Autophagy and Cathepsin D mediated apoptosis contributing to ovarian follicular atresia in the Nile tilapia

Follicular atresia is a hormonally controlled degenerative process involving apoptosis of the somatic and germ cells. Since different signaling pathways can induce cell death, the aim of the present study was to investigate cell death signaling and crosstalk between autophagic, apoptotic, and lysosomal proteins during follicular atresia in Nile tilapia. For this, females were kept in controlled conditions for 21 days, and ovary samples were collected weekly. The atretic follicles (AF) were analyzed in three regression phases: Early, advanced, and late. Under electron microscopy, the follicular cells exhibited numerous protein synthesis organelles in the early AF. Immunoreactivity for Bcl2, Beclin1, Lc3, and Cathepsin D increased significantly in advanced AF (p < .001), when follicular cells were in intense yolk phagocytosis. In this phase, autophagosomes and autolysosomes were frequently observed. In the late AF, follicular cells had a markedly electron‐lucid cytoplasm and immunoreactivity for Bax and TUNEL assay indicated an elevated apoptosis rate. Colocalisation of Lamp1/Cathepsin D and Lc3/Caspase‐3 suggests dynamic crosstalk between the autophagy, apoptosis, and lysosome pathways. Taken together, the data indicate that autophagy plays a role in the homeostasis and clearance of the follicular cells preceding Cathepsin D mediated apoptosis during follicular atresia in Nile tilapia.     

Size-frequency analysis of atresia in cycling rats

The purpose of this study was to delineate when, during follicular growth, the alternative developmental pathways leading to ovulation or atresia diverge. By using computerized image analysis techniques, random samples of healthy and atretic follicles in ovaries of cycling rats were subjected to size-frequency analysis. The vast preponderance of atretic follicles were of the early antral size class (approximately 300-350 micron diameter, 800-1000 granulosa cells in the largest cross-section); atretic small follicles (less than 250 granulosa cells in the largest cross-section) were rare. Follicles in early stages of atresia were uncommon in ovaries of animals killed at estrus, but were found with great frequency in ovaries of animals killed the following day (metestrus). These results suggest that, under normal cyclic conditions, there may be only one major branching point during follicular development when growing follicles become susceptible to atresia. The alternative developmental pathways leading to ovulation and atresia may not diverge until the penultimate stage of growth, immediately preceding the final transformation into a preovulatory follicle.     

Ovarian regression and apoptosis in the South American teleost Leporinus taeniatus Lütken (Characiformes, Anostomidae) from the São Francisco Basin

Involution and resorption of both postovulatory and atretic follicles were analysed in piau‐jejo Leporinus taeniatus (Characiformes, Anostomidae) in order to evaluate the role of apoptosis during ovarian regression. Histological and ultrastructural analyses showed hallmarks of apoptosis in the granulosa: aggregation of compacted chromatin against the nuclear envelope, cell shrinkage, surface blebbing, loss of cell adhesion and cell fragmentation into apoptotic bodies. Protein synthesis activity preceded the onset of the cell death. The breakdown of the basement membrane led to the detachment of the granulosa cells into the follicular lumen. TUNEL‐positive reactions were detected in in situ DNA fragmentation of granulosa of both postovulatory and atretic follicles. Apoptosis increased in a time‐dependent manner contributing to reduction of the follicular areas. The apoptotic index (per cent of apoptotic cells) of the granulosa increased in postovulatory follicles soon after spawning, then these follicles degenerated and only remnants were observed at 7 days. In contrast, the granulosa cells reabsorbed the yolk during follicular atresia and the apoptotic index increased only in the late stage of regression. The results indicated apoptosis as the major mechanism to rapidly eliminate postovulatory follicles and being an essential process in the ovarian regression after spawning.     

Theca interna: the other side of bovine follicular atresia

Currently, histological classifications of ovarian follicular atresia are almost exclusively based on the morphology of the membrana granulosa without reference to the theca interna. Atresia in the bovine small antral ovarian follicle has been redefined into antral or basal atresia where cell death commences initially within antral or basal regions of the membrana granulosa, respectively. To examine cell death in the theca interna in the two types of atretic follicles, bovine ovaries were collected and processed for immunohistochemistry and light microscopy. Follicles were classified as healthy, antral atretic, or basal atretic. Follicle diameter was recorded and sections stained with lectin from Bandeiraea simplicifolia to identify endothelial cells or with an antibody to cytochrome P450 cholesterol side-chain cleavage to identify steroidogenic cells and combined with TUNEL labeling to identify dead cells. The numerical density of steroidogenic cells within the theca interna was significantly reduced (P < 0.001) in basal atretic follicles in comparison with other follicles. Cell death was greater in both endothelial cells (P < 0.05) and steroidogenic cells (P < 0.01) of the theca interna of basal atretic follicles compared with healthy and antral atretic follicles. Thus, we conclude that the theca interna is susceptible to cell death early in atresia, particularly in basal atretic follicles.     

Apoptosis and ovarian function: novel perspectives from the teleosts

Apoptosis is a fundamental mechanism in follicular atresia and postovulatory regression in mammals, but its role in teleost ovarian function is currently unknown. This study tested the hypotheses that apoptosis mediates follicular atresia in teleosts and is inducible in vitro by incubation in serum-free conditions. Vitellogenic follicles from rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) and goldfish (Carassius auratus) were incubated overnight in serum-free medium and examined for apoptosis by 3'-end-labeling and/or TUNEL analysis. Primary, postovulatory, and oocytectomized vitellogenic trout follicles and atretic goldfish follicles were evaluated in similar fashion. Overall, goldfish follicles had lower levels of DNA fragmentation than trout follicles. The DNA fragmentation in atretic goldfish follicles was similar to that measured in healthy vitellogenic and prematurational follicles; DNA fragmentation did not change after incubation. In the trout, postovulatory and oocytectomized vitellogenic follicles showed significantly greater in vitro susceptibility to apoptosis than intact vitellogenic follicles, whereas primary follicles were least susceptible. The TUNEL analyses revealed that in trout vitellogenic follicles, more thecal/epithelial cells than granulosa cells showed fragmented DNA in vivo, but incubation (24 h) did not result in increased apoptosis in cells of either type. These results indicate that apoptosis is involved in normal ovarian growth and postovulatory regression in teleosts, but that it does not appear to be an early event in teleost follicular atresia.     

Mechanism of granulosa cell death during follicular atresia depends on follicular size

Changes in granulosa cell lysosomal and mitochondrial functions in relation to follicular size and to the stage of atresia were studied by fluorescent emission spectra and intensity using flow cytometry. Antral follicles were grouped by size in two groups: small, 3-6 mm and large, >6mm in diameter, and classified into three stages of atresia: non-atretic, initially atretic and advanced atretic. Differences in Rhodamine 123 (Rh123) and Acridine Orange (AO) fluorescent intensity indicated that changes in mitochondrial function are the primary mechanism of granulosa cell death in atretic follicles 3-6 mm in diameter, while its role in granulosa cell death in >6 mm atretic follicles seemed to be less important. However, modifications in lysosomal function (shown by a decrease in fluorometric intensity of AO incubated granulosa cells) were mainly associated with cell death in large atretic follicles. Our results support the hypothesis that the pathway of granulosa cell death during follicular atresia depends on the state of energy metabolism or on the production of hypoxic conditions related to follicular size. Changes in mitochondrial membrane potential and production of permeability transition pores were the main changes found in small follicles, while lysosomal function destabilization seemed to be the major cause of granulosa cell death during atresia in large follicles.     

Changes in the expression of tumor necrosis factor (TNF) alpha,TNFalpha receptor (TNFR) 2, and TNFR-associated factor 2 in granulosa cells during atresia in pig ovaries

Tumor necrosis factor (TNF) alpha can induce both cell death and cell proliferation and exerts its effects by binding to either TNF receptor (TNFR) 1 or 2. When TNFalpha-bound TNFR2 interacts with TNFR-associated factor 2 (TRAF2), expression of survival/antiapoptotic genes is up-regulated. In the present study we determined the changes in localization of TNFalpha and TRAF2 and their mRNAs and the expression of TNFR2 in granulosa cells during follicular atresia in pig ovaries. In healthy follicles, intense signals for TNFalpha and TRAF2 and their mRNAs were demonstrated in the outer zone of the granulosa layer, where many proliferating cells and no apoptotic cells were observed. In atretic follicles, decreased or trace staining for TRAF2 and its mRNA and decreased expression of TNFR2 were observed in the granulosa layer, where many apoptotic cells were seen. These findings suggested that TNFalpha acts as a survival factor in granulosa cells during follicular atresia in pig ovaries.     

Morphological patterns of cell death in ovarian follicles of primary and secondary growth and postovulatory follicle complex of the annual killifish Millerichthys robustus (Cyprinodontiformes: Cynolebiidae)

The dynamics of cellular development and homeostasis of the ovary depend on the balance between proliferation and cell death throughout the reproductive cycle. Millerichthys robustus is an annual fish whose ovarian follicles develop asynchronously, allowing daily reproduction from sexual maturity until death. The objective of this research is to describe, histologically, the processes of follicular atresia and regression of postovulatory follicular complexes (POC) throughout a reproductive cycle of M. robustus. Patterns of cell death were documented by apoptosis in atretic follicles and POC, and necrosis in the POC after ovulation with an associated inflammatory response. Atretic follicles were seen from the onset of sexual maturity, during week three post-hatching (PH), both in primary growth (from the Cortical alveoli step, with folliculogenesis completed) and secondary growth Stages, with a higher prevalence in the latter. POCs were observed in different stages of regression from week four PH until the death of the fish. The apoptotic characteristics found were: (i) fragmentation of the nuclear membrane and zona pellucida, and liquefaction of the cortical alveoli and yolk; (ii) follicular cells becoming phagocytic, increasing their size, and migrating within the oocyte; and (iii) formation of an intrafollicular lumen, a product of phagocytosis of the oocyte constituents and dispersed pigments that remain after the digestion of yolk and cortical alveoli. The morphological changes of the follicular cells of the POC, from a squamous morphology after ovulation to columnar during its regression with PAS+ contents, was documented, suggesting a secretory activity.     

Changes in expression of anti-apoptotic protein, cFLIP, in granulosa cells during follicular atresia in porcine ovaries

Follicular selection is performed in mammalian ovaries, as most follicles undergo atresia during follicular development and growth. Follicular regression is indicated to begin with granulosa cell apoptosis. To reveal the molecular mechanisms of the selection, we examined the changes in the levels of cellular-Flice like inhibitory protein (cFLIP) expression in porcine granulosa cells. cFLIP is the homologue of intracellular apoptosis inducer (procaspase-8/Flice), and has two alternative splicing isoforms: cFLIP short form (cFLIP(S)) and long form (cFLIP(L)). By competing with caspase-8, cFLIP inhibits apoptosis initiated by death receptors. The changes in the levels of cFLIP(S) and cFLIP(L) mRNA and protein expression in granulosa cells were determined by RT-PCR and Western blotting, respectively. cFLIP(L) mRNA and protein were highly expressed in granulosa cells of healthy follicles and decreased during atresia. cFLIP(S) mRNA levels in granulosa cells were low and showed no change among the stages of follicular development, and its protein level was extremely low. We examined the changes in the localization of cFLIP mRNAs in pig ovaries by in situ hybridization and found that cFLIP(L) is abundant in granulosa cells of healthy follicles in comparison with those of atretic follicles. Immunohistochemical analyses demonstrated that the cFLIP protein is highly expressed in the granulosa cell of healthy follicles but weakly expressed in that of atretic follicles. We presumed that cFLIP, especially cFLIP(L), plays an anti-apoptotic role in the granulosa cells of healthy follicles of pig ovaries, and that cFLIP could be a major survival factor that determines whether growth or atresia occurs in porcine follicles.     

Expression of hyaluronan synthase 1 and distribution of hyaluronan during follicular atresia in pig ovaries

CD44 on macrophages is recognized as a phagocytic receptor involved in the phagocytosis of apoptotic cells. Recently, we detected CD44 on macrophages in atretic follicles during atresia. In this study, we evaluated the distribution of the principal CD44 ligand hyaluronan (HA) and the expressions of HA synthases (HAS: HAS1, HAS2, and HAS3) during atresia in pig ovaries. We determined the 2139-bp sequence of Sus scrofa HAS1 and raised an anti-HAS1 polyclonal antibody. The S. scrofa HAS1 sequence contained six putative HA-binding motifs and conserved amino acid residues crucial for GlcNac transferase activity. HAS1 mRNA expression was upregulated during atresia; however, HAS2 and HAS3 mRNA expression levels were low and very low to undetectable, respectively. Western blotting showed that HAS1 was markedly upregulated during atresia. Immunohistochemical analyses revealed HAS1 distribution in theca cells of healthy and early atretic (stages I and II) follicles and in progressing atretic (stage III) follicles. Hyaluronan was visualized with the HA-binding protein; it accumulated in the theca layer during all stages and in stage III follicles. Hyaluronan assay showed a significantly increased HA concentration in follicular fluid at stage III. Flow cytometry showed HAS1 expression in 55.7% of SIRPA-positive macrophages in stage III follicles. Our results suggest that the HA concentration in follicular fluids increased during atresia and that HAS1 may be the dominant HAS protein in theca cells to produce HA in pig ovaries.     

Sphingosine-1-phosphate and ceramide are associated with health and atresia of bovine ovarian antral follicles

The follicle destiny towards ovulation or atresia is multi-factorial in nature and involves outcries, paracrine and endocrine factors that promote cell proliferation and survival (development) or unchain apoptosis as part of the atresia process. In several types of cells, sphingosine-1-phospate (S1P) promotes cellular proliferation and survival, whereas ceramide (CER) triggers cell death, and the S1P/CER ratio may determine the fate of the cell. The aim of present study was to quantify S1P and CER concentrations and their ratio in bovine antral follicles of 8 to 17 mm classified as healthy and atretic antral follicles. Follicles were dissected from cow ovaries collected from a local abattoir. The theca cell layer, the granulosa cells and follicular fluid were separated, and 17β-estradiol (E2) and progesterone (P4) concentrations were measured in the follicular fluid by radioimmunoassay. Based on the E2/P4 ratio, the follicles were classified as healthy (2.2±0.3) or atretic (0.2±0.3). In both follicular compartments (granulosa and theca cell layer), sphingolipids were extracted and S1P and CER concentrations were quantified by HPLC (XTerra RP18; 5 µm, 3.0×150 mm column). Results showed that in both follicular compartments, S1P concentrations were higher in healthy antral follicles than in atretic antral follicles (P<0.05). The concentration of CER in the granulosa cells was higher in atretic antral follicles than in healthy antral follicles, but no differences were observed in the theca cell layer. The S1P/CER ratio in both follicular compartments was also higher in healthy antral follicles. Interestingly, in these follicles, there was a 45-fold greater concentration of S1P than CER in the granulosa cells (P<0.05), whereas in the theca cell layer, S1P had only a 14-fold greater concentration than CER when compared with atretic antral follicles. These results suggest that S1P plays a role in follicle health, increasing cellular proliferation and survival. In contrast, reduction of S1P and the S1P/CER in the antral follicle could trigger cellular death and atresia.     

Ovarian follicular atresia is mediated by heterophagy, autophagy, and apoptosis in Prochilodus argenteus and Leporinus taeniatus (Teleostei: Characiformes)

We investigated apoptosis, cell proliferation antigen (PCNA), and heat shock protein (HSP70) during ovarian follicular atresia in two freshwater teleost species from the São Francisco River basin, Brazil: curimatã-pacu, Prochilodus argenteus and piau-jejo, Leporinus taeniatus. Fishes were maintained in captivity after the reproductive period and ovarian regression was assessed by gonadosomatic index for three stages: early, advanced, and late regression. Follicular atresia was analysed by light and transmission electron microscopy, as well as by TUNEL and immunohistochemistry for HSP70 and PCNA. During early regression, atretic follicles exhibited zona pellucida breakdown, yolk degeneration, and hypertrophied follicular cells (e.g. granulosa in mammals). Intense heterophagy to engulf the yolk, and autophagy were detected in the follicular cells during advanced and late atresia. The TUNEL assay detected DNA fragmentation, mainly in late follicular atresia. The apoptosis rate of the follicular cells increased up to 10% during follicular atresia in both species and was negatively correlated with follicular area. Immunohistochemistry reaction for HSP70 stained the follicular cells strongly during advanced atresia, when they are intensively involved in yolk engulfment, whereas the reaction for PCNA labelled theca cells. We inferred that heterophagy, autophagy, and apoptosis contributed to follicular atresia in teleost ovaries, thereby achieving a more efficient removal of the degenerating oocyte and dying follicular cells. Additionally, HSP70 may protect the follicular cells before apoptosis when they are involved in yolk engulfment, and cell proliferation in the theca contributed to ovarian remodelling.     

Comparison of glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase activity in healthy and atretic follicles in rat ovary

Changes in the glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase activity have been determined in relation to atresia of Graafian follicles in the rat ovary. Induction of atresia in follicles either due to absence of hCG in the hormonally stimulated immature ovaries or by repeated injections of pentobarbitone sodium to proestrous rats caused significant rise in the enzyme activity. Measurement of enzyme activity in isolated follicular compartments of healthy and atretic follicles revealed that it is significantly higher in the thecal tissue than the granulosa. Increase in enzyme activity in the atretic follicles than the healthy ones occurs due to its rise both in theca and granulosa cells. The significance of these changes in the enzyme activity in healthy and atretic follicles are discussed in relation to the precocious luteinization of cells in the follicular envelope with the onset of atresia.     

Ovarian follicular atresia is mediated by heterophagy,autophagy, and apoptosis in Prochilodus argenteus and Leporinus taeniatus (Teleostei: Characiformes)

We investigated apoptosis, cell proliferation antigen (PCNA), and heat shock protein (HSP70) during ovarian follicular atresia in two freshwater teleost species from the São Francisco River basin, Brazil: curimatã-pacu, Prochilodus argenteus and piau-jejo, Leporinus taeniatus. Fishes were maintained in captivity after the reproductive period and ovarian regression was assessed by gonadosomatic index for three stages: early, advanced, and late regression. Follicular atresia was analysed by light and transmission electron microscopy, as well as by TUNEL and immunohistochemistry for HSP70 and PCNA. During early regression, atretic follicles exhibited zona pellucida breakdown, yolk degeneration, and hypertrophied follicular cells (e.g. granulosa in mammals). Intense heterophagy to engulf the yolk, and autophagy were detected in the follicular cells during advanced and late atresia. The TUNEL assay detected DNA fragmentation, mainly in late follicular atresia. The apoptosis rate of the follicular cells increased up to 10% during follicular atresia in both species and was negatively correlated with follicular area. Immunohistochemistry reaction for HSP70 stained the follicular cells strongly during advanced atresia, when they are intensively involved in yolk engulfment, whereas the reaction for PCNA labelled theca cells. We inferred that heterophagy, autophagy, and apoptosis contributed to follicular atresia in teleost ovaries, thereby achieving a more efficient removal of the degenerating oocyte and dying follicular cells. Additionally, HSP70 may protect the follicular cells before apoptosis when they are involved in yolk engulfment, and cell proliferation in the theca contributed to ovarian remodelling.     

miR-26b promotes granulosa cell apoptosis by targeting ATM during follicular atresia in porcine ovary

More than 99% of ovarian follicles undergo atresia in mammals, but the mechanism of follicular atresia remains to be elucidated. In this study, we explored microRNA (miRNA) regulation of follicular atresia in porcine ovary. A miRNA expression profile was constructed for healthy, early atretic, and progressively atretic follicles, and the differentially expressed miRNAs were selected and analyzed. We found that miR-26b, which was upregulated during follicular atresia, increased the number of DNA breaks and promoted granulosa cell apoptosis by targeting the ataxia telangiectasia mutated gene directly in vitro.     

Role of gelatinase on follicular atresia in the bovine ovary

Follicular atresia, like follicular growth and ovulation, is characterized by excessive tissue remodeling. It is hypothesized that probably one of the tissue-remodeling enzymes, such as the gelatinases, could be playing an important role in this process. The present study was undertaken to determine the role of gelatinase on follicular atresia in the cow. Follicles of 2-6 mm in diameter were dissected from ovaries, and follicular fluid was categorized according to the morphological appearance of the cumulus-oocyte complexes. Gelatinase activity within the follicular fluid was analyzed by gelatin zymography, and film in situ zymography was employed in order to localize gelatinase. TUNEL was performed on cryosectioned ovaries to understand follicular health. The concentrations of steroids in follicular fluid were also measured by solid phase fluoroimmunoassay. ProMMP-2 was detected in all normal and atretic categories of follicular fluid. The active form of MMP-2 and an additional band of proMMP-9 were detected only in atretic follicular fluid. Gelatinase activity was recorded in both granulosa cells (GCs) and theca cells (TCs) but were found in comparatively higher numbers in those follicles that exhibited a thinned and partially detached granulosa layer. TUNEL confirmed that apoptosis had commenced in the GCs of follicles of the latter category. The estradiol-17beta (E(2)):progesterone (P(4)) ratio was found to be significantly lower in atretic follicles than in normal follicles. These results suggest a plausible role for gelatinase in follicular health, especially the active form of MMP-2 and proMMP-9, and that bovine follicular fluid may be a key indicator of atresia.     

Involvement of cell proliferation in the process of follicular atresia in the guinea pig

Cell morphology and proliferation was investigated in the atretic follicles during estrous cycles in the guinea pig. Ovarian samples on days 1, 4, 8, 12 and 16 of the estrous cycle in the guinea pig were taken in the morning for histologic staining with hematoxylin and eosin (HE), and immunohistochemical staining of the protein proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA). The results indicated that the granulosa cells degenerated and eliminated first in atretic follicles, while the fibroblast-like cells appeared in the innermost layer of theca interna cells. When the fibroblast-like cells migrated to the antrum, they proliferated and formed a new tissue in peripheral to the zona pellucida of the oocyte. Our results also revealed that the orientation of the theca interna cell arrangement changed twice during the process of atresia, and the loose connective tissue in the antrum was critical for follicular atresia. Therefore, follicular atresia was not a simple process of cell death and elimination, but coexisted with cell proliferation. To our knowledge, we have for the first time confirmed cell proliferation and the presence of new tissue in atretic follicles in guinea pigs.