Single amino acid replacements in an antigenic peptide are sufficient to alter the TCR V beta repertoire of the responding CD8+ cytotoxic lymphocyte population.

Cytotoxic CD8+ T lymphocytes are activated upon the engagement of their Ag-specific receptors by MHC class I molecules loaded with peptides 8-11 amino acids long. T cell responses triggered by certain antigenic peptides are restricted to a limited number of TCR V beta elements. The precise role of the peptide in causing this restricted TCR V beta expansion in vivo remains unclear. To address this issue, we immunized C57BL/6 mice with the immunodominant peptide of the vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) and several peptide variants carrying single substitutions at TCR-contact residues. We observed the expansion of a limited set of TCR V beta elements responding to each peptide variant. To focus our analysis solely on the TCR beta-chain, we created a transgenic mouse expressing exclusively the TCR alpha-chain from a VSV peptide-specific CD8+ T cell clone. These mice showed an even more restricted TCR V beta usage consequent to peptide immunization. However, in both C57BL/6 and TCR alpha transgenic mice, single amino acid replacements in TCR-contact residues of the VSV peptide could alter the TCR V beta usage of the responding CD8+ T lymphocytes. These results provide in vivo evidence for an interaction between the antigenic peptide and the germline-encoded complementarity-determining region-beta loops that can influence the selection of the responding TCR repertoire. Furthermore, only replacements at residues near the C terminus of the peptide were able to alter the TCR V beta usage, which is consistent with the notion that the TCR beta-chain interacts in vivo preferentially with this region of the MHC/peptide complex.     

Contribution of individual amino acids within MHC molecule or antigenic peptide to TCR ligand potency

The TCR recognition of peptides bound to MHC class II molecules is highly flexible in some T cells. Although progress has been made in understanding the interactions within the trimolecular complex, to what extent the individual components and their amino acid composition contribute to ligand recognition by individual T cells is not completely understood. We investigated how single amino acid residues influence Ag recognition of T cells by combining several experimental approaches. We defined TCR motifs for CD4+ T cells using peptide synthetic combinatorial libraries in the positional scanning format (PS-SCL) and single amino acid-modified peptide analogues. The similarity of the TCR motifs defined by both methods and the identification of stimulatory antigenic peptides by the PS-SCL approach argue for a contribution of each amino acid residue to the overall potency of the antigenic peptide ligand. In some instances, however, motifs are formed by adjacent amino acids, and their combined influence is superimposed on the overall contribution of each amino acid within the peptide epitope. In contrast to the flexibility of the TCR to interact with different peptides, recognition was very sensitive toward modifications of the MHC-restriction element. Exchanges of just one amino acid of the MHC molecule drastically reduced the number of peptides recognized. The results indicate that a specific MHC molecule not only selects certain peptides, but also is crucial for setting an affinity threshold for TCR recognition, which determines the flexibility in peptide recognition for a given TCR.     

A new twist in TCR diversity revealed by a forbidden alphabeta TCR

We report crystal structures of a negatively selected T cell receptor (TCR) that recognizes two I-A^u-restricted myelin basic protein peptides and one of its peptide/major histocompatibility complex (pMHC) ligands. Unusual complementarity-determining region (CDR) structural features revealed by our analyses identify a previously unrecognized mechanism by which the highly variable CDR3 regions define ligand specificity. In addition to the pMHC contact residues contributed by CDR3, the CDR3 residues buried deep within the Vα/Vβ interface exert indirect effects on recognition by influencing the Vα/Vβ interdomain angle. This phenomenon represents an additional mechanism for increasing the potential diversity of the TCR repertoire. Both the direct and indirect effects exerted by CDR residues can impact global TCR/MHC docking. Analysis of the available TCR structures in light of these results highlights the significance of the Vα/Vβ interdomain angle in determining specificity and indicates that TCR/pMHC interface features do not distinguish autoimmune from non-autoimmune class II-restricted TCRs.     

Modification of peptide interaction with MHC creates TCR partial agonists

We report the creation of TCR partial agonists by the novel approach of manipulating the interaction between immunogenic peptide and MHC. Amino acids at MHC anchor positions of the I-E(k)-restricted hemoglobin (64-76) and moth cytochrome c (88-103) peptides were exchanged with MHC anchor residues from the low affinity class II invariant chain peptide (CLIP), resulting in antigenic peptides with altered affinity for MHC class II. Several low affinity peptides were identified as TCR partial agonists, as defined by the ability to stimulate cytolytic function but not proliferation. For example, a peptide containing methionine substitutions at positions one and nine of the I-E(k) binding motif acted as a partial agonist for two hemoglobin-reactive T cell clones (PL.17 and 3.L2). The identical MHC anchor substitutions in moth cytochrome c (88-103) also created a partial agonist for a mCC-reactive T cell (A.E7). Thus, peptides containing MHC anchor modifications mediated similar T cell responses regardless of TCR fine specificity or antigen reactivity. This data contrasts with the unique specificity among individual clones demonstrated using traditional altered peptide ligands containing substitutions at TCR contact residues. In conclusion, we demonstrate that altering the MHC anchor residues of the immunogenic peptide can be a powerful method to create TCR partial agonists.     

Peptidic termini play a significant role in TCR recognition

TCR recognition of class I MHC is dependent on the composition of the antigenic peptide and the MHC. Single amino acid substitutions in either the MHC or the peptide may dramatically alter recognition. While the major interactions between TCR and the peptide/MHC complex appear to be focused on the complementarity-determining region (CDR)3, it is also clear from the cocrystal structure of class I MHC and TCR that the amino and carboxyl ends of the peptide may play a role through interactions with the CDR1. In this work we show that gp33 variants substituted at the peptidic termini at the putative CDR1 contact regions show improved recognition in B6 mice. The rank order of recognition is different using the P14 transgenic T cells, suggesting that one reason for improved recognition is a change in the TCR repertoire that recognizes the peptide. However, the affinity of the TCR by some of the peptide/MHC complex with increased recognition is improved, as shown by increased tetramer binding to P14 T cells. These substitutions at the termini of the peptide-binding cleft cause localized conformational changes as seen by changes in mAb binding and crystallographic structures. The different peptide structures also show different conformations in the center of the peptide, but these are shown to be energetically similar and thus most likely have no significance with respect to TCR recognition. Therefore, small conformational changes, localized to the CDR1 contact regions, may play a significant role in TCR recognition.     

Immunobiological analysis of TCR single-chain transgenic mice reveals new possibilities for interaction between CDR3alpha and an antigenic peptide bound to MHC class I

The interaction between TCRs and peptides presented by MHC molecules determines the specificity of the T cell-mediated immune response. To elucidate the biologically important structural features of this interaction, we generated TCR beta-chain transgenic mice using a TCR derived from a T cell clone specific for the immunodominant peptide of vesicular stomatitis virus (RGYVYQGL, VSV8) presented by H-2K(b). We immunized these mice with VSV8 or analogs substituted at TCR contact residues (positions 1, 4, and 6) and analyzed the CDR3alpha sequences of the elicited T cells. In VSV8-specific CTLs, we observed a highly conserved residue at position 93 of CDR3alpha and preferred Jalpha usage, indicating that multiple residues of CDR3alpha are critical for recognition of the peptide. Certain substitutions at peptide position 4 induced changes at position 93 and in Jalpha usage, suggesting a potential interaction between CDR3alpha and position 4. Cross-reactivity data revealed the foremost importance of the Jalpha region in determining Ag specificity. Surprisingly, substitution at position 6 of VSV8 to a negatively charged residue induced a change at position 93 of CDR3alpha to a positively charged residue, suggesting that CDR3alpha may interact with position 6 in certain circumstances. Analogous interactions between the TCR alpha-chain and residues in the C-terminal half of the peptide have not yet been revealed by the limited number of TCR/peptide-MHC crystal structures reported to date. The transgenic mouse approach allows hundreds of TCR/peptide-MHC interactions to be examined comparatively easily, thus permitting a wide-ranging analysis of the possibilities for Ag recognition in vivo.     

Hapten addition to an MHC class I-binding peptide causes substantial adjustments of the TCR structure of the responding CD8(+) T cells

T cell responses against hapten-modified peptides play an important role in the pathogenesis of certain diseases, including contact dermatitis and allergy. However, the structural features of TCRs recognizing bulky, potentially mobile hapten groups remain poorly defined. To analyze the structural basis of TCR recognition of defined hapten-modified peptides, the immunodominant octapeptide derived from vesicular stomatitis virus nucleoprotein (VSV8) was modified with a trinitrophenyl (TNP) group at the primary TCR contact residues (position 4 or 6) and used for immunization of mice carrying either the TCR alpha- or beta-chain of a VSV8 (unmodified)/H-2K(b)-specific CTL clone as a transgene. Such mice allow independent analysis of one TCR chain by maintaining the other fixed. The TCR V gene usage of the responding T cell population was specifically altered depending upon the presence of the TNP group and its position on the peptide. The CDR3 sequences of the TNP-modified peptide-specific TCRs showed a preferential J region usage in both the CDR3alpha and beta loops, indicating that the J regions of both CDR3s are critical for recognition of TNP-modified peptides. In contrast to our previous observations showing the prime importance of CDR3beta residues encoded by D-segment or N-addition nucleotides for recognition of position 6 of unmodified VSV8, our studies of TNP-modified peptides demonstrate the importance of the Jbeta region, while the Jalpha region was crucial for recognizing both TNP-modified and unmodified peptides. These data suggest that different structural strategies are utilized by the CDR3alpha and beta loops to allow interaction with a haptenated peptide.     

The study of high-affinity TCRs reveals duality in T cell recognition of antigen: specificity and degeneracy

TCRs exhibit a high degree of Ag specificity, even though their affinity for the peptide/MHC ligand is in the micromolar range. To explore how Ag specificity is achieved, we studied murine T cells expressing high-affinity TCRs engineered by in vitro evolution for binding to hemoglobin peptide/class II complex (Hb/I-Ek). These TCRs were shown previously to maintain Ag specificity, despite having up to 800-fold higher affinity. We compared the response of the high-affinity TCRs and the low-affinity 3.L2 TCR toward a comprehensive set of peptides containing single substitutions at each TCR contact residue. This specificity analysis revealed that the increase in affinity resulted in a dramatic increase in the number of stimulatory peptides. The apparent discrepancy between observed degeneracy in the recognition of single amino acid-substituted Hb peptides and overall Ag specificity of the high-affinity TCRs was examined by generating chimeric peptides between the stimulatory Hb and nonstimulatory moth cytochrome c peptides. These experiments showed that MHC anchor residues significantly affected TCR recognition of peptide. The high-affinity TCRs allowed us to estimate the affinity, in the millimolar range, of immunologically relevant interactions of the TCR with peptide/MHC ligands that were previously unmeasurable because of their weak nature. Thus, through the study of high-affinity TCRs, we demonstrated that a TCR is more tolerant of single TCR contact residue substitutions than other peptide changes, revealing that recognition of Ag by T cells can exhibit both specificity and degeneracy.     

Structural and functional consequences of altering a peptide MHC anchor residue

To better understand TCR discrimination of multiple ligands, we have analyzed the crystal structures of two Hb peptide/I-E(k) complexes that differ by only a single amino acid substitution at the P6 anchor position within the peptide (E73D). Detailed comparison of multiple independently determined structures at 1.9 A resolution reveals that removal of a single buried methylene group can alter a critical portion of the TCR recognition surface. Significant variance was observed in the peptide P5-P8 main chain as well as a rotamer difference at LeuP8, approximately 10 A distal from the substitution. No significant variations were observed in the conformation of the two MHC class II molecules. The ligand alteration results in two peptide/MHC complexes that generate bulk T cell responses that are distinct and essentially nonoverlapping. For the Hb-specific T cell 3.L2, substitution reduces the potency of the ligand 1000-fold. Soluble 3.L2 TCR binds the two peptide/MHC complexes with similar affinity, although with faster kinetics. These results highlight the role of subtle variations in MHC Ag presentation on T cell activation and signaling.     

Threshold signaling of human Th0 cells in activation and anergy: modulation of effector function by altered TCR ligand

Molecular interactions between TCR and its natural ligand, in the presence of costimulatory signals, elicit T cell effector functions, whereas subtle changes in the structure of antigenic peptides may induce only selected T cell effector function including anergy. In this study, we have investigated the immunological activity of an altered TCR ligand (p 2, 28-40A34,36) derived from the immunodominant T cell epitope of the group 2 allergen of house dust mite, in which residues at positions 34 and 36 were substituted by alanine. Elevated IFN-gamma synthesis was induced by equimolar concentrations of the analogue compared with native peptide (p 2, 28-40) and was paralleled by increased down-regulation of cell surface CD3. IL-5 and IL-10 production exhibit the same sensitivity to both peptides, implying that the induction of T cell effector functions are not all proportional to TCR occupancy. Both native peptide and the analogue bound to MHC class II (DRB1*1101) molecules with similar affinities. Furthermore, p 2, 28-40A34,36 induced T cell anergy at lower concentrations than native peptide. During the induction of anergy, TGF-beta production was comparable for both peptides, whereas IL-10 secretion was markedly increased but more so in response to p 2, 28-40A34,36. Membrane expression of costimulatory ligands CD80 and CD86 was similar for native peptide and p 2, 28-40A34,36 and increased in activation, whereas only CD86 was elevated during anergy. The modulation of T cell effector function with altered TCR ligands may have practical applications in reprogramming allergic inflammatory responses through the induction of T cell anergy and/or the promotion of Th1 cytokines.     

Inhibition of na?ve class I-restricted T cells by altered peptide ligands.

Amino acid variants of an antigenic peptide or altered peptide ligands have previously been investigated with CD4+ and CD8+ T cells. However, for CD8+ T cells, only clones (which are continually restimulated in vitro) have been assessed. Using TCR transgenic mice specific for a class I Kb-restricted OVA peptide (OVAp; OT-I mice) as a source of na?ve CD8+ T cells, single amino acid variants of the OVAp were analysed in vitro for their ability to antagonize the proliferative and cytotoxic function of na?ve OT-I cells. Peptides with substitutions at TCR contact residues were found to be the most potent antagonists of OT-I cell function. Those peptides that inhibited activation of cells to proliferate also inhibited activation of cells to become killers. Inhibition was inversely correlated with interferon (IFN)-gamma production. It was found that levels of antagonist peptide required for inhibition were higher than that described for T cell clones, presumably due to affinity differences.     

Differential CD3 zeta phosphorylation is not required for the induction of T cell antagonism by altered peptide ligands.

T cells recognize foreign Ags in the form of short peptides bound to MHC molecules. Ligation of the TCR:CD3 complex gives rise to the generation of two tyrosine-phosphorylated forms of the CD3 zeta-chain, pp21 and pp23. Replacement of residues in MHC-bound peptides that alter its recognition by the TCR can generate altered peptide ligands (APL) that antagonize T cell responses to the original agonist peptide, leading to altered T cell function and anergy. This biological process has been linked to differential CD3zeta phosphorylation and generation of only the pp21 phospho-species. Here, we show that T cells expressing CD3zeta mutants, which cannot be phosphorylated, exhibit a 5-fold reduction in IL-2 production and a 30-fold reduction in sensitivity following stimulation with an agonist peptide. However, these T cells are still strongly antagonized by APL. These data demonstrate that: 1) the threshold required for an APL to block a response is much lower than for an agonist peptide to induce a response, 2) CD3zeta is required for full agonist but not antagonist responses, and 3) differential CD3zeta phosphorylation is not a prerequisite for T cell antagonism.     

Fine specificity of TCR complementarity-determining region residues and lipid antigen hydrophilic moieties in the recognition of a CD1-lipid complex

alphabeta TCR can recognize peptides presented by MHC molecules or lipids and glycolipids presented by CD1 proteins. Whereas the structural basis for peptide/MHC recognition is now clearly understood, it is not known how the TCR can interact with such disparate molecules as lipids. Recently, we demonstrated that the alphabeta TCR confers specificity for both the lipid Ag and CD1 isoform restriction, indicating that the TCR is likely to recognize a lipid/CD1 complex. We hypothesized that lipids may bind to CD1 via their hydrophobic alkyl and acyl chains, exposing the hydrophilic sugar, phosphate, and other polar functions for interaction with the TCR complementarity-determining regions (CDRs). To test this model, we mutated the residues in the CDR3 region of the DN1 TCR beta-chain that were predicted to project between the CD1b alpha helices in a model of the TCR/CD1 complex. In addition, we tested the requirement for the negatively charged and polar functions of mycolic acid for Ag recognition. Our findings indicate that the CDR loops of the TCR form the Ag recognition domain of CD1-restricted TCRs and suggest that the hydrophilic domains of a lipid Ag can form a combinatorial epitope recognized by the TCR.     

Molecular analysis of TCR and peptide/MHC interaction using P18-I10-derived peptides with a single D-amino acid substitution

For the structural analysis of T-cell receptor (TCR) and peptide/MHC interaction, a series of peptides with a single amino acid substitution by a corresponding D-amino acid, having the same weight, size, and charge, within P18-I10 (aa318-327: RGPGRAFVTI), an immunodominant epitope of HIV-1 IIIB envelope glycoprotein, restricted by the H-2Dd class I MHC molecule, has been synthesized. Using those peptides, we have observed that the replacement at positions 324F, 325V, 326T, and 327I with each corresponding D-amino acid induced marked reduction of the potency to sensitize targets for P18-I10-specific murine CD8+ cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs), LINE-IIIB, recognition. To analyze further the role of amino acid at position 325, the most critical site for determining epitope specificity, we have developed a CTL line [LINE-IIIB(325D)] and its offspring clones specific for the epitope I-10(325v) having a D-valine (v) at position 325. Taking advantage of two distinct sets of CD8+ CTLs restricted by the same Dd, three-dimensional structural analysis on TCR and peptide/MHC complexes by molecular modeling was performed, which indicates that the critical amino acids within the TCRs for interacting with 325V or 325v appear to belong to the complementarity-determining region 1 but not to the complementarity-determining region 3 of Vbeta chain.     

Distinct footprints of TCR engagement with highly homologous ligands

T cell receptor engagement promotes proliferation, differentiation, survival, or death of T lymphocytes. The affinity/avidity of the TCR ligand and the maturational stage of the T cell are thought to be principal determinants of the outcome of TCR engagement. We demonstrate in this study that the same mouse TCR preferentially uses distinct residues of homologous peptides presented by the MHC molecules to promote specific cellular responses. The preference for distinct TCR contacts depends on neither the affinity/avidity of TCR engagement (except in the most extreme ranges), nor the maturity of engaged T cells. Thus, different portions of the TCR ligand appear capable of biasing T cells toward specific biological responses. These findings explain differences in functional versatility of TCR ligands, as well as anomalies in the relationship between affinity/avidity of the TCR for the peptide/MHC and cellular responses of T cells.     

Viral Escape Mutant Epitope Maintains TCR Affinity for Antigen yet Curtails CD8 T Cell Responses

T cells have the remarkable ability to recognize antigen with great specificity and in turn mount an appropriate and robust immune response. Critical to this process is the initial T cell antigen recognition and subsequent signal transduction events. This antigen recognition can be modulated at the site of TCR interaction with peptide:major histocompatibility (pMHC) or peptide interaction with the MHC molecule. Both events could have a range of effects on T cell fate. Though responses to antigens that bind sub-optimally to TCR, known as altered peptide ligands (APL), have been studied extensively, the impact of disrupting antigen binding to MHC has been highlighted to a lesser extent and is usually considered to result in complete loss of epitope recognition. Here we present a model of viral evasion from CD8 T cell immuno-surveillance by a lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV) escape mutant with an epitope for which TCR affinity for pMHC remains high but where the antigenic peptide binds sub optimally to MHC. Despite high TCR affinity for variant epitope, levels of interferon regulatory factor-4 (IRF4) are not sustained in response to the variant indicating differences in perceived TCR signal strength. The CD8+ T cell response to the variant epitope is characterized by early proliferation and up-regulation of activation markers. Interestingly, this response is not maintained and is characterized by a lack in IL-2 and IFNγ production, increased apoptosis and an abrogated glycolytic response. We show that disrupting the stability of peptide in MHC can effectively disrupt TCR signal strength despite unchanged affinity for TCR and can significantly impact the CD8+ T cell response to a viral escape mutant.     

TCR beta chain that forms peptide-independent alloreactive TCR transfers reduced reactivity with irrelevant peptide/MHC complex

A major feature of the TCR repertoire is strong alloreactivity. Peptides presented by allogeneic MHC are irrelevant for recognition by a subset of alloreactive T cells. To characterize peptide-independent TCRs at the molecular level, we forced the expression of a TCRbeta chain isolated from a peptide-independent alloreactive CD8+ T cell line. The alloreactive TCR repertoire in the transgenic mouse was peptide dependent. However, analysis of essential TCR contacts formed during the recognition of self-MHC-restricted Ag showed that fewer contacts with peptide were established by the transgenic TCRbeta chain, and that this was compensated by additional contacts formed by endogenous TCRalpha chains. Thus, reduced interaction with the peptide appears to be a transferable feature of the peptide-independent TCRbeta chain. In addition, these findings demonstrate that reactivity to peptides is preferred over the reactivity to MHC during the formation of the TCR repertoire.     

Recognition of an MHC class I-restricted antigenic peptide can be modulated by para-substitution of its buried tyrosine residues in a TCR-specific manner

Conformational dependence of TCR contact residues of the H-2Kb molecule on the two buried tyrosine side chains of the vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV)-8 peptide was investigated by systematic substitutions of the tyrosines with phenylalanine, p-fluorophenylalanine (pFF), or p-bromophenylalanine (pBrF). The results of peptide competition CTL assays revealed that all of the peptide variants, except for the pBrF analogues, had near-native binding to the H-2Kb molecule. Epitope-mapped anti-H-2Kb mAbs detected conformational differences among H-2Kb molecules stabilized with these VSV-8 variants on RMA-S cells. Selective recognition of the VSV-8 analogues was displayed by a panel of three H-2Kb-restricted, anti-VSV-8 TCRs. Thus, these substitutions result in an antigenically significant conformational change of the MHC molecular surface structure at both C and D pockets, and the effect of this change on cognate T cell recognition is dependent on the TCR structure. Our results confirm that the structure of buried peptide side chains can determine the surface conformation of the MHC molecule and demonstrate that even a very subtle structural nuance of the buried side chain can be incorporated into the surface conformation of the MHC molecule. The ability of buried residues to modulate this molecular surface augments the number of residues on the MHC-peptide complex that can be recognized as "foreign" by the CD8+ T cell repertoire and allows for a higher level of antigenic discrimination. This may be an important mechanism to expand the total number of TCR specificities that can respond to a single peptide determinant.     

Self-peptide/MHC and TCR antagonism: physiological role and therapeutic potential

TCR antagonists are peptides that bind MHC molecules and can specifically inhibit T cell activation induced by antigens. Studying TCR antagonism has taken an important place in immunology for both theoretical and practical reasons. Deciphering the mechanism(s) of action of TCR antagonists can yield important information about interactions of the TCR with ligands, T cell development, and TCR signaling. Moreover, microorganisms may employ TCR antagonism to elude the attention of the immune system. Finally, specificity of inhibition makes TCR antagonists an ideal tool to seek antigen-specific immunomodulation. Present state of knowledge on these topics is reviewed.     

CTL recognition of a bulged viral peptide involves biased TCR selection

MHC class I molecules generally present peptides of 8-10 aa long, forming an extended coil in the HLA cleft. Although longer peptides can also bind to class I molecules, they tend to bulge from the cleft and it is not known whether the TCR repertoire has sufficient plasticity to recognize these determinants during the antiviral CTL response. In this study, we show that unrelated individuals infected with EBV generate a significant CTL response directed toward an HLA-B*3501-restricted, 11-mer epitope from the BZLF1 Ag. The 11-mer determinant adopts a highly bulged conformation with seven of the peptide side chains being solvent-exposed and available for TCR interaction. Such a complex potentially creates a structural challenge for TCR corecognition of both HLA-B*3501 and the peptide Ag. Surprisingly, unrelated B*3501 donors recognizing the 11-mer use identical or closely related alphabeta TCR sequences that share particular CDR3 motifs. Within the small number of dominant CTL clonotypes observed, each has discrete fine specificity for the exposed side chain residues of the peptide. The data show that bulged viral peptides are indeed immunogenic but suggest that the highly constrained TCR repertoire reflects a limit to TCR diversity when responding to some unusual MHC peptide ligands.