Flexibility in monomeric Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase detected by limited proteolysis and molecular dynamics simulation

Limited proteolysis by trypsin of monomeric Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase from Escherichia coli induces a specific cleavage of the polypeptide chain at the level of Lys60 located in the S-S subloop of loop 6,5 where, when compared to the eukaryotic enzyme, a seven-residues insertion, completely exposed to the solvent, is observed. This result suggests that this subloop is disordered and flexible, thus enabling binding and adaptation to the active site of the proteolytic enzyme. Indeed, molecular dynamics simulation indicates that the S-S subloop undergoes high fluctuations and that its high flexibility coupled to an high solvent accessibility can explain the specific bond selection of the protease. As a matter of fact, of the possible 14 solvent accessible proteolytic sites only the Lys60 flexible site is cleaved. High flexibility and solvent exposure are confirmed by the short water residence time for the residues corresponding to the cleavage site evaluated by molecular dynamics simulation. These experiments demonstrate that molecular dynamics simulation and limited proteolysis are complementary and unambiguous tools to identify flexible sites in proteins.     

Degradation of proteins microinjected into HeLa cells. The role of substrate flexibility

Increasing the flexibility of a protein enhances its susceptibility to defined proteases in vitro. To ascertain whether flexibility also affects protein stability in vivo, radioiodinated proteins with similar structures, but dissimilar flexibilities, were introduced into HeLa cells using red cell-mediated microinjection. Intracellular proteolysis was then measured as the rate of release of 125I-tyrosine into the medium. Ribonuclease A was considerably more resistant to degradation by purified proteases or in reticulocyte lysate than its flexible derivatives ribonuclease S and S-protein. In contrast, all three proteins were equally stable within HeLa cells. Like the results obtained for RNases, the rates of degradation of trypsin inhibitors, trypsin analogs, and their complexes correlated with flexibility in reticulocyte lysate. However, the intracellular half-lives of anhydrotrypsin and various proteinaceous trypsin inhibitors were not affected upon formation of enzyme-inhibitor complexes. Furthermore, trypsinogen was degraded more slowly than the structurally similar anhydrotrypsin in HeLa cells, although trypsinogen has additional segmental flexibility in its activation domain. Electrophoretic analyses revealed that trypsin-inhibitor complexes remained intact following injection into HeLa cells, and that neither free inhibitors nor anhydrotrypsin formed Triton-stable complexes with soluble cytoplasmic proteins. The observation that the components of the trypsin-inhibitor complexes were degraded simultaneously indicates that neither constituent unfolded prior to the onset of proteolysis. These studies provide evidence that RNases, trypsin, and trypsin inhibitors are degraded by an intracellular proteolytic pathway(s) which recognizes surface features of the folded proteins.     

Limited proteolysis of native proteins: the interaction between avidin and proteinase K.

Avidin is a tetramer of 16-kDa subunits that have a high affinity for biotin. Proteolysis of native apoavidin by proteinase K results in a limited attack at the loop between beta-strands 3 and 4, involving amino acids 38-43. Specifically, sites of proteolysis are at Thr 40-Ser 41 and Asn 42-Glu 43. The limited proteolysis results in an avidin product that remains otherwise intact and which has enhanced binding for 4'-hydroxyazobenzene-2-benzoic acid (HABA), a chromogenic reporter that can occupy the biotin-binding site. Saturation of the biotin-binding site with the natural ligand protects avidin from proteolysis, but saturation with HABA enhances the rate of proteolysis of the same site. Analysis of the three-dimensional structures of apoavidin and holoavidin reveals that the 3-4 loop is accessible to solvent and scores highly in an algorithm developed to identify sites of proteolytic attack. The structure of holoavidin is almost identical to the apoprotein. In particular, the 3-4 loop has the same structure in the apo and holo forms, yet there are marked differences in proteolytic susceptibility of this region. Evidence suggests that the 3-4 loop is rather mobile and flexible in the apoprotein, and that it becomes constrained upon ligand binding. In one crystal structure of the apoprotein, this loop appears constrained by contacts with symmetry-related molecules. Structural analyses suggest that the "lid" to the biotin-binding site, formed by the 3-4 loop, is displaced and made more accessible by HABA binding, thereby enhancing its proteolytic susceptibility.     

Local fluctuations vs. global unfolding of proteins investigated by limited proteolysis

The structure of a protein molecule consists of both rigid and flexible sections to satisfy the demands for stability and catalysis. Because the flexibility of a protein segment is indispensable for a proteolytic attack, limited proteolysis is a superb tool to analyse both confined local fluctuations and global unfolding events in proteins. While the identification of the primary cleavage products allows the assignment of the flexible regions to the primary structure, the kinetics of proteolytic degradation enables differentiation between local fluctuations in the native protein molecule and the global unfolding process during denaturation. Modifications of the amino acid sequence in the concerned regions can tune proteolytic susceptibility and alter protein stability. In the present paper, we summarise our results on native-state and unfolded-state proteolysis of ribonuclease A (RNase A) and the effect of mutations in the detected flexible regions on the stability and unfolding of the RNase A molecule.     

Local fluctuations vs. global unfolding of proteins investigated by limited proteolysis

The structure of a protein molecule consists of both rigid and flexible sections to satisfy the demands for stability and catalysis. Because the flexibility of a protein segment is indispensable for a proteolytic attack, limited proteolysis is a superb tool to analyse both confined local fluctuations and global unfolding events in proteins. While the identification of the primary cleavage products allows the assignment of the flexible regions to the primary structure, the kinetics of proteolytic degradation enables differentiation between local fluctuations in the native protein molecule and the global unfolding process during denaturation. Modifications of the amino acid sequence in the concerned regions can tune proteolytic susceptibility and alter protein stability. In the present paper, we summarise our results on native-state and unfolded-state proteolysis of ribonuclease A (RNase A) and the effect of mutations in the detected flexible regions on the stability and unfolding of the RNase A molecule.     

Assessment of the conformational features of vasoactive intestinal peptide in solution by limited proteolysis experiments

The structural features of vasoactive intestinal peptide (VIP) and of its Gln16-diaminopropane derivative (VIP-DAP) in solution were investigated by limited proteolysis experiments with trypsin and thermolysin. The proteolysis of the native peptide by both proteinases takes place near the residues in positions 12 and 21/22, suggesting that these amino acids are embedded in segments more flexible than the rest of the molecule. VIP-DAP appears to be more resistant to the proteolytic attack of trypsin, indicating that the derivatization in position 16 is able to stabilize the structure of the peptide. Moreover, the analysis of the mass spectra of the proteolytic mixtures supports the evidence that the derivatization is also able to protect Met17 against oxidation. From these data it can be concluded that VIP in solution under physiological conditions is characterized by the presence of segments with secondary structure, linked together by "hinge" regions that confer flexibility to the peptide, whereas VIP-DAP is embedded in a more rigid conformation, more suitable to receptor interaction.     

Proteolytic sensitivity and helper T-cell epitope immunodominance associated with the mobile loop in Hsp10s.

Antigen three-dimensional structure potentially limits antigen processing and presentation to helper T-cell epitopes. The association of helper T-cell epitopes with the mobile loop in Hsp10s from mycobacteria and bacteriophage T4 suggests that the mobile loop facilitates proteolytic processing and presentation of adjacent sequences. Sites of initial proteolytic cleavage were mapped in divergent Hsp10s after treatment with a variety of proteases including cathepsin S. Each protease preferentially cleaved the Hsp10s in the mobile loop. Flexibility in the 22-residue mobile loop most probably allows it to conform to protease active sites. Three variants of the bacteriophage T4 Hsp10 were constructed with deletions in the mobile loop to test the hypothesis that shorter loops would be less sensitive to proteolysis. The two largest deletions effectively inhibited proteolysis by several proteases. Circular dichroism spectra and chemical cross-linking of the deletion variants indicate that the secondary and quaternary structures of the variants are native-like, and all three variants were more thermostable than the wild-type Hsp10. Local structural flexibility appears to be a general requirement for proteolytic sensitivity, and thus, it could be an important factor in antigen processing and helper T-cell epitope immunogenicity.     

Structural domains of human apolipoprotein B-100. Differential accessibility to limited proteolysis of B-100 in low density and very low density lipoproteins

The structural domains of human apolipoprotein B-100 in low density lipoproteins (LDL) and the conformational changes of B-100 that accompany the conversion of very low density lipoproteins (VLDL) to LDL were investigated by limited proteolysis with 12 endoproteases of various specificities, and their cleavage sites were determined. In B-100 of LDL, we identified two peptide regions that are highly susceptible to proteolytic cleavage. One region encompassed about 40 amino acids (residues 1280-1320, designated as the NH2-terminal region) and the other about 100 amino acids (residues 3180-3280, designated as the COOH-terminal region). IN LDL, the cleavage sites in both susceptible regions of B-100 were readily accessible to limited proteolysis; but in VLDL, only sites in the COOH-terminal region were readily accessible. Moreover, B-100 in VLDL appeared less degraded than B-100 in LDL by all enzymes used. Reduction of disulfide bonds of B-100 in both LDL and VLDL before digestion by Staphylococcus aureus V8 protease and clostripain exposed additional cleavage sites and increased the rate of B-100 degradation, suggesting that disulfide bonds probably exert conformational constraints. These results indicate the presence of three principal structural domains in B-100 of LDL that are relatively resistant to limited proteolysis. These three domains are connected by the two susceptible peptide regions. Our results also demonstrate differential accessibility of cleavage sites in B-100 of LDL and VLDL to limited proteolysis. This differential accessibility suggests that substantial changes in the conformation or environment of B-100 accompany the conversion of VLDL to LDL.     

Limited proteolysis in the investigation of beta2-microglobulin amyloidogenic and fibrillar states

Amyloid fibrils of patients treated with regular haemodialysis essentially consists of beta2-microglobulin (beta2-m) and its truncated species DeltaN6beta2-m lacking six residues at the amino terminus. The truncated fragment shows a higher propensity to self-aggregate and constitutes an excellent candidate for the analysis of a protein in the amyloidogenic conformation. The surface topology and the conformational analysis of native beta2-m and the truncated DeltaN6beta2-m species both in the soluble and in the fibrillar forms were investigated by the limited proteolysis/mass spectrometry strategy. The conformation in solution of a further truncated mutant DeltaN3beta2-m lacking three residues at the N-terminus was also examined. This approach appeared particularly suited to investigate the regions that are solvent-exposed, or flexible enough to be accessible to protein-protein interactions and to describe the conformation of transient intermediates. Moreover, proteolysis experiments can also be tailored to investigate amyloid fibrils by discriminating the protein regions constituting the unaccessible core of the fibrils and those still flexible and exposed to the solvent. Although native beta2-m and DeltaN3beta2-m shared essentially the same conformation, significative structural differences exist between the native and the DeltaN6beta2-m proteins in solution with major differences located at the end moiety of strand V and subsequent loop with strand VI and at both the N- and C-termini of the proteins. On the contrary, an identical distribution of preferential proteolytic sites was observed in both proteins in the fibrillar state, which was nearly superimposible to that observed for the soluble form of DeltaN6beta2-m. These data revealed that synthetic fibrils essentially consists of an unaccessible core comprising residues 20-87 of the beta2-m protein with exposed and flexible N- and C-terminal ends. Moreover, proteolytic cleavages observed in vitro at Lys 6 and Lys 19 reproduce specific cleavages that have to take place in vivo to generate the truncated forms of beta2-m occurring in natural fibrils. On the basis of these results, a molecular mechanism for fibril formation has been proposed.     

Probing protein structure by limited proteolysis

Limited proteolysis experiments can be successfully used to probe conformational features of proteins. In a number of studies it has been demonstrated that the sites of limited proteolysis along the polypeptide chain of a protein are characterized by enhanced backbone flexibility, implying that proteolytic probes can pinpoint the sites of local unfolding in a protein chain. Limited proteolysis was used to analyze the partly folded (molten globule) states of several proteins, such as apomyoglobin, alpha-lactalbumin, calcium-binding lysozymes, cytochrome c and human growth hormone. These proteins were induced to acquire the molten globule state under specific solvent conditions, such as low pH. In general, the protein conformational features deduced from limited proteolysis experiments nicely correlate with those deriving from other biophysical and spectroscopic techniques. Limited proteolysis is also most useful for isolating protein fragments that can fold autonomously and thus behave as protein domains. Moreover, the technique can be used to identify and prepare protein fragments that are able to associate into a native-like and often functional protein complex. Overall, our results underscore the utility of the limited proteolysis approach for unravelling molecular features of proteins and appear to prompt its systematic use as a simple first step in the elucidation of structure-dynamics-function relationships of a novel and rare protein, especially if available in minute amounts.     

Pericellular proteolysis by leukocytes and tumor cells on substrates: focal activation and the role of urokinase-type plasminogen activator

Previous studies have shown that the urokinase-type plasminogen activator receptor (uPAR) is localized to the adherence sites of leukocytes and tumor cells suggesting that pericellular proteolysis may accompany focal activation of adherence. To assess for focused pericellular proteolytic activity, we prepared two-dimensional substrates coated with FITC-casein or Bodipy FL-BSA. These molecules are poorly fluorescent, but become highly fluorescent after proteolytic degradation. Fluorescent peptide products were observed at adherence sites of stationary human neutrophils and at lamellipodia of polarized neutrophils. During cell migration, multiple regions of proteolysis appeared sequentially beneath the cell. Similarly, proteolytic action was restricted to adherence sites of resting HT1080 tumor cells but localized to the invadopodia of active cells. Using an extracellular fluorescence quenching method, we demonstrate that these fluorescent peptide products are extracellular. The uPA/uPAR system played an important role in the observed proteolytic activation. Plasminogen activator inhibitor-1 significantly reduced focal proteolysis. Sites of focal proteolysis matched the membrane distribution of uPAR. When uPA was dissociated from uPAR by acid washing, substantially reduced pericellular proteolysis was found. uPAR-negative T47D tumor cells did not express significant levels of substrate proteolysis. However, transfectant clones expressing uPAR (for example, T47D-26) displayed high levels of fluorescence indicating proteolysis at adherence sites. To provide further evidence for the role of the uPA/uPAR system in pericellular proteolysis, peritoneal macrophages from uPA knock-out (uPA–/–) and control (uPA+/+) mice were studied. Pericellular proteolysis was dramatically reduced in uPA-negative peritoneal macrophages. Thus, we have: (1) developed a novel methodology to detect pericellular proteolytic function, (2) demonstrated focused activation of proteolytic enzymatic activity in several cell types, (3) demonstrated its usefulness in real-time studies of cell migration, and (4) showed that the uPA/uPAR system is an important contributor to focal pericellular proteolysis.     

Conformational analysis of putative regulatory subunit D of the toluene/o-xylene-monooxygenase complex from Pseudomonas stutzeri OX1

A gene cluster isolated from Pseudomonas stutzeri OX1 genomic DNA and containing six ORFs codes for toluene/o-xylene-monooxygenase. The putative regulatory D subunit was expressed in Escherichia coli and purified. Its protein sequence was verified by mass spectrometry mapping and found to be identical to the sequence predicted on the basis of the DNA sequence. The surface topology of subunit D in solution was probed by limited proteolysis carried out under strictly controlled conditions using several proteases as proteolytic probes. The same experiments were carried out on the homologous P2 component of the multicomponent phenol hydroxylase from Pseudomonas putida CF600. The proteolytic fragments released from both proteins in their native state were analyzed by electrospray mass spectrometry, and the preferential cleavage sites were assessed. The results indicated that despite the relatively high similarity between the sequences of the two proteins, some differences in the distribution of preferential proteolytic cleavages were detected, and a much higher conformational flexibility of subunit D was inferred. Moreover, automatic modeling of subunit D was attempted, based on the known three-dimensional structure of P2. Our results indicate that, at least in this case, standard modeling procedures based on automatic alignment on the structure of P2 fail to produce a model consistent with limited proteolysis experimental data. Thus, it is our opinion that reliable techniques such as limited proteolysis can be employed to test three-dimensional models and highlight problems in automatic model building.     

Local flexibility facilitates oxidization of buried methionine residues

In proteins, all amino acid residues are susceptible to oxidation by various reactive oxygen species (ROS), with methionine and cysteine residues being particularly sensitive to oxidation. Methionine oxidation is known to lead to destabilization and inactivation of proteins, and oxidatively modified proteins can accumulate during aging, oxidative stress, and in various age-related diseases. Although the efficiency of a given methionine oxidation can depend on its solvent accessibility (evaluated from a protein structure as the accessible surface area of the corresponding methionine residue), many experimental results on oxidation rate and oxidation sites cannot be unequivocally explained by the methionine solvent accessible surface area alone. In order to explore other possible mechanisms, we analyzed a set of seventy-one oxidized methionines contained in thirty-one proteins by various bioinformatics tools. In which, 41% of the methionines are exposed, 15% are buried but with various degree of flexibility, and the rest 44% are buried and structured. Buried but highly flexible methionines can be oxidized. Buried and less flexible methionines can acquire additional local structural flexibility from flanking regions to facilitate the oxidation. Oxidation of buried and structured methionine can also be promoted by the oxidation of neighboring methionine that is more exposed and/or flexible. Our data are consistent with the hypothesis that protein structural flexibility represents another important factor favoring the oxidation process.     

Damage increases the flexibility of duplex DNA

It is proposed that much of the recognition of specific types of damaged DNAs is based on accessible structural features, while much of the recognition of damaged DNAs, as a class, is based on flexibility. The more flexible a DNA the faster its diffusion rate. The diffusion rates of each member of a series of damaged duplex DNAs has been found to be significantly faster than that of the corresponding undamaged duplex DNA. The damaged sites studied include apurinic and apyrimidinic a basic sites, thymine glycol and urea. The presence of mismatched sites also increases the diffusion. Thus, damaged DNAs appear to have sufficient flexibility for recognition and the flexibility may allow damaged sites to act as a universal joint or hinge that allows distant sites on the DNA to come together.     

Autolysis of a novel multidomain subtilase-cold-adapted deseasin MCP-01 is pH-dependent and the surface loops in its catalytic domain, the linker, and the P_proprotein domain are susceptible to proteolytic attack

Cold-adapted deseasin MCP-01 is a novel type subtilase with a multidomain structure containing a catalytic domain, a linker, a P_proprotein domain, and a PKD domain. Its autolysis was pH-dependent due to its flexible structure. N-terminal sequence analysis of the autolytic peptides revealed four autolytic sites in the catalytic domain. Three of these are in the same loops as mesophilic subtilases and one is unlike anything previously reported. Two autolytic sites were deduced in its linker and three in its P_proprotein domain, indicating the linker and the P_proprotein domain are flexible and susceptible to proteolytic attacks. Therefore, during MCP-01 autolysis, the linker and the P_proprotein domain of MCP-01 were easily attacked by proteolysis, resulting in cleavage of the C-terminal region. At the same time, some autolytic sites in the surface loops of the catalytic domain were cleaved. This is the first report describing the autolytic mechanism of a multidomain subtilase.     

Proteolysis of human trypsinogen 1. Pathogenic implication in chronic pancreatitis

SDS electrophoresis on polyacrylamide gels of purified trypsinogen 1 has shown the occurence of a proteolysis in some molecules during long storage at ?20°C. This proteolyzed trypsinogen gives a positive reaction with an antiserum directed against the precipitate protein, major protein of about 14 000 molecular weight extracted from precipitates present in the pancreatic juice of patients with chronic pancreatitis. The autoactivation of proteolyzed trypsinogen 1 liberates a polypeptide of 14 000 molecular weight which is immunologically identical to the precipitate protein. These results show that the major protein present in pancreatic precipitates (and pancreatic stones) of patients with chronic pancreatitis is a degradation product of trypsinogen 1 liberated by a proteolysis which necessarily requires a premature zymogen activation in the disease.     

Correlation between sites of limited proteolysis and segmental mobility in thermolysin

Limited proteolysis or autolysis of thermolysin under different experimental conditions leads to fission of a small number of peptide bonds located in exposed surface segments of the polypeptide chain characterized by highest mobility, as given by the temperature factors (B values) determined crystallographically [Holmes, M.A., & Matthews, B.W. (1982) J. Mol. Biol. 160, 623-639]. Considering also similar findings observed previously with other protein systems, it is proposed that this correlation between segmental mobility and sites of limited proteolysis in globular proteins is quite general. Thus, flexibility of the polypeptide chain of a globular protein at the site of proteolytic attack promotes optimal binding and proper interaction with the active site of the protease. These findings emphasize that apparent thermal motion seen in protein crystals is relevant to motion in solution and appear to be of general significance in protein-protein recognition processes.     

Calcium-induced sensitization of the central helix of calmodulin to proteolysis.

The rate of proteolysis of trypsin-sensitive bonds was used to examine the nature of the structural changes accompanying Ca2+ and Mg2+ binding to calmodulin. In the Ca(2+)-free form, the rates of proteolysis at Arg-106 and Arg-37 are rapid (greater than 300 and 28 nmol min-1 mL-1, respectively), the bonds at Arg-74, Lys-75, and Lys-77, in the central helix, are cleaved more slowly (10 nmol min-1 mL-1), and a lag in the cleavage at the remaining bonds (Lys-13, Lys-30, Arg-86, Arg-90, and Arg-126) suggests that they are not cleaved in the native protein. High concentrations of Ca2+, but not Mg2+, almost completely abolish proteolysis at Arg-106 and drastically reduce the rate of cleavage at Arg-37. Both Ca2+ and Mg2+ exert a moderate protective effect on the proteolysis of the central helix. These results suggest that the F-helix of domains III and, to a lesser extent, the F-helix of domain I are somewhat flexible in the Ca(2+)-free form and are stabilized by Ca2+. Whereas full occupancy of the four Ca(2+)-binding sites produces little change in the susceptibility of the central helix to proteolytic attack, binding of two Ca2+ produces a 10-fold enhancement of the rate of proteolysis in this part of the molecule. We propose that at intermediate Ca2+ levels the flexibility of the central helix of calmodulin is greatly increased, resulting in the transient formation of intermediates which have not been detected by spectroscopic techniques but are trapped by the irreversible action of trypsin.