Comparative sequencing analysis reveals high genomic concordance between matched primary and metastatic colorectal cancer lesions

Background

Colorectal cancer is the second leading cause of cancer death in the United States, with over 50,000 deaths estimated in 2014. Molecular profiling for somatic mutations that predict absence of response to anti-EGFR therapy has become standard practice in the treatment of metastatic colorectal cancer; however, the quantity and type of tissue available for testing is frequently limited. Further, the degree to which the primary tumor is a faithful representation of metastatic disease has been questioned. As next-generation sequencing technology becomes more widely available for clinical use and additional molecularly targeted agents are considered as treatment options in colorectal cancer, it is important to characterize the extent of tumor heterogeneity between primary and metastatic tumors.

Results

We performed deep coverage, targeted next-generation sequencing of 230 key cancer-associated genes for 69 matched primary and metastatic tumors and normal tissue. Mutation profiles were 100% concordant for KRAS, NRAS, and BRAF, and were highly concordant for recurrent alterations in colorectal cancer. Additionally, whole genome sequencing of four patient trios did not reveal any additional site-specific targetable alterations.

Conclusions

Colorectal cancer primary tumors and metastases exhibit high genomic concordance. As current clinical practices in colorectal cancer revolve around KRAS, NRAS, and BRAF mutation status, diagnostic sequencing of either primary or metastatic tissue as available is acceptable for most patients. Additionally, consistency between targeted sequencing and whole genome sequencing results suggests that targeted sequencing may be a suitable strategy for clinical diagnostic applications.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s13059-014-0454-7) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Exome Sequencing of Cell-Free DNA from Metastatic Cancer Patients Identifies Clinically Actionable Mutations Distinct from Primary Disease

The identification of the molecular drivers of cancer by sequencing is the backbone of precision medicine and the basis of personalized therapy; however, biopsies of primary tumors provide only a snapshot of the evolution of the disease and may miss potential therapeutic targets, especially in the metastatic setting. A liquid biopsy, in the form of cell-free DNA (cfDNA) sequencing, has the potential to capture the inter- and intra-tumoral heterogeneity present in metastatic disease, and, through serial blood draws, track the evolution of the tumor genome.In order to determine the clinical utility of cfDNA sequencing we performed whole-exome sequencing on cfDNA and tumor DNA from two patients with metastatic disease; only minor modifications to our sequencing and analysis pipelines were required for sequencing and mutation calling of cfDNA. The first patient had metastatic sarcoma and 47 of 48 mutations present in the primary tumor were also found in the cell-free DNA. The second patient had metastatic breast cancer and sequencing identified an ESR1 mutation in the cfDNA and metastatic site, but not in the primary tumor. This likely explains tumor progression on Anastrozole. Significant heterogeneity between the primary and metastatic tumors, with cfDNA reflecting the metastases, suggested separation from the primary lesion early in tumor evolution. This is best illustrated by an activating PIK3CA mutation (H1047R) which was clonal in the primary tumor, but completely absent from either the metastasis or cfDNA. Here we show that cfDNA sequencing supplies clinically actionable information with minimal risks compared to metastatic biopsies. This study demonstrates the utility of whole-exome sequencing of cell-free DNA from patients with metastatic disease. cfDNA sequencing identified an ESR1 mutation, potentially explaining a patient’s resistance to aromatase inhibition, and gave insight into how metastatic lesions differ from the primary tumor.     

基因突变在结直肠癌发生机制中的作用:殊途同归

结直肠癌的多步骤演进模式一直是肿瘤研究的经典,在这一过程中,序贯发生的基因突变(或其它遗传事件)是重要的推动力。本文综述了在结直肠癌中检测到的基因突变情况,并分析了在新一代测序技术的带动下,结直肠癌基因组学的最新进展。结直肠癌组织基因突变的地形图理念对于今后的肿瘤分子诊疗将具有重要意义。肿瘤不仅是基因病,更是信号通路异常病。     

Mutation of GDP-Mannose-4,6-Dehydratase in Colorectal Cancer Metastasis

Fucosylation is a crucial oligosaccharide modification in cancer. The known function of fucosylation in cancer is to mediate metastasis through selectin ligand-dependent processes. Previously, we found complete loss of fucosylation in the colon cancer cell line HCT116 due to a mutation in the GDP-fucose synthetic enzyme, GDP-mannose-4,6-dehydratase (GMDS). Loss of fucosylation led to escape of cancer cells from tumor immune surveillance followed by tumor progression and metastasis, suggesting a novel function of fucosylation in tumor progression pathway. In the present study, we investigated the frequency of GMDS mutation in a number of clinical colorectal cancer tissue samples: 81 samples of primary colorectal cancer tissue and 39 samples of metastatic lesion including liver and lymph node. Four types of deletion mutation in GMDS were identified in original cancer tissues as well as metastatic lesions. The frequency of GMDS mutation was slightly higher in metastatic lesions (12.8%, 5/39 samples) than in original cancer tissues (8.6%, 7/81 samples). No mutation of the GMDS gene was observed in normal colon tissues surrounding cancer tissues, suggesting that the mutation is somatic rather than in the germline. Immunohistochemical analysis revealed complete loss of fucosylation in three cases of cancer tissue. All three cases had GMDS mutation. In one of three cases, loss of fucosylation was observed in only metastatic lesion, but not its original colon cancer tissue. These data demonstrate involvement of GMDS mutation in the progression of colorectal cancer.     

Quantifying Clonal and Subclonal Passenger Mutations in Cancer Evolution

The vast majority of mutations in the exome of cancer cells are passengers, which do not affect the reproductive rate of the cell. Passengers can provide important information about the evolutionary history of an individual cancer, and serve as a molecular clock. Passengers can also become targets for immunotherapy or confer resistance to treatment. We study the stochastic expansion of a population of cancer cells describing the growth of primary tumors or metastatic lesions. We first analyze the process by looking forward in time and calculate the fixation probabilities and frequencies of successive passenger mutations ordered by their time of appearance. We compute the likelihood of specific evolutionary trees, thereby informing the phylogenetic reconstruction of cancer evolution in individual patients. Next, we derive results looking backward in time: for a given subclonal mutation we estimate the number of cancer cells that were present at the time when that mutation arose. We derive exact formulas for the expected numbers of subclonal mutations of any frequency. Fitting this formula to cancer sequencing data leads to an estimate for the ratio of birth and death rates of cancer cells during the early stages of clonal expansion.     

Familiärer Darmkrebs

Up to 5% of colorectal cancer cases are caused by a monogenic inherited disposition. Among these, hereditary nonpolyposis colorectal cancer (Lynch syndrome, HNPCC) accounts for 2–3% and adenomatous polyposis syndromes (familial adenomatous polyposis, FAP and MUTYH-associated polyposis, MAP) for about 1% of cases. Hamartomatous polyposis syndromes (juvenile polyposis syndrome, Peutz-Jeghers syndrome and Cowden syndrome) are rare disorders that are also associated with an increased colorectal cancer risk. The genetic basis is largely known for the tumour syndromes mentioned above. The identification of the causative germline mutation in the respective DNA repair genes (e.g. in HNPCC and MAP) or tumour suppressor genes (FAP or hamartomatous polyposis syndromes) allows confirmation of the diagnosis in affected individuals and provides predictive diagnostics for their healthy relatives. To achieve a targeted and useful molecular diagnostics, it is important that the clinician provides a detailed characterisation of the clinical picture; moreover, family history may also give a hint of the underlying gene defect. The screening of tumour tissue for the presence of a mismatch repair defect should precede mutation analysis in suspected cases of HNPCC, as it is difficult to differentiate between this condition and sporadic colorectal cancer. In contrast, mutation analysis can be directly performed in polyposis syndromes provided the syndrome has been correctly classified by the histology of polyps.     

Prospective analysis of KRAS wild-type patients with metastatic colorectal cancer using cetuximab plus FOLFIRI or FOLFOX4 treatment regimens

Cetuximab, a monoclonal antibody targeting epidermal growth factor receptor, has proven to be efficient in the treatment of metastatic colorectal cancer. We made a prospective study of the efficacy and toxicities of cetuximab-combination first-line (FOLFOX4) versus second/third-line (FOLFIRI) chemotherapy in 98 KRAS wild-type patients who had metastatic colorectal cancer. Wild-type KRAS had been identified by direct sequencing. Associations between clinical response/progression-free survival/overall survival/toxicities and cetuximab-combination chemotherapy timing were evaluated. The overall response rate was significantly higher for first-line treatment than for second/third-line treatment (relative risk = 1.707, 95% confidence interval = 1.121-2.598). Both progression-free survival and overall survival indicated significantly longer survival of first-line treatment than second/third-line treatment patients. This study is a validation of a molecular analysis of KRAS wild-type status for the prediction of response to cetuximab-combination chemotherapy for metastatic colorectal cancer patients; its predictive role was less prominent in the second/third-line than in the first-line treatment patients.     

Massive parallele Sequenzierung in der Diagnostik hereditärer BRCA1-/-2-Mutationen

During the past few years, application of massively-parallel sequencing (MPS) in molecular diagnostics of hereditary cancer has increased significantly. The potential advantages of MPS, compared for example to Sanger sequencing-based methods, are higher sample capacities, shorter turnaround times, and decreased costs. Adoption in routine diagnostics is simplified due to the availability of certified kits for sample preparation. Here, the validation of two MPS systems for routine BRCA1/2 sequencing diagnostics are describe. Users should keep in mind the technical advantages and disadvantages of the individual sequencing machines. The results achieved with MPS are equal to those from Sanger sequencing.     

基因突变在结直肠癌诊疗及预后中的研究进展

结直肠癌是常见的恶性肿瘤之一,其发病率居全球恶性肿瘤发病率的第三位,死亡率呈逐年上升趋势。中国已成为全球结直肠癌每年新发病例数和死亡病例数最多的国家。对结直肠癌基因突变状态的识别以及对结直肠癌发生发展过程进行精确分类,可实现对患者进行个性化精准治疗的目的,而精准治疗的实现有赖于基因测序技术。目前,二代测序技术(Next generation sequencing,NGS)结合基因捕获技术,集中对研究者感兴趣的候选基因或外显子进行平行测序,极大拓展了对肿瘤特征基因的认识,为发展新的治疗手段和治疗策略奠定了基础。整合癌症基因组数据库IntOgen已明确72个结直肠癌驱动突变基因,包括“TP53”、“KRAS”、“PIK3CA”等;癌基因数据库Cancer Gene Census目前收录的结直肠癌突变基因有59个,包括原癌基因“BRAF”、抑癌基因“SMAD4”等;在线人类孟德尔遗传OMIM数据库已收录55个与结直肠癌相关的体细胞突变基因,包括“SRC”、“APC”等。本文通过26篇国内外文献,对结直肠癌基因突变检测的共识基因进行综述,并总结了与结直肠癌患者临床诊断、分型、预后、治疗等临床病理特征相关的突变基因标志物。     

KRAS and BRAF mutation analysis can be reliably performed on aspirated cytological specimens of metastatic colorectal carcinoma

N. K. B. Pang, M. E. Nga, S. Y. Chin, T.‐M. Ismail, G. L. Lim, R. Soong and M. Salto‐Tellez
KRAS and BRAF mutation analysis can be reliably performed on aspirated cytological specimens of metastatic colorectal carcinoma Background: Sanger sequencing is one of several reliable methods in use to detect KRAS and BRAF mutations to facilitate clinical patient selection for anti‐epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) monoclonal antibody therapy in unresectable metastatic colorectal adenocarcinoma (CRC). Most analyses are made on pretreatment biopsy or resection specimens. There is a scarcity of published studies on the suitability of cytological samples for KRAS testing in this setting. Methods: DNA extraction was attempted on 11 search‐retrieved paired cases of histological resections or excisions of CRC and their corresponding cytological samples (representing metastases) and tested for KRAS mutations in exon 2 and 3, as well as BRAF exon 15 mutations by Sanger sequencing. Only KRAS wild‐type cases were subjected to BRAF analysis because this is the setting with true diagnostic value, as these mutations are mutually exclusive. Results: Of the 11 paired cases analysed, only eight histology cases showed satisfactory DNA quality for sequencing. Thus, only eight of the corresponding cytology cases were analysed. Seven of the eight cases tested showed the same KRAS genotype on both the aspirated cytology specimen of metastatic carcinoma and the primary tumour (histological specimen), from which we derive an overall concordance rate of 87.5%. The single discordant case was likely to be a true difference as it was demonstrated again on repeat testing of both samples. No BRAF mutations were detected on the four KRAS wild‐type cases. Conclusion: A range of cytological samples are suitable for KRAS and BRAF mutation testing, be it from previously stained preparations or cell blocks. These samples would be highly valuable in cases where cytological samples are the only material available for mutation testing.     

Accounting for Errors in Data Improves Divergence Time Estimates in Single-cell Cancer Evolution

Single-cell sequencing provides a new way to explore the evolutionary history of cells. Compared to traditional bulk sequencing, where a population of heterogeneous cells is pooled to form a single observation, single-cell sequencing isolates and amplifies genetic material from individual cells, thereby preserving the information about the origin of the sequences. However, single-cell data are more error-prone than bulk sequencing data due to the limited genomic material available per cell. Here, we present error and mutation models for evolutionary inference of single-cell data within a mature and extensible Bayesian framework, BEAST2. Our framework enables integration with biologically informative models such as relaxed molecular clocks and population dynamic models. Our simulations show that modeling errors increase the accuracy of relative divergence times and substitution parameters. We reconstruct the phylogenetic history of a colorectal cancer patient and a healthy patient from single-cell DNA sequencing data. We find that the estimated times of terminal splitting events are shifted forward in time compared to models which ignore errors. We observed that not accounting for errors can overestimate the phylogenetic diversity in single-cell DNA sequencing data. We estimate that 30–50% of the apparent diversity can be attributed to error. Our work enables a full Bayesian approach capable of accounting for errors in the data within the integrative Bayesian software framework BEAST2.     

Colorectal Cancer Patients with Low Abundance of KRAS Mutation May Benefit from EGFR Antibody Therapy

Epidermal growth factor receptor monoclonal antibody was approved for treatment of metastatic colorectal cancer patients carrying KRAS wild type DNA. However, recent studies showed that patients with KRAS G13D mutation may benefit from EGFR antibody therapy. In this study we tried to explore whether the abundance of KRAS mutation could affect the efficacy of EGFR antibody therapy. We firstly established a PNA-PCR method which could calculate the percentage of KRAS mutation in total DNA and proved its ability on 47 colorectal cancer samples bearing KRAS mutations. Then we analyzed the correlation between the abundance of KRAS mutations and efficacy of EGFR antibody therapy in another 35 metastatic colorectal cancer patients. We proved that PNA-PCR assay could calculate the abundance of KRAS mutation and the percentage of mutant DNA in tumor cells varied a lot (10.8%∼98.3%) on the 47 colorectal cancer patients. The efficacy of EGFR antibody correlated with the abundance of KRAS mutations: in the KRAS mutation less than 30% group, the disease control rate was 44.4% (4/9); the disease control rate of 30∼80% group was 5.6% (1/18) and the >80% group was 12.5% (1/8) (P = 0.038). In summary, our study showed that PNA-PCR method could easily detect the percentage of KRAS mutation in tumor cells and colorectal cancer patients with low abundance of KRAS mutation might benefit from EGFR antibody therapy.     

NF-kappaB and Hsp70 are involved in the phospholipase Cgamma1 signaling pathway in colorectal cancer cells

The majority of deaths from colorectal cancer are due to tumor invasion and metastasis. Induced migration of tumor cell is generally considered to be one critical step in cancer progression to the invasive and metastatic stage. Phospholipase Cgamma1 (PLCgamma1) is a key molecular switch in the process. But, the mechanism and function of PLCgamma1 in colorectal cancer motility are unclear. We showed first in this report that epidermal growth factor (EGF) stimulated the phosphorylation of PLCgamma1 in human colorectal cancer cell line LoVo. Inhibition of PLCgamma1 with the pharmacologic agent U73122 decreased the migration of LoVo cells in a dose-dependent manner while EGF treatment reversed it partially. PLCgamma1 signaling pathway also upregulated the activity of NF-kappaB. Furthermore, expression of Hsp70 was increased by treatment with U73122 or pyrrolidine dithiocarbamate (PDTC), a NF-kappaB inhibitor. These data indicated that PLCgamma1 played a pivotal role in the migration of human colorectal cancer cell and first demonstrated that upregulation of NF-kappaB binding activity and downregulation of Hsp70 expression were PLCgamma1-dependent in LoVo cells.     

基于微流控芯片的温度梯度毛细管电泳检测大肠癌石蜡标本中K-ras基因突变

K-ras基因突变检测可用于大肠癌的早期筛查与诊断,并有利于筛选出抗表皮生长因子受体靶向药物治疗有效的大肠癌患者,以实现肿瘤的个体化治疗．采用以倾斜式热辐射原理建立的微流控温度梯度毛细管电泳(temperature gradient capillary electrophoresis,TGCE)基因突变检测系统,实现了对98例石蜡包埋大肠癌组织中K-ras基因突变的高灵敏度筛查,突变阳性检出率为47.96%,显著高于PCR产物直接测序的23.47%．克隆测序显示该方法至少能检测到2.08%的K-ras基因突变体．K-ras基因突变与临床病理学参数的关系分析显示,直肠癌中K-ras基因突变率明显高于结肠癌(P < 0.05),而与年龄、性别、组织学类型和肿瘤分期等无显著相关性．该检测方法为肿瘤早期诊断和指导临床用药提供了一种灵敏度高、检测速度快、便于大规模筛查的有效手段.     

转移性结直肠癌抗血管生成靶向治疗的研究进展

近年来,由于各种新的化疗药物及分子靶向药物的使用,转移性结直肠癌(metastatic colorectal cancer,m CRC)的个体化治疗逐步取得了重要的成果。研究表明,抗血管生成靶向药物与化疗药物的联合使用作为转移性结直肠癌的一线治疗方案,可明显改善治疗效果,延长患者的生存时间。血管内皮生长因子(vascularendothelial growth factor,VEGF)是肿瘤血管生成过程中最主要的因子。贝伐单抗是通过基因工程技术得到的针对血管内皮生长因子-A(VEGF-A)的单克隆抗体,作为抗血管生成靶向药物用于转移性结直肠癌的临床治疗。本文对近年来转移性结直肠癌的抗血管生成靶向治疗,尤其是贝伐单抗治疗的相关研究进展进行综述并展望未来抗血管生成靶向治疗的发展前景。     

ZG16 regulates PD-L1 expression and promotes local immunity in colon cancer

CRC is a heterogeneous disease due to global molecular alterations, including mismatch-repair-deficient (dMMR) and microsatellite instability-high (MSI-H). Immunotherapy has achieved durable responses in a subset of patients with dMMR-MSI-H metastatic CRC. It has been showed that Loss of ZG16 is highly associated with colorectal cancer. However, whether ZG16 modulates tumor immunity in colorectal cancer is unclear. In this study, we demonstrated that the expression of ZG16 is associated with distant metastasis and lymphatic invasive in colorectal cancer. Besides, ZG16 is negatively correlated to PD-L1 expression in patient with CRC and overexpression of ZG16 blocks PD-L1 expression in colorectal cancer cells. In addition, overexpression of ZG16 promotes NK cells survival and proliferation, which is dependent on NKG2D expression. Our data demonstrate that ZG16 plays a role in modulation of immune response in colorectal cancer. The strong correlation between ZG16 and PD-L1 suggests that ZG16 may serve a biomarker to stratify patient who will benefit from immunotherapy.     

Oxidative stress-based cytotoxicity of delphinidin and cyanidin in colon cancer cells

Colorectal cancer is the second most frequent cause of cancer death in the western world. Although the prognosis has improved after the introduction of newer anticancer drugs, the treatment of metastatic colorectal cancer still remains a challenge due to a high percentage of drug-resistant tumor forms. We aimed at testing whether anthocyanidins exerted cytotoxicity in primary (Caco-2) and metastatic (LoVo and LoVo/ADR) colorectal cancer cell lines. Both cyanidin and delphinidin, though neither pelargonidin nor malvidin, were cytotoxic in metastatic cells only. The cell line most sensitive to anthocyanidins was the drug-resistant LoVo/ADR. There, cellular ROS accumulation, inhibition of glutathione reductase, and depletion of glutathione could be observed. This suggests that anthocyanidins may be used as sensitizing agents in metastatic colorectal cancer therapy.     

Age and metastasis – How age influences metastatic spread in cancer. Colorectal cancer as a model

Metastasis is the major cause of death in cancer patients. Whereas colorectal cancer (CRC) incidence increases with age, metastatic spread seems to decline. Furthermore, the epidemiology of CRC is changing. There is an increase in CRC incidence in the young, presenting at an advanced stage with higher likelihood of synchronous or metachronous metastases, and a decline in CRC incidence and metastatic spread in the oldest-old. Emerging data suggest that age-related changes with regard to tumor biology (e.g. genomic instability), the tumor microenvironment (e.g. inflammaging) and the immune system (e.g. immunosenescence), complemented by interaction between the genome and exposome might contribute to the observed metastatic patterns. As aging is a key prognostic factor, this highlights the need for further studies investigating age-related patterns and underlying mechanisms of tumor growth and dissemination. Eventually, this might allow for better risk stratification, refinement of screening strategies and follow-up care as well as therapies tailored to reflect patient age and that might possibly target responsible biomarkers in a precision medicine approach. This review aims to discuss the influence of aging on metastatic spread in colorectal cancer and elucidate underlying mechanisms responsible for the observed metastatic patterns.     

Sonic advance: CCN1 regulates sonic hedgehog in pancreatic cancer

Pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma (PDAC) is the fifth leading cause of cancer internationally. As the precise molecular pathways that regulate pancreatic cancer are incompletely understood, appropriate targets for drug intervention remain elusive. It is being increasingly appreciated that the cellular microenvironment plays an important role in driving tumor growth and metastasis. CCN1, a member of the CCN family of secreted matricellular proteins, is overexpressed in pancreatic cancer, and may represent a novel target for therapy. Sonic hedgehog (SHh) is responsible for PDAC cell proliferation, epithelial-mesenchymal transition (EMT), maintenance of cancer stemness, migration, invasion, and metastatic growth; in a recent report, it was shown that CCN1 is a potent regulator of SHh expression via Notch-1. CCN1 activity was mediated, at least in part, through altering proteosome activity. These results suggest that CCN1 may be an ideal target for treating PDAC.