Virus and prokaryote enumeration from planktonic aquatic environments by epifluorescence microscopy with SYBR Green I

Viruses are the most abundant biological entities in aquatic environments, typically exceeding the abundance of bacteria by an order of magnitude. The reliable enumeration of virus-like particles in marine microbiological investigations is a key measurement parameter. Although the size of typical marine viruses (20-200 nm) is too small to permit the resolution of details by light microscopy, such viruses can be visualized by epifluorescence microscopy if stained brightly. This can be achieved using the sensitive DNA dye SYBR Green I (Molecular Probes-Invitrogen). The method relies on simple vacuum filtration to capture viruses on a 0.02-microm aluminum oxide filter, and subsequent staining and mounting to prepare slides. Virus-like particles are brightly stained and easily observed for enumeration, and prokaryotic cells can easily be counted on the same slides. The protocol provides an inexpensive, rapid (30 min) and reliable technique for obtaining counts of viruses and prokaryotes simultaneously.     

Loss of Estuarine Bacteria by Viral Infection and Predation in Microcosm Conditions

The bacterioplankton density in Ria de Aveiro, a shallow estuarine ecosystem, varied in the broad range of 1.9-10.6 109 cells L-1. The range of values was about 2 times higher in brackish water than in marine water. At high tide bacterial abundance was 2-3 times lower than at low tide. The overall variation in virioplankton was in the range of 2.4-25.0 1010 particles L-1. Brackish water was about 2 times richer in viral particles than the marine water. Near low tide the virioplankton was 2-3 times higher that at high tide. Viral density followed the pattern of bacterial abundance (it explained 40% of virioplankton variation). The viruses to bacterium ratio varied, throughout tidal cycles, by a factor of about 10 establishing the range 4.7-55.6 (average 17.6). This ratio was rather similar in the two estuarine zones. We compared the effects of infection and predation on the control of bacterioplankton size in the two zones of the estuary. The approach to this question was conducted in experimental microcosms, set up in six combinations of plankton variables affecting the presence/absence of predators, virus-to-bacterium ratio (10-fold increase), virus-to-bacterium distance (2.2-fold increase), and bacterial growth rate. The results showed that predation was similar, in a percent basis, in marine (69%) and brackish water (73%). Viral infection was, however, higher in brackish water (59%) than in the marine water (36%). We conclude that the bacterioplankton along the salinity gradient evolves under biological pressures that are in different balance in the marine and brackish water zones. The effect of viral lysis on bacterial communities with enhanced growth (after yeast extract addition) was masked even when the initial ratio was 10-fold greater than in the natural samples. The high density of the virioplankton did not preclude the large and rapid increase in bacterial density. We suggest that the dynamics of the equilibrium between bacteria and viruses in the environment is driven to higher numerical levels during periods of intensive bacterial growth. On the contrary, at low bacterial growth rates the temporarily increased virus-to-bacterium ratio may drive the equilibrium to its lowest levels.     

High virus-to-cell ratios indicate ongoing production of viruses in deep subsurface sediments

Marine sediments cover two-thirds of our planet and harbor huge numbers of living prokaryotes. Long-term survival of indigenous microorganisms within the deep subsurface is still enigmatic, as sources of organic carbon are vanishingly small. To better understand controlling factors of microbial life, we have analyzed viral abundance within a comprehensive set of globally distributed subsurface sediments. Phages were detected by electron microscopy in deep (320 m below seafloor), ancient (∼14 Ma old) and the most oligotrophic subsurface sediments of the world''s oceans (South Pacific Gyre (SPG)). The numbers of viruses (10⁴–10⁹ cm⁻³, counted by epifluorescence microscopy) generally decreased with sediment depth, but always exceeded the total cell counts. The enormous numbers of viruses indicate their impact as a controlling factor for prokaryotic mortality in the marine deep biosphere. The virus-to-cell ratios increased in deeper and more oligotrophic layers, exhibiting values of up to 225 in the deep subsurface of the SPG. High numbers of phages might be due to absorption onto the sediment matrix and a diminished degradation by exoenzymes. However, even in the oldest sediments, microbial communities are capable of maintaining viral populations, indicating an ongoing viral production and thus, viruses provide an independent indicator for microbial life in the marine deep biosphere.     

Application of digital image analysis and flow cytometry to enumerate marine viruses stained with SYBR gold

A novel nucleic acid stain, SYBR Gold, was used to stain marine viral particles in various types of samples. Viral particles stained with SYBR Gold yielded bright and stable fluorescent signals that could be detected by a cooled charge-coupled device camera or by flow cytometry. The fluorescent signal strength of SYBR Gold-stained viruses was about twice that of SYBR Green I-stained viruses. Digital images of SYBR Gold-stained viral particles were processed to enumerate the concentration of viral particles by using digital image analysis software. Estimates of viral concentration based on digitized images were 1.3 times higher than those based on direct counting by epifluorescence microscopy. Direct epifluorescence counts of SYBR Gold-stained viral particles were in turn about 1.34 times higher than those estimated by the transmission electron microscope method. Bacteriophage lysates stained with SYBR Gold formed a distinct population in flow cytometric signatures. Flow cytometric analysis revealed at least four viral subpopulations for a Lake Erie sample and two subpopulations for a Georgia coastal sample. Flow cytometry-based viral counts for various types of samples averaged 1.1 times higher than direct epifluorescence microscopic counts. The potential application of digital image analysis and flow cytometry for rapid and accurate measurement of viral abundance in aquatic environments is discussed.     

Application of Digital Image Analysis and Flow Cytometry To Enumerate Marine Viruses Stained with SYBR Gold

A novel nucleic acid stain, SYBR Gold, was used to stain marine viral particles in various types of samples. Viral particles stained with SYBR Gold yielded bright and stable fluorescent signals that could be detected by a cooled charge-coupled device camera or by flow cytometry. The fluorescent signal strength of SYBR Gold-stained viruses was about twice that of SYBR Green I-stained viruses. Digital images of SYBR Gold-stained viral particles were processed to enumerate the concentration of viral particles by using digital image analysis software. Estimates of viral concentration based on digitized images were 1.3 times higher than those based on direct counting by epifluorescence microscopy. Direct epifluorescence counts of SYBR Gold-stained viral particles were in turn about 1.34 times higher than those estimated by the transmission electron microscope method. Bacteriophage lysates stained with SYBR Gold formed a distinct population in flow cytometric signatures. Flow cytometric analysis revealed at least four viral subpopulations for a Lake Erie sample and two subpopulations for a Georgia coastal sample. Flow cytometry-based viral counts for various types of samples averaged 1.1 times higher than direct epifluorescence microscopic counts. The potential application of digital image analysis and flow cytometry for rapid and accurate measurement of viral abundance in aquatic environments is discussed.     

Factors Influencing Bacterial Production in a Shallow Estuarine System

The bacterioplankton of the marine and brackish water zones of the complex system Ria de Aveiro was characterized as profiles of bacterial abundance and biomass productivity. During the warm season, total bacteria ranged from 0.2 to 8.5 x 109 cells L-1 and active bacteria number from 0.1 to 3.1 x 109 cells L-1. Total and active bacterial numbers were, on average, three times higher in brackish than in marine water. Bacterial productivity on different dates and different tides in the marine zone varied from 0.05 to 4.5 mg C L-1 h-1. Here the average productivity (1.1 mg C L-1 h-1) was 3.5 times less than in brackish water (average 3.8 mg C L-1 h-1; range 0.7-14.2 mg C L-1 h-1). Specific productivity varied from 0.05 to 2.61 fg C cell-1 h-1, a range that was similar throughout the ecosystem. However, specific productivity per active cell was 19% higher in brackish water. Bacterial production variation was best explained by the number of active bacteria, which, in turn, was highly associated with total bacterial number, temperature, and particulate organic carbon. In the marine zone, bacterial production was also influenced by depth and salinity. In the brackish zone, the set of independent variables explained a smaller percentage of bacterial production variation than in marine zone, suggesting greater importance of other variables. In the marine zone, and mainly near low tide, productivity was significantly higher (average 3.3 times) at the surface (down to 0.5 m) than in the deeper layers of the water column. This stratification of bacterial productivity was linked to the increased specific productivity per active cell, as no modification in the proportion of active cells in the population could be detected. The vertical profile of bacterial production in the deeper zone of this estuarine ecosystem, in which no clear salinity or thermal stratification occurs throughout the tidal cycle, seemed to reflect a biochemical stratification generated by increased phytoplankton exudation and/or by photochemical transformation of semilabile or recalcitrant organic compounds. Shallower water masses tend to blur this surface effect. The relative importance of photochemical transformation in the pattern of estuarine bacterial production will therefore tend to vary with the bathymetry of the system.     

Enumeration and biomass estimation of planktonic bacteria and viruses by transmission electron microscopy.

Bacteria and virus particles were harvested from water samples by ultracentrifugation directly onto Formvar-coated electron microscopy grids and counted in a transmission electron microscope. With this technique, we have counted and sized bacteria and viruses in marine water samples and during laboratory incubations. By X-ray microanalysis, we could determine the elemental composition and dry-matter content of individual bacteria. The dry weight/volume ratio for the bacteria was 600 fg of dry weight microns-3. The potassium content of the bacteria was normal compared with previous estimates from other bacterial assemblages; thus, this harvesting procedure did not disrupt the bacterial cells. Virus particles were, by an order of magnitude, more abundant than bacteria in marine coastal waters. During the first 5 to 7 days of incubation, the total number of viruses increased exponentially at a rate of 0.4 day-1 and thereafter declined. The high proliferation rate suggests that viral parasitism may affect mortality of bacteria in aquatic environments.     

Enumeration and biomass estimation of planktonic bacteria and viruses by transmission electron microscopy

Bacteria and virus particles were harvested from water samples by ultracentrifugation directly onto Formvar-coated electron microscopy grids and counted in a transmission electron microscope. With this technique, we have counted and sized bacteria and viruses in marine water samples and during laboratory incubations. By X-ray microanalysis, we could determine the elemental composition and dry-matter content of individual bacteria. The dry weight/volume ratio for the bacteria was 600 fg of dry weight microns-3. The potassium content of the bacteria was normal compared with previous estimates from other bacterial assemblages; thus, this harvesting procedure did not disrupt the bacterial cells. Virus particles were, by an order of magnitude, more abundant than bacteria in marine coastal waters. During the first 5 to 7 days of incubation, the total number of viruses increased exponentially at a rate of 0.4 day-1 and thereafter declined. The high proliferation rate suggests that viral parasitism may affect mortality of bacteria in aquatic environments.     

Quantitative intercomparison of transmission electron microscopy,flow cytometry,and epifluorescence microscopy for nanometric particle analysis

Nanometric biological particles such as viruses have received increased attention in a wide range of scientific fields. Evaluation of viral contributions to environmental processes and the use of viruses in medical applications such as gene therapy require viruses to be routinely and accurately enumerated. There are a variety of existing techniques for counting viruses, namely, plaque assays, transmission electron microscopy (TEM), epifluorescence microscopy (EFM), and flow cytometry (FCM); each has advantages and disadvantages. While there have been attempts to intercompare some of these techniques to determine the most effective means to count viruses, no previous study used a technique-independent standard for quantitative comparison of collection efficiency, accuracy, and precision. In this work, polystyrene nanospheres were used as standards for the intercomparison of performance characteristics for TEM, EFM, FCM, as well as a custom-built flow cytometer (the Single Nanometric Particle Enumerator, SNaPE). EFM and SNaPE exhibited the highest degree of accuracy and precision, with particle concentrations deviating < or =5% from true and relative errors less than half that of TEM, EFM and SNaPE are also significantly more time and cost efficient than TEM.     

Assessment of Factors Influencing Direct Enumeration of Viruses within Estuarine Sediments

Accurate enumeration of viruses within environmental samples is critical for investigations of the ecological role of viruses and viral infection within microbial communities. This report evaluates differences in viral and bacterial direct counts between estuarine sediment samples which were either immediately processed onboard ship or frozen at −20°C and later processed. Viral and bacterial abundances were recorded at three stations spanning the length of the Chesapeake Bay in April and June 2003 within three sediment fractions: pore water (PW), whole sediment (WS), and sediment after pore water removal (AP). No significant difference in viral abundance was apparent between extracts from fresh or frozen sediments. In contrast, bacterial abundance was significantly lower in the samples subjected to freezing. Both bacterial and viral abundance showed significant differences between sediment fractions (PW, WS, or AP) regardless of the fresh or frozen status. Although pore water viral abundance has been used in the past as a measurement of viral abundance in sediments, this fraction accounted for only ca. 5% of the total sediment viral abundance across all samples. The effect of refrigerated storage of sediment viral extracts was also examined and showed that, within the first 2 h, viral abundance decreased ca. 30% in formalin-fixed extracts and 66% in unfixed extracts. Finally, the reliability of direct viral enumeration via epifluorescence microscopy was tested by using DNase treatment of WS extractions. These tests indicated that a large fraction (>86%) of the small SYBR gold fluorescing particles are likely viruses.     

Assessment of factors influencing direct enumeration of viruses within estuarine sediments

Accurate enumeration of viruses within environmental samples is critical for investigations of the ecological role of viruses and viral infection within microbial communities. This report evaluates differences in viral and bacterial direct counts between estuarine sediment samples which were either immediately processed onboard ship or frozen at -20 degrees C and later processed. Viral and bacterial abundances were recorded at three stations spanning the length of the Chesapeake Bay in April and June 2003 within three sediment fractions: pore water (PW), whole sediment (WS), and sediment after pore water removal (AP). No significant difference in viral abundance was apparent between extracts from fresh or frozen sediments. In contrast, bacterial abundance was significantly lower in the samples subjected to freezing. Both bacterial and viral abundance showed significant differences between sediment fractions (PW, WS, or AP) regardless of the fresh or frozen status. Although pore water viral abundance has been used in the past as a measurement of viral abundance in sediments, this fraction accounted for only ca. 5% of the total sediment viral abundance across all samples. The effect of refrigerated storage of sediment viral extracts was also examined and showed that, within the first 2 h, viral abundance decreased ca. 30% in formalin-fixed extracts and 66% in unfixed extracts. Finally, the reliability of direct viral enumeration via epifluorescence microscopy was tested by using DNase treatment of WS extractions. These tests indicated that a large fraction (>86%) of the small SYBR gold fluorescing particles are likely viruses.     

Distribution of virus-like Particles in an Oligotrophic Marine Environment (Alboran Sea,Western Mediterranean)

Viruses are abundant in a variety of aquatic environments, often exceeding bacterial abundance by one order of magnitude. In the present study, the spatial distribution of viruses in offshore waters of the Alboran Sea (Western Mediterranean) have been studied to determine the relationships between viruses and host communities in this oligotrophic marine environment. Viral abundance was determined using two methods: (i) epifluorescence light microscopy using the dsDNA binding fluorochrome DAPI, and (ii) direct counts by transmission electron microscopy (TEM). The results obtained were significantly different; the highest viral counts were obtained by mean of TEM analyses. In all the samples tested the number of viruses was exceeded by the bacterial concentrations, with a ratio between viral and bacterial titers varying between 1.4 and 20. VLP (virus-like particle) counts were not significantly correlated (p > 0.001) with chlorophyll a concentration or the abundance of cyanobacteria. However, there was a positive and significant correlation with bacterial abundance (p < 0.001). The analysis of size and morphology of viral particles by TEM and the correlation obtained between the numbers of VLP and bacteria suggest that the majority of the viral particles in the Alboran Sea are bacteriophages. None of the indirect evidence suggested that eukaryotic algae or cyanobacteria were important host organisms in these waters.     

Abundance and diversity of viruses in six Delaware soils

The importance of viruses in marine microbial ecology has been established over the past decade. Specifically, viruses influence bacterial abundance and community composition through lysis and alter bacterial genetic diversity through transduction and lysogenic conversion. By contrast, the abundance and distribution of viruses in soils are almost completely unknown. This study describes the abundance and diversity of autochthonous viruses in six Delaware soils: two agricultural soils, two coastal plain forest soils, and two piedmont forest soils. Viral abundance was measured using epifluorescence microscopy, while viral diversity was assessed from morphological data obtained through transmission electron microscopy. Extracted soil virus communities were dominated by bacteriophages that demonstrated a wide range of capsid diameters (20 nm to 160 nm) and morphologies, including filamentous forms and phages with elongated capsids. The reciprocal Simpson's index suggests that forest soils harbor more diverse assemblages of viruses, particularly in terms of morphological distribution. Repeated extractions of virus-like particles (VLPs) from soils indicated that the initial round of extraction removes approximately 70% of extractable viruses. Higher VLP abundances were observed in forest soils (1.31 x 10(9) to 4.17 x 10(9) g(-1) dry weight) than in agricultural soils (8.7 x 10(8) to 1.1 x 10(9) g(-1) dry weight). Soil VLP abundance was significantly correlated to moisture content (r = 0.988) but not to soil texture. Land use (agricultural or forested) was significantly correlated to both bacterial (r = 0.885) and viral (r = 0.812) abundances, as were soil organic matter and water content. Thus, land use is a significant factor influencing viral abundance and diversity in soils.     

Enumerating viruses by using fluorescence and the nature of the nonviral background fraction

Bulk fluorescence measurements could be a faster and cheaper way of enumerating viruses than epifluorescence microscopy, flow cytometry, or transmission electron microscopy (TEM). However, since viruses are not imaged, the background fluorescence compromises the signal, and we know little about its nature. In this paper the size ranges of nucleotides that fluoresce in the presence of SYBR gold were determined for wastewater and a range of freshwater samples using a differential filtration method. Fluorescence excitation-emission matrices (FEEMs) showed that >70% of the SYBR fluorescence was in the <10-nm size fraction (background) and was not associated with intact viruses. This was confirmed using TEM. The use of FEEMs to develop a fluorescence-based method for counting viruses is an approach that is fundamentally different from the epifluorescence microscopy technique used for enumerating viruses. This high fluorescence background is currently overlooked, yet it has had a most pervasive influence on the development of a simple fluorescence-based method for quantifying viral abundance in water.     

Processing deep-sea particle-rich water samples for fluorescence in situ hybridization: consideration of storage effects, preservation, and sonication

Particles are often regarded as microniches of enhanced microbial production and activities in the pelagic ocean and are vehicles of vertical material transport from the euphotic zone to the deep sea. Fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) can be a useful tool to study the microbial community structures associated with these particles, and thus their ecological significance, yet an appropriate protocol for processing deep-sea particle-rich water samples is lacking. Some sample processing considerations are discussed in the present study, and different combinations of existing procedures for preservation, size fractionation sequential filtration, and sonication were tested in conjunction with FISH. Results from this study show that water samples should be filtered and processed within no more than 10 to 12 h after collection, or else preservation is necessary. The commonly used prefiltration formaldehyde fixation was shown to be inadequate for the rRNA targeted by FISH. However, prefiltration formaldehyde fixation followed by immediate freezing and postfiltration paraformaldehyde fixation yielded highly consistent cell abundance estimates even after 96 days or potentially longer storage. Size fractionation sequential filtration and sonication together enhanced cell abundance estimates by severalfold. Size fractionation sequential filtration effectively separated particle-associated microbial communities from their free-living counterparts, while sonication detached cells from particles or aggregates for more-accurate cell counting using epifluorescence microscopy. Optimization in sonication time is recommended for different specific types of samples. These tested and optimized procedures can be incorporated into a FISH protocol for sampling in deep-sea particle-rich waters.     

Processing Deep-Sea Particle-Rich Water Samples for Fluorescence In Situ Hybridization: Consideration of Storage Effects, Preservation, and Sonication

Particles are often regarded as microniches of enhanced microbial production and activities in the pelagic ocean and are vehicles of vertical material transport from the euphotic zone to the deep sea. Fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) can be a useful tool to study the microbial community structures associated with these particles, and thus their ecological significance, yet an appropriate protocol for processing deep-sea particle-rich water samples is lacking. Some sample processing considerations are discussed in the present study, and different combinations of existing procedures for preservation, size fractionation sequential filtration, and sonication were tested in conjunction with FISH. Results from this study show that water samples should be filtered and processed within no more than 10 to 12 h after collection, or else preservation is necessary. The commonly used prefiltration formaldehyde fixation was shown to be inadequate for the rRNA targeted by FISH. However, prefiltration formaldehyde fixation followed by immediate freezing and postfiltration paraformaldehyde fixation yielded highly consistent cell abundance estimates even after 96 days or potentially longer storage. Size fractionation sequential filtration and sonication together enhanced cell abundance estimates by severalfold. Size fractionation sequential filtration effectively separated particle-associated microbial communities from their free-living counterparts, while sonication detached cells from particles or aggregates for more-accurate cell counting using epifluorescence microscopy. Optimization in sonication time is recommended for different specific types of samples. These tested and optimized procedures can be incorporated into a FISH protocol for sampling in deep-sea particle-rich waters.     

Determination of virus abundance in marine sediments

In this study, we optimized procedures to enumerate viruses from marine sediments by epifluorescence microscopy using SYBR Green I as a stain. The highest virus yields from the bulk of the sediments were obtained by utilizing pyrophosphate and 3 min of sonication. The efficiency of extraction benthic viruses by pyrophosphate-ultrasound treatment was about 60% of the extractable virus particles. Samples treated with nucleases had increased virus counts, suggesting a masking effect of extracellular DNA. No significant differences were observed between virus counts obtained by epifluorescence microscopy and transmission electron microscopy. Both formaldehyde and glutaraldehyde gave significant reductions of virus counts after only 24 h of sediment storage, but no further loss occurred after 7 days.     

Determination of Virus Abundance in Marine Sediments

In this study, we optimized procedures to enumerate viruses from marine sediments by epifluorescence microscopy using SYBR Green I as a stain. The highest virus yields from the bulk of the sediments were obtained by utilizing pyrophosphate and 3 min of sonication. The efficiency of extraction benthic viruses by pyrophosphate-ultrasound treatment was about 60% of the extractable virus particles. Samples treated with nucleases had increased virus counts, suggesting a masking effect of extracellular DNA. No significant differences were observed between virus counts obtained by epifluorescence microscopy and transmission electron microscopy. Both formaldehyde and glutaraldehyde gave significant reductions of virus counts after only 24 h of sediment storage, but no further loss occurred after 7 days.     

Abundance of Viruses in Marine Waters: Assessment by Epifluorescence and Transmission Electron Microscopy

Abundance of bacteria and tiny DNA-associated particles in the upper layer of Japanese coastal and offshore waters was evaluated by epifluorescence microscopy with 0.015-μm-pore-size Nuclepore filters. The number of tiny DNA-associated particles was compared with the abundance of virus particles estimated by transmission electron microscopy. Although a large variation in virus abundance (1.2 × 10⁶ to 35 × 10⁶ ml⁻¹) was obtained with the transmission electron microscopy method, the ratio of 4′,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole-reactive tiny particles to viruses was in a rather narrow range (1.0 to 1.6), indicating that the majority of the tiny DNA-associated particles identified by epifluorescence microscopy were actually virus particles. This result implies the possibility of using epifluorescence microscopy for the evaluation of virus abundance in marine environments.     

Effects of sodium azide on the abundance of prokaryotes and viruses in marine samples

Flow cytometry is set to become the standard method for enumerating prokaryotes and viruses in marine samples. However, the samples need to be flash-frozen in liquid nitrogen directly after aldehyde fixation. Because liquid nitrogen may not always be available, we tested the potential of sodium azide as a preservative for prokaryotes and viruses in marine samples as a possible alternative. For that we conducted incubation experiments with untreated and sodium azide treated marine water samples at 4°C and room temperature. The data indicate that sodium azide cannot be used to maintain marine samples used for the enumeration of prokaryotes and viruses.