The ins and outs of human reticulocyte maturation: Autophagy and the endosome/exosome pathway

The maturation of reticulocytes into functional erythrocytes is a complex process requiring extensive cytoplasmic and plasma membrane remodeling, cytoskeletal rearrangements and changes to cellular architecture. Autophagy is implicated in the sequential removal of erythroid organelles during erythropoiesis, although how this is regulated during late stages of erythroid differentiation, and the potential contribution of autophagy during reticulocyte maturation, remain unclear. Using an optimized ex vivo differentiation system for human erythropoiesis, we have observed that maturing reticulocytes are characterized by the presence of one or few large vacuolar compartments. These label strongly for glycophorin A (GYPA/GPA) which is internalized from the plasma membrane; however, they also contain organellar remnants (ER, Golgi, mitochondria) and stain strongly for LC3, suggesting that they are endocytic/autophagic hybrid structures. Interestingly, we observed the release of these vacuoles by exocytosis in maturing reticulocytes, and speculate that autophagy is needed to concentrate the final remnants of the reticulocyte endomembrane system in autophagosome/endosome hybrid compartments that are primed to undergo exocytosis.     

Protein Distribution during Human Erythroblast Enucleation In Vitro

Enucleation is the step in erythroid terminal differentiation when the nucleus is expelled from developing erythroblasts creating reticulocytes and free nuclei surrounded by plasma membrane. We have studied protein sorting during human erythroblast enucleation using fluorescence activated cell sorting (FACS) to obtain pure populations of reticulocytes and nuclei produced by in vitro culture. Nano LC mass spectrometry was first used to determine the protein distribution profile obtained from the purified reticulocyte and extruded nuclei populations. In general cytoskeletal proteins and erythroid membrane proteins were preferentially restricted to the reticulocyte alongside key endocytic machinery and cytosolic proteins. The bulk of nuclear and ER proteins were lost with the nucleus. In contrast to the localization reported in mice, several key erythroid membrane proteins were detected in the membrane surrounding extruded nuclei, including band 3 and GPC. This distribution of key erythroid membrane and cytoskeletal proteins was confirmed using western blotting. Protein partitioning during enucleation was investigated by confocal microscopy with partitioning of cytoskeletal and membrane proteins to the reticulocyte observed to occur at a late stage of this process when the nucleus is under greatest constriction and almost completely extruded. Importantly, band 3 and CD44 were shown not to restrict specifically to the reticulocyte plasma membrane. This highlights enucleation as a stage at which excess erythroid membrane proteins are discarded in human erythroblast differentiation. Given the striking restriction of cytoskeleton proteins and the fact that membrane proteins located in macromolecular membrane complexes (e.g. GPA, Rh and RhAG) are segregated to the reticulocyte, we propose that the membrane proteins lost with the nucleus represent an excess mobile population of either individual proteins or protein complexes.     

Selective mitochondrial autophagy during erythroid maturation

Accumulating evidence suggests that autophagy can be selective in the clearance of organelles in yeast and in mammalian cells. We have observed that the sequestration of mitochondria by autophagosomes was defective in reticulocytes in the absence of Nix. Nix is required for the dissipation of mitochondrial membrane potential (DeltaPsim) during erythroid maturation. Moreover, pharmacological agents that induce the loss of DeltaPsim can restore the sequestration of mitochondria by autophagosomes and promote mitochondrial clearance in Nix(-/-) erythroid cells. Our data suggest that mitochondrial depolarization induces recognition and sequestration of mitochondria by autophagosomes. Elucidating the mechanisms underlying selective mitochondrial autophagy not only will help us to understand the mechanisms for erythroid maturation, but also may provide insights into mitochondrial quality control by autophagy in the protection against aging, cancer and neurodegenerative diseases.     

Fractionation analysis of the endosomal compartment during rat reticulocyte maturation

A subcellular fractionation procedure was developed to isolate the different endosomal compartments present during reticulocyte maturation. After reticulocyte lysis and removal of excess haemoglobin by gel chromatography, membrane vesicles were separated over a discontinuous sucrose gradient (10-40%). Two fractions were isolated: P1 at the 25-35% sucrose interface and P2 at the 17-25% sucrose interface. These fractions were morphologically characterized by electron microscopy and the distribution of endocytic markers in the fractions was detected by Western blot. Moreover, this fractionation technique was used to study the effect of 3-methyladenine (3-MA), an autophagy inhibitor, on reticulocyte maturation. The presence of 3-MA during in vitro maturation of reticulocytes induced a decrease in exosome secretion, as measured by the amount of transferrin receptor (TfR) released in the extracellular medium. The subcellular fractionation results suggested that multivesicular endosome formation from early endosomes is the step affected by 3-MA.     

The correlation of composition and morphology during the high to low potassium transition in single erythropoietic cells

The change from high potassium dog erythroid cells to low potassium red blood cells during erythropoiesis was investigated by X-ray microanalysis of single cells. A correlation of morphology and composition, using freeze-dried cryosectioned preparations, showed that during normal erythropoiesis in dog bone marrow the switch from high potassium to low potassium occurs during the change from early to late nucleated erythroid cells, and in synchrony with the beginning of iron accumulation. In contrast, during rapid erythropoiesis in dogs with phenylhydrazine-induced anemia, the most prominent change in cation composition as well as the accumulation of iron occurs during the reticulocyte stage in the peripheral blood. The determination of the absolute amounts of sodium and potassium per cell in stress reticulocytes of peripheral blood indicated that the changeover from high potassium to low potassium actually occurs by the loss of cellular potassium during volume reduction, with little change in the amount of cellular sodium. This suggests that maturation may involve a selective change in potassium permeability. Lastly, it was observed that not all cells followed the predominant pathway with respect to change in morphology, membrane permeability and hemoglobin synthesis. One particular subpopulation appeared to follow a sequence which expressed the complete HK to LK transition before the accumulation of any iron; this implies the possibility of completing protein synthesis in a low potassium intracellular milieu.     

Multivesicular bodies and autophagy in erythrocyte maturation

During reticulocyte maturation, hematopoietic progenitors undergo numerous changes to reach the final functional stage which concludes with the release of reticulocytes and erythrocytes into circulation. During this process some proteins, which are not required in the mature stage, are sequestered in the internal vesicles present in multivesicular bodies (MVBs). These small vesicles are known as exosomes because they are released into the extracellular medium by fusion of the MVB with the plasma membrane. Interestingly, during this maturation process some organelles, such as mitochondria and endoplasmic reticulum, are wrapped in double membrane vacuoles and degraded via autophagy. We have demonstrated in human leukemic K562 cells a role for calcium and Rab11 in the biogenesis of MVBs and exosome release. Here we discuss evidence indicating that K562 cells present a high basal level of autophagy, and that there is an association between MVBs and autophagosomes, suggesting a role for the autophagic pathway in the maturation process of this cell type.     

Selective mitochondrial autophagy during erythroid maturation

Accumulating evidence suggests that autophagy can be selective in the clearance of organelles in yeast and in mammalian cells. We have observed that the sequestration of mitochondria by autophagosomes was defective in reticulocytes in the absence of Nix. Nix is required for the dissipation of mitochondrial membrane potential (ΔΨm) during erythroid maturation. Moreover, pharmacological agents that induce the loss of ΔΨm can restore the sequestration of mitochondria by autophagosomes and promote mitochondrial clearance in Nix-/- erythroid cells. Our data suggest that mitochondrial depolarization induces recognition and sequestration of mitochondria by autophagosomes. Elucidating the mechanisms underlying selective mitochondrial autophagy not only will help us to understand the mechanisms for erythroid maturation, but also may provide insights into mitochondrial quality control by autophagy in the protection against aging, cancer, and neurodegenerative diseases.

Addendum to: Sandoval H, Thiagarajan P, Dasgupta SK, Schumacher A, Prchal JT, Chen M, Wang J. Essential role for Nix in autophagic maturation of erythroid cells. Nature 2008; 454:232-5.     

Differential regulatory and compensatory responses in hematopoiesis/erythropoiesis in alpha- and beta-globin hemizygous mice

Characterization of hematopoiesis/erythropoiesis in thalassemias from multipotent primitive cells to mature erythrocytes is of fundamental importance and clinical relevance. We investigated this process in alpha- and beta-globin hemizygous mice, lacking the two adult tandemly organized genes from either the alpha- or beta-globin locus. Although both mice backcrossed on a homogeneous background exhibited similar reduced red blood cell (RBC) survival, beta-globin hemizygous mice had less severe reticulocyte loss and globin chain imbalance, suggesting an apparently milder thalassemia than for alpha-globin hemizygous mice. In contrast, however, beta-globin hemizygous mice displayed a more marked perturbation of hematologic parameters. Quantification of erythroid precursor subpopulations in marrow and spleen of beta-globin hemizygous mice showed more severely impaired maturation from the basophilic to orthochromatophilic erythroblasts and substantial loss of these late precursors probably as a consequence of a greater susceptibility to an excess of free alpha-chain than beta-chain. Hence, only erythroid precursors exhibiting stochastically moderate chain imbalance would escape death and mature to reticulocyte/RBC stage, leading to survival and minimal loss of reticulocytes in the beta-globin hemizygous mice. Furthermore, in response to the ineffective erythropoiesis in beta-globin hemizygous mice, a dynamic compensatory hematopoiesis was observed at earlier differentiation stage as evidenced by a significant increase of erythroid progenitors (erythroid colony-forming units approximately 100-fold) as well as of multipotent primitive cells (day 12 spleen colony-forming units approximately 7-fold). This early compensatory mechanism was less pronounced in alpha-globin hemizygous mice. The expansion of multipotent primitive and potentially stem cell populations, taken together with ineffective erythropoiesis and increased reticulocyte/RBC destruction could confer major cumulative advantage for gene targeting/bone marrow transplantation. Therefore, this study not only corroborated the strong potential effectiveness of transplantation for thalassemic hematopoietic therapy but also demonstrated the existence of a differential regulatory response for alpha- and beta-thalassemia.     

NIX induces mitochondrial autophagy in reticulocytes

The controlled elimination of defective mitochondria is necessaryfor the health of long-lived post-mitotic cells, like cardiomyocytesand neurons. Mitochondrial elimination also occurs during thecourse of normal development, in lens epithelial and erythroidcells. Strikingly, at the final stage of erythroid cell maturation,newly formed erythrocytes, also known as reticulocytes, eliminatetheir entire cohort of mitochondria. We have employed thismodel to investigate the mechanism of programmed mitochondrialclearance. NIX (BNIP3L) is a Bcl-2-related protein that is upregulatedduring terminal erythroid differentiation.^1,2 NIX-deficientreticulocytes have a significant defect of mitochondrial clearance.Consistent with the ability of NIX to cause mitochondrial depolarization, ^3,4 we show that mitochondria are depolarized in wildtype but not NIX deficient reticulocytes. NIX does not functionthrough established proapoptotic pathways, nor does it mediate theinduction of autophagy in erythroid cells. Rather, NIX is requiredfor the selective incorporation of mitochondria into autophagosomes.Elucidation of the mechanism of this effect will improveour understanding of the role of autophagy in the maintenance ofcellular homeostasis.

Addendum to: Schweers RL, Zhang J, Randall MS, Loyd MR, Li W, Dorsey FC, Kundu M, Opferman JT, Cleveland JL, Miller JL, Ney PA. NIX is required for programmed mitochondrial clearance during reticulocyte maturation. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 2007; 104:19500-5.     

Transfer RNA in reticulocyte maturation

The disappearance of tRNA during the maturation of rabbit reticulocytes under the stress of phenylhydrazine-induced hemolysis was studied. The tRNA content of reticulocytes and of erythrocytes derived from them was compared. The results show that tRNA persists longer after reticulocyte maturation than ribosomes and than the ability to incorporate amino acids into protein. Considerable uniformity of tRNA degradation was noted with about 15% of the tRNA for most amino acids remaining after reticulocyte maturation. The half-life of tRNA in the maturing cells is estimated to be 50--60 h. There is little tRNA lacking the 3'-terminal pCpCpA moiety in cells derived from reticulocytes.     

Cytoskeletal distribution and function during the maturation and enucleation of mammalian erythroblasts

We have used murine splenic erythrolasts infected with the anemia- inducing strain of Friend virus (FVA cells), as an in vitro model to study cytoskeletal elements during erythroid maturation and enucleation. FVA cells are capable of enucleating in suspension culture in vitro, indicating that associations with an extracellular matrix or accessory cells are not required for enucleation to occur. The morphology of FVA cells undergoing enucleation is nearly identical to erythroblasts enucleating in vivo. The nucleus is segregated to one side of the cell and then appears to be pinched off resulting in an extruded nucleus and reticulocyte. The extruded nucleus is surrounded by an intact plasma membrane and has little cytoplasm associated with it. Newly formed reticulocytes have an irregular shape, are vacuolated and contain all cytoplasmic organelles. The spatial distribution of several cytoskeletal proteins was examined during the maturation process. Spectrin was found associated with the plasma membrane of FVA cells at all stages of maturation but was segregated entirely to the incipient reticulocyte during enucleation. Microtubules formed cages around nuclei in immature FVA cells and were found primarily in the incipient reticulocyte in cells undergoing enucleation. Reticulocytes occasionally contained microtubules, but a generalized diffuse distribution of tubulin was more common. Vimentin could not be detected at any time in FVA cell maturation. Filamentous actin (F-actin) had a patchy distribution at the cell surface in the most immature erythroblasts, but F-actin bundles could be detected as the cells matured. F-actin was found concentrated between the extruding nucleus and incipient reticulocyte in enucleating erythroblasts. Newly formed reticulocytes exhibited punctate actin fluorescence whereas extruded nuclei lacked F-actin. Addition of colchicine, vinblastine, or taxol to cultures of FVA cells did not affect enucleation. In contrast, cytochalasin D caused a complete inhibition of enucleation that could be reversed by washing out the cytochalasin D. These results demonstrate that F-actin plays a role in enucleation while the complete absence of microtubules or excessive numbers of polymerized microtubules do not affect enucleation.     

Vesicle formation during reticulocyte maturation. Association of plasma membrane activities with released vesicles (exosomes)

Vesicles are released during the in vitro culture of sheep reticulocytes which can be harvested by centrifugation at 100,000 X g for 90 min. These vesicles contain a number of activities, characteristic of the reticulocyte plasma membrane, which are known to diminish or disappear upon reticulocyte maturation. The activities include acetylcholinesterase, cytochalasin B binding (glucose transporter) nucleoside binding (i.e. nucleoside transporter), Na+-independent amino acid transport, and the transferrin receptor. Enzymes of cytosolic origin are not detectable or are present at low activity in the vesicles. Cultures of whole blood, mature red cells, or white cells do not yield comparable levels of these activities, supporting the conclusion that the activities arise from the reticulocytes. In addition, the lipid composition of the vesicles shows the high sphingomyelin content characteristic of sheep red cell plasma membranes, but not white cell or platelet membranes, also consistent with the conclusion that the vesicles are of reticulocyte origin. It is suggested that vesicle externalization may be a mechanism for shedding of specific membrane functions which are known to diminish during maturation of reticulocytes to erythrocytes.     

Characteristics of in vivo murine erythropoietic response to sodium orthovanadate

Current knowledge about the effects of vanadium compounds on erythropoiesis is still reduced and even contradictory. The aim of this work was to evaluate the in vivo effects of a single dose of sodium orthovanadate (OV, 33 mg/kg i.p.) on CF-1 mice in a time course study (0-8 days). Murine erythropoiesis was assessed through a combinatory of experimental approaches. Classical peripheral and bone marrow (BM) hematological parameters were determined. Erythroid maturation in blood stream and hemopoietic tissues (59Fe uptake assays), BM erythroid progenitor frequency (clonogenic assays) and erythroid crucial protein expressions for commitment and survival: GATA-1, erythropoietin receptor (Epo-R) and Bcl-xL (immunoblottings) were evaluated. Neither BM cellularities nor BM viabilities changed noticeably during the study. Peripheral reticulocytes showed a biphasic increment on days 2 and 8 post-OV. hematocrits enhanced transiently between days 2 and 4. 59Fe uptake percentages enhanced in peripheral blood nearly two-fold over control values between 4 and 8 days (p<0.01) without changes in BM and spleen. Additionally, mature erythroid BM compartments: polychromatophilic erythroblasts and orthochromatic normoblasts increased by the eighth day. BFU-E colonies remained near basal values during the whole experience, whilst CFU-E colonies raised 60% over control at 8 days post-OV (p<0.05). GATA-1 and Epo-R were significantly over-expressed from the third until the end of the experimental protocol (p<0.01). Surprisingly, Bcl-xL showed a constitutive expression pattern without changes during the experience. Experimental data let us suggest that OV does not to cause bone marrow cytotoxicity and that it accelerates maturation of BM committed erythroid precursors. Moreover, there are significant correlations among erythroid-related protein expressions: GATA-1 and Epo-R and the frequency of CFU-E. In addition, Bcl-xL expression invariance during the time course study would indicate that the stimulatory effect of OV treatment on erythropoiesis was mainly exerted on the maturation of red cell precursors rather than on the antiapoptosis of erythroid terminal progenitors.     

Translation of 15-lipoxygenase mRNA is inhibited by a protein that binds to a repeated sequence in the 3'' untranslated region.

During red blood cell differentiation, the mRNA encoding rabbit erythroid 15-lipoxygenase (LOX) is synthesized in the early stages of erythropoiesis, but is only activated for translation in peripheral reticulocytes. Erythroid LOX, which like other lipoxygenases catalyses the degradation of lipids, is unique in its ability to attack intact phospholipids and is the main factor responsible for the degradation of mitochondria during reticulocyte maturation. Strikingly, rabbit erythroid LOX mRNA has 10 tandem repeats of a slightly varied, pyrimidine-rich 19 nt motif in its 3'-untranslated region (3'-UTR). In this study we demonstrate, using gel retardation and UV-crosslinking assays, that this 3'-UTR segment specifically binds a 48 kDa reticulocyte protein. Furthermore, the interaction between the 3'-UTR LOX repeat motif and the 48 kDa protein, purified to homogeneity by specific RNA chromatography, is shown to be necessary and sufficient for specific translational repression of LOX as well as reporter mRNAs in vitro. To our knowledge this is the first case in which translation, presumably at the initiation step, is regulated by a defined protein-RNA interaction in the 3'-UTR.     

Penetration of maturating red blood cells by Toxoplasma gondii

Penetration of Toxoplasma gondii tachyzoites was studied in vitro using murine erythroid cells at different stages of development. Toxoplasma gondii penetrated nucleated erythroblasts and macroreticulocytes from foetal mouse liver and the circulating erythrocytes of foetal, neonatal or severely anaemic adult mice. Immature reticulocytes were more susceptible to penetration than mature ones, indicating that some change in their membrane properties occurred during maturation. The present results confirmed our previous finding that the major erythrocyte membrane-specific proteins do not prevent erythrocyte penetration since these proteins are known to be present in the reticulocyte membrane.     

NIX induces mitochondrial autophagy in reticulocytes

The controlled elimination of defective mitochondria is necessary for the health of long-lived post-mitotic cells, like cardiomyocytes and neurons. Mitochondrial elimination also occurs during the course of normal development, in lens epithelial and erythroid cells. Strikingly, at the final stage of erythroid cell maturation, newly formed erythrocytes, also known as reticulocytes, eliminate their entire cohort of mitochondria. We have employed this model to investigate the mechanism of programmed mitochondrial clearance. NIX (BNIP3L) is a Bcl-2-related protein that is upregulated during terminal erythroid differentiation. NIX-deficient reticulocytes have a significant defect of mitochondrial clearance. Consistent with the ability of NIX to cause mitochondrial depolarization, we show that mitochondria are depolarized in wild type but not NIX deficient reticulocytes. NIX does not function through established proapoptotic pathways, nor does it mediate the induction of autophagy in erythroid cells. Rather, NIX is required for the selective incorporation of mitochondria into autophagosomes. Elucidation of the mechanism of this effect will improve our understanding of the role of autophagy in the maintenance of cellular homeostasis.     

Exosomes released during reticulocyte maturation bind to fibronectin via integrin alpha4beta1.

Exosomes are vesicles formed in the endosomal compartment and released in the extracellular medium during reticulocyte maturation into erythrocytes. They have a clearing function because of their enrichment with some proteins known to decrease or disappear from the cell surface during maturation, e.g. acetylcholinesterase and transferrin receptor. We show here that integrin alpha4beta1, present on the surface of erythroid precursors but absent from the mature red cell membrane, is at least partly cleared from the reticulocyte plasma membrane by the exosomal pathway. Using flow cytometry, we found that the alpha4 subunit disappears from the reticulocyte surface during in vitro maturation. Two different monoclonal antibodies (B-5G10 and HP 2/1) were used to demonstrate the presence of the alpha4 chain on the exosome surface. Moreover, membrane acetylcholinesterase and lumenal peroxidase-like (i.e. hemoglobin) enzymatic activities were assayed to demonstrate exosome binding to plates coated with increasing fibronectin (FN) concentrations. This interaction was dependent on divalent cations (MnCl2 > MgCl2 > CaCl2). Similarly, vesicles bound to plates coated with the chymotryptic 40 K fragment (FN-40) containing the heparin-binding region of FN. This binding was inhibited by exosome preincubation with fibronectin CS1 peptide and with a monoclonal antibody (HP 2/1) against the integrin alpha4-chain, confirming an alpha4beta1-induced interaction. The importance of the exosome clearance function is highlighted here, since the presence of VLA-4 on reticulocytes often leads to blood circulation complications in some diseases. Moreover, the presence of alpha4beta1 on the exosome surface, by allowing binding to endothelial cells through vascular cell adhesion molecule 1 (VCAM-1), might confer another physiological function to the secreted vesicles.     

Member-associated changes during erythropoiesis. On the mechanism of maturation of reticulocytes to erythrocytes

The mature mammalian erythrocyte has a unique membranoskeleton, the spectrin-actin complex, which is responsible for many of the unusual membrane properties of the erythrocyte. Previous studies have shown that in successive stages of differentiation of the erythropoietic series leading to the mature erythrocyte there is a progressive increase in the density of spectrin associated with the membranes of these cells. An important stage of this progression occurs during the enucleation of the late erythroblast to produce the incipient reticulocyte, when all of the spectrin of the former cell is sequestered to the membrane of the reticulocyte. The reticulocyte itself, however, does not exhibit a fully formed membranoskeleton. In particular, the in vitro binding of multivalent ligands to specific membrane receptors on the reticulocyte was shown to cause a clustering of some fractions of these ligand-receptor complexes into special mobile domains on the cell surface. These domains of clustered ligand-receptor complexes became invaginated and endocytosed as small vesicles. By immunoelectron microscopic experiments, these invaginations and endocytosed vesicles were found to be specifically free of spectrin on their cytoplasmic surfaces. These earlier findings then raised the possibility that the maturation of reticulocytes to mature erythrocytes in vivo might involve a progressive loss of reticulocyte membrane free of spectrin, thereby producing a still more concentrated spectrin-actin membranoskeleton in the erythrocyte than in the reticulocyte. This proposal is tested experimentally in this paper. In vivo reticulocytes were observed in ultrathin frozen sections of spleens from rabbits rendered anemic by phenylhydrazine treatment. These sections were indirectly immunolabeled with ferritin-antibody reagents directed to rabbit spectrin. Most reticulocytes in a section had one or more surface invaginations and one or more intra-cellular vesicles that were devoid of spectrin labeling. The erythrocytes in the same sections did not exhibit these features, and their membranes were everywhere uniformly labeled for spectrin. Spectrin-free surface invaginations and intracellular vesicle were also observed with reticulocytes within normal rabbit spleens. Based on these results, a scheme for membrane remodeling during reticulocyte maturation in vivo is proposed.