Freeze-fracture studies of frog neuromuscular junctions during intense release of neurotransmitter. I. Effects of black widow spider venom and Ca2+-free solutions on the structure of the active zone

Black widow spider venom (BWSV) was applied to frog nerve-muscle preparations bathed in Ca2+-containing, or Ca2+-free, solutions and the neuromuscular junctions were studied by the freeze-fracture technique. When BWSV was applied for short periods (10-15 min) in the presence of Ca2+, numerous dimples (P face) or protuberances (E face) appeared on the presynaptive membrane and approximately 86% were located immediately adjacent to the double rows of large intramembrane particles that line the active zones. When BWSV was applied for 1 h in the presence of Ca2+, the nerve terminals were depleted of vesicles, few dimples or protuberances were seen, and the active zones were almost completely disorganized. The P face of the presynaptic membrane still contained large intramembrane particles. When muscles were soaked for 2-3 h in Ca2+-free solutions, the active zones became disorganized, and isolated remnants of the double rows of particles were found scattered over the P face of the presynaptic membrane. When BWSV was applied to these preparations, dimples or protuberances occurred almost exclusively alongside disorganized active zones or alongside dispersed fragments of the active zones. The loss of synaptic vesicles from terminals treated with BWSV probably occurs because BWSV interferes with the endocytosis of vesicle membrane. Therefore, we assume that the dimples or protuberances seen on these terminals identify the sites of exocytosis, and we conclude that exocytosis can occur mostly in the immediate vicinity of the large intramembrane particles. Extracellular Ca2+ seems to be required to maintain the grouping of the large particles into double rows at the active zones, but is not required for these particles to specify the sites of exocytosis.     

Analysis of outer membrane ultrastructure of pathogenic Treponema and Borrelia species by freeze-fracture electron microscopy.

We analyzed the outer membrane (OM) ultrastructure of four pathogenic members of the family Spirochaetaceae by freeze fracture. The OM of Treponema pallidum subsp. pertenue contained a low intramembranous particle concentration, indicating that it contains few OM transmembrane proteins. The concave OM fracture faces of Treponema hyodysenteriae and Borrelia burgdorferi contained dense populations of particles, typical of gram-negative organisms. A relatively low concentration of particles which were evenly divided between a small and a large species was present in the concave OM fracture face of Borrelia hermsii; the convex OM fracture face contained only small particles. As for gram-negative bacteria, the convex OM fracture face particle concentrations of these pathogens were low. These spirochetes cleaved preferentially within the OM, in contrast to typical gram-negative bacteria, which tend to fracture within the inner membrane. The OM ultrastructure of T. pallidum subsp. pertenue provides an explanation for the lack of antigenicity of the treponemal surface and may reflect a mechanism by which this pathogen evades the host immune response.     

A chloroplast membrane lacking Photosystem II. Thylakoid stacking in the absence of the Photosystem II particle

The polypeptide composition and membrane structure of a variegated mutant of tobacco have been investigated. The pale green mutant leaf regions contain chloroplasts in which the amount of membrane stacking has been reduced (although not totally eliminated). The mutant membranes are almost totally deficient in Photosystem II when compared to wild-type chloroplast membranes, but still show near-normal levels of Photosystem I activity. The pattern of membrane polypeptides separated by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis shows several differences between mutant and wild-type membranes, although the major chlorophyll-protein complexes described in many other plant species are present in both mutant and wild-type samples. Freeze-fracture analysis of the internal structure of these photosynthetic membranes shows that the Photosystem II-deficient membranes lack the characteristic large particle associated with the E fracture face of the thylakoid. These membranes also lack a tetramer-like particle visible on the inner (ES) surface of the membrane. The other characteristics of the photosynthetic membrane, including the small particles observed on the P fracture faces in both stacked and unstacked regions, and the characteristic changes in the background matrix of the E fracture face which accompany thylakoid stacking, are unaltered in the mutant. From these and other observations we conclude that the large (EF and ES) particle represents an amalgam of many components comprising the Photosystem II reaction complex, that the absence of one or more of its components may prevent the structure from assembling, and that in its absence, Photosystem II activity cannot be observed.     

A chloroplast membrane lacking photosystem II. Thylakoid stacking in the absence of the photosystem II particle.

The polypeptide composition and membrane structure of a variegated mutant of tobacco have been investigated. The pale green mutant leaf regions contain chloroplasts in which the amount of membrane stacking has been reduced (although not totally eliminated). The mutant membranes are almost totally deficient in Photosystem II when compared to wild-type chloroplast membranes, but still show near-normal levels of Photosystem I activity. The pattern of membrane polypeptides separated by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis shows several differences between mutant and wild-type membranes, although the major chlorophyll-protein complexes described in many other plant species are present in both mutant and wild-type samples. Freeze-fracture analysis of the internal structure of these photosynthetic membranes shows that the Photosystem II-deficient membranes lack the characteristic large particle associated with the E fracture face of the thylakoid. These membranes also lack a tetramer-like particle visible on the inner (ES) surface of the membrane. The other characteristics of the photosynthetic membrane, including the small particles observed on the P fracture faces in both stacked and unstacked regions, and the characteristic changes in the background matrix of the E fracture face which accompany thylakoid stacking, are unaltered in the mutant. From these and other observations we conclude that the large (EF and ES) particle represents an amalgam of many components comprising the Photosystem II reaction complex, that the absence of one or more of its components may prevent the structure from assembling, and that in its absence, Photosystem II activity cannot be observed.     

Structural and cytochemical differentiation of membrane elements of the apical membrane of amphibian urinary bladder epithelial cells. A label fracture study

It is now generally accepted that ADH-induced increase in water permeability in responsive epithelia is associated with the insertion of specific structures in the apical membrane of epithelial cells. Up to now, these structures have only been recognized in freeze-fractured preparations and their chemical nature is still unknown. In this study, we used the label-fracture method (Pinto da Silva and Kan, J. Cell Biol., 99, 1156-1161, 1984) to investigate the distribution of wheat germ agglutinin (WGA) on the luminal plasma membrane of freeze-fractured frog urinary bladder epithelial cells. With label-fracture, the cytochemical markers are seen superimposed with the conventional high resolution image of the E face. Label-fracture of tissue treated for 15 min with WGA and subsequently labeled with colloidal gold coated with ovomucoid showed uniform distribution of gold particles along the exoplasmic fracture face. Stereomicrographs show that the gold label is under the fracture face as it is attached to the outer surface of the membrane. Preincubation of the bladder with WGA for 3 hr induced a segregation of the intramembranous particles of the apical plasma membrane. In this condition, we observed a co-distribution of WGA-gold complexes with the segregated particles on the E face. This indicates that WGA-binding sites are located on glycoproteins which probably comprise the large intramembranous particles dispersed on the exoplasmic faces of freeze-fractured luminal membranes. In contrast, the numerous small intramembrane particles observed on P faces remained evenly distributed even after exposure to WGA and are, therefore, unrelated to WGA receptor sites. After WGA treatment, ADH still induced the formation of aggregates inside the smooth domains. A few WGA-binding sites appeared to be associated to these aggregates.     

Freeze-fracture studies of the plasmalemma of Candida albicans after treatment with econazole-nitrate.

In electron microscopic studies the interior of the plasmalemma of Candida albicans was revealed by means of the freeze-fracture technique. The superficial structures of the extracellular (E) and protoplasmic (P) fracture faces differed negligibly from structures on the corresponding fracture faces of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Following treatment with 2.2 x 10(-5) M econazole nitrate a layer, present on the P face in the form of a tight matrix of globular proteins, dissolved into isolated groups of particles whose globular elements sometimes formed hexagonal patterns. As the damage progressed, fissure-shaped membrane invaginations on the P face disappeared. Parts of the outer lipid layer of the plasmalemma were torn off the cell wall and adhered in fragments to the P face. The ultrastructural changes in the plasmalemma induced by econazole nitrate temporally correlate with an increase in the permeability of the cell envelope found in physiological studies performed by other authors.     

THE INTRAMEMBRANOUS PARTICLE PROFILE OF THE PARAMYLON MEMBRANE DURING PARAMYLON SYNTHESIS IN EUGLENA (EUGLENOPHYCEAE)1

Paramylon is the β-1, 3-glucan storage product in euglenoid algae. It is a fibrous crystal that occurs as membrane-bound granules in the cytosol. The role of the surrounding membrane in paramylon synthesis was investigated by the use of freeze-etch electron microscopy. When Euglena gracilis Klebs strain Z (Pringsheim) cells were frozen in supercooled liquid nitrogen, the fracture plane primarily was throuh the paramylon membrane. A large intramembranous particle (IMP, mean diam range 5.6-6.5 nm) and a small IMP (mean diam range 9.6-10.3 nm) were predominant in both PF (protoplasmic fracture) and EF (exoplasmic fracture) faces of the paramylon membrane. During paramylon synthesis induction, the ratio of small to large IMPs increased in both fracture faces. The IMP density decreased in both fracture faces concomitant to paramylon synthesis increase. These changes in IMP profile and density suggest that the paramylon membrane is involved in the synthesis of paramylon.     

Localization of substance P and leucine enkephalin in the nerve terminals of the guinea pig paracervical ganglion

Summary Immunoreactivities (IR) of substance P and leucine enkephalin have been demonstrated in the guinea-pig paracervical ganglion by an immunogold electron microscope method. Both substance P-IR and leucine enkephalin-IR were detected in large synaptic vesicles with electron-dense cores. The former neuropeptide was detected in nerve terminals and varicosities comprised mainly of large vesicles with electron-dense cores; the latter was detected in nerve terminals and varicosities that also included small, clear synaptic vesicles. In a minority of nerve terminals and varicosities coexistence of both immunoreactivities could be demonstrated within vesicles with an electron-dense core. Also present in these nerve terminals and varicosities were small, clear synaptic vesicles, though these were unreactive.     

Freeze-Fracture Study of the Bloodstream Form of Trypanosoma brucei gambiense

The ultrastructure of Trypanosoma brucei gambiense was investigated by the freeze-fracture method. Three different regions of the continuous plasma membrane; cell body proper, flagellar pocket, and flagellum were compared in density and distribution of the intramembranous particles (IMP's). The IMP-density was highest in the flagellar pocket membrane and lowest in flagellum. Intra membranous particles of the cell body membrane were distributed uniformly on both the protoplasmic (P) and exoplasmic (E) faces. On the P face of the flagellar membrane, a single row of IMP-clusters was seen along the juncture of the flagllum to the cell body. Since the spacing of the IMP-clusters was almost equal to the spacing of the paired rivet structures observed in thin section, these clusters likely are related to the junction of flagellum and cell body. At the neck of the flagellar pocket, several linear arrays of IMP's were found on the P face of the flagellar membrane, while on the E face rows of depressions were seen. At the flagellar base, the clusters of IMP's were only seen on the P face. On the flagellar pocket membrane, particle-rich depressions and linear particle arrays were also found on the P face, while on the E face such special particle arrangements were not recognized. These particle-rich depressions may correspond to the sites of pinocytosis of the bloodstream forms which have been demonstrated in thin sections.     

Reduction of intramembranous particles in the periacrosomal plasma membrane of boar spermatozoa during in vitro capacitation: a statistical study

Membrane remodeling in the periacrosomal plasma membrane (PAPM) of boar spermatozoa during incubation in capacitation medium was examined by the freeze-fracture technique. In the preservation medium (PM) group, the major small (about 8 nm) intramembranous particles (IMP) and the minor large (> 10 nm) IMP were distributed evenly in the PAPM. The IMP-free area increased during capacitation. To correct the IMP-free area, arithmetically redistributed (ARD)-IMP density was used for statistical analysis. In the PM group, the mean density +/- SD of large IMP was 379 +/- 64 and 266 +/- 58/microm2, and that of small IMP was 1450 +/- 155 and 672 +/- 252/microm2 in protoplasmic (P) and external (E) faces, respectively. During capacitation, the significant (P < 0.01) reduction of large IMP density was encountered only in the E face of a few incubation groups, while that of the small IMP density occurred in the P face by 2 h. Consequently, reduction of the total IMP density of both faces was not significant in the large IMP, but it was significant (P < 0.01) in the small IMP. One-fifth of the total small IMP density reduced by 2 h. Filipin-sterol complexes (FSC) were numerous in the PAPM, and FSC-free areas also increased during capacitation. The mechanism of IMP-free area formation and the behavior of the small IMP in the PAPM during capacitation were discussed in relation to membrane stability.     

Synaptic regulation of paraventricular arginine vasopressin-containing neurons by neuropeptide Y-containing monoaminergic neurons in rats

Summary Synaptic regulation of arginine vasopressin (AVP)-containing neurons by neuropeptide Y (NPY)-containing monoaminergic neurons was demonstrated in the paraventricular nucleus of the rat hypothalamus. NPY and AVP were immunolabeled in the pre- and the post-embedding procedures, respectively, and monoaminergic fibers were marked by incorporating 5-hydroxydopamine (5-OHDA), a false neurotransmitter. The immunoreaction for NPY was expressed by diaminobenzidine (DAB) chromogen, and that for AVP by gold particles. The DAB chromogen was localized on the surface of the membrane structures, such as vesicles or mitochondria, and on the core of large cored vesicles. Gold particles were located on the core of the secretory granules within the AVP cell bodies and processes. The incorporated 5-OHDA was found as dense cores within small or large vesicular structures. From these data, three types of nerve terminals were discernible: NPY-containing monoaminergic, NPY-containing non-aminergic, and monoaminergic fibers. The AVP cell bodies appeared to have synaptic junctions formed by these nerve terminals as well as by the unlabeled nerve terminals which have small clear vesicles and large cored vesicles. These different types of nerve terminals were frequently observed in a closely apposed position on the same AVP cell bodies. The functional relationships of these three types of neuronal terminals are discussed.     

The eyespot of the flagellateTetraselmis cordiformis stein (Chlorophyceae): Structural spezialization of the outer chloroplast membrane and its possible significance in phototaxis of green algae

Summary The eyespot region of the flagellateTetraselmis cordiformis Stein (Chlorophyceae) was investigated with the freeze-fracture technique. The only fracture faces observed in this region were the two complementary fracture faces (PF and EF) of the outer chloroplast envelope membrane. Intramembranous particle numbers on both fracture faces of this membrane were significantly higher in the eyespot region as compared to regions outside the eye-spot. Higher numbers of particles on the PF face in the eyespot region were mainly caused by an increase in particle numbers of the size class 6–8 mm, while on the EF face particle size distribution was not significantly different between eyespot and other regions. Functional implications are discussed and evidence is presented that the outer chloroplast envelope membrane may be the site of photoreceptor location in green algal phototaxis.     

Freeze-Fracture Study of the Endosymbiont of Blastocrithidia culicis1

The two unit membranes which envelope the endosymbiont of the trypanosomatid protozoon, Blastocrithidia culicis, were studied using the freeze-fracture technique. The distribution of the intramembranous particles on both fracture faces of the inner and outer membrane of the endosymbiont was analyzed in the replicas. The protoplasmic face of the inner membrane (PFi) had a higher density of membrane particles than that observed on the extracellular face (EFi), a pattern typical of plasma membranes. The extracellular face of the outer membrane (EFo) presented a density of membrane particles much higher than that observed on the P face of the outer membrane (PFo) a distribution significantly different from that found in the inner membrane of the endosymbiont and in the plasma membrane of the protozoon, but similar to that observed in Gram-negative bacteria. The data obtained support the idea that the endosymbiont of trypanosomatids represents a Gram-negative bacterium-like microorganism enveloped by two unit membranes and lacking a peptidoglycan layer and which lives in direct contact with the cytoplasm of the protozoon.     

Neurochemical pattern of the complex innervation of neuroepithelial bodies in mouse lungs

As best characterized for rats, it is clear that pulmonary neuroepithelial bodies (NEBs) are contacted by a plethora of nerve fiber populations, suggesting that they represent an extensive group of multifunctional intraepithelial airway receptors. Because of the importance of genetically modified mice for functional studies, and the current lack of data, the main aim of the present study was to achieve a detailed analysis of the origin and neurochemical properties of nerve terminals associated with NEBs in mouse lungs. Antibodies against known selective markers for sensory and motor nerve terminals in rat lungs were used on lungs from control and vagotomized mice of two different strains, i.e., Swiss and C57-Bl6. NEB cells were visualized by antibodies against either the general neuroendocrine marker protein gene-product 9.5 (PGP9.5) or calcitonin gene-related peptide (CGRP). Thorough immunohistochemical examination of NEB cells showed that some of these NEB cells also exhibit calbindin D-28 k (CB) and vesicular acetylcholine transporter (VAChT) immunoreactivity (IR). Mouse pulmonary NEBs were found to receive intraepithelial nerve terminals of at least two different populations of myelinated vagal afferents: (1) Immunoreactive (ir) for vesicular glutamate transporters (VGLUTs) and CB; (2) expressing P2X₂ and P2X₃ ATP receptors. CGRP IR was seen in varicose vagal nerve fibers and in delicate non-vagal fibers, both in close proximity to NEBs. VAChT immunostaining showed very weak IR in the NEB-related intraepithelial vagal sensory nerve terminals. nNOS- or VIP-ir nerve terminals could be observed at the base of pulmonary NEBs. While a single NEB can be contacted by multiple nerve fiber populations, it was clear that none of the so far characterized nerve fiber populations contacts all pulmonary NEBs. The present study revealed that mouse lungs harbor several populations of nerve terminals that may selectively contact NEBs. Although at present the physiological significance of the innervation pattern of NEBs remains enigmatic, it is likely that NEBs are receptor–effector end-organs that may host complex and/or multiple functional properties in normal airways. The neurochemical information on the innervation of NEBs in mouse lungs gathered in the present study will be essential for the interpretation of upcoming functional data and for the study of transgenic mice.     

Distribution of Intramembrane Particles and Its Changes during the Acrosome Reaction in Spermatozoa of the Japanese Abalone

The distribution of intramembrane particles in the plasma and acrosomal membranes of sperm of the Japanese abalone, Haliotis discus , and its changes during the acrosome reaction were studied by the freeze-fracture replica technique. The P face of the plasma membrane covering the acrosome has sparse membrane particles except in the apical region, which includes the trigger and 'truncated cone' regions. Large particles with an average diameter of 10 nm are located in this apical region. The E face of the plasma membrane has only a few particles. On the outer acrosomal membrane, many particles are randomly distributed throughout the P face, but only a small number of particles are found on the E face. Numerous particles on the P face of the inner acrosomal membrane show a regular arrangement as a dense lattice or with a concentric circular pattern. The initial change in the acrosome reaction is clearance of membrane particles from both the P and E faces of the plasma and outer acrosomal membranes around the apical region, where fusion of the two membranes occurs. As the acrosomal process elongates, the dense arrangement of particles on the inner acrosomal membrane changes via a loose lattice arrangement to a patchy distribution with particle-free areas. Then the arrangement is further disorganized becoming a sparse, random distribution.     

Ultrastructure of the Bacteroides nodosus cell envelope layers and surface.

The surface structure and cell envelope layers of various virulent Bacteroides nodosus strains were examined by light microscopy and by electron microscopy by using negative staining, thin-section, and freeze-fracture-etch techniques. Three surface structures were described: pili and a diffuse material, both of which emerged from one or both poles of the bacteria (depending on the stage of growth and division), and large rodlike structures (usually 30 to 40 nm in diameter) associated with a small proportion of the bacterial population. No capsule was detected. The cell envelope consisted of four layers: a plasma membrane, a peptidoglycan layer, an outer membrane, and an outermost additional layer. The additional layer was composed of subunits, generally hexagonally packed with center-to-center spacing of 6 to 7 nm. The outer membrane and plasma membrane freeze-fractured through their hydrophobic regions revealing four fracture faces with features similar to those of other gram-negative bacteria. However, some unusual features were seen on the fracture faces of the outer membrane: large raised ring structure (11 to 12 nm in diameter) on cw 3 at the poles of the bacteria; complementary pits or ring-shaped depressions on cw 2; and small raised ring structures (7 to 8 nm in diameter) all over cw 2.     

Freeze-fracture study of the trophozoite and the cyst of Entamoeba histolytica

The fine structure of the trophozoite and cyst of Entamoeba histolytica from the stool of a patient was compared using the freeze-fracture method. The intramembranous particles (IMP's) were heterogeneously distributed on the plasma membrane of the trophozoite and their density was 1139 +/- 105/micron 2 on the P face. Particle-rich depressions and linear particle arrays, reported by other investigators on cultured trophozoites, were also observed on the P face while on the E face such special particle arrangement was not recognized. Particle-free, small protrusions were frequently observed on the P face of the trophozoite membrane. The existence of these protrusions is a new finding. In the cyst, the IMP's were also distributed heterogeneously on both the P and E faces of the plasma membrane. The density of the IMP's, however, was much lower than in the trophozoite: 6 +/- 2/micron 2 on the P face and averaging less than 1/micron 2 on the E face. In freeze-fracture images, the plasma membrane of the cyst showed a variety of configurations from smooth to uneven or ridged surfaces. These morphological alterations of the plasma membrane may be attributed to the aging of the cyst. The thick wall of the cyst had a filamentous tri- or tetra-lamellar structure. The cytoplasm of the cyst was similar in structure to that of the trophozoite and the diameter of the nuclear pores was equal in both trophozoites and cysts.     

Freeze-fracture study of rat liver peroxisomes: evidence for an induction of intramembrane particles by agents stimulating peroxisomal proliferation

The membrane ultrastructure of isolated rat liver peroxisomes has been observed by rapid freezing and freeze-fracture techniques. Unidirectional and rotary shadowing allows a clear visualization of the intramembrane particles (IMPs) on both the protoplasmic fracture (PF) leaflet and the endoplasmic fracture (EF) leaflet and reveals an asymmetric distribution of IMPs. Both fracture faces were uniformly studded by IMPs, and the frequency was about seven times higher on the P face (2322 per 1.0 micron2) than on the E face (322 per 1.0 micron2). Administration of the peroxisomal proliferator clofibrate (ethyl-p-chlorophenoxyisobutyrate) induced a marked increase in the frequency of IMPs on both the P face (2.2-fold) and the E face (1.7-fold). The average size decreased (P less than 0.001) from 45.7 +/- 16.5 nm2 to 35.2 +/- 10.8 nm2 on the P face. A similar increase in the frequency of IMPs was observed on the P face (1.8-fold) and the E face (1.8-fold) of peroxisomes from rats fed a semisynthetic diet containing 20% (w/w) of partially hydrogenated fish oil. The average size increased (P less than 0.001) from 36.6 +/- 19.7 to 50.0 +/- 23.5 nm2 on the E face. This study demonstrates alterations both in frequency and size distribution of IMPs in liver peroxisomal membranes on exposure of rats to agents known to induce peroxisomal proliferation. The increase in frequency of IMPs was as expected from the observed increase in one of the major integral membrane polypeptides, with apparent molecular mass of 69 (or 70) kDa, in proliferating rat liver peroxisomes.     

A COMPLEMENTARY FREEZE-FRACTURE STUDY OF CHRYSOCHROMULINA CHITON (HAPTOPHYCEAE)

Complementary freeze-fracture replicas and high resolution tantalum-tungsten shadowing have been used in a study of the membanes of the marine alga Chrysochromulina chiton. Membrane particle populations range from 38/100 nm² in the plastid to 2/100 nm² in the pyrenoid cap membrane. Membrane asymmetry was evident in all membranes, but was most obvious in those with higher particle numbers. In all complementary replica pairs, particles were always more numerous on protoplasmic fracture faces. Small, particle-free areas with bordering particles were also seen as recurring membrane features. Complementarity of matching fracture faces was seen for very small background granularity patterns and for large membrane components, but not for particles. Complementarity can also be seen in non-membranous fracture faces both within and external to the cell, suggesting the presence of polymeric materials in these areas that produce “particles” due to plastic deformation.     

Decoration of specific sites on freeze-fractured membranes

Fracturing under ultrahigh vacuum (UHV, P less than or equal to 10(-9) Torr) produces membrane fracture faces devoid of contamination. Such clean surfaces are a prerequisite for studies of interactions between condensing gases and distinct regions of a surface. For the study of water condensation, a device has been developed which enables production of pure water vapor and controlled variation of its partial pressure in an UHV freeze-fracture apparatus. Experiments with yeast plasmalemma fracture faces, produced at -196 degrees C and exposed to pure water vapor before replication, resulted in a "specific decoration" with ice crystals of those pits in the extraplasmic face where the corresponding particles of the plasmic face had been removed. Because water condenses as discrete ice crystals which resemble intramembrane particles, ice crystals might easily be misinterpreted as actual membrane structures. At low specimen temperature (T less than or equal to 110 degrees C) the structural features of membrane fracture faces produced under high vacuum (P approximately 10(-6) Torr) should, therefore, be interpreted with caution.