Grazing of bacteria and phytoplankton by heterotrophic nanoflagellates in a Baltic Sea sample

Grazing by heterotrophic nanoflagellates on bacteria and phytoplankton was studied in a laboratory experiment, using a natural pelagic community originating from the Tvärminne sea area off the southern coast of Finland. Water was prescreened to remove larger grazers. Four experimental treatments were used: light and dark, with and without added nutrients. The growth of the large heterotrophic flagellates was stimulated by increased production of < 3 m phytoplankton. Clearance rates for heterotrophic nanoflagellates were estimated and were found to be within the range of previously reported values.     

8 Grazing by heterotrophic nanoflagellates on virus- and bacteria-sized particles in two lakes of different trophy

Although viruses are now widely recognized to infect aquatic bacteria as well as prokaryotic and eukaryotic phytoplankton, our understanding of how they fit into aquatic foodwebs remains still deficient. The present study examined the potential nutritional food source that viral particles represent for natural assemblages of heterotrophic nanoflagellates (HNF). We determined the seasonal and depth-related variability in the grazing activity of HNF on virus- and bacteria-sized particles in the oligomesotrophic Lake Pavin and the eutrophic Lake Aydat. Ingestion rates were determined using 50 and 500 nm diameter fluorescent microspheres. Estimated ingestion rates ranged from 0.01 to 1.7 viruses cell⁻¹·h⁻¹ (Aydat) and from 0.01 to 2 viruses cell⁻¹·h⁻¹ (Pavin). Derived clearance rates for viruses represented 3–5% (Aydat) and 10–12% (Pavin) of those for bacteria. In general, HNF grazing on both viruses and bacteria showed a similar pattern characterized by an apparent decrease in summer followed by autumnal peaks, with lowest values always being recorded in the hypolimnion. Viral production, estimated from the frequency of visibly infected cells (using transmission electronic microscopy), was consumed by HNF at rates averaging 2% (Aydat) and 10% (Pavin). This study suggests that, viruses, which are assumed to correspond to 1×10⁻⁷ ng C/particle, are likely to be of low nutritive value for HNF in both lakes. However, these results imply that HNF grazing may contribute significantly to the removal of viruses in freshwaters, especially in low productive systems.     

The densities of bacteria, picophytoplankton, heterotrophic nanoflagellates and ciliates in Lake Kasumigaura (Japan) monitored monthly since 1996

This data paper describes the densities of the bacterioplankton, picocyanobacteria, eukaryotic picoplankton, heterotrophic nanoflagellates and ciliates in the water of Lake Kasumigaura??a shallow, eutrophic lake that is the second largest in Japan. All of these planktonic organisms are components of a microbial loop and are countable using an epifluorescence microscope. These data represent the results of monthly collections from April 1996 through March 2010 at two sites on the lake, and this data set is unique among the available published data papers concerning lakes or plankton and continues to be freely available. The monitoring was performed as a component of the Lake Kasumigaura Long-term Environmental Monitoring program conducted by National Institute for Environmental Studies since 1977 and includes water quality, plankton, and benthos. The data have been used for ecological studies and for studies on the management of water quality.     

Grazing impact of heterotrophic dinoflagellates and ciliates on common red-tide euglenophyte Eutreptiella gymnastica in Masan Bay, Korea

The euglenophyte Eutreptiella gymnastica is a common red tide causative species. However, there have been no studies on the grazing impact of heterotrophic protists on this species. To investigate the grazing impact of heterotrophic protists on E. gymnastica, we measured daily the abundances of E. gymnastica and co-occurring potential heterotrophic protistan grazers in Masan Bay, Korea, in August 2004 when an E. gymnastica red tide occurred. In addition, we tested whether the common heterotrophic dinoflagellates Gyrodinium dominans, Oxyrrhis marina, Pfiesteria piscicida, Polykrikos kofoidii, Protoperidinium bipes, and Stoeckeria algicida and the naked ciliates Strobilidium sp. (30–40 μm in cell length) and Strombidinopsis sp. (70–100 μm in cell length) were able to feed on E. gymnastica. We also measured their growth and ingestion rates on E. gymnastica as a function of prey concentration. Finally, we calculated the grazing coefficients by combining field data on the abundance of the heterotrophic dinoflagellate and ciliate grazers and co-occurring E. gymnastica with laboratory data on ingestion rates obtained in this study. The maximum abundance of E. gymnastica in Masan Bay in August, 2004 was 7575 cells ml⁻¹, while those of Gyrodinium spp., P. kofoidii, P. bipes, the naked ciliates (≤50 μm in cell length), and naked ciliates (>50 μm in cell length) were 50, 9, 58, 32, and 3 cells ml⁻¹, respectively. The maximum growth rate of G. dominans on E. gymnastica (1.13 d⁻¹) was higher than that of O. marina (0.81 d⁻¹) or P. bipes (0.77 d⁻¹). However, E. gymnastica did not support positive growth of P. kofoidii, Strobilidium sp., and Strombidinopsis sp. (−0.04 ∼ −2.8 d⁻¹). The maximum ingestion rates of G. dominans, P. kofoidii, P. bipes, O. marina, and Strobilidium sp. on E. gymnastica (2.1–2.7 ng C predator⁻¹ d⁻¹) were similar, but they were much lower than that of Strombidinopsis sp. (156 ng C predator⁻¹ d⁻¹). The calculated grazing coefficients for P. bipes, small heterotrophic Gyrodinium spp. (25–35 μm in cell length), naked ciliates (≤50 μm in cell length), P. kofoidii, and naked ciliates (>50 μm in cell length) on E. gymnastica were up to 0.77, 0.61, 0.22, 0.07 and 0.03 d⁻¹, respectively (i.e., up to 54%, 46%, 20%, 7%, and 3% of E. gymnastica populations were removed by the population of each of these heterotrophic protistan grazers in 1 d, respectively). The results of the present study suggest that P. bipes, small heterotrophic Gyrodinium spp., and naked ciliates (≤50 μm in cell length) sometimes have considerable potential grazing impact on the populations of E. gymnastica.     

Growth and production of heterotrophic nanoflagellates in a meso-eutrophic lake

The growth of heterotrophic nanoflagellates (HNF) in mesotrophicLake Constance was measured in situ during a 13 month period.Experiments were conducted with 10 µm pre-filtered lakewater incubated in diffusion chambers at 3 m water depth atthe sampling location for 24 h. Growth rates were calculatedfrom changes in cell numbers occurring during the period ofincubation. Growth rates of all dominant taxa showed pronouncedseasonal variation (–0.13 to 1.76 day^–1 and weregenerally highest in summer at high water temperatures. In situgrowth rates were well below maximum growth rates known forthe respective and similar species from laboratory experiments.While water temperature was a key parameter positively relatedto the growth of all HNF species, the effect of various potentialfood items was taxon specific and less clear. Bacterial abundancewas equally important as temperature for growth in the smallbactenvorous Spumella sp., but was insignificant for growthrates of the larger omnivorous Kathablepharis sp. In Spuniellasp., 84% of the observed seasonal variation of its growth ratecould be explained by temperature and bacterial food supply.Based on these results, a multiple linear regression equationwith temperature and bacterial concentration as dependent variableswas calculated for the growth rate of Spumella. Taxon-specificproduction rates were derived from growth rates and averagebiomass of these two species, and compared to total HNF productionestimated from previously measured community growth rates andbiomass in Lake Constance. Production peaks of Spumella sp.and Kathablepharis sp. alternated seasonally. Total HINF productionranged from –0.01 to 10 mg C m^–3 day^–1. Theaverage seasonal production varied between 1.4 and 33 mg C m^–3day^–1 over 6 consecutive years. These small protozoa thuscontribute a substantial amount to total zooplankton productionin Lake Constance.     

Differential grazing of two heterotrophic nanoflagellates on marine Synechococcus strains

Grazing of heterotrophic nanoflagellates on marine picophytoplankton presents a major mortality factor for this important group of primary producers. However, little is known of the selectivity of the grazing process, often merely being thought of as a general feature of cell size and motility. In this study, we tested grazing of two heterotrophic nanoflagellates, Paraphysomonas imperforata and Pteridomonas danica , on strains of marine Synechococcus . Both nanoflagellates proved to be selective in their grazing, with Paraphysomonas being able to grow on 5, and Pteridomonas on 11, of 37 Synechococcus strains tested. Additionally, a number of strains (11 for Paraphysomonas , 9 for Pteridomonas ) were shown to be ingested, but not digested (and thus did not support growth of the grazer). Both the range of prey strains that supported growth as well as those that were ingested but not digested was very similar for the two grazers, suggesting a common property of these prey strains that lent them susceptible to grazing. Subsequent experiments on selected Synechococcus strains showed a pronounced difference in grazing susceptibility between wild-type Synechococcus sp. WH7803 and a spontaneous phage-resistant mutant derivative, WH7803PHR, suggesting that cell surface properties of the Synechococcus prey are an important attribute influencing grazing vulnerability.     

Grazing of attached bacteria by heterotrophic microflagellates

Four species of heterotrophic microflagellates were examined for their ability to graze attached and unattached bacteria. The species tested displayed pronounced differences in their ability to graze the bacteriumPseudomonas halodurans attached to chitin particles. Two species of microflagellates (Monas andCryptobia sp.) efficiently grazed unattached bacteria but showed little or no ability to graze attached or aggregated cells. In contrast,Rhynchomonas nasuta andBodo sp. showed marked preferences for attached and aggregated bacteria and a limited ability to graze unattached cells. The density of attached bacteria was reduced by an order of magnitude due to grazing byBodo andR. nasuta, even though the density of unattached bacteria was 5–90× the density of attached cells. The maximum densities attained by microflagellates in the cultures were related to the density of unattached bacteria forMonas andCryptobia but not forBodo andR. nasuta. Growth of the latter two species appeared to be related to the density of attached or aggregated bacteria. Based on the results of these experiments, it is concluded that the pelagic existence of microflagellates that graze attached bacteria may be strongly linked to the distribution of suspended particles and their associated bacteria. In addition, the removal of attached bacteria by microflagellates can significantly affect the density of bacteria attached to particles in the plankton. This activity may have important implications for the controversy concerning the relative importance of attached and free-living bacteria in the plankton.     

Photosynthetic efficiency and seasonality of autotrophic picoplankton in Lago Maggiore after its recovery

1. Lago Maggiore is a deep subalpine lake that has regained its previous oligotrophic state during the last decade after going through a process of cultural eutrophication and subsequent restoration. Autotrophic picoplankton (APP) have been studied in Lago Maggiore since 1992, with the primary production of the fraction being measured in 1994 and 1995. In 1998, we began to study the population structure and photosynthetic characteristics of APP after the restoration of the lake. We also compared the seasonal dynamics of APP and nanoplankton biomass and production. In this paper, we show the trend of annual and interannual dynamics of APP from 1993 to 1998. 2. Since 1993 and 1994, APP have almost tripled in numbers (mean values: 1993=44 × 10³ cell mL^–1 1998=123 × 10³ cell mL^–1) and in production. On average, APP produced 16 gC m^–2 year^–1 in 1994 and 41.2 gC m^–2 year^–1 in 1998, accounting for 10 and 20%, respectively, of total phototrophic production. 3. Although nanoplankton dominated in terms of biomass and production in the first 6 months of the year, APP were able to compete successfully with them in periods of P limitation. In September 1998, APP carbon fixation actually surpassed that of nanoplankton, reaching 13 mgC m^–3 h^–1 at 3 m. In a comparison of the daily chlorophyll‐specific photosynthesis rates of nanoplankton and APP, the latter proved to be more efficient in fixing carbon, particularly in summer and autumn. 4. While the spatial distribution of APP abundance and production followed the isotherms of 18 and 20 °C, and was strictly related to water stratification and thermocline appearance, the APP efficiency [mgC (mg chl)^–1Em^–2] had its maximum at the bottom of the euphotic zone, with irradiance in the range 0.5–18 μE m^–2 s^–1. 5. The existence of a significant regression between APP abundance and carbon fixation (P < 0.001, r²=0.92, d.f.=17; APP_prod=10.6 × 10³ cell mL^–1 + 15) enabled us to infer APP production from cell numbers, and supports the view that picocyanobacteria production is closely dependent on its standing crop. 6. Lago Maggiore is a good example of how APP in a stabilised oligotrophic system can, under favourable conditions, increase in numbers and effectively exploit the few available resources. We can conclude that the APP population reacts to the reduction in P‐levels, but only after several years of stable low nutrient conditions.     

Effects of UV radiation on grazing by two marine heterotrophic nanoflagellates on autotrophic picoplankton

Phytoplankton <4-3 µm in diameter, or autotrophic picoplankton,can constitute the majority of the biomass and productivityof photosynthetic organisms in marine and freshwater systems.Indirect evidence has indicated that mortality of autotrophicpicoplankton occurs principally at night in the open ocean,but continuously in coastal water. The predominant view of thefate of autotrophic picoplankton production in the ocean isthat they are consumed by heterotrophic nanoflagellates. A possiblemechanism to explain these observations is that grazing of heterotrophicnanoflagellates on autotrophic picoplankton is inhibited byultraviolet radiation (W), at least in clear open-ocean environments.A series of laboratory experiments was conducted to examinethe effects of UV radiation on the grazing impact of two heterotrophicnanoflagellates on Synechococcus spp., a commonly occurringgenus of autotrophic picoplankton. The two nanoflagellates usedwere Paraphysomonas bandaieensis and Paraphysomonas imperforata.For both nanoflagellates, there was an inverse relationshipbetween the grazing mortality of Synechococcus and UV irradiance.The grazing mortality of Synechococcus was reduced less withP.imperforata than with P.bandaiensis. In some experiments,the effect of UV on the grazing impact of the nanoflagellatepopulations was caused in part by UV-related reductions in nanoflagellatesurvival. However, UV reduced the grazing impact of nanoflagellatesprimarily by reducing the rates of consumption of Synechococcusby individual nanoflagellates, to a degree directly relatedto UV irradiance. The results suggat that UV radiation may bean important selection factor in clear open-ocean water, andthat in order to predict the effect of increasing UV radiationon marine microbial plankton communities, we must consider interactionsbetween trophic levels as well as effects on single trophiclevels.     

Particle handling during interception feeding by four species of heterotrophic nanoflagellates

High resolution video-microscopy was used to observe grazing patterns of the heterotrophic nanoflagellates Cafeteria roenbergensis, Bodo saltans, Spumella sp., and Ochromonas sp. Spumella and Ochromonas enclose food particles with pseudopodia while Cafeteria and Bodo engulf particles by invagination of the cell surface. The following parameters of the feeding process were quantified: frequency of flagellar beating, speed of particles in different positions of the feeding current, food size selection, feeding rate, and the time budget for the handling of particles. The mean handling times differed between 94 s for Cafeteria and 4 s for Ochromonas for ingested particles. Handling times for ingested particles were significantly longer than for non-captured particles. Long handling times were calculated to be disadvantageous only for flagellates which propel a high water volume per hour (esp. Ochromonas) or live in a bacteria-rich environment. Our model calculations may provide a reasonable theoretical explanation for a concentration-dependent behavioural variability of the feeding strategy of different heterotrophic nanoflagellates (HNF) species.     

Phytoplankton assemblage at equilibrium in large and deep subalpine lakes: a case study from Lago Maggiore (N. Italy)

In 1996, we studied the phytoplankton seasonal succession in Lago Maggiore (N. Italy) through weekly sampling. Such a frequency enabled us to evaluate the changes of the phytoplankton assemblage in the light of the equilibrium and non-equilibrium theories. The distinct phases of changing of the species composition were identified separating the samples by means of cluster analysis and non-metric multidimensional scaling (NMDS). We recognised well distinct phytoplankton associations, whose seasonal succession followed a clear cyclic path throughout the year, with spring and summer phases respectively characterised by a rapid turn-over of the assemblages and by a relative stability. Moreover, we observed an increase of species number and Shannon-Wiener diversity during the spring, followed by a summer decline of the diversity in spite of an unchanged species number. Because of the dominance of the same few species for about two months during summer, coupled with small fluctuations of the total biomass, we could identify the summer assemblage as a steady state assemblage. The aim of the present contribution, although describing the whole seasonal succession, is to draw the attention towards the species composition at the steady state, taking into account the functional properties of the species involved. The possible role of the metalimnetic niche in selecting a particular summer assemblage in deep and large lakes will be discussed.     

Seasonal dynamics of crustacean zooplankton, heterotrophic nanoflagellates and bacteria in a shallow, eutrophic lake

1. The seasonal development of crustacean zooplankton, heterotrophic nanoflagellates (HNF) and bacteria was examined in Grosser Binnensee, a shallow, eutrophic lake in northern Germany. The grazing impact of Daphnia on bacteria and nanoflagellates was estimated from field data on population abundances and from clearance rates obtained in laboratory experiments. 2. The seasonal succession of zooplankton showed distinct peaks of Daphnia magna, cyclopopid copepods, Bosmina longirostris and Daphnia galeata and D. hynlina. The population dynamics of Dapfinia had the strongest impact on all sestonic components. Daphnia maxima coincided with clearwater phases, and were negatively correlated with particulate organic carbon (POC), HNF and phytoplankton. Bacterial abundance was only slightly affected although daphnids were at times more important as bacterial consumers than HNF, as estimated from measured bacterial clearance rates. Other crustaceans (copepods, Bosmina) were probably of minor importance as grazers of bacteria and nanoplankton. 3. HNF abundance varied from 550 ml^?1 to more than 30000 ml^?1. HNF appeared to be suppressed by daphnids and reached highest densities when copepods dominated the metazooplankton. The variation in HNF abundance was not reflected in the concentration of heterotrophic bacteria, which fluctuated rather irregularly between 5 and 20 ± 10⁶ ml^?1. Long filamentous bacteria which were probably resistant to protozoan grazing, however, appeared parallel to the development of HNF. These bacterial cells, although small in number, could comprise more than 30% of the total bacterial biomass.     

Trophic relationships between planktonic bacteria,heterotrophic nanoflagellates and viruses in a mesoeutrophic reservoir

The abundance, biomass, and production (Р _В) of bacrerioplankton; the taxonomic composition, abundance, biomass of heterotrophic nanoflagellates (HNF) and the rate of consumption of bacteria by HNFs; and the abundance of virioplankton, frequency of visibly infected bacterial cells, virus-induced mortality of bacterioplankton, and viral production were estimated in the mesoeutrophic Rybinsk Reservoir. The rate of bacterial mortality due to viral lysis (7.8–34.1%, on average 17.2 ± 2.0% of daily Р _В) was lower than the consumption of bacteria by the HNF community (15.4–61.3%, on average 32.0 ± 4.2% of daily Р _В). While consuming bacteria, HNFs simultaneously absorbed a significant number of viruses residing on the surface and inside the bacterial cells.     

Seasonal dynamics of free and attached heterotrophic nanoflagellates in an oligomesotrophic lake

1. The seasonal development of heterotrophic nanoflagellates (HNF), bacteria, rotiferans and crustacean zooplankton was studied in the epilimnion of Lake Pavin, an oligomesotrophic lake in the Massif Central of France.
2. HNF abundance varied from 0.1 to 2.5 × 10³ mL^–1. Free-living HNF reached their highest density in spring when the copepod Acanthodiaptomus denticornis dominated the metazooplankton. They were present in low numbers when rotifers and cladocerans were numerous.
3. Attached HNF, consisting of bicoecids and choanoflagellates, were fixed to large diatoms and to the colonial cyanobacterium Anabaena flos-aquae . The abundance of attached HNF was significantly correlated to bacterial abundance, which fluctuated between 1.1 and 2.7 × 10⁶ mL^–1. Highest abundance of these epiphytic protists was recorded when free-living heterotrophic nanoflagellates declined.
4. The comparison of the dynamics of heterotrophic nanoflagellates, bacteria, and the impact of zooplankton grazing suggested that prey abundance, the presence of suitable attachment sites and limited competition from the free-living forms were the main factors controlling the development of the epiphytic flagellate protists. In contrast, the low abundance of free-living forms during the period of rotiferan and cladoceran development suggests the prevalence of a top-down control by predation of the metazoopankton.     

Changes in cell volume of bacteria and heterotrophic nanoflagellates in a hypereutrophic pond

Changes in cell volume of planktonic bacteria and heterotrophic nanoflagellates (HNF) were examined in a hypereutrophic pond from April to October, 1997. There were marked changes in the abundance of bacteria, HNF and ciliates and in protistan bacterivory during this period. The cell volume of free-living bacteria (0.121 ± 0.031 m³, mean ± SD) was large relative to that reported in the literature. The cell volumes of HNF was 71.1 ± 24.8 m³. Both cell volumes did not follow a seasonal trend. The dominant size class of bacteria was seasonally variable, whereas density of filamentous bacteria was relatively high between August and September. Biomass of filamentous bacteria accounted for up to 33.6% of total bacterial biomass. A correlation analysis for cell volume of bacteria and HNF, density of filamentous bacteria and some microbial variates was performed. The positive correlations detected (p<0.05) were between density of bacteria and cell volume of HNF, and between density of filamentous bacteria and cell volume of HNF.     

The long history of Cannabis and its cultivation by the Romans in central Italy, shown by pollen records from Lago Albano and Lago di Nemi

The cores from the Albano and Nemi lakes, near Rome, were studied within the European Union funded PALICLAS project and provided high resolution records of the Late-glacial and Holocene. Pollen evidence of increasing human influence on vegetation was recorded in the Holocene parts of both diagrams, and the Cannabis (hemp) curve was one of the major signs. In this paper we present unambiguous pollen evidence from the Cannabaceae records for the cultivation of hemp in central Italy by the Romans. The oldest records of Cannabis and Humulus (hop) date from to the Late-glacial. Hop pollen values rise during the mid Holocene, while hemp pollen becomes more abundant from ca. 3000 cal B.P. onwards. The highest earliest hemp peak (21%) is dated to the 1st century A.D. This ‘Cannabis phase’, with the abrupt rise of hemp pollen soon after the rise of cultivated trees (Castanea, Juglans and Olea) is associated with the increase in cereals and ruderal plants. This unambiguous proof of cultivation by Romans around 2000 B.P. occurs as well as a long lasting pre-Roman presence of hemp in the area, which is natural and possibly also anthropogenic. Subsequent clear episodes of cultivation in the medieval period were found. Received February 4, 2002 / Accepted September 13, 2002 Correspondence to: Anna Maria Mercuri, e-mail: mercuri.annamaria@unimo.it     

The dynamics of heterotrophic nanoflagellates and bacterioplankton in a large ultra-oligotrophic Antarctic lake

The abundance of both heterotrophic nanoflagellates (HNAN) andbacterioplankton in a large (9km²) ultraoligotrophic Antarcticlake (Crooked Lake) were investigated from December 1992 untilNovember 1993. HNAN abundance peaked in spring, summer and autumn,falling to lowest numbers during the winter. Numbers rangedbetween 0 and 50.9x10⁴ l^–1. Bacterioplankton abundancewas highest during the late summer and then fell progressivelytowards winter and autumn (range 1.19–4.46x10⁶ l^–1)In contrast to numbers, mean cell volumes (MCV) of the bacteriareached their highest in spring, and consequently highest bacterialbiomass occurred at this time. MCV ranged between 0.052 and0.224µm³. Bacterial production measurements followingthe incorporation of [³H] thymidine into DNA and [¹⁴C] leucineinto protein using a doubling-labelling procedure were undertakenin January, June, August, October and November. Rates variedbetween 2.8 and 52 ng C l¹ h¹. On occasions, a significant differencein production rates based on the uptake of leucine and thymidinewas observed, suggesting unbalanced growth. Highest rates ofproduction coincided with times of high dissolved organic carbonlevels in the water column and lowest production with low levelsof DOC. HNAN grazing rates were measured by following the uptakeof fluorescently labelled bacteria and averaged 4.8 bacterialcells individual¹ day¹ at 2 and 4°C. Specific growth rates(h¹) ranged around 0.00070–0.00077 in both the field andlaboratory, giving doubling times of 37.3 and 41.0 days, respectively.These low rates of grazing and growth indicate that there isno adaptation to low temperatures in these freshwater protists.Based on these data, the gross production efficiency is 24%.HNAN removed between 0.1 and 9.7% of bacterial production perday.     

Comparative growth rates and yields of ciliates and heterotrophic dinoflagellates

Growth rates, ingestion rates and grazer yields (grazer volumeproduced/prey volume consumed) were measured for six protozoanspecies (ciliates: Favella sp., Strombidinopsis acuminatum,Uronema sp.; heterotrophic dinoflagellates: Amphidinium sp.,Gymnodinium sp., Noctiluca scintillans) in laboratory batchculture experiments. Comparative growth data indicate that theprymnesiophyte Isochrysis galbana, the prasinophyte Mantoniellasquamata, two cryptophyte species and several autotrophic dinoflagellatespecies were suitable foods for these grazers. When grown onoptimized diets at 13C, maximum ciliate growth rates (range0.77–1.01 day^–1 uniformly exceeded maximum heterotrophicdioflagellate growth rates (range 0.41–0.48 day^–1).A compilation of published data demonstrates that this growthrate difference persists across a range of ciliate and dinoflagellatetaxa and cell sizes. Comparison of volume-specific ingestionrates and yields for the six species studied here showed thatthere was no single explanation for this growth rate disparity.Heterotrophic dinoflagellates exhibited both low ingestion ratesand, in one case, low yields; ciliates were able to achievehigher growth rates via either higher ingestion rates or higheryields, depending on ciliate species. Volume yield increasedover time throughout the exponential growth phase in nearlyall experiments, suggesting variation in response to changingfood concentrations or long-term acclimation to culture conditions.Higher maximum ciliate growth rates mean that these grazershave the potential to exercise tighter control over incipientblooms of their prey than do heterotrophic dinoflagellates.