Preheating induced homogeneity of the small heat shock protein from Methanococcus jannaschii

Small heat shock proteins usually exhibit increased chaperone-like activity either at high temperatures or after preheating. However, the activation mechanism is still unclear. In the current study, we investigated the preheating-activation process of Mj HSP16.5, using various biophysical methods. Although Mj HSP16.5 was reported to be the most monodispersed sHSPs, we found that the newly purified Mj HSP16.5 was actually heterogeneous. 85 degrees C-preheating could activate Mj HSP16.5 and turn it into a more compact homogeneous species at the same time. Different cooling rates after preheating did not change the activity of Mj HSP16.5, suggesting that the 85 degrees C-preheated Mj HSP16.5 is in the most active and also the most stable state. These results demonstrate that the activation process of Mj HSP16.5 might accompany a refolding process.     

Detecting the inter-peptide arrangement and maturation process of transthyretin (105-115) amyloid fibril using a FRET pair with short Förster distance

Transthyretin (TTR) is an amyloidogenic protein involved in many mental diseases. The peptide derived from TTR (105-115) has been widely studied as a model peptide for understanding the mechanism of amyloid fibril formation. However, the detailed arrangement of this peptide in amyloid fibril is still unclear. We have studied the amyloid fibril formation process of TTR (105-115) by introducing a pair of FRET probes into the peptide with a dansyl group at the N-terminal and a tryptophan residue at the C-terminal. Our experiment demonstrated that the strands of TTR (105-115) in the same beta-sheet may be parallel and the mating sheets may be anti-parallel to each other in the amyloid fibril. The kinetics followed by FRET and EM indicated for a possible intermediate state and the distance between sheets became shorter when the intermediate amyloid fibril turns into a more matured form.     

The minimal α‐crystallin domain of Mj Hsp16.5 is functional at non‐heat‐shock conditions

The small heat shock protein (sHSP) from Methanococcus jannaschii (Mj Hsp16.5) forms a monodisperse 24mer and each of its monomer contains two flexible N‐ and C‐terminals and a rigid α‐crystallin domain with an extruding β‐strand exchange loop. The minimal α‐crystallin domain with a β‐sandwich fold is conserved in sHSP family, while the presence of the β‐strand exchange loop is divergent. The function of the β‐strand exchange loop and the minimal α‐crystallin domain of Mj Hsp16.5 need further study. In the present study, we constructed two fragment‐deletion mutants of Mj Hsp16.5, one with both the N‐ and C‐terminals deleted (ΔNΔC) and the other with a further deletion of the β‐strand exchange loop (ΔNΔLΔC). ΔNΔC existed as a dimer in solution. In contrast, the minimal α‐crystallin domain ΔNΔLΔC became polydisperse in solution and exhibited more efficient chaperone‐like activities to prevent amorphous aggregation of insulin B chain and fibril formation of the amyloidogenic peptide dansyl‐SSTSAA‐W than the mutant ΔNΔC and the wild type did. The hydrophobic probe binding experiments indicated that ΔNΔLΔC exposed much more hydrophobic surface than ΔNΔC. Our study also demonstrated that Mj Hsp16.5 used different mechanisms for protecting different substrates. Though Mj Hsp16.5 formed stable complexes with substrates when preventing thermal aggregation, no complexes were detected when preventing aggregation under non‐heat‐shock conditions. Proteins 2014; 82:1156–1167. © 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Investigation of a peptide responsible for amyloid fibril formation of beta 2-microglobulin by achromobacter protease I.

To obtain insight into the mechanism of amyloid fibril formation from beta(2)-microglobulin (beta2-m), we prepared a series of peptide fragments using a lysine-specific protease from Achromobacter lyticus and examined their ability to form amyloid fibrils at pH 2.5. Among the nine peptides prepared by the digestion, the peptide Ser(20)-Lys(41) (K3) spontaneously formed amyloid fibrils, confirmed by thioflavin T binding and electron microscopy. The fibrils composed of K3 peptide induced fibril formation of intact beta2-m with a lag phase, distinct from the extension reaction without a lag phase observed for intact beta2-m seeds. Fibril formation of K3 peptide with intact beta2-m seeds also exhibited a lag phase. On the other hand, the extension reaction of K3 peptide with the K3 seeds occurred without a lag phase. At neutral pH, the fibrils composed of either intact beta2-m or K3 peptide spontaneously depolymerized. Intriguingly, the depolymerization of K3 fibrils was faster than that of intact beta2-m fibrils. These results indicated that, although K3 peptide can form fibrils by itself more readily than intact beta2-m, the K3 fibrils are less stable than the intact beta2-m fibrils, suggesting a close relation between the free energy barrier of amyloid fibril formation and its stability.     

Activation mechanism of HSP16.5 from Methanococcus jannaschii

The small heat shock proteins are the ubiquitous proteins found in a wide range of organisms and function as molecular chaperones by binding to the folding intermediates of their substrates. Although the crystal structure of HSP16.5, a small heat shock protein from Methanococcus jannaschii, revealed that it is a hollow sphere composed of 24 identical subunits, its activation mechanism remains unclear. We found out that HSP16.5 is active only at high temperatures and forms a stable complex with substrate in a stoichiometric manner. We also observed that the conformational change of HSP16.5 is correlated with the increasing hydrophobic site and its activation as a molecular chaperone. However, it is revealed that the conformational change is not accompanied with the change of the secondary structure of a subunit, but correlated with the increasing diameter of HSP16.5. Therefore, it is proposed that the activation mechanism of HSP16.5 involves temperature induced conformational change with size increment of the complex resulting in the exposure of hydrophobic substrate-binding site.     

Lysozyme amyloidogenesis is accelerated by specific nicking and fragmentation but decelerated by intact protein binding and conversion

We have revisited the well-studied heat and acidic amyloid fibril formation pathway (pH 1.6, 65 degrees C) of hen egg-white lysozyme (HEWL) to map the barriers of the misfolding and amyloidogenesis pathways. A comprehensive kinetic mechanism is presented where all steps involving protein hydrolysis, fragmentation, assembly and conversion into amyloid fibrils are accounted for. Amyloid fibril formation of lysozyme has multiple kinetic barriers. First, HEWL unfolds within minutes, followed by irreversible steps of partial acid hydrolysis affording a large amount of nicked HEWL, the 49-101 amyloidogenic fragment and a variety of other species over 5-40 h. Fragmentation forming the 49-101 fragment is a requirement for efficient amyloid fibril formation, indicating that it forms the rate-determining nucleus. Nicked full-length HEWL is recruited efficiently into amyloid fibrils in the fibril growth phase or using mature fibrils as seeds, which abolished the lag phase completely. Mature amyloid fibrils of HEWL are composed mainly of nicked HEWL in the early equilibrium phase but go through a "fibril shaving" process, affording fibrils composed of the 49-101 fragment and 53-101 fragment during more extensive maturation (incubation for longer than ten days). Seeding of the amyloid fibril formation process using sonicated mature amyloid fibrils accelerates the fibril formation process efficiently; however, addition of intact full-length lysozyme at the end of the lag phase slows the rate of amyloidogenesis. The intact full-length protein, in contrast to nicked lysozyme, slows fibril formation due to its slow conversion into the amyloid fold, probably due to inclusion of the non-amyloidogenic 1-48/102-129 portion of HEWL in the fibrils, which can function as a "molecular bumper" stalling further growth.     

Solid-state NMR as a method to reveal structure and membrane-interaction of amyloidogenic proteins and peptides

It is important to understand the Amyloid fibril formation in view of numerous medical and biochemical aspects. Structural determination of amyloid fibril has been extensively studied using electron microscopy. Subsequently, solid state NMR spectroscopy has been realized to be the most important means to determine not only microscopic molecular structure but also macroscopic molecular packing. Molecular structure of amyloid fibril was first predicted to be parallel β-sheet structure, and subsequently, was further refined for Aβ(1-40) to be cross β-sheet with double layered in register parallel β-sheet structure by using solid state NMR spectroscopy. On the other hand, anti-parallel β-sheet structure has been reported to short fragments of Aβ-amyloid and other amyloid forming peptides. Kinetic study of amyloid fibril formation has been studied using a variety of methods, and two-step autocatalytic reaction mechanism used to explain fibril formation. Recently, stable intermediates or proto-fibrils have been observed by electron microscope (EM) images. Some of the intermediates have the same microscopic structure as the matured fibril and subsequently change to matured fibrils. Another important study on amyloid fibril formation is determination of the interaction with lipid membranes, since amyloid peptide are cleaved from amyloid precursor proteins in the membrane interface, and it is reported that amyloid lipid interaction is related to the cytotoxicity. Finally it is discussed how amyloid fibril formation can be inhibited. Firstly, properly designed compounds are reported to have inhibition ability of amyloid fibril formation by interacting with amyloid peptide. Secondly, it is revealed that site directed mutation can inhibit amyloid fibril formation. These inhibitors were developed by knowing the fibril structure determined by solid state NMR.     

Detection and structural characterization of insulin prefibrilar oligomers using surface enhanced Raman spectroscopy

In vitro fibril formation typically exhibits a lag phase followed by a rapid elongation phase. Soluble prefibrilar oligomers form as multiple assembly states occur during the lag phase and, after forming a nucleus, rapidly propagate into amyloid aggregates and fibrils. The structure and morphology of amyloid fibrils have been extensively characterized over the last decades, while little is known about the structural organization of the prefibrilar oligomers or their multiple assembly states. The main difficulty in structural characterization of prefibrilar aggregates is their low concentration (pmolar) and their continual reactive conversion. Herein we overcome these difficulties by utilizing Surface‐Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy (SERS) with a model amyloid peptide, insulin. SERS is a powerful analytic tool that is able to provide detection of small molecules down to a single‐molecule level. Using SERS we found that during the 3 lag phase before the onset of insulin fibril formation, the amount of insulin oligomers increased more than twice after the first hour of incubation under fibrillation conditions (pH 1.6, 65°C) and then slowly decreased with time. The latter finding is kinetically linked to the conversion of the prefibrilar oligomers into fibril species. This study provides valuable new information about the time‐dependent structural organization of insulin oligomers and demonstrates the power and potential of SERS for detection and structural characterization of biological specimens present at low concentrations. © 2013 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 30:488–495, 2014     

Solid-state NMR as a method to reveal structure and membrane-interaction of amyloidogenic proteins and peptides

It is important to understand the Amyloid fibril formation in view of numerous medical and biochemical aspects. Structural determination of amyloid fibril has been extensively studied using electron microscopy. Subsequently, solid state NMR spectroscopy has been realized to be the most important means to determine not only microscopic molecular structure but also macroscopic molecular packing. Molecular structure of amyloid fibril was first predicted to be parallel beta-sheet structure, and subsequently, was further refined for Abeta(1-40) to be cross beta-sheet with double layered in register parallel beta-sheet structure by using solid state NMR spectroscopy. On the other hand, anti-parallel beta-sheet structure has been reported to short fragments of Abeta-amyloid and other amyloid forming peptides. Kinetic study of amyloid fibril formation has been studied using a variety of methods, and two-step autocatalytic reaction mechanism used to explain fibril formation. Recently, stable intermediates or proto-fibrils have been observed by electron microscope (EM) images. Some of the intermediates have the same microscopic structure as the matured fibril and subsequently change to matured fibrils. Another important study on amyloid fibril formation is determination of the interaction with lipid membranes, since amyloid peptide are cleaved from amyloid precursor proteins in the membrane interface, and it is reported that amyloid lipid interaction is related to the cytotoxicity. Finally it is discussed how amyloid fibril formation can be inhibited. Firstly, properly designed compounds are reported to have inhibition ability of amyloid fibril formation by interacting with amyloid peptide. Secondly, it is revealed that site directed mutation can inhibit amyloid fibril formation. These inhibitors were developed by knowing the fibril structure determined by solid state NMR.     

Two-dimensional crystallization of a small heat shock protein HSP16.3 on lipid layer

As a member of small heat shock proteins, HSP16.3 was identified as the major membrane-bound protein of Mycobacterium tuberculosis during stationary phase. Previous studies revealed that HSP16.3 was in a nonameric form in solution. Here, two-dimensional crystal of HSP16.3 molecules on lipid monolayer was obtained for the first time. The crystal exhibited p422 symmetry with lattice parameters a=b=90A, gamma=90 degrees. The projection map of untilted crystals showed that the basic unit of the crystal was a rod-like structure with two high-density regions. The three-dimensional map at 2.2 nm resolution revealed a rod-like structure with a dimension of 56A x 32A x 25A, similar to the dimeric forms of M. jannaschii HSP16.5 and wheat HSP16.9. Cross-linking experiments confirmed that HSP16.3 nonamers dissociated into dimers upon interaction with the positively charged lipid layer. Surface plasmon resonance measurements revealed that both electrostatic and hydrophobic forces involved in the formation of the 2D crystal on the lipid monolayer. These results provide a basis for further investigation on the unique dimeric structure of HSP16.3 and its functions in vivo.     

Counteracting effects of renal solutes on amyloid fibril formation by immunoglobulin light chains

In primary (light chain-associated) amyloidosis, immunoglobulin light chains deposit as amyloid fibrils in vital organs, especially the kidney. Because the kidney contains high concentrations of urea that can destabilize light chains as well as solutes such as betaine and sorbitol that serve as protein stabilizers, we investigated the effects of these solutes on in vitro amyloid fibril formation and thermodynamic stability of light chains. Two recombinant light chain proteins, one amyloidogenic and the other nonamyloidogenic, were used as models. For both light chains, urea enhanced fibril formation by reducing the nucleation lag time and diminished protein thermodynamic stability. Conversely, betaine or sorbitol increased thermodynamic stability of the proteins and partially inhibited fibril formation. These solutes also counteracted urea-induced reduction in protein thermodynamic stability and accelerated fibril formation. Betaine was more effective than sorbitol. A model is presented to explain how the thermodynamic effects of the solutes on protein state equilibria can alter nucleation lag time and, hence, fibril formation kinetics. Our results provide evidence that renal solutes control thermodynamic and kinetic stability of light chains and thus may modulate amyloid fibril formation in the kidney.     

The molecular chaperone alphaB-crystallin enhances amyloid beta neurotoxicity.

Amyloid beta (Abeta) is a 40- to 42-residue peptide that is implicated in the pathogenesis of Alzheimer's Disease (AD). As a result of conformational changes, Abeta assembles into neurotoxic fibrils deposited as 'plaques' in the diseased brain. In AD brains, the small heat shock proteins (sHsps) alphaB-crystallin and Hsp27 occur at increased levels and colocalize with these plaques. In vitro, sHsps act as molecular chaperones that recognize unfolding peptides and prevent their aggregation. The presence of sHsps in AD brains may thus reflect an attempt to prevent amyloid fibril formation and toxicity. Here we report that alphaB-crystallin does indeed prevent in vitro fibril formation of Abeta(1-40). However, rather than protecting cultured neurons against Abeta(1-40) toxicity, alphaB-crystallin actually increases the toxic effect. This indicates that the interaction of alphaB-crystallin with conformationally altering Abeta(1-40) may keep the latter in a nonfibrillar, yet highly toxic form.     

Conversion of non-fibrillar beta-sheet oligomers into amyloid fibrils in Alzheimer's disease amyloid peptide aggregation

Abeta(1-40) is one of the main components of the fibrils found in amyloid plaques, a hallmark of brains affected by Alzheimer's disease. It is known that prior to the formation of amyloid fibrils in which the peptide adopts a well-ordered intermolecular beta-sheet structure, peptide monomers associate forming low and high molecular weight oligomers. These oligomers have been previously described in electron microscopy, AFM, and exclusion chromatography studies. Their specific secondary structures however, have not yet been well established. A major problem when comparing aggregation and secondary structure determinations in concentration-dependent processes such as amyloid aggregation is the different concentration range required in each type of experiment. In the present study we used the dye Thioflavin T (ThT), Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy, and electron microscopy in order to structurally characterize the different aggregated species which form during the Abeta(1-40) fibril formation process. A unique sample containing 90microM peptide was used. The results show that oligomeric species which form during the lag phase of the aggregation kinetics are a mixture of unordered, helical, and intermolecular non-fibrillar beta-structures. The number of oligomers and the amount of non-fibrillar beta-structures grows throughout the lag phase and during the elongation phase these non-fibrillar beta-structures are transformed into fibrillar (amyloid) beta-structures, formed by association of high molecular weight intermediates.     

Inhibition of islet amyloid polypeptide fibril formation: a potential role for heteroaromatic interactions

The formation of amyloid fibril is associated with major human diseases, including Alzheimer's disease, prion diseases, and type 2 diabetes. Methods for efficient inhibition of amyloid fibril formation are therefore highly clinically important. A principal approach for the inhibition of amyloid formation is based on the use of modified molecular recognition elements. Here, we demonstrate efficient inhibition of amyloid formation of the type 2 diabetes-related human islet amyloid polypeptide (hIAPP) by a modified aromatic peptide fragment and a small aromatic polyphenol molecule. A molecular recognition assay using peptide array analysis suggested that molecular recognition between hIAPP and its core amyloidogenic module is mediated by aromatic rather than hydrophobic interactions. To study the possible effect of aromatic interactions on inhibition of hIAPP fibril formation, we have used peptide and small molecule inhibitors. The addition of a nonamyloidogenic peptide analogue of the core module NFGAILSS, in which phenylalanine was substituted with tyrosine (NYGAILSS), resulted in substantial inhibition of fibril formation by hIAPP. The inhibition was significantly stronger than the one achieved using a beta-sheet breaker-conjugated peptide NFGAILPP. On the basis of the molecular arrangement of the tyrosine-phenylalanine interaction, we suggest that the inhibition stems from the geometrical constrains of the heteroaromatic benzene-phenol interaction. In line with this notion, we demonstrate remarkable inhibition of hIAPP fibril formation and cytotoxicity toward pancreatic beta-cells by a small polyphenol molecule, the nontoxic phenol red compound. Taken together, our results provide further experimental support for the potential role of aromatic interactions in amyloid formation and establish a novel approach for its inhibition.     

Cooperative hydrogen bonding in amyloid formation

Amyloid diseases, including Alzheimer's and prion diseases, are each associated with unbranched protein fibrils. Each fibril is made of a particular protein, yet they share common properties. One such property is nucleation-dependent fibril growth. Monomers of amyloid-forming proteins can remain in dissolved form for long periods, before rapidly assembly into fibrils. The lag before growth has been attributed to slow kinetics of formation of a nucleus, on which other molecules can deposit to form the fibril. We have explored the energetics of fibril formation, based on the known molecular structure of a fibril-forming peptide from the yeast prion, Sup35, using both classical and quantum (density functional theory) methods. We find that the energetics of fibril formation for the first three layers are cooperative using both methods. This cooperativity is consistent with the observation that formation of amyloid fibrils involves slow nucleation and faster growth.     

Suppression of in vivo beta-amyloid peptide toxicity by overexpression of the HSP-16.2 small chaperone protein

Expression of the human beta-amyloid peptide (Abeta) in a transgenic Caenorhabditis elegans Alzheimer disease model leads to the induction of HSP-16 proteins, a family of small heat shock-inducible proteins homologous to vertebrate alphaB crystallin. These proteins also co-localize and co-immunoprecipitate with Abeta in this model (Fonte, V., Kapulkin, V., Taft, A., Fluet, A., Friedman, D., and Link, C. D. (2002) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 99, 9439-9444). To investigate the molecular basis and biological function of this interaction between HSP-16 and Abeta, we generated transgenic C. elegans animals with high level, constitutive expression of HSP-16.2. We find that constitutive expression of wild type, but not mutant, HSP-16.2 partially suppresses Abeta toxicity. Wild type Abeta-(1-42), but not Abeta single chain dimer, was observed to become sequestered in HSP-16.2-containing inclusions, indicating a conformation-dependent interaction between HSP-16.2 and Abeta in vivo. Constitutive expression of HSP-16.2 could reduce amyloid fibril formation, but it did not reduce the overall accumulation of Abeta peptide or alter the pattern of the predominant oligomeric species. Studies with recombinant HSP-16.2 demonstrated that HSP-16.2 can bind directly to Abeta in vitro, with a preferential affinity for oligomeric Abeta species. This interaction between Abeta and HSP-16.2 also influences the formation of Abeta oligomers in in vitro assays. These studies are consistent with a model in which small chaperone proteins reduce Abeta toxicity by interacting directly with the Abeta peptide and altering its oligomerization pathways, thereby reducing the formation of a minor toxic species.     

Covalent structural changes in unfolded GroES that lead to amyloid fibril formation detected by NMR: insight into intrinsically disordered proteins

Co-chaperonin GroES from Escherichia coli works with chaperonin GroEL to mediate the folding reactions of various proteins. However, under specific conditions, i.e. the completely disordered state in guanidine hydrochloride, this molecular chaperone forms amyloid fibrils similar to those observed in various neurodegenerative diseases. Thus, this is a good model system to understand the amyloid fibril formation mechanism of intrinsically disordered proteins. Here, we identified a critical intermediate of GroES in the early stages of this fibril formation using NMR and mass spectroscopy measurements. A covalent rearrangement of the polypeptide bond at Asn(45)-Gly(46) and/or Asn(51)-Gly(52) that eventually yield β-aspartic acids via deamidation of asparagine was observed to precede fibril formation. Mutation of these asparagines to alanines resulted in delayed nucleus formation. Our results indicate that peptide bond rearrangement at Asn-Gly enhances the formation of GroES amyloid fibrils. The finding provides a novel insight into the structural process of amyloid fibril formation from a disordered state, which may be applicable to intrinsically disordered proteins in general.     

Optimum amyloid fibril formation of a peptide fragment suggests the amyloidogenic preference of beta2-microglobulin under physiological conditions

Beta(2)-microglobulin (beta(2)m) is a major component of amyloid fibrils deposited in patients with dialysis-related amyloidosis. Although full-length beta(2)m readily forms amyloid fibrils in vitro by seed-dependent extension with a maximum at pH 2.5, fibril formation under physiological conditions as detected in patients has been difficult to reproduce. A 22-residue K3 peptide of beta(2)m, Ser(20)-Lys(41), obtained by digestion with Acromobacter protease I, forms amyloid fibrils without seeding. To obtain further insight into the mechanism of fibril formation, we studied the pH dependence of fibril formation of the K3 peptide and its morphology using a ThT fluorescence assay and electron microscopy, respectively. K3 peptide formed amyloid fibrils over a wide range of pH values with an optimum around pH 7 and contrasted with the pH profile of the seed-dependent extension reaction of full-length beta(2)m. This suggests that once the rigid native-fold of beta(2)m is unfolded and additional factors triggering the nucleation process are provided, full-length beta(2)m discloses an intrinsic potential to form amyloid fibrils at neutral pH. The fibril formation was strongly promoted by dimerization of K3 through Cys(25). The morphology of the fibrils varied depending on the fibril formation conditions and the presence or absence of a disulfide bond. Various fibrils had the potential to seed fibril formation of full-length beta(2)m accompanied with a characteristic lag phase, suggesting that the internal structures are similar.     

Transfection of human HSP27 in rodent cells: Absence of compensatory regulation between small heat shock proteins

1. 1. We examined rodent cells transfected with an expression plasmid encoding a human small heat shock protein for possible compensatory expression of endogenous heat shock genes. For these investigations, human hsp27 was transfected into CHO cells which express endogenous HSP25.

2. 2. Both endogenous HSP25 and transfected HSP27 were expressed and multiple phosphorylated isoforms were detected upon exposure to thermal stress.

3. 3. Levels of endogenous HSP70 and HSP25 did not appear to be altered by expression of the heterologous heat shock protein.

4. 4. These results suggest that compensatory interactions are not exhibited in the expression of the heat shock genes examined, and that independent regulation may exist not only between the large and small heat shock proteins, but also between individual small heat shock proteins as well.

     

Retardation of Aβ Fibril Formation by Phospholipid Vesicles Depends on Membrane Phase Behavior

An increasing amount of evidence suggests that in several amyloid diseases, the fibril formation in vivo and the mechanism of toxicity both involve membrane interactions. We have studied Alzheimer's disease related amyloid beta peptide (Aβ). Recombinant Aβ(M1-40) and Aβ(M1-42) produced in Escherichia coli, allows us to carry out large scale kinetics assays with good statistics. The amyloid formation process is followed in means of thioflavin T fluorescence at relatively low (down to 380 nM) peptide concentration approaching the physiological range. The lipid membranes are introduced in the system as large and small unilamellar vesicles. The aggregation lagtime increases in the presence of lipid vesicles for all situations investigated and the phase behavior of the membrane in the vesicles has a large effect on the aggregation kinetics. By comparing vesicles with different membrane phase behavior we see that the solid gel phase dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine bilayers cause the largest retardation of Aβ fibril formation. The membrane-induced retardation reaches saturation and is present when the vesicles are added during the lag time up to the nucleation point. No significant difference is detected in lag time when increasing amount of negative charge is incorporated into the membrane.