TGF-beta-mediated suppression by CD4+CD25+ T cells is facilitated by CTLA-4 signaling

CD4+CD25+ T cells play a pivotal role in immunological homeostasis by their capacity to exert immunosuppressive activity. However, the mechanism by which these cells function is still a subject for debate. We previously reported that surface (membrane) TGF-beta produced by CD4+CD25+ T cells was an effector molecule mediating suppressor function. We now support this finding by imaging surface TGF-beta on Foxp3+CD4+CD25+ T cells in confocal fluorescence microscopy. Then, using a TGF-beta-sensitive mink lung epithelial cell (luciferase) reporter system, we show that surface TGF-beta can be activated to signal upon cell-cell contact. Moreover, if such TGF-beta signaling is blocked in an in vitro assay of CD4+CD25+ T cell suppression by a specific inhibitor of TGF-betaRI, suppressor function is also blocked. Finally, we address the role of CTLA-4 in CD4+CD25+ T cell suppression, showing first that whereas anti-CTLA-4 does not block in vitro suppressor function, it does complement the blocking activity of anti-TGF-beta. We then show with confocal fluorescence microscopy that incubation of CD4+CD25+ T cells with anti-CTLA-4- and rB7-1/Fc-coated beads results in accumulation of TGF-beta at the cell-bead contact site. This suggests that CTLA-4 signaling facilitates TGF-beta-mediated suppression by intensifying the TGF-beta signal at the point of suppressor cell-target cell interaction.     

TGF-beta 1 plays an important role in the mechanism of CD4+CD25+ regulatory T cell activity in both humans and mice

In previous studies, we have shown that murine CD4+CD25+ regulatory T cells produce high levels of TGF-beta1 in a cell surface and/or secreted form, and blockade of such TGF-beta1 by anti-TGF-beta curtails the ability of these cells to suppress CD25- T cell proliferation and B cell Ig production in in vitro suppressor assays. In further support for the role of TGF-beta1 in suppression by CD4+CD25+ T cells, we show in this study that another TGF-beta1-blocking molecule, recombinant latency-associated peptide of TGF-beta1 (rLAP), also reverses suppression by mouse CD4+CD25+ T cells as well as their human counterparts, CD4+CD25(high) T cells. In addition, we show that CD25- T cells exposed to CD4+CD25+ T cells in vitro manifest activation of Smad-2 and induction of CD103, the latter a TGF-beta-inducible surface integrin. In further studies, we show that while CD4+CD25+ T cells from TGF-beta1-deficient mice can suppress CD25- T cell proliferation in vitro, these cells do not protect recipient mice from colitis in the SCID transfer model in vivo, and, in addition, CD4+LAP+, but not CD4+LAP- T cells from normal mice protect recipient mice from colitis in this model. Together, these studies demonstrate that TGF-beta1 produced by CD4+CD25+ T cells is involved in the suppressor activity of these cells, particularly in their ability to regulate intestinal inflammation.     

Distinct effects of TGF-beta 1 on CD4+ and CD8+ T cell survival, division, and IL-2 production: a role for T cell intrinsic Smad3

TGF-beta1 is critical for maintaining T cell homeostasis. Smad3 has been implicated in this regulatory process, yet the cellular targets and molecular details remain poorly understood. In this study, we report that TGF-beta1 impairs the entry of CD4+ and CD8+ T cells into the cell cycle as well as their progression through subsequent rounds of division, and show that Smad3 is essential for TGF-beta1 to inhibit TCR-induced division of only CD4+ and not CD8+ T cells. Both CD8+ and CD4+ T cells from Smad3-/- mice were refractory to TGF-beta1-induced inhibition of IL-2 production, thus demonstrating that not all CD8+ T cell responses to TGF-beta1 are Smad3 independent. These TGF-beta1 effects were all T cell intrinsic, as they were reproduced in purified CD4+ and CD8+ T cells. Finally, we found that Smad3 was critical for the survival of CD8+, but not CD4+ T cells following activation ex vivo. The TCR-induced death of Smad3-/- CD8+ T cells was not dependent upon TNF-alpha production. Exogenous TGF-beta1 partially rescued the CD8+ T cells by signaling through a Smad3-independent pathway. TGF-beta1 also enhanced survival of TCR-stimulated CD4+CD44high T cells in a Smad3-independent manner. Collectively, these findings firmly establish for the first time that TGF-beta1 discriminately regulates CD4+ and CD8+ T cell expansion by signaling through distinct intracellular pathways.     

TGF-beta 1 uses distinct mechanisms to inhibit IFN-gamma expression in CD4+ T cells at priming and at recall: differential involvement of Stat4 and T-bet

TGF-beta1 plays a critical role in restraining pathogenic Th1 autoimmune responses in vivo, but the mechanisms that mediate TGF-beta1's suppressive effects on CD4(+) T cell expression of IFN-gamma expression remain incompletely understood. To evaluate mechanisms by which TGF-beta1 inhibits IFN-gamma expression in CD4(+) T cells, we primed naive wild-type murine BALB/c CD4(+) T cells in vitro under Th1 development conditions in the presence or the absence of added TGF-beta1. We found that the presence of TGF-beta1 during priming of CD4(+) T cells suppressed both IFN-gamma expression during priming as well as the development of Th1 effector cells expressing IFN-gamma at a recall stimulation. TGF-beta1 inhibited the development of IFN-gamma-expressing cells in a dose-dependent fashion and in the absence of APC, indicating that TGF-beta1 can inhibit Th1 development by acting directly on the CD4(+) T cell. During priming, TGF-beta1 strongly inhibited the expression of both T-bet (T box expressed in T cells) and Stat4. We evaluated the importance of these two molecules in the suppression of IFN-gamma expression at the two phases of Th1 responses. Enforced expression of T-bet by retrovirus prevented TGF-beta1's inhibition of Th1 development, but did not prevent TGF-beta1's inhibition of IFN-gamma expression at priming. Conversely, enforced expression of Stat4 partly prevented TGF-beta1's inhibition of IFN-gamma expression during priming, but did not prevent TGF-beta1's inhibition of Th1 development. These data show that TGF-beta1 uses distinct mechanisms to inhibit IFN-gamma expression in CD4(+) T cells at priming and at recall.     

Spontaneous renal allograft acceptance associated with "regulatory" dendritic cells and IDO

MHC-mismatched DBA/2 renal allografts are spontaneously accepted by C57BL/6 mice by poorly understood mechanisms, but both immune regulation and graft acceptance develop without exogenous immune modulation. Previous studies have shown that this model of spontaneous renal allograft acceptance is associated with TGF-beta-dependent immune regulation, suggesting a role for T regulatory cells. The current study shows that TGF-beta immune regulation develops 30 days posttransplant, but is lost by 150 days posttransplant. Despite loss of detectable TGF-beta immune regulation, renal allografts continue to function normally for >200 days posttransplantation. Because of its recently described immunoregulatory capabilities, we studied IDO expression in this model, and found that intragraft IDO gene expression progressively increases over time, and that IDO in "regulatory" dendritic cells (RDC) may contribute to regulation associated with long-term maintenance of renal allografts. Immunohistochemistry evaluation confirms the presence of both Foxp3+ T cells and IDO+ DCs in accepted renal allografts, and localization of both cell types within accepted allografts suggests the possibility of synergistic involvement in allograft acceptance. Interestingly, at the time when RDCs become detectable in spleens of allograft acceptors, approximately 30% of these mice challenged with donor-matched skin allografts accept these skin grafts, demonstrating progression to "true" tolerance. Together, these data suggest that spontaneous renal allograft acceptance evolves through a series of transient mechanisms, beginning with TGF-beta and T regulatory cells, which together may stimulate development of more robust regulation associated with RDC and IDO.     

TGF-beta regulates airway responses via T cells

Allergic asthma is characterized by airway hyperreactivity, inflammation, and a Th2-type cytokine profile favoring IgE production. Beneficial effects of TGF-beta and conflicting results regarding the role of Th1 cytokines have been reported from murine asthma models. In this study, we examined the T cell as a target cell of TGF-beta-mediated immune regulation in a mouse model of asthma. We demonstrate that impairment of TGF-beta signaling in T cells of transgenic mice expressing a dominant-negative TGF-beta type II receptor leads to a decrease in airway reactivity in a non-Ag-dependent model. Increased serum levels of IFN-gamma can be detected in these animals. In contrast, after injection of OVA adsorbed to alum and challenge with OVA aerosol, transgenic animals show an increased airway reactivity and inflammation compared with those of wild-type animals. IL-13 levels in bronchoalveolar lavage fluid and serum as well as the number of inducible NO synthase-expressing cells in lung infiltrates were increased in transgenic animals. These results demonstrate an important role for TGF-beta signaling in T cells in the regulation of airway responses and suggest that the beneficial effects observed for TGF-beta in airway hyperreactivity and inflammation may be due to its regulatory effects on T cells.     

Cloned cytolytic T cells can suppress primary cytotoxic responses directed against them

In vivo and in vitro, murine peripheral T cells can suppress or "veto" the activation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes directed against antigens presented by those T cells. This suppression is antigen-specific and H-2-restricted. The recognition event initiating this suppression appears to be unidirectional; precursors of cytotoxic T lymphocytes recognize the antigen-bearing veto cell and are thereby inactivated--the veto cell need not recognize the CTL precursor. We show here that 3/3 cytolytic T cell clones can exert veto activity in vitro on normal spleen cells which do not bear antigens the T cell clones can recognize. This suppression results in greatly diminished cytotoxic activity generated during a primary 5-day mixed lymphocyte culture against antigens which the veto cell expresses, but not against third-party antigens present in the same culture. In this same system, a noncytolytic T cell clone will not serve as a source of veto cells. Secondary cytotoxic responses are relatively resistant to the veto cell activity of cloned cytolytic T cells. The cloned veto cells do not suppress the generation of cytotoxic activity directed against antigens they recognize (and presumably carry over via antigen-specific receptors). Cold target competition during the cytotoxic assay has been eliminated as a possible mechanism for T cell clone-induced suppression, and suppression cannot be reversed by the addition to the mixed lymphocyte cultures of supernatants from concanavalin A-activated spleen cells. It is suggested that this mechanism of inactivating primary cytotoxic T lymphocyte responses could play an important role in the maintenance of self-tolerance and in the induction and maintenance of tolerance to allografts.     

Peptide-specific CD8 T regulatory cells use IFN-gamma to elaborate TGF-beta-based suppression

We identified a murine peptide-specific CD8 T regulatory cell population able to suppress responding CD4 T cells. Immunization with OVA, poly(I:C), and anti-4-1BB generated a population of SIINFEKL-specific CD8 T regulatory cells that profoundly inhibited peptide-responding CD4 T cells from cellular division. The mechanism of suppression required IFN-gamma, but IFN-gamma alone was not sufficient to suppress the responding CD4 T cells. The data show that CD8 T regulatory cells were unable to suppress unless they engaged IFN-gamma. Furthermore, even in the absence of recall with peptide, the CD8 T regulatory cells suppressed CD4 responses as long as IFN-gamma was present. To examine the effector mechanism of suppression, we showed that neutralizing TGF-beta inhibited suppression because inclusion of anti-TGF-beta rescued the proliferative capacity of the responding cells. TGF-beta-based suppression was dependent completely upon the CD8 T regulatory cells being capable of binding IFN-gamma. This was the case, although peptide recall of primed IFN-gamma (-/-) or IFN-gammaR(-/-) CD8 T cells up-regulated pro-TGF-beta protein as measured by surface latency-associated peptide expression but yet were unable to suppress. Finally, we asked whether the CD8 T regulatory cells were exposed to active TGF-beta in vivo and showed that only wild-type CD8 T regulatory cells expressed the TGF-beta-dependent biomarker CD103, suggesting that latency-associated peptide expression is not always congruent with elaboration of active TGF-beta. These data define a novel mechanism whereby IFN-gamma directly stimulates CD8 T regulatory cells to elaborate TGF-beta-based suppression. Ultimately, this mechanism may permit regulation of pathogenic Th1 responses by CD8 T regulatory cells.     

Long-term control of alloreactive B cell responses by the suppression of T cell help

Alloantibodies can play a key role in acute and chronic allograft rejection. However, relatively little is known of factors that control B cell responses following allograft tolerance induction. Using 3-83 Igi mice expressing an alloreactive BCR, we recently reported that allograft tolerance was associated with the sustained deletion of the alloreactive B cells at the mature, but not the immature, stage. We have now investigated the basis for the long-term control of alloreactive B cell responses in a non-BCR-transgenic model of C57BL/6 cardiac transplantation into BALB/c recipients treated with anti-CD154 and transfusion of donor-specific spleen cells. We demonstrate that the long-term production of alloreactive Abs by alloreactive B cells is actively regulated in tolerant BALB/c mice through the dominant suppression of T cell help. Deletion of CD25(+) cells resulted in a loss of tolerance and an acquisition of the ability to acutely reject allografts. In contrast, the restoration of alloantibody responses required both the deletion of CD25(+) cells and the reconstitution of alloreactive B cells. Collectively, these data suggest that alloreactive B cell responses in this model of tolerance are controlled by dominant suppression of T cell help as well as the deletion of alloreactive B cells in the periphery.     

Cutting edge: TGF-beta signaling is required for the in vivo expansion and immunosuppressive capacity of regulatory CD4+CD25+ T cells

Data regarding the role of TGF-beta for the in vivo function of regulatory CD4(+)CD25(+) T cells (Treg) are controversial. A transgenic mouse model with impaired TGF-beta signaling specifically in T cells was used to assess the role of endogenous TGF-beta for the in vivo function of CD4(+)CD25(+) Treg in a murine model of colitis induced by dextran sulfate. Transfer of wild-type, but not transgenic CD4(+)CD25(+) Treg was found to suppress colitis in wild-type mice. In addition, by transferring CFSE-labeled CD4(+)CD25(+) Treg we could demonstrate that endogenous TGF-beta promotes the expansion of CD4(+)CD25(+) Treg in vivo. Transgenic mice themselves developed reduced numbers of peripheral CD4(+)CD25(+) Treg and were more susceptible to the induction of colitis, which could be prevented by the transfer of wild-type Treg. These data indicate that TGF-beta signaling in CD4(+)CD25(+) Treg is required for their in vivo expansion and suppressive capacity.     

CD3-specific antibody-induced immune tolerance involves transforming growth factor-beta from phagocytes digesting apoptotic T cells

Intact CD3-specific antibody transiently depletes large numbers of T cells and subsequently induces long-term immune tolerance. The underlying mechanisms for the systemic tolerance, however, remain unclear. We show here that treatment of normal mice with intact antibody to CD3 increases systemic transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) produced by phagocytes exposed to apoptotic T cells. Among the phagocytes, macrophages and immature dendritic cells (iDCs) secrete TGF-beta upon ingestion of apoptotic T cells, which induces CD4+Foxp3+ regulatory T cells in culture and contributes to immune tolerance mediated by CD3-specific antibody in vivo. In accordance with these results, depletion of macrophages and iDCs not only abrogates CD3-specific antibody-mediated prevention of myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein-induced acute experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE), but also reverses the therapeutic effects of antibody to CD3 on established disease in a model of relapsing-remitting EAE. Thus, CD3-specific antibody-induced immune tolerance is associated with TGF-beta production in phagocytes involved in clearing apoptotic T cells, which suggests that apoptosis is linked to active suppression in immune tolerance.     

Cutting edge: deficiency in the E3 ubiquitin ligase Cbl-b results in a multifunctional defect in T cell TGF-beta sensitivity in vitro and in vivo

Mice deficient in the E3 ubiquitin ligase Cbl-b have CD28-independent T cells and develop autoimmunity. We previously reported that Cbl-b-/- CD4+CD25- T effector cells are resistant in vitro to the antiproliferative effects of CD4+CD25+ regulatory T cells and TGF-beta. We have now asked whether the resistance noted in Cbl-b-/- T cells is restricted solely to TGF-beta's antiproliferative effects, whether the TGF-beta resistance has in vivo relevance, and whether a defect can be identified in the TGF-beta signaling pathway. We now demonstrate the following: 1) in vitro, Cbl-b deficiency prevents the TGF-beta-mediated induction of Foxp3+ functional regulatory T cells; 2) in vivo, Cbl-b-/- mice show a significantly enhanced response to a tumor that is strictly TGF-beta regulated; and 3) Cbl-b-/- T effector cells have defective TGF-beta-mediated Smad2 phosphorylation. These studies are the first to document that the E3 ubiquitin ligase Cbl-b plays an integral role in T cell TGF-beta signaling, and that its absence results in multifunctional TGF-beta-related defects that have important disease-related implications.     

TGF-beta as a T cell regulator in colitis and colon cancer

TGF-beta is a pleiotropic cytokine with powerful immunosuppressive functions. Mice deficient for TGF-beta1 show a dramatic phenotype with severe multiorgan inflammation and die shortly after birth. Recent investigations have highlighted the role of TGF-beta in suppression of T cell mediated autoimmune inflammation and anti-tumor immunity. In addition to its direct anti-inflammatory effects on T cells, TGF-beta has been implicated as central regulator of regulatory T cells. TGF-beta not only mediates the suppression of effector T cells by Tregs, recent evidence also reveals a role for TGF-beta along with TCR stimulation in the peripheral induction of regulatory T cells from na?ve CD4+CD25- cells.     

Linked suppression across an MHC-mismatched barrier in a miniature swine kidney transplantation model

We have demonstrated previously that a 12-day course of FK506 permits the induction of tolerance to fully MHC-mismatched renal transplants in miniature swine. In the present study, we examined the mechanism of this tolerance by assessing the possibility that the survival of one-haplotype mismatched third-party kidneys might be prolonged via linked suppression. Ten SLA(d/d) miniature swine received fully MHC-mismatched renal allografts from SLA(c/c) donors with 12 days of FK506. Six animals received second SLA(c/c) kidneys without immunosuppression to confirm tolerance. Regulatory mechanisms were assessed by mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) and cell-mediated lympholysis coculture assays and ELISA for regulatory cytokines. Linked suppression was investigated by transplanting SLA(a/c) or SLA(a/d) allografts into long-term tolerant recipients without immunosuppression. All recipients showed donor-specific unresponsiveness in standard cell-mediated lympholysis and MLR assays. Tolerant cells prestimulated with donor Ag and then cocultured with naive recipient MHC-matched cells inhibited antidonor responses, confirming the presence of regulatory cells. ELISA and MLR assays showed that TGF-beta2 was involved in mediating the suppression in vitro. SLA(a/d) renal allografts transplanted into tolerant recipients were rejected by postoperative day 8 (median, 7 days; range, 6-8). In contrast, SLA(a/c) allografts showed markedly prolonged survival (median, 52 days; range, 28-78; p = 0.0246), suggesting linked suppression. Animals not challenged with a second donor-matched graft did not manifest linked suppression consistent with in vitro data showing that re-exposure to tolerated Ags is important for generation of regulatory cells. To our knowledge, these data represent the first evidence of linked suppression across fully MHC-mismatched barriers in a large animal model.     

Requirements for apoptotic cell contact in regulation of macrophage responses

An important consequence of macrophage engulfment of apoptotic cells is suppression of inflammatory responses, which was first defined by assay of TNF-alpha release stimulated by LPS. These effects are apparently mediated in part by paracrine effects of TGF-beta released by the subset of stimulated macrophages that ingest apoptotic cells, which suppresses neighboring cells. However, the apoptotic cell-derived signal that stimulates TGF-beta release, and the nature of any additional signals required for the anti-inflammatory response remain poorly defined. In this study, we investigate the requirements for apoptotic cell engagement of macrophage surface receptors in these responses. We show that the apoptotic cell receptors CD36 and alphavbeta3 contribute to apoptotic cell phagocytosis by mouse macrophages, but are not essential for anti-inflammatory responses, suggesting that the mechanisms of response and phagocytosis are separate. In further defining requirements for response, we confirm the importance of TGF-beta in suppression by apoptotic cells, and identify an additional level of control of these effects. We show that LPS-stimulated mouse macrophage TNF-alpha release is only suppressed if macrophages have first contacted apoptotic cells, and hence, bystander macrophages are refractory to TGF-beta released by phagocytosing macrophages. We conclude that the profound suppression of LPS-driven TNF-alpha release by macrophage populations requires hitherto obscure contact-dependent licensing of macrophage responsiveness to TGF-beta by apoptotic cells.     

p21Cip1 and p27Kip1 act in synergy to alter the sensitivity of naive T cells to TGF-beta-mediated G1 arrest through modulation of IL-2 responsiveness

Induction of G(1) arrest by TGF-beta correlates with the regulation of p21(Cip1) and p27(Kip1), members of the Cip/Kip family of cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitors (cki). However, no definitive evidence exists that these proteins play a causal role in TGF-beta(1)-induced growth arrest in lymphocytes. In this report we show the suppression of cell cycle progression by TGF-beta is diminished in T cells from mice deficient for both p21(Cip1) and p27(Kip1) (double-knockout (DKO)) only when activated under conditions of optimal costimulation. Although there is an IL-2-dependent enhanced proliferation of CD8(+) T cells from DKO mice, TGF-beta is able to maximally suppress the proliferation of DKO T cells when activated under conditions of low costimulatory strength. We also show that the induction of p15(Ink4b) in T cells stimulated in the presence of TGF-beta is not essential, as TGF-beta also efficiently suppressed proliferation of T cells from p15(Ink4b-/-) mice. Finally, although these cki are dispensable for the suppression of T cell proliferation by TGF-beta, we now describe a Smad3-dependent down-regulation of cdk4, suggesting a potential mechanism underlying to resistance of Smad3(-/-) T cells to the induction of growth arrest by TGF-beta. In summary, the growth suppressive effects of TGF-beta in naive T cells are a function of the strength of costimulation, and alterations in the expression of cki modify the sensitivity to TGF-beta by lowering thresholds for a maximal mitogenic response.     

Cell intrinsic TGF-beta 1 regulation of B cells

TGF-beta family cytokines play multiple roles in immune responses. TGF-beta1-null mice suffer from multi-organ infiltration that leads to their premature death. T cells play a central role in the TGF-beta1 phenotype, as deficiency of TGF-beta1 only in T cells reproduces the lethal phenotype. Although it is known that TGF-beta1 controls B cells isotype switch and homeostasis, the source responsible for this control has not been characterized. Because of the major role that T cells play in regulating B cell responses, we addressed the T cell dependency of the TGF-beta1 control of B cells. The analysis of T cell-deficient, TGF-beta1 knockout mice and the production of chimeras in which B but not T cells lacked TGF-beta1 allowed us to show that B cells are controlled in part by cell autonomous production of TGF-beta1.     

Impaired TGF-beta responses in peripheral T cells of G alpha i2-/- mice

Null mutation of heterotrimeric G protein alpha2 inhibitory subunit (Galphai2) induces Th1-skewed hyperimmune responses in the colon, leading to chronic colitis and the development of colonic adenocarcinoma. However, the underlying molecular mechanisms and cellular basis, in particular, for the role of Galphai2 in regulating immune responses, are poorly understood. We show here that peripheral T cells from Galphai2-deficient mice do not respond normally to the inhibitory effects of TGF-beta on proliferation and cytokine production, revealing a previously unappreciated cross-talk between these two signaling pathways. Lack of Galphai2 resulted in decreased phosphorylation of Smad2 and Smad3 in T cells at the basal levels as well as at the late but not early phase of TGF-beta stimulation, which appears to be ascribed to differential expression of neither cell surface TGF-beta receptors nor Smad7. The altered phosphorylation of Smad proteins involves phospholipase C-mediated signaling, a downstream signaling molecule of Galphai2, because phospholipase C inhibitors could restore Smad2 and Smad3 phosphorylation in Galphai2(-/-) T cells at levels comparable to that in wild-type T cells. Moreover, adoptive transfer of Galphai2-deficient T cells into immunocompromised mice rendered an otherwise resistant mouse strain susceptible to trinitrobenzesulfonic acid-induced colitis, suggesting that an impaired response of Galphai2-deficient T cells to TGF-beta may be one of the primary defects accounting for the observed colonic Th1-skewed hyperimmune responses. These findings shed new lights on the molecular and cellular basis of how Galphai2 down-regulates immune responses, contributing to the maintenance of mucosal tolerance.