Gastropod predation patterns in the Eocene of Nigeria

The Ameki Formation (middle Eocene) of Nigeria contains a diverse, primarily molluscan macrofauna that probably lived in a shallow-shelf marine environment. Naticids, followed by muricids, were the most abundant and most successful borers. Cannibalism was high among the naticids. Though small (< 10 mm) gastropods were the most frequently exploited food source, there is no strict correlation between predator and prey sizes. Coarseness of sculpture and shell thickness similarly did not constitute effective deterrents to borers. Comparison of the predator-prey pattern in the Ameki with that of Eocene assemblages from the Paris Basin and Alabama and a Recent West African shelf assemblage shows that since the Eocene, pelecypods have replaced gastropods as the most frequently exploited food source of predatory borers, and muricids have become better represented numerically.     

Naticid gastropod predation in the Gatun Formation (late Middle Miocene), Panama: preliminary assessment

Understanding predator-prey interactions is an important component of community studies, both present and past. Patterns of naticid predation in a fossil molluscan assemblage were studied by examination of drilling frequencies in a series of samples collected at three sites of the Gatun Formation (late Middle Miocene), Panama. Overall drilling intensities were relatively low (18 %) and were not correlated with abundance. Turritellids, turrids, and terebrids (making up to 11 % of the studied fauna) were the most consumed, representing almost 29 % of the total prey. Especially important were turritellids representing over 20 % of the total consumed prey. Albeit abundant (54 % of the studied fauna), columbellids, cerithiids, and marginellids showed low drilling intensities (8.2–10.4 %). Naticids were the major predators. Con-familial drilling among naticids is high and did not seem to be related to absence of preferred prey. Consistent with other studies, these data indicate that predators demonstrate high prey selectivity.     

Alternative predation tactics of a tropical naticid gastropod

Aquarium observations of naticid gastropods from Hong Kong show that different species attack their bivalve prey in different ways. Natica gualteriana and Glossaulax didyma appeared always to use conventional modes of boring, i.e., through one shell valve, before consuming the prey, but some larger prey of C. didyma with incomplete borings were consumed after having apparently suffocated before boring was complete. In contrast, Polinices tumidus prey may be side-bored, edge-bored (i.e., through the commisure of the valves) or suffocated and consumed without boring. The frequency of each of these modes of attack vary with different prey species. Non-boring prédation, in aquarium experiments, accounted for 14.7–54.9% of attacks with different species of prey. Suffocated prey were found to be enwrapped in a thick, viscous coat of mucus, which in partially consumed prey showed a round hole overlying the ventral shell gape marking the entrance hole made by the proboscis. The observations reveal considerable flexibility in predation behaviour in this tropical naticid and have important implications in the interpretation of naticid prédation rates in recent and fossil dead shell assemblages.     

SHAPE DIFFERENCES AMONG BOREHOLES DRILLED BY THREE SPECIES OF NATICID GASTROPODS

Naticid gastropods leave a record of predation in the form ofcharacteristic countersunk circular boreholes. We fed bivalveprey to naticids to test whether the ratio between the innerand outer borehole diameter differed among three Recent naticidspecies: Euspira heros, E. lewisii and Neverita duplicata. Fossilshells from a Miocene-aged assemblage, containing naticids previouslyidentified as E. heros and N. duplicata, were also includedin our analyses. Ratios of the inner to outer diameters of naticidboreholes in bivalve shells showed that there were significantdifferences in borehole shape between E. heros and the two otherRecent species. We found no significant differences betweenthe ratios of E. lewisii and N. duplicata; however, a principalcomponent analysis showed that boreholes distinctly clusteraccording to species. The Miocene boreholes were also distinctfrom the Recent, indicating that the Miocene naticids may bea separate species from E. heros and N. duplicata. We have shownthat there is a species-specific component to borehole geometry.This may have important implications for palaeobiological studies,because the index of borehole functionality, previously describedas an inner to outer borehole ratio of 0.5 for all naticids,may differ between species. (Received 23 March 2004; accepted 10 January 2005)     

Invasion of a naticid predator and associated changes in death assemblages of bivalve prey in northern Japan: implications for palaeoecological studies

The recent invasion of a naticid predator (Laguncula pulchella) and associated changes in the death assemblages of bivalve prey (Ruditapes philippinarum) provide a baseline for interpreting predator–prey interactions in the fossil record. This article presents quantitative data on size‐frequency distributions (SFDs) of living and death assemblages, prey size selectivity and drillhole site selectivity from the Tona Coast, northern Japan. Before the appearance of the predator, the SFD of the death assemblage exhibited a right‐skewed platykurtic distribution, and there were very few predatory drillholes. Once the predator appeared, frequencies of predatory drillholes increased, particularly in the smallest size class (2–10 mm shell length). Furthermore, juvenile peaks in the SFDs of death assemblages sharpened, and thus, SFDs exhibited strongly right‐skewed leptokurtic distributions. These changes suggest that intense naticid predation precluded juvenile clams from growing to adulthood, and thus, many dead shells of juvenile clams were introduced into the sediment. The changes in SFDs may also indicate intensification of predation pressure in the fossil record. No temporal shifts in prey size selectivity and drillhole site selectivity were noted, despite substantial changes in the demographics of Ruditapes philippinarum. This suggests that lack of specific size classes of preferred prey species is unlikely to be a primary factor accounting for size mismatches between predator and prey, because, in such situations, naticid predators probably attack other prey species. Therefore, such a factor is unlikely to primarily explain the less stereotypical predatory behaviour (i.e. low prey size selectivity and low drillhole site selectivity), which has been frequently recognized in fossil assemblages. Such less stereotypical predatory behaviour in fossil assemblages is likely to be explained by other factors, such as the existence of multiple predator taxa and lack of specific size classes of all available prey.     

Invasion of Laguncula pulchella (Gastropoda: Naticidae) and predator–prey interactions with bivalves on the Tona coast, Miyagi prefecture, northern Japan

On the Tona coast, Miyagi prefecture, northern Japan, interactions between the alien predator Laguncula pulchella and its bivalve prey were explored using annually collected quadrat samples over a 10 year period, from 2001 to 2010. A single L. pulchella individual was first recorded in 2002, and the density increased 12-fold from 2002 to 2004. In contrast, population densities of Ruditapes philippinarum and Macoma incongrua rapidly decreased during this interval. Based on frequency of predatory drill holes on the dead shells, more than 35 % of Ruditapes philippinarum and 20 % of Macoma incongrua died because of naticid predation after 2004, while Pillucina pisidium was less vulnerable to naticid predation. L. pulchella focused attacks on P. pisidium in 2004, when R. philippinarum and M. incongrua had became scarce due to naticid predation. This species-selective predation affected bivalve community structure, and caused disagreements in taxonomic composition and species’ rank-order abundance between the living bivalve community and the assemblage of dead shells. This approach (live–dead analysis), frequently used in paleoecological research, is a conservative tool to identify impacts of an alien predator on community structure. When sample size is sufficient, frequency of predatory drill holes in preferred prey species is likely to reflect predation intensity.     

Traces of Naticid Predation on the Gryphaeid Oyster Pycnodonte dissimilaris: Epifaunal Drilling of Prey in the Paleocene

Traces of drilling predation by naticid gastropods were observed on 51 valves of the free-lying, semi-infaunal oyster Pycnodonte dissimilaris (Gryphaeidae) from the Paleocene Hornerstown Formation, in New Jersey. Stereotypic behavior of the predator is indicated by the highly constrained placement of drill holes, 94% of which are centrally located on the oyster shells. Predator—prey mismatches in size, involving small predators that drilled through the upper valves of relatively large oysters, are documented by comparison of outer borehole diameter, as an index of predator size, with the sizes of the oyster shells. Results of this analysis suggest that at least some prey were drilled epifaunally, as they were too large to be manipulated and buried by the predator. This indicates, together with reports of epifaunal drilling by living naticids, that such behavior is geographically and stratigraphically more widespread in the Naticidae than has previously been acknowledged. This in turn suggests that epifaunal drilling of prey is a plesiomorphic, opportunistic mode of behavior, conserved in the evolution of the Naticidae, that has permitted subsequent escalation or expansion in range of naticid foraging from a more narrowly defined infaunal paradigm into exposed intertidal refugia.     

Record of Naticid Predation on Scaphopods (Mollusca) from the Latest Maastrichtian of Rajahmundry,India

Drilling predation provides a rare opportunity to study and quantify prey-predator interactions in the fossil record. Records of drilling predation on scaphopod mollusc are rare. Here, we report naticid drilling predation on scaphopods from a “Turritelline-dominated assemblage” (TDA) stratigraphically just below the K-Pg boundary sections in Rajahmundry, India, which was situated in the Southern Hemisphere during that time. Low drilling frequency was found in the present assemblage based on 248 specimens, which was similar to most of the Cretaceous values previously reported. Majority of the specimens of previous studies were reported from higher latitudes in the Northern Hemisphere. Our report extended the palaeobiogeography of naticid predation on scaphopods into the Southern Hemisphere. Size and site stereotypy of drillholes on the scaphopod shell suggested that predatory behavior of naticids was already highly evolved, but evidence of escalation was less clear in scaphopod prey.     

Feeding ecology of Xenoturbella bocki (phylum Xenoturbellida) revealed by genetic barcoding

The benthic marine worm Xenoturbella is frequently contaminated with molluscan DNA, which had earlier caused confusion resulting in a suggested bivalve relationship. In order to find the source of the contaminant, we have used molluscan sequences derived from Xenoturbella and compared them to barcodes obtained from several individuals of the nonmicroscopic molluscs sharing the same environment as Xenoturbella. Using cytochrome oxidase 1, we found the contaminating sequences to be 98% similar to the bivalve Ennucula tenuis. Using the highly variable D1-D2 region of the large ribosomal subunit in Xenoturbella, we found three distinct species of contaminating molluscs, one of which is 99% similar to the bivalve Abra nitida, one of the most abundant bivalves in the Gullmarsfjord where Xenoturbella was found, and another 99% similar to the bivalve Nucula sulcata. These data clearly show that Xenoturbella only contains molluscan DNA originating from bivalves living in the same environment, refuting former hypotheses of a bivalve relationship. In addition, these data suggest that Xenoturbella feeds specifically on bivalve prey from multiple species, possibly in the form of eggs and larvae.     

Pulling or drilling, does size or species matter? An experimental study of prey handling in Octopus dierythraeus ()

The influence of both predator and prey size on the shift from a pulling to a drilling predatory response was examined in the intertidal octopus Octopus dierythraeus, using an experimental program. Additionally, selective drilling, where particular regions of the prey are targeted, was examined for a variety of bivalve and gastropod prey. O. dierythraeus always initially attempted to pull bivalves apart. Shells that were eventually drilled were always subjected to significantly more pulling attempts than those that could be pulled apart, indicating that octopus are willing to expend more energy to access the flesh quickly. There was no defined threshold where bivalve size caused an octopus to switch from a pulling to a drilling response. Instead, there was a broad size range where the octopus could adopt either handling method and it varied for each individual. Octopus may only able to pull open bivalves before the molecular ratchet or ‘catch’ mechanism that many bivalves possess is engaged. This might explain the lack of a relationship between either octopus or bivalve size and the success of pulling, as it is likely that when the bivalves were presented to individual octopus they were either setting the ‘catch’ mechanism, or had already engaged it. O. dierythraeus demonstrated selective drilling on a variety of molluscan prey, with penetration sites differing between prey species. O. dierythraeus targeted the valve periphery, which was the thinnest part of the shell, therefore minimizing handling time. O. dierythraeus always drilled gastropods, but did not target the thinnest regions of the shells, with drill site varying according to the morphology of the prey. Elongate species with pronounced aperture lips were drilled in the apical region, close to the columella on the side of the opercula whereas nonelongate species were drilled immediately above the aperture. The location of drilling sites may represent a trade-off between targeting the most effective places to inject paralyzing secretions and the mechanically simplest places to drill.     

Can Naticid Gastropod Predators Be Identified by the Holes They Drill?

We tested the hypothesis that drillholes made by different species of predatory naticid gastropods can be differentiated by variability in the inner (IBD) and outer borehole diameters (OBD) of the holes they drill. We compared two samples of Mya arenaria that were drilled by different predators, Euspira heros and Neverita duplicata, under experimental conditions. Mean IBD:OBD ratio was significantly greater for holes drilled by Euspira compared to Neverita, indicating that Euspira drills a steeper drillhole than Neverita. We also found consistent differences between the two naticids for slopes of regression lines of IBD on OBD after standardization for predator size and prey size and thickness, with slopes for Euspira being steeper, but results were not statistically significant. However, the range of IBD:OBD ratios was wide and overlapped considerably for each species, which decreases confidence in assignment of individual drillholes to a particular predator species. At least in the case of these two naticid species, interspecific differences in variation of the inner and outer diameters of the holes they drill have limited utility in identifying the maker of individual boring traces in the fossil record.     

Predation by juvenile Polinices duplicatvs (Say) on Gemma gemma (Totten)

Feeding by juvenile Polinices duplicatus (Say) on Gemma gemma (Totten) at Barnstable Harbor, Massachusetts, was examined using laboratory experiments and collections of naturally occurring bored shells. Snails < 19 mm fed on Gemma in the laboratory and borehole diameter was directly related to predator size. Field collections of drilled shells showed that Gemma was an important prey of 0-year-class Polinices. Boreholes in Gemma shells from field collections were made primarily by snails of 1– mm, and < 3% were made by snails of > 10 mm. Most bored Gemma were large 1- to 2-yr-old individuals. The proportion of empty Gemma shells containing boreholes ranged from 3.7–14.6%, indicating that naticid prédation was a minor source of total Gemma mortality. Collections of bored shells closely reflected both the size range and relative abundance of natural predators of Gemma.     

The first record and occurrence of Stagnicola turricula (Held, 1836) (Gastropoda: Pulmonata: Lymnaeidae) in Upper Silesia (Southern Poland) in relation to different environmental factors

The degradation of freshwater environments, e.g.: eutrophication, drainage, water pollution, has led to the decline of lymnaeid species distribution. Some of them are recorded in the Red Book and Red List of species as rare, vulnerable or legally protected. The survey was carried out in Upper Silesia (Southern Poland), which is one of the biggest coal basins in the world. This region is devoid of natural water bodies; only reservoirs of an anthropogenic origin are common. Anthropogenic reservoirs, which are not very degraded, constitute important lentic habitats in Upper Silesia and they provide refuges for wildlife including rare and vulnerable molluscan species. This survey uncovered the first occurrence of Stagnicola turricula in the anthropogenic reservoirs in this area. S. turricula has been subdominant in molluscan communities. Sixteen molluscan species, including 11 gastropod and 5 bivalve species, were recorded at the sampling sites. Based on a redundancy analysis (RDA), the organic matter content in the bottom sediments and pH were the parameters most associated (statistically significant) with the distribution of molluscan species including S. turricula.     

Consumption rates and prey preference of the invasive gastropod Rapana venosa in the Northern Adriatic Sea

The alien Asian gastropod Rapana venosa (Valenciennes 1846) was first recorded in 1973 along the Italian coast of the Northern Adriatic Sea. Recently, this predator of bivalves has been spreading all around the world oceans, probably helped by ship traffic and aquaculture trade. A caging experiment in natural environment was performed during the summer of 2002 in Cesenatico (Emilia-Romagna, Italy) in order to estimate consumption rates and prey preference of R. venosa. The prey items chosen were the Mediterranean mussel Mytilus galloprovincialis (Lamarck 1819), the introduced carpet clam Tapes philippinarum (Adams and Reeve 1850), both supporting the local fisheries, and the Indo-Pacific invasive clam Anadara (Scapharca) inaequivalvis (Bruguière 1789). Results showed an average consumption of about 1 bivalve prey per day (or 1.2 g wet weight per day). Predation was species and size selective towards small specimens of A. inaequivalvis; consumption of the two commercial species was lower. These results might reduce the concern about the economical impact on the local bivalve fishery due to the presence of the predatory gastropod. On the other hand, selective predation might probably alter local community structure, influencing competition amongst filter feeder/suspension feeder bivalve species and causing long-term ecological impact. The large availability of food resource and the habitat characteristics of the Emilia-Romagna littoral makes this area an important breeding ground for R. venosa in the Mediterranean Sea, thus worthy of consideration in order to understand the bioinvasion ecology of this species and to control its likely further dispersal.     

PREDATOR-PREY INTERACTIONS BETWEEN LEPSIELLA (BEDEVA) PAIVAE (GASTROPODA: MURICIDAE) AND KATELYSIA SCALARINA (BIVALVIA: VENERIDAE) IN PRINCESS ROYAL HARBOUR, WESTERN AUSTRALIA

On a sandy beach at Shoal Bay in Princess Royal Harbour, Albany,southwestern Western Australia, lives a small muricid gastropodthat feeds virtually monotonically on the overwhelmingly dominantresident bivalve Katelysia scalarina. Lepsiella paivae livesburied in the sand and attacks its prey within it. Because ofits small size (<13 mm shell height), bivalve prey isalso small and this study demonstrates a preference for K. scalarinaof 5 mm shell length, i.e. juveniles. Laboratory experimentsalso suggested a possible preference for attack of the rightvalve. Lepsiella paivae can and does, however, attack largerprey (up to 15 mm shell length), but cannot consume themcompletely. A second visit to Princess Royal Harbour in theAustral winter, when there was no juvenile K. scalarina present,showed L. paivae to be attacking at the sand surface, also bydrilling, the small (<4 mm) gastropod Hydrococcus brazieri(Hydrococcidae). SEM studies of experimentally determined drillholes of L. paivae show them to be of variable form, some straightsided, others bevelled (like a naticid) and <500 µmin diameter. On this sheltered Southern Ocean beach, therefore,L. paivae has specialized to attack juvenile bivalves by burrowingafter them. It can, however, attack other species opportunisticallyon the sand surface when seasonally favoured juvenile bivalveprey are not present. (Received 8 January 2005; accepted 16 March 2005)     

Influence of setting,sieve size,and sediment depth on multivariate and univariate assemblage attributes of coral reef-associated mollusc death assemblages from the Gulf of Aqaba

Measures of diversity and ecology of marine invertebrate assemblages depend on a variety of factors including environmental conditions and methodological decisions. In this study, the influence of such factors on multi- and univariate assemblage parameters of molluscan death assemblages from the Gulf of Aqaba (Red Sea, Jordan) was evaluated. Sediment samples were collected at two coral reef types, a patch reef at 13 m of water depth characterized by fine-grained sediments and a Millepora-fringing reef with coarse-grained sediments at 5 m of water depth. The upper and lower 10 cm of the sediment column were separately removed and sieved with mesh sizes of 1 and 2 mm. A large dataset of 6400 bivalve and gastropod shells was compiled to evaluate how setting, sediment depth, and sieve size influenced taxonomic composition and species richness, species-abundance patterns and the Shannon–Wiener index, the number of drilled shells per species and drilling frequency (DF) of the assemblage. Setting had the strongest impact on all aspects, followed by sieve size, but sediment depth was insignificant, probably due to complete homogenization of the sediments by reworking and bioturbation. Multivariate assemblage parameters distinguished much better between categories (setting, sieve size) than univariate measures. Sieve size-related disagreements recognized between the two higher taxa are mostly due to the underlying difference in body-size distribution of bivalve and gastropod assemblages. We conclude that species richness and other ecological characteristics of molluscan death assemblages in coral reef-associated sediments will most strongly reflect habitat complexity of the sites chosen, are significantly influenced by methodological decisions (i.e., sieve size), will only poorly preserve temporal patterns, and the results will differ between bivalves and gastropods.     

Additive interactions between the moon snail Euspira heros and the sea star Asterias forbesi, two predators of the surfclam Spisula solidissima

A laboratory experiment was conducted to determine whether the sea star Asterias forbesi and the naticid gastropod Euspira heros feed on surfclams, Spisula solidissima, in an additive or non-additive manner. Predators were allowed to feed on clams with conspecifics and in the presence of the other predator species. Clam mortality (measured as the rate of decline of clam number) and predator feeding rates were noted. To determine the effects of temperature on interactions among the predators, the experiment was conducted at three different temperatures. At all temperatures, feeding rate of each predator was not affected by the presence of the other species, and clam mortality in the presence of both predators was predictable from mortality in the presence of a single predator species. These additive interactions are most likely a result of habitat partitioning between the predators, with naticid snails being infaunal and sea stars being epifaunal. Previous studies in a variety of systems show no clear pattern of occurrence of non-additive interactions. Relatively small differences in predator or prey behavior may be responsible for the presence or absence of non-additive interactions. Received: 6 August 1998 / Accepted: 25 January 1999     

Immunohistochemical study of subepidermal connective of molluscan integument

Sections of integument from gastropod, bivalve and cephalopod species were studied immunohistochemically to determine reactivity to antibody against the type I-like collagen from Sepia cartilage and antibodies against components of the extracellular matrix (ECM) of vertebrate connective tissue: type I, III, IV, V, and VI collagens, laminin, nidogen and heparan sulphate. All samples exhibited similar reactivities to the antibodies, although differences in the intensity and localization of the immunostaining were found that were clearly correlated with between-species differences in integumental ultrastructure. These findings indicate that the composition of the integumental ECM is similar in the three classes of molluscs examined and that several types of collagen are present. However molluscan subepidermal connective tissue differs from the ECM of vertebrate dermis: molluscan integumental ECM contains collagens similar to type I, V and VI collagens but has no type III-similar collagen. Furthermore molecules similar to the type IV collagen, laminin, nidogen and heparan sulphate of vertebrates were present ubiquitously in molluscan basement membrane, confirming the statement that the structure and composition of basement membrane have remained constant throughout the evolution of all animal phyla.     

长江中下游湖泊软体动物的多样性及分布现状

长江中下游流域是我国淡水贝类多样性最为集中的地区,然而由于人类活动的影响,淡水贝类已成为高度濒危的类群。为有效保护淡水贝类的多样性,我们于2003年6月-2005年5月对长江中下游流域13个水体软体动物的多样性及分布进行了调查。共采集到软体动物69种(中国特有种42种),隶属于腹足类9科14属29种和瓣鳃类5科17属40种。其中,蚌科和田螺科是种类数最多的两个科,分别占总种类数的50.7%和14.5%。不同类型湖泊软体动物种类数的差别较大。通江湖泊所占种类数相对丰富,尤其是适应流水的种类,如河螺属、短沟蜷属及蚌科的种类。大型通江湖泊鄱阳湖和洞庭湖软体动物的种类数和特有种数分别66种和40种,分别占总种类数和总特有种数的95.7%和95.2%。阻隔水体所占种类数相对较少,种类数为4-19种。与历史资料相比,长江中下游湖泊软体动物的种类数和特有种数均减少50%左右,且多数种类的分布范围也明显缩小。造成贝类资源衰退的可能原因主要是江湖阻隔所引起的整个江湖复合系统栖息地和水文情势的改变,其他的人为活动如过度捕捞、围垦及废污水的过度排放等也可能是其中的重要原因。