Effects of bulge composition and flanking sequence on the kinking of DNA by bulged bases

We recently showed that bulged bases kink duplex DNA, with the degree of kinking increasing in roughly equal increments as the number of bases in the bulge increases from one to four [Hsieh, C.-H., & Griffith, J.D. (1989) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 86, 4833-4837]. Here we have examined the kinking of DNA by single A, C, G, or T bulges with different neighboring base pairs. Synthetic 30 base pair (bp) duplex DNAs containing 2 single-base bulges spaced by 10 bp were ligated head to tail, and their electrophoretic behavior in highly cross-linked gels was examined. All bulge-containing DNAs showed marked electrophoretic retardations as compared to non-bulge-containing DNA. Regardless of the sequence of the flanking base pairs, purine bulges produced greater retardations than pyrimidine bulges. Furthermore, C and T bulges produced the same retardations as did G and A bulges. Bulged DNA containing different flanking base pairs showed marked differences in electrophoretic mobility. For C-bulged DNA, the greatest retardations were observed with G.C neighbors, the least with T.A neighbors, and an intermediate amount with a mixture of neighboring base pairs. For A-bulged DNA, the retardations were greatest with G.C neighbors, less with T.A neighbors, even less with a mixture of neighboring base pairs, and finally least with C.G neighbors. Thus flanking base pairs affect C-bulged DNA and A-bulged DNA differently, and G.C and C.G flanking base pairs were seen to have very different effects. These results imply an important role of base stacking in determining how neighboring base pairs influence the kinking of DNA by a single-base bulge.     

Constructing RNA dynamical ensembles by combining MD and motionally decoupled NMR RDCs: new insights into RNA dynamics and adaptive ligand recognition

We describe a strategy for constructing atomic resolution dynamical ensembles of RNA molecules, spanning up to millisecond timescales, that combines molecular dynamics (MD) simulations with NMR residual dipolar couplings (RDC) measured in elongated RNA. The ensembles are generated via a Monte Carlo procedure by selecting snap-shot from an MD trajectory that reproduce experimentally measured RDCs. Using this approach, we construct ensembles for two variants of the transactivation response element (TAR) containing three (HIV-1) and two (HIV-2) nucleotide bulges. The HIV-1 TAR ensemble reveals significant mobility in bulge residues C24 and U25 and to a lesser extent U23 and neighboring helical residue A22 that give rise to large amplitude spatially correlated twisting and bending helical motions. Omission of bulge residue C24 in HIV-2 TAR leads to a significant reduction in both the local mobility in and around the bulge and amplitude of inter-helical bending motions. In contrast, twisting motions of the helices remain comparable in amplitude to HIV-1 TAR and spatial correlations between them increase significantly. Comparison of the HIV-1 TAR dynamical ensemble and ligand bound TAR conformations reveals that several features of the binding pocket and global conformation are dynamically preformed, providing support for adaptive recognition via a ‘conformational selection’ type mechanism.     

RNA recognition by Tat-derived peptides: interaction in the major groove?

Replication of human immunodeficiency virus requires binding of the viral Tat protein to its RNA target sequence TAR; peptides derived from Tat bind to a TAR "contact site" spanning 5 bp and a trinucleotide pyrimidine bulge. We find that high affinity binding requires a U residue in the bulge loop and 2 specific adjacent base pairs. Other bulged RNAs bind in a lower affinity nonspecific manner; sequence-specific binding requires a bulge loop of more than 1 nucleotide. Reaction with diethyl pyrocarbonate indicates that one effect of the bulge is to make the otherwise deep and narrow RNA major groove accessible. A model consistent with these data involves local distortion of A-form geometry at the bulge, which bends the helix and permits protein binding and interactive access in the RNA major groove.     

Conserved nucleotides in the TAR RNA stem of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 are critical for Tat binding and trans activation: model for TAR RNA tertiary structure.

Interaction between the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) trans-activator Tat and its cis-acting responsive RNA element TAR is necessary for activation of HIV-1 gene expression. We investigated the hypothesis that the essential uridine residue at position 23 in the bulge of TAR RNA is involved in intramolecular hydrogen bonding to stabilize an unique RNA structure required for recognition by Tat. Nucleotide substitutions in the two base pairs of the TAR stem directly above the essential trinucleotide bulge that maintain base pairing but change sequence prevent complex formation with Tat in vitro. Corresponding mutations tested in a trans-activation assay strongly affect the biological activity of TAR in vivo, suggesting an important role for these nucleotides in the Tat-TAR interaction. On the basis of these data, a model is proposed which implicates uridine 23 in a stable tertiary interaction with the GC pair directly above the bulge. This interaction would cause widening of the major groove of the RNA, thereby exposing its hydrogen-bonding surfaces for possible interaction with Tat. The model also predicts a gap between uridine 23 and the first base pair in the stem above, which would require one or more unpaired nucleotides to close, but does not predict any other role for such nucleotides. In accordance with this prediction, synthetic propyl phosphate linkers of equivalent length to 1 or 2 nucleotides, were found to be fully acceptable substitutes in the bulge above uridine 23, demonstrating that neither the bases nor the ribose moieties at these positions are implicated in the recognition of TAR RNA by Tat.     

Solution structure of dAATAA and dAAUAA DNA bulges

The NMR structure analysis is described for two DNA molecules of identical stem sequences with a five base loop containing a pyrimidine, thymin or uracil, in between purines. These five unpaired nucleotides are bulged out and are known to induce a kink in the duplex structure. The dAATAA bulge DNA is kinked between the third and the fourth nucleotide. This contrasts with the previously studied dAAAAA bulge DNA where we found a kink between the fourth and fifth nucleotide. The total kinking angle is ~104° for the dAATAA bulge. The findings were supported by electrophoretic data and fluorescence resonance energy transfer measurements of a similar DNA molecule end-labeled by suitable fluorescent dyes. For the dAAUAA bulge the NMR data result in a similar structure as reported for the dAATAA bulge with a kinking angle of ~87°. The results are discussed in comparison with a rAAUAA RNA bulge found in a group I intron. Generally, the sequence-dependent structure of bulges is important to understand the role of DNA bulges in protein recognition.     

Syntheses of alternating oligo-2'-O-methylribonucleoside methylphosphonates and their interactions with HIV TAR RNA

Oligonucleotide analogues 15-20 nucleotides in length have been prepared, whose sequences are complementary to nucleotides in the upper hairpin of HIV TAR RNA. These alternating oligonucleoside methylphosphonates, mr-AOMPs, contain 2'-O-methylribonucleosides and alternating methylphosphonate and phosphodiester internucleotide linkages. The methylphosphonate and phosphodiester linkages of these oligomers are highly resistant to hydrolysis by exonuclease activity found in mammalian serum and to endonucleases, such as S1 nuclease. The oligomers were prepared using automated phosphoramidite chemistry and terminate with a 5'-phosphate group, which provides an affinity handle for purification by strong anion exchange HPLC. A 15-mer mr-AOMP, 1676, that is complementary to the 5'-side of the TAR RNA hairpin, including the 3-base bulge and 6-base loop region, forms a 1:1 duplex with a complementary RNA 18-mer, mini-TAR RNA. The T(m) of this duplex is 71 degrees C, which is similar to that of the duplex formed by the corresponding all phosphodiester 15-mer. Introduction of two mismatched bases reduces the T(m) by 17 degrees C. The apparent dissociation constant, K(d), for the 1676/mini-TAR RNA duplex as determined by an electrophoretic mobility shift assay at 37 degrees C is 0.3 nM. Oligomer 1676 also binds tightly to the full length TAR RNA target under physiological conditions (K(d) = 20 nM), whereas no binding was observed by the mismatched oligomer. A 19-mer that is complementary to the entire upper hairpin also binds to TAR RNA with a K(d) that is similar to that of 1676, a result that suggests only part of the oligomer binds. When two of the methylphosphonate linkages in the region complementary to the 6-base loop are replaced with phosphodiester linkages, the K(d) is reduced by approximately a factor of 10. This result suggests that interactions between TAR RNA and the oligomer occur initially with nucleotides in the 6-base loop, and that these interactions are sensitive to presence and possibly the chirality of the methylphosphonate linkages in the oligomer. The high affinities of mr-AOMPs for TAR RNA and their resistance to nuclease hydrolysis suggests their potential utility as antisense agents in cell culture.     

Detailed mutational analysis of TAR RNA: critical spacing between the bulge and loop recognition domains.

Trans-activation of HIV-1 by the Tat protein is mediated through a cis-acting element (TAR) in the viral RNA. In order to obtain further insight into the molecular interactions for trans-activation, a detailed mutational analysis of TAR RNA was carried out. TAR RNA forms a hairpin structure with important sequence elements in the single-stranded bulge- and loop-domains. We found that the sequence of the base-pairs flanking the bulge is critical for Tat-mediated trans-activation. In addition, Tat-response is reduced when the bulge is forced into a base-paired configuration through the introduction of complementary nucleotides on the opposite side of the stem. Thus, the 3-nucleotide bulge and adjacent base-pairs comprise a recognition domain with both sequence- and structure-elements. Accessibility of the loop sequences is also important for Tat function, since base-pairing through the formation of a pseudoknot-like structure does inhibit Tat action. A third critical parameter that influences the magnitude of Tat response is the number of loop nucleotides. Finally, the relative spacing between the loop and the bulge is also important. We introduced additional base-pairs in the stem connecting the two domains. Such mutations progressively decreased the efficiency of Tat induction. Interestingly, activity of the HIV-2 Tat protein did markedly increase on targets with one or two additional basepairs. These results suggest that Tat interacts with a cellular loop-binding protein(s) to increase HIV gene expression.     

Oligonucleotide inhibition of the interaction of HIV-1 Tat protein with the trans-activation responsive region (TAR) of HIV RNA

The interaction of HIV-1 Tat protein with its recognition sequence, the trans-activation responsive region TAR is a potential target for drug discovery against HIV infection. We show by use of an in vitro competition filter binding interference assay that synthetic oligodeoxyribonucleotides complementary to the HIV-1 TAR RNA apical stem-loop and bulge region inhibit the binding of Tat protein or a Tat peptide (residues 37-72) better than two small molecules that have been shown to bind TAR RNA, Hoechst 33258 and neomycin B. The inhibition is not sensitive to length between 13 and 16 residues or precise positioning but shorter oligonucleotides are less effective. Enhanced inhibition was obtained for a 16-mer 2'-O-methyl oligoribonucleotide but not for C5-propyne pyrimidine-substituted oligonucleotides. Control non-antisense oligonucleotides were occasionally also effective in filter binding interference but only the complementary antisense 2'-O-methyl oligoribonucleotide was effective in gel mobility shift assays in direct TAR binding or in interference with Tat peptide binding to the TAR stem-loop. This is the first demonstration of effective inhibition of the Tat-TAR interaction by nuclease-stabilized oligonucleotide analogues.     

Raman and Raman optical activity (ROA) analysis of RNA structural motifs in Domain I of the EMCV IRES

Raman and Raman optical activity (ROA) spectra were collected for four RNA oligonucleotides based on the EMCV IRES Domain I to assess the contributions of helix, GNRA tetraloop, U·C mismatch base pair and pyrimidine-rich bulge structures to each. Both Raman and ROA spectra show overall similarities for all oligonucleotides, reflecting the presence of the same base paired helical regions and GNRA tetraloop in each. Specific bands are sensitive to the effect of the mismatch and asymmetric bulge on the structure of the RNA. Raman band changes are observed that reflect the structural contexts of adenine residues, disruption of A-form helical structure, and incorporation of pyrimidine bases in non-helical regions. The ROA spectra are also sensitive to conformational mobility of ribose sugars, and verify a decrease in A-type helix content upon introduction of the pyrimidine-rich bulge. Several Raman and ROA bands also clearly show cooperative effects between the mismatch and pyrimidine-rich bulge motifs on the structure of the RNA. The complementary nature of Raman and ROA spectra provides detailed and highly sensitive information about the local environments of bases, and secondary and tertiary structures, and has the potential to yield spectral signatures for a wide range of RNA structural motifs.     

Rotational symmetry in ribonucleotide strand requirements for binding of HIV-1 Tat protein to TAR RNA.

Transactivation of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) gene expression requires binding of the viral Tat protein to a RNA hairpin-loop structure (TAR) which contains a two or three-nucleotide bulge. Tat binds in the vicinity of the bulge and the two adjacent duplex stems, recognising both specific sequence and structural features of TAR. Binding is mediated by an arginine-rich domain, placing Tat in the family of arginine-rich RNA binding proteins that includes other transactivators, virus capsid proteins and ribosome binding proteins. In order to determine what features of TAR allow Tat to bind efficiently to RNA but not DNA forms, we examined Tat binding to a series of RNA-DNA hybrids. We found that only one specific strand in each duplex stem region needs to be RNA, implying that interaction between Tat and a given stem may be solely or predominantly with one of the two strands. However, the essential strand is not the same one for each stem, suggesting a switch in the bound strand on opposing sides of the bulge.     

Dynamic ensemble view of the conformational landscape of HIV-1 TAR RNA and allosteric recognition

RNA conformational dynamics and the resulting structural heterogeneity play an important role in RNA functions, e.g., recognition. Recognition of HIV-1 TAR RNA has been proposed to occur via a conformational capture mechanism. Here, using ultrafast time-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy, we have probed the complexity of the conformational landscape of HIV-1 TAR RNA and monitored the position-dependent changes in the landscape upon binding of a Tat protein-derived peptide and neomycin B. In the ligand-free state, the TAR RNA samples multiple families of conformations with various degrees of base stacking around the three-nucleotide bulge region. Some subpopulations partially resemble those ligand-bound states, but the coaxially stacked state is below the detection limit. When Tat or neomycin B binds, the bulge region as an ensemble undergoes a conformational transition in a position-dependent manner. Tat and neomycin B induce mutually exclusive changes in the TAR RNA underlying the mechanism of allosteric inhibition at an ensemble level with residue-specific details. Time-resolved anisotropy decay measurements revealed picosecond motions of bases in both ligand-free and ligand-bound states. Mutation of a base pair at the bulge--stem junction has differential effects on the conformational distributions of the bulge bases. A dynamic model of the ensemble view of the conformational landscape for HIV-1 TAR RNA is proposed, and the implication of the general mechanism of RNA recognition and its impact on RNA-based therapeutics are discussed.     

Molecular basis of HIV-1 TAR RNA specific recognition by an acridine tat-antagonist.

We investigated the interaction of a highly potent acridine-based tat-antagonist with the TAR RNA of HIV-1. The wild type TAR RNA and three mutants with U-->C23, G x C-->C x G26-39 or G x C-->A x U26-39 substitutions were used as substrates to study the molecular basis of drug-TAR RNA complex formation. Melting temperature and RNase protection experiments reveal that the G x C26-39 pair is a critical element for specific major groove recognition of TAR at the pyrimidine bulge. The results provide a rational basis for future design of optimized tat/TAR inhibitors.     

Inhibition of HIV-1 Tat-TAR interaction by diphenylfuran derivatives: effects of the terminal basic side chains.

A series of four biscationic diphenylfuran derivatives was used to investigate drug binding to the transactivation response element (TAR) RNA. The drugs, which are active against the Pneumocystis carinii pathogen (PCP), differ by the nature of the terminal basic side chains. Furimidazoline (DB60) is more potent at inhibiting binding of the Tat protein to TAR than furamidine (DB75) and the amidine-substituted analogues DB244 and DB226. In vivo studies using the fusion-induced gene stimulation (FIGS) assay entirely agree with the in vitro gel mobility shift data. The capacity of the drugs to antagonize Tat binding correlates with their RNA binding properties determined by melting temperature and RNase protection experiments. Footprinting studies indicate that the bulge region of TAR provides the identity element for the diphenylfurans. Access of the drugs to the major groove cavity at the pyrimidine bulge depends on the bulk of the alkylamine substituents. Experiments using TAR mutants show that the bulge of TAR is critical for drug binding but also reveal that the fit of the drugs into the major groove cavity of TAR does not involve specific contacts with the highly conserved residue U23 or the C x G26-39 base pair. The binding essentially involves shape recognition. The results are also discussed with respect to the known activity of the drug against PCP which is the major cause of mortality in AIDS patients. This study provides guidelines for future development of TAR-targeted anti-HIV-1 drugs.     

Identification of a novel HIV-1 TAR RNA bulge binding protein.

The Tat protein binds to TAR RNA to stimulate the expression of the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) genome. Tat is an 86 amino acid protein that contains a short region of basic residues (aa49-aa57) that are required for RNA binding and TAR is a 59 nucleotide stem-loop with a tripyrimidine bulge in the upper stem. TAR is located at the 5' end of all viral RNAs. In vitro, Tat specifically interacts with TAR by recognising the sequence of the bulge and upper stem, with no requirement for the loop. However, in vivo the loop sequence is critical for activation, implying a requirement for accessory cellular TAR RNA binding factors. A number of TAR binding cellular factors have been identified in cell extracts and various models for the function of these factors have been suggested, including roles as coactivators and inhibitors. We have now identified a novel 38 kD cellular factor that has little general, single-stranded or double-stranded RNA binding activity, but that specifically recognises the bulge and upper stem region of TAR. The protein, referred to as BBP (bulge binding protein), is conserved in mammalian and amphibian cells and in Schizosaccharomyces pombe but is not found in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. BBP is an effective competitive inhibitor of Tat binding to TAR in vitro. Our data suggest that the bulge-stem recognition motif in TAR is used to mediate cellular factor/RNA interactions and indicates that Tat action might be inhibited by such competing reactions in vivo.     

Comparative NMR study of A(n)-bulge loops in DNA duplexes: intrahelical stacking of A, A-A, and A-A-A bulge loops.

We have prepared a series of deoxyoligonucleotide duplexes of the sequence d(G-C-A-T-C-G-X-G-C-T-A-C-G).d(C-G-T-A-G-C-C-G-A-T-G-C), in which X represents either one (A), two (A-A), or three (A-A-A) unpaired adenine basis. Using two-dimensional proton and phosphorus NMR spectroscopy, we have characterized conformational features of these bulge-loop duplexes in solution. We find that Watson-Crick hydrogen bonding is intact for all 12 base pairs, including the GC bases that flank the bulge loop. Observation of NOE connectivities in both H2O and D2O allows us to unambiguously localize all of the bulged adenine residues to intrahelical positions within the duplex. This is in contrast to an earlier model for multiple-base bulge loops in DNA [Bhattacharyya, A., & Lilley, D. M. J. (1989) Nucleic Acids Res. 17, 6821-6840], in which all but the most 5' bulged base are looped out into solution. We find that insertion of two or three bases into the duplex results in the disruption of specific sequential NOEs for the base step across from the bulge loop site on the opposite strand. This disruption is characterized by a partial shearing apart of these bases, such that certain sequential NOEs for this base step are preserved. We observe a downfield-shifted phosphorus resonance, which we assign in the A-A-A bulge duplex to the 3' side of the last bulged adenine residue. Proton and phosphorus chemical shift trends within the An-bulge duplex series indicate that there is an additive effect on the structural perturbations caused by additional unpaired bases within the bulge loop. This finding parallels previous observations [Bhattacharyya, A., & Lilley, D. M. J. (1989) Nucleic Acids Res. 17, 6821-6840; Hsieh, C.-H., & Griffith, J. D. (1989) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 86, 4833-4837] on the magnitude of the induced bending of DNA duplexes by multiple-base bulge loops.     

Evidence for a base triple in the free HIV-1 TAR RNA

We propose the existence of a novel base triple in the HIV-1 TAR hairpin. This triple is supported by covariation of loop residue 31 with residue 22, which is part of an unusual base pair with U40 below the 3-nucleotide bulge. A set of mutants was constructed to test the involvement of bases A22, U31, and U40 in a triple interaction. RNA structure probing, trans-activation assays, and structure modeling are consistent with the existence of this base triple in a bent conformation of the free TAR element. However, disruption of the base triple does not affect binding of a Tat-derived peptide. We therefore compared the structure of free and Tat-bound TAR RNA by footprinting and site-specific cross-linking analyses. These studies indicate that the Tat arginine-rich motif, in addition to its known binding site at the bulge, is in close contact with U31 in the TAR loop. Because binding of Tat to TAR is known to coincide with the formation of a base triple with residues U23, A27, and U38, we hypothesize that Tat binding and the associated straightening of TAR triggers the disruption of the (A22-U40)U31 triple.