Induction of pathogen resistance and pathogenesis-related genes in tobacco by a heat-stable Trichoderma mycelial extract and plant signal messengers

Heat-stable mycelial extracts of the nonpathogenic fungus Trichoderma longibrachiatum induced resistance in tobacco seedlings ( Nicotiana tabacum L. cv. Wisconsin 38) to the pathogen Phytophthora parasitica var. nicotianae (race 0), which did not involve a hypersensitive response. Resistance could not be induced with mycelial extract prepared in the same manner from P. parasitica . The nonpathogenic mycelial extract induced expression of PR-1b and osmotin (PR-5) genes to a higher level than did mycelial extract from the pathogenic fungus. The tissue-specific pattern of PR gene induction by the nonpathogenic mycelial extract was different from that of the pathogenic mycelial extract and was consistent with the ability of the former to cause disease resistance. The expression patterns of these two PR genes and the accumulations of their encoded proteins also were affected by salicylic acid (SA), methyl jasmonate (MeJA), ethylene (E) and combinations of these plant signal messengers. However, only combined SA and MeJA treatment mimicked the pattern of PR gene mRNA and protein accumulation induced by the nonpathogenic mycelial extract. E inhibitors blocked both mycelial extract-induced and SA/MeJA-induced PR gene expression, and the cis pattern of responsiveness on the osmotin promoter was the same for the mycelial extract, SA, E, or E/MeJA. Seedlings treated with P. parasitica spores in the presence of SA/MeJA were protected from pathogen colonization. However, these seedlings exhibited symptoms of cell death (disease symptoms) both in the absence and presence of P. parasitica spores, in contrast to seedlings treated with nonpathogenic mycelial extract, which remained healthy. These results suggest that the signal transduction pathways for elicitation of defense responses by exogenously applied heat-stable nonpathogenic mycelial extract and SA/MeJA overlap at the point of PR protein induction but are not identical.     

Induction of tomato stress protein mRNAs by ethephon, 2,6-dichloroisonicotinic acid and salicylate

To study the possible involvement of plant hormones in the synthesis of stress proteins in tomato upon inoculation with Cladosporium fulvum, we investigated the induction of mRNAs encoding PR proteins and ethylene biosynthesis enzymes by ethephon, 2,6-dichloroisonicotinic acid (INA) and salicylic acid (SA) by northern blot analysis. Ethephon slightly induced some but not all mRNAs encoding intra- and extracellular PR proteins. INA induced all PR protein mRNAs analysed, except for intracellular chitinase and extracellular PR-4. SA induced all PR protein mRNAs analyzed, except for intracellular chitinase and osmotin. None of the inducers affected the expression of ACC synthase mRNA, whereas all three induced ethylene-forming enzyme (EFE) mRNA.Abbreviations ACC 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid - EFE ethylene-forming enzyme - HR hypersensitive response - INA 2,6-dichloroisonicotinic acid - PR pathogenesis-related - SA salicylic acid - SAR systemic acquired resistance     

Osmotin gene expression is controlled by elicitor synergism

Arachidonic acid (AA), a fatty-acid fungal elicitor, and a cellulase preparation from Aspergillus niger , a protein-type fungal elicitor, induced osmotin gene expression. Both elicitors activated the osmotin promoter fused to a β-glucuronidase (GUS) reporter gene in a tissue-specific manner in tobacco seedlings ( Nicotiana tabacum L. cv. Wisconsin 38). The cellulase preparation was more effective than AA at the concentrations tested and, unlike AA, also induced the accumulation of osmotin mRNA and protein. Combinations of AA and the cellulase preparation had a greater than additive effect on the activation of the osmotin promoter and the accumulation of osmotin mRNA and protein. Both AA and the cellulase preparation, when applied separately, were virtually ineffective in the induction of the osmotin promoter in cotyledon tissues. However, together they were able to induce synergistically GUS fused to the osmotin promoter. Increases in osmotin-promoter-driven GUS activity and accumulation of osmotin mRNA induced by AA, the cellulase preparation or their combination were reversed by norbornadiene, an ethylene action inhibitor, indicating that ethylene is involved in the induction of the osmotin gene by these elicitors.     

A Nitrilase-Like Protein Interacts with GCC Box DNA-Binding Proteins Involved in Ethylene and Defense Responses

Ethylene-responsive element-binding proteins (EREBPs) of tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.) bind to the GCC box of many pathogenesis-related (PR) gene promoters, including osmotin (PR-5). The two GCC boxes on the osmotin promoter are known to be required, but not sufficient, for maximal ethylene responsiveness. EREBPs participate in the signal transduction pathway leading from exogenous ethylene application and pathogen infection to PR gene induction. In this study EREBP3 was used as bait in a yeast two-hybrid interaction trap with a tobacco cDNA library as prey to isolate signal transduction pathway intermediates that interact with EREBPs. One of the strongest interactors was found to encode a nitrilase-like protein (NLP). Nitrilase is an enzyme involved in auxin biosynthesis. NLP interacted with other EREBP family members, namely tobacco EREBP2 and tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum L.) Pti4/5/6. The EREBP2-EREBP3 interaction with NLP required part of the DNA-binding domain. The specificity of interaction was further confirmed by protein-binding studies in solution. We propose that the EREBP-NLP interaction serves to regulate PR gene expression by sequestration of EREBPs in the cytoplasm.     

Hydrogen peroxide does not function downstream of salicylic acid in the induction of PR protein expression

The roles of salicylic acid (SA) and H₂O₂ in the induction of PR proteins in tobacco have been examined. Studies were conducted on wild-type tobacco and plants engineered to express a bacterial salicylate hydroxylase capable of metabolizing SA to catechol (SH-L plants). Wild-type and PR-1a—GUS-transformed plants express PR-1a following challenge with Pseudomonas syringae pathovar syringae , SA or 2,6-dichloro-isonicotinic acid (INA). In contrast, SH-L plants failed to respond to SA but did express PR-1a following INA treatment. H₂O₂ and the irreversible catalase inhibitor 3-amino-1,2,4-triazole (3-AT) were found to be weak inducers of PR-1a expression (relative to SA) in wild-type tobacco but were unable to induce PR-1a in SH-L plants, suggesting that the action of these compounds depends upon the accumulation of SA. A model has been proposed suggesting that SA binds to and inhibits a catalase inducing an increase in H₂O₂ leading to PR protein expression. Catalase activity has been measured in tobacco and no significant changes in activity following infection with P. syringae pv. syringae were detected. Furthermore, inhibition of catalase activity in vitro in plant extracts requires pre-incubation and only occurs at SA concentrations above 250 µM. Leaf disks pre-incubated with 1 mM SA do accumulate SA to these levels and PR-1a is efficiently induced but there is no apparent inhibition of catalase activity. It is also shown that a SA-responsive gene, PR-1a, and a H₂O₂-sensitive gene, AoPR-1, are both relatively insensitive to 3-AT suggesting that induction of these genes is unlikely to be due entirely to inhibition of an endogenous catalase.     

Salicylic acid is a systemic signal and an inducer of pathogenesis-related proteins in virus-infected tobacco.

Systemic induction of pathogenesis-related (PR) proteins in tobacco, which occurs during the hypersensitive response to tobacco mosaic virus (TMV), may be caused by a minimum 10-fold systemic increase in endogenous levels of salicylic acid (SA). This rise in SA parallels PR-1 protein induction and occurs in TMV-resistant Xanthi-nc tobacco carrying the N gene, but not in TMV-susceptible (nn) tobacco. By feeding SA to excised leaves of Xanthi-nc (NN) tobacco, we have shown that the observed increase in endogenous SA levels is sufficient for the systemic induction of PR-1 proteins. TMV infection became systemic and Xanthi-nc plants failed to accumulate PR-1 proteins at 32 degrees C. This loss of hypersensitive response at high temperature was associated with an inability to accumulate SA. However, spraying leaves with SA induced PR-1 proteins at both 24 and 32 degrees C. SA is most likely exported from the primary site of infection to the uninfected tissues. A computer model predicts that SA should move rapidly in phloem. When leaves of Xanthi-nc tobacco were excised 24 hr after TMV inoculation and exudates from the cut petioles were collected, the increase in endogenous SA in TMV-inoculated leaves paralleled SA levels in exudates. Exudation and leaf accumulation of SA were proportional to TMV concentration and were higher in light than in darkness. Different components of TMV were compared for their ability to induce SA accumulation and exudation: three different aggregation states of coat protein failed to induce SA, but unencapsidated viral RNA elicited SA accumulation in leaves and phloem. These results further support the hypothesis that SA acts as an endogenous signal that triggers local and systemic induction of PR-1 proteins and, possibly, some components of systemic acquired resistance in NN tobacco.     

Studies on the Salicylic Acid Inducted Lipid Peroxidation and Defense Gene Expression in Tobacco Cell Culture

Salicylic acid (SA) could inhibit catalase activity, induce rapid lipid peroxidation and PR-1 gene expression of the tobacco ( Nicotiana tabacum L. ) cell culture which was incubated with exogenous SA. Ρ-ihydroxybenzene and H2O2 could also induce lipid peroxidation and PR-1 gene expression at different level, but they were not able to inhibit the catalase activity of tobacco cells. Inhi0itors of mRNA and protein-synthesis (a-amanitine and cycloheximide, respectively) could not induce both lipid peroxidation and PR-1 gene expression of tobacco cell culture. However, coordinated action with SA respectively, a-amanitine or cycloheximide was able to induce lipid peroxidation effectively, but strongly blocked the activation of PR-1 gene expression by SA in tobacco cell culture. These results suggested that the generation of reactive metabolites or free radicals, which were induced by SA or other inducers through reaction with catalase or other compounds, initiated lipid peroxidation, subsequently activated pathogen-resistance genes expression. Obviously the lipid peroxidation molecule played an important role in SA signal transduction in tobacco.     

Protein dephosphorylation mediates salicylic acid-induced expression of PR-1 genes in tobacco

Several lines of evidence suggest that salicylic acid (SA) is an endogenous signal for the activation of several plant defense responses, including the expression of genes encoding pathogenesis-related (PR) proteins such as the acidic PR-1 proteins. During recent years, studies have suggested that interaction of SA with catalase and ascorbate peroxidase leads to two signals in tobacco - elevated H₂O₂ levels and lipid peroxides. However, to date, relatively little is known about the molecular and biochemical mechanisms that mediate transduction beyond these signals or through other SA-effector proteins. Using protein kinase and phosphatase inhibitors, this study demonstrates that PR-1 gene induction can be mediated by dephosphorylation of serine/threonine residue(s) of two or more unidentified phosphoproteins. The protein phosphatase inhibitors, okadaic acid and calyculin A blocked SA-mediated induction of PR-1 genes, implying the involvement of a phosphoprotein downstream of SA. The protein kinase inhibitors K-252a and staurosporine induced PR-1 gene expression. PR-1 gene induction by K-252a was suppressed by okadaic acid. Surprisingly, this induction was also suppressed in NahG transgenic tobacco plants which convert SA to catechol. Moreover, K-252a stimulated production of SA and its glucoside, suggesting that another phosphoprotein acts upstream of SA. Taken together, these results suggest that there are two (or more) phosphoproteins which function in the same signal transduction pathway leading to PR-1 gene induction. The SA-inducible acidic PR-2 genes were similarly affected by the inhibitors, while the genes for actin and phenylalanine ammonia lyase were not.     

Cholera toxin elevates pathogen resistance and induces pathogenesis-related gene expression in tobacco.

In animals, plants and fungi, cholera toxin (CTX) can activate signalling pathways dependent on heterotrimeric GTP binding proteins (G-proteins). We transformed tobacco plants with a chimeric gene encoding the A1 subunit of CTX regulated by a light-inducible wheat Cab-1 promoter. Tissues of transgenic plants expressing CTX showed greatly reduced susceptibility to the bacterial pathogen Pseudomonas tabaci, accumulated high levels of salicylic acid (SA) and constitutively expressed pathogenesis-related (PR) protein genes encoding PR-1 and the class II isoforms of PR-2 and PR-3. In contrast, the class I isoforms of PR-2 and PR-3 known to be induced in tobacco by stress, by ethylene treatment and as part of the hypersensitive response to infection, were not induced and displayed normal regulation. In good agreement with these results, microinjection experiments demonstrated that CTX or GTP-gamma-S induced the expression of a PR1-GUS reporter gene but not that of a GLB-GUS reporter gene containing the promoter region of a gene encoding the class I isoform of PR-2. Microinjection and grafting experiments strongly suggest that CTX-sensitive G-proteins are important in inducing the expression of a subset of PR genes and that these G-proteins act locally rather than systemically upstream of SA induction.     

Wound-induced expression of a tobacco peroxidase is not enhanced by ethephon and suppressed by methyl jasmonate and coronatine

In tobacco plants, wounding induces production of a set of defense-related proteins such as basic pathogenesis-related (PR) proteins and proteinase inhibitors (PIs) via the jasmonate/ethylene pathway. Although class III plant peroxidase (POX) is also wound-inducible, the regulatory mechanism for its wound-induced expression is not fully understood. Here, we describe that a tobacco POX gene (tpoxN1), which is constitutively expressed in roots, is induced locally 30 min after wounding and then systemically in tobacco plants. Infection of necrotizing virus also induced tpoxN1 gene. The wound-induced expression was not enhanced by known wound-signal compounds such as methyl jasmonate (MeJA) and ethephon in contrast to other wound-inducible genes such as basic PR-1 and PI-II genes. And treatment with MeJA and coronatine, biological analogs of jasmonate, rather suppressed the tpoxN1 expression. Salicylic acid, an antagonist of jasmonate-based wound signaling, did not suppress the wound-induced expression of tpoxN1. Only spermine, which is reported as an endogenous inducer for acidic PR genes in tobacco mosaic virus-infected tobacco leaves, could induce tpoxN1 gene expression. These results suggest that wound-induced expression of the tpoxN1 gene is regulated differently from that of the basic PR and PI-II genes.     

Differential targeting of the tobacco PR-1 pathogenesis-related proteins to the extracellular space and vacuoles of crystal idioblasts.

Several biochemical and localization studies have shown that the acidic isoforms of the tobacco pathogenesis-related (PR) proteins, PR-1a, -1b and -1c are secreted to the extracellular spaces of leaves in response to pathogen infection or chemical treatment. Here we report the differential accumulation of these proteins within the vacuoles of specialized cells known as crystal idioblasts. In situ hybridization analysis indicated that crystal idioblasts expressed the PR-1 genes at the mRNA level and suggested that PR-1 proteins were synthesized by these cells. Transgenic plants which constitutively express a chimeric gene encoding an acidic PR-1b isoform also accumulated PR-1 protein in the extracellular spaces and within crystal idioblast vacuoles. Analysis of mRNA derived from these transgenic plants indicated that expression of the introduced PR-1b gene was responsible for the accumulation of PR-1 protein in these two distinct locations. The synthesis and accumulation within crystal idioblasts of PR-1 proteins, which are secreted by other cell types, indicates that idioblasts sort these proteins in a unique manner. Moreover, this suggests that protein sorting in higher plants may be modulated in a cell specific manner.     

Spermine Is a Salicylate-Independent Endogenous Inducer for Both Tobacco Acidic Pathogenesis-Related Proteins and Resistance against Tobacco Mosaic Virus Infection

Intercellular spaces are often the first sites invaded by pathogens. In the spaces of tobacco mosaic virus (TMV)-infected and necrotic lesion-forming tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.) leaves, we found that an inducer for acidic pathogenesis-related (PR) proteins was accumulated. The induction activity was recovered in gel-filtrated fractions of low molecular mass with a basic nature, into which authentic spermine (Spm) was eluted. We quantified polyamines in the intercellular spaces of the necrotic lesion-forming leaves and found 20-fold higher levels of free Spm than in healthy leaves. Among several polyamines tested, exogenously supplied Spm induced acidic PR-1 gene expression. Immunoblot analysis showed that Spm treatment increased not only acidic PR-1 but also acidic PR-2, PR-3, and PR-5 protein accumulation. Treatment of healthy tobacco leaves with salicylic acid (SA) caused no significant increase in the level of endogenous Spm, and Spm did not increase the level of endogenous SA, suggesting that induction of acidic PR proteins by Spm is independent of SA. The size of TMV-induced local lesions was reduced by Spm treatment. These results indicate that Spm accumulates outside of cells after lesion formation and induces both acidic PR proteins and resistance against TMV via a SA-independent signaling pathway.     

Structure of tobacco genes encoding pathogenesis-related proteins from the PR-1 group.

Infection of Samsun NN tobacco with tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) was found to induce the synthesis of mRNA encoding a basic protein with a 67% amino acid sequence homology to the known acidic pathogenesis-related (PR) proteins 1a, 1b and 1c. By Southern blot hybridization it was shown that the tobacco genome contains at least eight genes for acidic PR-1 proteins and a similar number of genes encoding the basic homologues. Clones corresponding to three of the genes for acidic PR-1 proteins were isolated from a genomic library of Samsun NN tobacco. The nucleotide sequence of these genes and their flanking sequences were determined. One clone was found to correspond to the PR-1a gene; the two other clones do not correspond to known TMV-induced PR-1 mRNA's and may represent silent genes. Compared to the PR-1a gene, these genes contain an insertion or deletion in the putative promoter region and mutations affecting the PR-1 reading frame.     

Temperature-Dependent Induction of Salicylic Acid and Its Conjugates during the Resistance Response to Tobacco Mosaic Virus Infection

Increases in endogenous salicylic acid (SA) levels and induction of several families of pathogenesis-related genes (PR-1 through PR-5) occur during the resistance response of tobacco to tobacco mosaic virus infection. We found that at temperatures that prevent the induction of PR genes and resistance, the increases in SA levels were eliminated. The addition of exogenous SA to infected plants at these temperatures was sufficient to induce the PR genes but not the hypersensitive response. However, when the resistance response was restored by shifting infected plants to permissive temperatures, SA levels increased dramatically and preceded PR-1 gene expression and necrotic lesion formation associated with resistance. SA was also found in a conjugated form whose levels increased in parallel with the free SA levels. The majority of the conjugates appeared to be SA glucosides. The same glucoside was formed when plants were supplied with exogenous SA. These results provide further evidence that endogenous SA signals the induction of certain defense responses and suggests additional complexity in the modulation of this signal.     

Molecular Cloning of Osmotin and Regulation of Its Expression by ABA and Adaptation to Low Water Potential

In response to adaptation to NaCl, cultured tobacco cells (Nicotiana tabacum L. cv Wisconsin 38) synthesize a major 26 kilodalton protein which has been named osmotin due to its induction by low water potentials. To help characterize the expression of osmotin in adapted cells, a cDNA clone for osmotin has been isolated. Abscisic acid induces messenger RNA encoding osmotin. Levels of this mRNA in adapted cells are approximately 15-fold higher than in unadapted cells. Message for osmotin is present at constant levels through the growth cycle of adapted cells, while in unadapted cells, the level decreases during exponential phase of growth and increases again when the cells approach stationary phase. While abscisic acid induces the message for osmotin, a low water potential environment appears to be required for accumulation of the protein. An osmotic shock to unadapted cells does not increase the amount of message or protein present most likely because this treatment does not induce immediately the accumulation of abscisic acid. The increased expression of osmotin in adapted cells is not correlated with an increase in osmotin gene copy number. Osmotin is homologous to a 24 kilodalton NaCl-induced protein in tomato, as well as thaumatin, maize α-amylase/trypsin inhibitor and a tobacco mosaic virus-induced pathogenesis-related protein.     

Pathogenesis-related acidic beta-1,3-glucanase genes of tobacco are regulated by both stress and developmental signals

Three pathogenesis-related (PR) proteins of tobacco are acidic isoforms of beta-1,3-glucanase (PR-2a, -2b, -2c). We have cloned and sequenced a partial cDNA clone (lambda FJ1) corresponding to one of the PR-2 beta-1,3-glucanases. A small gene family encodes the PR-2 proteins in tobacco, and similar genes are present in a number of plant species. We analyzed the stress and developmental regulation of the tobacco PR-2 beta-1,3-glucanases by using northern and western analyses and a new technique to assay enzymatic activity. Stress caused by both thiamine and tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) infection resulted in a dramatic increase in the levels of PR-2 mRNA, protein, and enzyme activities. The increased PR-2 gene expression in upper uninoculated leaves of plants infected with TMV also suggests a role in systemic acquired resistance. During floral development, a number of beta-1,3-glucanase activities were observed in all flower tissues. However, PR-2 polypeptides were observed only in sepal tissue. In contrast, an mRNA that hybridized to the PR-2 cDNA was present in stigma/style tissue and the sepals. Primer extension analysis confirmed the identity of the PR-2 mRNA in sepals, but indicated that the beta-1,3-glucanase gene expressed in the stigma/style of flowers was distinct from the PR-2 genes. The induction of PR-2 protein synthesis by both stress and developmental signals was accompanied by a corresponding increase in the steady-state levels of PR-2 mRNA, suggesting that PR-2 gene expression is regulated, in part, at the level of mRNA accumulation.     

Harpin induces disease resistance in Arabidopsis through the systemic acquired resistance pathway mediated by salicylic acid and the NIM1 gene

Harpin, the product of the hrpN gene of Erwinia amylovora, elicits the hypersensitive response and disease resistance in many plants. Harpin and known inducers of systemic acquired resistance (SAR) were tested on five genotypes of Arabidopsis thaliana to assess the role of SAR in harpin-induced resistance. In wild-type plants, harpin elicited systemic resistance to Peronospora parasitica and Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato, accompanied by induction of the SAR genes PR-1 and PR-2. However, in experiments with transgenic Arabidopsis plants containing the nahG gene which prevents accumulation of salicylic acid (SA), harpin neither elicited resistance nor activated SAR gene expression. Harpin also failed to activate SAR when applied to nim1 (non-inducible immunity) mutants, which are defective in responding to SA and regulation of SAR. In contrast, mutants compromised in responsiveness to methyl jasmonate and ethylene developed the same resistance as did wild-type plants. Thus, harpin elicits disease resistance through the NIM1-mediated SAR signal transduction pathway in an SA-dependent fashion. The site of action of harpin in the SAR regulatory pathway is upstream of SA.