The effects of phosphate and electron transport on the carbonyl cyanide m-chlorophenylhydrazone-induced ATPase of rat-liver mitochondria

1. The effects of phosphate and electron transport on the ATPase induced in ratliver mitochondria by the uncoupler carbonyl cyanide m-chlorophenylhydrazone have been measured at different uncoupler concentrations and compared with those of ATP, oligomycin and aurovertin.

2. The inhibitory action of respiratory-chain inhibitors on the ATPase activity, which is independent of the actual inhibitor used, is greatly delayed or prevented by the presence of uncoupler, and, in the case of rotenone, can be reversed completely by the subsequent addition of succinate (in the absence of uncoupler). These results can be explained on the basis of the proposal previously made by others that coupled electron transfer causes a structural change in the ATPase complex that results in a decreased affinity of the ATPase inhibitor for the mitochondrial ATPase.

3. Inorganic phosphate specifically stimulates the ATPase activity at high uncoupler concentrations (> 0.2 μM), but has no effect at low concentrations. The stimulation is prevented or abolished by sufficiently high concentrations of aurovertin.

4. Aurovertin prevents the inhibition of the uncoupler-induced ATPase by high uncoupler concentrations.

5. It is proposed that the steady-state concentration of endogenous P_i may be an important regulator of the turnover of the ATPase in intact mitochondria and that the inhibition of ATPase activity by high concentrations of uncoupler is at least partially mediated via changes in the concentration of endogenous P_i.     

The interaction of glucagon treatment and uncoupler concentration on ATPase activity of rat liver mitochondria

Mitochondria isolated from livers of rats treated briefly with glucagon show an increased ATPase activity in the presence of appropriate concentrations of protonophoric uncouplers (Yamazaki, R. K., Sax, R.D., and Hauser, M.A. (1977) FEBS Lett. 75, 295-299). With the uncoupler carbonyl cyanide p-trifluoromethoxyphenylhydrazone (FCCP) the effect of glucagon treatment was most evident at concentrations of uncoupler higher than required for maximal stimulation of ATPase in control mitochondria. In this range of FCCP concentrations that produced the greatest contrast in ATPase activity of control and hormone-stimulated mitochondria, there were no significant differences in delta pH, delta psi, or delta p between the two groups. The presence of added succinate in the ATPase assay system mimicked the effect of glucagon treatment, permitting greater activity at high concentrations of uncoupler without significantly affecting delta p. No significant effect of glucagon treatment or uncoupler concentrations on mitochondrial volumes was observed. Following treatment with glucagon, the mitochondria retained a greater content of Mg+ and K+ throughout the range of FCCP concentrations tested. In the upper range of FCCP concentrations there was appreciable loss of K+ from the mitochondria which was greater in control mitochondria than in mitochondria from glucagon-treated rats or in mitochondria assayed in the presence of succinate. The activity of the uncoupler-dependent ATPase was greatly stimulated by increased concentrations of potassium chloride in the assay medium without significantly diminishing the hormone effect. It is proposed that the intrinsic peptide inhibitor of ATPase is dissociated from the enzyme to an increased degree following glucagon treatment and that high levels of uncoupler inhibit by causing an increased association of the enzyme and its inhibitor.     

Influence of adenine nucleotides on oligomycin inhibition of energy-transducing reactions in intact rat-liver mitochondria.

The inhibitory effect of oligomycin was investigated in intact mitochondria through oxidative phosphorylation and uncoupler induced ATPase activity. Results show that oligomycin inhibition curves can be either sigmoidal or hyperbolic depending on experimental conditions and chiefly on the metabolic state of mitochondria with regard to the distribution of mitochondrial endogenous adenine-nucleotides. Active respiration and uncoupler-induced ATPse activity produce sigmoidal titration curves for a high initial ATP : ADP ratio and hyperbolic curves for a low ATP : ADP ratio. Time-dependent inhibitions are observed for the two reactions. The maximal inhibitory action for low concentrations of the inhibitor is delayed by the initial presence of ATP or the possibility of generating from inorganic phosphate before adding oligomycin. Results presented here show that the initial adenine-nucleotide distribution is important for oligomycin sensitivity of energy-linked reactions. Although a limited conformational change of the oligomycin-sensitivity to the inhibitor, it is more likely that a gross structural change of the inner membrane induced by adenine-nucleotides modifies membrane permeability to oligomycin.     

The binding of aurovertin to mitochondria, and its effect on mitochondrial respiration

1. The fluorescence of aurovertin increases about 100-fold on binding to sub-mitochondrial particles.

2. The mitochondrial ATPase (F₁) binds one mole aurovertin/mole F₁ with a dissociation constant of 6·10⁻⁸ M.

3. The fluorescence of mitochondrion-bound aurovertin is maximal during State-3 respiration and is partially quenched on anaerobiosis, addition of respiratory inhibitor, oligomycin or uncoupler, or transition to State 4. This quenching is still present when the binding site is saturated with aurovertin, showing that the quantum yield of fluorescence is lowered.

4. Aurovertin is bound co-operatively to State-3 mitochondria.

5. The curve relating inhibition of State-3 respiration to aurovertin concentration is more sharply sigmoidal than the binding curve.

6. An analysis of the binding and inhibition data leads to the conclusion that aurovertin induces a conformation change in the binding site on F₁ in two ways: (i) directly by acting as an allosteric effector of an oligomeric system, (ii) indirectly by inhibiting State-3 respiration which changes the allosteric constant of the oligomeric system.

7. The concentration of the aurovertin-binding site in both rat-liver and rat-heart mitochondria is about the same as that of the antimycin-binding and oligomycin-binding sites.     

Crystal violet as an uncoupler of oxidative phosphorylation in rat liver mitochondria

Crystal violet exhibited characteristics of an uncoupler of oxidative phosphorylation, i.e. it released respiratory control, hindered ATP synthesis, enhanced ATPase activity, and produced swelling of isolated rat liver mitochondria. Maximal stimulation of respiration, ATPase activity, and swelling was observed at a concentration of 40 microM. The inhibition of State 3 respiration by oligomycin was released by crystal violet. High concentrations of crystal violet inhibited mitochondrial respiration. The uncoupling effect of crystal violet required inorganic phosphate and was abolished by N-ethylmaleimide. The adenine nucleotides ADP and ATP protected mitochondria from uncoupling by the dye. The dye taken up by mitochondria was released into the incubation medium on induction of uncoupling. In the absence of phosphate, the dye did not cause uncoupling, but its retention was much greater than in the presence of phosphate. Crystal violet is suggested to induce uncoupling by acting on the membrane, rather than by its electrophoretic transfer into the mitochondria.     

The equilibrium between the mitochondrial ATPase (F1) and its natural inhibitor in submitochondrial particles

1. The reversible equilibrium between the mitochondrial ATPase (F₁) and its naturally occurring inhibitor in Mg-ATP submitochondrial particles has been studied under different conditions.2. High ionic strength favours dissociation of the ATPase inhibitor as tested by ATPase and ATP-driven transhydrogenase activities.3. Dissociation of the ATPase inhibitor results in an increased maximal velocity of the ATPase activity measured in the presence of uncoupler and an increased affinity for adenine nucleotides, in particular for ATP.4. Association of the ATPase inhibitor with inhibitor-depleted Mg-ATP particles causes a slowing of the initial rate of succinate oxidation.5. The antibiotic aurovertin stimulates the ATPase activity of Mg-ATP particles preinculbated in the presence of a supply of oxidative energy. Bound aurovertin impedes the association of inhibitor-deficient particles with ATPase inhibitor.6. The fluorescence of aurovertin bound to inhibitor-containing particles is much less than that of aurovertin bound to inhibitor-depleted particles.7. The oligomycin-sensitivity-conferring protein, added either alone or in the presence or absence of membranous components of the ATPase complex, has little or no effect on the fluorescence of the F₁-aurovertin complex.8. It is suggested that the ATPase inhibitor brings F₁ in a conformation denoted 1F₁ that binds aurovertin with a low quantum yield, a decreased affinity and an increased binding capacity.     

The effect of DDT and related insecticides on the mitochondrial ATPase of houseflies

1. DDT is a weak inhibitor of the ATPase of housefly muscle mitochondria in the absence of Mg2+ but an activator in the presence of Mg2+. 2. By contrast, DDT and several p,p'-substituted alpha-trichlomethylbenzylanilines were strong inhibitors of the ATPase activity in the presence of the uncoupler, dinitrophenol. 3. Maximum inhibition of the DNP-ATPase was achieved when the ATPase complex was dissociated from its endogenous protein inhibitor. 4. The inhibition by DDT was noncompetitive, maximum at acid pH and independent of temperature. The inhibition was counteracted by exogenous phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylethanolamine. 5. The ATPase was also activated by NH+4 in the presence of valinomycin. This activation was reversed by K+ and strongly inhibited by DDT. 6. The possible mechanisms involved in the inhibition by DDT are discussed.     

Kinetics of ATP synthesis in pea cotyledon submitochondrial particles

A kinetic study of oxidative phosphorylation by pea submitochondrial particles gave two K_m values for ADP, one low, the other high. The high value probably reflected a damaged site or a population of leaky mitochondria. Only the high affinity site with a low K_m for ADP was involved in ATP synthesis. α,β-Methylene ADP was found to be a competitive inhibitor of ATP synthesis. The inorganic phosphate analog, thiophosphate, decreased the apparent K_m of ADP while the rate of the reaction remained approximately the same. Adenyl imidodiphosphate, a specific inhibitor of ATP hydrolysis activity, had little effect on oxidative phosphorylation. A slight decrease in the K_m of the high affinity binding site for ADP was noted. Aurovertin was found to be a potent inhibitor of oxidative phosphorylation in pea submitochondrial particles. The K_m of the high affinity site was increased 10-fold. Also, the inhibition normally exerted by ADP on ATPase activity was severely reduced by aurovertin. In contrast, increasing the concentration of aurovertin only slightly affected the level of inhibition caused by adenyl imidodiphosphate on ATP hydrolysis.     

Cell-free synthesis of mitochondrial ATPase inhibitor precursor and its transport into yeast mitochondria

ATPase inhibitor protein, which blocks mitochondrial ATPase activity by forming an enzyme-inhibitor complex, was found to be synthesized as a larger precursor in a cell-free translation system directed by yeast mRNA. Other protein factors, which stabilize latent ATPase by binding to the enzyme-inhibitor complex, were also found to be formed as larger precursors. The precursor of ATPase inhibitor protein was transported into isolated yeast mitochondria and was cleaved to the mature peptide in the mitochondria. Impaired mitochondria lacking phosphorylation activity could not convert the precursor to the mature form. Neither antimycin A nor oligomycin alone exhibited a marked effect on the transport-processing of the precursor by intact mitochondria. However, when antimycin A was added with oligomycin, the transport-processing was markedly inhibited. The processing was also strongly inhibited by an uncoupler, carbonylcyanide p-trifluoro-methoxyphenyl hydrazone. The inhibition by the uncoupler was not relieved by ATP added externally. It is concluded that the transport-processing of precursor proteins requires intact mitochondria with a potential difference across the inner membrane.     

A general characteristic of tumor mitochondria: Leakage of endogenous Mg2+ on incubation with uncoupler and resultant reduction of uncoupler-stimulated ATPase activity

Previous studies showed that stimulation of mouse mitochondrial ATPase activity of tumor cells, fetal liver, and adult brain by the uncoupler 2,4-dinitrophenol was markedly suppressed during incubation of the mitochondria with the uncoupler (J.-I. Hayashi et al., 1980, Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun.92, 261–267). The present work showed the reason for this suppression. More than half the endogenous Mg²⁺ leaked from mitochondria of all tumor cells tested, and of fetal liver and adult brain during incubation with the uncoupler, while only about 30% of the endogenous Mg²⁺ leaked from mitochondria of other normal tissues. The effect of the uncoupler on Mg²⁺ leakage from liver mitochondria changed from the fetal to the adult type within about 30 min after birth. In hypotonic medium, normal liver mitochondria also lost more than half their total Mg²⁺ and concomitantly stimulation of their ATPase activity by uncoupler was considerably reduced. Exogenously added Mg²⁺ could reverse this reduced effect of the uncoupler on ATPase activity of mitochondria from normal tissues and tumor cells. These results show that the endogenous Mg²⁺ content of mitochondria directly affects the stimulation by uncoupler of ATPase activity of mitochondria from both normal tissues and tumor cells. Thus, mitochondria of all tumor cells tested, and of fetal liver and adult brain are leaky to Mg²⁺ during incubation with uncoupler and as a result of the leakage, the stimulatory effect of the uncoupler on their ATPase activity is greatly reduced.     

The native mitochondrial F1-inhibitor protein complex carries out uni- and multisite ATP hydrolysis

The rate of ATP hydrolysis under multi- and unisite conditions was determined in the native F1-inhibitor protein complex of bovine heart mitochondria (Adolfsen, R., MacClung, J.A., and Moudrianakis, E.N. (1975) Biochemistry 14, 1727-1735). Aurovertin was used to distinguish between hydrolytic activity catalyzed by the F1-ATPase or the F1-inhibitor protein (F1.I) complex. We found that incubation of aurovertin with the F1.I complex, prior to the addition of substrate, results in a stimulation of the hydrolytic activity from 1 to 8-10 mumol min-1 mg-1. The addition of aurovertin to a F1.I complex simultaneously with ATP results in a 30% inhibition with respect to the untreated F1.I. In contrast, if the F1.I complex is activated up to a hydrolytic activity of 80 mumol min-1 mg-1, aurovertin inhibits the enzyme in a manner similar to that described for F1-ATPase devoid of the inhibitor protein. The native F1.I complex catalyzes the hydrolysis of ATP under conditions for single catalytic site, liberating 0.16-0.18 mol of Pi/mol of enzyme. Preincubation with aurovertin before the addition of substrate had no effect under these conditions. On the other hand, if the F1.I ATPase was allowed to hydrolyze ATP at a single catalytic site, catalysis was inhibited by 98% by aurovertin. In F1-ATPase, the hydrolysis of [gamma-32P]ATP bound to the first catalytic site is promoted by the addition of excess ATP, in the presence or absence of aurovertin. Under conditions for single site catalysis, hydrolysis of [gamma-32P]ATP in the F1.I complex was not promoted by excess ATP. We conclude that the endogenous inhibitor protein regulates catalysis by promoting the entrapment of adenine nucleotides at the high affinity catalytic site, thus hindering cooperative ATP hydrolysis.     

Mechanistic basis for differential inhibition of the F1Fo‐ATPase by aurovertin

The mitochondrial F₁F_o‐ATPase performs the terminal step of oxidative phosphorylation. Small molecules that modulate this enzyme have been invaluable in helping decipher F₁F_o‐ATPase structure, function, and mechanism. Aurovertin is an antibiotic that binds to the β subunits in the F₁ domain and inhibits F₁F_o‐ATPase‐catalyzed ATP synthesis in preference to ATP hydrolysis. Despite extensive study and the existence of crystallographic data, the molecular basis of the differential inhibition and kinetic mechanism of inhibition of ATP synthesis by aurovertin has not been resolved. To address these questions, we conducted a series of experiments in both bovine heart mitochondria and E. coli membrane F₁F_o‐ATPase. Aurovertin is a mixed, noncompetitive inhibitor of both ATP hydrolysis and synthesis with lower K_i values for synthesis. At low substrate concentrations, inhibition is cooperative suggesting a stoichiometry of two aurovertin per F₁F_o‐ATPase. Furthermore, aurovertin does not completely inhibit the ATP hydrolytic activity at saturating concentrations. Single‐molecule experiments provide evidence that the residual rate of ATP hydrolysis seen in the presence of saturating concentrations of aurovertin results from a decrease in the binding change mechanism by hindering catalytic site interactions. The results from these studies should further the understanding of how the F₁F_o‐ATPase catalyzes ATP synthesis and hydrolysis. © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Biopolymers 91: 830–840, 2009. This article was originally published online as an accepted preprint. The “Published Online” date corresponds to the preprint version. You can request a copy of the preprint by emailing the Biopolymers editorial office at biopolymers@wiley.com     

Studies on the structure and conformation of yeast mitochondrial ATPase using aurovertin and methanol as probes

1. The isolation of the mitochondrial ATPase F1 and its beta-subunit from commercial baker's yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) is described. 2. The molecular weight determined by ultracentrifugation is 340000 +/- 30000. Gel chromatography indicates a molecular weight of 300000 +/- 20000. 3. Fluorimetric titration of the isolated enzyme with aurovertin reveals two binding sites per molecule. The isolated beta-subunit binds aurovertin in a 1 : 1 stoicheiometry. It is concluded that the ATPase molecule contains two aurovertin-binding beta-subunits. 4. The stabilizing agent methanol influences both the measured Kd and the concentration of binding sites for aurovertin. These results fit a model in which both F1 and aurovertin are distributed between aqueous and methanol phases. 5. The effect of methanol on the ATPase activity can be described in terms of the model proposed by Recktenwald and Hess (Recktenwald, D. and Hess, B. (1977) FEBS Lett. 76, 25-28). It is proposed that methanol enhances the affinity of the regulatory site for ATP, but at higher concentrations prevents the interaction between the regulatory and catalytic sites. 6. Since HSO(-3), a typical effector of the assumed regulatory site of F1, has no effect on the binding of aurovertin, it is concluded that the binding site of aurovertin is not correlated with the regulatory site. 7. The inhibition of ATPase activity by aurovertin is slowly (t 1/2 = 70 s) induced during turnover conditions. 8. From the effect of methanol on the inhibition of ATPase activity by aurovertin it is concluded that under turnover conditions the conformation is such that the aurovertin-binding sites have a 6-fold higher affinity for methanol than under resting conditions.     

Control of adenine nucleotide metabolism in hepatic mitochondria from rats with ethanol-induced fatty liver

Male rats developed fatty liver after being fed on an ethanol-containing diet for 31 days. Liver mitochondria from these animals catalysed ATP synthesis at a slower rate when compared with mitochondria from pair-fed control rats (control mitochondria), and demonstrated lowered respiratory control with succinate as substrate, owing to a decrease in the State-3 respiratory rate. Respiration in the presence of uncoupler was comparable in mitochondria from both groups of rats. Translocation of both ATP and ADP was decreased in mitochondria from ethanol-fed rats, with ADP uptake being lowered more dramatically by ethanol feeding. Parameters influencing adenine nucleotide translocation were investigated in mitochondria from ethanol-fed rats. Experiments performed suggested that lowered adenine nucleotide translocation in these mitochondria is not the result of inhibition of the translocase by either long-chain acyl-CoA derivatives or unesterified fatty acids. Analysis of endogenous adenine nucleotides in these mitochondria revealed lowered ATP concentrations, but no decrease in total adenine nucleotides. In experiments where the endogenous ATP in these mitochondria was shifted to higher concentrations by incubation with oxidizable substrates or defatted bovine serum albumin, the rate of ADP translocation was increased, with a linear correlation being observed between endogenous ATP concentrations and the rate of ADP translocation. The depressed ATP concentration in mitochondria from ethanol-fed rats suggests that the ATP synthetase complex is replenishing endogenous ATP at a slower rate. The lowered ATPase activity of the ATP synthetase observed in submitochondrial particles from ethanol-fed animals suggests a decrease in the function of the synthetase complex. A decrease in the rate of ATP synthesis in mitochondria from ethanol-fed rats is sufficient to explain the decreased ADP translocation and State-3 respiration.     

Adenosine triphosphatase of rat liver mitochondria: detergent solubilization of an oligomycin- and dicyclohexylcarbodiimide-sensitive form of the enzyme.

The hydrolytic activity of the ATPase bound to purified inner membrane vesicles of rat liver mitochondria can be increased threefold by washing extensively with a high ionic strength phosphate buffer. The specific ATPase activities of such phosphate-washed membranes are the highest reported to date for a mitochondrial membrane preparation (21-24 mumol of ATP hydrolyzed min-1 mg-1 in bicarbonate buffer at 37 degrees C). Deoxycholate (0.1 mg/mg of protein) extracts from these membranes a soluble, cold-stable ATPase complex which exhibits a specific activity under optimal assay conditions of 12 mumol of ATP hydrolyzed min-1 mg-1. This complex is not sedimented by centrifugation at 201000 g for 90 min, and readily passes through a 250-A Millipore filter. The ATPase activity of the soluble complex is inhibited 95% by 2.4 muM oligomycin. In addition, inhibitions of 60% or better are obtained in the presence of 1-8 muM dicyclohexylcarbodiimide, p-chloromercuribenzoate, venturicidin, and aurovertin. While a similar complex may be extracted with Triton X-100 this preparation is always lower in both specific activity and in inhibitor sensitivities than the complex extracted with deoxycholate. Detergents of the Tween and Brij series and other detergents of the Triton series are also much less effective than deoxycholate in solubilizing the oligomycin-sensitive. ATPase complex of rat liver. It is concluded that deoxycholate is superior to other detergents as an extractant of the oligomycin-sensitive ATPase complex of rat liver mitochondria, and that the complex extracted with deoxycholate possesses a closer similarity to the membrane-associated ATPase than does the complex extracted with Triton X-100. These studies document the first report of a detergent-solubilized, oligomycin-sensitive ATPase preparation from rat liver mitochondria.     

Effects of oligomycins on adenosine triphosphatase activity of mitochondria isolated from the yeasts Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Schwanniomyces castellii

Functional mitochondria with respiratory control were isolated from the yeasts Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Schwanniomyces castellii. The presence of site I in Schw. castellii was indicated by higher ADP/O ratio than in S. cerevisiae where this site is absent. The ATPase Vmax was higher in S. cerevisiae than in Schw. castellii mitochondria. The latter was increased by the DR12 nuclear mutation. Nevertheless, the stimulation by heat and the inhibition profile of oligomycins on mitochondrial F1-F0 ATPase activities were similar in all three tested strains. In S. cerevisiae and Schw. castelli wild type or mutant mitochondria, the well-known inhibition of F1-F0 ATPase activity by low concentrations of oligomycins is abolished at high inhibitor concentrations near 60microg/ml suggesting uncoupling of F1 activity. At still higher oligomycin concentration the ATPase activity of both species and mutant is again strongly inhibited, suggesting an inhibitory effect on yeast F1 activity not detected so far.     

The Inhibitory Effect of 3-Nitropropionate on the Oxidative Phosphorylation in Rat Mitochondria

The effect of 3-nitropropionate (3-NPA)on oxidative phosphorylation by using mitochondria prepared from both rat liver and brain were investigated in connection with the toxicity of this material. It was found that 3-NPA inhibited oxidative phosphorylation. In this inhibition, the uptake of inorganic phosphate was blocked but the oxygen uptake was not influenced at all. Furthermore, increase in ATPase activity of intact mitochondria was shown by the addition of 3-NPA. Results showed that 3-NPA disturbed oxidative phosphorylation as an uncoupler. However, the degree of inhibition by 3-NPA was not so high in comparison with other well-known uncouplers.

Thus the toxicity of 3-NPA is not due to the inhibition of oxidative phosphorylation. 3-NPA also does not affect on cytochrome oxidase activity.     

Uncoupling of mitochondrial respiration by ADP

Even when oxidative phosphorylation is blocked completely by addition of high concentrations of oligomycin plus aurovertin, the addition of ADP to a suspension of mitochondria containing a high concentration of ATP inside the mitochondria induces a stimulation of respiration and oxidation of nicotinamide nucleotide.It is concluded that transport of ADP into mitochondria with a high endogenous ATP/ADP ratio requires energy.     

Specific properties of brown adipose tissue mitochondrial membrane.

1. Mitochondrial membrane of brown adipose tissue compared to that of liver possesses a very high activity of oxidative enzymes but a low activity of ATPase. 2. The polypeptide composition of the mitochondrial membranes proves that the above differences in enzyme activities are due to increased content of oxidative enzymes and decreased content of ATPase in brown adipose tissue. 3. The inhibition of ATPase of brown adipose tissue mitochondria by aurovertin, oligomycin and DCCD indicates modified proportions between the components of the ATPase complex. 4. The organization of brown adipose tissue mitochondrial membrane in relation to its thermogenic function is discussed.     

The Respiratory Chain of Plant Mitochondria: XI. Electron Transport from Succinate to Endogenous Pyridine Nucleotide in Mung Bean Mitochondria

Energy-linked reverse electron transport from succinate to endogenous NAD in tightly coupled mung bean (Phaseolus aureus) mitochondria may be driven by ATP if the two terminal oxidases of these mitochondria are inhibited, or may be driven by the free energy of succinate oxidation. This reaction is specific to the first site of energy conservation of the respiratory chain; it does not occur in the presence of uncoupler. If mung bean mitochondria become anaerobic during oxidation of succinate, their endogenous NAD becomes reduced in the presence of uncoupler, provided that both inorganic phosphate (P_i) and ATP are present. No reduction occurs in the absence of P_i, even in the presence of ATP added to provide a high phosphate potential. If fluorooxaloacetate is present in the uncoupled, aerobic steady state, no reduction of endogenous NAD occurs on anaerobiosis; this compound is an inhibitor of malate dehydrogenase. This result implies that endogenous NAD is reduced by malate formed from the fumarate generated during succinate oxidation. The source of free energy is most probably the endogenous energy stores in the form of acetyl CoA, or intermediates convertible to acetyl CoA, which removes the oxaloacetate formed from malate, thus driving the reaction towards reduction of NAD.