The effects of unnatural base pairs and mispairs on DNA duplex stability and solvation

In an effort to develop unnatural DNA base pairs we examined six pyridine-based nucleotides, d3MPy, d4MPy, d5MPy, d34DMPy, d35DMPy and d45DMPy. Each bears a pyridyl nucleobase scaffold but they are differentiated by methyl substitution, and were designed to vary both inter- and intra-strand packing within duplex DNA. The effects of the unnatural base pairs on duplex stability demonstrate that the pyridine scaffold may be optimized for stable and selective pairing, and identify one self pair, the pair formed between two d34DMPy nucleotides, which is virtually as stable as a dA:dT base pair in the same sequence context. In addition, we found that the incorporation of either the d34DMPy self pair or a single d34DMPy paired opposite a natural dA significantly increases oligonucleotide hybridization fidelity at other positions within the duplex. Hypersensitization of the duplex to mispairing appears to result from global and interdependent solvation effects mediated by the unnatural nucleotide(s) and the mispair. The results have important implications for our efforts to develop unnatural base pairs and suggest that the unnatural nucleotides might be developed as novel biotechnological tools, diagnostics, or therapeutics for applications where hybridization stringency is important.     

Beyond A, C, G and T: augmenting nature's alphabet

Efforts to expand the genetic alphabet are predicated upon a stable and replicable third base pair. Recent progress has resulted in the development of several candidates that are both stable in duplex DNA and replicated by DNA polymerases with various degrees of efficiency and fidelity. The candidate base pairs draw upon unnatural hydrogen-bonding topologies as well as upon shape complementarity and hydrophobic forces. This review provides a critical comparison of the third base pair candidates and discusses the further work required to expand the genetic alphabet.     

Nucleobase pairing in expanded Watson-Crick-like genetic information systems

To guide the design of alternative genetic systems, we measured melting temperatures of DNA duplexes containing matched and mismatched nucleobase pairs from natural and unnatural structures. The pairs were analyzed in terms of structural features, including nucleobase size, number of hydrogen bonds formed, the presence of uncompensated hydrogen bonding functional groups, the nature of the bond joining the nucleobase to the sugar, and nucleobase charge. The results suggest that stability of nucleobase pairs correlates with the number of H-bonds, size complementarity, the presence of uncompensated functional groups, and the presence of charge on a nucleobase. Each of these properties appear to be more significant than the nature of the glycosidic bond and sequence context. The results provide guidelines for constructing stable Watson-Crick like nucleobase pairs with unnatural nucleobases. The experiments also demonstrate that expanded genetic systems can be constructed using size complementary nucleobase pairs that contain three hydrogen bonds.     

KlenTaq polymerase replicates unnatural base pairs by inducing a Watson-Crick geometry

Many candidate unnatural DNA base pairs have been developed, but some of the best-replicated pairs adopt intercalated structures in free DNA that are difficult to reconcile with known mechanisms of polymerase recognition. Here we present crystal structures of KlenTaq DNA polymerase at different stages of replication for one such pair, dNaM-d5SICS, and show that efficient replication results from the polymerase itself, inducing the required natural-like structure.     

An unnatural hydrophobic base, 4-propynylpyrrole-2-carbaldehyde, as an efficient pairing partner of 9-methylimidazo[(4,5)-b]pyridine

To develop unnatural base pairs that function in replication, we designed 4-propynylpyrrole-2-carbaldehyde (designated as Pa′) and synthesized the nucleoside derivatives of Pa′. The base pairing of Pa′ with the partner, 9-methylimidazo[(4,5)-b]pyridine (Q), was compared to that of pyrrole-2-carbaldehyde (Pa), which was previously developed as a specific pairing partner of Q. The thermal stability of a DNA duplex containing the Q–Pa′ pair and the incorporation efficiency of the Pa′ substrate (dPa′TP) into DNA opposite Q by the Klenow fragment of Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I were improved, in comparison with those of the Q–Pa pair. These improvements result from the increased hydrophobicity and stacking stability of Pa′ by the introduction of the propynyl group to Pa, providing valuable information for the further development of unnatural base pairs toward the expansion of the genetic alphabet.     

A second-generation copper(II)-mediated metallo-DNA-base pair

Metal-dependent pairing of nucleobases represents an alternative DNA base pairing scheme. Our first-generation copper(II)-mediated pyridine-2,6-dicarboxylate (Dipic) and pyridine (Py) metallo-base pair has a stability comparable to the natural base pairs dA:dT and dC:dG but does not have the selectivity of the Watson Crick base pairs. In order to increase the selectivity of base pair formation, a second-generation metallo-base pair was generated consisting of a pyridine-2,6-dicarboxamide (Dipam) and a pyridine (Py) nucleobase. This new metallo-base pair is more stable than the natural base pairs dA:dT and dC:dG and highly selective against mispairing. In addition, incorporation of multiple metallo-base pairs into DNA results in the formation of stable duplexes demonstrating that hydrogen bonding base pairs can efficiently be replaced by metal-dependent base pairs at multiple sites in DNA.     

Silver(I)-mediated Hoogsteen-type base pairs

Metal-mediated Hoogsteen-type base pairs are useful for the construction of DNA duplexes containing contiguous stretches of metal ions along the helical axis. To fine-tune the stability of such base pairs and the selectivity toward different metal ions, the availability of a selection of artificial nucleobases is highly desirable. In this study, we follow a theoretical approach utilizing dispersion-corrected density functional methods to evaluate a variety of artificial nucleobases as candidates for metal-mediated Hoogsteen-type base pairs. We focus on silver(I)-mediated Hoogsteen- and reverse Hoogsteen-type base pairs formed between 1-deaza- and 1,3-dideazapurine-derived nucleobases, respectively, and cytosine. Apart from two coordinative bonds, these base pairs are stabilized by a hydrogen bond. We elucidate the impact of different substituents at the C6 position and the presence or absence of an endocyclic N3 nitrogen atom on the overall stability of a base pair and concomitantly on the strength of the hydrogen and coordinative bonds. All artificial base pairs investigated in this study are less stable than the experimentally established benchmark base pair C–Ag⁺–G. The base pair formed from 1,3-dideaza-6-methoxypurine is isoenergetic to the experimentally observed C–Ag⁺–C base pair. This makes 1,3-dideaza-6-methoxypurine a promising candidate for the use as an artificial nucleobase in DNA.     

Theoretical studies on protein-nucleic acid interactions. III. Stacking of aromatic amino acids with bases and base pairs of nucleic acids

Stacking of aromatic amino acids tryptophan (Trp), tyrosine (Tyr), phenylalanine (Phe), and histidine (His) with bases and base pairs of nucleic acids has been studied. Stacking energies of the amino acid–base (or base pair) complexes have been calculated by second-order perturbation theory. Our results show that, in general, the predominant contribution to the total stacking energy comes from the dispersion terms. In these cases, repulsion energy is greater than the sum of electrostatic and polarization energies. In contrast to this, interaction of histidine with the bases and base pairs is largely Coulombic in nature. The complexes of guanine with aromatic amino acids are more stable than the corresponding complexes of adenine. Among pyrimidines, cytosine forms the most stable complexes with the aromatic amino acids. The G · C base pair has the highest affinity with aromatic amino acids among various sets of base pairs. Optimized geometries of the stacked complexes show that the aromatic moieties overlap only partially. The heteroatom of one residue generally overlaps with the other aromatic moiety. There is a considerable degree of configurational freedom in the stacked geometries. The role of stacking in specific recognition of base sequences by proteins is discussed.     

Effect of base-pair stability of nearest-neighbor nucleotides on the fidelity of deoxyribonucleic acid synthesis

The influence of the stability of base pairs formed by nearest-neighbor nucleotides on misincorporation frequency has been studied with the large fragment of DNA polymerase I, the alternating DNA copolymers, poly(dI-dC) and poly-(dG-dC), as template-primers, and dGTP, dITP, and dCTP as substrates. We have utilized the difference in thermodynamic stability between the doubly H-bonded I X C base pair and triply H-bonded G X C base pair to examine the effects of base-pair stability of both the "preceding" and the "following" nucleotides on the frequency of insertion of a mismatched nucleotide, as well as on its stable incorporation into polynucleotide. The present studies demonstrate that the stability of the base pairs formed by nearest-neighbor nucleotides affects the frequency of incorporation of noncomplementary nucleotides. Misincorporation frequency is increased when the nearest-neighbor nucleotides form more stable base pairs with the corresponding nucleotides in the template and is decreased when they form less stable base pairs. The stability of the base pair formed by a nucleotide either preceding (5' to) or following (3' to) a misincorporated nucleotide influences misincorporation frequency, but by different mechanisms. The stability of base pairs formed by preceding nucleotides affects the rate of insertion of mismatched nucleotide but does not protect the mismatched nucleotide from removal by the 3' to 5' exonuclease activity. In contrast, the stability of a base pair formed by a following nucleotide determines whether a misincorporated nucleotide is extended or excised by affecting the ability of the enzyme to edit errors of incorporation.     

Synthesis of alanyl nucleobase amino acids and their incorporation into proteins

Proteins which bind to nucleic acids and regulate their structure and functions are numerous and exceptionally important. Such proteins employ a variety of strategies for recognition of the relevant structural elements in their nucleic acid substrates, some of which have been shown to involve rather subtle interactions which might have been difficult to design from first principles. In the present study, we have explored the preparation of proteins containing unnatural amino acids having nucleobase side chains. In principle, the introduction of multiple nucleobase amino acids into the nucleic acid binding domain of a protein should enable these modified proteins to interact with their nucleic acid substrates using Watson-Crick and other base pairing interactions. We describe the synthesis of five alanyl nucleobase amino acids protected in a fashion which enabled their attachment to a suppressor tRNA, and their incorporation into each of two proteins with acceptable efficiencies. The nucleobases studied included cytosine, uracil, thymine, adenine and guanine, i.e. the major nucleobase constituents of DNA and RNA. Dihydrofolate reductase was chosen as one model protein to enable direct comparison of the facility of incorporation of the nucleobase amino acids with numerous other unnatural amino acids studied previously. The Klenow fragment of DNA polymerase I was chosen as a representative DNA binding protein whose mode of action has been studied in detail.     

Enzymatic repair of an expanded genetic information system

The excision repair machinery of a thermophilic bacterium has been shown to recognize and repair an expanded genetic base pair. Native Thermus aquaticus DNA polymerase will remove a mispaired natural base and replace it with a non-natural base to form an expanded base pair. In addition, DNA ligase will recognize a nick formed by polymerase between two non-natural base pairs and covalently attach the two strands, thus demonstrating complete repair of a bifurcated base-paired model duplex. These results add evidence to the idea that the cellular replication and repair machinery of an organism containing an expanded genetic alphabet could recognize and properly repair a site containing consecutive unnatural bases.     

Synthesis and binding properties of new selective ligands for the nucleobase opposite the AP site

DNA is continuously damaged by endogenous and exogenous factors such as oxidative stress or DNA alkylating agents. These damaged nucleobases are removed by DNA N-glycosylase and form apurinic/apyrimidinic sites (AP sites) as intermediates in the base excision repair (BER) pathway. AP sites are also representative DNA damages formed by spontaneous hydrolysis. The AP sites block DNA polymerase and a mismatch nucleobase is inserted opposite the AP sites by polymerization to cause acute toxicities and mutations. Thus, AP site specific compounds have attracted much attention for therapeutic and diagnostic purposes. In this study, we have developed nucleobase-polyamine conjugates as the AP site binding ligand by expecting that the nucleobase part would play a role in the specific recognition of the nucleobase opposite the AP site by the Watson-Crick base pair formation and that the polyamine part should contribute to the access of the ligand to the AP site by a non-specific interaction to the DNA phosphate backbone. The nucleobase conjugated with 3,3'-diaminodipropylamine (A-ligand, G-ligand, C-ligand, T-ligand and U-ligand) showed a specific stabilization of the duplex containing the AP site depending on the complementary combination with the nucleobase opposite the AP site; that is A-ligand to T, G-ligand to C, C-ligand to G, T- and U-ligand to A. The thermodynamic binding parameters clearly indicated that the specific stabilization is due to specific binding of the ligands to the complementary AP site. These results have suggested that the complementary base pairs of the Watson-Crick type are formed at the AP site.     

Unnatural imidazopyridopyrimidine:naphthyridine base pairs: selective incorporation and extension reaction by Deep Vent (exo? ) DNA polymerase

In our previous communication we reported the enzymatic recognition of unnatural imidazopyridopyrimidine:naphthyridine (Im:Na) base pairs, i.e. ImO^N:NaN^O and ImN^O:NaO^N, using the Klenow fragment exo⁻ [KF (exo⁻)]. We describe herein the successful results of (i) improved enzymatic recognition for ImN^O:NaO^N base pairs and (ii) further primer extension reactions after the Im:Na base pairs by Deep Vent DNA polymerase exo⁻ [Deep Vent (exo⁻)]. Since KF (exo⁻) did not catalyze primer extension reactions after the Im:Na base pair, we carried out a screening of DNA polymerases to promote the primer extension reaction as well as to improve the selectivity of base pair recognition. As a result, a family B DNA polymerase, especially Deep Vent (exo⁻), seemed most promising for this purpose. In the ImO^N:NaN^O base pair, incorporation of NaN^OTP against ImO^N in the template was preferable to that of the natural dNTPs, while incorporation of dATP as well as dGTP competed with that of ImO^NTP when NaN^O was placed in the template. Thus, the selectivity of base pair recognition by Deep Vent (exo⁻) was less than that by KF (exo⁻) in the case of the ImO^N:NaN^O base pair. On the other hand, incorporation of NaO^NTP against ImN^O in the template and that of ImN^OTP against NaO^N were both quite selective. Thus, the selectivity of base pair recognition was improved by Deep Vent (exo⁻) in the ImN^O:NaO^N base pair. Moreover, this enzyme catalyzed further primer extension reactions after the ImN^O:NaO^N base pair to afford a faithful replicate, which was confirmed by MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry as well as the kinetics data for extension fidelity next to the ImN^O:NaO^N base pair. The results presented in this paper revealed that the ImN^O:NaO^N base pair might be a third base pair beyond the Watson–Crick base pairs.     

Towards a DNA-like duplex without hydrogen bonds

The inverse quadrupolar moments of the phenyl and pentafluorophenyl residues in the base pair P-F5 promotes strong intramolecular stacking interactions in DNA duplexes. The more natural base pairs are replaced by this novel pair the higher the thermodynamic stability of the resulting duplex if they are arranged in an alternating fashion.     

The biological equilibrium of base pairs

Summary An inherent feature of double-stranded DNA is the possible replacement of any base pair by another one upon replication. A replication-dependent substitution mutation of a matched base pair requires the temporary formation of a mismatched base pair (mispair). A functionally complementary pair of mispairs is ascribed to each of the four types of substitution mutations. Provided that all types of mispairs can be formed, a dynamic biological equilibrium between the four matched base pairs must exist in all DNA, which is directly related to the formation and stability of the corresponding eight mispairs in vivo. Each nucleotide position in a genome can therefore be described as a system of six dynamic equilibria between the four matched base pairs. After a sufficient number of replications, these equilibrium states will express an overall mutation-selection balance for each individual base pair. In a thermodynamic context, the mispairs represent intermediate states on the transformation pathway between the matched base pairs. Catalysts change the stability and probability of formation of intermediate states. Mutagenic proteins are proposed as hypothetical substitution mutation catalysts in vivo. Functionally, they would be capable of recognizing a particular DNA sequence, tautomerizing a nucleotide base thereof, and hence efficiently inducing a specific misincorporation. Phenomenologically such catalysts would accelerate the rates of substitution mutations and provide pathways for directional mutation pressure. Present address until March 31 1990: University Chemical Laboratory, Lensfield Road, Cambridge CB2 1EW, Great Britain