Ectonucleoside triphosphate diphosphohydrolases and ecto-5′-nucleotidase in purinergic signaling: how the field developed and where we are now

Geoffrey Burnstock will be remembered as the scientist who set up an entirely new field of intercellular communication, signaling via nucleotides. The signaling cascades involved in purinergic signaling include intracellular storage of nucleotides, nucleotide release, extracellular hydrolysis, and the effect of the released compounds or their hydrolysis products on target tissues via specific receptor systems. In this context ectonucleotidases play several roles. They inactivate released and physiologically active nucleotides, produce physiologically active hydrolysis products, and facilitate nucleoside recycling. This review briefly highlights the development of our knowledge of two types of enzymes involved in extracellular nucleotide hydrolysis and thus purinergic signaling, the ectonucleoside triphosphate diphosphohydrolases, and ecto-5′-nucleotidase.

     

The history of the Purine Club: a tribute to Prof. Geoffrey Burnstock

The international purinergic scientific community has lost its pioneer. Geoffrey Burnstock, born on the 10th of May 1929 in London, died on the 2nd of June 2020, aged 91, in Melbourne (Australia). Geoff was one of the most highly regarded scientists of his generation. In the 1960s and 1970s, he developed a radical and somehow heretical new theory and opened an entire new field of science, signalling via extracellular nucleotides (the “purinergic theory”), which revolutionized our understanding of how cells communicate between each other. Initially, his unconventional theory found a lot of resistance in the scientific community. Once, one scientist even threatened to devote his entire life to disproving Burnstock’s theory. Undeterred, Geoff went further on, and continued to accumulate evidence in favour of his hypothesis, and led the field ever since. He struggled to attract new scientists to this new field of research and, in the early 1990s, due to new molecular biology techniques making it possible to isolate and identify cell surface receptors for ATP and its breakdown product adenosine, did evidence emerge that eventually convinced the doubters. The number of spontaneous obituaries and messages honouring Geoff’s memory that have appeared on specialized Journals and in the public press throughout the world since last June indicates that many people are clearly affected by his death. Besides being a rigorous, ethical and extremely brilliant scientist, Geoff was an extraordinary human being, always eager to collaborate and share data, never jealous of his findings and capable of learning things even from young people. He was known for his enthusiasm, empathy and ability to motivate young scientists and promote their careers. After the establishment of the Purine Club back in the 1990s, numerous Purine Club Chapters have been formed around the world with Geoff’s help and encouragement. He has obviously also been the inspirator and founder of our Journal, Purinergic Signalling (PUSI). For this reason, Charles Kennedy, the current Editor of the Journal, and myself thought that it might be nice to invite representatives from all known Purine Clubs to send a few notes to be published in PUSI on the history of their club and how Geoff inspired, aided or supported them. Here, I have collected all their contributions and I share with the entire purinergic community my personal memories on how the Purine Club was born and developed thanks to the invaluable mentoring of Geoffrey Burnstock. I apologize in advance if I am missing some information or forgot to mention somebody, and I strongly encourage all readers to submit memories and additional information that I shall gather for future writing. Keeping alive the history of how the field developed will be the best tribute that we can play to celebrate Geoff’s work along the years.

     

The impact of commercially available purinergic ligands on purinergic signalling research

Due to the extremely wide-spread expression of purinergic receptors, purinergic signalling has been implicated in numerous physiological and pathophysiological areas. To better understand the involvement of purinergic receptors in such areas, the researcher’s requirement for diverse and varied purinergic receptor ligands has greatly increased. This has generated increased commercial opportunities for life science suppliers, and ultimately, has led to a rapid expansion in the number of commercially available purinergic receptor ligands. The wide-spread availability of ligands to researchers has greatly benefited the scientific community, nurturing the rapid and continued expansion of the purinergic signalling field.

     

Burnstock and the legacy of the inhibitory junction potential and P2Y1 receptors

The synaptic event called the inhibitory junction potential (IJP) was arguably one of the more important discoveries made by Burnstock and arguably one of his finer legacies. The discovery of the IJP fundamentally changed how electromechanical coupling was visualised in gastrointestinal smooth muscle. Its discovery also set in motion the search for novel inhibitory neurotransmitters in the enteric nervous system, eventually leading to proposal that ATP or a related nucleotide was a major inhibitory transmitter. The subsequent development of purinergic signalling gave impetus to expanding the classification of surface receptors for extracellular ATP, not only in the GI tract but beyond, and then led to successive phases of medicinal chemistry as the P2 receptor field developed. Ultimately, the discovery of the IJP led to the successful cloning of the first P2Y receptor (chick P2Y1) and expansion of mammalian ATP receptors into two classes: metabotropic P2Y receptors (encompassing P2Y1, P2Y2, P2Y4, P2Y6, P2Y11–14 receptors) and ionotropic P2X receptors (encompassing homomeric P2X1–P2X7 receptors). Here, the causal relationship between the IJP and P2Y1 is explored, setting out the milestones reached and achievements made by Burnstock and his colleagues.

     

Development of a comprehensive set of P2 receptor pharmacological research compounds

Pharmacological manipulation of P2X and P2Y receptors has been critical to the elucidation of the biological roles of these receptors within a multitude of physiological and pathological processes. Initial purinergic signalling research made use of compounds based on pyridoxal phosphate, suramin and nucleotide analogues; recently developed compounds are often derivatives of these early tools. Tocris Bioscience first entered the field of purinergic signalling reagents with the commercial release of the pyridoxal phosphate derivative, iso-PPADS. During the past two decades, Tocris has assembled a collection of over 50 compounds for P2 receptor modulation, including research tools commercialised from both academic and industrial laboratories. Recently, a number of P2X subtype-selective compounds have been generated by pharmaceutical company medicinal chemistry programmes, supplementing our range of P2Y-selective compounds. Here, we detail the current, commercially available agonists and antagonists of P2X_1,2/3,3,4,7 and P2Y_1,6,11,12 receptors; considered together, they form the foundations of a comprehensive P2 receptor pharmacological ‘toolkit’.

     

Geoffrey Burnstock: most highly cited scientist

If you haven't taken the time to read up on purinergic signaling, consider this: of the ten most cited scientists in pharmacology for the past decade, no less than four work on biological responses to purines and related molecules(1). If you're surprised by this statistic, you're in good company: until a few weeks ago, the fact was also unknown to Geoffrey Burnstock, the single-most cited researcher on the list and the scientist who coined the term "purinergic nerves" in the early 70s. (He is also about to launch a new journal devoted to the discipline, Purinergic Signalling, as Editor-in-Chief ). At that time, Burnstock's depiction of ATP as an important neurotransmitter was met with considerable skepticism, even among those who otherwise accepted and studied the intracellular actions of purines. This year in June, Burnstock appeared at the Purines 2004 Meeting, appropriately enough, to deliver the "First Burnstock Lecture." Many of the symposia presenters openly acknowledged Burnstock's work in driving the purinergic field to its present state of fruition; this acknowledgment, along with the genuine affection that typically accompanies it, seems to surprise as much as it delights Burnstock, who remembers very well the many meetings where his results went hotly challenged. The following interview took place at Purines 2004 in Chapel Hill.     

Measurement of purine release with microelectrode biosensors

Purinergic signalling departs from traditional paradigms of neurotransmission in the variety of release mechanisms and routes of production of extracellular ATP and adenosine. Direct real-time measurements of these purinergic agents have been of great value in understanding the functional roles of this signalling system in a number of diverse contexts. Here, we review the methods for measuring purine release, introduce the concept of microelectrode biosensors for ATP and adenosine and explain how these have been used to provide new mechanistic insight in respiratory chemoreception, synaptic physiology, eye development and purine salvage. We finish by considering the association of purine release with pathological conditions and examine the possibilities that biosensors for purines may one day be a standard part of the clinical diagnostic tool chest.

     

Real-time measurement of adenosine and ATP release in the central nervous system

This brief review recounts how, stimulated by the work of Geoff Burnstock, I developed biosensors that allowed direct real-time measurement of ATP and adenosine during neural function. The initial impetus to create an adenosine biosensor came from trying to understand how ATP and adenosine-modulated motor pattern generation in the frog embryo spinal cord. Early biosensor measurements demonstrated slow accumulation of adenosine during motor activity. Subsequent application of these biosensors characterized real-time release of adenosine in in vitro models of brain ischaemia, and this line of work has recently led to clinical measurements of whole blood purine levels in patients undergoing carotid artery surgery or stroke. In parallel, the wish to understand the role of ATP signalling in the chemosensory regulation of breathing stimulated the development of ATP biosensors. This revealed that release of ATP from the chemosensory areas of the medulla oblongata preceded adaptive changes in breathing, triggered adaptive changes in breathing via activation of P2 receptors, and ultimately led to the discovery of connexin26 as a channel that mediates CO₂-gated release of ATP from cells.

     

Modulatory effect of iron chelators on adenosine deaminase activity and gene expression in Trichomonas vaginalis

Trichomonas vaginalis is a flagellate protozoan that parasitises the urogenital human tract and causes trichomoniasis. During the infection, the acquisition of nutrients, such as iron and purine and pyrimidine nucleosides, is essential for the survival of the parasite. The enzymes for purinergic signalling, including adenosine deaminase (ADA), which degrades adenosine to inosine, have been characterised in T. vaginalis. In the evaluation of the ADA profile in different T. vaginalis isolates treated with different iron sources or with limited iron availability, a decrease in activity and an increase in ADA gene expression after iron limitation by 2,2-bipyridyl and ferrozine chelators were observed. This supported the hypothesis that iron can modulate the activity of the enzymes involved in purinergic signalling. Under bovine serum limitation conditions, no significant differences were observed. The results obtained in this study allow for the assessment of important aspects of ADA and contribute to a better understanding of the purinergic system in T. vaginalis and the role of iron in establishing infection and parasite survival.     

Purinergic signalling in the musculoskeletal system

It is now widely recognised that extracellular nucleotides, signalling via purinergic receptors, participate in numerous biological processes in most tissues. It has become evident that extracellular nucleotides have significant regulatory effects in the musculoskeletal system. In early development, ATP released from motor nerves along with acetylcholine acts as a cotransmitter in neuromuscular transmission; in mature animals, ATP functions as a neuromodulator. Purinergic receptors expressed by skeletal muscle and satellite cells play important pathophysiological roles in their development or repair. In many cell types, expression of purinergic receptors is often dependent on differentiation. For example, sequential expression of P2X5, P2Y₁ and P2X2 receptors occurs during muscle regeneration in the mdx model of muscular dystrophy. In bone and cartilage cells, the functional effects of purinergic signalling appear to be largely negative. ATP stimulates the formation and activation of osteoclasts, the bone-destroying cells. Another role appears to be as a potent local inhibitor of mineralisation. In osteoblasts, the bone-forming cells, ATP acts via P2 receptors to limit bone mineralisation by inhibiting alkaline phosphatase expression and activity. Extracellular ATP additionally exerts significant effects on mineralisation via its hydrolysis product, pyrophosphate. Evidence now suggests that purinergic signalling is potentially important in several bone and joint disorders including osteoporosis, rheumatoid arthritis and cancers. Strategies for future musculoskeletal therapies might involve modulation of purinergic receptor function or of the ecto-nucleotidases responsible for ATP breakdown or ATP transport inhibitors.     

METHIONINE PROXIMITY ASSAY,A NOVEL METHOD FOR EXPLORING PEPTIDE LIGAND–RECEPTOR INTERACTION

ABSTRACT

Probing G-protein coupled receptor (GPCR) structures is a priority in the functional and structural understanding of GPCRs. In the past, we have used several approaches around photoaffinity labeling in order to establish contact points between peptide ligands and their cognate receptors. Such contact points are helpful to build reality based molecular models of GPCRs and to elucidate their activation mechanisms. Most studies of peptidergic GPCRs have been done with photolabeling peptides containing the benzophenone moiety as a reputedly non-selective probe. However our recent results are now showing that p-benzoylphenylalanine (Bpa) has some selectivity for Met residues in the receptor protein, reducing the accuracy of this method. Turning a problem into an asset, modified analogues of Bpa, e.g. p,?p″-nitrobenzoylphenylalanine (NO₂Bpa), display increased selectivity for such Met residues. It means a photoprobe containing such modified benzophenone-moieties does not label a receptor protein unless a Met residue is in the immediate vicinity. This unique property allows us to propose and show the feasibility and utility of a new method for scanning the contact areas of peptidergic GPCRs, the Methionine Proximity Assay (MPA). Putative contact residues of the receptor are exchanged to Met residues by site-directed mutagenesis and are subjected to photoaffinity labeling with such modified benzophenone-containing peptides. Successful incorporation indicates physical proximity of those residues. This principle is established and explored with benzophenone-containing analogues of angiotensin II and the two known human angiotensin II receptors AT₁ and AT₂, determining contact points in both receptors. This approach has several important advantages over other scanning approaches, e.g., the SCAM procedure, since the MPA-method can be used in the hydrophobic core of receptors.     

Phospholipase C-γ2 via p38 and ERK1/2 MAP kinase mediates diperoxovanadate-asparagine induced human platelet aggregation and sCD40L release

Abstract

Objective

Redox imbalance either inside platelets or in their immediate surroundings prove detrimental to their physiologic functions during haemostasis. This study was therefore aimed to assess the effect of peroxide radicals on platelet functions and underlying signalling mechanisms using asparagine-conjugated diperoxovanadate (DPV-Asn).

Methods

Platelet aggregation, ATP secretion, TxB₂ release, intra-platelet calcium mobilization, protein tyrosine phosphorylation, GPIIbIIIa activation by PAC1 labelling and sCD40L release (enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay) was monitored using various concentrations of DPV-Asn. Cell viability was assessed by Annexin V labelling, MTT assay, LDH leakage and mitochondrial membrane potential by JC-1.

Results

Platelet aggregation induced by DPV-Asn was chiefly regulated by dense granule secretion, thromboxane A₂ (TxA₂) generation, intra-platelet [Ca²⁺] influx, GPIIbIIIa activation and sCD40L release, which were significantly reduced in presence of U73122 (PLC inhibitor), aspirin (COX), SB203580 (p38 inhibitor), and PD98059 (ERK inhibitor). This was further corroborated by enhanced tyrosine phosphorylation of numerous platelet proteins including PLC-γ2, which apparently played a central role in transducing peroxide signals to regulate [Ca²⁺] influx and phosphorylation of p38 and ERK1/2 MAP kinase.

Discussion

Peroxide radicals critically regulate the thrombo-inflammatory functions of platelets via the PLCγ2-p38-ERK1/2-TxA₂ pathway, which closely resembles the clinical scenario of various pathologies like hyperglycemia and atherosclerosis during which oxidative stress disrupts platelet functions.     

Purinergic signalling in the cardiovascular system—a tribute to Geoffrey Burnstock

Purinergic Signalling - Geoffrey Burnstock made groundbreaking discoveries on the physiological roles of purinergic receptors and led on P2 purinergic receptor classification. His knowledge, vision...     

Development of a comprehensive set of P2 receptor pharmacological research compounds

Pharmacological manipulation of P2X and P2Y receptors has been critical to the elucidation of the biological roles of these receptors within a multitude of physiological and pathological processes. Initial purinergic signalling research made use of compounds based on pyridoxal phosphate, suramin and nucleotide analogues; recently developed compounds are often derivatives of these early tools. Tocris Bioscience first entered the field of purinergic signalling reagents with the commercial release of the pyridoxal phosphate derivative, iso-PPADS. During the past two decades, Tocris has assembled a collection of over 50 compounds for P2 receptor modulation, including research tools commercialised from both academic and industrial laboratories. Recently, a number of P2X subtype-selective compounds have been generated by pharmaceutical company medicinal chemistry programmes, supplementing our range of P2Y-selective compounds. Here, we detail the current, commercially available agonists and antagonists of P2X_1,2/3,3,4,7 and P2Y_1,6,11,12 receptors; considered together, they form the foundations of a comprehensive P2 receptor pharmacological ‘toolkit’.     

Apoptosis signal-regulating kinase 1 is an intracellular inducer of p38 MAPK-mediated myogenic signalling in cardiac myoblasts

Myogenic differentiation is an essential process for the myogenesis in response to various extracellular stimuli. p38 MAPK is a core signalling molecule in myogenic differentiation. The activation of p38 MAPK is required for myogenic differentiation; however, the mechanism for this activation remains undefined. ASK1 is a member of the MAP3K family that activates both JNK and p38 MAPK pathways in response to an array of stresses such as oxidative stress, endoplasmic reticulum stress and calcium influx. Here, we reported that TNFα was significantly released from H9c2 cardiac myoblast in differentiation medium. Furthermore, the oxidant H₂O₂ acted as a messenger in the TNFα signalling pathway to disrupt the complex of ASK1-Trx, which was followed by the activation of ASK1 in cardiac myogenic differentiation. Subsequently, the activated ASK1 stimulated MKK3/6-p38MAPK signalling cascade to induce specific myogenic differentiation. In addition, exogenous TNFα added to the medium at physiological levels enhanced the ASK1-p38 MAPK signalling pathway through the increased generation of H₂O₂. Interestingly, inhibition of p38 MAPK abrogated the production of H₂O₂, suggesting that there might be a positive feedback loop in the myogenic-redox signalling pathway. These results indicate that ASK1 is a new intracellular regulator of activation of the p38 MAPK in cardiac myogenic differentiation.     

A Conspicuous Connection: Structure Defines Function for the Phosphatidylinositol-Phosphate Kinase Family

ABSTRACT

The phosphatidylinositol phosphate (PIP) kinases are a unique family of enzymes that generate an assortment of lipid messengers, including the pivotal second messenger phosphatidylinositol 4,5-bisphosphate (PI4,5P₂). While members of the PIP kinase family function by catalyzing a similar phosphorylation reaction, the specificity loop of each PIP kinase subfamily determines substrate preference and partially influences distinct subcellular targeting. Specific protein-protein interactions that are unique to particular isoforms or splice variants play a key role in targeting PIP kinases to appropriate subcellular compartments to facilitate the localized generation of PI4,5P₂ proximal to effectors, a mechanism key for the function of PI4,5P₂ as a second messenger. This review documents the discovery of the PIP kinases and their signaling products, and summarizes our current understanding of the mechanisms underlying the localized generation of PI4,5P₂ by PIP kinases for the regulation of cellular events including actin cytoskeleton dynamics, vesicular trafficking, cell migration, and an assortment of nuclear events.     

Purines as potential morphogens during embryonic development

Components of purinergic signalling are expressed in the early embryo raising the possibility that ATP, ADP and adenosine may contribute to the mechanisms of embryonic development. We summarize the available data from four developmental models-mouse, chick, Xenopus and zebrafish. While there are some notable examples where purinergic signalling is indeed important during development, e.g. development of the eye in the frog, it is puzzling that deletion of single components of purinergic signalling often results in rather minor developmental phenotypes. We suggest that a key step in further analysis is to perform combinatorial alterations of expression of purinergic signalling components to uncover their roles in development. We introduce the concept that purinergic signalling could create novel morphogenetic fields to encode spatial location via the concentration of ATP, ADP and adenosine. We show that using minimal assumptions and the known properties of the ectonucleotidases, complex spatial patterns of ATP and adenosine can be set up. These patterns may provide a new way to assess the potential of purinergic signalling in developmental processes.     

Connexins and pannexins in neuronal development and adult neurogenesis

Connexins and pannexins share very similar structures and functions; they also exhibit overlapping expression in many stages of neuronal development. Here, we review evidence implicating connexin- and pannexin-mediated communication in the regulation of the birth and development of neurons, specifically Cx26, Cx30, Cx32, Cx36, Cx43, Cx45, Panx1, and Panx2. We begin by dissecting the involvement of these proteins in the generation and development of new neurons in the embryonic, postnatal, and adult brain. Next we briefly outline common mechanisms employed by both pannexins and connexins in these roles, including modulation of purinergic receptor signalling and signalling nexus functions. Throughout this review we highlight developing themes as well as important gaps in knowledge to be bridged.

     

A novel method for the purification of inositol phosphates from biological samples reveals that no phytate is present in human plasma or urine

Inositol phosphates are a large and diverse family of signalling molecules. While genetic studies have discovered important functions for them, the biochemistry behind these roles is often not fully characterized. A key obstacle in inositol phosphate research in mammalian cells has been the lack of straightforward techniques for their purification and analysis. Here we describe the ability of titanium dioxide (TiO₂) beads to bind inositol phosphates. This discovery allowed the development of a new purification protocol that, coupled with gel analysis, permitted easy identification and quantification of InsP₆ (phytate), its pyrophosphate derivatives InsP₇ and InsP₈, and the nucleotides ATP and GTP from cell or tissue extracts. Using this approach, InsP₆, InsP₇ and InsP₈ were visualized in Dictyostelium extracts and a variety of mammalian cell lines and tissues, and the effects of metabolic perturbation on these were explored. TiO₂ bead purification also enabled us to quantify InsP₆ in human plasma and urine, which led to two distinct but related observations. Firstly, there is an active InsP₆ phosphatase in human plasma, and secondly, InsP₆ is undetectable in either fluid. These observations seriously question reports that InsP₆ is present in human biofluids and the advisability of using InsP₆ as a dietary supplement.