Photoperiod and Vernalization Responses in Triticum turgidumxT. tauschii Synthetic Hexaploid Wheats

Studies of synthetic hexaploid wheat developed from Triticumturgidum(AABB genomes) and T. tauschii(DD genome) can provideinformation on potentially useful characters in T. tauschiiand/or T. turgidum for genetic improvement of hexaploid wheat(T. aestivum). Synthetic hexaploid wheats and the T. turgidumand T. tauschii parents were assessed for their developmentalresponses to photoperiod and vernalization for days to ear emergence,final leaf number and the number of spikelets per spike. Theresponses to photoperiod and vernalization of the synthetichexaploids were generally intermediate between those of theparents but in some instances the levels of expression exhibitedby the T. tauschii or T. turgidum parents were epistatic inthe synthetic hexaploids. The relatively strong photoperiodresponse of the T. tauschii accessions was not expressed inthe synthetic hexaploids, but rather the synthetic hexaploidsreflected the photoperiod response of the respective T. turgidumparents. The synthetic hexaploids had vernalization responsesstronger than those of the T. turgidum and bread wheats usedin the study. The expression of ear emergence in response tovernalization of these synthetic hexaploids appeared to be modifiedby the T. turgidum parent. Copyright 2001 Annals of Botany Company Photoperiod, synthetic hexaploids, Triticum aestivum, Triticum tauschii, Triticum turgidum, vernalization     

The potential of synthetic hexaploid wheats to improve zinc efficiency in modern bread wheat

Synthetic hexaploid wheats (Triticum aestivum L) derived from crosses between durum wheat [Triticum turgidum ssp. durum (Desf.) Husn.] and diploid wheat (Aegilops tauschii Coss.) have been developed as a means of transferring desirable characteristics of Aegilops tauschii Coss. such as disease resistance and abiotic stress tolerance into modern bread wheat genotypes. In a growth room experiment using soil culture, we studied a group of 30 synthetic hexaploid wheat accessions together with modern wheat genotypes in order to identify new sources of zinc efficiency for further improvement of zinc efficiency in modern wheat genotypes. There was considerable genetic variation in expression of zinc deficiency symptoms (slight to severe), zinc efficiency (70–100%), shoot Zn concentration (5.8–10.5 and 33–53 mg/kg DW under deficient and sufficient Zn, respectively), shoot Zn content (3.8–10.6 and 34.0–64.6 μg/plant, under deficient and sufficient Zn, respectively) and Zn utilization (0.096–0.172 and 0.019-0.033 g DW/μg Zn under deficient and sufficient Zn, respectively) within synthetic accessions. The presence of synthetic accessions with greater zinc efficiency (100%) than zinc efficient modern wheat genotypes (85%) indicates that the synthetic hexaploids can be used to improve current levels of zinc efficiency in modern wheat genotypes. Synthetic hexaploids may also be a good source of high grain Zn concentration (28–66 mg Zn/kg seed DW).     

Mixed Nitrogen Nutrition and Productivity of Wheat Grown in Hydroponics

The objective of this study was to study the effects of nitrogen(N) supplied as either mixtures of NO₃ and NH₄ or as all NO₃on the final yield of spring wheat. Two separate greenhouseexperiments evaluated the durum spring wheat (Triticum durumL.) cultivar ‘Inbar’ in 1986, and the hard red springwheat (Triticum aestmum L.) cultivar ‘Len’ in 1987.Nitrogen treatments consisted of all NO, or mixtures (75/25or 50/50) of NO₃ and NH₄. At maturity, plants were harvested,separated into leaves, stems, roots, and grain, and each partanalysed for dry matter and chemical composition Compared to plants receiving only NO₃ as the source of N, mixedN nutrition resulted in greater accumulation of whole plantreduced-N (49 to 108% more), phosphorus (38 to 69% more), andpotassium (25% more) for both cultivars. In all cases, plantsproduced higher grain yields (28% for Len to 78% for Inbar)when grown with mixed N nutrition than with only NO₃. The yieldincrease was not associated with heavier grains or more grainsper ear, but rather with an increase in the number of ear-bearingtillers per plant. For both cultivars, the higher yields withmixed N resulted from the production of more total biomass (36to 76%) as the partitioning of dry matter between plant partswas not altered by N treatment. Under the hydroponic conditionsof this experiment, the utilization of both NO₃ and NH₄ resultedin greater growth, nutrient absorption, and yield than NO₃ alone,which was primarily associated with an enhancement in tillerdevelopment Triticum aestivum L., Triticum durum L., spring wheat, hydroponics, ammonium nutrition, nitrate nutrition, tillering, yield components, partitioning     

Reproductive and genetic roles of the maternal progenitor in the origin of common wheat (Triticum aestivum L.)

Common wheat (Triticum aestivum L., AABBDD genome) is thought to have emerged through natural hybridization between Triticum turgidum L. (AABB genome) and Aegilops tauschii Coss. (DD genome). Hybridization barriers and doubling of the trihaploid F₁ hybrids’ genome (ABD) via unreduced gamete fusion had key roles in the process. However, how T. turgidum, the maternal progenitor, was involved in these mechanisms remains unknown. An artificial cross‐experiment using 46 cultivated and 31 wild T. turgidum accessions and a single Ae. tauschii tester with a very short genetic distance to the common wheat D genome was conducted. Cytological and quantitative trait locus analyses of F₁ hybrid genome doubling were performed. The crossability and ability to cause hybrid inviability did not greatly differ between the cultivars and wild accessions. The ability to cause hybrid genome doubling was higher in the cultivars. Three novel T. turgidum loci for hybrid genome doubling, which influenced unreduced gamete production in F₁ hybrids, were identified. Cultivated T. turgidum might have increased the probability of the emergence of common wheat through its enhanced ability to cause genome doubling in F₁ hybrids with Ae. tauschii. The ability enhancement might have involved alterations at a relatively small number of loci.     

Expression of Vernalization Requirement and Spikelet Number in Synthetic Hexaploid Wheats and their Triticum tauschii and Tetraploid Wheat Parents

Vernalization requirement, as measured by days from sowing toear emergence (plants grown under an 18-h photoperiod), andspikelet number per ear were recorded for 17 synthetic hexaploidwheats and the six tetraploid (Triticum durum) and the ninediploid T. tauschii parents used to synthesize them. The tetraploid parents and the synthetic hexaploids had springphenotypes (little or no vernalization requirement) whereasthe T. tauschii parents were all winter types (strong vernalizationrequirement). The tetraploid wheats and the synthetic hexaploidsreached ear emergence 50·3 to 63·8 d and 58·2to 75·3 d after sowing, respectively, while the T. tauschiilines reached ear emergence 114·3 to 179·5 d aftersowing. The spring habit of the synthetic hexaploids demonstrates theepistasis of spring over winter habit. It is considered thatwith a presumed single vrn locus in the diploid species T. tauschiithe range of ear emergence in these lines is consistent withthe action of multiple alleles at that locus. Although there was no general epistasis for spikelet number,the tetraploid parents appear to be exerting more influenceover spikelet number in the synthetic hexaploids than T. tauschii.The well established association between the duration from sowingto ear emergence and spikelet number was not evident eitherwithin each ploidy group or when the 32 lines were consideredtogether. Triticum tauschii, Triticum durum, hexaploid wheat, spikelet number, vernalization requirement     

Kinetic parameters of Zn uptake by wheat are affected by the herbicide chlorsulfuron

Kinetic parameters of Zn uptake were determined for wheat plants(Triticum aestivum cvs Excalibur and Gatcher, and Triticum turgidumconv. durum cv. Durati) pre-grown at deficient or sufficientZn supply and with 0 or 4 mg m^-3 sulphonylurea herbicide chlorsulfuron(2-chloro-N-(((4-methoxy-6-methyl-1,3,5-triazin-2-yl) amino)carbonyl)-benzenesulphonamide].Net Zn uptake generally showed a saturable response to increasingsolution Zn concentrations; this response fitted a modifiedMichaelis-Menten equation incorporating the C_min term (solutionconcentration when net uptake is     

Meiotic restriction in emmer wheat is controlled by one or more nuclear genes that continue to function in derived lines

Highly fertile F₁ hybrids were made between Triticum turgidum L. ssp. turgidum (2n = 28, AABB) and Aegilops tauschii Coss. (2n = 14, DD) without embryo rescue and hormone treatment. The F₁ plants had an average seed set of 25%. Approximately 96% of the F₂ seeds were able to germinate normally and about 67% of the F₂ plants were spontaneous amphidiploid (2n = 42, AABBDD). Cytological analysis of male gametogenesis of the F₁ plants showed that meiotic restitution is responsible for the high fertility. A mitosis-like meiosis led to meiotic restitution at either of the two meiotic divisions resulting in unreduced gametes. Test crosses of the T. t. turgidum–Ae. tauschii amphidiploid with Ae. variabilis and rye suggested that the mitosis-like meiosis is controlled by one or more nuclear genes that continue to function in derived lines. This discovery indicates a potential application of such genes in producing double haploids.     

Poly(A) polymerase in Dormant Embryos of Triticum durum

Triticum durum‘Cappelli’ has a ‘relative’dormancy which can be broken by dry after-ripening at room temperature.The breakage of dormancy in the embryos of T. durum , is accompaniedby a decline in content and a different degree of synthesisof poly(A)⁺RNA. This work studies the activity of poly(A) polymerase(E.C. 2.7.7.19), the enzyme which permits polyadenylation. Anincrease in the activity of this enzyme in parallel with theenhanced rate of germination is revealed. Since poly(A) polymeraseactivity is the same in dormant and non-dormant dry embryos,it seems that the activity of the enzyme is not involved inthe breakage of dormancy. The use of cycloheximide and cordycepinshows the presence of enzymes with different origins: a storedenzyme and one bound to a long lived mRNA, present in dormantand non-dormant embryos, plus an enzyme bound to newly synthesizedmRNA which is mainly active in non-dormant embryos. Since dormancycould be the result of an interaction between hormones, thiswork analyses the effects of GA₃and ABA on poly(A) polymerase.GA₃enhanced poly(A) polymerase activity only in dormant embryoswhile ABA inhibited this activity only in non-dormant embryos.Cycloheximide applied to excised wheat embryos represses thestimulatory and inhibitory effects of GA₃and ABA, respectively.The hormone action on poly(A) polymerase activity is thus dependenton de novo protein synthesis. Results using cordycepin suggestthe presence of a stored mRNA for poly(A) polymerase, togetherwith hormonal regulation of enzyme activity at a translationallevel. Copyright 1999 Annals of Botany Company Triticum durum , wheat, dormancy breakage, poly(A) polymerase, GA₃, ABA, germination.     

Development of chromosome 6D-specific markers for α-gliadin genes and their use in assessing dynamic changes at the Gli-2 loci

To develop chromosome 6D-specific point mutation (PM) markers for α-gliadin genes, 79 α-gliadin sequences cloned from Aegilops tauschii and another 40 α-gliadin genes with known chromosome locations were used in multi-sequence alignment and phylogenic analysis. Additional multiple alignment adjustments were performed manually to facilitate discovery of putative chromosome 6D-specific point mutations. A total of 85 PM primers were designed to detect 68 candidate chromosome 6D-specific point mutations. Experimental tests revealed 11 chromosome 6D-specific PM markers by using genomic DNA from homoeologous group 6 nullisomic–tetrasomic lines of Chinese Spring and putative diploid and tetraploid ancestors of hexaploid wheat as PCR templates. Detection of PM markers in one synthetic hexaploid wheat and its parental lines indicated that some α-gliadin genes were lost from Gli-2 loci during the formation of hexaploid wheat by amphidiploidization of the genomes of Triticum turgidum and Ae. tauschii. Detection of these PM markers in Ae. tauschii, T. aestivum and its four subspecies indicated that at least two genetically distinct sources of Ae. tauschii contributed germplasm to the D genome of T. aestivum.     

Salt Tolerance in the Triticeae: K/Na Discrimination in Barley

Concentrations of ions were measured in the youngest fully-expandedleaves of Triticum aestivum, T. durum, Hordeum vulgare, H. spontaneum,Secale cereale, and Aegilops squarrosa accessions grown in hydroponicculture in the presence of salt (NaCl+CaCl₂). Triticum aestivum,Secale cereale, and Ae. squarrosa had the low leaf Na and highleaf K concentrations typical of plants which contain the enhancedK/Na discrimination character originally found in Ae. squarrosa.T. durum and the Hordeum species did not have this character.The better growth of H. vulgare than of T. durum with similarsalt concentrations in the youngest fully-expanded leaves maybe a result of better compartmentation of Na, Cl, and K betweendifferent tisssues or between different compartments withincells. The enhanced K/Na discrimination character was expressedin disomic addition lines of H. vulgare chromosomes in Triticumaestivum. The H. vulgare variety Herta and its slender mutantboth had similar leaf cation concentrations, although they differedin growth rate when grown at 60 mol m^–3 NaCl. H. vulgareand T. durum seedlings grown in the absence of monovalent cationsaccumulated more ²²Na in their shoots than seedlings of otherspecies when incubated in 1.0 mol m^–3 NaCl labelled with²²Na. Key words: Salt, ion transport, I genome, barley, wheat     

Genetic characterization and molecular mapping of Hessian fly resistance genes derived from Aegilops tauschii in synthetic wheat

Two synthetic hexaploid wheat lines (×Aegilotriticum spp., 2n = 6x = 42, genomes AABBDD), SW8 and SW34, developed from the crosses of the durum wheat cultivar Langdon (Triticum turgidum L. var. durum, 2n = 4x = 28, genomes AABB) with two Aegilops tauschii Cosson accessions (2n = 2x = 14, genome DD), were determined to carry Hessian fly [Mayetiola destructor (Say)] resistance genes derived from the Ae. tauschii parents. SW8 was resistant to the Hessian fly biotype Great Plains (GP) and strain vH13 (virulent to H13). SW34 was resistant to biotype GP, but susceptible to strain vH13. Allelism tests indicated that resistance genes in SW8 and SW34 may be allelic to H26 and H13 or correspond to paralogs at both loci, respectively. H26 and H13 were localized to chromosome 4D and 6D, respectively, in previous studies. Molecular mapping in the present study, however, assigned the H26 locus to chromosome 3D rather than 4D. On the other hand, mapping of the resistance gene in SW34 verified the previous assignment of the H13 locus to chromosome 6D. Linkage analysis and physical mapping positioned the H26 locus to the chromosomal deletion bin 3DL3-0.81–1.00. A linkage map for each of these two resistance genes was constructed using simple sequence repeat (SSR) and target region amplification polymorphism (TRAP) markers.     

Chromosomal structural changes and microsatellite variations in newly synthesized hexaploid wheat mediated by unreduced gametes

Allohexaploid wheat was derived from interspecific hybridization, followed by spontaneous chromosome doubling. Newly synthesized hexaploid wheat by crossing Triticum turgidum and Aegilops tauschii provides a classical model to understand the mechanisms of allohexaploidization in wheat. However, immediate chromosome level variation and microsatellite level variation of newly synthesized hexaploid wheat have been rarely reported. Here, unreduced gametes were applied to develop synthesized hexaploid wheat, NA0928, population by crossing T. turgidum ssp. dicoccum MY3478 and Ae. tauschii SY41, and further S0–S3 generations of NA0928 were assayed by sequential cytological and microsatellite techniques. We demonstrated that plentiful chromosomal structural changes and microsatellite variations emerged in the early generations of newly synthesized hexaploid wheat population NA0928, including aneuploidy with whole-chromosome loss or gain, aneuploidy with telosome formation, chromosome-specific repeated sequence elimination (indicated by fluorescence in situ hybridization) and microsatellite sequence elimination (indicated by sequencing), and many kinds of variations have not been previously reported. Additionally, we reported a new germplasm, T. turgidum accession MY3478 with excellent unreduced gametes trait, and then succeeded to transfer powdery mildew resistance from Ae. tauschii SY41 to synthesized allohexaploid wheat population NA0928, which would be valuable resistance resources for wheat improvement.     

Phylogenetic analysis of tetraploid wheat based on nuclear DMC1 gene

Tetraploid wheat (AABB or AAGG, 2n = 4x = 28) holds an important place in Triticum. It includes two allopolyploid species, Triticum turgidum and Triticum timopheevii. Many problems concerning the phylogenetic relationships among tetraploid wheat species remain unresolved. In this study, sequences data for the nuclear DMC1 gene from 61 accessions of Triticum and Aegilops species, representing diploid and tetraploid species, were used to examine the phylogenetic relationships among tetraploid wheat. Phylogenetic trees were constructed using maximum-likelihood and neighbor-joining approaches, and gene flow and genetic differentiation values were computed. The results indicated that the A genome of tetraploid wheat originated from T. urartu rather than T. monococcum, and Aegilops speltoides was the donor of the B and G genomes. Hulled tetraploid wheat accessions formed a subclade, and naked tetraploid wheat got other subclade, indicating that at least two intermediary subspecies were involved in the evolution of T. turgidum. Triticum turgidum and T. timopheevii might have simultaneously originated from a hybridization events. These results indicated that the DMC1 gene sequences are useful for resolution of the molecular phylogenetic relationships of tetraploid wheat.     

Influence of Vernalization and Photoperiod on Supernumerary Spikelet Expression in Wheat

Two tetraploid (Triticum turgidum L.emend gr. turgidum and gr.durum) and five hexaploid wheats (Triticum x aestivum L. emendgr. aestivum) with reported tendencies for ‘branched heads’(supernurnerary spikelets) exhibited variation in its expressionunder different vernalization photoperiod and temperature regimes. Two main types of supernumerary spikelets were identified, multiplesessile spikelets (MSS) with two or more complete spikeletsat a rachis node and indeterminate rachilla spikelets (IRS)with two to 13 spikelets on an extended rachilla. The degree of supernumerary spikelet expression in wheats withvernalization response differed from those without. Short photoperiods(9–14 h) both outdoors and in a glasshouse environment,were more conducive to supernumerary spikelet expression than24 h photoperiod in both environments. The 24 h photoperiodglasshouse environment (higher mean temperatures) was leastconducive to its expression except in lines with a strong vernalizationresponse. The high stability of supernumerary spikelet expression in certaingenotypes in the different environments indicated the feasibilityof incorporating this character in breeding and selecting commercialwheats to increase grain number per head. Triticum, wheat, ear-branching, supernumerary spikelets, vernalization, photoperiod, temperature     

An immunochemical approach to species relationship in Triticum and some related species

Summary An immunological reaction, precipitation in gel, was produced using a rabbit antiserum directed to a specific protein constantly present in bread wheats (T. aestivum, genome AABBDD), but absent in durum wheat (T. durum Desf., genome AABB). This protein was isolated in the soluble-protein fraction of bread wheat caryopses by combined biochemical and immunological techniques.The availability of such a specific anti-bread wheat serum made possible the analysis of a series of varieties and species of wheat and of some closely related (Secale, Aegilops) and less closely related (Hordeum, Haynaldia) taxa to determine whether the protein was present or absent. Hordeum vulgare, Haynaldia villosa, Triticum monoccocum and Triticum turgidum gave a negative result, while positive results were obtained in T. aestivum, T. timopheevi, T. zhukovskyi, Secale cereale, Aegilops speltoides, Ae. mutica, Ae. comosa, Ae. caudata, Ae. umbellulata, Ae. squarrosa, and also in the artificial amphiploids (Ae. speltoides x T. monococcum) and (Ae. caudata x T. monococcum).It is concluded that these results agree closely with the classification of Triticum proposed by MacKey in 1966. The investigated protein not only permits the differentiation of T. aestivum from T. turgidum, but also T. turgidum from T. timopheevi at tetraploid level and T. monococcum from all the diploid species of Aegilops.     

Normalizing Development of Cultured Triticum aestivum L. Embryos: I. LOW OXYGEN TENSIONS AND EXOGENOUS ABA

Wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) embryos form in dynamically-regulatedovular environments. Our objectives were to improve developmentof cultured immature wheat embryos by simulating, in vitro,abscisic acid (ABA) levels and O₂ tensions as found in wheatovules during zygotic embryogenesis. We characterized from intactwheat kernels embryo respiration, embryo morphology and embryoand endosperm + ABA levels at 13, 19 and 25 d post-anthesis(DPA). Young (13 DPA) embryos were then excised and culturedin vitro, where they were exposed to 0·2 or 2·Ommol m^–3 ±ABA and 2.·1, 2·5 or 7·4mol m^–3 (6, 7 and 21%, respectively) gaseous O₂. At 6and 12 d in culture, + ABA levels, embryo respiration and embryomorphology were characterized by treatment. Thirteen-day-oldembryos from two different plant populations differed by 17-foldin initial ABA content. However, this difference did not affectprecocious germination in vitro, nor did it affect the amountof exogenous ABA required to reduce precocious germination by40%. In this respect, embryos from both populations were equallysensitive to exogenous ABA. Cavity sap O₂ levels (2·1to 2·5 mol m^–3) were much more effective in preventingprecocious germination of cultured embryos than were cavitysap levels of ABA (0·2 to 2·0 mmol m^–3).The combination of physiological levels of both ABA and O₂ largelynormalized DW accumulation and embryo morphology without alteringendogenous + ABA levels. Residual respiration of cultured embryoswas higher than that of embryos grown in situ, and was not influencedby the exogenous O₂ and ABA treatments Key words: Abscisic acid, embryo development, oxygen tensions, respiration, wheat     

Increase in ascorbate-glutathione metabolism as local and precocious systemic responses induced by cadmium in durum wheat plants

Durum wheat plants (Triticum durum cv Creso) were grown in thepresence of cadmium (0–40 µM) and analysed after3 and 7 d for their growth, oxidative stress markers, phytochelatins,and enzymes and metabolites of the ascorbate (ASC)–glutathione(GSH) cycle. Cd exposure produced a dose-dependent inhibitionof growth in both roots and leaves. Lipid peroxidation, proteinoxidation and the decrease in the ascorbate redox state indicatethe presence of oxidative stress in the roots, where H₂O₂ overproductionand phytochelatin synthesis also occurred. The activity of theASC–GSH cycle enzymes significantly increased in roots.Consistently, a dose-dependent accumulation of Cd was evidentin these organs. On the other hand, no oxidative stress symptomsor phytochelatin synthesis occurred in the leaves; where, atleast during the time of our analysis, the levels of Cd remainedirrelevant. In spite of this, enzymes of the ASC–GSH cyclesignificantly increased their activity in the leaves. When ASCbiosynthesis was enhanced, by feeding plants with its last precursor,L-galactono--lactone (GL), Cd uptake was not affected. On theother hand, the oxidative stress induced in the roots by theheavy metal was alleviated. GL treatment also inhibited theCd-dependent phytochelatin biosynthesis. These results suggestthat different strategies can successfully cope with heavy metaltoxicity. The changes that occurred in the ASC–GSH cycleenzymes of the leaves also suggest that the whole plant improvedits antioxidant defense, even in those parts which had not yetbeen reached by Cd. This precocious increase in the enzymesof the ASC–GSH cycle further highlight the tight regulationand the relevance of this cycle in the defense against heavymetals.     

Cloning,expression analysis and In silico characterization of HSP101: a potential player conferring heat stress in Aegilops speltoides (Tausch) Gren

Heat shock protein (HSP101) function as molecular chaperones and confer thermotolerance to plants. In the present investigation, identification, comprehensive expression analysis, phylogeny and protein modelling of HSP101 gene has been done in Aegilops speltoides accession Pau3583. In the present study, we cloned and in silico characterized a HSP101C gene designated as AsHSP101C-Pau3583. AsHSP101C-Pau3583 is 4180 bp long with seven exons and six introns and encoded a polypeptide of 910 amino acids predicted by FGENESH. We have identified 58 SNPs between the AsHSP101C-Pau3583 and reference gene sequence extracted from Ae. speltoides TGAC assembly. Real-time RT-PCR analysis of expression levels of HSP101 gene in two wheat genotypes under heat stress revealed that gene namely HSP101C was up-regulated in Aegilops speltoides acc. Pau3583 by > fourfold in comparison to Triticum aestivum cv. PBW343 under heat stress signifies that it plays a role in conferring heat tolerance. Sequence comparison and phylogenetic analysis of AsHSP101C-Pau3583 with seven wheat homologs Triticum aestivum, Aegilops speltoides (TGAC), Triticum durum cv Cappelli, Triticum durum cv Strongfield, Triticum monococcum, Aegilops tauschii and Triticum urartu showed significant similarities with highly conserved coding regions and functional domains (AAA, AAA + 2, ClpB domains), suggesting the conserved function of HSP101C in different species. The illustration of the protein models of HSP101C in homologs provided information for the ATP-binding motifs within the nucleotide binding domains (NBD), specific for the chaperone activity. These findings are important and identified SNPs could be used for designing markers for ensuring the transfer of AsHSP101C-Pau3583 gene into hexaploid wheat and its role in heat tolerance.Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s12298-021-01005-2.