Tracing the domestication of a biofilm-forming bacterium

Over the course of more than a century of laboratory experimentation, Bacillus subtilis has become "domesticated," losing its ability to carry out many behaviors characteristic of its wild ancestors. One such characteristic is the ability to form architecturally complex communities, referred to as biofilms. Previous work has shown that the laboratory strain 168 forms markedly attenuated biofilms compared with the wild strain NCIB3610 (3610), even after repair of a mutation in sfp (a gene involved in surfactin production) previously known to impair biofilm formation. Here, we show that in addition to the sfp mutation, mutations in epsC, swrA, and degQ are necessary and sufficient to explain the inability of the laboratory strain to produce robust biofilms. Finally, we show that the architecture of the biofilm is markedly influenced by a large plasmid present in 3610 but not 168 and that the effect of the plasmid can be attributed to a gene we designate rapP. When rapP is introduced into 168 together with wild-type alleles of sfp, epsC, swrA, and degQ, the resulting repaired laboratory strain forms biofilms that are as robust as and essentially indistinguishable in architecture from those of the wild strain, 3610. Thus, domestication of B. subtilis involved the accumulation of four mutations and the loss of a plasmid-borne gene.     

Comparative analysis of the development of swarming communities of Bacillus subtilis 168 and a natural wild type: critical effects of surfactin and the composition of the medium

The natural wild-type Bacillus subtilis strain 3610 swarms rapidly on the synthetic B medium in symmetrical concentric waves of branched dendritic patterns. In a comparison of the behavior of the laboratory strain 168 (trp) on different media with that of 3610, strain 168 (trp), which does not produce surfactin, displayed less swarming activity, both qualitatively (pattern formation) and in speed of colonization. On E and B media, 168 failed to swarm; however, with the latter, swarming was arrested at an early stage of development, with filamentous cells and rafts of cells (characteristic of dendrites of 3610) associated with bud-like structures surrounding the central inoculum. In contrast, strain 168 apparently swarmed efficiently on Luria-Bertani (LB) agar, colonizing the entire plate in 24 h. However, analysis of the intermediate stages of development of swarms on LB medium demonstrated that, in comparison with strain 3610, initiation of swarming of 168 (trp) was delayed and the greatly reduced rate of expansion of the swarm was uncoordinated, with some regions advancing faster than others. Moreover, while early stages of swarming in 3610 are accompanied by the formation of large numbers of dendrites whose rapid advance involves packs of cells at the tips, strain 168 advanced more slowly as a continuous front. When sfp+ was inserted into the chromosome of 168 (trp) to reestablish surfactin production, many features observed with 3610 on LB medium were now visible with 168. However, swarming of 168 (sfp+) still showed some reduced speed and a distinctive pattern compared to swarming of 3610. The results are discussed in terms of the possible role of surfactin in the swarming process and the different modes of swarming on LB medium.     

Extracellular proteolytic activity plays a central role in swarming motility in Bacillus subtilis

Natural isolates of Bacillus subtilis exhibit a robust multicellular behavior known as swarming. A form of motility, swarming is characterized by a rapid, coordinated progression of a bacterial population across a surface. As a collective bacterial process, swarming is often associated with biofilm formation and has been linked to virulence factor expression in pathogenic bacteria. While the swarming phenotype has been well documented for Bacillus species, an understanding of the molecular mechanisms responsible remains largely isolated to gram-negative bacteria. To better understand how swarming is controlled in members of the genus Bacillus, we investigated the effect of a series of gene deletions on swarm motility. Our analysis revealed that a strain deficient for the production of surfactin and extracellular proteolytic activity did not swarm or form biofilm. While it is known that surfactin, a lipoprotein surfactant, functions in swarming motility by reducing surface tension, this is the first report demonstrating that general extracellular protease activity also has an important function. These results not only help to define the factors involved in eliciting swarm migration but support the idea that swarming and biofilm formation may have overlapping control mechanisms.     

铜绿假单胞菌PAO1中c-di-GMP代谢相关基因PA0575对表型的影响

【背景】铜绿假单胞菌PAO1中存在与环鸟苷二磷酸(cyclic-di-guanosine monophosphate,c-di-GMP)代谢相关基因PA0575。【目的】探讨铜绿假单胞菌PAO1中环鸟苷二磷酸代谢相关基因PA0575对运动能力及生物膜的影响。【方法】通过PCR对菌株遗传背景进行确认;利用刚果红结合实验及电转PcdrA-gfp质粒间接测量胞内c-di-GMP水平;利用泳动性(swimming)、蜂群泳动(swarming)、蹭行运动(twiching)和生物膜定量实验对细菌进行表型分析,并在运动培养基中添加抗生素研究其对运动能力的影响;针对PA0575基因进行融合蛋白表达载体的构建,并对蛋白进行原核诱导表达。【结果】3株突变体菌株的转座子插入突变位点不一致,胞内c-di-GMP水平检测结果显示,PA0575-1菌株的c-di-GMP含量高于野生型PAO1菌株(P0.05),PA0575-2、PA0575-3菌株胞内c-di-GMP水平与野生型PAO1菌株无差异(P0.05)。运动能力检测实验中,与野生型PAO1菌株相比,PA0575-1菌株泳动性增强(P0.05);PA0575-2、PA0575-3菌株的泳动性、蜂群运动均增强(P0.05);该基因不同位点的突变均导致氯霉素对菌株的运动能力产生抑制作用。生物膜定量结果显示,与野生型PAO1菌株相比,细菌培养18 h后PA0575-1的生物膜含量降低(P0.05),PA0575-2、PA0575-3菌株的生物膜含量升高。最后成功构建了PA0575基因不同结构域的8个表达载体,并获得了异源表达蛋白。【结论】PA0575基因降低铜绿假单胞菌胞内c-di-GMP的水平,影响表型的同时也抑制了氯霉素抗性基因的表达。以上研究为PA0575基因对表型的影响奠定了基础。     

Swarming motility in undomesticated Bacillus subtilis

Swarming motility was identified and characterized in an undomesticated strain of Bacillus subtilis. Rapid surface migration was preceded by a cell density-dependent lag period, which could be eliminated if actively swarming cells were used as the inoculum. The leading edge of the swarm was characterized by multicellular rafts of highly flagellated cells. Flagellum biosynthesis and surfactant production were required for swarming. Swarming was not found in any of several standard laboratory strains. Laboratory strains are characteristically unable to produce surfactant, but such a strain remained unable to swarm even when surfactant was provided by extracellular complementation. We conclude that robust swarming is a feature of undomesticated B. subtilis and that this behaviour has been lost or attenuated in laboratory strains through the accumulation of multiple genetic defects.     

Kin discrimination drives territorial exclusion during Bacillus subtilis swarming and restrains exploitation of surfactin

Swarming is the collective movement of bacteria across a surface. It requires the production of surfactants (public goods) to overcome surface tension and provides an excellent model to investigate bacterial cooperation. Previously, we correlated swarm interaction phenotypes with kin discrimination between B. subtilis soil isolates, by showing that less related strains form boundaries between swarms and highly related strains merge. However, how kin discrimination affects cooperation and territoriality in swarming bacteria remains little explored. Here we show that the pattern of surface colonization by swarming mixtures is influenced by kin types. Closely related strain mixtures colonize the surface in a mixed swarm, while mixtures of less related strains show competitive exclusion as only one strain colonizes the surface. The outcome of nonkin swarm expansion depends on the initial ratio of the competing strains, indicating positive frequency-dependent competition. We find that addition of surfactin (a public good excreted from cells) can complement the swarming defect of nonkin mutants, whereas close encounters in nonkin mixtures lead to territorial exclusion, which limits the exploitation of surfactin by nonkin nonproducers. The work suggests that kin discrimination driven competitive territorial exclusion may be an important determinant for the success of cooperative surface colonization.Subject terms: Microbial ecology, Biofilms     

产表面活性素和伊枯草菌素A菌株的筛选及其脂肽类产物的特性

采用血琼脂平板法, 从菜园土壤中分离到8株代谢表面活性剂的菌株, 比较各菌株的排油性、抑菌性, 根据合成脂肽类物质表面活性素(Surfactin)和伊枯草菌素A (Iturin A)必需的sfp、ituD和lpa-14基因设计引物, 结合PCR的方法筛选到一株具广谱抗菌性且含有sfp、ituD和lpa-14 3个关键基因的细菌XZ-173。经过生理生化试验测定和16S rDNA序列系统发育学分析, 将其鉴定为解淀粉芽孢杆菌(Bacillus amyloliquefaciens)。通过红外光谱(FT-IR)分析该菌株代谢产物, 初步鉴定为脂肽类物质, 并对照高效液相色谱(HPLC)与标准品比对结果, 确定含有Surfactin和Iturin A组分。该菌株产生的脂肽粗品能使纯水的表面张力降低至26.6 mN/m, 临界胶束浓度(CMC)为500 mg/L, 具有很好的乳化性能, 对立枯丝核菌和青枯菌表现出很好的拮抗活性。因此, 产脂肽细菌XZ-173是一株应用前景广阔的功能菌。     

Swarming differentiation and swimming motility in Bacillus subtilis are controlled by swrA, a newly identified dicistronic operon

The number and disposition of flagella harbored by eubacteria are regulated by a specific trait successfully maintained over generations. The genes governing the number of flagella in Bacillus subtilis have never been identified, although the ifm locus has long been recognized to influence the motility phenotype of this microorganism. The characterization of a spontaneous ifm mutant of B. subtilis, displaying diverse degrees of cell flagellation in both liquid and solid media, raised the question of how the ifm locus governs the number and assembly of functional flagella. The major finding of this investigation is the characterization of a newly identified dicistronic operon, named swrA, that controls both swimming motility and swarming differentiation in B. subtilis. Functional analysis of the swrA operon allowed swrAA (previously named swrA [D. B. Kearns, F. Chu, R. Rudner, and R. Losick, Mol. Microbiol. 52:357-369, 2004]) to be the first gene identified in B. subtilis that controls the number of flagella in liquid environments and the assembly of flagella in response to cell contact with solid surfaces. Evidence is given that the second gene of the operon, swrAB, is essential for enabling the surface-adhering cells to undergo swarming differentiation. Preliminary data point to a molecular interaction between the two gene products.     

一种快速分离检测产脂肽类生物表面活性剂枯草芽孢杆菌的方法

脂肽(Lipopeptide)是由枯草芽孢杆菌(Bacillus subtilis)等微生物产生的一类具有较强表面活性的生物表面活性剂.枯革杆菌磷酸泛酰巯基转移酶基因(afp)是枯草芽孢杆菌中参与脂肽代谢的功能性基因.采用sfp基因PCR对从环境中得到的一组产生表面活性剂的微生物进行筛选,结合Tricine-SDS-PAGE电泳对PCR结果呈阳性的菌蛛的代谢粗初提物进行检测,初步鉴定得到两株枯草芽孢杆菌.进一步利用16S rDNA序列的系统发育学分析确定这两种菌株为枯草芽孢杆菌,并利用TLC、HPLC鉴定其产物为脂肽类表面活性剂,从而建立了一套快速分离检测产生脂肽类生物表面活性剂的枯草芽孢杆菌方法.     

suhB基因对绿针假单胞菌HT66生防能力的影响

[背景]绿针假单胞菌(Pseudomonaschlororaphis)HT66是一株兼具生防安全性和吩嗪-1-甲酰胺(Phenazine-1-Carboxamide,PCN)高产的植物根际促生菌,在生物防治、生态农业及可持续发展农业领域具有广阔的应用前景.非编码RNA(ncRNA)SuhB参与了细胞中多个过程的代谢调控...     

Laboratory Strains of Bacillus subtilis Do Not Exhibit Swarming Motility

We redemonstrate that SwrA is essential for swarming motility in Bacillus subtilis, and we reassert that laboratory strains of B. subtilis do not swarm. Additionally, we find that a number of other genes, previously reported to be required for swarming in laboratory strains, are dispensable for robust swarming motility in an undomesticated strain. We attribute discrepancies in the literature to a lack of reproducible standard experimental conditions, selection for spontaneous swarming suppressors, inadvertent genetic linkage to swarming mutations, and auxotrophy.Many species of bacteria are capable of flagellum-mediated swimming motility in liquid broth. Of those species, a subset is also capable of a related, but genetically separable, form of flagellum-mediated surface movement called swarming motility (17). Examples of swarming-proficient species include Proteus mirabilis, Vibrio parahaemolyticus, Serratia marcescens, Escherichia coli, Salmonella enterica, and Bacillus subtilis (1, 15, 16, 20, 28). In general, swarming requires a surfactant or wetting agent to reduce surface tension, an increase in flagellar number per cell, and other genetic features that are distinct from swimming (7, 14).There is confusion in the literature concerning the genetic requirements of the swarming phenotype of B. subtilis. It is generally accepted that the ancestral undomesticated strain B. subtilis 3610 exhibits robust swarming motility (18, 20, 33). Swarming motility of strain 3610 requires the production of a secreted surfactant, called surfactin (6, 20), to reduce surface tension and permit surface spreading, and it also requires the protein SwrA to activate flagellar biosynthesis gene expression and increase the number of flagella on the cell surface (5, 20). Some reports claim that domesticated derivatives of 3610, such as the commonly used laboratory strain 168, are also swarming proficient (10, 18, 19, 24). Strain 168, however, is defective in both surfactin production (9, 25) and SwrA (5, 21, 31), and thus, swarming 168 strains challenge the genetic definition of swarming motility. Our lab has never observed swarming in laboratory strains, and here we investigated swarming motility in a reportedly swarming-proficient 168 strain.We obtained a reportedly swarming-proficient 168 strain (13) (generous gift of Simone Séror, Orsay University, Paris-Sud, France) (Table ​(Table1)1) and compared its swarming phenotype to that of 3610 under our standard conditions (20). Swarm plates were prepared one day prior to use with 25 ml of LB medium (10 g Bacto tryptone, 5 g Bacto yeast extract, 5 g NaCl per liter) fortified with 0.7% Bacto agar. To minimize water on the agar surface and thus minimize the potentially confounding influence of swimming motility, plates were dried 20 min prior to inoculation and 10 min postinoculation open-faced in a laminar flow hood. For qualitative swarm assays, plates were centrally inoculated with cells from a freshly grown overnight colony using a sterile stick. For quantitative swarm expansion assays, 1 ml of cells grown to mid-exponential phase (optical density at 600 nm [OD₆₀₀], 0.5) was resuspended in PBS buffer (8 g NaCl, 0.2 g KCl, 1.44 g Na₂HPO₄, 0.24 g KH₂PO₄ per liter, pH 7.0) containing 0.5% India ink (Higgins) to an OD₆₀₀ of 10 and centrally spotted (10 μl). Swarm expansion was measured at 0.5-h intervals along a transect on the plate. Plates were incubated at 37°C in 20 to 30% humidity. Whereas strain 3610 was swarming proficient, strain 168 (Orsay) was swarming deficient (Fig. ​(Fig.1A).1A). Thus, strain 168 (Orsay) appeared to behave similarly to all other laboratory strains we have tested previously (20, 21).Open in a separate windowFIG. 1.Swarming motility on LB and B media. In qualitative plate images, colonized agar appears white and uncolonized agar appears black on LB and B media, as indicated. Swarming cells colonize a larger surface area than nonswarming cells. All strains are derivatives of strain 3610 unless otherwise indicated. Bar, 2 cm. (A) Quantitative swarm expansion assays on solid medium and growth in liquid medium of the indicated strains on LB medium (closed symbols) and on B medium (open symbols). To indicate variability in a particular experiment, we have reproduced the quantitative swarm expansion assay of strain 3610 on LB and B media with error bars in Fig. S5 in the supplemental material. (B) Quantitative swarm expansion assays on LB (closed symbols) and B (open symbols) media. The following strains were used: DS3337 (sfp), DS2415 (swrA), DS5106 (168 swrA⁺), DS5758 (168 sfp⁺), and DS5759 (168 swrA⁺ sfp⁺). In all assays, B medium was made according to reference 2 except for strain DS5759, for which B medium was supplemented with 780 μM threonine to compensate for thrC auxotrophy. (C) Swarm plates of the indicated strains on LB medium made with equal parts peptone instead of tryptone. (D) Quantitative swarm expansion assays of the indicated 3610-derived mutant strains on LB medium (closed symbols) and on B medium (open symbols). The following strains were used: DS72 (yvzB), DS2268 (epr), DS3903 (phrC), DS4978 (rapC), DS4979 (oppD), DS2509 (swrB), and DS3649 (degU). All points are averages for three replicates.

TABLE 1.

Strains

海绵共生萎缩芽孢杆菌C89 PPTase bap基因的异源表达

【背景】磷酸泛酰巯基乙胺基转移酶(PPTase)催化非核糖体肽合成酶(NRPS)中肽酰载体蛋白(PCP)从无活性的脱辅基形态转化为有活性的全辅基形态,从而启动非核糖体肽类化合物的生物合成。【目的】鉴定贪婪倔海绵共生萎缩芽孢杆菌C89中Sfp型PPTase Bap,验证Bap激活NRPS中PCP的能力。【方法】通过BLAST和氨基酸多序列比对鉴定萎缩芽孢杆菌C89中Sfp型PPTase Bap。将bap基因在sfp基因突变株枯草芽孢杆菌168中异源表达,通过重组菌枯草芽孢杆菌168-bap的代谢物检测非核糖体肽类化合物Surfactin。【结果】Bap为Sfp型PPTase,检测到重组菌枯草芽孢杆菌168-bap中Surfactin的产生。【结论】本研究为海洋萎缩芽孢杆菌中NRPS基因簇的异源表达奠定了基础。     

Defining the genetic differences between wild and domestic strains of Bacillus subtilis that affect poly-gamma-dl-glutamic acid production and biofilm formation

Biofilms are communities of microbial cells that are encased in a self-produced, polymeric matrix and are adherent to a surface. For several species of bacteria, an enhanced ability to form biofilms has been linked with an increased capability to produce exopolymers. To identify exopolymers of Bacillus subtilis that can contribute to biofilm formation, we transferred the genetic determinants that control exopolymer production from a wild, exopolymer-positive strain to a domesticated, exopolymer-negative strain. Mapping these genetic determinants led to the identification of gamma-poly-dl-glutamic acid (gamma-PGA) as an exopolymer that increases biofilm formation, possibly through enhancing cell-surface interactions. Production of gamma-PGA by Bacillus subtilis was known to be dependent on the two-component regulator ComPA; this study highlighted the additional dependence on the DegS-DegU, DegQ and SwrA regulator proteins. The inability of the domestic strain of B. subtilis to produce gamma-PGA was mapped to two base pairs; a single base pair change in the promoter region of degQ and a single base pair insertion in the coding region of swrA. Introduction of alleles of degQ and swrA from the wild strain into the domestic strain was sufficient to allow gamma-PGA production. In addition to controlling gamma-PGA production, ComPA and DegSU were also shown to activate biofilm formation through an as yet undefined pathway. The identification of these regulators as affecting gamma-PGA production and biofilm formation suggests that these processes are regulated by osmolarity, high cell density and phase variation.     

苜蓿中华根瘤菌(Sinorhizobium meliloti)LuxR家族转录因子ExpR调节motC操纵子的表达

目前已知苜蓿中华根瘤菌(S.meliloti)Rm1021 ExpR 突变导致胞外多糖Ⅱ(EPSⅡ)的过量表达,而胞外多糖是根瘤菌成功侵染宿主植物形成有效根瘤必需的物质。软琼脂板实验发现ExpR 突变株运动能力有缺陷。但是鞭毛染色实验并没有检测到突变株的鞭毛与野生型有什么不同。通过启动子-lacZ融合子进一步研究突变株中基因表达的差异发现,ExpR以细胞密度依赖的方式调节motC操纵子的表达。由此可见,在苜蓿中华根瘤菌中,ExpR同时参与了胞外多糖Ⅱ的合成和细胞运动能力的调节。     

Slow motile mutant in Salmonella typhimurium

Enomoto, Masatoshi (National Institute of Genetics, Misima, Japan). Slow motile mutant in Salmonella typhimurium. J. Bacteriol. 90:1696-1702. 1965.-A slow motile mutant, SJ399, was isolated from a wild-type strain of Salmonella typhimurium TM2. The mutant was as motile as the wild type in broth culture at 37 C. However, on semisolid medium it produced a much narrower swarming band than TM2. The motility of this mutant was hindered by the viscosity of semisolid medium. H antigenicity and morphological characters of flagella of the mutant were the same as those of the wild type. The motility phage, chi, responded differently to SJ399 and the wild type. Plaques of SJ399 were small and cloudy, whereas on the wild type they were large and clear. The efficiency of plating on SJ399 was 0.36 as compared with 1 with the wild type. Stained preparations revealed that the mutant had about one-third the number of flagella of the wild type. The reduction of the number of flagella also was ascertained by biochemical measurement of flagellar protein which was purified after deflagellation from cells. The content of flagellin in SJ399 was about 32% of that of the wild type. Phage P22-mediated transductions from SJ399 to nonflagellated (fla(-)) and paralyzed (mot(-)) mutants showed that the mutant SJ399 complements seven fla(-) and three mot(-) strains which are representative mutants of flagellation and motility cistrons, respectively. The mutation site of SJ399 was cotransduced with both motA and B cistrons. The two point cross tests between SJ399 and mot mutants revealed that the mutation site of SJ399 is located in the motB cistron. The insertion of the genetic region containing the mutation site of SJ399 to the motB cistron is discussed in relation to intracistronic complementation.     

Importance ofeps genes fromBacillus subtilis in biofilm formation and swarming

Unicellular organisms naturally form multicellular communities, differentiate into specialized cells, and synchronize their behaviour under certain conditions. Swarming, defined as a movement of a large mass of bacteria on solid surfaces, is recognized as a preliminary step in the formation of biofilms. The main aim of this work was to study the role of a group of genes involved in exopolysaccharide biosynthesis during pellicle formation and swarming inBacillus subtilis strain 168. To assess the role of particular proteins encoded by the group ofepsI-epsO genes that form theeps operon, we constructed a series of insertional mutants. The results obtained showed that mutations inepsJ-epsN, but not in the last gene of theeps operon (epsO), have a severe effect on pellicle formation under all tested conditions. Moreover, the inactivation of 5 out of the 6 genes analysed caused total inhibition of swarming in strain 168 (that does not produce surfactin) on LB medium. Following restoration of thesfp gene (required for production of surfactin, which is essential for swarming of the wild-type bacteria), thesfp ⁺ strains defective ineps genes (exceptepsO) generated significantly different patterns during swarming on synthetic B medium, as compared to the parental strain 168sfp ⁺.