Benzoate Fermentation by the Anaerobic Bacterium Syntrophus aciditrophicus in the Absence of Hydrogen-Using Microorganisms

The anaerobic bacterium Syntrophus aciditrophicus metabolized benzoate in pure culture in the absence of hydrogen-utilizing partners or terminal electron acceptors. The pure culture of S. aciditrophicus produced approximately 0.5 mol of cyclohexane carboxylate and 1.5 mol of acetate per mol of benzoate, while a coculture of S. aciditrophicus with the hydrogen-using methanogen Methanospirillum hungatei produced 3 mol of acetate and 0.75 mol of methane per mol of benzoate. The growth yield of the S. aciditrophicus pure culture was 6.9 g (dry weight) per mol of benzoate metabolized, whereas the growth yield of the S. aciditrophicus-M. hungatei coculture was 11.8 g (dry weight) per mol of benzoate. Cyclohexane carboxylate was metabolized by S. aciditrophicus only in a coculture with a hydrogen user and was not metabolized by S. aciditrophicus pure cultures. Cyclohex-1-ene carboxylate was incompletely degraded by S. aciditrophicus pure cultures until a free energy change (ΔG′) of −9.2 kJ/mol was reached (−4.7 kJ/mol for the hydrogen-producing reaction). Cyclohex-1-ene carboxylate, pimelate, and glutarate transiently accumulated at micromolar levels during growth of an S. aciditrophicus pure culture with benzoate. High hydrogen (10.1 kPa) and acetate (60 mM) levels inhibited benzoate metabolism by S. aciditrophicus pure cultures. These results suggest that benzoate fermentation by S. aciditrophicus in the absence of hydrogen users proceeds via a dismutation reaction in which the reducing equivalents produced during oxidation of one benzoate molecule to acetate and carbon dioxide are used to reduce another benzoate molecule to cyclohexane carboxylate, which is not metabolized further. Benzoate fermentation to acetate, CO₂, and cyclohexane carboxylate is thermodynamically favorable and can proceed at free energy values more positive than −20 kJ/mol, the postulated minimum free energy value for substrate metabolism.     

Isolation and characterization of an anaerobic syntrophic benzoate-degrading bacterium from sewage sludge

An anaerobic, motile, gram-negative, rod-shaped bacterium is described which degrades benzoate in coculture with an H₂-utilizing organism and in the absence of exogenous electron acceptors such as O₂, SO ₄ ⁼ or NO ₃ ^- . The bacterium was isolated from a municipal primary, anaerobic sewage digestor using anaerobic roll-tube medium with benzoate as the main energy source and in syntrophic association with an H₂-utilizing sulfate-reducing Desulfovibrio sp. which cannot utilize benzoate or fatty acids apart from formate as energy source. The benzoate utilizer produced acetate (3 mol/mol of substrate degraded) and presumably CO₂ and H₂, or formate from benzoate. In media without sulfate and with Methanospirillum hungatei (a methanogen that utilizes only H₂–CO₂ or formate as the energy source) added, 3 mol of acetate and 0.7 mol of methane were produced per mol of benzoate and CO₂ was probably formed. Low numbers of Desulfovibrio sp. were present in the methanogenic coculture and a pure coculture of the benzoate utilizer with M. hungatei was not obtained. The generation times for growth of the sulfate-reducing and methanogenic cocultures were 132 and 166h, respectively. The benzoate utilizer did not utilize other common aromatic compounds, C ₃ ^- –C₇ monocarboxylic acids, or C₄-C₆ dicarboxylic acids for growth, nor did it appear to use SO ₄ ⁼ , NO ₃ ^- or fumarate as alternative electron acceptors. Addition of H₂ inhibited growth and benzoate degradation.     

Propionate-Degrading Bacterium, Syntrophobacter wolinii sp. nov. gen. nov., from Methanogenic Ecosystems

A new genus and species of a nonmotile gram-negative rod, Syntrophobacter wolinii, is the first bacterium described which degrades propionate only in coculture with an H₂-using organism and in the absence of light or exogenous electron acceptors such as O₂, sulfate, or nitrate. It was isolated from methanogenic enrichments from an anaerobic municipal sewage digestor, using anaerobic roll tubes containing a medium with propionate as the energy source in association with an H₂-using, sulfate-reducing Desulfovibrio sp. which cannot utilize fatty acids other than formate. S. wolinii produced acetate and, presumably, CO₂ and H₂ (or formate) from propionate. In media without sulfate and with Methanospirillum hungatei, a methanogen that uses only H₂-CO₂ or formate as an energy source, acetate, methane, and, presumably, CO₂ were produced from propionate and only small amounts of Desulfovibrio sp. were present. Isolation in coculture with the methanogen was not successful. S. wolinii does not use other saturated fatty acids as energy sources.     

Syntrophus aciditrophicus sp. nov., a new anaerobic bacterium that degrades fatty acids and benzoate in syntrophic association with hydrogen-using microorganisms

Strain SB^T is a new, strictly anaerobic, gram-negative, nonmotile, non-sporeforming, rod-shaped bacterium that degrades benzoate and certain fatty acids in syntrophic association with hydrogen/formate-using microorganisms. Strain SB^T produced approximately 3 mol of acetate and 0.6 mol of methane per mol of benzoate in coculture with Methanospirillum hungatei strain JF1. Saturated fatty acids, some unsaturated fatty acids, and methyl esters of butyrate and hexanoate also supported growth of strain SB^T in coculture with Desulfovibrio strain G11. Strain SB^T grew in pure culture with crotonate, producing acetate, butyrate, caproate, and hydrogen. The molar growth yield was 17 ± 1 g cell dry mass per mol of crotonate. Strain SB^T did not grow with fumarate, iron(III), polysulfide, or oxyanions of sulfur or nitrogen as electron acceptors with benzoate as the electron donor. The DNA base composition of strain SB^T was 43.1 mol% G+C. Analysis of the 16 S rRNA gene sequence placed strain SB^T in the δ-subdivision of the Proteobacteria, with sulfate-reducing bacteria. Strain SB^T was most closely related to members of the genus Syntrophus. The clear phenotypic and genotypic differences between strain SB^T and the two described species in the genus Syntrophus justify the formation of a new species, Syntrophus aciditrophicus. Received: 2 June 1998 / Accepted: 16 November 1998     

Investigation of the catabolism of acetate and peptides in the new anaerobic thermophilic bacterium Caldithrix abyssi

This work is concerned with the metabolism of Caldithrix abyssi—an anaerobic, moderately thermophilic bacterium isolated from deep-sea hydrothermal vents of the Mid-Atlantic Ridge and representing a new, deeply deviated branch within the domain Bacteria. Cells of C. abyssi grown on acetate and nitrate, which was reduced to ammonium, possessed nitrate reductase activity and contained cytochromes of the b and c types. Utilization of acetate occurred as a result of the operation of the TCA and glyoxylate cycles. During growth of C. abyssi on yeast extract, fermentation with the formation of acetate, propionate, hydrogen, and CO₂ occurred. In extracts of cells grown on yeast extract, acetate was produced from pyruvate with the involvement of the following enzymes: pyruvate: ferredoxin oxidoreductase (2.6 μmol/(min mg protein)), phosphate acetyltransferase (0.46 μmol/(min mg protein)), and acetate kinase (0.3 μmol/(min mg protein)). The activity of fumarate reductase (0.14 μmol/(min mg protein)), malate dehydrogenase (0.17 μmol/(min mg protein)), and fumarate hydratase (1.2 μmol/(min mg protein)), as well as the presence of cytochrome b, points to the formation of propionate via the methyl-malonyl-CoA pathway. The activity of antioxidant enzymes (catalase and superoxide dismutase) was detected. Thus, enzymatic mechanisms have been elucidated that allow C. abyssi to switch from fermentation to anaerobic respiration and to exist in the gradient of redox conditions characteristic of deep-sea hydrothermal vents.     

Growth of Syntrophomonas wolfei in pure culture on crotonate

A Synthrophomonas wolfei-Methanospirillum hungatei coculture was adapted to catabolize crotonate. S. wolfei was then isolated in axenic culture using agar spread plates and roll tubes with crotonate as the sole energy source. S. wolfei catabolized crotonate via a disproportionation mechanism similar to that of some Clostridium species. Growth on crotonate was very slow (specific growth rate of 0.029 h^–1) but the conversion of energy into cell material was very efficient with cell yields of 14.6 g (dry wt.) per mol of crotonate. S. wolfei alone did not catabolize butyrate, but butyrate was stoichiometrically degraded to acetate and presumably methane when S. wolfei was reassociated with M. hungatei. S. wolfei-M. hungatei cocultures accumulated some butyrate during growth on crotonate indicating that protons were not the sole electron acceptors used for crotonate oxidation by the coculture.     

Fructose degradation byDesulfovibrio sp. in pure culture and in coculture withMethanospirillum hungatei

In a mineral medium containing sulfate, the sulfate-reducing bacteriumDesulfovibrio sp. strain JJ degraded 1 mol of fructose stoichiometrically to 1 mol of H₂S, 2 mol of acetate, and presumably 2 mol of CO₂. The doubling time was 10 h, and the yield was 41.6 g dry weight/mol fructose degraded. In the absence of sulfate, the hydrogenophilic methanogenMethanospirillum hungatei replaced sulfate as hydrogen sink. In such cocultures, 1 mol of fructose was converted to acetate, methane, succinate, and presumably CO₂ in varying concentrations. The growth yield of the H₂-transferring association was 33 g dry weight/mol fructose. In the absence of sulfate,Desulfovibrio strain JJ slowly fermented 1 mol of fructose to 1 mol of succinate, 0.5 mol of acetate, and 0.5 mol of ethanol. The results are compared with those of other anaerobic hexose-degrading bacteria.     

Sulfate-Dependent Interspecies H2 Transfer between Methanosarcina barkeri and Desulfovibrio vulgaris during Coculture Metabolism of Acetate or Methanol

We compared the metabolism of methanol and acetate when Methanosarcina barkeri was grown in the presence and absence of Desulfovibrio vulgaris. The sulfate reducer was not able to utilize methanol or acetate as the electron donor for energy metabolism in pure culture, but was able to grow in coculture. Pure cultures of M. barkeri produced up to 10 μmol of H₂ per liter in the culture headspace during growth on acetate or methanol. In coculture with D. vulgaris, the gaseous H₂ concentration was ≤2 μmol/liter. The fractions of ¹⁴CO₂ produced from [¹⁴C]methanol and 2-[¹⁴C]acetate increased from 0.26 and 0.16, respectively, in pure culture to 0.59 and 0.33, respectively, in coculture. Under these conditions, approximately 42% of the available electron equivalents derived from methanol or acetate were transferred and were utilized by D. vulgaris to reduce approximately 33 μmol of sulfate per 100 μmol of substrate consumed. As a direct consequence, methane formation in cocultures was two-thirds that observed in pure cultures. The addition of 5.0 mM sodium molybdate or exogenous H₂ decreased the effects of D. vulgaris on the metabolism of M. barkeri. An analysis of growth and carbon and electron flow patterns demonstrated that sulfate-dependent interspecies H₂ transfer from M. barkeri to D. vulgaris resulted in less methane production, increased CO₂ formation, and sulfide formation from substrates not directly utilized by the sulfate reducer as electron donors for energy metabolism and growth.     

Anaerobic Degradation of Propionate by a Mesophilic Acetogenic Bacterium in Coculture and Triculture with Different Methanogens

A mesophilic acetogenic bacterium (MPOB) oxidized propionate to acetate and CO₂ in cocultures with the formate- and hydrogen-utilizing methanogens Methanospirillum hungatei and Methanobacterium formicicum. Propionate oxidation did not occur in cocultures with two Methanobrevibacter strains, which grew only with hydrogen. Tricultures consisting of MPOB, one of the Methanobrevibacter strains, and organisms which are able to convert formate into H₂ plus CO₂ (Desulfovibrio strain G11 or the homoacetogenic bacterium EE121) also degraded propionate. The MPOB, in the absence of methanogens, was able to couple propionate conversion to fumarate reduction. This propionate conversion was inhibited by hydrogen and by formate. Formate and hydrogen blocked the energetically unfavorable succinate oxidation to fumarate involved in propionate catabolism. Low formate and hydrogen concentrations are required for the syntrophic degradation of propionate by MPOB. In triculture with Methanospirillum hungatei and the aceticlastic Methanothrix soehngenii, propionate was degraded faster than in biculture with Methanospirillum hungatei, indicating that low acetate concentrations are favorable for propionate oxidation as well.     

Effects of Organic Acid Anions on the Growth and Metabolism of Syntrophomonas wolfei in Pure Culture and in Defined Consortia

The effects of organic acid anions on the growth of Syntrophomonas wolfei was determined by varying the initial concentration of the acid anion in the medium. The addition of 15 mM acetate decreased the growth rate of a butyrate-catabolizing coculture containing Methanospirillum hungatei from 0.0085 to 0.0029 per hour. Higher initial acetate concentrations decreased the butyrate degradation rate and the yield of cells of S. wolfei per butyrate degraded. Inhibition was not due to the counter ion or the effect of acetate on the methanogen. Initial acetate concentrations above 25 mM inhibited crotonate-using pure cultures and cocultures of S. wolfei. Benzoate and lactate inhibited the growth of S. wolfei on crotonate in pure culture and coculture. Lactate was an effective inhibitor of S. wolfei cultures at concentrations greater than 10 mM. High concentrations of acetate and lactate altered the electron flow in crotonate-catabolizing cocultures, resulting in the formation of less methane and more butyrate and caproate. The inclusion of the acetate-using methanogen, Methanosarcina barkeri, in a methanogenic butyrate-catabolizing coculture increased both the yield of S. wolfei cells per butyrate degraded and the efficacy of butyrate degradation. Butyrate degradation by acetate-inhibited cocultures occurred only after the addition of Methanosarcina barkeri. These results showed that the metabolism of S. wolfei was inhibited by high levels of organic acid anions. The activity of acetate-using methanogens is important for the syntrophic degradation of fatty acids when high levels of acetate are present.     

Fermentative degradation of monohydroxybenzoates by defined syntrophic cocultures

From anaerobic freshwater enrichment cultures with 3-hydroxybenzoate as sole substrate, a slightly curved rod-shaped bacterium was isolated in coculture with Desulfovibrio vulgaris as hydrogen scavenger. The new isolate degraded only 3-hydroxybenzoate or benzoate, and depended on syntrophic cooperation with a hydrogenoxidizing methanogen or sulfate reducer. 3-Hydroxybenzoate was degraded via reductive dehydroxylation to benzoate. With 2-hydroxybenzoate (salicylate), short coccoid rods were enriched from anaerobic freshwater mud samples, and were isolated in defined coculture with D. vulgaris. This isolate also fermented 3-hydroxybenzoate or benzoate in obligate syntrophy with a hydrogen-oxidizing anaerobe. The new isolates were both Gram-negative, non-sporeforming strict anaerobes. They fermented hydroxybenzoate or benzoate to acetate, CO₂, and, presumably, hydrogen which was oxidized by the syntrophic partner organism. With hydroxybenzoates, but not with benzoate, Acetobacterium woodii could also serve as syntrophic partner. Other substrates such as sugars, alcohols, fatty or amino acids were not fermented. External electron acceptors such as sulfate, sulfite, nitrate, or fumarate were not reduced. In enrichment cultures with 4-hydroxybenzoate, decarboxylation to phenol was the initial step in degradation which finally led to acetate, methane and CO₂.     

Fermentation of trihydroxybenzenes by Pelobacter acidigallici gen. nov. sp. nov., a new strictly anaerobic,non-sporeforming bacterium

Five strains of rod-shaped, Gram-negative, non-sporing, strictly anaerobic bacteria were isolated from limnic and marine mud samples with gallic acid or phloroglucinol as sole substrate. All strains grew in defined mineral media without any growth factors; marine isolates required salt concentrations higher than 1% for growth, two freshwater strains only thrived in freshwater medium. Gallic acid, pyrogallol, 2,4,6-trihydroxybenzoic acid, and phloroglucinol were the only substrates utilized and were fermented stoichiometrically to 3 mol acetate (and 1 mol CO₂) per mol with a growth yield of 10g cell dry weight per mol of substrate. Neither sulfate, sulfur, nor nitrate were reduced. The DNA base ratio was 51.8% guanine plus cytosine. A marine isolate, Ma Gal 2, is described as type strain of a new genus and species, Pelobacter acidigallici gen. nov. sp. nov., in the family Bacteroidaceae. In coculture with Acetobacterium woodii, the new isolates converted also syringic acid completely to acetate. Cocultures with Methanosarcina barkeri converted the respective substrates completely to methane and carbon dioxide.     

Growth of the syntrophic anaerobic acetogen, strain PA-1, with glucose or succinate as energy source

Strain PA-1 (S. Barik, W.J. Brulla, and M.P. Bryant, Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 50:304-310, 1985) is an anaerobic, gram-negative rod that in pure culture decarboxylates succinate to propionate and that grows syntrophically as an acetogen with the H2 utilizer Methanospirillum hungatei if glucose, pyruvate, aspartate, or fumarate is provided. In pure culture, strain PA-1 grows optimally in a medium containing 5% ruminal fluid, 0.1% yeast extract, a 4:1 N2-CO2 gas phase, and 20 mM succinate. With the PA-1 plus M. hungatei coculture, good growth was obtained with 7.5 mM glucose and tryptophan could replace the yeast extract. Strain PA-1 in pure culture grew quite well in glucose medium if the large headspace was flushed intermittently with N2. Flushing with H2 inhibited this growth.     

Growth of the syntrophic anaerobic acetogen, strain PA-1, with glucose or succinate as energy source.

Strain PA-1 (S. Barik, W.J. Brulla, and M.P. Bryant, Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 50:304-310, 1985) is an anaerobic, gram-negative rod that in pure culture decarboxylates succinate to propionate and that grows syntrophically as an acetogen with the H2 utilizer Methanospirillum hungatei if glucose, pyruvate, aspartate, or fumarate is provided. In pure culture, strain PA-1 grows optimally in a medium containing 5% ruminal fluid, 0.1% yeast extract, a 4:1 N2-CO2 gas phase, and 20 mM succinate. With the PA-1 plus M. hungatei coculture, good growth was obtained with 7.5 mM glucose and tryptophan could replace the yeast extract. Strain PA-1 in pure culture grew quite well in glucose medium if the large headspace was flushed intermittently with N2. Flushing with H2 inhibited this growth.     

Energetics of Growth of a Defined Mixed Culture of Desulfovibrio vulgaris and Methanosarcina barkeri: Interspecies Hydrogen Transfer in Batch and Continuous Cultures

Interspecies hydrogen transfer was studied in Desulfovibrio vulgaris-Methanosarcina barkeri mixed cultures. Experiments were performed under batch and continuous growth culture conditions. Lactate or pyruvate was used as an energy source. In batch culture and after 30 days of simultaneous incubation, these organisms were found to yield 1.5 mol of methane and 1.5 mol of carbon dioxide per mol of lactate fermented. When M. barkeri served as the hydrogen acceptor, growth yields of D. vulgaris were higher compared with those obtained on pyruvate without any electron acceptor other than protons. In continuous culture, all of the carbon derived from the oxidation of lactate was recovered as methane and carbon dioxide, provided the dilution rate was minimal. Increasing the dilution rate induced a gradual accumulation of acetate, causing acetate metabolism to cease at above μ = 0.05 h⁻¹. Under these conditions all of the methane produced originated from carbon dioxide. The growth yields of D. vulgaris were measured when sulfate or M. barkeri was the electron acceptor. Two key observations resulted from the present study. First, although sulfate was substituted by M. barkeri, metabolism of D. vulgaris was only slightly modified. The coculture-fermented lactate produced equimolar quantities of carbon dioxide and methane. Second, acetogenesis and methane formation from acetate were completely separable.     

Thermodynamics and H2 Transfer in a Methanogenic,Syntrophic Community

Microorganisms in nature do not exist in isolation but rather interact with other species in their environment. Some microbes interact via syntrophic associations, in which the metabolic by-products of one species serve as nutrients for another. These associations sustain a variety of natural communities, including those involved in methanogenesis. In anaerobic syntrophic communities, energy is transferred from one species to another, either through direct contact and exchange of electrons, or through small molecule diffusion. Thermodynamics plays an important role in governing these interactions, as the oxidation reactions carried out by the first community member are only possible because degradation products are consumed by the second community member. This work presents the development and analysis of genome-scale network reconstructions of the bacterium Syntrophobacter fumaroxidans and the methanogenic archaeon Methanospirillum hungatei. The models were used to verify proposed mechanisms of ATP production within each species. We then identified additional constraints and the cellular objective function required to match experimental observations. The thermodynamic S. fumaroxidans model could not explain why S. fumaroxidans does not produce H₂ in monoculture, indicating that current methods might not adequately estimate the thermodynamics, or that other cellular processes (e.g., regulation) play a role. We also developed a thermodynamic coculture model of the association between the organisms. The coculture model correctly predicted the exchange of both H₂ and formate between the two species and suggested conditions under which H₂ and formate produced by S. fumaroxidans would be fully consumed by M. hungatei.     

Methanogenic degradation of acetone by an enrichment culture

An anaerobic enrichment culture degraded 1 mol of acetone to 2 mol of methane and 1 mol of carbon dioxide. Two microorganisms were involved in this process, a filament-forming rod similar to Methanotrix sp. and an unknown rod with round to slightly pointed ends. Both organisms formed aggregates up to 300 m in diameter. No fluorescing bacteria were observed indicating that hydrogen or formate-utilizing methanogens are not involved in this process. Acetate was utilized in this culture by the Methanothrix sp. Inhibition of methanogenesis by bromoethanesulfonic acid or acetylene decreased the acetone degradation rate drastically and led to the formation of 2 mol acetate per mol of acetone. Streptomycin completely inhibited acetone degradation, and neither acetate nor methane was formed. ¹⁴CO₂ was incorporated exclusively into the C-1 atom of acetate indicating that acetone is degraded via carboxylation to an acetoacetate residue. It is concluded that acetone is degraded by a coculture of an eubacterium and an acetate-utilizing methanogen and that acetate is the only intermediate transferred between both. The energetical problems of the eubacterium converting acetone to acetate are discussed.     

Fermentation of Cellulose to Methane and Carbon Dioxide by a Rumen Anaerobic Fungus in a Triculture with Methanobrevibacter sp. Strain RA1 and Methanosarcina barkeri

The fermentation of cellulose by a rumen anaerobic fungus in the presence of Methanobrevibacter sp. strain RA1 and Methanosarcina barkeri strain 227 resulted in the formation of 2 mol each of methane and carbon dioxide per mol of hexose fermented. Coculture of the fungus with either Methanobrevibacter sp. or M. barkeri produced 0.6 and 1.3 mol of methane per mol of hexose, respectively. Acetate, formate, ethanol, hydrogen, and lactate, which are major end products of cellulose fermentation by the fungus alone, were either absent or present in very low quantities at the end of the triculture fermentation (≤0.08 mol per mol of hexose fermented). During the time course of cellulose fermentation by the triculture, hydrogen was not detected (<1 × 10⁻⁵ atm; <0.001 kPa) and only acetate exhibited transitory accumulation; the maximum was equivalent to 1.4 mol per mol of hexose at 6 days which was higher than the total acetate yield of 0.73 in the fungus monoculture. The effect of methanogens is interpreted as a shift in the flow of electrons away from the formation of electron sink products lactate and ethanol to methane via hydrogen, favoring an increase in acetate, which is in turn converted to methane and carbon dioxide by M. barkeri. The maximum rate of cellulose degradation in the triculture (3 mg/ml per day) was faster than previously reported for bacterial cocultures and within 16 days degradation was complete. The triculture was used successfully also in the production of methane from cellulose in the plant fibrous materials, sisal (fiber from leaves of Agave sisalona L.) and barley straw leaf.     

Photoproduction of H2 from Cellulose by an Anaerobic Bacterial Coculture

Cellulomonas sp. strain ATCC 21399 is a facultatively anaerobic, cellulose-degrading microorganism that does not evolve hydrogen but produces organic acids during cellulose fermentation. Rhodopseudomonas capsulata cannot utilize cellulose, but grows photoheterotrophically under anaerobic conditions on organic acids or sugars. This report describes an anaerobic coculture of the Cellulomonas strain with wild-type R. capsulata or a mutant strain lacking uptake hydrogenase, which photoevolves molecular hydrogen by the nitrogenase system of R. capsulata with cellulose as the sole carbon source. In coculture, the hydrogenase-negative mutant produced 4.6 to 6.2 mol of H₂ per mol of glucose equivalent, compared with 1.2 to 4.3 mol for the wild type.     

Acetate Inhibition of Methanogenic, Syntrophic Benzoate Degradation

Acetate inhibited benzoate degradation by a syntrophic coculture of an anaerobic benzoate degrader (strain BZ-2) and Methanospirillum strain PM-1; the apparent K_i for acetate was approximately 40 mM. The addition of acetate resulted in a decrease in the hydrogen concentration in the coculture, indicating that phenomena related to interspecies hydrogen transfer affected this value and that the effect of acetate on the benzoate-degrading partner was probably greater than the apparent K_i for the coculture suggests.