Stable carbon isotope ratios in Asian elephant collagen: implications for dietary studies

Summary Stable carbon isotope ratios in bone collagen have been used in a variety of dietary studies in modern and fossil animals, including humans. Inherent in the stable isotope technique is the assumption that the isotopic signature is a reflection of the diet and is persistent in collagen because this is a relatively inert protein. Carbon isotope analyses of bones from a southern Indian population of Asian elephant (Elephas maximus), a long-lived mammal that alternates seasonally between a predominantly C₃ (browse) and C₄ (grass) plant diet, showed two patterns that have important implications for dietary interpretation based on isotopic studies. Relative to the quantity of the two plant types consumed on average, the δ¹³C signal in collagen indicated that more carbon was incorporated from C₃ plants, possibly due to their higher protein contribution. There was a much greater variance in δ¹³C values of collagen in sub-adult (range -10.5‰ to-22.7‰, variance=14.51) compared to adult animals (range -16.0‰ to -20.3‰, variance=1.85) pointing to high collagen turnover rates and non-persistent isotopic signatures in younger, growing animals. It thus seems important to correct for any significant relative differences in nutritive value of food types and also consider the age of an animal before drawing definite conclusions about its diet from isotope ratios.     

Chemoinformatics-assisted development of new anti-biofilm compounds

The fuel oxygenate, methyl tert-butyl ether (MTBE), although now widely banned or substituted, remains a persistent groundwater contaminant. Multidimensional compound-specific isotope analysis (CSIA) of carbon and hydrogen is being developed for determining the extent of MTBE loss due to biodegradation and can also potentially distinguish between different biodegradation pathways. Carbon and hydrogen isotopic fractionation factors were determined for MTBE degradation in aerobic and anaerobic laboratory cultures. The carbon isotopic enrichment factor (εC) for aerobic MTBE degradation by a bacterial consortium containing the aerobic MTBE-degrading bacterium, Variovorax paradoxus, was −1.1 ± 0.2‰ and the hydrogen isotope enrichment factor (εH) was −15 ± 2‰. This corresponds to an approximated lambda value (Λ = εH/εC) of 14. Carbon isotope enrichment factors for anaerobic MTBE-degrading enrichment cultures were −7.0 ± 0.2‰ and did not vary based on the original inoculum source, redox condition of the enrichment, or supplementation with syringic acid as a co-substrate. The hydrogen enrichment factors of cultures without syringic acid were insignificant, however a strong hydrogen enrichment factor of −41 ± 3‰ was observed for cultures which were fed syringic acid during MTBE degradation. The Λ = 6 obtained for NYsyr cultures might be diagnostic for the stimulation of anaerobic MTBE degradation by methoxylated compounds by an as yet unknown pathway and mechanism. The stable-isotope enrichment factors determined in this study will enhance the use of CSIA for monitoring anaerobic and aerobic MTBE biodegradation in situ.     

Carbon isotope fractionation between diet and bioapatite in ungulate mammals and implications for ecological and paleoecological studies

 The isotope enrichment ɛ* of ¹³C between tooth enamel of large ruminant mammals and their diet is 14.1 ± 0.5‰. This value was obtained by analyzing both the dental enamel of a variety of wild and captive mammals and the vegetation that comprised their foodstuffs. This isotope enrichment factor applies to a wide variety of ruminant mammals. Non-ruminant ungulates have a similar isotope enrichment, although our data cannot determine if it is significantly different. We also found a ¹³C isotope enrichment ɛ* of 3.1 ± 0.7‰ for horn relative to diet, and 11.1 ± 0.8‰ for enamel relative to horn for ruminant mammals. Tooth enamel is a faithful recorder of diet. Its isotopic composition can be used to track changes in the isotopic composition of the atmosphere, determine the fraction of C₃ or C₄ biomass in diets of modern or fossil mammals, distinguish between mammals using different subpathways of C₄ photosynthesis,and identify those mammals whose diet is derived from closed-canopy habitats. Received: 1 July 1998 / Accepted: 9 February 1999     

Isotopic insight into host–endosymbiont relationships in Liolaemid lizards

Nitrogen isotopes have been widely used to investigate trophic levels in ecological systems. Isotopic enrichment of 2–5‰ occurs with trophic level increases in food webs. Host–parasite relationships deviate from traditional food webs in that parasites are minimally enriched relative to their hosts. Although this host–parasite enrichment pattern has been shown in multiple systems, few studies have used isotopic relationships to examine other potential symbioses. We examined the relationship between two gut-nematodes and their lizard hosts. One species, Physaloptera retusa, is a documented parasite in the stomach, whereas the relationship of the other species, Parapharyngodon riojensis (pinworms), to the host is putatively commensalistic or mutualistic. Based on the established trophic enrichments, we predicted that, relative to host tissue, parasitic nematodes would be minimally enriched (0–1‰), whereas pinworms, either as commensals or mutualists, would be significantly enriched by 2–5‰. We measured the ¹⁵N values of food, digesta, gut tissue, and nematodes of eight lizard species in the family Liolaemidae. Parasitic worms were enriched 1±0.2‰ relative to host tissue, while the average enrichment value for pinworms relative to gut tissue was 6.7±0.2‰. The results support previous findings that isotopic fractionation in a host–parasite system is lower than traditional food webs. Additionally, the larger enrichment of pinworms relative to known parasites suggests that they are not parasitic and may be several trophic levels beyond the host.     

Hydrogen and oxygen isotope ratios of tree ring cellulose for field-grown riparian trees

The isotopic composition of tree ring cellulose was obtained over a 2-year period from small-diameter riparian-zone trees at field sites that differed in source water isotopic composition and humidity. The sites were located in Utah (cool and low humidity), Oregon (cool and high humidity), and Arizona (warm and low humidity) with source water isotope ratio values of –125/–15‰ (δD/δ¹⁸O), –48/–6‰, and –67/–7‰, respectively. Monthly environmental measurements included temperature and humidity along with measurements of the isotope ratios in atmospheric water vapor, stream, stem, and leaf water. Small riparian trees used only stream water (both δD and δ¹⁸O of stem and stream water did not differ), but δ values of both atmospheric water vapor and leaf water varied substantially between months. Differences in ambient temperature and humidity conditions between sites contributed to substantial differences in leaf water evaporative enrichment. These leaf water differences resulted in differences in the δD and δ¹⁸O values of tree ring cellulose, indicating that humidity information was recorded in the annual rings of trees. These environmental and isotopic measurements were used to test a mechanistic model of the factors contributing to δD and δ¹⁸O values in tree ring cellulose. The model was tested in two parts: (a) a leaf water model using environmental information to predict leaf water evaporative enrichment and (b) a model describing biochemical fractionation events and isotopic exchange with medium water. The models adequately accounted for field observations of both leaf water and tree ring cellulose, indicating that the model parameterization from controlled experiments was robust even under uncontrolled and variable field conditions. Received: 7 April 1999 / Accepted: 8 December 1999     

Stable Isotope Techniques and Applications for Primatologists

Stable isotope biogeochemistry is useful for quantifying the feeding ecology of modern and extinct primates. Over the past three decades, substantial advances have been made in our knowledge of the physiological causes of isotopic patterns as well as effective methodology to prepare samples for isotopic analysis. Despite these advances, the potential of stable isotope biogeochemistry has yet to be fully exploited by primate researchers, perhaps due to the prolific and somewhat daunting nature of the isotopic literature. I here aim to present a cogent overview of stable isotope applications to nonhuman primate feeding ecology. I review the factors that influence ecological patterns in carbon, nitrogen, and oxygen stable isotopes. I present methods for collecting and preparing samples of tooth enamel and bone mineral hydroxyapatite, bone collagen, fur and hair keratin, blood, feces, and urine for isotope analysis. I discuss both the existing and potential applications of these isotopic patterns to primate feeding ecology. Lastly, I point out some of the pitfalls to avoid when interpreting and comparing isotopic results.     

Isotopic enrichment in a phloem-feeding insect: influences of nutrient and water availability

The isotopic enrichment between an animal and its diet can vary among and within living systems, but the sources of variation are not yet fully understood. Some studies have found that diet quality or an animal’s nutritional status can influence the degree of trophic enrichment, while others have dismissed nutrition as a contributing factor. We evaluated the effects of nutrient and water availability on carbon and nitrogen isotopic enrichment in a specialized plant–herbivore system. Aphids are largely sedentary and rely exclusively on nitrogen-poor phloem sap of their host for nutrition. We grew potato aphids [Macrosiphum euphorbiae (Aphididae)] on an accepted host, pumpkin [Cucurbita pepo L. (Cucurbitaceae)], in a glasshouse environment. Twelve pumpkin plants growing under high- and low-watering regimes were inoculated at 4 weeks of age with aphids. During the course of the experiment we collected leaves, phloem sap, aphids and honeydew (i.e., aphid exudates). We found no trophic enrichment between aphids and their phloem sap diet, but significant carbon enrichment of honeydew relative to aphids (2.5‰) and phloem sap (2.1‰). Honeydew was also enriched in nitrogen compared to the phloem sap (1.2‰). Watering treatment had a substantial impact on trophic enrichment. Correlations among tissues, an indication of uniform trophic enrichment among samples, were significant only for the carbon isotopic composition, and then only for plants and aphids grown in the low-water treatment. Diet quality also influenced the degree of isotopic enrichment; trophic enrichment for both carbon and nitrogen isotopic composition increased as diet quality (C/N) declined. We conclude that the degree of trophic enrichment is variable due, in part, to diet quality, but that the scale of variation is small.     

Diet: tissue stable isotope fractionation of carbon and nitrogen in blood plasma and whole blood of male reindeer Rangifer tarandus

Estimates of diet derived from stable isotope analyses are sensitive to the accuracy of corrections made for diet-tissue fractionation. In particular, diet-tissue fractionation in reindeer Rangifer tarandus may be expected to differ significantly from the generic values often used in stable isotope dietary calculations, given the known values obtained from other ungulates and the complex digestive system and nutrient recycling characteristic of the species. We fed domestic reindeer a homogenous artificial diet of known isotopic value in order to directly determine diet-tissue isotopic fractionation of carbon and nitrogen, the main elements used in stable isotope dietary analyses. Diet-tissue fractionation values for blood plasma were +3.5 ± 0.1‰ (δ¹³C) and +4.2 ± 0.3‰ (δ¹⁵N). Diet-tissue fractionation values for whole blood were +3.7 ± 0.2‰ (δ¹³C) and +2.5 ± 0.3‰ (δ¹⁵N). Metabolic turnover rates were clearly sufficient for complete tissue replacement over the period of artificial feeding for blood plasma, but may not have been so for whole blood, especially for δ¹⁵N. Our values, except for whole blood δ¹⁵N, differ considerably from the generic values often used in dietary studies and interspecific comparisons of trophic niche. The results underline the importance of obtaining as specific as possible fractionation values for the species, tissue, and in some cases sex and physiological status of animals under examination, and the potential problems associated with assuming ‘generic’ fractionation values when comparing species, especially where digestive processes are dissimilar.     

Food web structure of a shallow eutrophic lake (Lake Taihu,China) assessed by stable isotope analysis

Lake Taihu is a large, shallow, and eutrophic lake in China. It has provided local communities with valuable fisheries for centuries, but little is known of the trophodynamics, or of its faunal communities. Carbon and nitrogen isotopic composition was used to assess its trophic pathways and the food web structure [food sources and trophic levels (TL)]. Basal food sources were distinguishable based on their δ¹³C values, ranging from −27.2 to −15.2‰. Consumers were also well separated in δ¹³C (−26.9 to −17.9‰ for invertebrates and −25.7 to −18.1‰ for fishes), which allowed for an effective discrimination of carbon sources between these fauna. An average trophic enrichment factor of 3.4‰ was used to calculate the TLs based on δ¹⁵N of zooplankton, with results indicating a food web having four TLs. Although δ¹⁵N values overlap and cover a large range within trophic compartments, the isotopic signatures of the species assessed revealed a general trend of ¹⁵N enrichment with increasing TL. Stable isotope signatures were also used to establish a general food web scheme in which five main trophic pathways were analyzed.     

Effects of growth and tissue type on the kinetics of <Superscript>13</Superscript>C and <Superscript>15</Superscript>N incorporation in a rapidly growing ectotherm

The use of stable isotopes to investigate animal diets, habitat use, and trophic level requires understanding the rate at which animals incorporate the ¹³C and ¹⁵N from their diets and the factors that determine the magnitude of the difference in isotopic composition between the animal’s diet and that of its tissues. We determined the contribution of growth and catabolic turnover to the rate of ¹³C and ¹⁵N incorporation into several tissues that can be sampled non-invasively (skin, scute, whole blood, red blood cells, and plasma solutes) in two age classes of a rapidly growing ectotherm (loggerhead turtles, Caretta caretta). We found significant differences in C and N incorporation rates and isotopic discrimination factors (Δ¹³C = δ¹³C_tissues − δ¹³C_diet and Δ¹⁵N = δ¹⁵N_tissues − δ¹⁵N_diet) among tissues and between age classes. Growth explained from 26 to 100% of the total rate of incorporation in hatchling turtles and from 15 to 52% of the total rate of incorporation in juvenile turtles. Because growth contributed significantly to the rate of isotopic incorporation, variation in rates among tissues was lower than reported in previous studies. The contribution of growth can homogenize the rate of isotopic incorporation and limit the application of stable isotopes to identify dietary changes at contrasting time scales and to determine the timing of diet shifts. The isotopic discrimination factor of nitrogen ranged from −0.64 to 1.77‰ in the turtles’ tissues. These values are lower than the commonly assumed average 3.4‰ discrimination factors reported for whole body and muscle isotopic analyses. The increasing reliance on non-invasive and non-destructive sampling in animal isotopic ecology requires that we recognize and understand why different tissues differ in isotopic discrimination factors.     

δ<Superscript>15</Superscript>N dynamics of ammonium and particulate nitrogen in a temperate eutrophic estuary

We monitored the stable nitrogen isotopic composition (δ¹⁵N) of suspended matter and ammonium in the freshwater stretch of the Scheldt estuary (Belgium) over a full year to investigate for seasonal evolution and possible co-variation between isotopic signatures. The δ¹⁵N value of ammonium remained rather constant during winter (average = +11.4‰) but increased significantly with the spring and summer bloom, reaching values as high as +70‰. This enrichment of the ammonium pool in ¹⁵N coincided with significant ammonium depletion during summer period, suggesting a close causal relationship. Based on a semi-closed system approach we deduced an apparent fractionation factor associated with NH₄⁺ utilization (i.e. combining effects of uptake and nitrification) of 18.4‰ (SE = 2.0‰), which is similar to values reported in literature. Observed variations of ammonium δ¹⁵N could account for about 69% of δ¹⁵N variation in suspended matter.     

Isotopic enrichment in herbivorous insects: a comparative field-based study of variation

Researchers will be able to use stable isotope analysis to study community structure in an efficient way, without a need for extensive calibrations, if isotopic enrichment values are consistent, or if variation in enrichment values can be predicted. In this study, we generated an experimental data set of δ¹⁵N and δ¹³C enrichment means for 22 terrestrial herbivorous arthropods feeding on 18 different host plants. Mean enrichments observed across a single trophic transfer (plants to herbivores) were −0.53±0.26‰ for δ¹³C (range: −3.47‰ to 1.89‰) and 1.88±0.37‰ for δ¹⁵N (range: −0.20‰ to 6.59‰). The mean δ¹³C enrichment was significantly lower than that reported in recent literature surveys, whereas the mean δ¹⁵N enrichment was not significantly different. The experimental data set provided no support for recent hypotheses advanced to explain variation in enrichment values, including the proposed roles for consumer feeding mode, development type, and diet C:N ratio. A larger data set, formed by combining our experimental data with data from the literature, did suggest possible roles for feeding mode, nitrogen recycling, herbivore life stage, and host plant type. Our results indicate that species enrichment values are variable even in this relatively narrow defined group of organisms and that our ability to predict enrichment values of terrestrial herbivorous arthropods based on physiological, ecological, or taxonomic traits is low. The primary implications are that (1) mean enrichment may have to be measured empirically for each trophic link of interest, rather than relying on estimates from a broad survey of animal taxa and (2) the advantage of using stable isotope analysis to probe animal communities that are recalcitrant to other modes of study will be somewhat diminished as a consequence.Electronic Supplementary Material Supplementary material is available for this article at     

Diurnal variations of needle water isotopic ratios in two pine species

Diurnal fluctuations of leaf water isotope ratios (δ¹⁸O and δD) were measured for Jeffrey (Pinus jeffreyi Balf.) and lodgepole (Pinus contorta Douglas ex Louden) pine. Two trees per species were sampled every few hours on 15–16 October 2005 and 19–20 June 2006. Diurnal gas exchange was measured during the summer sampling. In fall 2005, leaf water δ¹⁸O ranged from 0.7 to 9.0‰, and leaf water δD ranged from −70 to −50‰. In summer 2006, leaf water δ¹⁸O ranged from 7.7 to 20.7‰, and leaf water δD ranged from −61 to −24‰. Diurnal variation of leaf water isotope values typically reached a maximum in early afternoon, began decreasing around midnight, and reached a minimum in mid-morning. Both periods showed a high degree of enrichment relative to source water, with leaf water–source water enrichments ranging up to 37.8‰ for δ¹⁸O, and up to 95‰ for δD. Leaf water enrichment varied by season with summer enrichment being greater than fall enrichment. A steady-state model (i.e., modified Craig–Gordon modeling) for leaf water isotope compositions did not provide a good fit to measured values of leaf water. In summer, a non-steady state model provided a better fit to the measured data than the steady-state model. Our findings demonstrate substantial leaf water enrichment above source water and diurnal variations in the isotopic composition of leaf water, which has application to understanding short-term variability of atmospheric gases (water vapor, CO₂, O₂), climate studies based on the isotopic composition of tree rings, and ecosystem water fluxes.     

Experimental determination of nitrogen kinetic isotope fractionation: Some principles; illustration for the denitrification and nitrification processes

Summary A few principles relative to the presentation and use of nitrogen stable isotopic data are briefly reviewed. Some classical relationships between the isotope composition of a substrate undergoing a single-step unidirectional reaction, are introduced. They are illustrated through controlled experiments on denitrification in a soil, and through nitrification by pure cultures ofNitrosomonas europaea. In the latter case, the isotope fractionation is calculated from the isotopic composition of the residual substrate, then of the product and the result is shown to be statistically the same for the two procedures. The isotopic enrichment factor for denitrification is −29.4±2.4‰ at 20°C, and −24.6±0.9‰ at 30°C; for nitrification this factor is −34.7±2.5‰ under the experimental conditions employed.     

Isotopic signature (<Superscript>15</Superscript>N/<Superscript>14</Superscript>N and <Superscript>13</Superscript>C/<Superscript>12</Superscript>C) confirms similarity of trophic niches of millipedes (Myriapoda,diplopoda) in a temperate deciduous forest

The species composition, abundance, and isotopic signature of millipedes (Myriapoda, Diplopoda) were investigated in seven biotopes of Kaluzhskie Zaseki State Nature Reserve. Nine Diplopoda species were found in total, and the local species diversity (within a sampling plot) reached seven species. The Diplopoda tissues were similar to the plant litter in the isotopic composition of nitrogen (δ¹⁵N was by 0.4‰ higher, on average), but were strongly enriched in heavy carbon (δ¹³C was by 4‰ higher, on average). Removal of mineral carbon from the cuticle reduced δ¹³C of Diplopoda by about 1.4‰ on average. Differences in the δ¹⁵N and δ¹³C values between the species did not exceed 2.5‰. Differences in the isotopic compositions of the considered species were small, and, it is impossible to distinguish particular trophic guilds in the Diplopoda community. Analysis of the published data confirmed that isotopic differentiation of millipedes was much less pronounced than in other investigated groups of soil animals. Hence, millipedes of the deciduous forest form a uniform trophic group.     

Benthic-pelagic trophic interactions within the fish assemblage in the western Bering Sea shelf area according to stomach content analysis and ratios of C and N stable isotopes

The composition, abundance, diet and trophic status of zooplankton, bottom invertebrates, fish and nekton were analyzed based on the data collected by the staff of the TINRO-Center during complex bottom trawl catches on the Bering Sea shelf in the fall of 2004. The stomach contents of mass fish species were analyzed and the nitrogen and carbon isotopic composition of 36 mass species of plankton, benthos, nekton and nektobenthos, which together make up the basis of pelagic and bottom communities, was determined. It was found that zooplankton noticeably differ from benthic invertebrates in carbon isotopic composition: δ¹³C values in zooplankton varied from −20.3‰ to −17.9‰; in benthos—from −17.5‰to −13.0‰; and in fish—from −19.2‰ (juvenile walleye pollock) to −15.3‰ (saffron cod). The levels of ¹³C isotope in the tissues of fish depended mostly on the share of pelagic or benthic animals in their diet. δ¹⁵N values in the studied species ranged from 8.6‰ (in sea urchins) to 17.2‰ (in large Pacific cods), which corresponds to a trophic level of 2.8. Obviously the δ¹⁵N values reflect the degree of predation and generally show the ratio of primary, secondary and tertiary consumers in a fish’s diet. Trophic interactions manifest a high degree of interdependence between benthic and pelagic communities (even without taking into account such lower components of the food web as phytoplankton, bacteria, and protozoa) occurring in most nektonic species that depend on both bottom and pelagic food.     

Isotopic signatures, foraging habitats and trophic relationships between fish and seasnakes on the coral reefs of New Caledonia

A predator’s species, sex and body size can influence the types of prey that it consumes, but why? Do such dietary divergences result from differences in foraging habitats, or reflect differential ability to locate, capture or ingest different types of prey? That question is difficult to answer if foraging occurs in places that preclude direct observation. In New Caledonia, amphibious sea kraits (Laticauda laticaudata and L. saintgironsi) mostly eat eels—but the species consumed differ between snake species and vary with snake body size and sex. Because the snakes capture eels within crevices on the sea floor, it is not possible to observe snake foraging on any quantitative basis. We used stable isotopes to investigate habitat-divergence and ontogenetic shifts in feeding habits of sympatric species of sea kraits. Similarities in δ15 N (~10.5‰) values suggest that the two snake species occupy similar trophic levels in the coral-reef foodweb. However, δ13C values differed among the eight eel species consumed by snakes, as well as between the two snake species, and were linked to habitat types. Specifically, δ13C differed between soft- vs. hard-substrate eel species, and consistently differed between the soft-bottom forager L. laticaudata (~ −14.7‰) and the hard-bottom forager L. saintgironsi (~ −12.5‰). Differences in isotopic signatures within and between the two sea krait species and their prey were consistent with the hypothesis of habitat-based dietary divergence. Isotopic composition varied with body size within each of the snake species and varied with body size within some eel species, reflecting ontogenetic shifts in feeding habits of both the sea kraits and their prey. Our results support the findings of previous studies based on snake stomach contents, indicating that further studies could usefully expand these isotopic analyses to a broader range of trophic levels, fish species and spatial scales.     

The Late Eocene ‘Whiskey Creek’ methane-seep deposit (western Washington State)

The Late Eocene ‘Whiskey Creek’ deposit (Pysht Formation, Olympic Penisula, Washington State) formed at a methane-seep. Early diagenetic micrites and aragonite cement have δ¹³C values as low as −36‰ indicating that the seepage fluids contained methane. With respect to micrite samples, low δ¹³C values correlate with relatively high δ¹³O values andvice versa. Ongoing micrite formation after the cessation of the seepage during increased burial might have altered the isotopic composition of the microcrystalline carbonates toward lower δ¹³O values and higher δ¹³C values. Alternatively, the trend in isotope values may reflect a change in the composition of seepage fluids. The principal difference between these scenarios is the duration of seepage with respect to micrite formation. Two petrographically similar varieties of blocky calcite spar are related to different carbonate sources. The δ¹³C values range from −32 to −29‰ for one type of blocky spar and are either the result of methane oxidation or indicate thermal decarboxylation of organic matter. Low δ¹⁸O values are in favour of the latter. For the other type of spar, δ¹³C values as high as +6‰ indicate carbonate formation within the zone of methanogensis. The ‘Whiskey Creek’ limestone exhibits a chaotic fabric produced by a variety of processes, including bioturbation, concretionary carbonate formation, earlyin situ brecciation, carbonate corrosion, and late fracturing of the rock. Two varieties of micrite aggregates are responsible for the nodular fabric of the limestone. Smoothly-shaped pyritiferous micrite nodules are of diagenetic origin and formed in a manner similar to that which produces carbonate concretions. Apart from being induced by anaerobic oxidation of methane, their formation is proposed to be linked to iron reduction and sulphide formation. The second, dominant variety is represented by irregularly-shaped, nodular to angular micrite aggregates surrounded by massive rims of pyrite, resulting from carbonate corrosion. A pure, fluorescent seam-micrite, constructive in origin, lines cavities or surrounds micritic aggregates.     

Contributions of stable-isotope data to elucidating food webs of Mediterranean rocky littoral fishes

The food webs of rocky infra-littoral ecosystems in the Mediterranean have been little studied. In this investigation stable isotopes and dietary data were compared in an attempt to describe features of the food webs concerned. δ¹³C and δ¹⁵N were determined for plants, invertebrates and fishes from the Bay of Calvi, Corsica. Dietary data were derived from the literature. δ¹³C of plants ranged from –8.59‰ to –33.74‰, of benthic invertebrates from –17.0‰ to –20.52‰, of planktonic invertebrates from –20.08‰ to –22.34‰ and of fishes from –16.27‰ to –19.59‰. δ¹⁵N was generally greater at higher trophic levels. δ¹⁵N of plants was 0.95–2.92‰, of benthic invertebrates 1.69–6.54‰, of planktonic invertebrates 3.51–6.82‰ and of fishes 4.63–9.77‰. ¹³C enrichment tended to be associated with benthic food chains and ¹³C depletion with planktonic chains. Stable-isotope data suggested more varied diets for many species than implied by gut-contents data. Omnivory and trophic plasticity were widespread, and many consumers fed lower down the food chain than previous studies had suggested. Both stable-isotope and gut-contents analysis resolved differences between fishes feeding on planktonic and benthic prey and indicated that the herbivorous fish Sarpa salpa fed on a diet substantially different from that of other fishes. Zooplankton were important in the diets of several consumers (both primary and secondary), as was plankton derived detritus. One species of fish previously identified as planktivorous was shown to feed largely on benthic organisms, whilst several species of benthic invertebrates may feed on plankton-derived detritus. Although herbivores seemed to obtain most of their C from macroalgae, δ¹⁵N data suggested that many of these animals supplemented their intake of N, although gut-contents analysis did not provide evidence for such uptake. The isotopic data have elucidated several features of the food web which we would not otherwise have detected. Received: 26 April 1999 / Accepted: 24 September 1999