Biomass and Pigment Production in Three Isolates of Azolla II. Response to Light and Temperature Stress

Two isolates of Azolla caroliniana Willd. (RAR, M-3) and oneof Azolla filiculoides LAM. (LA) were compared and characterizedin defined growth environments. A moderate environment (200–230µ mol m^–2 S^–1, 18/6 h photoperiod and 26/22C thermoperiods) was selected to record growth in near-optimumconditions. All isolates doubled their fresh and dry weightsin approximately 2–3 d during the first week of trials.Acetylene reduction rates were low for all isolates, but RAR(from Amazonian Colombia) generally grew the fastest. RAR alsoaccumulated more chlorophyll, its chlorophyll doubling times(2.14 0.1 d) were 1–2 d faster than those of M-3 orLA, and it retained the most stable chlorophyll a/b ratios andtotal chlorophyll densities. Growth data for all isolates convergedduring the second week. Dry-weight doubling times were longerthan 3 d. None of the isolates excreted measureable amountsof nitrogen in month-long trials. Stress trials were conducted using high light (450–510µ mol m^–2 s^–1) and/or high temperature (35/31C conditions Biomass yields were usually least inhibited, ifat all, with elevation of only photon flux densities. High temperaturealone stimulated the dry-weight growth only of M-3 comparedwith its growth under moderate conditions. Biomass, chlorophyll,and acetylene reduction data suggested that M-3 may have a higheroptimum growth temperature than RAR or LA. The combined effectof light and temperature stress depressed acetylene reductionrates in RAR and M-3 to a greater extent than did either parameteralone. High light levels had more effect than high temperatures ininhibiting chlorophyll doubling times and inducing anthocyaninproduction in RAR and M-3. These two isolates did not form anyanthocyanin in elevated temperatures. Pre-incubation in darknessbefore exposure to elevated light/temperature conditions facilitatedanthocyanin production in all isolates. LA, however, provedto be the isolate most sensitive to stress by heat, alone oraugmented by light stress, according to all criteria used. Azolla caroliniana Willd., Azolla filiculoides Lam., biomass and chlorophyll accumulation, anthocyanin production, acetylene reduction, light/temperature stress     

Taxonomic re-evaluation of the Azolla genus in Portugal

ABSTRACT

The Portuguese and the European Flora refer to the presence of two or three Azolla species in Portugal: A. filiculoides Lam., A. caroliniana Willd. and/or Azolla mexicana Presl., the latter included in the last edition of Flora Europaea. In the present work, the taxonomy of Azolla species is reviewed using the two most important characters that can distinguish between these two/three species: papillae in the dorsal leaf lobe and perine architecture of the megaspore apparatus. Other characteristics, such as the hyaline border cells of the dorsal leaf lobes and the number of glochidia septa in microsporangium massulae, are also used. All the Azolla specimens, collected from several locations in Portugal, were identified as Azolla filiculoides Lam. This identification disagrees with previous published reports on Azolla taxonomy in Portugal as well as with herbarium identification.     

The growth of four species of Azolla as affected by temperature

The growth of 22 strains of Azolla pinnata R. Br., 3 strains of A. filiculoides Lam. and one strain each of A. mexicana Presl and A. caroliniana Willd. was tested separately in liquid culture media kept in controlled, artificial light (30 klux) growth cabinets. Three temperature levels were used: 33°C (37/29°C day/night), 29°C (33/25°C) and 22°C (26/18°C)/ Photoperiod was 12 h a day.For most A. pinnata strains (except three) and an A. mexicana strain the maximum weekly relative growth rate was higher at 33°C than at 22°C, but not for A. filiculoides and A. caroliniana. The highest value of maximum relative growth rate corresponded to 1.9 doubling days and in most strains this occurred in the first week. As the plants grew, the growth rate slowed down more severely at higher temperatures. The maximum biomass was higher at 22°C than at 33°C in all strains. At 22°C, it took 30–50 days to attain maximum biomass and the highest value was 14 g N m^?2 or 320 g dry m^?2 by A. caroliniana, followed by 12 g N m^?2 or 290 g dry wt. m^?2 by one strain of A. filiculoides. At 29°C, the maximum biomass was attained in 20–35 days. The highest value was 6.3 g N m^?2 or 154 g dry wt. m^?2 by A. caroliniana. At 33°C, most A. pinnata strains gave a maximum biomass of less than 4 g N m^?2 after 13–23 days, while some strains grew up to 30 days, resulting in a higher maximum biomass. The highest maximum biomass at 33°C was 5.5 g N m^?2 or 140 g m^?2 dry wt. by A. pinnata from Cheng Mai while the maximum biomass of A. filiculoides and A. caroliniana was much less. Azolla filiculoides requires lower temperature than other species for its growth. Azolla pinnata has the best tolerance to high temperatures among the four species. Azolla mexicana could not be discriminated from A. pinnata in its response to temperature. Azolla caroliniana may keep an intermediate position between A. filiculoides and A. pinnata in temperature response.The formation of ammonia in the medium was examined and it occurred mostly under stationary growth conditions, but, at 33°C, some strains of A. pinnata and A. mexicana released or formed ammonia at 0.3–0.8 μg N ml^?1 per week during their initial exponential growth stage.     

The Azolla, Anabaena azollae Relationship: II. Localization of Nitrogenase Activity as Assayed by Acetylene Reduction

Anaerobic (microaerophilic) acetylene reduction by Azolla caroliniana Willd. was dependent on light and saturated at approximately 450 foot candles. Maximum rates of acetylene reduction were 60 nmoles/mg chlorophyll minute. However, rates of 25 to 30 nmoles/mg chlorophyll minute were more common.     

Collection and Germination of Sporocarps of Azolla caroliniana

Azolla caroliniana Willd. with matured mega- and microsporocarpswere harvested from the field, sun dried and sieved to formballs of megasporocarps and massulae. The separated sporocarpswere tested for germination in different media in Petri dishesunder laboratory/greenhouse conditions. Only the swollen, greenmegasporocarps germinated. Nutrient medium was superior to asoil solution. The observed percentage germination was betteron a solid surface than in a liquid medium. Germination didnot occur with dark incubated sporocarps. The addition of phosphorusstimulated sporocarp germination and at a concentration of 30ppm, an 86% increase in germination was noted against the control.Percentage germination varied widely with pH, and optimum germinationwas recorded at a neutral pH. The effect of nitrogen sourceson sporocarp germination indicated that 70 ppm of nitrate, 7.5ppm of ammonium, 15 ppm of nitrite and 15 ppm of urea increasedgermination by 51, 66, 44 and 63%, respectively; further increasesin concentration inhibited germination. Treatment with 100 ppmof either kinetin or gibberellic acid, or a mixture of both,enhanced germination by 67, 55 and 84%, respectively. Azolla caroliniana Willd., sporocarp collection, germination     

Differential response ofAzolla microphylla kaulf. andAzolla filiculoides Lam. to sodium fluoride

We assessed the differential response ofAzolla microphylla andAzolla filiculoides to fluoride stress by growing them in culture media containing 1 to 50 ppm sodium fluoride (NaF).A microphylla had a higher total chlorophyll content thanA. filiculoides. Both species showed gradual decreases in protein content as the concentration of NaF increased.A. microphylla accumulated less proline thanA. filiculoides when more NaF was added to the culture medium. For all concentrations tested, the amount of residual fluoride in the nutrient media that supportedA. microphylla was higher than in the nutrient media used for growingA. filiculoides.     

High Concentrations of Ammonium Ions at Low pH Decrease the Number of Cyanobionts in Apical Portions of Azolla

When Azolla plants (Azolla filiculoides vax.japonica) were grownin media with high concentrations of ammonium ions at pH 3.5,numbers of cyanobionts in apical portions were very much reduced.Microscopic observations revealed that cyanobionts in theseplants were preferentially damaged, with resultant death andlysis. (Received August 2, 1991; Accepted December 27, 1991)     

Adaptation of exotic Azolla to tropical environment of Thailand

There are seven known species of Azolla, two of which have been used in cultivated systems, the tropical speciesA. pinnata, and the temperate speciesA. filiculoides. OnlyA. pinnata is indigenous in Thailand. In this study the two exotic species,A. caroliniana andA. microphylla, were evaluated under the various tropical field conditions in Thailand. When compared with seven selected strains ofA. pinnata under three field conditions,A. caroliniana andA. microphylla were similar to the indigenous species, in terms of growth performance, N₂ fixation, and yield. This study suggests thatA. caroliniana andA. microphylla can be successfully cultivated as a nitrogen fixing green manure for rice production in the tropics.     

The Azolla, Anabaena azollae Relationship: I. Initial Characterization of the Association

Cultures of Azolla caroliniana Willd. free of the symbiotic blue-green alga, Anabaena azollae, were obtained by treatment of Azolla fronds with a regimen of antibiotics. These symbiontfree plants can be maintained only on medium containing a combined nitrogen source.     

The effects of floating mats of Azolla filiculoides Lam. and Lemna minuta Kunth on the growth of submerged macrophytes

In laboratory experiments, the growth characteristics of the submerged species Elodea nuttallii (Planch.) St. John and Potamogeton crispus L. were assessed in the presence and absence of floating mats of Azolla filiculoides Lam. and Lemna minuta Kunth. Light penetration and the development of pH and dissolved oxygen differences were monitored. The growth of P. crispus was suppressed much more than that of E. nuttallii and the effects of A. filiculoides were more severe than those of L. minuta. Findings are related to possible field responses of submerged plants under floating mats, especially their abilities to compensate for the potential suppressive effects of floating mats under natural conditions.     

Effects of sodium dodecyl sulphate on the aquatic macrophytes Azolla and Lemna

Abstract

In this work, we determined the tolerance to sodium dodecyl sulphate (SDS) of Azolla filiculoides and of Lemna minor. The presence of the detergent in the media affected growth more than the chlorophyll content. On the basis of the effect indices, Lemna is more tolerant to SDS than Azolla. The fern had a better capacity, compared with duckweed, to remove and accumulate the pollutant.     

Comparison of main emissions at--196?C from phycobilisomes of two blue-green algae Anabaena cylindrica and Anacystis nidulans

Main emissions at—196?C from phycobilisomes of two blue-greenalgae Anabaena cylindrica and Anacystis nidulans were studiedwith special reference to allophycocyanin (APC) B content. Supplementaryexperiments were done with Anabaena variabilis (M-2 and M-3).The main emission from phycobilisome of Anacystis nidulans richin APC B was located at 681 nm. The location was identical tothat of the main emission from APC B but at a shorter wavelengththan that of in vivo emission (685 nm). Results indicate thatAPC B acts as the energy output of phycobilisomes, but thatthe in vivo 685 nm emission is not attributed to APC B. The main emission of the phycobilisome of Anabaena cylindricawas always located at 685 nm irrespective of the preparationmethod; 0.75 M phosphate buffer [Plant Physiol., 63: 615–620(1979)] or 30% polyethylene glycol [Special Issue of Plant &Cell Physiol., No. 3, p. 23–31 (1977)]. This alga alsocontained a special form of APC, but its content was very low.The location of its emission band (681 nm) was identical tothat of APC B, but shorter than that of the main band of phycobilisomes(685 nm). The 685 nm emitter in phycobilisomes showed a charactersimilar to chlorophyll a but not phycobiliproteins in treatmentsfor aqueous extraction or methanol extraction. Results indicatethat the pigment is probably chlorophyll a as we assumed previously.The 685 nm emission from phycobilisomes of Anabaena variabilis(M-2 and M-3) showed the same character. Results were interpreted as indicating that (i) the contentof the special form of APC varies with the species or strainof blue-green algae and (ii) the energy at the phycobilin levelis transferred directly from APC to pigment system II chlorophylla when the amount of the special form of APC is low. (Received October 24, 1979; )     

The supraspecific taxonomy and evolution of the fern genusAzolla (Azollaceae)

The systematics of the aquatic fern genusAzolla Lam. is revised at the supraspecific level. Published morphological data are reviewed, and cytological and cladistic analyses of the genus conducted, enabling a discussion of the putative evolutionary trends in the genus, and a revision of the current taxonomy. A phylogenetically more acceptable subgeneric and sectional classification is proposed, viz. subg.Azolla sect.Azolla (comprisingA. filiculoides Lam.,A. rubra R. Br.,A caroliniana auct. nonWilld.,A. microphylla auct. nonKaulf. andA. mexicana Presl), subg.Azolla sect.Rhizosperma (Mey.)Mett. (comprisingA. pinnata R. Br.), and subg.Tetrasporocarpia subg. nov. (comprisingA. nilotica Decne. exMett.).     

Outdoor mass culture ofAzolla spp.: yields and efficiencies of nitrogen fixation

Summary The productivity of three species of Azolla (A. pinnata, A. filiculoides andA. caroliniana) in outdoor culture has been evaluated at different planting densities. The highest yields were obtained with biomass concentration ranging from 40 to 70g d.w. m^–2. The mean productivity over a 90 days period (from May 10th to August 10th) ranged from 10g d.w. m^–2 day^–1 forA. filiculoides up to 11.5 g d.w. m^–2 day^–1 forA. caroliniana. The nitrogen content of the dried biomasses was 48.3 mg (g d.w.)^–1 forA. pinnata, 51.5mg (g d.w.)^–1 forA. filiculoides and 52.3 mg (g d.w.)^–1 forA. caroliniana. Very little variations of the nitrogen content of the ferns during the experimental period were observed.The nitrogen-fixing efficiency of the Azolla-Anabaena azollae symbiosis grown in outdoor conditions was evaluated both by direct measurement of the amount of N₂ fixed by the culture and by the C₂H₂-reduction and H₂-evolution tests in an air atmosphere. These tests were performed outdoor under the same environmental conditions as the growing cultures. For all the species the ratios of C₂H₂-reduced to N₂-fixed were unexpectedly low, ranging from 2.04 (A. pinnata) to 1.50 (A. caroliniana).The results suggest that the reliability of the C₂H₂-reduction assay, particularly when applied to complex biological N₂-fixing systems, must be re-examined.     

Characterization and comparisons of five N2-fixing Azolla-Anabaena associations,I. Optimization of growth conditions for biomass increase and N content in a controlled environment*

Abstract Biomass increase, C and N content, C₂H₂ reduction, percentage dry weight and chlorophyll a/b ratios were determined for clones of Azolla caroliniana Willd., A. filiculoides Lam., A. mexicana Presl., and A. pinnata R. Br. as a function of nutrient solution, pH, temperature, photoperiod, and light intensity in controlled environment studies. These studies were supplemented by a glasshouse study. Under a 16 h, 26°C day at a light intensity of 200 μmol m^?2 s^?1 and an 8 h, 19° C dark period, there was no significant difference in the growth rates of the individual species on the five nutrient solutions employed. Growth was comparable from pH 5 to pH 8, but decreased at pH 9. Using the same photoperiod and light intensity but constant growth temperatures of 15–40°C, at 5°C intervals, the individual species exhibited maximum growth, nitro-genase (N²ase) activity and N content at either 25° or 30°C. There was no difference in the temperature optima at pH 6 and pH 8. The tolerance of the individual species to elevated temperature was indicated to be A. mexicana> A. pinnata> A. caroliniana> A.filiculoides. At the optimum temperature, growth rates increased with increasing photoperiod at both pH 6 and pH 8 but N₂ase activity was usually highest at a 16 h light period. At photon flux densities of 100, 200, 400 and 600 μmol m^?2 s^?1, during a 16 h light period and optimum growth temperature of the individual species, N₂ase activity was saturated at less than 200 μmol m^?2 s^?1 and growth at 400 μmol m^?2 s^?1.No interacting effects of light and pH were noted for any species, nor were light intensities up to 1700 μmol m^?2 s^?1 detrimental to the growth rate or N content of any species in a 5 week glasshouse study with a natural 14.5 h light period and a constant temperature of 27.5°C. Using the optimum growth temperature, a 16 h light period, and a photon flux density of at least 400 μmol m^?2 s^?1, the Azolla species all doubled their biomass in 2 days or less and contained 5–6% N on a dry weight basis.     

Alteration in growth and thylakoid membrane lipid composition of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Azolla caroliniana</Emphasis> under phosphate deficiency

The changes in the fresh biomass accumulation, photosynthetic and anthocyanin pigments, photosystem 2 (PS 2) activity, ultrastructure of chloroplast, total lipids and fatty acid composition of thylakoid membrane were followed in the aquatic fern Azolla caroliniana grown on medium either deficient or supplied with various phosphorus concentrations. The content of photosynthetic pigments and the anthocyanin/chlorophyll ratio increased significantly with increasing PO₄ ³⁻ concentration. Phosphate deficiency inhibited growth and PS 2 activity and decreased content of total lipids and phospholipids in isolated thylakoids. This was accompanied with a significant increase in the percentage of galalactolipids.     

The response of rice to the growth and nitrogen fixation inAzolla caroliniana andAzolla pinnata at varying rates of phosphate fertilization

The response of rice toAzolla caroliniana, newly introduced in India, was compared with the reponse to the local isolate ofAzolla pinnata at varying rates of phosphate fertilizer (4.4–8.8 kg P ha^–1) during a wet and a dry season.Fresh weight, dry weight and fixed N were more for both species 21 DAI (days after inoculation) than 14 DAI, but acetylene reduction activity (ARA) was higher 14 DAI than 21 DAI. Dry weight of Azolla and fixed N were less 14 DAI forA. caroliniana than forA. pinnata during the wet season. Twenty-one DAI, fresh weight ofA. caroliniana was 62.1 and 27.6% higher than that ofA. pinnata during the wet and dry season, respectively. However, dry weight and fixed N were more 21 DAI inA. caroliniana than inA. pinnata during only the wet season. The ARA was higher inA. caroliniana both 14 and 21 DAI, irrespective of season. The presence of either species in the rice field increased grain yield, straw yield, number of panicles m^–2, number of grains per panicle and reduced percentage sterility during both the wet and the dry season. Phosphate application significantly increased fresh weight, dry weight, ARA and fixed N for both species as well as grain and straw yields of rice. The responses to phosphate fertilizer were similar for both Azolla species and for rice grown with either one of the Azolla species.     

Differential response of antioxidant enzymes to salinity stress in two varieties of Azolla (Azolla pinnata and Azolla filiculoides)

The activity and modulation of antioxidant components were comparatively analyzed in two varieties of Azolla (Azolla pinnata and Azolla filiculoides) under different concentrations of NaCl. The total superoxide dismutase (SOD) and ascorbate peroxidase (APX) activity increased in A. pinnata, whereas both enzyme activities decreased in A. filiculoides. The plants of A. pinnata exposed to 30 mM NaCl contained a lower amount of Na⁺ ions and showed a lower electrolyte leakage than A. filiculoides. Our studies indicate a differential response of antioxidant enzymes in relation to salt tolerance in Azolla plants. On the basis of our comparative analysis, A. pinnata has been ranked salt tolerant as compared with A. filiculoides, which is salt sensitive.     

Amino acid composition of azolla as affected by strains and population density

The total nitrogen and amino acid composition of seven Azolla strains were compared at four different growth phases. Total nitrogen content of the individual strains ranged from 2.6% to 5.7% of dry matter and was not significantly influenced by growth phase or population density. The concentration of the sixteen amino acids determined was maximal during the linear growth stage and specific differences occurred among Azolla strains. AnAzolla microphylla strain was the best source of amino acids and anA. filiculoides strain the poorest under the cultural conditions used. The chemical index score demonstrated the potential of some species, such as theA. microphylla strain, as contributor of protein for animals. Strains of other species, such asA. filiculoides, had several limiting amino acids and appear more suited for use solely as a green manure. All Azolla strains contained a similar proportion of essential (55%) and non-essential (45%) amino acids. Leucine, lysine, arginine and phenylanine+tyrosine were the predominant essential amino acids whereas the sulfur containing amino acids (methionine and cystine) were present in smaller amounts.     

Use of Azolla as a test organism in a growth chamber of simple design

Summary The construction and application of a new type of growth chamber, in which different growth conditionsi.e.: temperature, humidity, pH, light intensity, light colour, change in nutrient composition and gas exchange can easily be controlled, are presented. The method has previously been applied to twoAzolla speciesviz. Azolla filiculoides, which is cold tolerant andAzolla pinnata (distinguished in Vietnam as the form Xanh), which is heat tolerant. In the growth chamber natural growth conditions of the Azolla —Anabaena azollae symbiotic association were imitated as much as possible. For testing the system, methods discussed earlier^8,14 and some previously presented data, concerning photosynthetic activities, such as oxygen evolution and nitrogen fixation (acetylene reduction) of twoAzolla species³⁹, were partially used. Biomass ofA. filiculoides was measured and reactions to its environment at conditions when grown in the field and in the growth chamber, were studied. Growth and photosynthesis measurements were performed under special light conditions and with whole plants grown under laboratory conditions. Anthocyanin synthesis was studied in relation with humidity. Anthocyanin spectra were analyzed by means of a spectrum-deconvolution method. On leave from the Department of Plant Physiology of the University of Hanoi, Vietnam.