Examination of Ulva bloom species richness and relative abundance reveals two cryptically co-occurring bloom species in Narragansett Bay,Rhode Island

Blooms caused by the green macroalga Ulva pose a serious threat to coastal ecosystems around the world. Despite numerous studies of the causes and consequences of these blooms, we still have a limited understanding of Ulva bloom species richness and abundance due to difficulties in identifying Ulva species using morphological features. Along the northeastern U.S. coastline, all blooms of distromatic Ulva blades were previously identified as Ulva lactuca. Recent molecular sequencing, however, discovered the presence of additional distromatic Ulva species. Therefore, in order to determine the relative abundance of Ulva species within blooms, we conducted monthly surveys at four Narragansett Bay, RI, sites representing a gradient of bloom severity. We found that the biomass of Ulva within blooms was a mix of Ulva compressa and Ulva rigida, not U. lactuca as previously reported. In contrast, sites not impacted by blooms that were located near the mouth of Narragansett Bay were dominated by U. lactuca. We also observed spatial and temporal differences in Ulva and total macroalgal diversity between bloom-impacted sites, indicating that Ulva bloom composition can be radically different between similar sites within close proximity. We discuss our results in the context of Ulva blooms worldwide, highlighting the need to definitively determine bloom species composition in order to fully understand bloom dynamics.     

Seasonal variation of dominant free-floating and attached Ulva species in Rudong coastal area,China

In this paper, species compositions and seasonal variations of attached Ulva species on Porphyra aquaculture rafts and free floating Ulva species at Rudong coastal area, Jiangsu Province of China were investigated during 2010–2011. Based on the sequences analysis of nuclear-encoded ITS (including 5.8S rDNA regions) and 5S rDNA spacer regions, dominant species of both attached and free-floating Ulva samples were identified as Ulva compressa, Ulva linza, Ulva prolifera and Ulva flexuosa. Phylogenetic tree based on sequences of ITS and 5S rDNA spacer regions for attached and free-floating Ulva species was constructed, respectively. Species compositions of the Ulva population attached on aquaculture rafts varied with seasons, and U. prolifera was only found on aquaculture rafts in March 2011 during the 2010–2011 Porphyra yezoensis cultivation season, which had the same sequences of ITS and 5S rDNA spacer regions as that of the dominant species bloomed in the Yellow Sea of China in 2008. Dominant species of the free-floating Ulva population at the early stage of the green tide were U. compressa, U. flexuosa, and U. linza. Free-floating U. prolifera appeared in the middle of May, 2011. ITS sequence similarity rates of U. compressa and U. flexuosa between the attached and free-floating species were 100%. And ITS and 5S rDNA spacer sequences of the attached and the free-floating U. prolifera population also showed no differences. Further study showed that there were two types of free-floating U. prolifera population (Type 5S-A and Type 5S-B) based on 5S rDNA spacer sequences. The present study would provide some useful information for clarifying the outbreak mechanism of green tides occurred in the Yellow Sea, China.     

Morphological and molecular characterization of free-floating and attached green macroalgae Ulva spp. in the Yellow Sea of China

During the summer of 2008 and 2009, massive algal blooms repeatedly broke out in the Yellow Sea of China. These were undoubtedly caused by the accumulations of one or more species in the macroalgal genus Ulva. In previous reports, morphological observation indicated that the species involved in this phenomenon is Ulva prolifera but molecular analyses indicated that the species belongs to an Ulva linza–procera–prolifera (LPP) clade. Correct identification of the bloom species is required to understand and manage the blooms, but the taxonomic status of the bloom species remains unclear. In the current study, the taxonomic status of 22 selected specimens from the Yellow Sea was assessed by using both morphological and molecular (ITS and rbcL sequences) data. In addition, 5S rDNA analyses were performed for those samples clustering in the LPP clade, and phylogenetic tree and ribotype analyses were constructed for determining the possible origin of the bloom. Three free-floating and two attached Ulva species were distinguished and described: Ulva compressa Linnaeus and Ulva pertusa Kjellman were found in free-floating samples; U. linza Linnaeus was found on rocks; and U. prolifera O.F. Müller was found in both habitats. Diversity in free-floating Ulva of the Yellow Sea appears to be greater than previously thought. The dominant free-floating Ulva species, U. prolifera, was not closely related to local populations attached to rocks but was closely related to populations from Japan.     

Molecular and morphological diversity of Narragansett Bay (RI,USA) Ulva (Ulvales,Chlorophyta) populations

Macroalgal bloom‐forming species occur in coastal systems worldwide. However, due to overlapping morphologies in some taxa, accurate taxonomic assessment and classification of these species can be quite challenging. We investigated the molecular and morphological characteristics of 153 specimens of bloom‐forming Ulva located in and around Narragansett Bay, RI, USA. We analyzed sequences of the nuclear internal transcribed spacer 1 region (ITS1) and the chloroplast‐encoded rbcL; based on the ITS1 data, we grouped the specimens into nine operational taxonomic units (OTUs). Eight of these OTUs have been previously reported to exist, while one is novel. Of the eight OTUs, all shared sequence identity with previously published sequences or differed by less than 1.5% sequence divergence for two molecular markers. Previously, 10 species names were reported for Ulva in Rhode Island (one blade and nine tube‐forming species) based upon morphological classification alone. Of our nine OTUs, three contained blade‐forming specimens (U. lactuca, U. compressa, U. rigida), one OTU had a blade with a tubular stipe, and six contained unbranched and/or branched tubular morphologies (one of these six, U. compressa, had both a blade and a tube morphology). While the three blade‐forming OTUs in Narragansett Bay can frequently be distinguished by careful observations of morphological characteristics, and spatial/temporal distribution, it is much more difficult to distinguish among the tube‐forming specimens based upon morphology or distribution alone. Our data support the molecular species concept for Ulva, and indicate that molecular‐based classifications of Ulva species are critical for proper species identification, and subsequent ecological assessment or mitigation of Ulva blooms.     

Ploidy Distribution of the Harmful Bloom Forming Macroalgae Ulva spp. in Narragansett Bay,Rhode Island,USA, Using Flow Cytometry Methods

Macroalgal blooms occur worldwide and have the potential to cause severe ecological and economic damage. Narragansett Bay, RI is a eutrophic system that experiences summer macroalgal blooms composed mostly of Ulva compressa and Ulva rigida, which have biphasic life cycles with separate haploid and diploid phases. In this study, we used flow cytometry to assess ploidy levels of U. compressa and U. rigida populations from five sites in Narragansett Bay, RI, USA, to assess the relative contribution of both phases to bloom formation. Both haploid gametophytes and diploid sporophytes were present for both species. Sites ranged from a relative overabundance of gametophytes to a relative overabundance of sporophytes, compared to the null model prediction of √2 gametophytes: 1 sporophyte. We found significant differences in cell area between ploidy levels for each species, with sporophyte cells significantly larger than gametophyte cells in U. compressa and U. rigida. We found no differences in relative growth rate between ploidy levels for each species. Our results indicate the presence of both phases of each of the two dominant bloom forming species throughout the bloom season, and represent one of the first studies of in situ Ulva life cycle dynamics.     

Discrimination of the common macroalgae (Ulva and Blidingia) in coastal waters of Yellow Sea,northern China,based on restriction fragment-length polymorphism (RFLP) analysis

Since 2007, reoccurring large-scale green algae blooms have caused deleterious effects to the estuarine ecosystem of Yellow Sea, northern China and subsequent economical losses. Previous surveys indicated the green tides were initiated in the coastal water of southern Jiangsu province where Porphyra farming was intensively conducted; however, the main ‘seed source’ of floating green algae is still under debate. Ulva prolifera was confirmed to be the major causative species of green tides. The multiple sympatric ulvoid species in the natural environment has complicated species identification in both field surveys and laboratory studies due to their morphological plasticity. Thus, we developed a genetic identification key based on restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) analysis of the ITS nuclear marker to discriminate the common Ulva and Blidingia species in the Yellow Sea. Ten genetic lineages (1 in Blidingia, 9 in Ulva) were detected along the coast of China through phylogenetic analysis of ITS sequences. They can be separated by virtual restriction digestion using the four selected restriction enzymes (BspT107 I, EcoO109 I, Hin1 I and VpaK11B I). With additional PCR amplification of the 5S spacer region, we were able to discriminate U. prolifera from Ulva linza. Using this genetic key, we screened macroalgal samples collected from the coast of the Yellow Sea, and the results indicated 6 common lineages (U. prolifera, U. linza, Ulva compressa, Ulva pertusa, Clade 6 and Blidingia sp.) in this region, which could be explicitly distinguished by a single enzyme (BspT107 I) coupled with 5S spacer polymorphism. U. prolifera was confirmed to be present on the Porphyra aquaculture rafts with seasonal variation in the species composition. This genetic key will facilitate our long-term field surveys to investigate the origin of the floating U. prolifera and furthermore to explore its bloom dynamics along the coast of the Yellow Sea. It also provided a framework for the future inclusion of more Ulva species, which will expand the usage of this key.     

Cryptic diversity of Ulva (Ulvales,Chlorophyta) in the Great Bay Estuarine System (Atlantic USA): introduced and indigenous distromatic species

Distromatic foliose blades of the algal genus Ulva are notoriously difficult to identify due to their simple morphologies and few diagnostic characteristics that often exhibit intraspecific variation and interspecific overlap. Hence, species differentiation is difficult and diversity estimates are often inaccurate. Two major goals of this study were to assess the diversity of distromatic Ulva spp. in the Great Bay Estuarine System (GBES) of New Hampshire and Maine, USA, and to compare historical and present day records of these species. Molecular analysis (using ITS sequences) of field-collected specimens revealed four distinct taxa: Ulva lactuca, U. rigida, U. compressa, and U. pertusa. Prior to molecular screening, Ulva lactuca was the only distromatic Ulva species reported for the GBES. Ulva pertusa and the foliose form of U. compressa are newly recorded for the Northwest Atlantic, and the range of U. rigida has been extended. Molecular analysis of historical herbarium voucher specimens indicates that U. rigida, U. pertusa, and the foliose form of U. compressa have been present in the GBES since at least 1966, 1967, and 1972, respectively. The distromatic morphotype of U. compressa is found only in low salinity areas, which suggests that salinity may influence its morphological development. Molecular and morphological evaluations are critical if we are to distinguish between cryptic taxa, accurately assess biodiversity, and effectively monitor the spread of non-indigenous macroalgae.     

Tempo-spatial distribution and species diversity of green algae micro-propagules in the Yellow Sea during the large-scale green tide development

From 2008 to 2013, vast green tides mainly composed of Ulva prolifera consecutively invaded the coast of Qingdao (36°06′N, 120°25′E, PR China) in June and July. Previous studies have shown that the early green tides initially formed in the Porphyra yezoensis aquaculture area of the Subei Shoal, southern Yellow Sea. To date, multiple studies have demonstrated that green algae micro-propagules play an important role in the formation of green tides. In this study, we aimed to assess the temporal and spatial distribution of green algae micro-propagules in an extensive area of the Yellow Sea and to determine the species diversity of propagules during the development of the large-scale green tide. We found that the quantity of micro-propagules increased with the free-floating biomass from the initial generation to the development phase of the green tide in mid May. From late May to mid June, the micro-propagule density decreased sharply despite a continuous increase of the floating macroalgae biomass. In addition, our data indicate that the coastal area of the Subei Shoal has always been the distribution center of the micro-propagules, even prior to the large-scale green tide formation. Furthermore, diverse green algae species, including Ulva prolifera, Ulva linza, Ulva flexuosa, Ulva compressa, Ulva pertusa and Blidingia sp., were identified among the micro-propagules in the survey sea area. Finally, we determined that the distribution of U. prolifera micro-propagules is closely related to the floating algal mats and attached macroalgae on Porphyra aquaculture rafts.     

Spatial and temporal variability in macroalgal blooms in a eutrophied coastal estuary

All three macroalgal clades (Chlorophyta, Rhodophyta, and Phaeophyceae) contain bloom-forming species. Macroalgal blooms occur worldwide and have negative consequences for coastal habitats and economies. Narragansett Bay (NB), Rhode Island, USA, is a medium sized estuary that is heavily influenced by anthropogenic activities and has been plagued by macroalgal blooms for over a century. Over the past decade, significant investment has upgraded wastewater treatment from secondary treatment to water-quality based limits (i.e. tertiary treatment) in an effort to control coastal eutrophication in this system. The goal of this study was to improve the understanding of multi-year macroalgal bloom dynamics through intensive aerial and ground surveys conducted monthly to bi-monthly during low tides in May–October 2006–2013 in NB. Aerial surveys provided a rapid characterization of macroalgal densities across a large area, while ground surveys provided high resolution measurements of macroalgal identity, percent cover, and biomass.Macroalgal blooms in NB are dominated by Ulva and Gracilaria spp. regardless of year or month, although all three clades of macroalgae were documented. Chlorophyta cover and nutrient concentrations were highest in the middle and upper bay. Rhodophyta cover was highest in the middle and lower bay, while drifting Phaeophyceae cover was patchy. Macroalgal blooms of >1000 g fresh mass (gfm)/m² (max = 3510 gfm/m²) in the intertidal zone and >3000 gfm/m³ (max = 8555 gfm/m³) in the subtidal zone were observed within a heavily impacted embayment (Greenwich Bay). Macroalgal percent cover (intertidal), biomass (subtidal), and diversity varied significantly between year, month-group, site, and even within sites, with the highest species diversity at sites outside of Greenwich Bay. Total intertidal macroalgal percent cover, as well as subtidal Ulva biomass, were positively correlated with temperature. Dissolved inorganic nitrogen concentrations were correlated with the total biomass of macroalgae and the subtidal biomass of Gracilaria spp. but not the biomass of Ulva spp. Despite seasonal reductions in the nutrient output of wastewater treatment facilities emptying into upper Narragansett Bay in recent years, macroalgal blooms still persist. Continued long-term monitoring of water quality, macroalgal blooms, and ecological indicators is essential to understand the changes in macroalgal bloom dynamics that occur after nutrient reductions from management efforts.     

Ulva diversity in the Yellow Sea during the large‐scale green algal blooms in 2008–2009

In the Yellow Sea of China, large‐scale green tides have broken out for three consecutive years from 2007 to 2009. As part of the efforts to localize the algal source, two cruises were conducted in the early stage and the outbreak stage of the bloom in 2009. We analyzed the morphological and genetic diversity of drifting Ulva specimens and culture‐derived isolates from seawater sampled in different localities. For phylogenetic analyses, the nuclear encoded ribosomal DNA internal transcribed spacer region (ITS nrDNA) and the plastid encoded large subunit of ribulose‐1, 5‐bisphosphate carboxylase/oxgenase gene (rbcL) were used. Our molecular and morphological data indicate that the dominant free‐floating Ulva species in 2008 and 2009 possibly belonged to a single strain of the U. linza‐procera‐prolifera (LPP) clade. The ITS sequences from bloom‐forming algal samples with dense branches were identical to those from U. linza‐like specimens without branches derived from the Yellow Sea. Microscopic individuals of the dominant Ulva strain were detected in eight stations, revealing that spore dispersal in the water helped to enlarge biomass in the water during the outbreak stage of green tide in the Yellow Sea.     

Tracing the origin of green macroalgal blooms based on the large scale spatio-temporal distribution of Ulva microscopic propagules and settled mature Ulva vegetative thalli in coastal regions of the Yellow Sea,China

From 2008 to 2016, massive floating green macroalgal blooms occurred annually during the summer months in the Yellow Sea. The original source of these blooms was traced based on the spatio-temporal distribution and species composition of Ulva microscopic propagules and settled Ulva vegetative thalli monthly from December 2012 to May 2013 in the Yellow Sea. High quantities of Ulva microscopic propagules in both the water column and sediments were found in the Pyropia aquaculture area along the Jiangsu coast before a green macroalgal bloom appeared in the Yellow Sea. The abundance of Ulva microscopic propagules was significantly lower in outer areas compared to in Pyropia aquaculture areas. A molecular phylogenetic analysis suggested that Ulva prolifera microscopic propagules were the dominant microscopic propagules present during the study period. The extremely low biomass of settled Ulva vegetative thalli along the coast indicated that somatic cells of settled Ulva vegetative thalli did not provide a propagule bank for the green macroalgal blooms in the Yellow Sea. The results of this study provide further supporting evidence that the floating green macroalgal blooms originate from green macroalgae attached to Pyropia aquaculture rafts along the Jiangsu coastline of the southern Yellow Sea.     

Two bloom-forming species of Ulva (Chlorophyta) show different responses to seawater temperature and no antagonistic interaction

The generalized use of molecular identification tools indicated that multispecific green tides are more common than previously thought. Temporal successions between bloom-forming species on a seasonal basis were also revealed in different cold temperate estuaries, suggesting a key role of photoperiod and temperature controlling bloom development and composition. According to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, water temperatures are predicted to increase around 4°C by 2100 in Ireland, especially during late spring coinciding with early green tide development. Considering current and predicted temperatures, and photoperiods during bloom development, different eco-physiological experiments were developed. These experiments indicated that the growth of Ulva lacinulata was controlled by temperature, while U. compressa was unresponsive to the photoperiod and temperatures assayed. Considering a scenario of global warming for Irish waters, an earlier development of bloom is expected in the case of U. lacinulata. This could have significant consequences for biomass balance in Irish estuaries and the maximum accumulated biomass during peak bloom. The observed seasonal patterns and experiments also indicated that U. compressa may facilitate U. lacinulata development. When both species were co-cultivated, the culture performance showed intermediate responses to experimental treatments in comparison with monospecific cultures of both species.     

Foliose Ulva Species Show Considerable Inter‐Specific Genetic Diversity,Low Intra‐Specific Genetic Variation,and the Rare Occurrence of Inter‐Specific Hybrids in the Wild

Foliose Ulva spp. have become increasingly important worldwide for their environmental and financial impacts. A large number of such Ulva species have rapid reproduction and proliferation habits, which explains why they are responsible for Ulva blooms, known as “green tides”, having dramatic negative effects on coastal ecosystems, but also making them attractive for aquaculture applications. Despite the increasing interest in the genus Ulva, particularly on the larger foliose species for aquaculture, their inter‐ and intra‐specific genetic diversity is still poorly described. We compared the cytoplasmic genome (chloroplast and mitochondrion) of 110 strains of large distromatic foliose Ulva from Ireland, Brittany (France), the Netherlands and Portugal. We found six different species, with high levels of inter‐specific genetic diversity, despite highly similar or overlapping morphologies. Genetic variation was as high as 82 SNPs/kb between Ulva pseudorotundata and U. laetevirens, indicating considerable genetic diversity. On the other hand, intra‐specific genetic diversity was relatively low, with only 36 variant sites (0.03 SNPs/kb) in the mitochondrial genome of the 29 Ulva rigida individuals found in this study, despite different geographical origins. The use of next‐generation sequencing allowed for the detection of a single inter‐species hybrid between two genetically closely related species, U. laetevirens, and U. rigida, among the 110 strains analyzed in this study. Altogether, this study represents an important advance in our understanding of Ulva biology and provides genetic information for genomic selection of large foliose strains in aquaculture.     

Molecular phylogenetic analyses of Ulva (Chlorophyta, Ulvophyceae) mats in the Xiangshan Bay of China using high-resolution DNA markers

Intertidal Ulva mats occur annually in winter and spring in the Xiangshan Bay (29°26′–29°34′ N, 121°27′–121°50′ E) of China. Thousands of tons of Ulva biomass have been harvested as edible seaweeds for human consumption for several decades in this region. This investigation was designed to quantify Ulva microscopic propagules associated with the mat, identify species composition, and to analyze intra-species relationships using three molecular markers. Phylogenetic analysis based on the nuclear encoded rDNA internal transcribed spacer region, the plastid encoded large subunit of the ribulose 1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase gene, and the 5S rDNA spacer region showed that the mat was principally composed of Ulva prolifera and Ulva flexuosa. Their propagules were detected in both the water column and sediment. Based on phylogenetic analyses of the 5S rDNA spacer region, mat samples of U. prolifera and U. flexuosa were genetically distinct from the green tide samples in the Yellow Sea and U. flexuosa samples from Jiangsu coasts, respectively, revealing that isolated geographical position of the Xiangshan Bay might result in the maintenance of a distinct Ulva population. The results demonstrate that high-resolution DNA markers have great potential in identification and discrimination at and below the species level.     

Molecular analysis of green-tide-forming macroalgae in the Yellow Sea

In the summer of 2008, free-floating green algae bloomed in the Yellow Sea. Samples were collected in a wide area (119°32′-122°00′E, 32°25′-36°49′N). We calculated the sequence divergences of nuclear ITS, chloroplast rbcL, and psbA data of free-floating samples collected from the Yellow Sea and Ulvaceae from Europe and Japan. In the ITS sequence, 19 out of the 21 Yellow Sea samples of 2008 were identical to those of a sample taken at Qingdao in 2007. A low divergence (0.2%) was found in remaining two samples. Similar evidence was shown by pairwise distances of rbcL and psbA gene sequence data, implying the uniformity of the Yellow Sea blooms in 2007 and 2008. The ITS sequence of the Yellow Sea samples differed 8.1-10.8% from free-floating Enteromorpha or Ulva reported worldwide. ITS-based molecular phylogenetic results and rbcL sequence data grouped the free-floating alga in the Yellow Sea into one clade with Enteromorpha procera, Enteromorpha linza and Enteromorpha prolifera. Furthermore, both morphological characteristics and ribotype network of the ITS sequences imply that the blooming algae in 2007 and 2008 were E. prolifera. The haplotypes of the Yellow Sea free-floating E. prolifera are closely related to those from the Japanese coast but less to European and American algae.     

Comparative study on mitogenomes of green tide algae

Since 2007, the annual green tide disaster in the Yellow Sea has brought serious economic losses to China. There is no research on the genetic similarities of four constituent species of green tide algae at the genomic level. We previously determined the mitochondrial genomes of Ulva prolifera, Ulva linza and Ulva flexuosa. In the present work, the mitochondrial genome of another green tide (Ulva compressa) was sequenced and analyzed. With the length of 62,311 bp, it contained 29 encoding genes, 26 tRNAs and 10 open reading frames. By comparing these four mitochondrial genomes, we found that U. compressa was quite different from the other three types of Ulva species. However, there were similarities between U. prolifera and U. linza in the number, distribution and homology of open reading frames, evolutionary and codon variation of tRNA, evolutionary relationship and selection pressure of coding genes. Repetitive sequence analysis of simple sequence repeats, tandem repeat and forward repeats further supposed that they have evolved from the same origin. In addition, we directly analyzed gene homologies and translocation of four green tide algae by Mauve alignment. There were gene order rearrangements among them. With fast-evolving genomes, these four green algal mitochondria have both conservatism and variation, thus opening another window for the understanding of origin and evolution of Ulva.     

DNA content of Ulva compressa (Ulvales, Chlorophyta) nuclei determined with laser scanning cytometry

The green macroalgal genus Ulva (incl. Entemmorpha) contains economically valuable species, is of relevance for coastal management (green tides), and certain taxa serve as experimental organisms for fundamental research in green algae. The nuclear genome size of Ulva (Entemmorpha) compressa Linnaeus was measured in propidium iodide stained nuclei using laser scanning cytometry. Nuclei of fixed gametes yielded reproducible values, whereas nuclei extracted from multicellular gametophytes were unsuitable. With nuclei of Arabidopsis thaliana (L.) Heynh and Saccharomyces cerevisiae Hansen as references, the haploid nuclear genome size of U. compressa was calculated as 135 ± 7 Mbp. This is the smallest genome so far known from any species of Ulva.     

A Strategy for the Proliferation of Ulva prolifera,Main Causative Species of Green Tides,with Formation of Sporangia by Fragmentation

Ulva prolifera, a common green seaweed, is one of the causative species of green tides that occurred frequently along the shores of Qingdao in 2008 and had detrimental effects on the preparations for the 2008 Beijing Olympic Games sailing competition, since more than 30 percent of the area of the games was invaded. In view of the rapid accumulation of the vast biomass of floating U. prolifera in green tides, we investigated the formation of sporangia in disks of different diameters excised from U. prolifera, changes of the photosynthetic properties of cells during sporangia formation, and development of spores. The results suggested that disks less than 1.00 mm in diameter were optimal for the formation of sporangia, but there was a small amount of spore release in these. The highest percentage of area of spore release occurred in disks that were 2.50 mm in diameter. In contrast, sporangia were formed only at the cut edges of larger disks (3.00 mm, 3.50 mm, and 4.00 mm in diameter). Additionally, the majority of spores liberated from the disks appeared vigorous and developed successfully into new individuals. These results implied that fragments of the appropriate size from the U. prolifera thalli broken by a variety of factors via producing spores gave rise to the rapid proliferation of the seaweed under field conditions, which may be one of the most important factors to the rapid accumulation of the vast biomass of U. prolifera in the green tide that occurred in Qingdao, 2008.     

Free-floating Ulva in the southwest Netherlands: species or morphotypes? a morphological,molecular and ecological comparison

Free-floating Ulva L. biomass in the eutrophic brackish ‘Veerse Meer’ lagoon (southwest Netherlands) consists of four morphologically identified species: U. curvata (Kützing) De Toni, U. lactuca L., U. rigida C. Agardh and U. scandinavica Bliding. U. curvata could be recognized easily because of the characteristic central cavity in the holdfast of the attached plants, the arrangement of cells in rows and the single pyrenoid in each cell. U. rigida was distinguished by the thick thallus and the large number of pyrenoids. The Veerse Meer isolate, however, was slightly different from the isolate from the Oosterschelde estuary (the Netherlands). U. lactuca and U. scandinavica showed a high degree of overlap in thallus thickness and cell size, but U. scandinavica usually possessed more pyrenoids. However, doubts have frequently been expressed about the use of some morphological characters in Ulva taxonomy. To determine the validity of such characters in the identification of Ulva species, the morphological variation within and between morphological species was recorded and a molecular data set generated. To detect possible ecophysiological differences between species, optimum temperatures and salinities for growth were determined experimentally. The sequences of the nuclear ribosomal DNA internal transcribed spacer 2 (ITS2) and flanking regions of U. lactuca, U. rigida and U. scandinavica from the Veerse Meer were all identical, but differed from that of U. rigida from the Oosterschelde estuary. Ulva species from the Veerse Meer were most closely related to U. armoricana and U. rigida from Brittany (2.9% and 3.5% divergence respectively); the difference between U. rigida from the Veerse Meer and from the Oosterschelde estuary was 7.5%. Rooted trees, based on a comparison of these sequences with sequences of other Ulva and Enteromorpha species obtained from the literature, using Monostroma arcticum as outgroup, suggested that Ulva is paraphyletic with respect to Enteromorpha. The optimum temperature for growth of U. curvata was 25?°C; for all other species it was 10?°C. The optimum salinity for growth was 30?°C for all isolates. It is concluded that U. lactuca, U rigida and U. scandinavica from the Veerse Meer are all members of one highly polymorphic species.