RNase P: role of distinct protein cofactors in tRNA substrate recognition and RNA-based catalysis

The Escherichia coli ribonuclease P (RNase P) has a protein component, termed C5, which acts as a cofactor for the catalytic M1 RNA subunit that processes the 5′ leader sequence of precursor tRNA. Rpp29, a conserved protein subunit of human RNase P, can substitute for C5 protein in reconstitution assays of M1 RNA activity. To better understand the role of the former protein, we compare the mode of action of Rpp29 to that of the C5 protein in activation of M1 RNA. Enzyme kinetic analyses reveal that complexes of M1 RNA–Rpp29 and M1 RNA–C5 exhibit comparable binding affinities to precursor tRNA but different catalytic efficiencies. High concentrations of substrate impede the activity of the former complex. Rpp29 itself exhibits high affinity in substrate binding, which seems to reduce the catalytic efficiency of the reconstituted ribonucleoprotein. Rpp29 has a conserved C-terminal domain with an Sm-like fold that mediates interaction with M1 RNA and precursor tRNA and can activate M1 RNA. The results suggest that distinct protein folds in two unrelated protein cofactors can facilitate transition from RNA- to ribonucleoprotein-based catalysis by RNase P.     

RNase P from bacteria. Substrate recognition and function of the protein subunit

RNase P recognizes many different precursor tRNAs as well as other substrates and cleaves all of them accurately at the expected position. RNase P recognizes the tRNA structure of the precursor tRNA by a set of interactions between the catalytic RNA subunit and the T- and acceptor-stems mainly, although residues in the 5-leader sequence as well as the 3-terminal CCA are important. These conclusions have been reached by several studies on mutant precursor tRNAs as well as cross-linking studies between RNase P RNA and precursor tRNAs. The protein subunit of RNase P seems also to affect the way that the substrate is recognized as well as the range of substrates that can be used by RNase P, although the protein does not seem to interact directly with the substrates. The interaction between the protein and RNA subunits of RNase P has been extensively studiedin vitro. The protein subunit sequence is not highly conserved among bacteria, however different proteins are functionally equivalent as heterologous reconstitution of the RNase P holoenzyme can be achieved in many cases.Abbreviations C5 protein protein subunit fromE. coli RNase P - EGS external guide sequence - M1 RNA RNA subunit formE. coli RNase P - ptRNA precursor tRNA - RNase P ribonuclease P     

Influence of Conformation of M. tuberculosis RNase P Protein Subunit on Its Function

RNase P is an essential enzyme that processes 5'' end leader sequence of pre-tRNA to generate mature tRNA. The bacterial RNase Ps contain a RNA subunit and one protein subunit, where the RNA subunit contains the catalytic activity. The protein subunit which lacks any catalytic activity, relaxes the ionic requirements for holoenzyme reaction and is indispensable for pre-tRNA cleavage in vivo. In the current study, we reconstituted the M. tuberculosis RNase P holoenzyme in vitro. We prepared the RNase P protein through two different strategies that differ in the conditions under which the recombinant M. tuberculosis protein, expressed in E. coli was purified. The mycobacterial RNase P protein which was purified under native conditions subsequent to isolation from inclusion bodies and in vitro renaturation, was capable of cleaving pre-tRNA specifically without the requirement of RNase P RNA. However, the preparation that was purified under denaturing conditions and refolded subsequently lacked any inherent pre-tRNA processing activity and cleaved the substrate only as a component of the holoenzyme with the RNA subunit. We found that the two RNase P protein preparations attained alternative conformations and differed with respect to their stability as well.     

RNase P RNA mediated cleavage: substrate recognition and catalysis

The universally conserved endoribonuclease P consists of one RNA subunit and, depending on its origin, a variable number of protein subunits. RNase P is involved in the processing of a large variety of substrates in the cell, the preferred substrate being tRNA precursors. Cleavage activity does not require the presence of the protein subunit(s) in vitro. This is true for both prokaryotic and eukaryotic RNase P RNA suggesting that the RNA based catalytic activity has been preserved during evolution. Progress has been made in our understanding of the contribution of residues and chemical groups both in the substrate as well as in RNase P RNA to substrate binding and catalysis. Moreover, we have access to two crystal structures of bacterial RNase P RNA but we still lack the structure of RNase P RNA in complex with its substrate and/or the protein subunit. Nevertheless, these recent advancements put us in a new position to study the way and nature of interactions between in particular RNase P RNA and its substrate. In this review I will discuss various aspects of the RNA component of RNase P with an emphasis on our current understanding of the interaction between RNase P RNA and its substrate.     

Novel mechanisms for maturation of chloroplast transfer RNA precursors

Despite the prokaryotic origins of chloroplasts, a plant chloroplast tRNA precursor is processed in a homologous in vitro system by a pathway distinct from that observed in Escherichia coli, but identical to that utilized for maturation of nuclear pre-tRNAs. The mature tRNA 5' terminus is generated by the site-specific endonucleolytic cleavage of an RNase P (or P-type) activity. The 3' end is likewise produced by a single precise endonucleolytic cut at the 3' terminus of the encoded tRNA domain. This is the first complete structural characterization of an organellar tRNA processing system using a homologous substrate. In contrast to eubacterial RNase P, chloroplast RNase P does not appear to contain an RNA subunit. The chloroplast activity bands with bulk protein at 1.28 g/ml in CsCI density gradients, whereas E.coli RNase P bands as ribonucleoprotein at 1.73 g/ml. Chloroplast RNase P activity survives treatment with micrococcal nuclease (MN) at levels 10- to 100-fold higher than those required to totally inactivate the E.coli enzyme. The chloroplast system is sensitive to a suppression of tRNA processing, caused by binding of inactive MN to pre-tRNA substrate, which is readily overcome by addition of carrier RNA to the assay.     

Functional role of putative critical residues in Mycobacterium tuberculosis RNase P protein

RNase P is involved in processing the 5⿲ end of pre-tRNA molecules. Bacterial RNase P contains a catalytic RNA subunit and a protein subunit. In this study, we have analyzed the residues in RNase P protein of M. tuberculosis that differ from the residues generally conserved in other bacterial RNase Ps. The residues investigated in the current study include the unique residues, Val27, Ala70, Arg72, Ala77, and Asp124, and also Phe23 and Arg93 which have been found to be important in the function of RNase P protein components of other bacteria. The selected residues were individually mutated either to those present in other bacterial RNase P protein components at respective positions or in some cases to alanine. The wild type and mutant M. tuberculosis RNase P proteins were expressed in E. coli, purified, used to reconstitute holoenzymes with wild type RNA component in vitro, and functionally characterized. The Phe23Ala and Arg93Ala mutants showed very poor catalytic activity when reconstituted with the RNA component. The catalytic activity of holoenzyme with Val27Phe, Ala70Lys, Arg72Leu and Arg72Ala was also significantly reduced, whereas with Ala77Phe and Asp124Ser the activity of holoenzyme was similar to that with the wild type protein. Although the mutants did not suffer from any binding defects, Val27Phe, Ala70Lys, Arg72Ala and Asp124Ser were less tolerant towards higher temperatures as compared to the wild type protein. The K_m of Val27Phe, Ala70Lys, Arg72Ala and Ala77Phe were >2-fold higher than that of the wild type, indicating the substituted residues to be involved in substrate interaction. The study demonstrates that residues Phe23, Val27 and Ala70 are involved in substrate interaction, while Arg72 and Arg93 interact with other residues within the protein to provide it a functional conformation.     

Analysis of substrate recognition by the ribonucleoprotein endonuclease RNase P

Ribonuclease P (RNase P), is a ribonucleoprotein complex that catalyzes the site-specific cleavage of pre-tRNA and a wide variety of other substrates. Although RNase P RNA is the catalytic subunit of the holoenzyme, the protein subunit plays a critical role in substrate binding. Thus, RNase P is an excellent model system for studying ribonucleoprotein function. In this review we describe methods applied to the in vitro study of substrate recognition by bacterial RNase P, covering general considerations of reaction conditions, quantitative measurement of substrate binding equilibria, enzymatic and chemical protection, cross-linking, modification interference, and analysis of site-specific substitutions. We describe application of these methods to substrate binding by RNase P RNA alone and experimental considerations for examining the holoenzyme. The combined use of these approaches has shown that the RNA and protein subunits cooperate to bind different portions of the substrate structure, with the RNA subunit predominantly interacting with the mature domain of tRNA and the protein interacting with the 5(') leader sequence. However, important questions concerning the interface between the two subunits and the coordination of RNA and protein subunits in binding and catalysis remain.     

Functional characterization of the conserved amino acids in Pop1p, the largest common protein subunit of yeast RNases P and MRP

RNase P and RNase MRP are ribonucleoprotein enzymes required for 5'-end maturation of precursor tRNAs (pre-tRNAs) and processing of precursor ribosomal RNAs, respectively. In yeast, RNase P and MRP holoenzymes have eight protein subunits in common, with Pop1p being the largest at >100 kDa. Little is known about the functions of Pop1p, beyond the fact that it binds specifically to the RNase P RNA subunit, RPR1 RNA. In this study, we refined the previous Pop1 phylogenetic sequence alignment and found four conserved regions. Highly conserved amino acids in yeast Pop1p were mutagenized by randomization and conditionally defective mutations were obtained. Effects of the Pop1p mutations on pre-tRNA processing, pre-rRNA processing, and stability of the RNA subunits of RNase P and MRP were examined. In most cases, functional defects in RNase P and RNase MRP in vivo were consistent with assembly defects of the holoenzymes, although moderate kinetic defects in RNase P were also observed. Most mutations affected both pre-tRNA and pre-rRNA processing, but a few mutations preferentially interfered with only RNase P or only RNase MRP. In addition, one temperature-sensitive mutation had no effect on either tRNA or rRNA processing, consistent with an additional role for RNase P, RNase MRP, or Pop1p in some other form. This study shows that the Pop1p subunit plays multiple roles in the assembly and function of of RNases P and MRP, and that the functions can be differentiated through the mutations in conserved residues.     

Unexpected diversity of RNase P, an ancient tRNA processing enzyme: Challenges and prospects

For an enzyme functioning predominantly in a seemingly housekeeping role of 5′ tRNA maturation, RNase P displays a remarkable diversity in subunit make-up across the three domains of life. Despite the protein complexity of this ribonucleoprotein enzyme increasing dramatically from bacteria to eukarya, the catalytic function rests with the RNA subunit during evolution. However, the recent demonstration of a protein-only human mitochondrial RNase P has added further intrigue to the compositional variability of this enzyme. In this review, we discuss some possible reasons underlying the structural diversity of the active sites, and use them as thematic bases for elaborating new directions to understand how functional variations might have contributed to the complex evolution of RNase P.     

Molecular modeling of the three-dimensional structure of the bacterial RNase P holoenzyme

Bacterial ribonuclease P (RNase P), an enzyme involved in tRNA maturation, consists of a catalytic RNA subunit and a protein cofactor. Comparative phylogenetic analysis and molecular modeling have been employed to derive secondary and tertiary structure models of the RNA subunits from Escherichia coli (type A) and Bacillus subtilis (type B) RNase P. The tertiary structure of the protein subunit of B.subtilis and Staphylococcus aureus RNase P has recently been determined. However, an understanding of the structure of the RNase P holoenzyme (i.e. the ribonucleoprotein complex) is lacking. We have now used an EDTA-Fe-based footprinting approach to generate information about RNA-protein contact sites in E.coli RNase P. The footprinting data, together with results from other biochemical and biophysical studies, have furnished distance constraints, which in turn have enabled us to build three-dimensional models of both type A and B versions of the bacterial RNase P holoenzyme in the absence and presence of its precursor tRNA substrate. These models are consistent with results from previous studies and provide both structural and mechanistic insights into the functioning of this unique catalytic RNP complex.     

Alterations in the intracellular level of a protein subunit of human RNase P affect processing of tRNA precursors

The human ribonucleoprotein ribonuclease P (RNase P), processing tRNA, has at least 10 distinct protein subunits. Many of these subunits, including the autoimmune antigen Rpp38, are shared by RNase MRP, a ribonucleoprotein enzyme required for processing of rRNA. We here show that constitutive expression of exogenous, tagged Rpp38 protein in HeLa cells affects processing of tRNA precursors. Alterations in the site-specific cleavage and in the steady-state level of 3′ sequences of the internal transcribed spacer 1 of rRNA are also observed. These processing defects are accompanied by selective shut-off of expression of Rpp38 and by low expression of the tagged protein. RNase P purified from these cells exhibits impaired activity in vitro. Moreover, inhibition of Rpp38 by the use of small interfering RNA causes accumulation of the initiator methionine tRNA precursor. Expression of other protein components, but not of the H1 RNA subunit, is coordinately inhibited. Our results reveal that normal expression of Rpp38 is required for the biosynthesis of intact RNase P and for the normal processing of stable RNA in human cells.     

Bacterial ribonuclease P holoenzyme crosslinking analysis reveals protein interaction sites on the RNA subunit

The structure of the Escherichia coli ribonuclease P (RNase P) holoenzyme was investigated by site-directed attachment of an aryl azide crosslink reagent to specific sites in the protein subunit of the enzyme. The sites of crosslinking to the RNase P RNA subunit were mapped by primer extension to several conserved residues and structural features throughout the RNA. The results suggest rearrangement of current tertiary models of the RNA subunit, particularly in regions poorly constrained by earlier data. Crosslinks to the substrate precursor-tRNA were also detected, consistent with previous crosslinking results in the Bacillus subtilis RNase P holoenzyme.     

Pre-tRNA turnover catalyzed by the yeast nuclear RNase P holoenzyme is limited by product release

Ribonuclease P (RNase P) is a ribonucleoprotein that catalyzes the 5′ maturation of precursor transfer RNA in the presence of magnesium ions. The bacterial RNase P holoenzyme consists of one catalytically active RNA component and a single essential but catalytically inactive protein. In contrast, yeast nuclear RNase P is more complex with one RNA subunit and nine protein subunits. We have devised an affinity purification protocol to gently and rapidly purify intact yeast nuclear RNase P holoenzyme for transient kinetic studies. In pre-steady-state kinetic studies under saturating substrate concentrations, we observed an initial burst of tRNA formation followed by a slower, linear, steady-state turnover, with the burst amplitude equal to the concentration of the holoenzyme used in the reaction. These data indicate that the rate-limiting step in turnover occurs after pre-tRNA cleavage, such as mature tRNA release. Additionally, the steady-state rate constants demonstrate a large dependence on temperature that results in nonlinear Arrhenius plots, suggesting that a kinetically important conformational change occurs during catalysis. Finally, deletion of the 3′ trailer in pre-tRNA has little or no effect on the steady-state kinetic rate constants. These data suggest that, despite marked differences in subunit composition, the minimal kinetic mechanism for cleavage of pre-tRNA catalyzed by yeast nuclear RNase P holoenzyme is similar to that of the bacterial RNase P holoenzyme.     

Evidence that substrate-specific effects of C5 protein lead to uniformity in binding and catalysis by RNase P

The ribonucleoprotein enzyme RNase P processes all pre-tRNAs, yet some substrates apparently lack consensus elements for recognition. Here, we compare binding affinities and cleavage rates of Escherichia coli pre-tRNAs that exhibit the largest variation from consensus recognition sequences. These results reveal that the affinities of both consensus and nonconsensus substrates for the RNase P holoenzyme are essentially uniform. Comparative analyses of pre-tRNA and tRNA binding to the RNase P holoenzyme and P RNA alone reveal differential contributions of the protein subunit to 5' leader and tRNA affinity. Additionally, these studies reveal that uniform binding results from variations in the energetic contribution of the 5' leader, which serve to compensate for weaker tRNA interactions. Furthermore, kinetic analyses reveal uniformity in the rates of substrate cleavage that result from dramatic (> 900-fold) contributions of the protein subunit to catalysis for some nonconsensus pre-tRNAs. Together, these data suggest that an important biological function of RNase P protein is to offset differences in pre-tRNA structure such that binding and catalysis are uniform.     

Evidence for induced fit in bacterial RNase P RNA-mediated cleavage

RNase P with its catalytic RNA subunit is involved in the processing of a number of RNA precursors with different structures. However, precursor tRNAs are the most abundant substrates for RNase P. Available data suggest that a tRNA is folded into its characteristic structure already at the precursor state and that RNase P recognizes this structure. The tRNA D-/T-loop domain (TSL-region) is suggested to interact with the specificity domain of RNase P RNA while residues in the catalytic domain interact with the cleavage site. Here, we have studied the consequences of a productive interaction between the TSL-region and its binding site (TBS) in the specificity domain using tRNA precursors and various hairpin-loop model substrates. The different substrates were analyzed with respect to cleavage site recognition, ground-state binding, cleavage as a function of the concentration of Mg(2+) and the rate of cleavage under conditions where chemistry is suggested to be rate limiting using wild-type Escherichia coli RNase P RNA, M1 RNA, and M1 RNA variants with structural changes in the TBS-region. On the basis of our data, we conclude that a productive TSL/TBS interaction results in a conformational change in the M1 RNA substrate complex that has an effect on catalysis. Moreover, it is likely that this conformational change comprises positioning of chemical groups (and Mg(2+)) at and in the vicinity of the cleavage site. Hence, our findings are consistent with an induced-fit mechanism in RNase P RNA-mediated cleavage.     

Interactions between subunits of Saccharomyces cerevisiae RNase MRP support a conserved eukaryotic RNase P/MRP architecture

Ribonuclease MRP is an endonuclease, related to RNase P, which functions in eukaryotic pre-rRNA processing. In Saccharomyces cerevisiae, RNase MRP comprises an RNA subunit and ten proteins. To improve our understanding of subunit roles and enzyme architecture, we have examined protein-protein and protein–RNA interactions in vitro, complementing existing yeast two-hybrid data. In total, 31 direct protein–protein interactions were identified, each protein interacting with at least three others. Furthermore, seven proteins self-interact, four strongly, pointing to subunit multiplicity in the holoenzyme. Six protein subunits interact directly with MRP RNA and four with pre-rRNA. A comparative analysis with existing data for the yeast and human RNase P/MRP systems enables confident identification of Pop1p, Pop4p and Rpp1p as subunits that lie at the enzyme core, with probable addition of Pop5p and Pop3p. Rmp1p is confirmed as an integral subunit, presumably associating preferentially with RNase MRP, rather than RNase P, via interactions with Snm1p and MRP RNA. Snm1p and Rmp1p may act together to assist enzyme specificity, though roles in substrate binding are also indicated for Pop4p and Pop6p. The results provide further evidence of a conserved eukaryotic RNase P/MRP architecture and provide a strong basis for studies of enzyme assembly and subunit function.     

An essential protein-binding domain of nuclear RNase P RNA

Eukaryotic RNase P and RNase MRP are endoribonucleases composed of RNA and protein subunits. The RNA subunits of each enzyme share substantial secondary structural features, and most of the protein subunits are shared between the two. One of the conserved RNA subdomains, designated P3, has previously been shown to be required for nucleolar localization. Phylogenetic sequence analysis suggests that the P3 domain interacts with one of the proteins common to RNase P and RNase MRP, a conclusion strengthened by an earlier observation that the essential domain can be interchanged between the two enzymes. To examine possible functions of the P3 domain, four conserved nucleotides in the P3 domain of Saccharomyces cerevisiae RNase P RNA (RPR1) were randomized to create a library of all possible sequence combinations at those positions. Selection of functional genes in vivo identified permissible variations, and viable clones that caused yeast to exhibit conditional growth phenotypes were tested for defects in RNase P RNA and tRNA biosynthesis. Under nonpermissive conditions, the mutants had reduced maturation of the RPR1 RNA precursor, an expected phenotype in cases where RNase P holoenzyme assembly is defective. This loss of RPR1 RNA maturation coincided, as expected, with a loss of pre-tRNA maturation characteristic of RNase P defects. To test whether mutations at the conserved positions inhibited interactions with a particular protein, specific binding of the individual protein subunits to the RNA subunit was tested in yeast using the three-hybrid system. Pop1p, the largest subunit shared by RNases P and MRP, bound specifically to RPR1 RNA and the isolated P3 domain, and this binding was eliminated by mutations at the conserved P3 residues. These results indicate that Pop1p interacts with the P3 domain common to RNases P and MRP, and that this interaction is critical in the maturation of RNase P holoenzyme.