Analysis of denitrification genes and comparison of nosZ, cnorB and 16S rDNA from culturable denitrifying bacteria in potato cropping systems

Bacterial denitrification in agricultural soils is a major source of nitrous oxide, a potent greenhouse gas. This study examined the culturable bacterial population of denitrifiers in arable field soils in potato (Solanum tuberosum L.) production and denitrification genes (nir, nor and nos) and 16S rDNA in those isolates. Enrichments for culturable denitrifiers yielded 31 diverse isolates that were then analysed for denitrification genes. The nitrous oxide reductase (nosZ) gene was found in all isolates. The majority of isolates ( approximately 90%) contained the cnorB nitric oxide reductase gene, with the remainder containing the qnorB gene. Nitrite reductase genes (nirS and nirK) were amplifiable from most of the isolates, and were segregated between species similar to previously isolated denitrifiers. Isolated strains were preliminarily identified using fatty acid methyl ester analysis and further identified using 16S rDNA sequencing. The majority of isolates (21) were classified as Pseudomonas sp., with smaller groups of isolates being most similar to Bosea spp. (4), Achromobacter spp. (4) and two isolates closely related to Sinorhizobium/Ensifer spp. Phylogenetic trees were compared among nosZ, cnorB and 16S rDNA genes for a subset of Pseudomonas strains. The trees were mostly congruent, but some Pseudomonas sp. isolates grouped differently depending on the gene analysed, indicating potential horizontal gene transfer of denitrification genes. Although Bosea spp. are known denitrifiers, to the best of our knowledge this is the first report of isolation and sequencing of denitrification genes from this bacterial genus.     

Detection of a nitrous oxide reductase structural gene in Rhizobium meliloti strains and its location on the nod megaplasmid of JJ1c10 and SU47.

The gene encoding a denitrification enzyme, nitrous oxide reductase (EC 1.7.99.6), in Rhizobium meliloti and other gram-negative bacteria was detected by hybridization to an internal 1.2-kb PstI fragment of the structural gene (nosZ) cloned from Pseudomonas stutzeri Zobell (W.G. Zumft, A. Viebrock-Sambale, and C. Braun, Eur. J. Biochem. 192:591-599, 1990). Homology to the probe was detected in the DNAs of two N2-fixing strains of P. stutzeri, two denitrifying Pseudomonas species, one Alcaligenes eutrophus strain, and 36 of 56 R. meliloti isolates tested. Except for two isolates of R. meliloti, all showed nitrous oxide reduction activity (Nos+). Therefore, at least part of the nosZ sequence appears to be conserved and widely distributed among denitrifiers, which include free-living and symbiotic diazotrophs. By using Agrobacterium tumefaciens transconjugants harboring different megaplasmids of R. meliloti JJ1c10 and SU47, sequence homology with the nosZ probe was unequivocally located on the nod megaplasmid. A cosmid clone of JJ1c10 in which nosZ homology was mapped on a 4.2-kb BamHI fragment was selected. This cosmid, which conferred Nos+ activity to the R. meliloti wild-type strains ATCC 9930 and Balsac (Nos- and nondenitrifying, respectively) also restored Nos+ activity in the mutants of JJ1c10 and SU47 in which the 4.2-kb BamHI segment was deleted. Therefore, this segment contains sequences essential for nos gene expression in JJ1c10 and SU47 and thus confirms that the nod megaplasmid in JJ1c10 and SU47 which carries genes essential for symbiotic dinitrogen fixation also carries genes involved in the antagonistic process of denitrification.     

Characterization of the denitrifying bacterial community in a full-scale rockwool biofilter for compost waste-gas treatment

The potential denitrification activity and the composition of the denitrifying bacterial community in a full-scale rockwool biofilter used for treating livestock manure composting emissions were analyzed. Packing material sampled from the rockwool biofilter was anoxically batch-incubated with 15N-labeled nitrate in the presence of different electron donors (compost extract, ammonium, hydrogen sulfide, propionate, and acetate), and responses were compared with those of activated sludge from a livestock wastewater treatment facility. Overnight batch-incubation showed that potential denitrification activity for the rockwool samples was higher with added compost extract than with other potential electron donors. The number of 16S rRNA and nosZ genes in the rockwool samples were in the range of 1.64–3.27 × 109 and 0.28–2.27 × 108 copies/g dry, respectively. Denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis analysis targeting nirK, nirS, and nosZ genes indicated that the distribution of nir genes was spread in a vertical direction and the distribution of nosZ genes was spread horizontally within the biofilter. The corresponding denitrifying enzymes were mainly related to those from Phyllobacteriaceae, Bradyrhizobiaceae, and Alcaligenaceae bacteria and to environmental clones retrieved from agricultural soil, activated sludge, freshwater environments, and guts of earthworms or other invertebrates. A nosZ gene fragment having 99% nucleotide sequence identity with that of Oligotropha carboxidovorans was also detected. Some nirK fragments were related to NirK from micro-aerobic environments. Thus, denitrification in this full-scale rockwool biofilter might be achieved by a consortium of denitrifying bacteria adapted to the intensely aerated ecosystem and utilizing mainly organic matter supplied by the livestock manure composting waste-gas stream.     

Characteristics of bacteria showing high denitrification activity in saline wastewater

AIMS: Denitrification efficiency at 10% salinity was compared with that at 2% salinity. The characteristics of bacterial strains isolated from the denitrification system, where an improvement of denitrification efficiency was observed at a high salinity were investigated. METHODS AND RESULTS: Two continuous feeding denitrification systems for saline solutions of 2% and 10% salinity, were operated. Denitrification efficiency at 10% salinity was higher than that at 2% salinity. The bacterial strains were isolated using the trypticase soy agar (TSA) medium at 30 degrees C. The phylogenetic analysis of 16S rRNA gene sequences of isolates indicated that halophilic species were predominant at 10% salinity. CONCLUSIONS: The improvement of denitrification efficiency at a high salinity was demonstrated. The strains isolated from the denitrifying system with 10% salinity were halophilic bacteria, Halomonas sp. and Marinobacter sp., suggesting that these bacteria show a high denitrifying activity at 10% salinity. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: The long-term acclimated sludge used in this study resulted in high denitrification performance at a high salinity, indicating that the design of a high-performance denitrification system for saline wastewater will be possible.     

Abundance of narG, nirS, nirK, and nosZ genes of denitrifying bacteria during primary successions of a glacier foreland

Quantitative PCR of denitrification genes encoding the nitrate, nitrite, and nitrous oxide reductases was used to study denitrifiers across a glacier foreland. Environmental samples collected at different distances from a receding glacier contained amounts of 16S rRNA target molecules ranging from 4.9 x 10(5) to 8.9 x 10(5) copies per nanogram of DNA but smaller amounts of narG, nirK, and nosZ target molecules. Thus, numbers of narG, nirK, nirS, and nosZ copies per nanogram of DNA ranged from 2.1 x 10(3) to 2.6 x 10(4), 7.4 x 10(2) to 1.4 x 10(3), 2.5 x 10(2) to 6.4 x 10(3), and 1.2 x 10(3) to 5.5 x 10(3), respectively. The densities of 16S rRNA genes per gram of soil increased with progressing soil development. The densities as well as relative abundances of different denitrification genes provide evidence that different denitrifier communities develop under primary succession: higher percentages of narG and nirS versus 16S rRNA genes were observed in the early stage of primary succession, while the percentages of nirK and nosZ genes showed no significant increase or decrease with soil age. Statistical analyses revealed that the amount of organic substances was the most important factor in the abundance of eubacteria as well as of nirK and nosZ communities, and copy numbers of these two genes were the most important drivers changing the denitrifying community along the chronosequence. This study yields an initial insight into the ecology of bacteria carrying genes for the denitrification pathway in a newly developing alpine environment.     

一株荧光假单胞杆菌的分离鉴定与反硝化特性

【目的】从污水厂的活性污泥中获得一株高效反硝化细菌。【方法】采用低温驯化,进行初筛、复筛选取一株反硝化活性最高的菌株,命名为L2,通过形态学、生理生化特征及16S r RNA基因序列分析研究其分类地位,系统研究理化因素对该菌株反硝化性能的影响。【结果】菌株在低温条件下能够稳定高效地进行反硝化,鉴定该菌株为荧光假单胞杆菌(Pseudomonas fluorescens),其反硝化最适接种量为10%,温度为20°C,p H为7.0,盐浓度为0.5%,碳源为葡萄糖,C/N为5.0,能够耐受较高初始硝态氮浓度。【结论】菌株L2是一株耐低温、耐高浓度初始硝态氮、耐低C/N、兼性厌氧、高效反硝化的荧光假单胞杆菌。     

Spatially tripartite interactions of denitrifiers in arctic ecosystems: activities, functional groups and soil resources

Soil denitrification is one of the most significant contributors to global nitrous oxide (N(2) O) emissions, and spatial patterns of denitrifying communities and their functions may reveal the factors that drive denitrification potential and functional consortia. Although denitrifier spatial patterns have been studied extensively in most soil ecosystems, little is known about these processes in arctic soils. This study aimed to unravel the spatial relationships among denitrifier abundance, denitrification potential and soil resources in 279 soil samples collected from three Canadian arctic ecosystems encompassing 7° in latitude and 27° in longitude. The abundance of nirS (10(6) -10(8) copies?g(-1) dry soil), nirK (10(3) -10(7) copies?g(-1) dry soil) and nosZ (10(6) -10(7) copies?g(-1) dry soil) genes in these soils is in the similar range as non-arctic soil ecosystems. Potential denitrification in Organic Cryosols (1034?ng?N(2) O-N?g(-1) soil) was 5-11 times higher than Static/Turbic Cryosols and the overall denitrification potential in Cryosols was also comparable to other ecosystems. We found denitrifier functional groups and potential denitrification were highly spatially dependent within a scale of 5?m. Functional groups and soil resources were significantly (P?相似文献   

Phenotypic and genotypic heterogeneity among closely related soil-borne N2 - and N2 O-producing Bacillus isolates harboring the nosZ gene

Little is known about the genetic and phenotypic diversity of Gram-positive denitrifying bacteria. We compared the production of gaseous denitrification products for 14 closely related Bacillus soil isolates at pH 6 and 7 during 48-h batch incubations using a robotic gas-sampling apparatus. Primers targeting the nosZ gene encoding the nitrous oxide reductase were designed to confirm the presence of this gene in the isolates. The variation in the production of gaseous nitrogen products was compared with the genetic variation based on 16S rRNA gene sequences, genomic fingerprinting and nosZ sequences. The nosZ gene was detected in all isolates and all produced N(2) as the dominant end product at pH 7. Production of gaseous nitrogen products was more variable at pH 6, with different levels of NO and N(2) O production among the isolates, although minimal variation was observed among the 16S rRNA and nosZ gene sequences. One isolate was more divergent from the others based on genomic fingerprinting, and had two different nosZ gene copies, which coincided with the highest production of N(2) at pH 7 and the lack of intermediates at pH 6. Overall, our analysis suggests that genetic variation plays a role in the variation in N(2) O and N(2) production, but the variation in activity caused by acidification can be substantially greater than genotypic variation among closely related Bacillus.     

Reduction in denitrification activity in field soils exposed to long term contamination by 2,4,6-trinitrotoluene (TNT)

Terrestrial sites contaminated with 2,4,6-trinitrotoluene (TNT) are a widespread and persistent problem and often contain non-vegetated areas with TNT concentrations well in excess of 1000 mg kg(-1). In this study, we examined the effect of TNT on denitrification activity in field soils, and compared the sensitivity of denitrifying enzymes to TNT. DNA probes assessed the prevalence of nirS, nirK and nosZ (encoding cd(1) or copper nitrite reductase and nitrous oxide reductase, respectively), denitrifying genotypes in the culturable and total microbial community. The nitrate (NaR), nitrite (NiR) and nitrous oxide (N(2)OR) reductase activities in field soil and in isolates were assessed by gas chromatography. The relative occurrence of the nirK, nirS or nosZ genotypes increased in the cultured community and in total uncultured community DNA as nitroaromatic concentrations increased. However, denitrifying activity decreased in response to increasing TNT concentrations, with an IC(50) for NaR+NiR+nitric oxide reductase (NOR) of 400 mg TNT kg(-1) soil and for N(2)OR of 26 mg TNT kg(-1) soil. The denitrifying activity of four soil isolates also decreased in response to TNT, with N(2)OR activity being three times more sensitive to TNT than NaR+NiR+NOR activity. Interestingly, there were 118 times more nirK isolates than nirS isolates in uncontaminated soil but only 1.5 times more in soil containing 17400 mg kg(-1) TNT. The results from this study indicated that TNT reduced denitrification activity in field soils, and N(2)OR was much more sensitive to TNT than NaR+NiR+NOR.     

Activity and composition of the denitrifying bacterial community respond differently to long-term fertilization

The objective of this study was to explore the long-term effects of different organic and inorganic fertilizers on activity and composition of the denitrifying and total bacterial communities in arable soil. Soil from the following six treatments was analyzed in an experimental field site established in 1956: cattle manure, sewage sludge, Ca(NO3)2, (NH4)2SO4, and unfertilized and unfertilized bare fallow. All plots but the fallow were planted with corn. The activity was measured in terms of potential denitrification rate and basal soil respiration. The nosZ and narG genes were used as functional markers of the denitrifying community, and the composition was analyzed using denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis of nosZ and restriction fragment length polymorphism of narG, together with cloning and sequencing. A fingerprint of the total bacterial community was assessed by ribosomal intergenic spacer region analysis (RISA). The potential denitrification rates were higher in plots treated with organic fertilizer than in those with only mineral fertilizer. The basal soil respiration rates were positively correlated to soil carbon content, and the highest rates were found in the plots with the addition of sewage sludge. Fingerprints of the nosZ and narG genes, as well as the RISA, showed significant differences in the corresponding communities in the plots treated with (NH4)2SO4 and sewage sludge, which exhibited the lowest pH. In contrast, similar patterns were observed among the other four treatments, unfertilized plots with and without crops and the plots treated with Ca(NO3)2 or with manure. This study shows that the addition of different fertilizers affects both the activity and the composition of the denitrifying communities in arable soil on a long-term basis. However, the treatments in which the denitrifying and bacterial community composition differed the most did not correspond to treatments with the most different activities, showing that potential activity was uncoupled to community composition.     

Polyphosphate accumulation among denitrifying bacteria in activated sludge

Bacterial polyphosphate accumulation and denitrification are important processes in biological removal of nutrients from wastewater. It has been suggested that phosphorus accumulators are able to denitrify. However, the bacteria known as the most important phosphorus accumulators, belonging to the genus Acinetobacter are generally not known to denitrify. To clarify how commonly both physiological traits are present in the same organism, we screened 165 isolates from activated sludge and wastewater for their ability to denitrify, and the ability of the denitrifying isolates to accumulate polyphosphate. Of the 165 isolates, 149 were from acetate mineral medium (87 of these identified as Acinetobacter by the API 20 NE identification system) and 16 were from nutrient broth and nitrate medium. Only 15 of 165 isolates tested showed true respiratory denitrification activity. In the presence of acetylene they converted more than 80% of 5mM NO3- to N2O in 6 days. None of the Acinetobacter isolates were among the 15 respiratory denitrifiers. The denitrifying isolates were identified as species of Pseudomonas, Agrobacterium, Pasteurella, Sphingomonas or could not be identified by the API 20 NE identification system. According to the BIOLOG identification system the denitrifiers were species of Pseudomonas, Hydrogenophaga, Citrobacter, Xanthomonas or they could not be identified. The ability of confirmed denitrifiers to accumulate phosphate was measured in experiments where cells pregrown under phosphorus limitation were exposed to phosphate (8 mg P/L) under aerobic conditions. The rates of excess phosphate uptake varied from 0.3 to more than 23 mg P/g dry matter/h. Rates for four isolates were higher than those reported for Acinetobacter strains. These results show that polyphosphate accumulation and denitrification in activated sludge can be carried out by the same organisms.     

Changes in bacterial denitrifier community abundance over time in an agricultural field and their relationship with denitrification activity

This study measured total bacterial and denitrifier community abundances over time in an agricultural soil cropped to potatoes (Solanum tuberosum L.) by using quantitative PCR. Samples were collected on 10 dates from spring to autumn and from three spatial locations: in the potato "hill" between plants (H), close to the plant (H(p)), and in the "furrow" (F). The denitrification rates, N(2)O emissions, and environmental parameters were also measured. Changes in denitrifier abundance over time and spatial location were small (1.7- to 2.7-fold for the nirK, nosZ, and cnorB(B) guilds), whereas the cnorB(P) community (Pseudomonas mandelii and closely related spp.) showed an approximately 4.6-fold change. The seasonal patterns of denitrifier gene numbers varied with the specific community: lower nosZ gene numbers in April and May than in June and July, higher cnorB(P) gene numbers in May and June than in March and April and September and November, higher nirK gene numbers in early spring than in late autumn, and no change in cnorB(B) gene numbers. Gene numbers were higher for the H(p) than the H location for the nosZ and nirK communities and for the cnorB(P) community on individual dates, presumably indicating an effect of the plant on denitrifier abundance. Higher cnorB(P) gene numbers for the H location than the F location and for nosZ and cnorB(B) on individual dates reflect the effect of spatial location on abundance. Denitrifier abundance changes were not related to any environmental parameter, although a weak relationship exists between cnorB(P) gene numbers, extractable organic carbon values, and temperature. Denitrification and N(2)O emissions were mostly regulated by inorganic nitrogen availability and water-filled pore space but were uncoupled from denitrifier community abundances measured in this system.     

Mathematical estimations of hyper-ammonia producing ruminal bacteria and evidence for bacterial antagonism that decreases ruminal ammonia production(1)

Bacteria capable of denitrification are spread among phylogenetically diverse groups. In the present investigation, molecular methods (amplified ribosomal DNA restriction analysis (ARDRA) and partial 16S rDNA gene sequencing) were used to determine the genetic diversity of culturable denitrifying soil bacteria. The purpose of this work was to study the microbial density and diversity of denitrifying communities isolated from two luvisols and a rendosol. The denitrifying bacterial density was significantly higher in the two luvisols (3x10(6) and 4x10(6) bacteria g(-1) dry soil) than in the rendosol (4x10(5) bacteria g(-1) dry soil). Denitrifying isolates from soils were grouped according to the similarity of their restriction patterns into 26 ARDRA types. Interestingly ARDRA analysis suggests that some denitrifying isolates are specific to a soil type while others seem to be geographically widespread. The number of individual isolates found in each ARDRA type appeared to be highly variable between the two sampling dates but some denitrifying types were capable of persisting in soil. The tree obtained from the partial sequences revealed five major branches exhibiting highest identity to the following genera: (i) Burkholderia-Ralstonia, (ii) Pseudomonas, (iii) Xanthomonas-Frateuria, (iv) Bacillus and (v) Streptomyces. Our 16S rDNA-based analysis clearly reveals broad diversity exceeding that previously described in the literature.     

Community composition and functioning of denitrifying bacteria from adjacent meadow and forest soils

We investigated communities of denitrifying bacteria from adjacent meadow and forest soils. Our objectives were to explore spatial gradients in denitrifier communities from meadow to forest, examine whether community composition was related to ecological properties (such as vegetation type and process rates), and determine phylogenetic relationships among denitrifiers. nosZ, a key gene in the denitrification pathway for nitrous oxide reductase, served as a marker for denitrifying bacteria. Denitrifying enzyme activity (DEA) was measured as a proxy for function. Other variables, such as nitrification potential and soil C/N ratio, were also measured. Soil samples were taken along transects that spanned meadow-forest boundaries at two sites in the H. J. Andrews Experimental Forest in the Western Cascade Mountains of Oregon. Results indicated strong functional and structural community differences between the meadow and forest soils. Levels of DEA were an order of magnitude higher in the meadow soils. Denitrifying community composition was related to process rates and vegetation type as determined on the basis of multivariate analyses of nosZ terminal restriction fragment length polymorphism profiles. Denitrifier communities formed distinct groups according to vegetation type and site. Screening 225 nosZ clones yielded 47 unique denitrifying genotypes; the most dominant genotype occurred 31 times, and half the genotypes occurred once. Several dominant and less-dominant denitrifying genotypes were more characteristic of either meadow or forest soils. The majority of nosZ fragments sequenced from meadow or forest soils were most similar to nosZ from the Rhizobiaceae group in alpha-Proteobacteria species. Denitrifying community composition, as well as environmental factors, may contribute to the variability of denitrification rates in these systems.     

Genetic characterization of denitrifier communities with contrasting intrinsic functional traits

Microorganisms capable of denitrification are polyphyletic and exhibit distinct denitrification regulatory phenotypes (DRP), and thus, denitrification in soils could be controlled by community composition. In a companion study (D?rsch et al., 2012) and preceding work, ex situ denitrification assays of three organic soils demonstrated profoundly different functional traits including N(2) O/N(2) ratios. Here, we explored the composition of the underlying denitrifier communities by analyzing the abundance and structure of denitrification genes (nirK, nirS, and nosZ). The relative abundance of nosZ (vs. nirK + nirS) was similar for all communities, and hence, the low N(2) O reductase activity in one of the soils was not because of the lack of organisms with this gene. Similarity in community composition between the soils was generally low for nirK and nirS, but not for nosZ. The community with the most robust denitrification (consistently low N(2) O/N(2) ) had the highest diversity/richness of nosZ and nirK, but not of nirS. Contrary results found for a second soil agreed with impaired denitrification (low overall denitrification activity, high N(2) O/N(2) ). In conclusion, differences in community composition and in the absolute abundance of denitrification genes clearly reflected the functional differences observed in laboratory studies and may shed light on differences in in situ N(2) O emission of the soils.     

Molecular analysis of halophilic bacterial community for high-rate denitrification of saline industrial wastewater

A denitrification system for saline wastewater utilizing halophilic denitrifying bacteria has not been developed so far. In this study, denitrification performance and microbial community under various saline conditions were investigated using denitrifying sludge acclimated under low-salinity condition for a few years as seed sludge. A continuous denitrification experiment showed that denitrification performance and microbial community at 10% salinity was higher than that at 1% salinity. The microbial community in the denitrification sludge that was acclimated under low salinity was monitored by terminal-restriction fragment length polymorphism (T-RFLP) analysis during acclimation to high-salinity condition. T-RFLP profiles and clone analysis based on 16S rRNA-encoding genes in the sludge of the denitrification system with 10% salinity indicated that the γ-Proteobacteria, particularly Halomonas spp., were predominant species, suggesting that these bacterial members were possibly responsible for a high denitrification activity under high-salinity conditions. Furthermore, the investigation of denitrification performance under various saline conditions revealed that 4–10% salinity results in the highest denitrification rate, indicating that this salinity was optimal for predominant bacterial species to exhibit denitrification activity. These results indicate the possibility that an appropriate denitrification system for saline wastewater can be designed using acclimated sludge with a halophilic community.     

一株高效好氧反硝化菌的分离及特性

利用富集培养的方法从南昌市郊某养鱼塘采样分离出22株反硝化细菌,其中8株反硝化率较高,从中选择一株效果最好的作为研究对象,命名为HS-N62,对其生长特性进行了深入研究。结果表明:硝酸盐氮初始浓度为140mg/L,菌株HS-N62在12h内对硝酸盐氮的去除率可达96%,而且没有亚硝酸盐氮的积累。该菌最适生长温度范围为30°C-37°C,最适生长pH范围6.0-8.0,最适C/N比为10:1,并能利用多种碳源生长。运用正交试验探讨了该菌株最适的反硝化条件。反硝化菌株HS-N62还具有较好的除磷能力,12h除磷率达到67.7%(初始磷酸盐浓度57mg/L)。通过形态学特性和生理生化分析以及16S rRNA基因序列分析,菌株HS-N62与Pseudomonas sp.亲缘关系最为接近,相似性达99%,初步鉴定该菌为假单胞菌属(Pseudomonas sp.)。     

Phylogenetic analysis of nitrite, nitric oxide, and nitrous oxide respiratory enzymes reveal a complex evolutionary history for denitrification

Denitrification is a facultative respiratory pathway in which nitrite (NO2(-)), nitric oxide (NO), and nitrous oxide (N2O) are successively reduced to nitrogen gas (N(2)), effectively closing the nitrogen cycle. The ability to denitrify is widely dispersed among prokaryotes, and this polyphyletic distribution has raised the possibility of horizontal gene transfer (HGT) having a substantial role in the evolution of denitrification. Comparisons of 16S rRNA and denitrification gene phylogenies in recent studies support this possibility; however, these results remain speculative as they are based on visual comparisons of phylogenies from partial sequences. We reanalyzed publicly available nirS, nirK, norB, and nosZ partial sequences using Bayesian and maximum likelihood phylogenetic inference. Concomitant analysis of denitrification genes with 16S rRNA sequences from the same organisms showed substantial differences between the trees, which were supported by examining the posterior probability of monophyletic constraints at different taxonomic levels. Although these differences suggest HGT of denitrification genes, the presence of structural variants for nirK, norB, and nosZ makes it difficult to determine HGT from other evolutionary events. Additional analysis using phylogenetic networks and likelihood ratio tests of phylogenies based on full-length sequences retrieved from genomes also revealed significant differences in tree topologies among denitrification and 16S rRNA gene phylogenies, with the exception of the nosZ gene phylogeny within the data set of the nirK-harboring genomes. However, inspection of codon usage and G + C content plots from complete genomes gave no evidence for recent HGT. Instead, the close proximity of denitrification gene copies in the genomes of several denitrifying bacteria suggests duplication. Although HGT cannot be ruled out as a factor in the evolution of denitrification genes, our analysis suggests that other phenomena, such gene duplication/divergence and lineage sorting, may have differently influenced the evolution of each denitrification gene.