Rapid optimization of electroporation conditions for plant cells,protoplasts, and pollen

The optimization of electroporation conditions for maximal uptake of DNA during direct gene transfer experiments is critical to achieve high levels of gene expression in transformed plant cells. Two stains, trypan blue and fluorescein diacetate, have been applied to optimize electroporation conditions for three plant cell types, using different square wave and exponential wave electroporation devices. The different cell types included protoplasts from tobacco, a stable mixotrophic suspension cell culture from soybean with intact cell walls, and germinating pollen from alfalfa and tobacco. Successful electroporation of each of these cell types was obtained, even in the presence of an intact cell wall when conditions were optimized for the electroporation pulse. The optimal field strength for each of these cells differs, protoplasts having the lowest optimal pulse field strength, followed by suspension cells and finally germinating pollen requiring the strongest electroporation pulse. A rapid procedure is described for optimizing electroporation parameters using different types of cells from different plant sources.     

Experession and integration of genes introduced into highly synchronized plant protoplasts

Summary Chimaeric genes containing the chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT) coding sequence were introduced into protoplasts of suspension-cultured tobacco cells using improved conditions of electroporation (Okada et al. 1986). CAT activity became detectable in the protoplasts within 3 h, was maximal during a period of 18–36 h after electroporation, and then declined gradually. Alpha-amanitin added to the medium abolished the transient expression of the CAT gene. The closed circular form of input DNA was as effective as the linear form for the transient expression. The suspension culture was treated with aphidicolin, and S, G₂, M and G₁ phases were identified in the highly synchronized cell cycle obtained by releasing the cells from the inhibition of DNA synthesis. When a chimacric CAT gene was introduced into M phase protoplasts prepared from the synchronized culture, the transient expression of the CAT gene was 3–4 times higher than when it was introduced into protoplasts of other cell cycle phases. The frequency of stable transformation with a chimaeric neomycin phosphotransferase II gene was studied using the same system. G-418-resistant transformants were obtained from M phase protoplasts at frequencies 2–8 times those obtained from protoplasts at other cell cycle phases. The results indicate that the absence of the nuclear membrane in mitotic cells favours delivery to the nucleus of exogenous DNA introduced into the cytoplasm.     

Transient gene expression in electroporated Solanum protoplasts

Electroporation was used to evaluate parameters important in transient gene expression in potato protoplasts. The protoplasts were from leaves of wild potato Solanum brevidens, and from leaves, tubers and suspension cells of cultivated Solanum tuberosum cv. Désirée. Reporter enzyme activity, chloramphenicol acetyl transferase (CAT) under the control of the cauliflower mosaic virus (CaMV) 35S promoter, depended on the field strength and the pulse duration used for electroporation. Using field pulses of 85 ms duration, the optimum field strengths for maximum CAT activity were: S. brevidens mesophyll protoplasts –250 V/cm; Désirée mesophyll protoplasts –225 V/cm; Désirée suspension culture protoplasts –225 V/cm; and Désirée tuber protoplasts –150 V/cm. The optimum field strengths correlated inversely with the size of the protoplasts electroporated; this is consistent with biophysical theory. In time courses, maximum CAT activity (in Désirée mesophyll protoplasts) occurred 36–48 h after electroporation. Examination at optimised conditions of a chimaeric gene consisting of a class II patatin promoter linked to the -glucuronidase (gus) gene, showed expression (at DNA concentrations between 0–10 pmol/ml) comparable to the CaMV 35S promoter in both tuber and mesophyll protoplasts. At higher DNA concentrations (20–30 pmol/ml) the patatin promoter directed 4–5 times higher levels of gus expression. Implications and potential contributions towards studying gene expression, in particular of homologous genes in potato, are discussed.     

Linear DNA introduced into carrot protoplasts by electroporation undergoes ligation and recircularization

The integrated DNA in stable transformants formed by direct gene transfer often shows complex restriction patterns. One cause of these complex restriction patterns could be the ligation of plasmid fragments prior to their integration. This paper provides evidence for the ligation of plasmid fragments by plant cells. Carrot protoplasts were electroporated in the presence of pCaMVCATM and assayed for chloramphenicol actyltransferase (CAT) activity 24h later. Linear and supercoiled forms of pCaMVCATM supported similar levels of CAT expression. Surprisingly, digestion of the plasmid at a site between the CaMV 35S promoter and the CAT coding region reduced expression by only 40–50%. Electroporation carried out in the presence of isolated plasmid fragments suggested that this result was due to ligation of the linearized plasmid by the protoplasts. CAT expression was obtained with a mixture of isolated CaMV 35S promoter and the CAT coding region; neither fragment alone supported expression. Further evidence of ligation was provided by electroporation of protoplasts in the presence of a mixture of linearized pGEM and the 1.5-kbHind III fragment of pCaMVCATM. DNA isolated from nuclei of the protoplasts was used to transform competent cells ofEscherichia coli, and colonies were recovered that carried pGEM withHind III-CaMVCAT inserts. Electroporation of protoplasts in the presence of linear and supercoiled pGEM and use of DNA isolated from nuclei to transformE. coli yielded an estimate of the frequency of plasmid ligation. A maximum of only 4% of the input linear DNA was recovered as circular molecules. This result suggests the frequency of ligation is low, but examination of the plasmid DNA in the plant nuclei by electrophoresis indicates extensive degradation of the plasmid and preferential loss of the circular forms. Thus, the ligated plasmids may be converted to the linear form and hence rendered unrecoverable by cloning intoE. coli.     

Chimeric gene expression using maize intron in cultured cells of breadwheat

High voltage electrical pulses were used to introduce the CAT reporter gene into cultured protoplasts of breadwheat,Triticum aestivum. Four DNA constructs harboring the CAT gene and the 35S or mannipine synthase promoter were tested for levels of CAT activity 40–45 hr after electroporation of protoplasts. One construct, containing a maize intron sequence between 35S and CAT sequences, conferred 30 to 185 fold greater CAT activity over the other three constructs. Data from these experiments suggest that a maize intron or sequences with similar effects may be required in DNA constructs for efficient heterologous gene expression in cultured cells of breadwheat.Abbreviations CAT Chloramphenicol acetyl transferase - NPT II neomycin phosphotransferase - 35S the 35S promoter of Cauliflower Mosaic Virus - PEG Polyethylene glycol - MES 2-[N-morpholino] ethanesulfonic acid     

Factors influencing transient gene expression in electroporated tall fescue protoplasts

For the rapid establishment of optimal conditions for a genetic transformation system for tall fescue, several factors influencing transient gene expression were studied in protoplasts, after the reporter β-glucuronidase gene was introduced by electroporation. In a time-course study of transient gene expression, GUS activity peaked at 24 h after electroporation. Among the different field strength conditions tested, maximum GUS activity was observed at 750 V/cm. Increases in the amount of plasmid DNA to 80 μg/ml led to increased GUS activity. GUS activities increased in linear fashion with increasing protoplast densities up to 2 × 10⁶/ml. Age of suspension cells from which protoplasts were derived influenced transient expression with maximum GUS activity obtained in 3- and 5-day-old suspensions. These results show that monocot and dicot protoplasts respond similarly in electroporation.     

Comparative analysis of free DNA delivery and expression into protoplasts of Panicum maximum Jacq. (Guinea grass) by electroporation and polyethylene glycol

Relative levels of gene expression were studied in protoplasts isolated from two cell lines of Panicum maximum following DNA delivery by electroporation and polyethylene glycol (PEG). Gene expression was evaluated by assaying for chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT) activity expressed by the CaMV 35S promoter with a nopaline synthase 3' polyadenylation signal, approximately 48 hours after DNA delivery. The expression of the CAT gene was slightly higher in electroporated protoplasts in comparison to PEG mediated delivery. However, PEG treated protoplasts showed higher plating efficiency. The effect of different salts and the molecular weight of PEG used on gene expression was also studied.     

Factors affecting transient gene expression in electroporated Glycine max protoplasts

Electroporation was used to evaluate parameters affecting transient gene expression in Glycine max protoplasts. Protoplast viability and reporter enzyme activity for chloramphenicol acetyl transferase (CAT) and ß-glucuronidase (GUS) depended on the field strength employed. Maximum CAT and GUS activity was obtained when a field strength of 500 V/cm at 1000 F and a protoplast concentration of 1–3 × 10⁶/ml was used. Transformation efficiencies up to approximately 1.6% GUS positive protoplasts were obtained. Transient gene expression increased with increasing plasmid DNA concentration and with the time after electroporation, reaching a maximum after 48 hr. Addition of polyethylene glycol at 5.6% and heat shock (5 rain at 45 °C) given to the protoplasts before adding DNA further enhanced the transformation efficiency. Under the optimized experimental conditions, CAT and GUS activity increased simultaneously, thereby indicating that the increased expression is caused by DNA uptake by more cells rather than greater DNA uptake by the same cells. Our results demonstrate that both GUS and CAT can be used as efficient screenable markers for transformation studies in soybean.Abbreviations CAT chloramphenicol acetyl transferase - GUS ß-glucuronidase - PEG polyethylene glycol     

Delivery of plasmid DNA into intact plant cells by electroporation of plasmolyzed cells

This report describes the delivery of plasmid DNA containing either the β-glucuronidase (GUS) or the green fluorescent protein (GFP) reporter gene into intact plant cells of bamboo callus, lilium scales, and Nicotiana benthamiana suspension culture cells. By first plasmolyzing the tissues or cells with 0.4 m sucrose in the presence of plasmid DNA, electroporation effectively delivers plasmid DNA into the intact plant cells. Transient expression of the GUS gene, as revealed by histochemical assays, showed the presence of blue-staining areas in the electroporated tissues. A short exposure of cells to 2% DMSO (dimethyl sulfoxide) prior to plasmolysis elevated the level of transient GUS activity. When plasmid DNA containing a synthetic GFP gene was used, a strong green fluorescence was observed in N. benthamiana suspension culture cells that were subjected to plasmolysis and electroporation. These results suggest that plasmolysis brings the plasmid DNA into the void space that is in close vicinity to the plasmalemma, allowing electroporation to efficiently deliver the plasmid DNA into intact plant cells. Received: 15 June 1998 / Revision received: 18 August 1998 / Accepted: 28 August 1998     

Transient expression of electroporated DNA in monocotyledonous and dicotyledonous species

Transient expression of electroporated DNA was monitored in protoplasts of several monocot and dicot species by assaying for expression of chimeric chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT) gene constructions. Expression was obtained in the dicot species of Daucus carota, Glycine max and Petunia hybrida and the monocot species of Triticum monococcum, Pennisetum purpureum, Panicum maximum, Saccharum officinarum, and a double cross, trispecific hybrid between Pennisetum purpureum, P. americanum, and P. squamulatum. Recovery and viability of protoplasts after electroporation decreased with increasing voltages and capacitance while CAT activity increased up to a critical combination of voltage and capacitance beyond which the activity dramatically decreased. The optimal compromise between DNA uptake and expression versus cell survival was determined for D. carota and applied successfully to the other species. Maximum transient expression occurred 36 hours after electroporation of D. carota. The potential for using this procedure to rapidly assay gene function in dicot and monocot cells and application of this technique to obtain transformed cereals is discussed.     

Transformation of protoplasts and intact cells from slowly growing embryogenic callus of wheat (Triticum aestivum L.)

A procedure for culturing protoplasts from slowly growing embryogenic calli of wheat was developed. The procedure was dependent on the ability to isolate large numbers of culturable protoplasts from slowly growing embryogenic callus. Approximately 68% of the isolated protoplasts divided, and 22% formed colonies; of the latter, 67% continued to proliferate. Plating efficiency was reduced when protoplasts were transformed by polythylene glycol, electroporation, and/or Agrobacterium. Intact cells were also directly transformed by electroporation. Direct electroporation of the Agrobacterium binary vector into intact cells resulted in a significant increase of GUS activity over the control.     

High level of GUS gene expression driven by pollen-specific promoters in electroporated lily pollen protoplasts

Gene constructs that contained the -glucuronidase (GUS) gene under the control of a pollen-specific Zm13 promoter from maize and a LAT52 promoter from tomato were introduced by electroporation into pollen protoplasts isolated from bicellular pollen grains of Lilium longiflorum. After 20 h in culture, the pollen protoplasts exhibited the apparent expression of GUS in a fluorometric assay. The GUS activity induced under the control of the Zm13 promoter was over 10 000 times higher than activity in the control (with no DNA or without electroporation). By contrast, the GUS gene was nearly silent in the lily microspore protoplasts and generative cell protoplasts. The GUS activity driven by the Zm13 and LAT52 promoters was also detected by a cytochemical assay. The frequency of blue-staining pollen protoplasts was about 70% in the case of the Zm13 promoter. The efficiency of gene transfer by electroporation was much higher than by particle bombardment. This protoplast-specific electroporation system is suitable for rapid and reliable examination of pollen-specific promoters, being as good as the particle bombardment system.     

Introduction of Foreign Gene into Small Cell Groups Digested Partial-Enzymically in Rice and Regeneration of Transgenic Plants

Suspension cultures of small cell groups (SCG; ca. 50–100 cells per group) were established from calli of Japonica rice Fang 7 and Hl24. The SCG were partially digested and transformed by plasmid pBll21 harboring the NPT-II (neomycin phosphotransferase) and GUS (betaglucuronidase) genes. Plasmid DNA was introduced into cells' by PEG, electroporation and PEG plus electroporation. NTP-II and GUS activity assay showed that the report genes were expressed in transformed cells. Transgenic plants were regeneiated possessing GUS activity due to the integration of intact foreign DNA into their genome as evidanced by hybridization. The results prove that the partially digested SCG is a potential, feasible system as receptor for gene transfer, especially for plants which are difficult for protoplast culture and plant regeneration from protoplasts.     

Somatic proembryo formation and transient expression of a luciferase gene in Douglas fir and loblolly pine protoplasts

Somatic pro-embryos were regenerated from morphogenic protoplasts of cell suspension cultures of Douglas fir and loblolly pine. Morphogenic protoplasts were obtained from suspension cultures of embryonal cells grown in a modified basal medium high in myo-inositol. After 11–12 weeks, microcolonies of embryonal-suspensor masses (ESMs) were recovered from agarose-embedded protoplasts. Somatic pro-embryos were regenerated after 18–20 weeks by somatic polyembryogenesis from new ESMs on agar plates. The luciferase (luc) gene was successfully introduced into fir and pine protoplasts by electroporation. While viability of protoplasts was reduced from 90% to 45–55% by electroporation, the transient expression of the luc gene was detected in protoplasts surviving 36 h after electroporation. Gene expression was improved by the addition of polythylene glycol (PEG) to the electroporation mixture.     

Effects of electroporation pulse wave on the incorporation of viral RNA into tobacco protoplasts

The uptake and expression of cucumber mosaic viral (CMV) RNA by tobacco protoplasts was examined using both square wave and exponential wave electroporation pulses. These electropulses, when supplied at sufficient field strength for a critical duration, enabled RNA to be incorporated and expressed in more than 60% of the surviving protoplasts. The results of experiments using these two electroporation wave forms showed significant differences in RNA uptake and expression. The number of viable protoplasts and cells showing expression of RNA was higher over a much broader range of experimental conditions using the square rather than exponential wave generator, even when both machines were optimized for maximal performance. However, at a narrow range of low field strengths the exponential wave pulse generated a higher percentage of transformants than did the square wave pulse. It was shown that after an electroporation pulse from either wave form, there were viable cells which expressed foreign RNA at predictable levels.     

Direct gene transfer to plant protoplasts by electroporation by alternating,rectangular and exponentially decaying pulses

Summary The efficiency of electroporation of sugar beet (Beta vulgaris L.) and tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.) protoplasts by alternating, rectangular and exponentially decaying pulses was studied by assaying transient expression of an introduced gene for chloramphenicol acetyltransferase. A simple device for electroporation by alternating current was constructed. The mains (220 V) were used as power supply and the pulse duration was controlled by the blow-out of a small fuse. Electroporation of sugar beet protoplasts by alternating current and exponentially decaying pulses resulted in 3–4 fold higher transient expression compared to rectangular pulses. Transient expression in tobacco protoplasts electroporated by exponentially decaying pulses was 30 % and 85 % higher than when electroporated by rectangular and alternating current pulses, respectively.Abbreviations CAT Chloramphenicol acetyltransferase     

Electroporation of cells

By measuring uptake of the membrane impermeable dye. phenosafranine, it can be shown that the plasma membrane of intact cells within cell aggregates can be reversibly permeabilized by electroporation. However, the plant cell wall is a barrier to DNA uptake by intact cells, although under certain circumstances expression of DNA, electroporated into intact cells, can be demonstrated. The level of expression is about 20–50 times lower than that obtained by electroporation of protoplasts, and depends on cell wall properties and pretreatments of cell aggregates. In contrast, efficient transformation of whole cells of bacteria and yeasts can be achieved by electroporation. Factors which influence DNA transfer into whole plant cells and the possibility of stable transformation are discussed.     

Flow cytometric quantification of electroporation-mediated uptake of macromolecules into plant protoplasts

Summary Flow cytometry was used to provide a rapid and accurate assessment of electroporation-induced uptake of macromolecules into plant protoplasts. Rice protoplasts were electroporated in the presence of fluorescein isothiocyanate-conjugated dextran (FITC-dextran). After washing, the protoplasts were resuspended in a solution containing propidium iodide which intercalates with DNA, but which is excluded by an intact plasma membrane. Electroporation in the presence of FITC-dextran gave rise to populations of protoplasts that fluoresced green or yellow due to the presence of non-conjugated FITC. Non-viable protoplasts fluoresced red because of their inability to exclude propidium iodide molecules. Flow cytometry was used to resolve and quantify these protoplast populations and thus identify optimal conditions for macromolecule uptake. A direct relationship was observed between FITC-dextran uptake and transient gene expression following plasmid uptake. Thus, simultaneous electroporation of protoplasts with foreign DNA and FITC-dextran followed by fluorescence activated cell sorting may permit partial selection of transformed cells and so reduce the need for a selectable marker.Abbreviations ADC analogue to digital converter - CAT chloramphenicol acetyl transferase (enzyme) - cat chloramphenicol acetyl transferase (gene) - CPW solution cell and protoplast wash solution - DC direct current - EF electrofusion - FALS forward angle light scatter - FITC fluorescein isothiocyanate - FITC-dextran fluorescein isothiocyanate conjugated dextran - PI propidium iodide - PMT photomultipliertube - TLC thin layer chromatography     

Transient expression of fluorescent fusion proteins in protoplasts of suspension cultured cells

Transient expression of fluorescent fusion proteins in plant cells has dramatically facilitated our study of newly identified genes and proteins. This protocol details an in vivo transient expression system to study the subcellular localization and dynamic associations of plant proteins using protoplasts freshly prepared from Arabidopsis or tobacco BY-2 suspension cultured cells. The method relies on the transformation of DNA constructs into protoplasts via electroporation. The whole protocol is comprised of three major stages: protoplast generation and purification, transformation of DNA into protoplasts via electroporation and incubation of protoplasts for protein analysis. Similar to stably transformed cell lines, transformed protoplasts are compatible with protein localization studies, pharmaceutical drug treatment and western blot analysis. This protocol can be completed within 11-24 h from protoplast production to protein detection.