Proteolytic processing of MucA protein in SOS mutagenesis: Both processed and unprocessed MucA may be active in the mutagenesis

Summary The mucAB operon carried on plasmid pKM101, which is an analogue of the umuDC operon of Escherichia coli, is involved in UV mutagenesis and mutagenesis induced by many chemicals. Mutagenesis dependent on either the umuDC or mucAB operon requires the function of the recA gene and is called SOS mutagenesis. By treating the cell with agents that damage DNA, RecA protein is activated by conversion into a form (RecA^*) that mediates proteolytic cleavage of the LexA repressor and derepresses the SOS genes including mucAB. Since UmuD protein is proteolytically processed to an active form (UmuD^*) in a RecA^*-dependent fashion, and MucA shares extensive amino acid homology with UmuD, we examined whether MucA is similarly processed in the cell, using antiserum against a LacZ-MucA fusion protein. Like UmuD, MucA protein is indeed proteolytically processed in a RecA^*-dependent fashion. In recA430 strains, MucAB but not UmuDC can mediate UV mutagenesis. However, MucA was not processed in the recA430 cells treated with mitomycin C. We constructed, by site-directed mutagenesis, several mutant mucA genes that encode MucA proteins with alterations in the amino acids flanking the putative cleavage site (Ala25-Gly26). MucA(Cys25) was processed and was as mutagenically active as wild-type MucA; MucA(Asp26) and MucA(Cys25,Asp26) were not processed, and were mutagenically inactive; MucA-(Thr25) was not processed, but was mutagenically as active as wild-type MucA. The mutant mucA gene that encoded the putative cleavage product of MucA was as active as mucA ⁺ in UV mutagenesis. These results raise the possibility that both the nascent MucA and the processed product are active in mutagenesis.     

Induction of only one SOS operon, umuDC, is required for SOS mutagenesis in Escherichia coli

The actions of UmuDC and RecA proteins, respectively in SOS mutagenesis are studied here with the following experimental strategy. We used lexAl (Ind^–) bacteria to maintain all SOS proteins at their basal concentrations and then selectively increased the concentration of either UmuDC or RecA protein. For this purpose, we isolated operator-constitutive mutations o ^c in the umuDC and umuD'C operons and also used the o ₉₈ ^c -recA mutation. The o ₁ ^c -umuDC mutation prevents LexA repressor from binding to the operator and improves the Pribnow box consensus sequence. As a result, 5000 UmuD and 500 UmuC molecules per cell were produced in lexAl bacteria. This concentration is sufficient to restore SOS mutagenesis. The level of RecA protein present in the repressed state promoted full UmuD cleavage. Overproduction of RecA alone did not promote SOS mutagenesis. Increasing the level of RecA in the presence of high concentrations of UmuDC proteins has no further effect on SOS mutgenesis. We conclude that, after DNA damage, umuDC is the only SOS operon that must be induced in Escherichia coli to promote SOS mutagenesis.     

Induction of only one SOS operon,umuDC, is required for SOS mutagenesis in Escherichia coli

The actions of UmuDC and RecA proteins, respectively in SOS mutagenesis are studied here with the following experimental strategy. We used lexAl (Ind^?) bacteria to maintain all SOS proteins at their basal concentrations and then selectively increased the concentration of either UmuDC or RecA protein. For this purpose, we isolated operator-constitutive mutations o ^c in the umuDC and umuD'C operons and also used the o ₉₈ ^c -recA mutation. The o ₁ ^c -umuDC mutation prevents LexA repressor from binding to the operator and improves the Pribnow box consensus sequence. As a result, 5000 UmuD and 500 UmuC molecules per cell were produced in lexAl bacteria. This concentration is sufficient to restore SOS mutagenesis. The level of RecA protein present in the repressed state promoted full UmuD cleavage. Overproduction of RecA alone did not promote SOS mutagenesis. Increasing the level of RecA in the presence of high concentrations of UmuDC proteins has no further effect on SOS mutgenesis. We conclude that, after DNA damage, umuDC is the only SOS operon that must be induced in Escherichia coli to promote SOS mutagenesis.     

Different efficiency of UmuDC and MucAB proteins in UV light induced mutagenesis in Escherichia coli

Summary Two multicopy plasmids carrying either the umuDC or the mucAB operon were used to compare the efficiency of UmuDC and MucAB proteins in UV mutagenesis of Escherichia coli K12. It was found that in recA ⁺ uvr ⁺bacteria, plasmid pIC80, mucAB ⁺mediated UV mutagenesis more efficiently than did plasmid pSE117, umuDC ⁺. A similar result was obtained in lexA51(Def) cells, excluding the possibility that this was due to a differential regulation by LexA of the umuDC and mucAB operons. We conclude that some structural characteristic of the UmuDC and MucAB proteins determines their different efficiency in UV mutagenesis. This characteristic could be also responsible for the observation that in the recA430 mutant, pIC80 but no pSE117 can mediate UV mutagenesis. In the recA142 mutant, pIC80 also promoted UV mutagenesis more efficiently than pSE117. In this mutant, the recombination proficiency, the protease activity toward LexA and the mutation frequency were increased by the presence of adenine in the medium. In recA ⁺ uvrB5 bacteria, plasmid pSE117,umuDC caused both an increase in UV sensitivity as well as a reduction in the mutation frequency. These nagative effects resulting from the overproduction of UmuDC proteins were higher in recA142 uvrB5 than in recA ⁺ uvrB5 cells. In contrast, overproduction of MucAB proteins in excision-deficient bacteria containing pIC80 led to a large increase in the mutation frequency. We suggest that the functional differences between UmuDC and MucAB proteins might be due to their different dependence on the direct role of RecA protease in UV mutagenesis.     

Increased expression of the Escherichia coli umuDC operon restores SOS mutagenesis in lexA41 cells

Summary The lexA41 allele of Escherichia coli encodes a semidefective mutant repressor that is also resistant to RecA facilitated cleavage. Cells harboring the lexA41 allele were found previously to repress only a subset of operons in the SOS regulon. lexA41 cells cannot promote SOS mutagenesis, presumably because one or more operons required for mutagenesis are repressed by this mutant repressor. Using the lac regulatory system to increase the expression of the umuDC operon, we were able to restore mutagenesis in the lexA41 mutant. We conclude that the products of the umuDC operon appear to be uniquely limiting in this mutant.     

A new mutation inEscherichia coli K12,isfA, which is responsible for inhibition of SOS functions

A new mutation inEscherichia coli K12,isfA, is described, which causes inhibition of SOS functions. The mutation, discovered in a ΔpolA ⁺ mutant, is responsible for inhibition of several phenomena related to the SOS response inpolA ⁺ strains: UV- and methyl methanesulfonate-induced mutagenesis, resumption of DNA replication in UV-irradiated cells, cell filamentation, prophage induction and increase in UV sensitivity. TheisfA mutation also significantly reduces UV-induced expression of β-galactosidase fromrecA::lacZ andumuC′::lacZ fusions. The results suggest that theisfA gene product may affect RecA^* coprotease activity and may be involved in the regulation of the termination of the SOS response after completion of DNA repair. TheisfA mutation was localized at 85 min on theE. coli chromosome, and preliminary experiments suggest that it may be dominant to the wild-type allele.     

A umuDC-independent SOS pathway for frameshift mutagenesis.

Summary The chemical carcinogen N-acetoxy-N-2-acetylaminofluorene induces mainly frameshift mutations, which occur within two types of sequences (mutation hot spots): –1 frameshift mutations within contiguous guanine sequences and –2 frameshift mutations within alternating GC sequences such as the NarI and BssHII restriction site sequences. We have investigated the genetic control of mutagenesis at these sequences by means of a reversion assay using plasmids pW17 and pX2, which contain specific targets for contiguous guanine and alternating GC sequences, respectively. Our results suggest that mutations at these hot spot sequences are generated by two different genetic pathways, both involving induction of SOS functions. The two pathways differ both in their LexA-controlled gene and RecA protein requirements. In the mutation pathway that acts at contiguous guanine sequences, the RecA protein participates together with the umuDC gene products. In contrast, RecA is not essential for mutagenesis at alternating GC sequences, except to cleave the LexA repressor. The LexA-regulated gene product(s), which participate in this latter mutational pathway, do not involve umuDC but another as yet uncharacterized inducible function. We also show that wild-type RecA and RecA430 proteins exert an antagonistic effect on mutagenesis at alternating GC sequences, which is not observed either in the presence of activated RecA (RecA^*), RecA730 or RecA495 proteins, or in the complete absence of RecA as in recA99. It is concluded that the –1 mutation pathway presents the same genetic requirements as the pathway for UV light mutagenesis, while the –2 mutation pathway defines a distinct SOS pathway for frameshift mutagenesis.     

Mutational specificity of a proof-reading defective Escherichia coli dnaQ49 mutator

Summary The dnaQ (mutD) gene product which encodes the -subunit of the DNA polymerase III holoenzyme has a central role in controlling the fidelity of DNA replication because both mutD5 and dnaQ49 mutations severely decrease the 3–5 exonucleolytic editing capacity.It is shown in this paper that more than 95% of all anaQ49-induced base pair substitutions are transversions of the types G:C-T:A and A:T-T:A. Not only is this unusual mutational specificity precisely that observed recently for a number of potent carcinogens such as benzo(a) pyrene diolepoxide (BPDE) and aflatoxin B1 (AFB1), which are dependent on the SOS system to mutagenize bacteria, but it is also seen for the constitutively expressed SOS mutator activity in E. coli tif-1 strains as well as for the SOS mutator activity mediated gap filling of apurinic sites. Because the G:C-T:A and A:T-T:A transversions can either result from the insertion of an adenine across from apurinic sites or arise due to the incorporation of syn-adenine opposite a purine base, we postulate that the DNA polymerase III holoenzyme also has a reduced discrimination ability in a dnaQ49 background.The introduction of a lexA (Ind^-) allele, which prevents the expression of SOS functions, led to a significant reduction in the dnaQ49-caused mutator effect.Both, the mutational specificity observed and the partial lexA ⁺ dependence of the mutator effect provoke a reanalysis of the hypothesis that the DNA polymerase III holoenzyme can be converted into the postulated but until now unidentified SOS polymerase.     

Different UmuC requirements for generation of different kinds of UV-induced mutations in Escherichia coli

An Escherichia coli strain bearing the dnaQ49 mutation, which results in a defective s subunit of DNA polymerase III, and carrying the lexA71 mutation, which causes derepression of the SOS regulon, is totally unable to maintain high-copy-number plasmids containing the umuDC operon. The strain is also unable to maintain the pAN4 plasmid containing a partial deletion of the umuD gene but retaining the wild-type umuC gene. These results suggest that a high cellular level of UmuC is exceptionally harmful to the defective DNA polymerase III of the dnaQ49 mutant. We have used this finding as a basis for selection of new plasmid umuC mutants. The properties of two such mutants, bearing the umuC61 or umuC95 mutation, are described in detail. In the umuC122:: Tn 5 strain harbouring the mutant plasmids, UV-induced mutagenesis is severely decreased compared to that observed with the parental umuDC ⁺ plasmid. Interestingly, while the frequency of UV-induced GC AT transitions is greatly reduced, the frequency of AT TA transversions is not affected. Both mutant plasmids bear frameshift mutations within the same run of seven A residues present in umuC ⁺; in umuC61 the run is shortened to six A whereas in umuC95 is lengthened to eight A. We have found in both umuC61 and umuC95 that translation is partially restored to the proper reading frame. We propose that under conditions of limiting amounts of UmuC, the protein preferentially facilitates processing of only some kinds of UV-induced lesions.     

A new model for SOS-induced mutagenesis: how RecA protein activates DNA polymerase V

In Escherichia coli, cell survival and genomic stability after UV radiation depends on repair mechanisms induced as part of the SOS response to DNA damage. The early phase of the SOS response is mostly dominated by accurate DNA repair, while the later phase is characterized with elevated mutation levels caused by error-prone DNA replication. SOS mutagenesis is largely the result of the action of DNA polymerase V (pol V), which has the ability to insert nucleotides opposite various DNA lesions in a process termed translesion DNA synthesis (TLS). Pol V is a low-fidelity polymerase that is composed of UmuD′₂C and is encoded by the umuDC operon. Pol V is strictly regulated in the cell so as to avoid genomic mutation overload. RecA nucleoprotein filaments (RecA*), formed by RecA binding to single-stranded DNA with ATP, are essential for pol V-catalyzed TLS both in vivo and in vitro. This review focuses on recent studies addressing the protein composition of active DNA polymerase V, and the role of RecA protein in activating this enzyme. Based on unforeseen properties of RecA*, we describe a new model for pol V-catalyzed SOS-induced mutagenesis.     

Biochemical basis of hyper-recombinogenic activity of Pseudomonas aeruginosa RecA protein in Escherichia coli cells

The replacement of Escherichia coli recA gene (recA_Ec) with the Pseudomonas aeruginosa recA_Pa gene in Escherichia coli cells results in constitutive hyper-recombination (high frequency of recombination exchanges per unit length of DNA) in the absence of constitutive SOS response. To understand the biochemical basis of this unusual in vivo phenotype, we compared in vitro the recombination properties of RecA_Pa protein with those of RecA_Ec protein. Consistent with hyper-recombination activity, RecA_Pa protein appeared to be more proficient both in joint molecule formation, producing extensive DNA networks in strand exchange reaction, and in competition with single-stranded DNA binding (SSB) protein for single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) binding sites. The RecA_Pa protein showed in vitro a normal ability for cleavage of the E. coli LexA repressor (a basic step in SOS regulon derepression) both in the absence and in the presence (i.e. even under suboptimal conditions for RecA_Ec protein) of SSB protein. However, unlike other hyper-recombinogenic proteins, such as RecA441 and RecA730, RecA_Pa protein displaced insufficient SSB protein from ssDNA at low magnesium concentration to induce the SOS response constitutively. In searching for particular characteristics of RecA_Pa in comparison with RecA_Ec, RecA441 and RecA803 proteins, RecA_Pa showed unusually high abilities: to be resistant to the displacement by SSB protein from poly(dT); to stabilize a ternary complex RecA::ATP::ssDNA to high salt concentrations; and to be much more rapid in both the nucleation of double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) and the steady-state rate of dsDNA-dependent ATP hydrolysis at pH 7.5. We hypothesized that the high affinity of RecA_Pa protein for ssDNA, and especially dsDNA, is the factor that directs the ternary complex to bind secondary DNA to initiate additional acts of recombination instead of to bind LexA repressor to induce constitutive SOS response.     

Molecular cloning, sequence and regulation of expression of the recA gene of the phototrophic bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides

The recA gene of Rhodobacter sphaeroides 2.4.1 has been isolated by complementation of a UV-sensitive RecA^– mutant of Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Its complete nucleotide sequence consists of 1032 bp, encoding a polypeptide of 343 amino acids. The deduced amino acid sequence displayed highest identity to the RecA proteins from Rhizobium mehloti, Rhizobium phaseoli, and Agrobacterium tumefaciens. An Escherichia coli-like SOS consensus region, which functions as a binding site for the LexA repressor molecule was not present in the 215 by upstream region of the R. sphaeroides recA gene. Nevertheless, by using a recA-lacZ fusion, we have shown that expression of the recA gene of R. sphaeroides is inducible by DNA damage. A recA-defective strain of R. sphaeroides was obtained by replacement of the active recA gene by a gene copy inactived in vitro. The resulting recA mutant exhibited increased sensitivity to UV irradiation, and was impaired in its ability to perform homologous recombination as well as to trigger DNA damage-mediated expression. This is the first recA gene from a Gram-negative bacterium that lacks an E. coli-like SOS box but whose expression has been shown to be DNA damage-inducible and auto-regulated.     

MucAB but not UmuDC proteins enhance ?2 frameshift mutagenesis induced by N-2-acetylaminofluorene at alternating GC sequences

N-2-acetylaminofluorene has been shown efficiently to induce both –1 and –2 frameshift mutations in Escherichia coli as well as in mammalian cells. In E. coli, the genetic characteristics of –1 and –2 frameshift mutations were found to be distinct. The –1 frameshift mutation pathway occurs at monotonous runs of G residues (i.e. GGGGG). This pathway exhibits the same genetic requirements as UV light-induced base substitution mutagenesis. Indeed, optimal mutagenesis requires the expression of both UmuDC and the activated form of RecA. The –2 frameshift mutation pathway operates at short alternating GpC sequences, such as the NarI sequence (i.e. GGCGCCGGCC). In contrast to the –1 frameshift mutation pathway, optimal induction does not require the UmuDC and RecA proteins. This pathway involves a LexA-repressed function tentatively called Npf (for NarI processing factor). In this paper, we show that MucAB efficiently stimulates the –2 frameshift mutation pathway. However, unlike the Npf pathway, MucAB-mediated stimulation requires expression of the RecA protein.     

A new mutation inEscherichia coli K12,isfA,which is responsible for inhibition of SOS functions

A new mutation inEscherichia coli K12,isfA, is described, which causes inhibition of SOS functions. The mutation, discovered in a ΔpolA ⁺ mutant, is responsible for inhibition of several phenomena related to the SOS response inpolA ⁺ strains: UV- and methyl methanesulfonate-induced mutagenesis, resumption of DNA replication in UV-irradiated cells, cell filamentation, prophage induction and increase in UV sensitivity. TheisfA mutation also significantly reduces UV-induced expression of β-galactosidase fromrecA::lacZ andumuC′::lacZ fusions. The results suggest that theisfA gene product may affect RecA^* coprotease activity and may be involved in the regulation of the termination of the SOS response after completion of DNA repair. TheisfA mutation was localized at 85 min on theE. coli chromosome, and preliminary experiments suggest that it may be dominant to the wild-type allele.     

Nature of the SOS mutator activity: genetic characterization of untargeted mutagenesis in Escherichia coli

Summary In Escherichia coli, induction of the SOS functions by UV irradiation or by mutation in the recA gene promotes an SOS mutator activity which generates mutations in undamaged DNA. Activation of RecA protein by the recA730 mutation increases the level of spontaneous mutation in the bacterial DNA. The number of recA730-induced mutations is greatly increased in mismatch repair deficient strains in which replication errors are not corrected. This suggests that the majority of recA730-induced mutations (90%) arise through correctable, i.e. non-targeted, replication errors. This recA730 mutator effect is suppressed by a mutation in the umuC gene. We also found that dam recA730 double mutants are unstable, segregating clones that have lost the dam or the recA mutations or that have acquired a new mutation, probably in one of the genes involved in mismatch repair. We suggest that the genetic instability of the dam recA730 mutants is provoked by the high level of replication errors induced by the recA730 mutation, generating killing by coincident mismatch repair on the two unmethylated DNA strands. The recA730 mutation increases spontaneous mutagenesis of phage poorly. UV irradiation of recA730 host bacteria increases phage untargeted mutagenesis to the level observed in UV-irradiated recA ⁺ strains. This UV-induced mutator effect in recA730 mutants is not suppressed by a umuC mutation. Therefore UV and the recA730 mutation seem to induce different SOS mutator activities, both generating untargeted mutations.     

Identification of mucAB-like homologs on two IncT plasmids, R394 and Rts-1

Recent phylogenetic analysis of the superfamily of lesion-replicating DNA polymerases suggest that they can be broadly divided into four sub-groups comprised of UmuC-like, DinB-like, Rev1-like and Rad30-like proteins. The UmuC-like sub-family is best characterized at the genetic level and sequence analysis of eleven umu orthologs, residing on bacterial chromosomes or on self-transmissible R-plasmids allows further subdivision into five sub-groups (UmuDC, MucAB, ImpAB, RumAB and RulAB) based on amino acid sequence conservation. Some of these orthologs are apparently inactive in situ, but may promote increased mutagenesis and survival when subcloned and expressed from high-copy number plasmids. We were, therefore, interested in devising an assay that would identify umuC-like genes in situ in the absence of a functional assay. To this end, degenerate primers directed towards conserved amino acid regions within the UmuC-like sub-family of DNA polymerases were designed and used to identify mucAB-like operons on the IncT plasmids, R394 and Rts-1.Interestingly, DNA sequence analysis of an 7 kb region of R394 identified two LexA-regulated genes immediately downstream of mucAB_(R394) that are similar to the chromosomally-encoded Escherichia coli tus gene and the IncI plasmid-encoded impC gene, respectively. Analysis of the R394 and Rts-1 mucB genes revealed that both contain insertions which result in the expression of a truncated inactive MucB protein. While R394 was unable to restore mutagenesis functions to a ΔumuDC E. coli strain, Rts-1 surprisingly promoted significant levels of MMS-induced SOS mutagenesis, raising the possibility that Rts-1 encodes another, yet unidentified, umu-like homolog.     

Mutator activity and specificity of Escherichia coli dnaQ49 allele--effect of umuDC products

The high fidelity of DNA replication in Escherichia coli is ensured by the alpha (DnaE) and epsilon (DnaQ) subunits of DNA polymerase providing insertion fidelity, 3'-->5' exonuclease proofreading activity, and by the dam-directed mismatch repair system. dnaQ49 is a recessive allele that confers a temperature-sensitive proofreading phenotype resulting in a high rate of spontaneous mutations and chronic induction of the SOS response. The aim of this study was to analyse the mutational specificity of dnaQ49 in umuDC and DeltaumuDC backgrounds at 28 and 37 degrees C in a system developed by J.H. Miller. We confirmed that the mutator activity of dnaQ49 was negligible at 28 degrees C and fully expressed at 37 degrees C. Of the six possible base pair substitutions, only GC-->AT transitions and GC-->TA and AT-->TA transversions were appreciably increased. However, the most numerous mutations were frameshifts, -1G deletions and +1A insertions. All mutations which increased in response to dnaQ49 damage were to a various extent umuDC-dependent, especially -1G deletions. This type of mutations decreased in CC108dnaQ49DeltaumuDC to 10% of the value found in CC108dnaQ49umuDC+ and increased in the presence of plasmids producing UmuD'C or UmuDC proteins. In the recovery of dnaQ49 mutator activity the plasmid harbouring umuD'C genes was more effective than the one harbouring umuDC. Analysis of mutational specificity of pol III with defective epsilon subunit indicates that continuation of DNA replication is allowed past G:T, C:T, T:T (or C:A, G:A, A:A) mismatches but does not allow for acceptance of T:C, C:C, A:C (or A:G, G:G, T:G) (the underlined base is in the template strand).     

The appearance of the UmuD'C protein complex in Escherichia coli switches repair from homologous recombination to SOS mutagenesis

The process of SOS mutagenesis in Escherichia coli requires (i) the replisome enzymes, (ii) RecA protein, and (iii) the formation of the UmuD'C protein complex which appears to help the replisome to resume DNA synthesis across a lesion. We found that the UmuD'C complex is an antagonist of RecA-mediated recombination. Homologous recombination in an Hfr x F^- cross decreased as a function of the UmuD'C cell concentration; this effect was challenged by increasing RecA concentration. Recombination of a u.v.-damaged F-lac with the lac gene of an F^- recipient was reduced by increasing the UmuD'C concentration while lac mutagenesis increased, showing an inverse relationship between recombination and SOS mutagenesis. We explain our data with the following model. The kinetics of appearance of the UmuD'C complex after DNA damage is slow, reaching a maximum after an hour. Within that period, excision and recombinational repair have had time to occur. When the UmuD'C concentration relative to the number of residual RecA filaments, not resolved by recombinational repair, becomes high enough, UmuD'C proteins provide a processive factor for the replisome to help replication bypass and repel the standing RecA filament. Thus, at a high enough concentration, the UmuD'C complex will switch repair from recombination to SOS mutagenesis.     

Alleviation of EcoK DNA restriction in Escherichia coli and involvement of umuDC activity.

Summary The activity of the EcoK DNA restriction system of Escherichia coli reduces both the plating efficiency of unmodified phage and the transforming ability of unmodified pBR322 plasmid DNA. However, restriction can be alleviated in wild-type cells, by UV irradiation and expression of the SOS response, so that 10³-to 10⁴-fold increases in phage growth and fourfold increases in plasmid transformation occurred with unmodified DNA. Restriction alleviation was found to be a transient effect because induced cells, which initially failed to restrict unmodified plasmid DNA, later restricted unmodified phage . Although the SOS response was needed for restriction alleviation, constitutive SOS induction, elicited genetically with a recA730 mutation, did not alleviate restriction and UV irradiation was still needed. A hitherto unsuspected involvement of the umuDC operon in this alleviation of restriction is characterized and, by differential complementation, was separated from the better known role of umuDC in mutagenic DNA repair. The need for cleavage of UmuD for restriction alleviation was shown with plasmids encoding cleavable, cleaved, and non-cleavable forms of UmuD. However, UV irradiation was still needed even when cleaved UmuD was provided. The possibility that restriction alleviation occurs by a general inhibition of the EcoK restriction/modification complex was tested and discounted because modification of was not reduced by UV irradiation. An alternative idea, that restriction activity was competitively reduced by an increase in EcoK modification, was also discounted by the lack of any increase in the modification of Ral^–, a naturally undermodified phage. Other possible mechanisms for restriction alleviation are discussed.