Particle size influence in an impaction bone grafting model. Comparison of fresh-frozen and freeze-dried allografts

BackgroundImpaction bone grafting with large particles is considered as mechanically superior to smaller morsels. Interest of freeze-dried irradiated bone for impaction bone grafting has been observed with small particles. Influence of bone process on other particle sizes still needed to be assessed.Material and methodsTwenty-four osteoarthrotic femoral heads were used to prepare fresh-frozen and freeze-dried irradiated cancellous bone. Each group was divided into four batches of different particle sizes, each batch containing 18 samples. The different particle sizes were obtained with a Retsch Cross Beater Mill SK 100, Noviomagus rotating bone mills with two sizes of rasps and a Luer bone rongeur. Bone grafts were impacted in a contained cylinder. Stiffness was monitored during impaction.ResultsFreeze-dried irradiated grafts showed higher stiffness than fresh-frozen bone whatever the size of the particles. Large particles obtained with the rongeur and the large rasp from the Noviomagus bone mill were mechanically superior than small particles up to 30 impactions.InterpretationLarge particles offer better mechanical performance as a greater magnitude of force would be required to deform and break the particles. Freeze-dried irradiated bone brittleness reduces this advantage after 30 impactions. Large particles embrittlement leads to similar mechanical results as small particles at higher impaction rate. This may account for partial collapse of the graft layer in clinical situation when impaction rate is lower. This model supports the use of small particles obtained with thin rasp bone mill when freeze-dried irradiated bone for impaction bone grafting and large particles obtained with the Rongeur when fresh-frozen bone is available.     

Fresh-frozen human bone allograft in vertical ridge augmentation: clinical and tomographic evaluation of bone formation and resorption

The aim of the current study is to evaluate fresh-frozen human bone allografts (FHBAs) used in vertical ridge augmentation clinically and by computed tomography, and to analyze the resulting bone formation and graft resorption. Sixteen FHBAs were grafted in the maxillae and mandibles of 9 patients. The FHBAs, which were provided by the Musculoskeletal Tissue Bank of Marilia Hospital (Unioss), were frozen at -80°C. After 7?months, dental implants were placed and bone parameters were evaluated. Vertical bone formation was measured by computerized tomography before (T0) and at 7?months (T1) after the surgical procedure. Bone graft resorption was measured clinically from a landmark screw head using a periodontal probe. The results were analyzed by Student's t-test. Significant differences existed in the bone formation values at T0 and T1, with an average change of 4.03?±?1.69?mm. Bone graft resorption values were 1.0?±?0.82?mm (20%). Implants were placed with varying insertion torque values (35-45?Ncm), and achieved primary stability. This study demonstrates that FHBAs promote satisfactory vertical bone formation with a low resorption rates, good density, and primary implant stability.     

Designs from the deep: marine organisms for bone tissue engineering

Current strategies for bone repair have accepted limitations and the search for synthetic graft materials or for scaffolds that will support ex vivo bone tissue engineering continues. Biomimetic strategies have led to the investigation of naturally occurring porous structures as templates for bone growth. The marine environment is rich in mineralizing organisms with porous structures, some of which are currently being used as bone graft materials and others that are in early stages of development. This review describes the current evidence available for these organisms, considers the relative promise of each and suggests potential future directions.     

DEXA对骨髓炎骨缺损治疗中骨痂密度的评价

目的：探讨DEXA对骨髓炎骨缺损治疗中骨痂密度的评价及意义。方法：严格按照纳入排除标准,选取21例骨髓炎清创后伴大段皮质骨缺损一期植骨的病人。术后4,6,8,10个月后对骨折端骨痂行双能X线骨密度仪检测,并进行X摄片以及Enneking评分,从而明确植骨区愈合骨痂的密度变化趋势,骨愈合情况以及症状改善情况。结果：（1）X线摄片结果显示：4个月后：骨缺损区依然清晰可见,内有少量稀疏骨痂通过,少量外骨痂形成。6个月后：植骨区内骨痂含量明显增多,且外骨痂膨大。8个月：缺损区模糊,有较致密骨痂生成,且外骨痂逐渐减少。10个月：植骨区骨痂更加致密,且部份髓腔再通。（2）Enneking评分：患者术后第10个月功能恢复情况评估正常功能20例,20分以下的患者1例。（3）BMD测定：骨折端的骨密度及骨密度比率随时间延长而增加,植骨10个月后患侧的骨密度已可基本上达到正常对照侧的骨密度水平。结论：双能X线骨密度测量从一定程度上反映出骨痂的力学强度特性。在感染性骨缺损治疗中可以作为检测植骨区的恢复情况的参考。     

A new transplant bone for maxillary alveolar cleft

An innovative technique with distraction osteogenesis has been developed in our research group to explore autogenous bone transplantation into craniofacial bone defects. This technique was designed to investigate bone-marrow transplantion using a chondroid or fibula bone graft into simulated alveolar bone defects in mice in terms of the osteogenic process and activity. As an experimental model of maxillary alveolar bone cleft available for testing bone-inductive materials, a critical-size defect was formed in the pre-maxillary bone of male mice using a surgical trephine bur with a low-speed dental engine. Distraction osteogenesis was performed using an external fixation device. The osteotomy site was occupied by an external callus consisting of hyaline cartilage with a large quantity of chondroid bone. Moreover, bone remodelling with new bone formation was demonstrated 30 days after the transplantation. Bone adhesion was better in chondroid bone grafting than in fibula bone grafting. The present findings are the first to demonstrate the potential of chondroid bone transplantation as a new therapeutic system of bone grafting, suitable for bone substitutes in craniofacial bone defects.     

椎间植骨粒体积对腰椎滑脱融合内固定术融合效果的影响

目的:探讨在腰椎后路植骨融合手术中,椎间植骨粒的体积对手术效果的影响。方法:回顾性分析我院2012年5月-2013年9月采用腰椎后路植骨融合术的75例患者的临床资料,根据患者手术中椎间植骨粒体积不同分为A组(小体积组,5粒/cm3)、B组(中体积组,11粒/cm3)以及C组(大体积组,23粒/cm3)。分析三组患者的植骨粒体积、植骨融合率以及手术效果。结果:三组患者植骨粒体积比较,差异具有统计学意义(P0.05);椎间植骨总体积比较,差异无统计学意义(P0.05)。与术前比较,三组术后ODI指数及VAS评分明显下降,差异具有统计学意义(P0.05);但三组间比较,差异无统计学意义(P0.05)。B组植骨融合率高于A组及C组,而A组高于C组,组间比较,差异均具有统计学意义(P0.05)。手术后各组椎体滑脱程度与术前相比得到明显改善(P0.05)。结论:腰椎滑脱内固定术中应用中等体积植骨粒可明显提高椎体间融合率。     

Reliable simulations of the human proximal femur by high-order finite element analysis validated by experimental observations

Background: The mechanical response of patient-specific bone to various load conditions is of major clinical importance in orthopedics. Herein we enhance the methods presented in Yosibash et al. [2007. A CT-based high-order finite element analysis of the human proximal femur compared to in-vitro experiments. ASME Journal of Biomechanical Engineering 129(3), 297–309.] for the reliable simulations of the human proximal femur by high-order finite elements (FEs) and validate the simulations by experimental observations.

Method of approach: A fresh-frozen human femur was scanned by quantitative computed tomography (QCT) and thereafter loaded (in vitro experiments) by a quasi-static force of up to 1250 N. QCT scans were manipulated to generate a high-order FE bone model with distinct cortical and trabecular regions having inhomogeneous isotropic elastic properties with Young's modulus represented by continuous spatial functions. Sensitivity analyses were performed to quantify parameters that mostly influence the mechanical response. FE results were compared to displacements and strains measured in the experiments.

Results: Young moduli correlated to QCT Hounsfield Units by relations in Keyak and Falkinstein [2003. Comparison of in situ and in vitro CT scan-based finite element model predictions of proximal femoral fracture load. Medical Engineering and Physics 25, 781–787.] were found to provide predictions that match the experimental results closely. Excellent agreement was found for both the displacements and strains. The presented study demonstrates that reliable and validated high-order patient-specific FE simulations of human femurs based on QCT data are achievable for clinical computer-aided decision making.     

椎弓根内固定联合椎体间植骨融合术治疗退行性腰椎滑脱症的临床探讨

目的:探讨椎弓根内固定联合椎体间植骨融合术治疗退行性腰椎滑脱症的临床效果。方法:回顾性分析我院2012年3月至2014年3月收治的30例采用椎弓根内固定联合椎体间植骨融合术治疗的退行性腰椎滑脱症患者临床资料,观察患者对手术效果的满意度,并对症状进行JOA评分。比较患者术前术后的腰椎X线的影像学变化,观察术后临近节段的退变发生率与影像的融合率。结果:术后随访1-3年发现患者JOA评分的平均改善率为(73.81±16.12)%,术后滑脱率与椎间高度均有明显改善,与术前比较差异具有统计学意义(P0.05)。术后影像学显示植骨融合A级15例,B级12例,C级3例,融合优良率为90%。结论:椎弓根内固定联合椎体间植骨融合术对退行性腰椎滑脱症具有显著的临床效果,不仅可以缓解疼痛,改善功能评分,而且使患者影像学变化恢复正常生理形态,是理想的手术方法之一。     

Very long-term radiographic and bone scan results of frozen autograft and allograft bone grafting in 17 patients (20 grafts) a 30- to 35-year follow-up

In the early 1950s, 48 patients received bone implants from a bone bank in Tel-Hashomer Hospital that stored frozen autograft and allograft bones at temperatures less than -17 degrees C. Seventeen (35%) of these patients (20 implants), 10 men and 7 women, with a mean age of 52.4 (34-69) years were available for follow-up after a mean period of 32.5 (30-35) years. They underwent clinical examination, radiographs and bone scans to evaluate their surgical results. Fracture healing, non-union, graft resorption, osteoporosis and bone sclerosis were used as radiographic criteria for bone incorporation, and normal, increased and decreased uptake served to assess the bone scan. Based on the above criteria, the results were satisfactory in 17 (85%) and poor in 3 (15%). The three failures were after shelf operation for hip dysplasia that used two allografts and one autograft. Allogenous or a combination of allogenous with autogenous frozen bone grafts proved to be a satisfactory and durable method for filling bone defects.     

Bone grafts and bone morphogenetic proteins in spine fusion

Spinal fusions are being performed for various pathologies of the spine. Stabilizing vertebral segments by eliminating motion across those segments becomes critical in dealing with pathologies of the spine that lead to instability. The use of autograft has been the gold standard for spine fusion. However, due to complications such as donor site morbidity, increased operating time, and limited supply, the use of allograft as a graft extender has become an acceptable practice especially in fusions spanning multiple segments. The discovery and isolation of novel proteins (i.e., bone morphogenetic proteins, BMPs), which initiate the molecular cascade of bone formation, have experimentally been shown in numerous animal studies to be as effective as autografts. Although the use of BMPs has exciting applications in spine surgery, long-term clinical studies must be evaluated for its efficacy in various applications in humans. The use of biomimetic materials such as hydroxyapatite (HA), or tricalcium phosphate (TCP) has also been examined in several animal models as bone graft substitutes or carriers. Although these materials have shown some promise in specific site applications, more work remains in elucidating an efficacious combination of these materials and BMPs that can be as effective as autografts. This review will present the status of bone grafts, bone morphogenetic proteins, gene therapy, and work that has been done to facilitate spinal fusion and simultaneously eliminate the need for bone graft. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Effects of gamma irradiation on mechanical properties of defatted trabecular bone allografts assessed by speed-of-sound measurement

New sterilization methods for human bone allografts may lead to alterations in bone mechanical properties, which strongly influence short- and medium-term outcomes. In many sterilization procedures, bone allografts are subjected to gamma irradiation, usually with 25 KGy, after treatment and packaging. We used speed-of-sound (SOS) measurements to evaluate the effects of gamma irradiation on bone. All bone specimens were subjected to the same microbial inactivation procedure. They were then separated into three groups, of which one was treated and not irradiated and two were exposed to 10 and 25 KGy of gamma radiation, respectively. SOS was measured using high- and low-frequency ultrasound beams in each orthogonal direction. SOS and Young modulus were altered significantly in the three groups, compared to native untreated bone. Exposure to 10 or 25 KGy had no noticeable effect on the study variables. The impact of irradiation was small compared to the effects of physical or chemical defatting. Reducing the radiation dose used in everyday practice failed to improve graft mechanical properties in this study.     

Effect of bovine fetal growth plate as a new xenograft in experimental bone defect healing: radiological,histopathological and biomechanical evaluation

Bone grafting is used to enhance healing in osteotomies, arthrodesis, and multifragmentary fractures and to replace bony loss resulting from neoplasia or cysts. They are source of osteoprogenitor cells and induce bone formation and provide mechanical support for vascular and bone ingrowth. Autografts are used commonly but quantity of retrieved bone is limit. This study was designed to evaluate autograft and new xenograft (Bovine fetal growth plate) effects on bone healing process. Twenty male White New Zealand rabbits were used in this study. In autograft group the defect was filled by fresh autogenous cortical graft, in xenograft group the defect was filled by a segment of bovine fetal growth plate and was fixed by cercelage wire. Radiological, histopathological and biomechanical evaluations were performed blindly and results scored and analyzed statistically. Statistical tests did not support significant differences between two groups at the 14th and 28th postoperative day radiographically (P > 0.05). There was a significant difference for remodeling at the 42nd postoperative radiologically (P < 0.05). Xenograft was superior to autograft at the 56th postoperative day for radiological bone formation (P < 0.03). Histopathological and biomechanical evaluation revealed no significant differences between two groups. The results of this study indicate that satisfactory healing occurred in rabbit radius defect filled with calf fetal growth plate. Complications were not identified and healing was faster than cortical autogenous grafting. It was concluded that the use of calf fetal growth plate as a new xenograft is an acceptable alternative to cortical autogenous graft and could reduce the morbidity associated with harvesting autogenous graft during surgery.     

Posterolateral spinal fusion with ostegenesis induced BMSC seeded TCP/HA in a sheep model

Autogenous bone graft is the gold standard for fusion procedure. However, pain at donor site and inconsistent outcome have left a surgeon to venture into some other technique for spinal fusion. The objective of this study was to determine whether osteogenesis induced bone marrow stem cells with the combination of ceramics granules (HA or TCP/HA), and fibrin could serve as an alternative to generate spinal fusion. The sheep's bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells (BMSCs) were aspirated form iliac crest and cultured for several passages until confluence. BMSCs were trypsinized and seeded on hydroxyapatite scaffold (HA) and tricalcium phosphate/hydroxyapatite (TCP/HA) for further osteogenic differentiation in the osteogenic medium one week before implantation. Six adult sheep underwent three-level, bilateral, posterolateral intertransverse process fusions at L1–L6. Three fusion sites in each animal were assigned to three treatments: (a) HA constructs group/L1–L2, (b) TCP/HA constructs group/L2–L3, and (c) autogenous bone graft group/L5–L6. The spinal fusion segments were evaluated using radiography, manual palpation, histological analysis and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) 12 weeks post implantation. The TCP/HA constructs achieved superior lumbar intertransverse fusion compared to HA construct but autogenous bone graft still produced the best fusion among all.     

Segmental bone replacement via patient‐specific,three‐dimensional printed bioresorbable graft substitutes and their use as templates for the culture of mesenchymal stem cells under mechanical stimulation at various frequencies

The treatment of large segmental bone defects remains a challenge as infection, delayed union, and nonunion are common postoperative complications. A three‐dimensional printed bioresorbable and physiologically load‐sustaining graft substitute was developed to mimic native bone tissue for segmental bone repair. Fabricated from polylactic acid, this graft substitute is novel as it is readily customizable to accommodate the particular size and location of the segmental bone of the patient to be replaced. Inspired by the structure of the native bone tissue, the graft substitute exhibits a gradient in porosity and pore size in the radial direction and exhibit mechanical properties similar to those of the native bone tissue. The graft substitute can serve as a template for tissue constructs via seeding with stem cells. The biocompatibility of such templates was tested under in vitro conditions using a dynamic culture of human mesenchymal stem cells. The effects of the mechanical loading of cell‐seeded templates under in vitro conditions were assessed via subjecting the tissue constructs to 28 days of daily mechanical stimulation. The frequency of loading was found to have a significant effect on the rate of mineralization, as the alkaline phosphatase activity and calcium deposition were determined to be particularly high at the typical walking frequency of 2 Hz, suggesting that mechanical stimulation plays a significant role in facilitating the healing process of bone defects. Utilization of such patient‐specific and biocompatible graft substitutes, coupled with patient’s bone marrow cells seeded and exposed to mechanical stimulation of 2 Hz have the potential of reducing significant volumes of cadaveric tissue required, improving long‐term graft stability and incorporation, and alleviating financial burdens associated with delayed or failed fusions of long bone defects.     

Interfacial Strength of Cement Lines in Human Cortical Bone

In human cortical bone, cement lines (or reversal lines) separate osteons from the interstitial bone tissue, which consists of remnants of primary lamellar bone or fragments of remodeled osteons. There have been experimental evidences of the cement line involvement in the failure process of bone such as fatigue and damage. However, there are almost no experimental data on interfacial properties of cement lines in human cortical bone. The objective of this study is to design and assemble a precision and computer controlled osteon pushout microtesting system, and to experimentally determine the interfacial strength of cement lines in human cortical bone by performing osteon pushout tests. Thirty specimens were prepared from humeral diaphyses of four human subjects. Twenty specimens were tested under the condition of a small hole in the supporting plate, in which the cement line debonding occurred. The cement line interfacial strength ranged from 5.38 MPa to 10.85 MPa with an average of 7.31±1.73 MPa. On the other hand, ten specimens were tested under the condition of a large hole in the supporting plate, in which the shear failure inside osteons was observed. The specimens tested under the condition of the large hole resulted in an average shear strength of 73.71±15.06 MPa, ranging from 45.97 MPa to 93.74 MPa. Therefore, our results suggest that the cement line interface between osteon and interstitial bone tissue is weaker than that between bone tissue lamellae.     

Bone defect repair in rat tibia by TGF-β1 and IGF-1 released from hydrogel scaffold

Bone repair is one of the major challenges facing reconstructive surgery. Bone regeneration is needed for the repair of large defects and fractures. The ability of TGF-β1 and IGF-1 incorporated into hydrogel scaffold to induce bone regeneration was evaluated in a rat tibia segmental defect model. External fixation was performed prior to the induction of the segmental bone defect in order to stabilize the defect site. Hydrogel scaffold containing either TGF-β, IGF-1, TGF-β + IGF-1, hydrogel containing saline or saline, were inserted in the defect. Calcified material was observed in the defects treated with TGF-β 2 weeks following the start of treatment. Bone defects treated with TGF-β, IGF-1 or TGF-β + IGF-1 revealed significant bone formation after 4 and 6 weeks when compared to the control specimens. X-ray images showed that solid bone was present at the defect site after 6 weeks of treatment with TGF-β or TGF-β + IGF-1. A less pronounced bone induction was observed in the control specimens and bones treated with IGF-1. Percent closure ratio of bone defects after 6 weeks were 40, 80, 89, and 97% for saline, hydrogel, IGF-1, TGF-β and IGF-1 + TGF-β groups, respectively. It is concluded that hydrogel scaffold can serve as a good osteoconductive matrix for growth factors, and that it provides a site for bone regeneration and enhances bone defect healing and could be used as alternative graft material. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Combined computational study of mechanical behaviour and drug delivery from a porous, hydroxyapatite-based bone graft

This paper presents a numerical model of a porous, hydroxyapatite-based bone graft also suitable as a drug delivery device. The graft was positioned in different sites and with different porosities inside a human femur model. The structural analyses were carried out to verify the graft mechanical strength, using the Tsai–Wu criterion, and the maximum porosity at which static failure does not occur. A local stress shielding risk was also calculated as the ratio between the bone stress in the intact condition and the stress after implantation of the graft. Drug release kinetics was calculated by means of the finite element method. High porosity grafts were found to fail in all implantation sites. Lower porosity grafts showed to have adequate strength if implanted in some positions, while provided insufficient resistance for other implantation sites. Drug release kinetics was found to be strongly dependent both on the porosity of the graft and the bone density near the bone-graft interface.     

Fresh cortical autograft versus fresh cortical allograft effects on experimental bone healing in rabbits: radiological, Histopathological and Biomechanical evaluation

Bone grafting is used to enhance healing in osteotomies, arthrodesis, and multifragmentary fractures and to replace bony loss resulting from neoplasia or cysts. They are source of osteoprogenitor cells and induce bone formation and provide mechanical support for vascular and bone ingrowth. Autografts are used commonly but quantity of harvested bone is limit. This study was designed to evaluate fresh cortical autograft and allograft effects on bone healing process. Twenty male White New Zealand rabbits were used in this study. In autograft group the defect was filled by fresh autogenous cortical graft, in allograft group the defect was filled by a segment of fresh allogenous cortical bone which was harvested at the time of surgery during the creation of radius bone defect. Then all surface soft tissue, such as muscle attachments, were removed from the harvested bone and changed between rabbits as a fresh allogenous cortical bone graft and was fixed by cercelage wire. Radiological, histopathological and biomechanical evaluations were performed blindly and results scored and analyzed statistically. Statistical tests did not support significant differences between two groups at the 14th and 56th postoperative day radiographically (P > 0.05). There was a significant difference radiologically for the 28th and the 42nd postoperative (P < 0.05). Autograft was superior to allograft at the 28th and 42nd postoperative day in radiological evaluation (P < 0.03). Histopathological and biomechanical evaluation revealed no significant differences between two groups.     

自体颏部骨移植并种植体修复前牙槽骨缺损的应用研究

目的:评价自体颏部骨移植方法在前牙槽骨缺损植骨及种植的效果。方法:对16例前牙骨缺损的患者进行自体颏部骨移植,分别于植骨12～16周后植入种植体,共植入18枚种植体,术后16～20周完成修复治疗。结果:16例自体骨移植患者中,1例出现术后感染,经局部冲洗换药后后愈合良好,其余患者移植骨均已成活,修复后种植体至今均无脱落,局部外形良好。结论:自体颏部骨移植能有效恢复局部牙槽外形,为前牙美学修复提供良好的基础。