Genetic diversity and population structure of the endangered and medically important Rheum tanguticum (Polygonaceae) revealed by SSR Markers

Rheum tanguticum (Polygonaceae), an endangered plant, is endemic to the Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau. A total of 114 individual of R. tanguticum from 10 geographically separate populations were analyzed using seven pairs simple sequence repeats (SSR) markers. 102 alleles were recorded, with an average of 14.6 alleles per locus (ranging from 13 to 17) and the expected heterozygosity (H_e) ranged from 0.384 to 0.515 (average 0.459). The genetic differentiation between populations was relatively high (F_st = 0.249); the gene flow (N_m = 0.754), however, was limited, which suggested that around 21.18% of the total genetic variations occurred between populations. Our results revealed high levels of genetic variations within and between populations. The endangered status of this species is probably due to harvesting of the wild populations, rather than a lack of the genetic diversity. Anthropologic effects as well as other factors may, together, have shaped the genetic structure of this species.     

Genetic differentiation in endangered Gynostemma pentaphyllum (Thunb.) Makino based on ISSR polymorphism and its implications for conservation

Studies were performed to investigate the genetic variation of 14 natural populations of Gynostemma pentaphyllum (Thunb.) Makino, an outcrossing clonal plant species in China, using inter-simple sequence repeat (ISSR) markers. Fourteen selected primers were used to amplify DNA samples from 140 individuals, and totally 194 loci were detected. The percentage of polymorphic bands (PPBs) showed that the genetic diversity was pretty high at the species level (PPB = 96.39%) but quite low at the population level (PPB = 1.03–25.26%). Shannon's information index (I) and Nei's gene diversity (h) displayed a similar trend to PPB. According to the hierarchical analysis of molecular variance (AMOVA) and Nei's analysis of gene diversity, the percentages of genetic variation among populations were 88.66 and 88.94%, respectively, indicating a high level of inter-population genetic differentiation. The low levels of genetic diversity within populations and high genetic differentiation among populations were assumed to result from the limited gene flow, the clonal nature and genetic drift. Based on the genetic data, effective conservation strategies were proposed for conserving this traditional Chinese medicinal herb. Concerning the management of G. pentaphyllum, we suggested that in situ conservation be an important and practical measure for maintaining the genetic diversity and that a possibly maximum number of populations be conserved. Populations EMS and HLT, in which particularly low levels of genetic variation were characterized, should be given the priority for ex situ conservation.     

Genetic diversity within and among populations of the endangered species Taxus fuana (Taxaceae) from Pakistan and implications for its conservation

The West Himalayan yew, Taxus fuana Nan Li & R.R. Mill (Taxaceae), is an endangered species endemic to the Western Himalayas. An investigation of the genetic diversity of wild populations of T. fuana in Pakistan was undertaken. The genetic diversity and genetic structure was quantified using random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) variation in 219 individuals of the 10 populations. Of the 32 universal primers screened 16 produced highly reproducible, clear RAPD bands. Using these primers, 193 discernible DNA fragments were generated, of which 164 (84.97%) were polymorphic. The statistical results indicated that there was a relatively low genetic diversity within populations (with percentages of polymorphic bands, PPB, ranging from 29.53 to 50.26%, with an average of 38.34% and a Nei's genetic diversity index (H_E) of 0.1165), and a high genetic differentiation among populations (G_ST = 0.5842, Φ_ST = 0.5685) within these populations. The gene flow (N_m) was low with only 0.3558.     

Genetic diversity and biogeography of the traditional Chinese medicine, Gardenia jasminoides, based on AFLP markers

Gardenia jasminoides Ellis is used in traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) in China. Levels of genetic variation and patterns of population structure within and among eight wild or cultivated populations of G. jasminoides Ellis in China were investigated using amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) markers. Of the 11 primers screened, four produced highly reproducible AFLP bands. Using these primers, 244 discernible DNA fragments were generated with 165 bands (67.6%), were polymorphic, indicating considerable genetic variation at the species level. In contrast, there were relatively low levels of polymorphism at the population level with the percentage of polymorphic bands (PPB) ranging from 36.89% to 59.43%. Genetic diversity within populations ranged from 0.2086 to 0.3108, averaging 0.2392 at the species level. A high level of genetic differentiation among populations was detected based on Nei's genetic diversity analysis (76.59%), Shannon's index analysis (64.8%) and AMOVA analysis (72.75%). No significant statistical differences (analysis of molecular variance [AMOVA], p = 0.0639) in AFLP variation were found between regions. However, the variance among populations and within populations differed significantly (p < 0.001). An indirect estimate of historical levels of gene flow (N_m = 1.7448) was consistent with the high mean genetic identity (mean I = 0.9263) found among populations. There is an association between geographic and genetic distances between populations. Presently gene change exists between populations.     

Population structure and genetic diversity of Stipa grandis P. Smirn,a dominant species in the typical steppe of northern China

Random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) markers were used to characterize genetic heterogeneity within and among five populations of Stipa grandis in the Xilingol Plateau. Estimates of the percentage of polymorphic bands, Shannon's diversity information index and Nei's gene diversity index were comparatively high in the five populations, and the Population GSM was found to have the highest genetic diversity among all populations. An analysis of molecular variance indicated that the majority of variation existed within populations (74.12%), and that there was significant differentiation among populations (Φ_ST = 25.88%, P < 0.001). Genetic distance (Φ_ST) ranged from 0.198 to 0.310 and the differentiation between pair-wise populations was significant when individual pairs of populations were compared. Based on the Φ_ST values, gene flow (Nm) was estimated and was found to vary from 0.556 to 1.013 between pair-wise populations and 0.7412 among populations. The results of UPGMA cluster analysis and nonmetric multi-dimensional scaling analysis indicated that most variation occurred within populations and that genetic differentiation had happened between populations. These findings are important for a better understanding of the adaptive strategy of S. grandis in northern China and will be useful for conservation managers to work out an effective strategy to protect this important species.     

High genetic differentiation and low genetic diversity in Incarvillea younghusbandii, an endemic plant of Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau,revealed by AFLP markers

Incarvillea younghusbandii Sprague (Bignoniaceae) is a perennial herbaceous plant endemic to Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau. As a species of medical and horticulture importance, I. younghusbandii is threatened by over exploitation and habitat fragmentation. In this study, we analyze the genetic diversity and population structure of I. younghusbandii using amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) markers. Our data reveal very low levels of genetic diversity in seven natural populations across Tibet. Specifically, at population level, the average Nei's genetic diversity index (H_E) and Shannon's diversity index (I) were 0.063 and 0.096, respectively. In contrast, high genetic differentiation among populations (Gst = 0.6238, Φ_ST = 0.614) is detected. The results of Neighbor-joining cluster, PCO, and STRUCTURE assignment reveal consistent pattern, suggesting seven well-defined genetic groups that are concordant with their geographical origins. The possible mechanisms and implications of these findings for conservation are discussed.     

Analysis of the genetic structure of Rhodiola rosea (Crassulaceae) using inter-simple sequence repeat (ISSR) polymorphisms

The genetic diversity and differentiation of eleven R. rosea populations from different parts of its wide area of occurrence were studied by ISSR markers. Using eight primers, 252 DNA fragments were generated, and 243 of those DNA fragments were found to be polymorphic, indicating a high genetic variability at the species level (P = 96.4%, h = 0.176, SI = 0.291). Relatively low levels of diversity were determined at the population level (P 30.6-59.1%, h 0.088-0.165, SI 0.137-0.257). AMOVA analysis revealed that the majority of the genetic variation was within populations (65.42%), and the variance among populations was 34.58%. Cluster analysis revealed two groups of R. rosea populations; these groups likely represent distinct evolutionary lines in the species, which are different in genetic structure, evolutionary history and chorological migration routes.     

Inter-simple sequence repeat (ISSR) analysis of genetic variation of Chondrus crispus populations from North Atlantic

ISSR analysis was used to investigate genetic variations of 184 haploid and diploid samples from nine North Atlantic Chondrus crispus Stackhouse populations and one outgroup Yellow Sea Chondrus ocellatus Holmes population. Twenty-two of 50 primers were selected and 163 loci were scored for genetic diversity analysis. Genetic diversity varied among populations, percentage of polymorphic bands (PPB) ranged from 27.0 to 55.8%, H (Nei's genetic diversity) ranged from 0.11 to 0.20 and I (Shannon's information index) ranged from 0.16 to 0.30. Estimators PPB, H and I had similar values in intra-population genetic diversity, regardless of calculation methods. Analysis of molecular variance (AMOVA) apportioned inter-population and intra-population variations for C. crispus, showing more genetic variance (56.5%) occurred in intra-population, and 43.5% variation among nine populations. The Mantel test suggested that genetic differentiation between nine C. crispus populations was closely related with geographic distances (R = 0.78, P = 0.002). Results suggest that, on larger distance scale (ca. >1000 km), ISSR analysis is useful for determining genetic differentiations of C. crispus populations including morphologically inseparable haploid and diploid individuals.     

Genetic diversity of the endangered species Kirengeshoma palmata (Saxifragaceae) in China

In order to investigate the levels of genetic diversity of the endangered species Kirengeshoma palmata (Saxifragaceae), four extant populations were sampled and analyzed using inter-simple sequence repeats (ISSR) markers. We expected a low genetic diversity level, but our results revealed a high level of intraspecific genetic diversity, probably resulting from this species being in a refuge during the last glaciation (at population level: P = 63.25%, A_e = 1.47, H_E = 0.26 and H_O = 0.37; at species level: P = 79.00%, A = 1.5538, H_T = 0.2586 and H_sp = 0.3104). A low level of genetic differentiation among populations was detected based on Nei's genetic diversity analysis (16.69%) and AMOVA (19.36%). Populations shared high levels of genetic identity. Insect pollination and seed dispersal by wind may have facilitated extensive gene flow and are likely responsible for this present structure of genetic variation.     

Genetic Variation in Rheum palmatum and Rheum tanguticum (Polygonaceae), Two Medicinally and Endemic Species in China Using ISSR Markers

Aims

Both Rheum palmatum and R. tanguticum are important but endangered medicinal plants endemic to China. In this study, we aimed to (i) investigate the level and pattern of genetic variability within/among populations of those species; (ii) evaluate genetic differentiation between both species and its relationships and ascertain whether both species are consistent with their current taxonomical treatment as separate species; and (iii) discuss the implications for the effective conservation of two species.

Methods

Total 574 individuals from 30 populations of R. palmatum and R. tanguticum were collected, covering the entire distribution range of two species in China. The genetic variation within and among 30 populations was evaluated using inter-simple sequence repeat (ISSR) markers.

Important Findings

Twelve selected ISSR primers generated a total of 175 fragments, 173 (98.86%) of which were polymorphic. The Nei''s gene diversity (H) and Shannon''s index (I) of both species were high at species level (H = 0.3107, I = 0.4677 for R. palmatum; H = 0.2848, I = 0.4333 for R. tanguticum). But for both species, the genetic diversity was low at population level, and average within-population diversity of R. palmatum was H = 0.1438, I = 0.2151, and that of R. tanguticum was H = 0.1415, I = 0.2126. The hierarchical AMOVA revealed high levels of among-population genetic differentiation in both species, in line with the gene differentiation coefficient and the limited among-population gene flow (R. palmatum: Φ_st = 0.592, G_st = 0.537, N_m = 0.432; R. tanguticum: Φ_st = 0.567, G_st = 0.497, N_m = 0.507). By contrast, only 6.52% of the total genetic variance was partitioned between R. palmatum and R. tanguticum. Bayesian analysis, UPGMA cluster analysis, and PCoA analysis all demonstrated the similar results. A significant isolation-by-distance pattern was revealed in R. palmatum (r = 0.547, P = 0.010), but not in R. tanguticum (r = 0.241, P = 0.100). Based on these results, effective conservation strategies were proposed for these two species. The small molecular variance between R. palmatum and R. tanguticum revealed that they had a common ancestor, and we considered that these two species might not be good species.     

Genetic variation in cultivated Rheum tanguticum populations

To examine whether cultivation reduced genetic variation in the important Chinese medicinal plant Rheum tanguticum, the levels and distribution of genetic variation were investigated using ISSR markers. Fifty-eight R. tanguticum individuals from five cultivated populations were studied. Thirteen primers were used and a total of 320 DNA bands were scored. High levels of genetic diversity were detected in cultivated R. tanguticum (PPB = 82.19, H = 0.2498, H_B = 0.3231, I = 0.3812) and could be explained by the outcrossing system, as well as long-lived and human-mediated seed exchanges. Analysis of molecular variance (AMOVA) showed that more genetic variation was found within populations (76.1%) than among them (23.9%). This was supported by the coefficient of gene differentiation (G_st = 0.2742) and Bayesian analysis (θ_B = 0.1963). The Mantel test revealed no significant correlation between genetic and geographic distances among populations (r = 0.1176, p = 0.3686). UPGMA showed that the five cultivated populations were separated into three clusters, which was in good accordance with the results provided by the Bayesian software STRUCTURE (K = 3). A short domestication history and no artificial selection may be an effective way of maintaining and conserving the gene pools of wild R. tanguticum.     

Genetic diversity and geographical differentiation of Dipteronia Oliv. (Aceraceae) endemic to China as revealed by AFLP analysis

The genus Dipteronia Oliv. endemic to central and southern China consists of two species, Dipteronia sinensis Oliv. and Dipteronia dyeriana Henry, both of them are rare and endangered. AFLP markers were used to characterize the genetic diversity and geographical differentiation of the genus. Eight out of 32 PstI + 3/MseI + 3 selective primer combinations screened were applied to the analysis on 142 individuals of 17 D. sinensis and 4 D. dyeriana populations, respectively. A total of 324 fragments with 316 polymorphic were amplified. The proportion of polymorphic loci (PPB) was 97.53%. The Nei's gene diversity in D. sinensis and D. dyeriana was 0.3319 and 0.3047, respectively. About 43.6% (G_ST = 0.4356) of the genetic variation occurred among the populations, indicating a relatively high genetic differentiation among the populations. Cluster analysis grouped the 21 populations into two groups according to their species delimitation. The populations of D. sinensis were further divided into three subgroups corresponding to their geographical distributions. Correlation analysis revealed a significant correlation (p < 0.05) between geographical distance and genetic distance of these populations, suggesting that the relatively high genetic differentiation among the populations of D. sinensis might be caused by geographical isolation.     

Assessing genetic diversity of populations of topmouth culter (Culter alburnus) in China using AFLP markers

Genetic diversity of five wild populations and a cultured population of topmouth culter (Culter alburnus) was investigated using amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP). A total of 373 reproducible bands amplified with seven AFLP primer combinations were obtained from 163 fish. The percentage of polymorphic loci ranged widely from 37.0% to 69.2% within distinct populations. The cultured population appeared to have a lower level of polymorphism (37.0%), gene diversity (0.121 ± 0.188) and Shannon's Information index (0.183 ± 0.263) than the wild populations. Analysis of molecular variance (AMOVA) revealed that average F_ST value overall loci was 0.2671, and the percentage of variation within population (73.29%) was larger than among populations (26.71%) (P < 0.01). The six populations were clustered into two major clades with UPGMA. The results from analysis of population pairwise gene flow indicated moderate gene flow among populations. Our study indicated that the genetic diversity of the cultured population was reduced compared with the wild populations. Geographic isolation, habitat, and artificial selection all may have played important roles in population differentiation. The information may be beneficial to future broodstock selection and defining conservation management for the different populations of topmouth culter.     

Conservation genetics of endangered medicinal plant Commiphora wightii in Indian Thar Desert

To ascertain the conservation priorities and strategies for Commiphora wightii, an endangered medicinal plant of Indian Thar Desert, genetic diversity was estimated within and among different populations. The total of 155 amplification products were scored using ten each of RAPD and ISSR primers, exhibiting an overall 86.72% polymorphism across 45 individuals representing eight populations. The cumulative data of two markers were used to compute pair-wise distances. The Neighbor-Joining tree revealed high genetic differentiation among populations except Kiradu population. Nei's gene diversity (h) ranged between 0.082 and 0.193 with total diversity at species level is 0.294. Shannon's information index (I) ranged between 0.118 and 0.275 with an overall diversity of 0.439. Analysis of molecular variance showed more diversity among population level (56.65%) than at within population level (43.35%). The low gene flow value (Nm = 0.349) and high coefficient of genetic differentiation (G_ST = 0.589) and high fixation index (F_ST = 0.566) demonstrated elevated genetic differentiation among the population and can be predicted that these populations are not in Hardy–Weinberg proportions. Principal Co-ordinate Analysis confirms that Akal population has become phylogenetically more distinct and less diverse than the rest of the samples. Mantel's test revealed no correlation between genetic and geographical distances of populations (R² = 0.122). Overall highest diversity was observed in the population of Machiya Safari Park and Kiradu, while lowest in Akal population, later may constitute an evolutionary significant unit, having merit for special management.     

Genetic diversity and local population structure in Ambrosina bassii (Araceae,Ambrosineae), a Mediterranean relict species

The effects of habitat fragmentation on the genetic structure of Ambrosina bassii are analyzed. The species, whose reproductive biology is mostly unknown, is the only representative of its genus and tribe and it is endemic to the central Mediterranean area. The selected study area was the island of Sicily, in which wild populations show a wide morphological variability and ecological amplitude. Patterns of within- and among-population genetic diversity in eleven Sicilian populations, occurring in six disjunct areas, were examined by means of allozyme electrophoresis. High levels of genetic diversity were found as shown by the mean expected heterozygosity (H_e = 0.263), the percentage of polymorphic loci (P₉₅ = 65.3), the mean number of alleles per locus (A = 2.0). Genetic differentiation between populations was relatively low (mean F_ST = 0.091 and Nm = 1.98). A very weak correlation exists between genetic distances and geographic distances between populations. Despite its restricted and fragmented geographical range, A. bassii showed (i) high levels of genetic diversity, mainly within populations; (ii) no genetic differentiation between populations and morphotypes.     

Start Codon Targeted (SCoT) marker reveals genetic diversity of Dendrobium nobile Lindl., an endangered medicinal orchid species

Genetic variability in the wild genotypes of Dendrobium nobile Lindl. collected from different parts of Northeast India, was analyzed using a Start Codon Targeted (SCoT) marker system. A total of sixty individuals comprising of six natural populations were investigated for the existing natural genetic diversity. One hundred and thirty two (132) amplicons were produced by SCoT marker generating 96.21% polymorphism. The PIC value of the SCoT marker system was 0.78 and the Rp values of the primers ranged between 4.43 and 7.50. The percentage of polymorphic loci (Pp) ranging from 25% to 56.82%, Nei's gene diversity (h) from 0.08 to 0.15 with mean Nei's gene diversity of 0.28, and Shannon's information index (I) values ranging from 0.13 to 0.24 with an average value of 0.43 were recorded. The gene flow value (0.37) and the diversity among populations (0.57) demonstrated higher genetic variation among the populations. Analysis of molecular variance (AMOVA) showed 43.37% of variation within the populations, whereas 56.63% variation was recorded among the populations. Cluster analysis also reveals high genetic variation among the genotypes. Present investigation suggests the effectiveness of SCoT marker system to estimate the genetic diversity of D. nobile and that it can be seen as a preliminary point for future research on the population and evolutionary genetics of this endangered orchid species of medicinal importance.     

Patterns of morphological and genetic diversity of Valeriana jatamansi Jones in different habitats and altitudinal range of West Himalaya,India

Importance to know and understand diversity of Himalayan plants is increasingly recognized considering the fact that various natural and anthropogenic pressures might bring about serious influences to morphological and genetic diversity of the vegetation in the region. In this context, Valeriana jatamansi was investigated in detail, taking into account its importance in various Ayurvedic and modern medicines. Randomly selected mature plants from twenty five different populations (located between 1215 m to 2775 m asl) of V. jatamansi were analysed for their morphological attributes. Further, ISSR markers were used to detect genetic variation among 151 plants of selected 25 populations. Use of 20 primers yielded 125 reproducible polymorphic loci which were used to estimate different parameters of genetic diversity. These parameters were in turn applied to develop relationships with habitat types and altitude range. Significant variation (p < 0.05) in above ground dry weight (AGDW) and below ground dry weight (BGDW) across the populations was observed. Nei's genetic diversity index (He) ranged from 0.25 to 0.37 across the populations, with a mean of 0.31. Genetic diversity exhibited a decreasing trend with increasing altitude, and maximum diversity (He = 0.325) was observed in the range of 1201–1500 m asl. Among the different habitat conditions, highest genetic diversity (He = 0.334; Pp = 84.38) was observed in grassland habitats while minimum in mixed forest habitats (He = 0.285; Pp = 72.433). The genetic diversity (He) had significant negative relationships with AGDW, BGDW and rhizome diameter (Pearson r = −0.359, −0.424 and −0.317, respectively; p < 0.05). The genetic characterization of V. jatamansi from the western Himalaya by this study suggests influences of habitat types and the altitudinal range upon genetic diversity, and based on these proposals for conservation strategies in favour of the species are made.     

陕西省林麝mtDNA D-loop区序列结构和种群遗传多样性

林麝(Moschus berezovskii)曾广泛分布于中国,由于盗猎和栖息地缩小,秦岭地区野生种群数量迅速下降,圈养繁殖种群已成立了几十年,但大多数圈养种群的遗传背景不清,种群规模增长非常缓慢。为了给这一物种的保护和管理提供有用的信息,调查了陕西省林麝1个圈养种群3个野生种群线粒体DNA(mt DNA)D-Loop 632 bp片段的遗传多样性和种群结构。在69个个体中其碱基组成为A+T的平均含量63.2%高于G+C含量36.8%,共检测到变异位点171个(约占总位点数的27.05%)。核苷酸多样性(Pi)为0.04424,平均核苷酸差异数(K)为19.908。69个个体分属32个单倍型,单倍型间的平均遗传距离(P)为0.070。32个单倍型构建的NJ系统树聚为3个分支,4个林麝群体中的单倍型是随机分布的。4个群体的平均遗传距离为0.043(标准误SE为0.005),凤县养殖场群体与留坝和陇县群体的亲缘关系较远。单倍型间的平均遗传距离为0.043,可见其遗传分化尚未达到种群分化的水平。结果表明,陕西省林麝群体mt DNA D-loop区序列存在着较丰富的变异和遗传多样性,凤县野生群体和凤县养殖场群体的核苷酸多样性和单倍型多样较高,养殖场种群没有出现近亲繁殖及遗传多样性下降的情况。凤县野生群体和凤县养殖场群体两者遗传分化较小,存在着较高的基因流水平。     

Microsatellite diversity and mating system of Sinojackia xylocarpa (Styracaceae), a species extinct in the wild

Sinojackia xylocarpa is a Chinese endemic species that is extinct in the wild but extant in botanical gardens. Microsatellites were used to investigate the genetic diversity and mating system of this species for future use in a reintroduction program. Ex situ conserved populations of S. xylocarpa maintain intermediate levels of genetic diversity (H_E = 0.570–0.640). However, a general and significant heterozygote excess was found, with a mean F_IS of −0.103. S. xylocarpa was determined to be predominantly outcrossing (t_m = 0.992; t_s = 1.092). Population size and genetic diversity were found to be positively correlated (r = 0.991; P = 0.084). Principal coordinate analysis (PCA) suggests that all extant individuals are derived from two source populations. Reintroduction strategies of S. xylocarpa were proposed on the basis of these results.     

Genetic diversity of the threatened aquatic plant Ottelia alismoides in the Yangtze River

Ottelia alismoides is a threatened submerged macrophyte in China. Genetic variation and population structure of 11 O. alismoides populations from lakes in mid-lower reaches of the Yangtze River were assessed by inter-simple sequence repeat (ISSR) markers. Eleven primer combinations produced a total of 130 unambiguous bands of which 57 (43.9%) were polymorphic. O. alismoides exhibited a very low level of intra-population genetic diversity (P_p = 13.0%, H_E = 0.042, I = 0.063). The main factors responsible for that were its short life history and high degree of autogamy in the reproductive system of the species. The F statistics calculated by different approaches consistently revealed a high genetic differentiation among populations, contributing >55% of the total gene diversity. The evident population structure of O. alismoides could be due to self-fertilizing reproduction, restricted gene flow and genetic drift. Estimates of gene flow by F_ST and coalescent-based simulation analysis indicated a restricted recurrent gene exchange among populations (Nm = 0.180, M = 0.190). Genetic drift played a more important role than gene flow in the current population genetic structure of O. alismoides because its habitat range was fragmented and highly influenced by environment changes. The results are discussed in relation to both in situ and ex situ conservation efforts of the species. A conservation strategy for conserving all extant populations to maximize genomic representation of the species is recommended.