Aromatase activity in gonads of turtle embryos as a function of the incubation temperature of eggs

In embryos of the European pond turtle, sexual differentiation of gonads is temperature-dependent. Production of oestrogens appears to play a key role in this phenomenon. Gonadal aromatase activity was measured in embryos incubated at 25°C (masculinizing temperature) and at 30°C (feminizing temperature). At the beginning of the thermosensitive period, the aromatase activity was low at both temperatures but was somewhat higher at 30 than at 25°C. Afterwards, it remained low in differentiating testes at 25°C, whereas it increased in differentiating ovaries at 30°C to form a marked peak when germ cells underwent meiotic prophase. Eggs were shifted either from 25 to 30°C (highly feminizing) or from 30 to 35°C for 6 days at different stages of embryonic development. The 25–35°C shifts performed during the thermosensitive period strongly increased the aromatase activity but were ineffective after this period. The 30–35°C shifts increased the aromatase activity at all stages. Altogether, results indicate that, in differentiating gonads of turtle embryos, temperature acts on the regulation of synthesis (and therefore activity) of cytochrome P-450 aromatase (P-450-aro). The expression of the P-450-aro gene itself could be temperature-dependent. However, temperature could also act upon the expression of another gene involved in P-450-aro regulation.     

Involvement of oestrogens in sexual differentiation of gonads as a function of temperature in turtles

Abstract. To investigate the possible involvement of oestrogens in the phenomenon of temperature sex-reversal in the turtle Emys orbicularis , the effects of oestrone, oestradiol and an antioestrogen. tamoxifen, on sexual differentiation of gonads were examined at a male-producing temperature of 25° C and at a female-producing temperature of 30° C. When oestrone or oestradiol were injected into eggs incubated at 25° C just before or at the beginning of the thermosensitive period, the gonads differentiated into ovaries instead of testes. Conversely, when tamoxifen was injected, at the same stages, into eggs incubated at 30° C, epithelial cords or tubes, similar to potential seminiferous cords, differentiated in the interior part of the gonads. However, an ovarian-like cortex persisted at their surface. At 25° C, treatment with tamoxifen or with both tamoxifen and oestradiol also resulted in differentiation of ovotestes. These experiments show that tamoxifen binding to oestrogen receptors prevented the inhibitory action of oestrogens on testicular cord development. Maintenance (at 30° C) or development (at 25° C) of ovarian cortex in the presence of tamoxifen can be expected from an agonistic action of this drug, as already described. Preliminary data on steroid content in the gonads indicate that, during the early stages of the thermosensitive period, the level of estrogens is higher at 30° C than at 25° C. It is proposed that in species displaying temperature sensitivity for the sexual differentiation of gonads, temperature acts on the processes regulating the synthesis or the activity of cyto-chrome-P450 aromatase.     

Expression of P450(arom) in Malaclemys terrapin and Chelydra serpentina: a tale of two sites.

The formation of estrogens from androgens in all vertebrates is catalyzed by the "aromatase" complex, which consists of a membrane bound P(450) enzyme, P(450) aromatase (which binds the androgen substrate and inserts an oxygen into the molecule), and a flavoprotein (NADPH-cytochrome P450 reductase). Among vertebrates, the two major sites of aromatase expression are the brain and gonads. Given the importance of estrogen in reptile sex determination, we set out to examine whether P450arom was involved in the initiation and/or stabilization of sex determination in turtles. We examined the expression of aromatase activity in the brain and gonads of two turtle species exhibiting temperature dependent sex determination (TSD), the diamondback terrapin (Malaclemys terrapin), and the common snapping turtle (Chelydra serpentina). Estradiol when applied at stage 14 of the terrapin induces expression of aromatase in the gonad of embryos incubated at male temperatures (26.5 degrees C). The level of expression is similar to that of a normal embryonic ovary. When applied at stage 22, estradiol does not induce aromatase expression in the terrapin. The xenoestrogen, nonylphenol, sex reverses terrapin embryos at 26.5 degrees C. Letrazole, a nonsteroidal aromatase inhibitor, suppresses aromatase activity in the brain at either incubation temperature. Ovotestes are produced by letrazole administration in the terrapin when incubated at 30.5 degrees C. In the snapping turtle at stage 23, gonadal and brain aromatase activity in embryos incubated at female temperatures (30.5 degrees C) is nearly half that exhibited in terrapin embryos at the same temperature. Moreover, letrazole administration suppresses aromatase expression to nearly basal levels. At male incubation temperatures (26.5 degrees ), brain aromatase expression is nearly three times higher than at female temperatures, while gonadal expression levels are nearly one third lower. However, the gonadal expression levels at male temperatures in the snapping turtle are nearly 25 times higher than that found in the terrapin. Estradiol administration elevates this level nearly three fold. These data suggest that is not merely the expression of aromatase that is important for ovarian development, but that the level of expression may be more important.     

Immunologic identification of the aromatase enzyme system in human endometrium

Confluent human endometrial stromal cells were cultured in medium with no hormone or supplemented with medroxyprogesterone acetate (MPA), estradiol (E2), and porcine relaxin (RLX) for 5 days. These stromal cells were then labeled with [35S]methionine for 3 h. The radioactive proteins in the particulate fraction of cell homogenate were extracted by detergent and incubated with antisera to purified placental aromatase cytochrome P-450 (P-450arom) and NADPH-cytochrome P-450 reductase to isolate the radio-labeled aromatase enzyme components. Analysis of the radio-labeled protein, isolated by antibody to the cytochrome P-450arom from different preparations (P45FBIII or R-8-2) showed a major band at molecular weight 54k on SDS polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE). The intensity of 54k band was stronger in hormone treated stromal cells than that of control in parallel with the increase of aromatase activity. The radio-labeled protein isolated by anti-NADPH cytochrome P-450 reductase, REDFBIV, showed a major band at the molecular weight 73k on SDS-PAGE with comparable intensity in control and hormone treated samples. Thus, the apparent molecular weights of endometrial cytochrome P-450arom and cytochrome P-450 reductase were identical to placental aromatase enzyme system. When a secretory endometrium and a decidua were labeled with [35S]methionine, the cytochrome P-450arom was detected only in the decidua. NADPH cytochrome P-450 reductase was detected both in the endometrium and the decidua. These results show that antisera to placental aromatase enzyme system cross reacts with the endometrial aromatase enzyme components. The synthesis of cytochrome P-450arom was stimulated by MPA, E2 and RLX while the synthesis of the NADPH-cytochrome P-450 reductase aromatase component was not affected by the hormone.     

Sequence analysis and expression of the P450 aromatase and estrogen receptor genes in the Xenopus ovary

Recent studies point to a key role for the estrogen synthesizing enzyme P450 aromatase (P450 arom) in ovary determination in fish, birds and reptiles. It is unclear whether estrogen synthesis is important in sex determination of Xenopus gonad. To determine whether the aromatase gene is transcribed in the gonads of Xenopus tadpoles during the sex determination, we cloned a P450 arom cDNA and examined the level of P450 arom and estrogen receptor (ER) gene expression in association with estrogen activity. cDNA clones for P450 arom were isolated from a Xenopus ovarian cDNA library. There was an open reading frame (ORF) of 1500 bp from the ATG start to TAA stop codons encoding 500 predicted amino acids. cDNAs for P450 arom have previously been cloned from various vertebrates. The homology between the Xenopus P450 aromatase and the human P450 arom was higher. The expression of the P450 arom gene was mainly limited to reproductive organs. To determine the beginning of estrogen activity in gonads of embryos, expression of the aromatase and ER gene was also examined by RQ-RT-PCR. Both Xenopus aromatase and ER mRNA was detected at stage 51 in gonads. These observations are consistent with estrogens having a key role in ovarian development in various other vertebrates.     

P450 aromatase expression in the temperature-sensitive sexual differentiation of salamander (Hynobius retardatus) gonads

Sex differentiation of gonads in amphibians is believed to be controlled genetically, but altered epigenetically or environmentally. When larvae of the salamander Hynobius retardatus were reared at defined temperatures from hatching to metamorphic stages, a high temperature (28 degrees C) induced exclusively female gonads (ovaries), whereas intermediate (20 and 23 degrees C) or lower (16 degrees C) temperatures produced a 1:1 sex ratio of the morphological gonads. The thermosensitive period was determined to be restricted from 15 to 30 days after hatching, just before or when sexual differentiation occurred. Hynobius P450 aromatase (P450arom) cDNA was isolated from adult gonads and the partial nucleotide or deduced amino acid sequences were determined, showing a high level of identity with various vertebrate species. The P450arom gene was expressed predominantly in the adult ovary and brain, weakly in testis, but not in other somatic organs. A typical sexual dimorphism in P450arom expression was detected in normally developing larvae by a quantitative competitive RT-PCR; strong expression in the female gonads but very weak in male gonads. The dimorphism was detected much earlier than the morphological sexual differentiation of the gonads. When larvae were reared at the female-producing temperature (28 degrees C), strong expression was detected in all the temperature-treated larvae, suggesting that P450arom was up-regulated, even in genetic males. Our results confirm the importance of the P450arom regulation in the sexual differentiation of gonads and demonstrate that an up-regulation of P450arom is involved in the process of temperature-sensitive sex reversal in this species.     

An aromatase inhibitor or high water temperature induce oocyte apoptosis and depletion of P450 aromatase activity in the gonads of genetic female zebrafish during sex-reversal

Dietary administration of a cytochrome P450 aromatase (P450arom) inhibitor (fadrozole) in genetic female juveniles of zebrafish (Danio rerio) was performed at 15-40 days post-hatching. The percentage of gonadal masculinization in the genetic all-females at 40 days post-hatching, treated with 0, 10, 100 and 1000 microg fadrozole g(-1) diet(-1) were 0, 62.5, 100 and 100%, respectively. Rearing at high water temperature in genetic all-females was performed at 15-25 days post-hatching. The percentage of gonadal masculinization in the genetic all-females at 40 days post-hatching, at water temperatures of 28.5, 35 and 37 degrees C were 0, 68.8 and 100%, respectively. Terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-mediated dUTP nick-end labeling (TUNEL)-positive oocytes of early diplotene and perinucleolar stages in fadrozole-treated genetic females (1000 microg g(-1) diet(-1)) were observed at 15-40 days post-hatching during sex-reversal. In contrast, apoptotic oocytes of early diplotene stage in high temperature-treated genetic females (at 35 and 37 degrees C) during sex-reversal and presumptive males of wild-type fish during sex differentiation were found at 15-27 days post-hatching. Our findings indicate that oocyte apoptosis, depletion of P450arom activity and differentiation of spermatogonia during gonadal sex-reversal are caused by treatments of aromatase inhibitor or high water temperature.     

Immunohistochemical Localization of Laminin and Cytokeratin in Embryonic Alligator Gonads

Gonadal sex differentiation is temperature-dependent in Alligator mississippiensis; testis differentiation occurs in embryos incubated at 33°C and ovary differentiation occurs in embryos incubated at 30°C. Laminin and cytokeratin were examined immunohistochemically in the gonads of alligator embryos incubated at these temperatures. The aim of this study was to determine whether these structural proteins show the same sex-specific expression patterns reported for mammalian embryos, and to assess their usefulness as early markers of gonadal differentiation in species with temperature-dependent sex determination. Laminin delineated enlarged seminiferous cords in differentiating testes from developmental stage 23 to hatching. Laminin distribution was more diffuse and revealed smaller cords of cells in differentiating ovaries. Cytokeratin was also detected in developing gonads of both sexes. Cytokeratin became concentrated in the basal cytoplasm of differentiating Sertoli cells in developing testes. In developing ovaries, prefollicular cells of the ovarian cortex and cell cords in the medulla stained strongly for cytokeratin. Cytokeratin did not show the same basal distribution in female medullary cord cells as seen in the Sertoli cells of testes, however. These sex-specific patterns of laminin and cytokeratin distribution in embryonic alligator gonads may serve as early markers of sexual differentiation.     

Sex reversal and aromatase in chicken.

Aromatase inhibitors administered before sexual differentiation of the gonads can induce sex reversal in female chickens. To analyze the process of sex reversal, we have followed for several months the changes induced by Fadrozole, a nonsteroidal aromatase inhibitor, in gonadal aromatase activity and in morphology and structure of the female genital system. Fadrozole was injected into eggs on day four of incubation, and its effects were examined during the embryonic development and for eight months after hatching. In control females, aromatase activity in the right and the left gonad was high in the middle third of embryonic development, and then decreased up to hatching. After hatching, aromatase activity increased in the left ovary, in particular during folliculogenesis, whereas in the right regressing gonad, it continued to decrease to reach testicular levels at one month. In treated females, masculinization of the genital system was characterized by the maintenance of the right gonad and its differentiation into a testis, and by the differentiation of the left gonad into an ovotestis or a testis; however, in all individuals, the left Müllerian duct and the posterior part of the right Müllerian duct were maintained. In testes and ovotestes, aromatase activity was lower than in gonads of control females (except in the right gonad as of one month after hatching) but remained higher than in testes of control and treated males. Moreover, in ovotestes, aromatase activity was higher in parts displaying follicles than in parts devoid of follicles. The main structural changes in the gonads during sex reversal were partial (in ovotestes) or complete (in testes) degeneration of the cortex in the left gonad, and formation of an albuginea and differentiation of testicular cords/tubes in the two gonads. Testicular cords/tubes transdifferentiated from ovarian medullary cords and lacunae whose epithelium thickened and became Sertolian. Transdifferentiation occurred all along embryonic and postnatal development; thus, new testicular cords/tubes were continuously formed while others degenerated. The sex reversed gonads were also characterized by an abundant fibrous interstitial tissue and abnormal medullary condensations of lymphoid-like cells; in the persisting testicular cords/tubes, spermatogenesis was delayed and impaired. Related to aromatase activity, persistence of too high levels of estrogens can explain the presence of oviducts, gonadal abnormalities and infertility in sex reversed females.     

Temporal difference between testis and ovary determinations with possible involvement of testosterone and aromatase in gonadal differentiation in TSD lacking lizard, Calotes versicolor

In the garden lizard, Calotes versicolor, which lacks identifiable sex chromosomes, incubation temperature also does not have a deterministic effect on the gender. However, the embryos reared at high temperature (33-35 degrees C) have a shorter duration of incubation as well as gonadal differentiation. In contrast, exogenous application of the male hormone testosterone to embryos at ambient temperature (28 degrees C) results in almost all individuals with only testis. Thus the testosterone treatment reverts genic females to males and accelerates the differentiation of testis, a feature similar to the high-temperature treatment. Treatment of eggs with estradiol shows no difference from that seen in the untreated eggs. The present series of experiments was done to establish the "window" of testosterone sensitivity and to understand the interaction between sex hormones and high temperature on gonadal differentiation. The period between day 5 and 15 of embryonic development was the window period of testosterone sensitivity for sex reversal. This period coincided with the formation of the genital ridge and its differentiation into cortex and medulla. Treatment of the 33 degrees C-reared embryos with testosterone resulted in hatchlings of both the sexes, in contrast to only males at the ambient temperature. In contrast, at the same temperature (33 degrees C), all the dihydrotestosterone (nonaromatisable testosterone)-treated embryos hatched into males. However, those given estradiol showed no sex bias regardless of the day of application and the concentration of drug. Eggs were also treated with aromatase inhibitor, CGS 16949 A, at ambient temperature and at 33 degrees C. All the 33 degrees C eggs to which the drug was given on day 25 hatched into males. These results suggest that though high temperature has no direct effect on sex determination in this species, it may have a stimulatory effect on aromatase activity, leading to the conversion of the exogenously applied testosterone into estradiol and permitting ovarian differentiation in the genic females. It also follows from the present report that the pathway of testis formation in Calotes versicolor is triggered much earlier, and irreversibly, than that for the ovary.     

Lymphoid aggregates in gonads of embryos, hatchlings, and young of turtles with temperature-dependent sex determination

Cellular infiltrations forming lymphoid-like aggregates were previously observed in gonads of two turtle species exhibiting temperature-dependent sex determination (TSD): at hatching in Chelydra serpentina; at and after hatching in Emys orbicularis. We show here that such aggregates are also present in gonads of Testudo graeca by the end of embryonic development, suggesting that their occurrence is general in turtles. Since in C. serpentina, infiltrations were observed mainly in testes exhibiting remnants of the germinal epithelium, it was assumed that their occurrence was an expression of maleness leading to rejection of this epithelium. The generality of this hypothesis was tested in E. orbicularis by looking for lymphoid-like aggregates in three types of gonads (testes, ovotestes, and ovaries) and for the stages at which they occur. Gonads were from embryos, hatchlings, and young incubated at various temperatures. Ovotestes obtained by treatment with an aromatase inhibitor of eggs incubated at female-producing temperature were also examined. In these gonads, the differentiation of Sertoli cells in testicular cords/tubes was ascertained by expression of SOX9. Moreover, the cell composition of aggregates was determined on electron micrographs. Aggregates appear in ovaries and ovotestes by the end of embryonic development and are present in the majority of these gonads at hatching, and at least up to one year after hatching. They are composed mainly of lymphocytes and fibroblasts. Aggregates are not present in typical testes. Since they occur in most ovaries, they cannot be seen as an expression of maleness. Rather, lymphocytic infiltration and formation of lymphoid aggregates in turtle gonads can be seen as components of the immune system, and can be under the control of gonadal endogenous sex steroids.     

Sex reversal and aromatase in the European pond turtle: treatment with letrozole after the thermosensitive period for sex determination

In the European pond turtle (Emys orbicularis), gonadal sex differentiation is temperature-dependent. The temperature sensitive period (TSP) of gonadogenesis lies between stages 16 and 22 of embryonic development. Previous studies have shown that embryos incubated at 30 degrees C, a temperature yielding 100% phenotypic females, can be sex reversed by treatments with an aromatase inhibitor administered during TSP or even somewhat after TSP (as of stage 22+). The goal of the present study was to determine whether the ovary still retains male potential at later stages of embryonic development and whether the induced male characters persist after hatching. For this purpose, eggs of E. orbicularis were treated with letrozole, a nonsteroidal aromatase inhibitor, at or as of stages 23, 24 or 25, then gonadal aromatase activity in each individual and the related gonadal structure were studied at hatching (stage 26) and for one year after hatching. Two kinds of treatments were carried out: 1) repeated applications of 10 microg of letrozole in ethanolic solution onto the eggshell; and 2) a single injection of 10 microg of letrozole in olive oil. Similar results were obtained with either application or injection of the aromatase inhibitor. In treatments as of or at stage 23, individuals with gonadal aromatase activity lower than 20 fmoles/hour/gonad had ovotestes, i.e., 22% of the treated individuals. At hatching, the inner part of these ovotestes contained testicular cords and also mixed lacunae presenting various degrees of transdifferentiation of the epithelium into a Sertolian epithelium. The cortex was maintained, although some germ cells degenerated within it. These processes continued after hatching. However, at 12 months, gonads were still ovotestes displaying some follicles with a growing oocyte in the remaining parts of the cortex. In treatments as of or at stages 24 or 25, only a few individuals were masculinized. One had ovotestes; in others, the cortex was absent in some parts and when it was present oocytes were degenerating. These results show that in the European pond turtle, differentiation of ovotestes from ovaries can be induced by treatment with an aromatase inhibitor starting at late stages of embryonic development (between the end of TSP and hatching), although such differentiation is less frequent as embryonic development proceeds. Sex reversal persists for at least one year after hatching. J. Exp. Zool. 290:490-497, 2001.     

A comparative approach to structure-function studies of mammalian aromatases

To date, structure–function studies of aromatase cytochrome P450 (P450arom) have been advanced by point mutation analyses utilizing almost exclusively the human enzyme, in conjunction with computer-generated models of the three-dimensional form of the enzyme based on prokaryotic cytochromes P450. Recent studies have identified duplicated isozymes of porcine P450arom, the gonadal and placental forms of which appear to differ substantially in substrate utilization and inhibitor sensitivity. We present a comparative approach to define regions of P450arom responsible for specific functional characteristics using complimentary DNAs encoding the porcine isozymes. Constructs encoding the native and chimeric porcine and human P450arom enzymes were transiently expressed and activity was assessed using the tritiated water assay. Sensitivity to inhibition by the imidazole etomidate was investigated, and P450arom expression was assessed by immunoblot analysis. All constructs yielded active P450arom, suggesting that exchanging entire structural elements does not preclude catalytic function. The activity of the gonadal isozyme was shown to be inhibited by etomidate at concentrations 185 and 300-fold lower than those required to induce a similar inhibition of the placental and human enzymes, respectively. In contrast, there was only a two-fold difference in the sensitivity of the gonadal and placental isozymes to inhibition by CGS16949A. Analysis of chimeric constructs indicated that the sensitivity to etomidate was associated with residues in the B, B′ and C helices of the gonadal P450arom encompassing only one of six putative substrate recognition sites. Additionally, sensitivity to etomidate was not correlated with enzyme activity among the chimeric enzymes. Therefore, it appears that residues of the porcine gonadal P450arom that are responsible for etomidate binding may be distinct from those involved in substrate recognition and metabolism. These data support the notion that a comparative approach employing the use of chimeric enzymes provides a useful tool in directing point mutational analysis to determine residues important in inhibitor and perhaps substrate recognition of P450 enzymes such as P450arom. These studies are currently in progress.     

Estrogen-induced gonadal sex reversal in the tammar wallaby

Estrogens have a feminizing effect on gonadal differentiation in fish, amphibians, reptiles, and birds. However, the role of estrogen during gonadal differentiation in mammals is less clear. We investigated the effect of estrogen on gonadal differentiation of male tammar wallabies. Male pouch young were treated orally with estradiol benzoate or oil from the day of birth, before seminiferous cords develop, to Day 25 postpartum and were killed at Day 50 postpartum. In all estrogen-treated neonates, a decrease in gonadal volume, volume of the seminiferous cords, thickness of the tunica albuginea, and number of germ cells was found. The stage of treatment affected the magnitude of the response. Two of three male young born prematurely after 25 days of gestation and treated subsequently with estradiol had ovary-like gonads, with well-developed cortical and medullary regions and primordial follicle formation. Furthermore, at Day 50 postpartum, many (21%) of the germ cells in these sex-reversed ovaries were in the leptotene and zygotene stages of meiosis, similar to female germ cells at the same stage of development. In the other males born on Day 26 of gestation or later, estradiol treatment from the day of birth caused development of dysgenetic testes, with abnormal Sertoli cells, atrophy of the seminiferous tubules and tunica albuginea, and absence of meiotic germ cells. In this marsupial, therefore, estradiol can induce either partial or complete transformation of the male gonads into an ovary with meiotic germ cells. These results confirm that estrogen can inhibit early testicular development, and that testis determination occurs during a narrow window of time.     

Hormonal regulation of estradiol biosynthesis, aromatase activity, and aromatase mRNA in rat ovarian follicles and corpora lutea

To determine the molecular basis for changes in aromatase (P450arom) activity in rat ovarian follicles and corpora lutea, seven clones for rat P450arom cDNA have been identified and isolated from a rat granulosa cell λgtll cDNA expression library using a 62 mer deoxyoligonucleotide probe (derived from an amino acid sequence of purified human placental aromatase) and a human placental P450arom cDNA probe. One of the rat P450arom cDNA clones contained an insert 1.2 kb in size. Both the human 1.8 kb cDNA and the rat 1.2 kb cDNA probes hybridized to a single species of P450arom mRNA that was 2.6 kb in size. Northern blot analysis revealed that corpora lutea isolated on day 15 of pregnancy contained high amounts of P450arom mRNA, whereas granulosa cells of antral follicles of hormonally primed, hypophysectomized rats (i.e., those from which mRNA was isolated to construct the cDNA library) contained only low amounts of P450arom mRNA. The lower amounts of P450arom in granulosa cells of preovulatory follicles in the estradiol-follicle-stimulating hormone primed hypophysectomized rats were unexpected because follicles incubated in medium containing testosterone substrate produce more estradiol than do corpora lutea isolated on day 15 of pregnancy and incubated under similar conditions. Additional studies will determine the hormonal events responsible for the elevated amounts and constitutive maintenance of P450arom mRNA and aromatase activity in luteal cells in vivo and in vitro.     

Aromatase cytochrome P-450. Purification and characterization of the enzyme from human placenta

Aromatase cytochrome P-450 (P-450arom) was purified from human placental microsomes. Preparations exhibit a single major band of approximately 55 kDa on SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and have a specific content of 11-13 nmol P-450/mg protein. The purified enzyme exhibits spectral properties typical of ferric and ferrous forms of cytochromes P-450. Full enzymatic activity can be reconstituted with rabbit liver P-450 reductase, and catalytic characteristics similar to aromatase in microsomes are observed. Rabbit antibodies to purified P-450arom were affinity purified and show high specificity and sensitivity on immunoblots.