Binaural disparity cues available to the barn owl for sound localization

1. Bilateral recording of cochlear potentials was used to measure the variations in interaural time differences (ITDs) and interaural intensity differences (IIDs) as a free-field auditory stimulus was moved to different positions around a barn owl's head. 2. ITD varied smoothly with stimulus azimuth across a broad frequency range. 3. ITD varied minimally with stimulus elevation, except at extreme angles from the horizontal. 4. IID varied with both stimulus elevation and stimulus azimuth. Lower frequencies were more sensitive to variations in azimuth, whereas higher frequencies were more sensitive to variations in elevation. 5. The loci of spatial coordinates that form iso-IID contours and iso-ITD contours form a non-orthogonal grid that relates binaural disparity cues to sound location.     

Sensitivity to spectral interaural intensity difference cues in space-specific neurons of the barn owl

Barn owls use interaural intensity differences to localize sounds in the vertical plane. At a given elevation the magnitude of the interaural intensity difference cue varies with frequency, creating an interaural intensity difference spectrum of cues which is characteristic of that direction. To test whether space-specific cells are sensitive to spectral interaural intensity difference cues, pure-tone interaural intensity difference tuning curves were taken at multiple different frequencies for single neurons in the external nucleus of the inferior colliculus. For a given neuron, the interaural intensity differences eliciting the maximum response (the best interaural intensity differences) changed with the frequency of the stimulus by an average maximal difference of 9.4±6.2 dB. The resulting spectral patterns of these neurally preferred interaural intensity differences exhibited a high degree of similarity to the acoustic interaural intensity difference spectra characteristic of restricted regions in space. Compared to stimuli whose interaural intensity difference spectra matched the preferred spectra, stimuli with inverted spectra elicited a smaller response, showing that space-specific neurons are sensitive to the shape of the spectrum. The underlying mechanism is an inhibition for frequency-specific interaural intensity differences which differ from the preferred spectral pattern. Collectively, these data show that space-specific neurons are sensitive to spectral interaural intensity difference cues and support the idea that behaving barn owls use such cues to precisely localize sounds.Abbreviations ABI average binaural intensity - HRTF head-related transfer function - ICx external nucleus of the inferior colliculus - IID interaural intensity difference - ITD interaural time difference - OT optic tectum - RMS root mean square - VLVp nucleus ventralis lemnisci laterale, pars posterior     

Influence of the facial ruff on the sound-receiving characteristics of the barn owl’s ears

The barn owl, a nocturnal predator, derives its German name (“Schleiereule”, direct English translation “veil owl”) from the conspicuous ruff that covers the ear openings and gives the head a face-like appearance. The ruff is a specialization for the perception of sound. The densely-ramified reflector feathers forming the border of the ruff direct sound to the ear-openings. We studied the influence of the ruff on the behaviorally relevant sound-localization parameters interaural time difference (ITD) and interaural level difference (ILD). The directionality of the ear was much greater when the ruff was intact than when the reflector feathers were removed. With ruff intact, the distribution of ILDs was oblique and the maximum ITD occurred around 110° of azimuth. When all head feathers were removed, the steepest ILD gradient was much closer to the horizontal axis and ITD was maximal at 90°. Many effects were frequency specific. Thus, the ruff reflects some properties of the human pinna. However, by shifting the point where ITD becomes maximal beyond 90°, the ruff also introduces a break of the front–back symmetry of ITD.     

Sensitivity to interaural time difference and representation of azimuth in central nucleus of inferior colliculus in the barn owl

Standard electrophysiology and virtual auditory stimuli were used to investigate the influence of interaural time difference on the azimuthal tuning of neurons in the core and the lateral shell of the central nucleus of the inferior colliculus of the barn owl. The responses of the neurons to virtual azimuthal stimuli depended in a periodic way on azimuth. Fixation of the interaural time difference, while leaving all other spatial cues unchanged, caused a loss of periodicity and a broadening of azimuthal tuning. This effect was studied in more detail in neurons of the core. The azimuthal range tested and the frequency selectivity of the neurons were additional parameters influencing the changes induced by fixating the interaural time difference. The addition of an interaural time difference to the virtual stimuli resulted in a shift of the tuning curves that correlated with the interaural time difference added. In this condition, tuning strength did not change. These results suggest that interaural time difference is an important determinant of azimuthal tuning in all neurons of the core and lateral shell of the central nucleus of the inferior colliculus, and is the only determinant in many of the neurons from the core.     

Coding interaural time differences at low best frequencies in the barn owl.

In birds and mammals, precisely timed spikes encode the timing of acoustic stimuli, and interaural acoustic disparities propagate to binaural processing centers. The Jeffress model proposes that these projections act as delay lines to innervate an array of coincidence detectors, every element of which has a different relative delay between its ipsilateral and contralateral excitatory inputs. Thus, interaural time difference (ITD) is encoded into the position of the coincidence detector whose delay lines best cancel out the acoustic ITD. Neurons of the avian nucleus laminaris and mammalian MSO phase-lock to both monaural and binaural stimuli but respond maximally when phase-locked spikes from each side arrive simultaneously, i.e. when the difference in the conduction delays compensates for the ITD. McAlpine et al. [Nat. Neurosci. 4 (2001) 396] identified an apparent difference between avian and mammalian ITD coding. In the barn owl, the maximum firing rate appears to encode ITD. This may not be the case for the guinea pig, where the steepest region of the function relating discharge rate to interaural time delay (ITD) is close to midline for all neurons, irrespective of best frequency (BF). These data suggest that low BF ITD sensitivity in the guinea pig is mediated by detection of a change in slope of the ITD function, and not by maximum rate. We review coding of low best frequency ITDs in barn owls and mammals and discuss whether there may be differences in the code used to signal ITD in mammals and birds.     

Binaural processing in the synthesis of auditory spatial receptive fields

The owls auditory system computes interaural time (ITD) and interaural level (ILD) differences to create a two-dimensional map of auditory space. Space-specific neurons are selective for combinations of ITD and ILD, which define, respectively, the horizontal and vertical dimensions of their receptive fields. ITD curves for postsynaptic potentials indicate that ICx neurons integrate the results of binaural cross correlation in different frequency bands. However, the difference between the main and side peaks is slight. ICx neurons further enhance this difference in the process of converting membrane potentials to impulse rates. Comparison of subthreshold postsynaptic potentials (PSPs) and spike output for the same neurons showed that receptive fields measured in PSPs were much larger than those measured in spikes in both ITD and ILD dimensions. A multiplication of separate postsynaptic potentials tuned to ITD and ILD can account for the combination sensitivity of these neurons to ITD–ILD pairs.     

On the ability of neurons in the barn owl's inferior colliculus to sense brief appearances of interaural time difference

Summary This paper investigates the ability of neurons in the barn owl's (Tyto alba) inferior colliculus to sense brief appearances of interaural time difference (ITD), the main cue for azimuthal sound localization in this species. In the experiments, ITD-tuning was measured during presentation of a mask-probe-mask sequence. The probe consisted of a noise having a constant ITD, while the mask consisted of binaurally uncorrelated noise. Collicular neurons discriminated between the probe and masking noise by showing rapid changes from untuned to tuned and back to untuned responses.The curve describing the relation between probe duration and the degree of ITD-tuning resembled a leaky-integration process with a time constant of about 2 ms. Many neurons were ITD-tuned when probe duration was below 1 ms. These extremely short effective probe durations are interpreted as evidence for neuronal convergence within the pathway computing ITD. The minimal probe duration necessary for ITD-tuning was independent of the bandwidth of the neurons' frequency tuning and also of the best frequency of a neuron. Many narrowly tuned neurons having different best frequencies converge to form a broad-band neuron. To yield the short effective probe durations the convergence must occur in strong temporal synchronism.Abbreviations ICc central nucleus of the inferior colliculus; - ICx external nucleus of the inferior colliculus; - ITD interaural time difference - LP Likelihood parameter     

Forward masking in the evoked responses of the guinea pig auditory cortex: effects of variation of the interaural time and phase differences

In anaesthesized guinea pigs the evoked potentials of the auditory cortex were studied in a forward masking paradigm. In-phase and out-of-phase binaurally presented clicks with interaural time delay (ITD) were used as masker, in-phase click with ITD = 0 served as probe signal. Addition of the masking stimulus suppressed the probe-evoked response that followed the masker. The magnitude of the suppression correlated with the amount of the masker-evoked response: an increase in masker-evoked excitation caused a greater reduction in probe response magnitude. Amplitude of masker-evoked response was seen to be a monotonic or non-monotonic function of ITD. The non-monotonic response exhibited a sensitivity to the interaural phase differences when in-phase and out-of-phase maskers were presented, and showed the tendency to be periodic function of ITD in the expanded range of ITD values. Phase-sensitive responses differed in recovery time following the in-phase and out-of-phase masking stimuli. At near-threshold levels of a forward masker an enhancement of the probe-evoked response was observed.     

Multiplicative Auditory Spatial Receptive Fields Created by a Hierarchy of Population Codes

A multiplicative combination of tuning to interaural time difference (ITD) and interaural level difference (ILD) contributes to the generation of spatially selective auditory neurons in the owl''s midbrain. Previous analyses of multiplicative responses in the owl have not taken into consideration the frequency-dependence of ITD and ILD cues that occur under natural listening conditions. Here, we present a model for the responses of ITD- and ILD-sensitive neurons in the barn owl''s inferior colliculus which satisfies constraints raised by experimental data on frequency convergence, multiplicative interaction of ITD and ILD, and response properties of afferent neurons. We propose that multiplication between ITD- and ILD-dependent signals occurs only within frequency channels and that frequency integration occurs using a linear-threshold mechanism. The model reproduces the experimentally observed nonlinear responses to ITD and ILD in the inferior colliculus, with greater accuracy than previous models. We show that linear-threshold frequency integration allows the system to represent multiple sound sources with natural sound localization cues, whereas multiplicative frequency integration does not. Nonlinear responses in the owl''s inferior colliculus can thus be generated using a combination of cellular and network mechanisms, showing that multiple elements of previous theories can be combined in a single system.     

Discrimination of the dynamic properties of sound source spatial location in humans: Electrophysiology and psychophysics

The spatial resolution of the human auditory system was studied under conditions, where the location of the sound source was changed according to different temporal patterns of interaural time delay. Two experimental procedures were run in the same group of subjects: a psychophysical procedure (the transformed staircase method) and an electrophysiological one (which requires recording of mismatch negativity, the auditory evoked response component). It was established that (1) the value of the mismatch negativity reflected the degree of spatial deviation of the sound source; (2) the mismatch negativity was elicited even at minimum (20μs) interaural time delays under both temporal patterns (abrupt azimuth change and gradual sound movement at different velocities); (3) an abrupt change of the sound source azimuth resulted in a greater mismatch negativity than gradual sound movement did if the interaural time delay exceeded 40 μs; (4) the discrimination threshold values of the interaural delay obtained in the psychophysical procedure were greater than the minimum interaural delays that elicited mismatch negativity, with the exception of the expert listeners, who exhibited no significant difference.     

The Modulation by Intensity of the Processing of Interaural Timing Cues for Localizing Sounds

Features of sounds such as time and intensity are important binaural cues for localizing their sources. Interaural time differences (ITDs) and interaural level differences are extracted and processed in parallel by separate pathways in the brainstem auditory nuclei. ITD cues are small, particularly in small-headed animals, and processing of these cues is optimized by both morphological and physiological specializations. Moreover, recent observations in mammals and in some birds indicate that interaural time and level cues are not processed independently but cooperatively to improve the detection of interaural differences. This review will specifically summarize what is known about how inhibitory circuits improve the measurements of ITD in a sound-level-dependent manner.     

Asymmetric Excitatory Synaptic Dynamics Underlie Interaural Time Difference Processing in the Auditory System

Low-frequency sound localization depends on the neural computation of interaural time differences (ITD) and relies on neurons in the auditory brain stem that integrate synaptic inputs delivered by the ipsi- and contralateral auditory pathways that start at the two ears. The first auditory neurons that respond selectively to ITD are found in the medial superior olivary nucleus (MSO). We identified a new mechanism for ITD coding using a brain slice preparation that preserves the binaural inputs to the MSO. There was an internal latency difference for the two excitatory pathways that would, if left uncompensated, position the ITD response function too far outside the physiological range to be useful for estimating ITD. We demonstrate, and support using a biophysically based computational model, that a bilateral asymmetry in excitatory post-synaptic potential (EPSP) slopes provides a robust compensatory delay mechanism due to differential activation of low threshold potassium conductance on these inputs and permits MSO neurons to encode physiological ITDs. We suggest, more generally, that the dependence of spike probability on rate of depolarization, as in these auditory neurons, provides a mechanism for temporal order discrimination between EPSPs.     

Responses of neurons in the primary auditory cortex of the cat to the auditory motion stimuli with variable interaural delay

Unit responses in the primary auditory cortex of anesthetized cats to stationary and apparently moving stimuli resulted from a static and dynamically varying interaural delay (ITD) were recorded. The static stimuli consisted of binaurally presented tones and clicks. The dynamic stimuli were produced by in-phase and out-of-phase binaurally presented click trains with time-varying ITD. Sensitivity to ITDs was mostly seen in responses of the neurons with low characteristic frequency (below 2.8 kHz). All cells sampled with static stimuli responded to simulated motion. A motion effect could take the form of a difference in response magnitude depending on the direction of stimulus motion and a shift in the ITD-function opposite the direction of motion. The magnitude of motion effects was influenced by the position of motion trajectory relative to the ITD-function. The greatest motion effect was produced by motion crossing the ITD-function slopes.     

Avian interaural canal enhances interaural delay

Summary Using a simple model of the birds' binaural pressure difference acoustic receivers it was predicted that the interaural delay achieved by birds at low frequencies is far greater than that of mammals with a similar head-size. This was upheld when interaural delay was recorded, between the cochlear microphonics, for six species. Stimulus positions were varied over the azimuthal range from the frontal midline to the interaural axis. Predicted delays were frequency dependent (higher frequency, smaller delay), as were the actual delays, and the magnitude of the measured delays were comparable with predictions. Delays measured at high frequencies were close to those expected from pathlength around the head, but delays measured at low frequencies could be more than three times this expectation. This finding raises the possibility that interaural delay may be a useful localization cue in birds, even for those species with very small heads, since the large delays at low frequencies are sufficient to provide a physiological cue to azimuth.     

Tuning bat LSO neurons to interaural intensity differences through spike-timing dependent plasticity

Bats, like other mammals, are known to use interaural intensity differences (IID) to determine azimuthal position. In the lateral superior olive (LSO) neurons have firing behaviors which vary systematically with IID. Those neurons receive excitatory inputs from the ipsilateral ear and inhibitory inputs from the contralateral one. The IID sensitivity of a LSO neuron is thought to be due to delay differences between the signals coming from both ears, differences due to different synaptic delays and to intensity-dependent delays. In this paper we model the auditory pathway until the LSO. We propose a learning scheme where inputs to LSO neurons start out numerous with different relative delays. Spike timing-dependent plasticity (STDP) is then used to prune those connections. We compare the pruned neuron responses with physiological data and analyse the relationship between IID’s of teacher stimuli and IID sensitivities of trained LSO neurons.     

Sound localization: Jeffress and beyond

Many animals use the interaural time differences (ITDs) to locate the source of low frequency sounds. The place coding theory proposed by Jeffress has long been a dominant model to account for the neural mechanisms of ITD detection. Recent research, however, suggests a wider range of strategies for ITD coding in the binaural auditory brainstem. We discuss how ITD is coded in avian, mammalian, and reptilian nervous systems, and review underlying synaptic and cellular properties that enable precise temporal computation. The latest advances in recording and analysis techniques provide powerful tools for both overcoming and utilizing the large field potentials in these nuclei.     

The directionality of the ear of the pigeon (Columba livia)

Summary The directionality of cochlear microphonic potentials in the azimuthal plane was investigated in the pigeon (Columba livia), using acoustic free-field stimulation (pure tones of 0.25–6 kHz).At high frequencies in the pigeon's hearing range (4–6 kHz), changing azimuth resulted in a maximum change of the cochlear microphonic amplitude by about 20 dB (SPL). The directionality decreased clearly with decreasing frequency.Acoustic blocking of the contralateral ear canal could reduce the directional sensitivity of the ipsilateral ear by maximally 8 dB. This indicates a significant sound transmission through the bird's interaural pathways. However, the magnitude of these effects compared to those obtained by sound diffraction (maximum > 15 dB) suggests that pressure gradients at the tympanic membrane are only of subordinate importance for the generation of directional cues.The comparison of interaural intensity differences with previous behavioral results confirms the hypothesis that interaural intensity difference is the primary directional cue of azimuthal sound localization in the high-frequency range (2–6 kHz).Abbreviations CM cochlear microphonic potential - IID interaural intensity difference - IID-MRA minimum resolvable angle calculated from interaural intensity difference - MRA minimum resolvable angle - OTD interaural ongoing time difference - RMS root mean square - SPL sound pressure level     

Functional delay of myelination of auditory delay lines in the nucleus laminaris of the barn owl

In the barn owl, maps of interaural time difference (ITD) are created in the nucleus laminaris (NL) by interdigitating axons that act as delay lines. Adult delay line axons are myelinated, and this myelination is timely, coinciding with the attainment of adult head size, and stable ITD cues. The proximal portions of the axons become myelinated in late embryonic life, but the delay line portions of the axon in NL remain unmyelinated until the first postnatal week. Myelination of the delay lines peaks at the third week posthatch, and myelinating oligodendrocyte density approaches adult levels by one month, when the head reaches its adult width. Migration of oligodendrocyte progenitors into NL and the subsequent onset of myelination may be restricted by a glial barrier in late embryonic stages and the first posthatch week, since the loss of tenascin-C immunoreactivity in NL is correlated with oligodendrocyte progenitor migration into NL.     

Spatial orientation in the bushcricket <Emphasis Type="Italic">Leptophyes punctatissima</Emphasis> (Phaneropterinae; Orthoptera): III. Peripheral directionality and central nervous processing of spatial cues

We examined peripheral and central nervous cues underlying the ability of the bushcricket Leptophyes punctatissima to orient to elevated and depressed sound sources broadcasting the female acoustic reply. The peripheral spatial directionality of the ear was measured physiologically using monaural preparations of an auditory interneuron (T-fibre). In the azimuth, maximal interaural intensity differences of 18 dB occur between ipsi- and contralateral stimulation. With increasing elevation or depression of the sound sources, IIDs decrease systematically and reach zero with the source exactly above or below the preparation. Bilateral, simultaneous recordings of the activity of the pair of interneurons allowed determining the binaural discharge differences which occur in response to the extremely short (1 ms) female reply. These discharge differences are large (four action potentials/stimulus) and reliable in the azimuth with lateral stimulation, and decrease gradually with more frontal stimulation. With elevation and depression of sound sources these differences again decrease to one action potential/stimulus at 60° or 75° elevation, and lateral stimulus angles of about 60°. We also calculated the reliability with which a receiver could correctly determine the location of the sound source. We discuss these quantitative measures in relation to the spatial phonotactic behaviour of male L. punctatissima.     

Modeling coincidence detection in nucleus laminaris

A biologically detailed model of the binaural avian nucleus laminaris is constructed, as a two-dimensional array of multicompartment, conductance-based neurons, along tonotopic and interaural time delay (ITD) axes. The model is based primarily on data from chick nucleus laminaris. Typical chick-like parameters perform ITD discrimination up to 2 kHz, and enhancements for barn owl perform ITD discrimination up to 6 kHz. The dendritic length gradient of NL is explained concisely. The response to binaural out-of-phase input is suppressed well below the response to monaural input (without any spontaneous activity on the opposite side), implicating active potassium channels as crucial to good ITD discrimination.Abbreviations NL Nucleus Laminaris - NM Nucleus Magnocellularis - ITD Interaural Time Difference - BF Best Frequency