Human choriocarcinoma cell resistance to natural killer lysis due to defective triggering of natural killer cells

The trophoblast, the outermost layer of the human placenta, lacks expression of the classical human leukocyte antigen (HLA) class I molecules. This prevents allorecognition by T cells but raises the question of what protects the trophoblast from natural killer (NK) cells. In a previous study, we have shown that choriocarcinoma cell (CC) resistance to NK lysis was mainly independent of HLA class I molecules. In the present study, we postulated that CC may prevent activation of NK cells by failing to stimulate their triggering receptors (TR). To test this hypothesis, we evaluated the lysis of JAR and JEG-3 CC after effective cross-linking and activation of NK cells by means of lectins or antibodies. Our results show that NK-resistant CC were sensitive to lysis by unstimulated peripheral blood lymphocytes in the presence of phytohemagglutin (PHA), to antibody-dependent cell cytotoxicity in presence of anti-Tja antibodies, and to monoclonal antibody redirected killing using anti-TR antibodies anti-CD16 and anti-CD244/2B4. Finally, CC fail to express CD48, the ligand for CD244/2B4. These results indicate that the resistance of CC to lysis results primarily from defective NK cell activation, at least partially due to the lack of expression of ligands, such as CD48, involved in the triggering of NK cells.     

Inability of interferon to protect virus-infected cells against lysis by natural killer (NK) cells correlates with NK cell-mediated antiviral effects in vivo

Murine cytomegalovirus (MCMV) is a natural killer (NK) cell-sensitive virus, whereas lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV) is an NK cell-resistant virus. Selective depletion of NK cell activity by injection of mice with anti-asialo GM1 antibody enhanced synthesis of MCMV but not that of LCMV when mice were simultaneously infected with the two viruses. This suggests that the NK cell-mediated antiviral effects may depend on target cell susceptibility to NK cell-mediated lysis rather than the ability of a virus to induce a specialized antiviral NK cell. In support of this concept, activated NK cells isolated from either MCMV- or LCMV-infected mice had similar patterns of killing against all targets tested. Mouse embryonic fibroblasts (MEF) infected with MCMV were less sensitive to lysis by activated NK cells than either uninfected or LCMV-infected MEF. However, when MEF were pretreated with IFN, activated NK cell-mediated lysis against MCMV-infected MEF was undiminished and was much higher (up to fourfold) than that against uninfected MEF, whose sensitivity to lysis was almost totally abolished by IFN pretreatment. LCMV-infected MEF were also protected by IFN against activated NK cell-mediated lysis. During infection, the virus-induced IFN may protect uninfected and LCMV-infected cells from IFN-activated, NK cell-mediated lysis, but MCMV-infected cells may remain sensitive to lysis. This could explain how NK cells play a role in resistance to MCMV but not LCMV.     

Human oncogene-transfected tumor cells display differential susceptibility to lysis by lymphokine-activated killer cells (LAK) and natural killer cells

NIH 3T3 tertiary transfectants containing the N-ras or c-Ha-ras oncogenes derived from human tumors were tested for susceptibility to lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cell and natural killer (NK) cell lysis. N-ras tertiary transfectants contained a human acute lymphocytic leukemia-derived N-ras oncogene. C-Ha-ras transfectants contained either the position 61-activated form of the oncogene (45.342, 45.322, and 45.3B2) or the position 12-activated form (144-162). In 4 hr 51Cr release assays, seven of seven in vivo grown human oncogene transfected NIH 3T3 fibroblasts were lysed by murine LAK effectors, whereas six of seven were lysed by human LAK effectors. There was no difference in susceptibility to lysis between cells transfected with the N-ras oncogene, the position 61 activated c-Ha-ras oncogene, or the position 12 activated c-Ha-ras oncogene. Cultured NIH 3T3 fibroblasts, as well as in vitro and in vivo grown NIH 3T3 tertiary transfectants were resistant to lysis by murine NK effectors and were relatively resistant (4/6 were not lysed) to lysis by human NK effectors. We conclude that human oncogene-transfected tumors are susceptible to lysis by both murine and human LAK cells while being relatively resistant to lysis by murine and human NK cells. Different oncogenes or the same oncogene activated by different point mutations do not specifically determine susceptibility to lysis by LAK or NK. Also the presence of an activated oncogene does not appear to be sufficient for inducing susceptibility to these cytotoxic lymphocyte populations.     

Enhancement of susceptibility of HSV-1-infected cells to natural killer lysis by interferon

The effect of interferon (IFN) on the natural killer (NK) activity of human PBL against HSV-1-infected HeLa cells was studied. Human PBL from several individuals did not consistently show a preferential lysis of HSV-1-, vaccinia-, or adenovirus type 5-infected cells with respect to uninfected HeLa cells. Treatment with IFN of effector PBL increased their lytic activity but did not alter the degree of preference on the lysis of the target cells shown by untreated PBL. Pretreatment with IFN of HSV-1-infected HeLa cells increased their susceptibility to lysis 5- to 10-fold. In contrast, identical pretreatment of the uninfected, adenovirus type 5- or vaccinia virus-infected HeLa cells before the assay decreased their susceptibility to NK lysis. This effect was not likely to be due to a block of the viral replication because other inhibitors like mitomycin C did not have the same effect. All target cells induced IFN synthesis in effector PBL cells. A similar level of IFN was induced by HSV-1-infected or uninfected HeLa cells. Pretreatment with IFN of HSV-1-infected, but not uninfected, HeLa cells induced 5 to 10 times more IFN by PBL, in good correlation with the increase in lytic activity. PBL treated with IFN, however, in conditions to give maximal stimulation of NK activity, presented the same preferential lysis of HSV-1-infected HeLa cells and synthesized similar levels of IFN as untreated PBL. In addition, HSV-1-infected HeLa cells were killed through different target structures than uninfected cells. Taken together, our results indicate an effect of IFN at the level of the NK target structures in HSV-1-infected HeLa cells by increasing either their number or, more likely, their affinity for NK cells independent of the effect of IFN in the effector cells or as an antiviral agent.     

Fractalkine expression induces endothelial progenitor cell lysis by natural killer cells

Background

Circulating CD34⁺ cells, a population that includes endothelial progenitors, participate in the maintenance of endothelial integrity. Better understanding of the mechanisms that regulate their survival is crucial to improve their regenerative activity in cardiovascular and renal diseases. Chemokine-receptor cross talk is critical in regulating cell homeostasis. We hypothesized that cell surface expression of the chemokine fractalkine (FKN) could target progenitor cell injury by Natural Killer (NK) cells, thereby limiting their availability for vascular repair.

Methodology/Principal Findings

We show that CD34⁺-derived Endothelial Colony Forming Cells (ECFC) can express FKN in response to TNF-α and IFN-γ inflammatory cytokines and that FKN expression by ECFC stimulates NK cell adhesion, NK cell-mediated ECFC lysis and microparticles release in vitro. The specific involvement of membrane FKN in these processes was demonstrated using FKN-transfected ECFC and anti-FKN blocking antibody. FKN expression was also evidenced on circulating CD34⁺ progenitor cells and was detected at higher frequency in kidney transplant recipients, when compared to healthy controls. The proportion of CD34⁺ cells expressing FKN was identified as an independent variable inversely correlated to CD34⁺ progenitor cell count. We further showed that treatment of CD34⁺ circulating cells isolated from adult blood donors with transplant serum or TNF-α/IFN-γ can induce FKN expression.

Conclusions

Our data highlights a novel mechanism by which FKN expression on CD34⁺ progenitor cells may target their NK cell mediated killing and participate to their immune depletion in transplant recipients. Considering the numerous diseased contexts shown to promote FKN expression, our data identify FKN as a hallmark of altered progenitor cell homeostasis with potential implications in better evaluation of vascular repair in patients.     

High expression of the c-myc oncogene renders melanoma cells prone to lysis by natural killer cells

NK cells kill a wide variety of tumor cells, but usually leave normal cells intact. It was earlier reported that low class I HLA expression can be one of the factors that render target cells relatively susceptible to NK lysis. In this contribution, we show that in human melanomas the class I HLA expression is down-modulated by high expression of transfected c-myc oncogenes. The extent of down-modulation depended on the level of c-myc expression in a dose-dependent way. Taken together, these data suggested to us that one of the results of high c-myc expression could be the induction of a NK susceptible phenotype in melanoma cells. Therefore, we analyzed the effect of c-myc on NK susceptibility. We have found that high expression of transfected c-myc genes indeed converts the melanoma cell lines from poor into good targets for NK cells. IFN-gamma was used to restore the class I HLA expression of the c-myc transfectants, and the resulting cells showed a decreased NK susceptibility. These results suggest the possibility that the c-myc-induced NK susceptibility is mediated by the reduction of class I HLA expression.     

Isolation of a novel tumor protein that induces resistance to natural killer cell lysis

The human metastatic tumor cell line CAP-2, produces a soluble factor that induces resistance to NK lysis of K-562 susceptible leukemia cell line, and does not inhibit the cytotoxic capacity of effector cells. The use of sequential HPLC, hydrophobic interaction chromatography, and reverse phase chromatography, coupled with cytotoxic assays, resulted in the isolation and separation to homogeneity of a novel protein responsible for this biologic activity. Size estimation studies based on TSK HPLC columns showed that this protein has a mass of 8 to 12 kDa. The amino acid composition analysis of the CAP-2 protein calculated from HPLC chromatograms shows that this protein contains around 108 amino acids. Subsequent gas phase sequence analysis, however, was hampered because the N terminus of this protein was blocked and therefore unsuitable for sequencing by Edman degradation. The functional studies showed that the NK lysis-resistance activity of the CAP-2 protein is mediated by interaction with and nonspecific binding to NK target cells. The lymphokine-activated killer and macrophage-mediated cytotoxicity and mitogen-induced proliferation is not affected. Unexpectedly, the CAP-2 protein appears to be mitogenic to its own cell line. Thus, the induction of NK lysis-resistance and the mitogenic activity showed by CAP-2 protein could contribute to the tumor growth and metastatic establishment.     

Decay-accelerating factor expression on either effector or target cells inhibits cytotoxicity by human natural killer cells.

Previous studies have shown that freshly isolated CD16+ NK cells are deficient in the expression of decay-accelerating factor (DAF), or CD55, a membrane regulator of C3 activation. In this study we investigated the significance, for NK cell-mediated lysis, of DAF expression on the target and effector cells. The effect of DAF expression on the susceptibility of NK cell targets was investigated by several means: first, DAF- cell lines were cloned from K562; second, the cloned DAF- cells were reconstituted with exogenous purified DAF; and third, anti-DAF F(ab')2 was used to block DAF function on the DAF+ K562 cells. Consistently, the presence of DAF in the target cell membrane, either naturally occurring or experimentally incorporated, afforded the target cell protection against lysis, and this protection could be blocked with anti-DAF. Similarly, targets for antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity with exogenous DAF incorporated in their plasma membrane became less sensitive to antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity by NK cells compared with the same target cells without incorporated DAF in their membranes. DAF incorporated in the plasma membranes of the effector NK cells made the NK cells less effective at killing K562 targets. The known function of DAF is to regulate C3 activation, and we were able to demonstrate that the isolated NK cell is capable of releasing C3. It is also possible that the participation of DAF in NK cell function represents a new, noncomplement-dependent function for DAF.     

Heat-shock protein 72 cell-surface expression on human lung carcinoma cells is associated with an increased sensitivity to lysis mediated by adherent natural killer cells

 The cell-surface expression patterns of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I, class II and heat-shock protein 72 (HSP72) molecules were measured on human lung (LX-1) and mammary (MX-1) carcinoma cells. No major differences were found in the MHC cell-surface expression pattern of both cell lines. However, they differ significantly in their capacity to express HSP72 on their cell surface. Under physiological conditions LX-1 cells express HSP72 molecules on more than 90% of the cells, whereas MX-1 cells exhibit no significant HSP72 cell-surface expression (less than 5%). These expression patterns remained stable in all further cell passages tested. The sensitivity to lysis mediated by an interleukin-2 (IL-2)-stimulated, adherent natural killer (NK) cell population could be correlated with the amount of cell-surface-expressed HSP72 molecules. By antibody-blocking studies, using HSP72-specific monoclonal antibody (mAb), a strong inhibition of lysis was only found with LX-1 cells but not with MX-1 cells. In contrast to the cell-surface expression, the cytoplasmic amount of HSP72 in MX-1 cells was twice as high compared to LX-1 cells under physiological conditions. After nonlethal heat-shock the rate of induction and the total cytoplasmic amounts of HSP72 were comparable in both cell lines. The clonogenic cell viability of LX-1 cells after incubation at temperatures ranging from 41°C to 44°C was significantly elevated compared to that of MX-1 cells. In conclusion we state the following: (i) HSP72 cell-surface expression on human carcinoma cells is independent of the cytoplasmic amount of HSP72; (ii) the cell-surface expression of HSP72 is associated with an increased sensitivity of tumour cells to lysis mediated by an IL-2-stimulated, adherent NK cell population; (iii) thermoresistance is not related to the cytoplasmic HSP72 level but might be related to the amount of HSP72 expressed on the cell surface. Received: 20 June 1996 / Accepted: 25 September 1996     

N-acetylcysteine reduces transformed 3T3-SV40 fibroblast sensitivity to lysis by natural killer cells

We have shown that 18-20 h cultivation of transformed mouse fibroblasts 3T3-SV40 in the presence of antioxidant, N-acetylcysteine (NAC, 10 mM), did not change their sensitivity to lysis by natural killer (NK) mouse splenocytes. However, in 18-20 h after NAC removal 3T3-SV40 cells demonstrated resistance to NK cell activity. The cytotoxicity index (CI) was reduced up to 4.6 +/- 2.4 % (in comparison with the control value 31.8 +/- 2.4 %) approximating to the value in non-transformed 3T3 mouse fibroblasts. Normal 3T3 cells were resistant to NK action in all experimental conditions (CI varied within 0.7-5.3 %). These results show that NAC can induce partial reversion of transformed phenotype. We suggest that this effect may be due to the NAC-induced modifications of the cell surface and extracellular matrix proteins.     

Adenovirus E1A gene induction of susceptibility to lysis by natural killer cells and activated macrophages in infected rodent cells.

Rodent cells immortalized by the E1A gene of nononcogenic adenoviruses are susceptible to lysis by natural killer (NK) cells and activated macrophages. This cytolysis-susceptible phenotype may contribute to the rejection of adenovirus-transformed cells by immunocompetent animals. Such increased cytolytic susceptibility has also been observed with infected rodent cells. This infection model provided a means to study the role of E1A gene products in induction of cytolytic susceptibility without cell selection during transformation. Deletion mutations outside of the E1A gene had no effect on adenovirus type 2 (Ad2) or Ad5 induction of cytolytic susceptibility in infected hamster cells, while E1A-minus mutant viruses could not induce this phenotype. E1A mutant viruses that induced expression of either E1A 12S or 13S mRNA in infected cells were competent to induce cytolytic susceptibility. Furthermore, there was a correlation between the accumulation of E1A gene products in Ad5-infected cells and the level of susceptibility of such target cells to lysis by NK cells. The results of coinfection studies indicated that the E1A gene products of highly oncogenic Ad12 could not complement the lack of induction of cytolytic susceptibility by E1A-minus Ad5 virus in infected cells and also could not block induction of this infected-cell phenotype by Ad5. These data suggest that expression of the E1A gene of nononcogenic adenoviruses may cause the elimination of infected cells by the immunologically nonspecific host inflammatory cell response prior to cellular transformation. The lack of induction of this cytolysis-susceptible phenotype by Ad12 E1A may result in an increased persistence of Ad12-infected cells in vivo and may lead to an increased Ad12-transformed cell burden for the host.     

Interferon-gamma reduces the sensitivity of cultured and fresh human tumor cells to lysis by lymphokine-activated killer cells

We have shown that interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma), in pharmacologically achievable doses, can reduce the the sensitivity of human tumor cells to lysis by allogeneic lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) effector cells. Cultured tumor cells showed a consistent reduction in sensitivity to lysis following pretreatment for 18 h with 1-10 units/ml IFN-gamma. Tumor cells cultured up to 7 days in 100 units/ml IFN-gamma remained less sensitive to lysis. Induction of protection from LAK did not appear to correlate with IFN-gamma-induced changes in cell growth or proliferation. Reduced LAK sensitivity also did not correlate with the level of expression of major histocompatibility antigens. Eight of 11 surgically obtained human tumor cell specimens showed a reduction in sensitivity to lysis by allogeneic LAK cells following pretreatment with IFN-gamma. IFN-induced reduction of tumor cell sensitivity to lysis by LAK may play a role in altering the host-tumor relationship, since relatively high concentrations of IFN-gamma may exist in the tumor microenvironment.     

Human neuroblastoma cell lines are susceptible to lysis by natural killer cells but not by cytotoxic T lymphocytes

The susceptibility of human neuroblastoma cells to direct cellular cytotoxicity has not been previously established. This is of particular interest because of their aggressive growth and low HLA expression. Neuroblastoma lines CHP 100 and CHP 126 were found to be excellent targets in 4-hr CML assays. Natural killer (NK) cells from fresh PBL and from an NK clone, 3.3, have high lytic activity against both cell lines. We also studied mixed lymphocyte culture-generated cytotoxic lines containing allo-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) directed against HLA antigens present on the neuroblastoma target cell lines. These lines did show excellent lytic activity, but cold target competition studies indicated that all of the lysis resulted from NK activity. This was verified by using inhibition studies with the use of monoclonal antibodies. OKT 3 and anti-HLA antibodies that block CTL function caused no reduction in kill. In contrast, anti-lymphocyte function antigen-1 (anti-LFA-1), which blocks both NK and CTL function, significantly inhibited lysis. These results serve as a functional confirmation of earlier findings of a very weak expression of HLA-A,B,C and beta 2-microglobulin on neuroblastoma cells.     

Lysis of human solid tumor cells by lymphokine-activated natural killer cells

The ability of NK cells to lyse noncultured solid tumor cells was investigated, and the results were compared with lysis of K562. Purified NK cell fractions separated by either Percoll centrifugation or a cell sorter exhibited higher level of lysis against noncultured melanoma cells than did NK-depleted cell fractions. However, the level of lysis was low (less than 10% lysis). Adding recombinant interleukin 2 (rIL 2) to the 4-hr assay induced significant lysis (more than 10%) of noncultured melanoma cells in 18 of 23 (78%) Percoll-enriched NK cell fractions and seven of 11 (64%) sorted Leu-11a+ cells at an E:T ratio of 80 and 10, respectively. In contrast, only two of 13 (14%) PBMC, five of 17 (29%) Percoll-decreased NK cell fractions, and one of 12 (8%) sorted Leu-11a- cells lysed noncultured melanomas in the presence of rIL 2. rIL 2 induced NK cells to lyse noncultured lung and breast cancer cells, as well as melanoma tumors. Exposure of NK cells to 2000 rad radiation abrogated the rIL 2-induced cytotoxicity against noncultured melanomas. Preculture of PBMC for 18 hr with recombinant interferon-gamma (rIFN-gamma) resulted in a modest level of lysis of non-cultured melanomas by sorted Leu-11a+ cells. Adding rIL 2 to the assay increased the cytotoxic activity in both rIFN-gamma-activated Leu-11a+ and Leu-7+ NK subsets. The level of noncultured tumor lysis correlated well with that of K562 lysis in all of the experiments. Purified NK cell fractions in rIL 2 cultures increased cytotoxic activity against noncultured tumor cells with incubation time for up to 3 days, and the level of NK cell-mediated lysis was dependent on both doses of rIL 2 and length of incubation. In contrast, both NK-depleted and sorted Leu-11a- cells demonstrated very low levels of solid tumor lysis after 3-day cultures with a high dose of rIL 2. Killer cell precursors induced by 3-day cultures of sorted cell fractions with rIL 2 and rIFN-gamma were found in both Leu-11a+ and Leu-7+ NK subsets, but not Leu-4+ or Leu-3a+ T lymphocytes. These results indicate that NK cells become cytotoxic for noncultured solid tumor cells by a brief contact with rIL 2, and increase cytotoxic activity after culture with rIL 2.     

Susceptibility to lysis by natural killer and natural cytotoxic cells is independent of the mitotic stage of the target cell cycle

Natural cell-mediated cytotoxicity (NCMC) against a number of target cells is mediated by at least two distinct effector populations, with natural killer (NK) and natural cytotoxic (NC) cells being the predominant in the murine system. The studies described in this report examine the role that the phase of the mitotic cycle of the target cell has on its susceptibility to lysis by NC and NK cells. We show that neither the kinectics nor the magnitude of NC cell lysis is altered when assayed using target cells which have been enriched for G1, S, or G2 + M stages of the cell cycle. Similarly, NK cell lysis by fresh or poly-IC augmented effector cells was not effected by target Cell Cycle.     

Reorganization of actin cytoskeleton in 3T3-SV40 cells and their sensitivity to lysis by natural killer cells

The present work was aimed to examine whether the actin reorganization of 3T3-SV40 cells influences their sensitivity to natural killer (NK) cells activity. The effects of N-acetylcystein (NAC) and latrunculin B, actin depolimerizator, on both cellular parameters were studied. Experiments with NAC demonstrated that 3T3-SV40 sensitivity to NK cells activity remained unchanged under the disordered microfilaments but decreased upon the appearance of structured stress-fibres. The data on latrunculin B action resulted in the opposite conclusion: the more microfilaments disorganization in the presence of latrunculin B the lesser 3T3-SV40 sensitivity to lysis by NK cells. These facts suggest that relations between microfilament integrity in 3T3-SV40 cells and their sensitivity to NK cells are rather independent. The latter confirms our previous conclusion (Gamaley et al., 2006). Decrease in 3T3-SV40 sensitivity to NK cells activity accompanied by actin reorganization resulted from both latrunculin B and NAC action suggests changes in cellular surface, which ultimately lead to inactivation (or loss) of the molecules being activating signals to NK cells.     

Properties and characterization of a rat spleen cell-derived factor that induces resistance to natural killer cell lysis in YAC lymphoma cells

Supernatants of Con A-stimulated rat spleen cell cultures contain a factor that induces relative resistance to NK cell-mediated cytotoxicity in the YAC cell line, a line that is otherwise highly susceptible to murine NK cell-mediated lysis. This NK-lysis resistance-inducing factor (LRIF) has a Mr of 12,600 Da, as determined by gel filtration chromatography, and an isoelectric pH of 4.8. NK-LRIF is heat labile and is de-activated by treatment with proteolytic enzymes. Unlike immune-IFN (IFN-gamma), NK-LRIF is not inactivated by pH 2 treatment, and antibodies capable of neutralizing IFN-alpha and IFN-gamma do not abrogate the effect of NK-LRIF. Highly purified IL-2 preparations lack NK-LRIF activity. NK-LRIF does not induce a general resistance to lysis in YAC cells, because control and NK-LRIF-treated YAC cells were equally susceptible to alloimmune cytotoxic T cells. YAC cells treated with NK-LRIF showed a marked enhancement (5- to 10-fold) in the expression of class I MHC Ag. This observation supports the proposition that the NK susceptibility of target cells could be inversely related to the expression of class I MHC Ag.     

Acute exposure to human interferon-alpha affects ion currents in human natural killer cells.

Interferon-alpha (IFN-alpha) is a particularly potent stimulator of human natural killer (NK) cell activity. The initial trigger for IFN action is not known, but there is indirect evidence from a number of cell types that changes in ion channel activity are among the earliest responses. Previous evidence includes changes in Ca2+ fluxes and intracellular activity, membrane potential changes, and effects of ion-channel blockers. Killing by human NK cells is dependent on external Ca2+ and on K+ channel activity. In the present study we have confirmed this dependence and the augmentation by human IFN-alpha. Then we directly studied the effects of IFN-alpha on ion currents in human NK cells using the patch-clamp electrophysiological techniques. We find that IFN-alpha can increase the predominant K+ current near the resting potential but suppresses it at higher voltages. Within 1 min after acute IFN-alpha treatment a new current is induced. This small current appears to be through nonselective cation channels that allow monovalent and divalent cations, including Ca2+ to permeate. This current presents a possible early triggering mechanism whereby acute exposure to IFN-alpha augments NK cytotoxicity.