Analysis of fruiting body development in the aggregative ciliate Sorogena stoianovitchae (Ciliophora, Colpodea)

The fruiting body-forming ciliate Sorogena stoianovitchae is a protist that is multicellular in one stage of its life cycle. When nutrient levels are depleted, a number of Sorogena cells aggregate beneath the water surface to form an aerial fruiting body. Based on morphologies and the inhibition of protein synthesis, fruiting body development is divided into five distinct stages: (1) aggregation before sunrise, (2) compact aggregation after sunrise, (3) secretion of mucous matrix, (4) stalk-elongation, and (5) completion of the fruiting-body. In the aggregation stage, the cells were trapped in a matrix material that stained orange with 4',6-diamino-2-phenylindole (DAPI), but differed from the mucous matrix in the later stage. A short interruption of the dark period, at 6-8 h after the onset of dark, inhibited fruiting body development. Irrespective of the length of the dark period (10-16 h), the cells remained in the aggregation stage until the beginning of the light period. Therefore, an uninterrupted dark period of more than 8 h is critical for the initial aggregation of cells, but subsequent development is triggered by light.     

The control of chemotactic cell movement during Dictyostelium morphogenesis

Differential cell movement is an important mechanism in the development and morphogenesis of many organisms. In many cases there are indications that chemotaxis is a key mechanism controlling differential cell movement. This can be particularly well studied in the starvation-induced multicellular development of the social amoeba Dictyostelium discoideum. Upon starvation, up to 10(5) individual amoebae aggregate to form a fruiting body The cells aggregate by chemotaxis in response to propagating waves of cAMP, initiated by an aggregation centre. During their chemotactic aggregation the cells start to differentiate into prestalk and prespore cells, precursors to the stalk and spores that form the fruiting body. These cells enter the aggregate in a random order but then sort out to form a simple axial pattern in the slug. Our experiments strongly suggest that the multicellular aggregates (mounds) and slugs are also organized by propagating cAMP waves and, furthermore, that cell-type-specific differences in signalling and chemotaxis result in cell sorting, slug formation and movement.     

Morphogenetic movements and multicellular development in the fruiting Myxobacterium, Stigmatella aurantiaca.

Stigmatella aurantiaca, strain DW-4, is a bacterium that grows as single cells in liquid culture but will synchronously aggregate and construct multicellular fruiting bodies when starved on an agar surface. The fruiting body consists of a stalk and several sporangia housing differentiated myxospores. Fruiting body development is stimulated by exposure of the aggregating cells to incandescent light.     

Morphogenesis of Stigmatella aurantiaca fruiting bodies.

Scanning electron micrographs of intermediate stages of fruiting body formation in the myxobacterium Stigmatella aurantiaca suggest that fruiting body formation can be divided into several stages distinguishable on the basis of the motile behavior of the cells. Aggregates formed at sites where cells glide as groups in circles or spirals. Thus, each aggregate was surrounded by a wide band of cells. Several streams of cells were pointed toward and connected to the wide band of cells at the base of the aggregate, suggesting directed cell movement toward the aggregate. The pattern of cells at the base of taller, more mature aggregates suggested that groups of cells enter the aggregate from the surrounding band of cells by changing the pitch of their movement, thus creating an ascending spiral. Stalk formation was characterized by a distinctly different pattern, which suggested that single cells emerge from the band of cells and move toward the aggregate, under it, and then vertically to create the stalk. At this stage, the aggregate appeared to be torn from the substrate as it was lifted off the surface. The cells in the completed stalks were well separated, and most had their long axes pointed in a vertical direction. A great deal of the stalk material appeared to be slime in which the cells were embedded and through which they were presumably moving in the live material. Some suggestions regarding factors that may direct the observed morphogenetic movements are discussed.     

Spatial organization of Myxococcus xanthus during fruiting body formation

Microcinematography was used to examine fruiting body development of Myxococcus xanthus. Wild-type cells progress through three distinct phases: a quiescent phase with some motility but little aggregation (0 to 8 h), a period of vigorous motility leading to raised fruiting bodies (8 to 16 h), and a period of maturation during which sporulation is initiated (16 to 48 h). Fruiting bodies are extended vertically in a series of tiers, each involving the addition of a cell monolayer on top of the uppermost layer. A pilA (MXAN_5783) mutant produced less extracellular matrix material and thus allowed closer examination of tiered aggregate formation. A csgA (MXAN_1294) mutant exhibited no quiescent phase, aberrant aggregation in phase 2, and disintegration of the fruiting bodies in the third phase.     

Alternative Developmental Pathways Determined by Environmental Conditions in the Cellular Slime Mold Dictyostelium discoideum

The cellular slime mold Dictyostelium discoideum grows in the soil as a population of independent, uninucleate amoebae. Upon entrance to the stationary phase, the amoebae collect in multicellular aggregates to form organized fruiting bodies composed of spores and stalk cells. Depending upon environmental conditions, the developing aggregate either constructs the fruiting body at the site of aggregation or transforms into a structure that can migrate to a more favorable location. Environmental conditions that favor migration are (i) the accumulation of metabolite(s) produced by the aggregate and (ii) a low ionic strength in the substratum. Conditions that prevent migration or that stop a migrating slug are (i) the presence of buffer and (ii) illumination by overhead light.     

Scanning electron microscopy of fruiting body formation by myxobacteria.

Scanning electron microscopy was used to follow fruiting body formation by pure cultures of Chondromyces crocatus M38 and Stigmatella aurantica. Vegetative cells were grown on SP agar and then transferred to Bonner salts agar for fructification. Fruiting in both species commences with the formation of aggregation centers which resemble a fried egg in appearance. In Chondromyces the elevated center or "yolk" region of the aggregation enlarges into a bulbous structure under which the stalk forms and lengthens. At maximum stalk height the bulb extends laterally as bud-like swellings appear. These are immature sporangia and are arranged in a distintive radial pattern around the top of the stalk. This symmetry is lost as more sporangia are formed. Stigmatella does not form a bulb; rather the yolk region of the aggregation center projects upward to form a column-like stalk which is nearly uniform in diameter throughout its length. At maximum stalk height, the terminus of the stalk develops an irregular pattern of bud-like swellings. These differentiate into sporangia. Stalks of 2-week-old mature fruiting bodies of both species appear to be cellular in composition. Stereomicrographs suggest orientation of these cells parallel to the long axis of the stalk. Stalks of 8-week-old fruiting bodies of Chondromyces were acellular and consisted of empty tubules, suggesting that the cells undergo degeneration with aging of the fruiting body.     

Induction of fruiting bodies in a macrocyst-forming mutant of the cellular slime mold, Dictyostelium mucomides

Some wild-type strains of Dictyostelium mucoroides exhibit dimorphism in development depending on culture conditions: on agar, fruiting bodies containing stalk and spore cells are formed, whereas under water, a thick-walled structure lacking spore and stalk cells (the macro-cyst) is formed. The mutant, MF-1, was derived from one of these wild-type strains. It forms macrocysts on an agar surfxe as well as under water. It was found that MF-1 could be induced to form fruiting bodies in two ways. First, when an aggregation center from the wild-type strain was grafted to an MF-1 aggregation center. MF-1 cells migrated to the center and formed a large aggregate that gave rise to many slugs that became fruiting bodies. This result, along with the observation that MF-1 aggregates have no tip, suggests that MF-1 normally produces an aggregation center that is unable to organize the aggregate to form a slug. Second, when MF-1 cells were allowed to develop on 1.2 mM ethionine (an analog of methionine), they formed aggregates with tips and developed into fruiting bodies with thick stalks instead of macrocysts. The effect of ethionine was blocked by the presence of 2.4 mM methio-nine. Two other methionine analogs were also tested, i.e., α-methylmethionine and norleucine. When cultured on the former at concentrations ranging from 1.2 to 9.6 mM, MF-1 cells still produced macrocysts; when cultured on norleucine at concentrations ranging from 2.4 to 9.6 mM, MF-1 cells aggregated into large clumps that formed numerous slugs, but these failed to continue development to fruiting bodies. In vertebrates, it is known that a major biochemical effect of ethionine is the inhibition of the methylation of nucleic acids, proteins, and phospholipids. Norleucine and a-methylmethionine inhibit methylation to a lesser extent. Thus, it can be speculated that the biological effects of ethionine on MF-1 cells may result from its interference with methylation reactions, suggesting that macrocyst formation may involve excess methylation as compared with the situation during fruiting-body development.     

Phylogenetic position of Sorogena stoianovitchae and relationships within the class Colpodea (Ciliophora) based on SSU rDNA sequences

The ciliate Sorogena stoianovitchae, which can form a multicellular fruiting body, has been classified based upon its ultrastructure and morphology: the oral and somatic infraciliature of S. stoianovitchae most closely resemble those of members of the order Cyrtolophosidida in the class Colpodea. We characterized the small subunit ribosomal DNA (SSU rDNA) gene sequence from S. stoianovitchae and compared this sequence with those from representatives of all ciliate classes. These analyses placed S. stoianovitchae as either sister to members of the class Nassophorea or Colpodea. In an in-group analysis, including all SSU rDNA sequences from members of the classes Nassophorea and Colpodea and representatives of appropriate outgroups, S. stoianovitchae was always sister to Platyophrya vorax (class Colpodea, order Cyrtolophosidida). However, our analyses failed to support the monophyly of the class Colpodea. Instead, our data suggest that there are essentially three unresolved clades: (1) the class Nassophorea; (2) Bresslaua vorax, Colpoda inflata, Pseudoplatyophrya nana, and Bursaria truncatella (class Colpodea); and (3) P. vorax and S. stoianovitchae (class Colpodea).     

Evolution of self-organisation in Dictyostelia by adaptation of a non-selective phosphodiesterase and a matrix component for regulated cAMP degradation

Dictyostelium discoideum amoebas coordinate aggregation and morphogenesis by secreting cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP) pulses that propagate as waves through fields of cells and multicellular structures. To retrace how this mechanism for self-organisation evolved, we studied the origin of the cAMP phosphodiesterase PdsA and its inhibitor PdiA, which are essential for cAMP wave propagation. D. discoideum and other species that use cAMP to aggregate reside in group 4 of the four major groups of Dictyostelia. We found that groups 1-3 express a non-specific, low affinity orthologue of PdsA, which gained cAMP selectivity and increased 200-fold in affinity in group 4. A low affinity group 3 PdsA only partially restored aggregation of a D. discoideum pdsA-null mutant, but was more effective at restoring fruiting body morphogenesis. Deletion of a group 2 PdsA gene resulted in disruption of fruiting body morphogenesis, but left aggregation unaffected. Together, these results show that groups 1-3 use a low affinity PdsA for morphogenesis that is neither suited nor required for aggregation. PdiA belongs to a family of matrix proteins that are present in all Dictyostelia and consist mainly of cysteine-rich repeats. However, in its current form with several extensively modified repeats, PdiA is only present in group 4. PdiA is essential for initiating spiral cAMP waves, which, by organising large territories, generate the large fruiting structures that characterise group 4. We conclude that efficient cAMP-mediated aggregation in group 4 evolved by recruitment and adaptation of a non-selective phosphodiesterase and a matrix component into a system for regulated cAMP degradation.     

Cell patterning in branched and unbranched fruiting bodies of the cellular slime mold Polysphondylium pallidum

Cell patterning, the percentage of spores and stalk cells, was measured in branched and unbranched asexual fruiting bodies of Polysphondylium pallidum. Unlike D. discoideum, where small and large fruiting bodies are more stalky than average-sized fruiting bodies, the overall cell patterning was the same in branched and unbranched fruiting bodies of all sizes in P. pallidum. Light greatly increased the numbers of fruiting bodies in P. pallidum per unit area (or decreased aggregation territory size) so that most fruiting bodies formed in the light were small and unbranched. By contrast, light had little effect on the cell patterning of P. pallidum, although there was a slight increase in the percentage of stalk cells in the light compared to the dark. This indicates that the mechanisms governing light sensitivity of aggregation territory size and cell patterning have different components in P. pallidum. The accuracy of cell patterning of individual branches of branched fruiting bodies was so imprecise as to leave doubt that patterning is occurring at the branch level. Individual whorls of branched fruiting bodies had a greater percentage spores (90%) than whole fruiting bodies (78%) and the cell patterning was relatively imprecise. Only in whole fruiting bodies was the spore:stalk ratio highly correlated. These findings are consistent with cell pattern determination operating at the whole aggregate level, rather than at the individual whorl or branch level in P. pallidum.     

Altruism, cheating, and anticheater adaptations in cellular slime molds

Cellular slime molds (CSMs) possess a remarkable life cycle that encompasses an extreme act of altruism. CSM cells live as individual amoebae until starved, then aggregate and ultimately transform themselves into a multicellular fruiting body. This fruiting body consists of stalk cells (altruists that eventually die) and spores (the beneficiaries of this sacrifice). Altruistic systems such as this are vulnerable to cheaters, which are individuals unrelated to the altruists that obtain the benefits provided by them without reciprocating. Here, we investigate two forces that can maintain CSM altruism despite cheating: kin selection and anticheater adaptations. First, we present new kinship-based models based on CSM developmental biology to evaluate the efficacy of kin selection. These models show that stalk-making genotypes can still be maintained when aggregations are initiated by multiple "founder" spores, provided that spores of stalkless fruiting bodies have low rates of dispersal and dispersal success is a concave function of stalk height. Second, we review proposals that several features of CSM development, such as the chemical suppression of the redifferentiation of prestalk cells into prespores, act as anticheater adaptations.     

The Fine Structure of the Scopula-Stalk Region of Vorticella convallaria

ABSTRACT. We examined by SEM and TEM the stalk-scopular junction, the stalk, and stalk formation in Vorticella convallaria Linnaeus, 1767. The stalk sheath is anchored to the walls of the scopular lip and to the scopular cilia by thin fibrils. Experimental extraction of these fibrils weakens this junction enough to separate the stalk from the cell body. Telotrochs escape from the stalk by means of violent contractions of the cell body, accelerated beating of the trochal band cilia, and twisting of the cell body against the stalk. The edges of the scopular lip spread over the scopular cilia after escape and, in some cases, fuse to enclose the entire, aboral scopular surface in a cupola-like structure. The sessile cells contain fewer and smaller scopular granules than telotrochs. The presence of disintegrating scopular granules in the stalk matrix of some sessile cells suggests that they contain material which is secreted over a period of time to form the stalk. Eruptive formation of the initial adhesive pad and quick elongation of the distal part of the stalk suggests a rapid exocytosis of the larger, more numerous granules of the telotroch. The stalk sheath is formed of fibrils making up complete and incomplete compartments peripherally arranged along the major stalk axis.     

Multicellular development in Myxococcus xanthus is stimulated by predator-prey interactions

Myxococcus xanthus is a predatory bacterium that exhibits complex social behavior. The most pronounced behavior is the aggregation of cells into raised fruiting body structures in which cells differentiate into stress-resistant spores. In the laboratory, monocultures of M. xanthus at a very high density will reproducibly induce hundreds of randomly localized fruiting bodies when exposed to low nutrient availability and a solid surface. In this report, we analyze how M. xanthus fruiting body development proceeds in a coculture with suitable prey. Our analysis indicates that when prey bacteria are provided as a nutrient source, fruiting body aggregation is more organized, such that fruiting bodies form specifically after a step-down or loss of prey availability, whereas a step-up in prey availability inhibits fruiting body formation. This localization of aggregates occurs independently of the basal nutrient levels tested, indicating that starvation is not required for this process. Analysis of early developmental signaling relA and asgD mutants indicates that they are capable of forming fruiting body aggregates in the presence of prey, demonstrating that the stringent response and A-signal production are surprisingly not required for the initiation of fruiting behavior. However, these strains are still defective in differentiating to spores. We conclude that fruiting body formation does not occur exclusively in response to starvation and propose an alternative model in which multicellular development is driven by the interactions between M. xanthus cells and their cognate prey.     

Quantitative analysis of the spatial distribution of ultrastructural differentiation markers during development ofDictyostelium discoideum

Summary The appearance and spatial distrubution of ultrastructural markers ofDictyostelium discoideum differentiation were quantitatively analysed. Our results combined with data from the literature on the functions of cells at various stages of development lead to the following conclusions. When food is no longer available all amoebae initially develop an autophagic apparatus in order to sustain metabolism. After slugs have been formed, autophagy is suppressed in the prespore cells. During aggregation a number of cells gradually form prespore characteristics. These cells arise at random but later they become located in the basal part of the tip-forming aggregate. From the early slug stage onwards, cells of the posterior two third region gradually enter into the prespore pathway. During prolonged slug migration the optimal acquirement of prespore characteristics is blocked. Cells of the anterior region show no active differentiation but they maintain the morphology and most of the functions of aggregating cells. At the rear-guard of the slug and later on in the basal region of the maturing fruiting body, a second anteriorlike region appears. Actual stalk cell differentiation takes place only at the apex and at the base of the developing fruiting body.     

The organisation of fruiting body formation in Dictyostelium minutum

The process of culmination was investigated in three strains of the species Dictyostelium minutum. After aggregates have been formed a pulsatile signalling mechanism arises; the centre of signal emission becomes the apex of the developing fruiting structure. In the late aggregate, all cells differentiate into prespore cells. Cells that have reached the apex of the culminating cells mass redifferentiate into stalk cells. In two of the three D. minutum strains, interruption of regular stalk formation, more or less random formation of stalk cells and the synthesis of stalk supporting material from cell debris often takes place. The formation of multiple apices on aggregates and early fruiting structures is characteristic for these two strains. Within the species D. minutum, the exhibition of a marked pulsatile signalling mechanism is correlated with a capacity to form a regularly shaped stalk and to organize relatively large cell masses. The possible function of pulsatile signalling in the culmination process is discussed.     

The Structure and Composition of the Stalk of the Ciliated Protozoan Sorogena stoianovitchae1

Sorogena stoianovitchae is an unusual ciliated protozoan with a life cycle characterized by the aggregation of individual trophic cells to form a multicellular sorogen that rises from the liquid culture medium surface by the secretion of a stalk. The noncellular stalk is a tapered, longitudinally furrowed structure composed of a fibrillar matrix that is initially hydrated, but with time dehydrates, the stalk becoming thin and brittle. This dehydration is of importance from the earliest stages of stalk formation since it results in the formation of the outer sheath-like region of the stalk that appears to provide much of the support of the stalk. Cytochemical tests of the stalk for polysaccharides (including acidic mucopolysaccharides) and proteins are positive. Proteolytic enzymes degrade the stalk. Lectins specific for glucose and N-acetyl-D-glucosamine bind to the stalk. Gas chromatography analysis detected the presence of fucose, glucose, glucosamine, and arabinose, as well as a variety of amino acids, predominantly glycine. The cytochemical and biochemical tests, the ultrastructural data, and the behavior of the stalk material suggest that the staik is composed of a matrix of complex protein-polysaccharide molecules.     

Synthesis of several membrane proteins during developmental aggregation in Myxococcus xanthus

We have examined the pattern of synthesis of several membrane proteins during the aggregation phase of development in Myxococcus xanthus. Development was initiated by plating vegetative cells on polycarbonate filters placed on top of an agar medium that supported fruiting body formation. At various times during aggregation a filter was removed, the cells were pulse-labeled with [35S]methionine, and the membrane proteins were separated by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The rate of synthesis of numerous individual proteins changed during aggregation; we concentrated on six whose pattern of synthesis was greatly altered during aggregation. The rate of synthesis of five of the six proteins increased considerably during aggregation; that of the remaining protein was curtailed and appeared to be regulated by nutrient conditions. Three of the five major membrane proteins that increased during aggregation had a unique pattern of synthesis that was displayed only under conditions that are are required for development - high cell density, nutrient depletion, and a solid (agar) surface. The remaining two proteins were not unique to development; the appearance of one protein could be induced under conditions of high cell density, whereas the other could be induced by placing the cells on a solid agar surface. All of the five major proteins that appeared during development did so during the preaggregation stage, and the synthesis of four of the five proteins appeared to be curtailed late in aggregation. The synthesis of the remaining protein continued throughout aggregation.     

Potential morphogens involved in pattern formation during Dictyostelium differentiation.

Upon starvation, Dictyostelium amoebae aggregate together and then differentiate into either the stalk or spore cells that, respectively, form the stalk and sorus of the fruiting body. During differentiation, the prestalk and prespore cells become spatially segregated in a clearly defined developmental pattern. Several low molecular weight molecules that influence cell type determination during in vitro differentiation have been identified. The possible role of these molecules as morphogens, responsible for the formation of the developmental pattern, is discussed.