Velocity and turbulence measurements past mitral valve prostheses in a model left ventricle

Thrombogenesis and hemolysis have both been linked to the flow dynamics past heart valve prostheses. To learn more about the particular flow dynamics past mitral valve prostheses in the left ventricle under controlled experimental conditions, an in vitro study was performed. The experimental methods included velocity and turbulent shear stress measurements past caged-ball, tilting disc, bileaflet, and polyurethane trileaflet mitral valves in an acrylic rigid model of the left ventricle using laser Doppler anemometry. The results indicate that all four prosthetic heart valves studied create at least mildly disturbed flow fields. The effect of the left ventricular geometry on the flow development is to produce a stabilizing vortex which engulfs the entire left ventricular cavity, depending on the orientation of the valve. The measured turbulent shear stress magnitudes for all four valves did not exceed the reported value for hemolytic damage. However, the measured turbulent shear stresses were near or exceeded the critical shear stress reported in the literature for platelet lysis, a known precursor to thrombus formation.     

Tomographic PIV in a model of the left ventricle: 3D flow past biological and mechanical heart valves

Left ventricular flow is intrinsically complex, three-dimensional and unsteady. Its features are susceptible to cardiovascular pathology and treatment, in particular to surgical interventions involving the valves (mitral valve replacement). To improve our understanding of intraventricular fluid mechanics and the impact of various types of prosthetic valves thereon, we have developed a custom-designed versatile left ventricular phantom with anatomically realistic moving left ventricular membrane. A biological, a tilting disc and a bileaflet valve (in two different orientations) were mounted in the mitral position and tested under the same settings. To investigate 3D flow within the phantom, a four-view tomographic particle image velocimetry setup has been implemented. The results compare side-by-side the evolution of the 3D flow topology, vortical structures and kinetic energy in the left ventricle domain during the cardiac cycle. Except for the tilting disc valve, all tested prosthetic valves induced a crossed flow path, where the outflow crosses the inflow path, passing under the mitral valve. The biological valve shows a strong jet with a peak velocity about twice as high compared to all mechanical heart valves, which makes it easier to penetrate deeply into the cavity. Accordingly, the peak kinetic energy in the left ventricle in case of the biological valve is about four times higher than the mechanical heart valves. We conclude that the tomographic particle imaging velocimetry setup provides a useful ground truth measurement of flow features and allows a comparison of the effects of different valve types on left ventricular flow patterns.     

In vitro pulsatile flow velocity and shear stress measurements in the vicinity of mechanical mitral heart valve prostheses

A three beam laser Doppler anemometer system was used to study the flow fields created by various types of mitral heart valve prostheses under physiological pulsatile flow conditions. The prosthetic valves studied were: Beall caged disc valve, Bjork-Shiley tilting disc valve, Medtronic-Hall tilting disc valve and St. Jude bileaflet valve. The results indicate that all four prosthetic valve designs studied create very disturbed flow fields with elevated turbulent shear stresses and regions of flow separation and/or stagnation. The observed elevated turbulent shear stresses could cause sublethal and/or lethal damage to red cells and platelets. The regions of flow separation and/or stagnation, could lead to thrombus formation and/or tissue overgrowth on the valve structure, as observed on clinically recovered prosthetic valves.     

In vitro flow dynamics of four prosthetic aortic valves: a comparative analysis

The velocity fields downstream of four prosthetic heart valves were mapped in vitro over the entire cross-section of a model aortic root using laser Doppler anemometry. THe Bj?rk-Shiley 60 degrees convexo-concave tilting disc valve, the Smeloff-Cutter caged ball valve, the St. Jude Medical bileaflet valve, and the Ionescu-Shiley standard bioprosthesis were examined under both steady and pulsatile flows. Velocity profiles under steady flow conditions were a good approximation for pulsatile profiles only during midsystole. The pulsatile flow characteristics of the four valves showed variation in large scale flow structures. Comparison of the valves according to pressure drop, shear stress and maximum velocities are also provided.     

Results of a comparative in vitro study of Duromedics and Björk-Shiley monostrut mitral heart valve prostheses

Two different mechanical heart valves with annulus diameters 21–29 mm, (five Björk-Shiley monostrut tilting disc valves and five Duromedics bileaflet valves) have been tested in pulsatile flow in the mitral position of a mock circulation. Reflux, pressure, and orifice area have been measured while cardiac output was varied between 2 and 6 1 min⁻¹. Insufficiency, mean orifice area, discharge coefficient, and performance and efficiency indices have been calculated. Mean values of insufficiency for the Björk-Shiley monostrut valves varied between 4.8 and 17.2% while the corresponding values for the Duromedics valves were in the range 6.1–17.3%. Mean values for orifice areas of the Björk-Shiley monostrut valves increased with the larger valve sizes from 101.1 to 210.2 mm²; for the Duromedics valves the area range was 134.5–262.9 mm². Because of the larger orifice areas the values of discharge coefficient and performance index for the Duromedic valves were higher than those for the Björk-Shiley monostrut valves. As the insufficiency of the two mechanical valves was similar, and the orifice area of the bileaflet valves was greater than that of the tilting disc valves, Duromedics valves gave higher values for the efficiency index, which varied between 0.31 and 0.39; for Björk-Shiley monostrut valves the index varied between 0.24 and 0.28 under the same test conditions. This hydrodynamic in vitro comparison of mechanical heart valves showed that the Duromedics bileaflet valves were superior to the Björk-Shiley tilting disc valves.     

Time-resolved DPIV analysis of vortex dynamics in a left ventricular model through bileaflet mechanical and porcine heart valve prostheses

The performance of the heart after a mitral valve replacement operation greatly depends on the flow character downstream of the valve. The design and implanting orientation of valves may considerably affect the flow development. A study of the hemodynamics of two orientations, anatomical and anti-anatomical, of the St. Jude Medical (SJM) bileaflet valve are presented and compared with those of the SJM Biocor porcine valve, which served also to represent the natural valve. We document the velocity field in a flexible, transparent (LV) using time-resolved digital particle image velocimetry (TRDPIV). Vortex formation and vortex interaction are two important physical phenomena that dominate the filling and emptying of the ventricle. For the three configurations, the following effects were examined: mitral valve inlet jet asymmetry, survival of vortical structures upstream of the aortic valve, vortex-induced velocities and redirection of theflow in abidance of the Biot-Savart law, domain segmentation, resonant times of vortical structures, and regions of stagnantflow. The presence of three distinct flow patterns, for the three configurations, was identified by the location of vortical structures and level of coherence corresponding to a significant variation in the turbulence level distribution inside the LV. The adverse effect of these observations could potentially compromise the efficiency of the LV and result in flow patterns that deviate from those in the natural heart.     

Pulsatile flow past aortic valve bioprostheses in a model human aorta

Pulsatile flow development past tissue valve prostheses in a model human aorta has been studied using qualitative flow visualization and quantitative laser-Doppler techniques. Experiments were conducted both in steady and physiological pulsatile flow situations and the measurements included the pressure drop across the valve, the instantaneous flow rate as well as the velocity profiles and turbulent stresses downstream to the valves. Our study shows that the velocity profiles with pericardial valves are closer to those measured past natural aortic valves. The porcine valves with a smaller valve opening area produce a narrower and stronger jet downstream from the valve with relatively larger turbulent axial stresses in the boundary of the jet. Our study suggests that the pericardial valves with turbulent stresses comparable to those of caged ball and tilting disc valves are preferable from a hemodynamic point of view.     

In vitro study of flow regulation for pulmonary insufficiency

Given the tolerance of the right heart circulation to mild regurgitation and gradient, we study the potential of using motionless devices to regulate the pulmonary circulation. In addition, we document the flow performance of two mechanical valves. A motionless diode, a nozzle, a mechanical bileaflet valve, and a tilting disk valve were tested in a pulmonary mock circulatory system over the normal human range of pulmonary vascular resistance (PVR). For the mechanical valves, regurgitant fractions (RFs) and transvalvular pressure gradients were found to be weak functions of PVR. On the low end of normal PVR, the bileaflet and tilting disk valves fluttered and would not fully close. Despite this anomaly, the regurgitant fraction of either valve did not change significantly. The values for RF and transvalvular gradient measured varied from 4 to 7% and 4 to 7 mm Hg, respectively, at 5 lpm for all tests. The diode valve was able to regulate flow with mild regurgitant fraction and trivial gradient but with values higher than either mechanical valve tested. Regurgitant fraction ranged from 2 to 17% in tests extending from PVR values of 1 to 4.5 mm Hg/lpm at 5 lpm and with concomitant increases in gradient up to 17 mm Hg. The regurgitant fraction for the nozzle increased from 2 to 23% over the range of PVR with gradients increasing to 18 mm Hg. The significant findings were: (1) the mechanical valves controlled regurgitation at normal physiological cardiac output and PVR even though they failed to close at some normal values of PVR and showed leaflet flutter; and (2) it may be possible to regulate the pulmonary circulation to tolerable levels using a motionless pulmonary valve device.     

Numerical Modeling of Intraventricular Flow during Diastole after Implantation of BMHV

This work presents a numerical simulation of intraventricular flow after the implantation of a bileaflet mechanical heart valve at the mitral position. The left ventricle was simplified conceptually as a truncated prolate spheroid and its motion was prescribed based on that of a healthy subject. The rigid leaflet rotation was driven by the transmitral flow and hence the leaflet dynamics were solved using fluid-structure interaction approach. The simulation results showed that the bileaflet mechanical heart valve at the mitral position behaved similarly to that at the aortic position. Sudden area expansion near the aortic root initiated a clockwise anterior vortex, and the continuous injection of flow through the orifice resulted in further growth of the anterior vortex during diastole, which dominated the intraventricular flow. This flow feature is beneficial to preserving the flow momentum and redirecting the blood flow towards the aortic valve. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first attempt to numerically model intraventricular flow with the mechanical heart valve incorporated at the mitral position using a fluid-structure interaction approach. This study facilitates future patient-specific studies.     

Laser anemometry measurements of pulsatile flow past aortic valve prostheses

Experimental results are presented on physiological pulsatile flow past caged ball and tilting disc aortic valve prostheses mounted in an axisymmetric chamber incorporated in a mock circulatory system. The measurements of velocity profiles and turbulent normal stresses during several times in a cardiac cycle were obtained using laser-Doppler anemometry. Our results show that with increased angle of opening for the tilting disc valves, a large but locally confined vortex is observed along the wall in the minor flow region throughout most of the cardiac cycle. The turbulent normal stresses measured downstream to the tilting disc in the minor flow region parallel to the tilt axis were found to be larger than those measured downstream to the caged ball valves. Comparison of measurements with steady flow at flow rates comparable to peak pulsatile flow rate show that the turbulent normal stresses are larger by a factor of two in pulsatile flow with a frequency of 1.2 Hz.     

Experimental study of physiological pulsatile flow past valve prosthesis in a model of human aorta--II. Tilting disc valves and the effect of orientation

In Part II of this two paper sequence, pulsatile flow development past a tilting disc valve in a model human aorta has been studied using quantitative laser Doppler techniques. The valve was mounted in three different orientations with respect to the aortic root in this study. Under pulsatile flow, the region of flow reversal induced near the wall of the minor flow orifice extends to more than one tissue annulus diameter downstream from the valve into the ascending aorta. In a plane perpendicular to the tilt axis, a bi-helical secondary flow is induced distal to the valve. This secondary flow is further compounded by the multiple curvatures in the aorta. Hence the valve orientation affects the velocity profiles as far downstream as the mid-arch region as well as in the brachio-cephalic arterial branch. In the mid-arch region, a flow reversal along the entire cross-section is observed in early diastole for all the three orientations of the disc valve.     

Steady flow development past valve prostheses in a model human aorta—II. Tilting disc valves

The flow development in the model human aorta with uniform entry as well as with centrally occuluding valves mounted at the root of the aorta was described in Part I of this two-paper sequence. Part II deals with the flow development in the model aorta with tilting disc valves mounted at the root of the aorta. Bjork-Shiley and Hall-Kaster tilting disc valves were mounted in three different orientations with respect to the root of the aorta. The velocity profiles and turbulent stresses were measured with laser-Doppler anemometry. Our results under steady flow conditions in the model human aorta show quantitatively that the flow development in the ascending aorta as well as in the brachio-cephalic artery are strongly dependent on the orientation of the tilting disc valves. With the valves tilting towards the outer wall of curvature, our results suggest a tendency for flow separation at the flow divider region of the brachio-cephalic artery.     

New insights into the assessment of the prosthetic valve performance in the presence of subaortic stenosis through a fluid-structure interaction model

The aim of this study was to contribute to improving the accuracy of clinical assessments of valve performance in situations involving the concomitant presence of a prosthetic valve and subaortic stenosis (SAS). Physiological flow in a two-dimensional model for a bileaflet mechanical heart valve was investigated numerically in terms of the fluid-structure interactions. The fluid dynamics in a model with SAS of the left ventricle outflow tract were compared with those given by a healthy model. The results show that in the model with SAS, one leaflet did not close during the observed systolic phase, whereas the other one showed similar behaviour to that of the leaflet in the healthy model. In addition, the main flow did not occur along the central axis and a deviated jet was set up between leaflets, contrary to what occurred in the model without SAS. Current clinical diagnostic indices, which are mainly based on the central jet flow velocities, are therefore unsuitable for use in this pathological situation and should be used with great caution.     

Comparative study of the function of the Abiomed polyurethane heart valve for use in left ventricular assist devices

Hydrodynamic testing of the Abiomed polyurethane trileaflet valve has been carried out to establish performance data of valve function. A Medtronic Hall tilting disk, a Carbomedics bileaflet, a Hancock II bioprosthesis and an Abiomed polyurethane trileaflet valve, all size 27 mm, underwent both pulsatile and steady-flow hydrodynamic testing. Results of the variation of pressure difference with RMS pulsatile flow and steady flow, and effective orifice area, showed that the Abiomed valve had significantly poorer opening characteristics than the tissue valve and the two mechanicalvalves. The Abiomed valve's performance was seen to be related to its construction and manufacture. This study highlights some of the problems associated with the design and development of synthetic trileaflet heart valve prostheses.     

Hemodynamic Changes following Aortic Valve Bypass: A Mathematical Approach

Aortic valve bypass (AVB) has been shown to be a viable solution for patients with severe aortic stenosis (AS). Under this circumstance, the left ventricle (LV) has a double outlet. The objective was to develop a mathematical model capable of evaluating the hemodynamic performance following the AVB surgery. A mathematical model that captures the interaction between LV, AS, arterial system, and AVB was developed. This model uses a limited number of parameters that all can be non-invasively measured using patient data. The model was validated using in vivo data from the literature. The model was used to determine the effect of different AVB and AS configurations on flow proportion and pressure of the aortic valve and the AVB. Results showed that the AVB leads to a significant reduction in transvalvular pressure gradient. The percentage of flow through the AVB can range from 55.47% to 69.43% following AVB with a severe AS. LV stroke work was also significantly reduced following the AVB surgery and reached a value of around 1.2 J for several AS severities. Findings of this study suggest: 1) the AVB leads to a significant reduction in transvalvular pressure gradients; 2) flow distribution between the AS and the AVB is significantly affected by the conduit valve size; 3) the AVB leads to a significant reduction in LV stroke work; and 4) hemodynamic performance variations can be estimated using the model.     

Vortex shedding as a mechanism for free emboli formation in mechanical heart valves

The high incidence of thromboembolic complications of mechanical heart valves (MHV) limits their success as permanent implants. The thrombogenicity of all MHV is primarily due to platelet activation by contact with foreign surfaces and by nonphysiological flow patterns. The latter include elevated flow stresses and regions of recirculation of blood that are induced by valve design characteristics. A numerical simulation of unsteady turbulent flow through a bileaflet MHV was conducted, using the Wilcox k-omega turbulence model for internal low-Reynolds-number flows, and compared to quantitative flow visualization performed in a pulse duplicator system using Digital Particle Image Velocimetry (DPIV). The wake of the valve leaflet during the deceleration phase revealed an intricate pattern of interacting shed vortices. Particle paths showed that platelets that were exposed to the highest flow stresses around the leaflets were entrapped within the shed vortices. Potentially activated, such platelets may tend to aggregate and form free emboli. Once formed, such free emboli would be convected downstream by the shed vortices, increasing the risk of systemic emboli.     

Patient-specific MRI-based 3D FSI RV/LV/patch models for pulmonary valve replacement surgery and patch optimization

A patient-specific right/left ventricle and patch (RV/LV/patch) combination model with fluid-structure interactions (FSIs) was introduced to evaluate and optimize human pulmonary valve replacement/insertion (PVR) surgical procedure and patch design. Cardiac magnetic resonance (CMR) imaging studies were performed to acquire ventricle geometry, flow velocity, and flow rate for healthy volunteers and patients needing RV remodeling and PVR before and after scheduled surgeries. CMR-based RV/LV/patch FSI models were constructed to perform mechanical analysis and assess RV cardiac functions. Both pre- and postoperation CMR data were used to adjust and validate the model so that predicted RV volumes reached good agreement with CMR measurements (error <3%). Two RV/LV/patch models were made based on preoperation data to evaluate and compare two PVR surgical procedures: (i) conventional patch with little or no scar tissue trimming, and (ii) small patch with aggressive scar trimming and RV volume reduction. Our modeling results indicated that (a) patient-specific CMR-based computational modeling can provide accurate assessment of RV cardiac functions, and (b) PVR with a smaller patch and more aggressive scar removal led to reduced stress/strain conditions in the patch area and may lead to improved recovery of RV functions. More patient studies are needed to validate our findings.     

The 12 cc Penn State pulsatile pediatric ventricular assist device: fluid dynamics associated with valve selection

The mortality rate for infants awaiting a heart transplant is 40% because of the extremely limited number of donor organs. Ventricular assist devices (VADs), a common bridge-to-transplant solution in adults, are becoming a viable option for pediatric patients. A major obstacle faced by VAD designers is thromboembolism. Previous studies have shown that the interrelated flow characteristics necessary for the prevention of thrombosis in a pulsatile VAD are a strong inlet jet, a late diastolic recirculating flow, and a wall shear rate greater than 500 s(-1). Particle image velocimetry was used to compare the flow fields in the chamber of the 12 cc Penn State pediatric pulsatile VAD using two mechanical heart valves: Bjork-Shiley monostrut (BSM) tilting disk valves and CarboMedics (CM) bileaflet valves. In conjunction with the flow evaluation, wall shear data were calculated and analyzed to help quantify wall washing. The major orifice inlet jet of the device containing BSM valves was more intense, which led to better recirculation and wall washing than the three jets produced by the CM valves. Regurgitation through the CM valve served as a significant hindrance to the development of the rotational flow.     

Comparative study of the amount of backflow produced by four types of aortic valve prostheses

To determine the extent of backflow encountered with currently used prosthetic valves, four types of aortic valves with comparable orifice diameters were tested in a pulse duplicating system. These were a Hancock porcine valve, a Lillehei-Kaster pivoting disk valve, a St. Jude bileaflet valve and a Bj?rk-Shiley tilting disk valve. Mean aortic pressure was sequentially increased from 83 to 147 mmHg, keeping the pump rate essentially constant (69-73 strokes/min). The porcine valve produced the least amount of total backflow (backflow due to closure plus leakage backflow) (1.6 to 2.4 mL/stroke). Among the mechanical valves the Bj?rk-Shiley valve showed the least amount of total backflow (5.0 to 6.0 mL/stroke). At a mean aortic pressure of 100 mmHg and a low cardiac output of 2 L/min, the total backflow with the porcine valve was only 6 percent of forward flow; whereas it was 19 percent with the Lillehei-Kaster valve, 22 percent with the St. Jude valve and 18 percent with the Bj?rk-Shiley valve. Leakage backflow at a given level of mean aortic pressure was, as expected, directly related to the annular clearance area. It is concluded that the Hancock valve showed the least amount of backward flow, which would be particularly beneficial in low output states. In the presence of normal hemodynamics, the amount of backflow with the three mechanical valves appeared to be well below the level of backflow considered to be clinically significant.     

Comparative in vitro study of bileaflet and tilting disk valve behavior in the pulmonary position

A study of mechanical heart valve behavior in the pulmonary position as a function of pulmonary vascular resistance is reported for the St. Jude Medical bileaflet (SJMB) valve and the MedicalCV Omnicarbon (OTD) tilting disk valve. Tests were conducted in a pulmonic mock circulatory system and impedance was varied in terms of system pulmonary vascular resistance (PVR). An impedance spectrum was found using instantaneous pulmonary artery pressure and flow rate curves. Both valves fully opened and closed at and above a nominal PVR of 3.0 mmHg/L/min. The SJMB valve was prone to leaflet bounce at closure, but otherwise completely closed, at settings above and below this nominal setting. At PVR values at and below 2.0 mmHg/L/min, the SJMB valve exhibited two types of leaflet aberrant behavior: single leaflet only closure while the other leaflet fluttered, and incomplete closure where both leaflets flutter but neither remain fully closed. The OTD valve fully opened and closed to a PVR value of 1.6 mmHg/L/min. At lower values, the valve did not close. Valves designed for the left heart can show aberrant behavior under normal conditions as pulmonary valves.