Conformational and dynamic considerations in the design of peptide hormone analogs

Efforts to understand the chemical-physical basis for peptide hormone and neurotransmitter action requires integration of conformational parameters and biological properties. Since most peptide hormones are conformationally flexible, the question arises as to which of the manifold of conformations is of biological significance. In molecular terms, it is necessary to carefully distinguish chemical-physical features important to binding (the binding message) from those involved in transduction (the biological activity message). One approach to this involves the design, synthesis, and conformational analysis of semirigid hormone analogs. The distinction between binding and transduction can best be examined by evaluation of full biological profiles of partial agonists, antagonists, and analogs with prolonged biological activity. Using this multidisciplinary approach, we have prepared several semirigid [Pen¹]-oxytocin antagonist analogs and evaluated their conformational properties and biological activities. Specific conformational features can be related to inhibitory activities in several cases. On the basis of structure–activity relationships and conformational considerations, we have designed a series of conformationally restricted cyclic and acyclic analogs of the linear peptide α-melanotropin. Some of these peptides have exceptionally prolonged in vivo activity (weeks), and others exhibit superagonist potency (10,000 times the native hormone). We have evidence that potency and prolonged activity have different structural and conformational requirements. It is suggested that potency is primarily a function of receptor recognition (the binding message), whereas prolonged activity is related to transduction (the biological activity message).     

Conformational restrictions of biologically active peptides via amino acid side chain groups

Determining the relationships between conformation and biological activity in peptide hormones and neurotransmitters is an important goal of contemporary biology. A major difficulty in these studies is the conformational flexibility of most peptides and the high dependence of the conformations on environment. The question arises whether conformations determined in solution are relevant to those important to the peptide at the membrane receptor(s). One recent approach to overcome these difficulties has been the use of conformational constraints by covalent bonding of side chain groups of residues in the peptide. In this manner linear peptides are rendered cyclic, and cyclic peptides are further conformationally constrained either by ring contractions or by other conformational constraints. Biologically active peptides specifically designed by this approach have been found to possess several useful properties including: 1) greater conformational integrity; 2) increased agonist or antagonist potency; 3) prolonged biological activity; 4) increased enzymatic stability; and 5) increased specificity for a particular receptor. Careful applications of this approach have provided important new designs features for peptide structure-function studies, and new insights into peptide conformation-activity relationships for oxytocin, somatostatin, enkephalin, bradykinin, vasopressin, and other biologically active peptides.     

Conformation-activity relationships of opioid peptides with selective activities at opioid receptors

The discovery of endogenous opioid peptides 25 years ago opened up a new chapter in efforts to understand the origins and control of pain, its relationships to other biological functions, including inflammatory and other immune responses, and the relationships of opioid peptides and their receptors to a variety of undesirable or toxic side effects often associated with the nonpeptide opiates such as morphine including addiction, constipation, a variety of neural toxicities, tolerance, and respiratory depression. For these investigations the need for potent and highly receptor selective agonists and antagonists has been crucial since they in principle allow one to distinguish unequivocally the roles of the different opioid receptors (mu, delta, and kappa) in the various biological and pathological roles of the opioid peptides and their receptors. Conformational and topographical constraint of the linear natural endogenous opioid peptides has played a major role in developing peptide ligands with high selectivity for mu, delta, and kappa receptors, and in understanding the conformational, topographical, and stereoelectronic structural requirements of the opioid peptides for their interactions with opioid receptors. In turn, this had led to insights into the three-dimensional pharmacophore for opioid receptors. In this article we review and discuss some of the developments that have led to potent, selective, and stable peptide and peptidomimetic ligands that are highly potent and selective, and that have delta agonist, mu antagonist, and kappa agonist biological activities (other authors in this issue will discuss the development of other types of activities and selectivities). These have led to ligands that provide unique insight into opioid pharmacophores and the critical roles opioid ligands and receptor scan play in pain, addiction, and other human maladies.     

Design and bioactivities of melanotropic peptide agonists and antagonists: Design based on a conformationally constrained somatostatin template

Summary α-Melanotropin and ACTH, POMC peptides, initiate biological activity by interaction with the classical pigment cell (α-MSH receptor, MC1R) and adrenal gland (ACTH receptor, MC2R) melanocortin receptors, respectively. The recently discovered MC3R, MC4R and MC5R receptors provide new targets and new biological functions for POMC peptides. We have developed conformationally constrained α-melanotropin peptides that interact with all of these receptors as agonists and antagonists and are examining new approaches to obtain highly selective ligands for each of these melanocortin receptors. Previously, we had converted somatostatin-derived peptides into potent and highly selective analogues that act as antagonists at the μ opioid receptors. Using the reverse turn template that came out of these studies, we have designed, de novo, agonist and antagonist peptide analogues that interact with melanocortin receptors.     

Conformation-activity relationship of peptide T and new pseudocyclic hexapeptide analogs.

Peptide T (ASTTTNYT), a segment corresponding to residues 185-192 of gp120, the coat protein of HIV, has several important biological properties in vitro that have stimulated the search for simpler and possibly more active analogs. We have previously shown that pseudocyclic hexapeptide analogs containing the central residues of peptide T retain considerable chemotactic activity. We have now extended the design of this type of analogs to peptides containing different aromatic residues and/or Ser in lieu of Thr. The complex conformation-activity relationship of these analogs called for a reexamination of the basic conformational tendencies of peptide T itself. Here, we present an exhaustive NMR conformational study of peptide T in different media. Peptide T assumes a gamma-turn in aqueous mixtures of ethylene glycol, a type-IV beta-turn conformation in aqueous mixtures of DMF, and a type-II beta-turn conformation in aqueous mixtures of DMSO. The preferred conformations for the analogs were derived from modeling, starting from the preferred conformations of peptide T. The best models derived from the gamma-turn conformation of peptide T are those of peptides XII (DSNYSR), XIII (ETNYTK) and XVI (ESNYSR). The best models derived from the type-IV beta-turn conformation of peptide T are those of peptides XIV (KTTNYE) and XV (DSSNYR). No low-energy models could be derived starting from the type-II beta-turn conformation of peptide T. The analogs with the most favored conformations are also the most active in the chemotactic test.     

Design of biologically active, conformationally constrained GnRH antagonists

The introduction of conformational constraints into a flexible peptide hormone can be exploited to develop models for the conformation required for receptor binding and activity. In this review, we illustrate this approach to analog design using our work on antagonists of gonadotropin-releasing hormone (GnRH). Design of a conformationally constrained, competitive antagonist of GnRH, cyclo[delta 3,4 Pro-D4ClPhe-DTrp-Ser-Tyr-DTrp-NMeLeu-Arg-Pro-bet a Ala] led to the prediction of its bioactive conformation. Template forcing experiments show that this conformation is accessible to other active GnRH analogs. Two-dimensional NMR studies verified the predicted conformation in solution. The predicted binding conformation has recently been used to design two new analogs incorporating side chain-side chain linkages suggested by the conformational model: Ac-delta 3,4Pro-D4FPhe-DTrp-Dap-Tyr-DTrp-Leu-Arg-Asp-Gly- NH2 and Ac-delta 3,4Pro-D4FPhe-DTrp-Dap-Tyr-D2Nal-Leu-Arg-Pro-Asp -NH2. These analogs were synthesized and the one predicted to be most similar to the parent conformation had equivalent potency while the second, designed to refine the conformational hypothesis, was found to exhibit enhanced potency, thus confirming the original binding conformation hypothesis. These compounds and their derivatives now provide a new class of GnRH antagonists possessing both high biological potency and limited conformational flexibility, thus making them ideal for both biophysical and structure-activity studies.     

Design and bioactivities of melanotropic peptide agonists and antagonists: Design based on a conformationally constrained somatostatin template

-Melanotropin and ACTH, POMC peptides, initiate biological activity by interaction with the classical pigment cell (-MSH receptor, MC1R) and adrenal gland (ACTH receptor, MC2R) melanocortin receptors, respectively. The recently discovered MC3R, MC4R and MC5R receptors provide new targets and new biological functions for POMC peptides. We have developed conformationally constrained -melanotropin peptides that interact with all of these receptors as agonists and antagonists and are examining new approaches to obtain highly selective ligands for each of these melanocortin receptors. Previously, we had converted somatostatin-derived peptides into potent and highly selective analogues that act as antagonists at the opioid receptors. Using the reverse turn template that came out of these studies, we have designed, de novo, agonist and antagonist peptide analogues that interact with melanocortin receptors.     

Presence of an amphipathic helical segment and its relationship to biological potency of calcitonin analogs

The conformational properties of a number of calcitonin analogs were studied by circular dichroism. The ability of dimyristoylphosphatidylglycerol, lysophosphatidylcholine or sodium dodecyl sulfate to induce the formation of more highly ordered structures in these peptides was also assessed by circular dichroism. In all cases sodium dodecyl sulfate induced the largest change in the circular dichroism spectra of the peptides. Salmon calcitonin and its analogs were slightly more helical in the presence of the anionic phospholipid than in the presence of the zwitterionic detergent lysophosphatidylcholine while the reverse is true for human calcitonin and its analogs. Some of the calcitonin analogs convert turbid suspensions of phosphatidylglycerol to a clear solution from which the phospholipid is no longer readily sedimentable by centrifugation. Several of the physical properties of these peptides could be correlated with their biological activity. Generally peptides which showed no hypocalcemic activity had the least negative mean residue ellipticities at 222 nm. Only biologically active analogs were able quantitatively to solubilize dimyristoyl-phosphatidylglycerol and in this solubilized form the peptides have a higher helical content. More active derivatives exhibit larger increases in helix content in the presence of this phospholipid. Inactive analogs had the least negative mean residue ellipticities at 222 nm in the presence of lysophosphatidylcholine or sodium dodecyl sulfate. Thus, the ability of a calcitonin analog to form structures of higher helical content in the presence of amphiphiles is a requirement for the analog to exhibit high potency in assays of biological activity.     

Models of thioredoxin hairpin structures: conformational properties of beta-turn containing sequences

Sequences 74–91 and 77–91 of E. coli thioredoxin, which according to x-ray structure contain an irregular β-turn, a hairpinlike structural element, have been synthesized and their conformational properties in solution have been investigated by means of CD spectroscopy. In addition, analogs of these sequences, containing the regular β-turn element Gly-Pro-(Gly)₂, have also been prepared and investigated. These are BOC-Ile-Gly-Pro-(Gly)₂-Val-OMe (III) and BOC-(Ile)₃Gly-Pro-(Gly)₂-(Val)₅-OMe (IV) that on the basis of probability, should form hairpin structures stabilized by intramolecular interactions. While the natural sequences were shown to be unable to adopt structures characterized by an intrinsic conformational stability, the two analogs showed evidence of intramolecular folding in methanol and trifluoroethanol–water solution. In particular, the CD spectra are indicative of β-structure. The most interesting case was observed for compound IV, as the highest degree of conformational order was present in solutions containing a large proportion of water. In addition, the formation of this structure took place in a highly cooperative manner. The results are utilized to discuss whether and to what extent conformationally stable folding peptide units of small size can be formed in aqueous solution.     

Design, synthesis and antithrombin activity for conformationally restricted analogs of peptide anticoagulants based on the C-terminal region of the leech peptide, hirudin

Synthetic peptides cyclized via disulfide linkages have been synthesized as conformationally restricted analogs of a novel class of antithrombotic peptides that inhibit fibrinogen cleavage by binding to a non-enzymatic site on thrombin. Several conformational models for these inhibitors have been considered and cyclic analogs were synthesized to test their validity. Compounds designed on an alpha-helical model yielded several cyclic analogs that retained antithrombin activity. [D-Cys58, Cys61]-hirudin54-65, 5, and [D-Cys60, Cys63]-hirudin54-65, 6, had IC50 values of 26 and 30 microM, respectively, in an in vitro clot assay compared with a value of 3.7 microM for the linear hirudin54-65.     

Design rationale, synthesis, and characterization of non-natural analogs of the cationic amino acids arginine and lysine.

A series of non-natural isosteric analogs of the cationic, ion-pairing, natural amino acids arginine and lysine have been synthesized, characterized with regard to relevant physical parameters, and protected for routine inclusion in Merrifield solid-phase synthesis. The design of these molecules is based on the concept of steric inhibition of solvation, in that judicious placement of alkyl groups can destabilize aqueous ion solvation and favor ion-pairing [see Beeson & Dix (1993) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 115, 10275]. When the residues are substituted for the natural amino acids in biologically active peptides, enhanced ion-pairing of the peptides to their receptors to increase the peptides' biological activities can result. The increased lipophilicity of the non-natural residues can also improve pharmacokinetic parameters and agonist/antagonist behaviors of peptides. While the synthesis of the L-series is described, the D-isomers were also prepared using identical chemistry.     

Secondary structure characteristics of proenkephalin peptides E,B, and F

The conformations of three adrenal medullary enkephalin containing polypeptides (ECPs) were investigated to gain an understanding of their potential structure-activity relationships. Secondary structure characteristics of peptides E, B, and F were examined by circular dichrosim (CD) under conditions designed to mimic both the soluble state and the anisotropic environment which exists at the biological effector site. Conformational differences between the three peptides were further examined by Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FTIR) and by empirical predictions for conformation and hydrophobic periodicity. Although all three peptides have a similar structure, existing in random confirgurations in aqueous solutions, they do exhibit unique individual potentials to assume secondary structure in less polar environments. These conformational differences may be important factors in determining their unique individual biological activities.Special issue dedicated to Dr. Sidney Udenfriend.     

Lactam constraints provide insights into the receptor-bound conformation of secretin and stabilize a receptor antagonist

The natural ligands for family B G protein-coupled receptors are moderate-length linear peptides having diffuse pharmacophores. The amino-terminal regions of these ligands are critical for biological activity, with their amino-terminal truncation leading to production of orthosteric antagonists. The carboxyl-terminal regions of these peptides are thought to occupy a ligand-binding cleft within the disulfide-bonded amino-terminal domains of these receptors, with the peptides in amphipathic helical conformations. In this work, we have characterized the binding and activity of a series of 11 truncated and lactam-constrained secretin(5-27) analogues at the prototypic member of this family, the secretin receptor. One peptide in this series with lactam connecting residues 16 and 20 [c[E(16),K(20)][Y(10)]sec(5-27)] improved the binding affinity of its unconstrained parental peptide 22-fold while retaining the absence of endogenous biological activity and competitive antagonist characteristics. Homology modeling with molecular mechanics and molecular dynamics simulations established that this constrained peptide occupies the ligand-binding cleft in an orientation similar to that of natural full-length secretin and provided insights into why this peptide was more effective than other truncated conformationally constrained peptides in the series. This lactam bridge is believed to stabilize an extended α-helical conformation of this peptide while in solution and not to interfere with critical residue-residue approximations while docked to the receptor.     

Plasmon-waveguide resonance spectroscopy: a new tool for investigating signal transduction by G-protein coupled receptors

Plasmon-waveguide resonance (PWR) spectroscopy provides a highly sensitive method for characterizing the kinetics, affinities and conformational changes involved in ligand binding to G-protein coupled receptors, without the need for radioactive or other labeling strategies. In the case of the cloned delta-opioid receptor from human brain incorporated into a lipid bilayer, we have shown that affinities determined in this way are consistent with those measured by standard binding procedures using membranes or whole cells containing the receptors, and that the spectral and kinetic properties of the binding processes allow facile distinction between agonist, inverse agonist, and antagonist ligands. We have also shown by direct measurements that G-protein binding affinities and the ability to undergo GTP/GDP exchange are dependent upon the type of ligand pre-bound to the receptor. PWR spectroscopy thus provides a powerful new approach to investigating signal transduction in biological membrane systems.     

Design and immunological properties of topographic immunogenic determinants of a protein antigen (LDH-C4) as vaccines.

Antibodies elicited by immunization with short peptides containing antigenic determinants have been shown, in general, to bind with greatly reduced affinity to the corresponding region in the native proteins. Thus, contiguous linear peptides have not proven to be effective immunogens in generating high affinity neutralizing or protective antibodies and consequently appear to be poor prospects for vaccines. The molecular basis for such reduced reactivity is clear from the crystal structure determination of antibody Fabs bound to protein antigens, which showed the complementarity between interfaces to be lock-and-key-like and extending over a large area (750 A2) involving discontinuous segments of the polypeptide chain. Thus, small perturbations in the secondary and tertiary structure of the antigen have profound effects on the fit of the antigen and its corresponding antibody. Because short peptides are unlikely to assume any particular conformation in solution, the fit is likely to be poor. New strategies are therefore required to produce conformationally stable peptides that mimic the critical structural features of the protein antigenic site. Here we show that a putative topographic determinant of the testis-specific isozyme of lactate dehydrogenase C4 (LDH-C4), designed and synthesized to adopt a well defined alpha-helical secondary and tertiary structure (four-helix bundle motif) in aqueous solutions, is highly immunogenic in both rabbits and mice, inducing IgG antibodies that bind to native LDH-C4. This engineered conformational 40-residue peptide is considerably more effective in inducing antibodies, as compared with the corresponding linear peptide. The antibody response is obtained without coupling the peptide to a carrier protein, suggesting that the peptide contains a T-cell antigenic determinant. The strategy described here to produce a conformationally stable peptide that mimics the native structure may have general applications in vaccine design.     

Conformational and topographical considerations in the design of biologically active peptides

An outline of the basic considerations that are under development for the rational design of biologically active peptides and peptidomimetics is given. The necessary interplay of biophysical, chemical, and biological considerations is emphasized. The importance of properly designed biological assays to provide chemical information analogous to that from biophysical studies is discussed. The development of asymmetric synthesis in conjunction with conformational considerations for the preparation of specialized amino acids and amino acid mimetics is a critical aspect of the approach. The overall approach is illustrated with three examples from our laboratory: (1) the redesign of somatostatin to a highly potent and selective μ-opioid receptor antagonist using conformational and topographical considerations in design and for obtaining insights into the pharmacophor; (2) the use of topographical considerations for obtaining oxytocin antagonists; and (3) the application of designer amino acids prepared by asymmetric synthesis to obtain insight into the topographical requirements at δ-opioid receptors. © 1993 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Mu-opiate binding and morphine antagonism by octapeptide analogs of somatostatin

A series of cyclic conformationally restrained octapeptide analogs of somatostatin were examined for their ability to inhibit the binding of tritiated mu, kappa, and delta opiate receptor ligands. Several of these substances were found to have high affinity for mu opiate receptors while having very low affinity for both kappa and delta receptors. Previous suggestions that somatostatin analogs exhibit opiate antagonist activity led to a study of the ability of the two most potent compounds to inhibit morphine analgesia in rats after intracerebroventricular injection. One of the compounds significantly antagonized morphine analgesia although the other displayed severe toxicity. These two compounds differed in that the very toxic compound had previously been found to possess significant somatostatin activity. It thus appears that the structural requirements for toxicity and somatostatin activity can be differentiated from those for opiate activity.     

Biologically active calcitonin analogs which have minimal interactions with phospholipids

A number of peptide hormones have been shown to contain amphipathic helical segments capable of binding to phospholipids. This conformational feature has been associated with increased biological activity of these hormones. We demonstrate, however, that two calcitonin analogs, [Gly8,Ala16]-des-Leu19 salmon calcitonin and des-1-amino-[Ala1,7,Gly8]-des-Leu19 salmon calcitonin have minimal interactions with phospholipids. Neither of these peptides acquire any increased helical content in the presence of dimyristoylphosphatidylglycerol and these peptides have only weak effects in altering the phase transition properties of this lipid. Therefore, although the presence of a phospholipid-induced amphipathic helical sequence may enhance the biological activity, it is not required for activity.     

Structure-function analysis of tritrpticin analogs: potential relationships between antimicrobial activities, model membrane interactions, and their micelle-bound NMR structures

Tritrpticin is a member of the cathelicidin family of antimicrobial peptides. Starting from its native sequence (VRRFPWWWPFLRR), eight synthetic peptide analogs were studied to investigate the roles of specific residues in its biological and structural properties. This included amidation of the C-terminus paired with substitutions of its cationic and Phe residues, as well as the Pro residues that are important for its two-turn micelle-bound structure. These analogs were determined to have a significant antimicrobial potency. In contrast, two other peptide analogs, those with the three Trp residues substituted with either Phe or Tyr residues are not highly membrane perturbing, as determined by leakage and flip-flop assays using fluorescence spectroscopy. Nevertheless the Phe analog has a high activity; this suggests an intracellular mechanism for antimicrobial activity that may be part of the overall mechanism of action of native tritrpticin as a complement to membrane perturbation. NMR experiments of these two Trp-substituted peptides showed the presence of multiple conformers. The structures of the six remaining Trp-containing analogs bound to dodecylphosphocholine micelles showed major, well-defined conformations. These peptides are membrane disruptive and show a wide range in hemolytic activity. Their micelle-bound structures either retain the typical turn-turn structure of native tritrpticin or have an extended alpha-helix. This work demonstrates that closely related antimicrobial peptides can often have remarkably altered properties with complex influences on their biological activities.