melting profile showed deviations from the theory of Privalov et al. [P.L. Privalov, V. Griko Yu, S. Venyaminov, V.P. Kutyshenko, Cold denaturation of myoglobin, J. Mol. Biol. 190 (1986) 487-498] probably due to deviations from a two-state mechanism. High thermal stability as well as cold and heat denaturation was also observed for a mutant of the coiled-coil domain of COMP in which glutamine 54 was replaced by isoleucine but it still forms pentamer. The melting temperatures in plain buffer for the heat denaturation of COMP coiled-coil domain and its mutant obtained by extrapolation to zero molar guanidinium chloride concentration are approximately 160 and 220 degrees C, respectively, which groups them among the most stable proteins.     

Difference in the mechanisms of the cold and heat induced unfolding of thioredoxin h from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii: spectroscopic and calorimetric studies

The thermodynamic stability and temperature induced structural changes of oxidized thioredoxin h from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii have been studied using differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), near- and far-UV circular dichroism (CD), and fluorescence spectroscopies. At neutral pH, the heat induced unfolding of thioredoxin h is irreversible. The irreversibly unfolded protein is unable to refold due to the formation of soluble high-order oligomers. In contrast, at acidic pH the heat induced unfolding of thioredoxin h is fully reversible and thus allows the thermodynamic stability of this protein to be characterized. Analysis of the heat induced unfolding at acidic pH using calorimetric and spectroscopic methods shows that the heat induced denaturation of thioredoxin h can be well approximated by a two-state transition. The unfolding of thioredoxin h is accompanied by a large heat capacity change [6.0 +/- 1.0 kJ/(mol.K)], suggesting that at low pH a cold denaturation should be observed at the above-freezing temperatures for this protein. All used methods (DSC, near-UV CD, far-UV CD, Trp fluorescence) do indeed show that thioredoxin h undergoes cold denaturation at pH <2.5. The cold denaturation of thioredoxin h cannot, however, be fitted to a two-state model of unfolding. Furthermore, according to the far-UV CD, thioredoxin h is fully unfolded at pH 2.0 and 0 degrees C, whereas the other three methods (near-UV CD, fluorescence, and DSC) indicate that under these conditions 20-30% of the protein molecules are still in the native state. Several alternative mechanisms explaining these results such as structural differences in the heat and cold denatured state ensembles and the two-domain structure of thioredoxin h are discussed.     

Fused in sarcoma undergoes cold denaturation: Implications for phase separation

The mediation of liquid–liquid phase separation (LLPS) for fused in sarcoma (FUS) protein is generally attributed to the low-complexity, disordered domains and is enhanced at low temperature. The role of FUS folded domains on the LLPS process remains relatively unknown since most studies are mainly based on fragmented FUS domains. Here, we investigate the effect of metabolites on full-length (FL) FUS LLPS using turbidity assays and differential interference contrast (DIC) microscopy, and explore the behavior of the folded domains by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. FL FUS LLPS is maximal at low concentrations of glucose and glutamate, moderate concentrations of NaCl, Zn²⁺, and Ca²⁺ and at the isoelectric pH. The FUS RNA recognition motif (RRM) and zinc-finger (ZnF) domains are found to undergo cold denaturation above 0°C at a temperature that is determined by the conformational stability of the ZnF domain. Cold unfolding exposes buried nonpolar residues that can participate in LLPS-promoting hydrophobic interactions. Therefore, these findings constitute the first evidence that FUS globular domains may have an active role in LLPS under cold stress conditions and in the assembly of stress granules, providing further insight into the environmental regulation of LLPS.     

Effects of protein perturbants on phospholipid bilayers

Series of alcohols, amides, ureas, and sulfoxides with increasingly longer hydrocarbon chains have been shown to lower progressively the thermal denaturation temperature of proteins. This effect is presumably due to a hydrophobic interaction between the solute and nonpolar domains of the protein. Theoretically, these interactions should occur between the solute and any macromolecular structure having a nonpolar region to which the solute has access. A recent review by Arakawa et al. has summarized evidence for such an interaction between organic solutes and proteins and suggested that these interactions are favored at higher temperatures. The present study investigates the effects of several classes of compounds on the stability of phospholipid vesicles. The results show that many compounds that are known to perturb protein function also destabilize phospholipid bilayers as reflected by solute-induced loss of vesicle contents.     

Observation of Solvent Penetration during Cold Denaturation of E.?coli Phosphofructokinase-2

Phosphofructokinase-2 is a dimeric enzyme that undergoes cold denaturation following a highly cooperative N₂ 2I mechanism with dimer dissociation and formation of an expanded monomeric intermediate. Here, we use intrinsic fluorescence of a tryptophan located at the dimer interface to show that dimer dissociation occurs slowly, over several hours. We then use hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry experiments, performed by taking time points over the cold denaturation process, to measure amide exchange throughout the protein during approach to the cold denatured state. As expected, a peptide corresponding to the dimer interface became more solvent exposed over time at 3°C; unexpectedly, amide exchange increased throughout the protein over time at 3°C. The rate of increase in amide exchange over time at 3°C was the same for each region and equaled the rate of dimer dissociation measured by tryptophan fluorescence, suggesting that dimer dissociation and formation of the cold denatured intermediate occur without appreciable buildup of folded monomer. The observation that throughout the protein amide exchange increases as phosphofructokinase-2 cold denatures provides experimental evidence for theoretical predictions that cold denaturation primarily occurs by solvent penetration into the hydrophobic core of proteins in a sequence-independent manner.     

Protein stability and hydrophobic interactions

The paper summarizes results of calorimetric studies of protein denaturation and of dissolution of non-polar substances in water. The analysis of the available experimental data shows that the positive contribution of the hydrophobic interactions in stabilization of the protein compact state is due to van der Waals interactions between the protein non-polar groups, while the contribution of water solvation by these groups, in spite of the widely spread opinion, appears to be always negative. This destabilizing action of water solvation on the protein increases as the temperature decreases, and at a significantly low temperature causes unfolding of the compact structure of protein, i. e. cold denaturation.