DNase I sensitivity of ribosomal genes in isolated nucleosome core particles

The level of chromatin structure at which DNase I recognizes conformational differences between inert and activated genes has been investigated. Bulk and ribosomal DNA's of Tetrahymena pyriformis were differentially labeled in vivo with [14C]- and [3H]-thymidine, respectively, utilizing a defined starvation-refeeding protocol. The 3H-labeled ribosomal genes were shown to be preferentially digested by DNase I in isolated nuclei. Staphylococcal nuclease digested the ribosomal genes more slowly than bulk DNA, probably owing to the higher GC content of rDNA. DNase I and staphylococcal nuclease digestions of purified nucleosomes and of nucleosome core particles isolated from dual-labeled, starved-refed nuclei were indistinguishable from those of intact nuclei. We conclude from these studies that DNase I recognizes an alteration in the internal nucleosome core structure of activated ribosomal genes.     

Nuclease sensitivity of active chromatin.

The active regions of chicken erythrocyte nuclei were labeled using the standard DNase I directed nick translation reaction. These nuclei were then used to study the characteristics and, in particular, the nuclease sensitivity of active genes. Although DNase I specifically attacks active genes, micrococcal nuclease solubilizes these regions to about the same degree as the total DNA. On the other hand micrococcal nuclease does selectively cut the internucleosomal regions of active genes resulting in the appearance of mononucleosomal fraction which is enriched in active gene DNA. A small percentage of the active chromatin is also released from the nucleus by low speed centrifugation following micrococcal nuclease treatment. The factors which make active genes sensitive to DNase I were shown to reside on individual nucleosomes from these regions. This was established by showing that isolated active mononucleosomes were preferentially sensitive to DNase I digestion. Although the high mobility group proteins are essential for the maintenance of DNase I sensitivity in active regions, these proteins are not necessary for the formation of the conformation which makes these genes preferentially accessible to micrococcal nuclease. The techniques employed in this paper enable one to study the chromatin structure of the entire population of actively expressed genes. Previous studies have elucidated the structure of a few special highly prevalent genes such as ovalbumin and hemoglobin. The results of this paper show that this special conformation is a general feature of all active genes irregardless of the extent of expression.     

A correlation between nucleosome spacer region susceptibility to DNase I and histone acetylation.

Hepatoma tissue culture (HTC) cell nuclei were digested with either DNase I or micrococcal nuclease and the nucleohistone digestion products fractionated by gel electrophoresis or exclusion chromatography. Under appropriate conditions, gel electrophoresis demonstrates that for both nucleases, only cleavages within the nucleosome spacer regions and not within the nucleosome core lead to freely migrating nucleohistone particles. These particles consist of nucleosome cores, nucleosomes and nucleosome oligomers. Following DNase I digestion and fractionation by exclusion chromatography, analysis of the histones indicates a direct relationship between increased spacer region susceptibility to nuclease and increased nucleosomal histone acetylation. Evidently digestion sites outside the regions of DNA protected by core histones can reflect the degree of acetylation of core histones. Such a relationship is not found when micrococcal nuclease is used to digest the samples.     

Deoxyribonuclease I sensitivity of the ovomucoid-ovoinhibitor gene complex in oviduct nuclei and relative location of CR1 repetitive sequences

The location of CR1 middle repetitive sequences within or near the boundaries of the ovalbumin DNase I sensitive domain has suggested that CR1 sequences may play a role in defining transition regions of DNase I sensitivity in hen oviduct nuclei. We have examined this apparent relationship of CR1 sequences and transitions of chromatin structure by determining the DNase I sensitivity in oviduct nuclei of a 47-kilobase region that contains five CR1 sequences and the transcribed ovomucoid and ovoinhibitor genes. We find that three of the CR1 sequences occur within a broad transition region of decreasing DNase I sensitivity downstream of the ovomucoid gene. Another CR1 is in a region of decreased DNase I sensitivity within the ovoinhibitor gene. The fifth CR1 sequence is in a DNase I sensitive region between the two genes but which is less sensitive to DNase I digestion than the region immediately upstream from the ovomucoid gene. Thus, the CR1 sequences occur within regions of reduced relative DNase I sensitivity, suggesting that CR1s could facilitate the formation of a chromatin conformation that is less sensitive to DNase I digestion. Unexpectedly, the noncoding strand of sequences within and immediately adjacent to the 5' end of the actively transcribed ovomucoid and ovalbumin genes was less sensitive to DNase I digestion than their respective coding strands.     

Differential nuclease sensitivity of the ovalbumin and beta-globin chromatin regions in erythrocytes and oviduct cells of laying hen.

We have monitored the differential nuclease sensitivity of defined regions of the chicken genome in different cells using a method which combines restriction enzyme digestion and blotting to diazobenzyloxymethyl (DBM)-paper (see Ref. 11). By using different specific probes and by scanning the bands on the autoradiograms, it is possible to compare on the same blot the digestion patterns of similar-sized fragments from different regions of the genome corresponding to "active" and reference "inactive" genes. We have demonstrated the preferential sensitivity to DNaseI and micrococcal nuclease digestion of the ovalbumin gene region in hen oviduct chromatin. The beta-globin gene region (containing both an adult and an embryonic gene) is also preferentially digested by DNaseI in hen mature erythrocyte nuclei, but at a lower rate than the ovalbumin gene region in oviduct. These observations raise the possibility that there may be several types of preferential nuclease sensitivities, all characterized by increased rates of digestion but to different levels, the highest corresponding to the very actively transcribing genes.     

Structure of chromatin containing extensively acetylated H3 and H4

I have grown HeLa cells in 5 mM sodium n-butyrate leading to extensive in vivo histone acetylation, and have characterized the structure of chromatin containing the modified histones. Nuclear DNA in butyrate-treated cells is digested 5-10 fold more rapidly by DNAase I than the DNA of control cells. Staphylococcal nuclease degrades the two nuclear samples to acid-soluble material with identical rates; this nuclease, however, does excise nucleosomes with extensively acetylated histones from the nucleoprotein chain preferentially. The physical properties of unsheared chromatin and isolated core particles from control and butyrate-treated cells are closely similar, as are the rates of digestion of core particles from the two cell preparations by DNAase I. Determination of the relative susceptibilities of cleavage sites for DNAase I demonstrates that the site 60 bases from the ends of the DNA resistant in control cells, becomes susceptible to the nuclease in core particles containing acetylated histones. Similarly, the 5' terminal phosphate at the end of DNA in core prticles is removed by staphylococcal nuclease 2-3 fold faster in particles containing acetylated histones than in particles from control cells.     

The effect of histone hyperacetylation on the nuclease sensitivity and the solubility of chromatin

We have examined the effects of histone hyperacetylation upon nuclease digestion of nuclei and subsequent fractionation of chromosomal material in the presence of MgCl2. DNase I shows a maximum sensitivity towards hyperacetylated nuclei at somewhat elevated ionic strengths (150-200 mM NaCl), whereas micrococcal nuclease exhibits no specificity for acetylated nuclei over a broad range of ionic strengths. Fractionation in the presence of MgCl2 of hyperacetylated nuclei digested with micrococcal nuclease results in a substantial increase in the amount of soluble chromatin relative to that obtained with control nuclei. This increased yield of Mg2+-soluble chromatin results from the recruitment into this fraction of oligonucleosomes containing extremely hyperacetylated histones. These results suggest that contiguous nucleosomes containing highly acetylated histones may be altered in their ability to interact with themselves and with other nucleosomes.     

Assembly of an active chromatin structure during replication.

MSB cells were pulse labeled with 3H-thymidine and the isolated nuclei digested with either staphylococcal nuclease (to about 40% acid solubility) or DNase I (to 15% acid solubility). The purified, nuclease resistant single-copy DNA was then hybridized to nuclear RNA (nRNA). The results of these experiments show that actively transcribed genes are assembled into nucleosome-like structures within 5-10 nucleosomes of the replication fork and that they also acquire a conformation characteristic of actively transcribed nucleosomes (ie, a DNase I sensitive structure) within 20 nucleosomes of the fork. Assuming DNA sequence specific interactions are required for establishing a DNase I sensitive conformation on active genes during each round of replication, our results indicate that a specific recognition event can occur very rapidly and very specifically in eukaryotic cells. The results are discussed in terms of the possible mechanisms responsible for propagating active, chromosomal conformations from mother cells to daughter cells.     

DNA methylation: correlation with DNase I sensitivity of chicken ovalbumin and conalbumin chromatin.

To analyse the relationship between DNA undermethylation at some sites in the ovalbumin and conalbumin gene regions (1) and the expression of these genes in chick oviduct, digestions with HhaI, which differentiates between methylated and unmethylated HhaI restriction sites, was performed on DNA isolated from chicken erythrocyte or oviduct chromatin treated with DNase I which degrades preferentially "active" chromatin. This was followed by analysis with ovalbumin- and conalbumin-specific hybridization probes. We conclude that the residual DNA methylation found at some sites of the ovalbumin and conalbumin gene regions is derived from the fraction of cells in which the chromatin of these genes is not in an "active" form. On the other hand, the ovalbumin and conalbumin sites which are partially unmethylated in erythrocyte DNA correspond to chromatin regions which are not DNase I-senitive. We have also detected a site about 1 kb downstream from the 3' end of the conalbumin gene that is hypersensitive to DNase I in all tissues tested.     

Chromatin structure of the chicken beta-globin gene region. Sensitivity to DNase I, micrococcal nuclease, and DNase II

We have examined in some detail the chromatin structure of a 6.2 kilobase pair (kbp) chromosomal region containing the chicken beta-globin gene. The chromatin structure was probed with three nucleases, DNase I, micrococcal nuclease, and DNase II, and the rate of digestion of specific subfragments of the region was compared with the rate of bulk DNA digestion. We have characterized the rate of digestion of each fragment in terms of a sensitivity factor which measures the sensitivity of a fragment to a particular nuclease relative to bulk DNA. The sensitivity factors were determined by a least squares curve fitting method based on target analysis. In nuclei isolated from 14-day-old chicken embryo red blood cells, the entire 6.2-kbp region shows approximately a 10- to 20-fold increase in sensitivity to DNase I, a 3-fold increased sensitivity to micrococcal nuclease, and a 6-fold increased sensitivity to DNase II. In addition to the adult beta-globin gene, this region contains 5' and 3' flanking sequences, the 5' half of the inactive, embryonic globin gene, epsilon, and some repeated sequences. There is no obvious correlation between these genetic elements and the overall chromatin structure as measured by the nuclease sensitivity. This same region shows little or no special sensitivity in nuclei isolated from 14-day-old chicken embryo brain. Furthermore, fragments of the inactive ovalbumin gene show little or no sensitivity in either red blood cells or brain. These results support the conclusion that the entire 6.2-kbp region is largely packaged as active chromatin in 14-day-old chicken embryo red blood cells.     

Nucleosome core particle self-assembly kinetics and stability at physiological ionic strength

Micrococcal nuclease, DNase I, and trypsin have been employed to study the kinetics of core particle self-assembly by salt jump from 2.0 to 0.2 M NaCl. A few seconds after the initiation of the reassociation reaction, the bulk of core particle DNA becomes protected from digestion by micrococcal nuclease, whereas free DNA, under the same conditions, is completely hydrolyzed. The central and C-terminal regions of core histones are also protected from trypsin digestion immediately after the 2.0-0.2 M NaCl salt jump. Moreover, the extent of degradation produced by trypsin is the same for samples digested a few seconds after the salt jump and for samples digested 20 min after the salt jump. With DNase I, minor structural differences have been detected between samples obtained at different times during the reaction. However, even in this case our results indicate that many of the characteristic histone-DNA contacts within the core particle are made a few seconds after the initiation of the self-assembly reaction. Furthermore, core particles have been labeled with the fluorescent reagent N-(1-pyrenyl)maleimide (NPM), which was previously used as a sensitive probe for nucleosome conformation. Extensive DNase I or trypsin digestion of NPM-labeled core particles in 0.2 M NaCl does not produce significant changes in excimer fluorescence. This allows us to conclude that the covalent continuity of DNA is not required for the maintenance of the folded conformation of the core particle and that the trypsin-resistant domains of core histones play a fundamental role in the stabilization of this structure.     

The DNase I sensitive state of "active" globin gene chromatin resists trypsin treatments which disrupt chromatin higher order structure

Active genes in higher eukaryotes reside in chromosomal domains which are more sensitive to digestion by DNase I than the surrounding inactive chromatin. Although it is widely assumed that some modification of higher order structure is important to the preferential DNase I sensitivity of active chromatin, this has so far not been tested. Here we show that the structural distinction between DNase I sensitive and resistant chromatin is remarkably stable to digestion by trypsin. Chick embryonic red blood cell nuclei were subjected to increasing levels of trypsin digestion and then assayed in the following three ways: (1) by gel electrophoresis for histone cleavage, (2) by sedimentation and nuclease digestion for loss of higher order structure, and (3) by dot-blot hybridization to globin and ovalbumin probes for disappearance of preferential DNase I sensitivity. We have found that chromatin higher order structure is lost concomitantly with the cleavage of histones H1, H5, and H3. In contrast, the preferential sensitivity of the globin domain to DNase I persists until much higher concentrations of trypsin, and indeed is not completely abolished even by the highest levels of trypsin we have used. We therefore conclude that the structural distinction of active chromatin, recognized by DNase I, does not reside at the level of higher order structure.     

Effect of histone acetylation on structure and in vitro transcription of chromatin.

n-Butyrate treatment of growing Hela cells produces a dramatic increase in the levels of histone acetylation. We have exploited this system to study the effect of histone acetylation on chromatin structure. Chromatin containing highly acetylated histones is more rapidly digested to acid-soluble material by DNase I, but not by micrococcal nuclease. The same pattern of nuclease sensitivity was exhibited by in vitro-assembled chromatin consisting of SV40 DNA Form I and the 2 M salt-extracted core histones from butyrate-treated cells. Using this very defined system, it was possible to demonstrate that acetylated nucleosomes do not have a greatly diminished stability. Stability was measured in terms of exhange of histone cores onto competing naked DNA or sliding of histone cores along ligated naked DNA. Finally, it was shown that acetylated nucleosomes are efficient inhibitors of in vitro RNA synthesis by the E. coli holoenzyme as well as by the mammalian polymerases A and B.     

Chicken ovalbumin promoter is demethylated upon expression in the regions specifically involved in estrogen-responsiveness

Here we report the methylation status of the chicken ovalbumin promoter. Genomic DNA of oviduct from immature chickens and laying hens was analyzed through bisulfite genomic sequencing. In the ovalbumin control locus up to the 6 kb upstream region, CpG sites were methylated in immature chickens, except for several sites, and almost all CpGs residing in DNase I hypersensitive sites I, II, and III, but not IV, were selectively unmethylated in ovalbumin expressing chickens. Chromatin immunoprecipitation assays showed that the ovalbumin control region was associated with acetylated histone H3 but not with dimethylated histone H3 at Lys 27. These results demonstrate that DNA demethylation was restricted to short DNA regions of DNase I hypersensitive sites, especially to those which participated in estrogen-responsiveness, even when cells expressed extremely high levels of ovalbumin and these sites were associated with acetylated histones.     

Chicken Ovalbumin Promoter Is Demethylated upon Expression in the Regions Specifically Involved in Estrogen-Responsiveness

Here we report the methylation status of the chicken ovalbumin promoter. Genomic DNA of oviduct from immature chickens and laying hens was analyzed through bisulfite genomic sequencing. In the ovalbumin control locus up to the 6 kb upstream region, CpG sites were methylated in immature chickens, except for several sites, and almost all CpGs residing in DNase I hypersensitive sites I, II, and III, but not IV, were selectively unmethylated in ovalbumin expressing chickens. Chromatin immunoprecipitation assays showed that the ovalbumin control region was associated with acetylated histone H3 but not with dimethylated histone H3 at Lys 27. These results demonstrate that DNA demethylation was restricted to short DNA regions of DNase I hypersensitive sites, especially to those which participated in estrogen-responsiveness, even when cells expressed extremely high levels of ovalbumin and these sites were associated with acetylated histones.     

Histone acetylation and the deoxyribonuclease I sensitivity of the Tetrahymena ribosomal gene

Under appropriate conditions, up to 8.5% of the total acetate can be removed from the histones of isolated Tetrahymena macronuclei by an endogenous histone deacetylase activity. After in vitro deacetylation, the ribosomal genes are still preferentially digested by DNase I. These observations suggested that either the majority of histone-bound acetate is unnecessary to maintain the DNase I sensitive state or ribosomal chromatin (rChromatin) histones remain acetylated under these conditions. The characteristics of histones acetylation were studied in Tetrahymena rChromatin, which can be isolated in a relatively pure form. Histones associated with the presumably active, DNase I sensitive ribosomal genes have a high steady-state level of histone acetylation which, surprisingly, is maintained by very low acetate turnover rates.