Rational design of highly potent HIV-1 fusion inhibitory proteins: implication for developing antiviral therapeutics

Recombinant protein containing one heptad-repeat 1 (HR1) segment and one HR2 segment of the HIV-1 gp41 (HR1-HR2) has been shown to fold into thermally stable six-helix bundle, representing the fusogenic core of gp41. In this study, we have used the fusogenic core as a scaffold to design HIV-1 fusion inhibitory proteins by linking another HR1 to the C terminus of HR1-HR2 (HR121) or additional HR2 to the N terminus of HR1-HR2 (HR212). Both recombinant proteins could be abundantly and solubly expressed and easily purified, exhibiting high stability and potent inhibitory activity on HIV-1 fusion with IC50 values of 16.2+/-2.8 and 2.8+/-0.63 nM, respectively. These suggest that these rationally designed proteins can be further developed as novel anti-HIV-1 therapeutics.     

Interaction between dengue virus fusion peptide and lipid bilayers depends on peptide clustering

Dengue fever is one of the most widespread tropical diseases in the world. The disease is caused by a virus member of the Flaviviridae family, a group of enveloped positive sense single-stranded RNA viruses. Dengue virus infection is mediated by virus glycoprotein E, which binds to the cell surface. After uptake by endocytosis, this protein induces the fusion between viral envelope and endosomal membrane at the acidic environment of the endosomal compartment. In this work, we evaluated by steady-state and time-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy the interaction between the peptide believed to be the dengue virus fusion peptide and large unilamellar vesicles, studying the extent of partition, fusion capacity and depth of insertion in membranes. The roles of the bilayer composition (neutral and anionic phospholipids), ionic strength and pH of the medium were also studied. Our results indicate that dengue virus fusion peptide has a high affinity to vesicles composed of anionic lipids and that the interaction is mainly electrostatic. Both partition coefficient and fusion index are enhanced by negatively charged phospholipids. The location determined by differential fluorescence quenching using lipophilic probes demonstrated that the peptide is in an intermediate depth in the hemilayers, in-between the bilayer core and its surface. Ultimately, these data provide novel insights on the interaction between dengue virus fusion peptide and its target membranes, namely, the role of oligomerization and specific types of membranes.     

The N-terminal 12 residue long peptide of HIV gp41 is the minimal peptide sufficient to induce significant T-cell-like membrane destabilization in vitro

Here, we predicted the minimal N-terminal fragment of gp41 required to induce significant membrane destabilization using IMPALA. This algorithm is dedicated to predict peptide interaction with a membrane. We based our prediction of the minimal fusion peptide on the tilted peptide theory. This theory proposes that some protein fragments having a peculiar distribution of hydrophobicity adopt a tilted orientation at a hydrophobic/hydrophilic interface. As a result of this orientation, tilted peptides should disrupt the interface. We analysed in silico the membrane-interacting properties of gp41 N-terminal peptides of different length derived from the isolate BRU and from an alignment of 710 HIV strains available on the Los Alamos National Laboratory. Molecular modelling results indicated that the 12 residue long peptide should be the minimal fusion peptide. We then assayed lipid-mixing and leakage of T-cell-like liposomes with N-terminal peptides of different length as first challenge of our predictions. Experimental results confirmed that the 12 residue long peptide is necessary and sufficient to induce membrane destabilization to the same extent as the 23 residue long fusion peptide. In silico analysis of some fusion-incompetent mutants presented in the literature further revealed that they cannot insert into a modelled membrane correctly tilted. According to this work, the tilted peptide model appears to explain at least partly the membrane destabilization properties of HIV fusion peptide.     

Are fusion peptides a good model to study viral cell fusion?

Fusion peptides are hydrophobic and conserved sequences located within glycoprotein ectodomains that protrude from the virion surface. Direct participation of fusion peptides in the viral membrane fusion phenomenon has been inferred from genetic analyses showing that even a single residue substitution or a deletion within these sequences may completely block the process. However, the specific fusion peptide activities associated to the multi-step fusion mechanism are not well defined. Based on the assumption that fusion peptides are transferred into target membranes, biophysical methodologies have been applied to study integration into model membranes of synthetic fragments representing functional and non-functional sequences. From these studies, it is inferred that, following insertion, functional sequences generate target membrane perturbations and adopt specific structural arrangements within. Further characterization of these artificial systems may help in understanding the molecular processes that bring initial bilayer destabilizations to the eventual opening of a fusion pore.     

Structural analysis of the epitope of the anti-HIV antibody 2F5 sheds light into its mechanism of neutralization and HIV fusion

Inhibition of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) fusion with the host cell has emerged as a viable therapeutic strategy, and rational design of inhibitors and vaccines, interfering with this process, is a prime target for antiviral research. To advance our knowledge of the structural biology of HIV fusion, we have studied the membrane-proximal region of the fusogenic envelope subunit gp41, which includes the epitope ELDKWA of the broadly neutralizing human antibody 2F5. The structural evidence available for this region is contradictory, with some studies suggesting an overall helical conformation, while the X-ray structure of the ELDKWAS peptide bound to the antibody shows it folded in a type I beta turn. We used a two-step strategy: Firstly, by a competition binding assay, we identified the proper boundaries of the domain recognized by 2F5, which we found considerably larger than the ELDKWAS hexapeptide. Secondly, we studied the structure of the resulting 13 amino acid residue peptide by collecting NMR data and analyzing them by our previously developed statistical method (NAMFIS). Our study revealed that the increase in binding affinity goes in parallel with stabilization of specific local and global conformational propensities, absent from the shorter epitope. When compounded with the available biological evidence, our structural analysis allows us to propose a specific role for the membrane-proximal region during HIV fusion, in terms of a conformational transition between the turn and the helical structure. At the same time, our hypothesis offers a structural explanation for the mechanism of neutralization of mAb 2F5.     

Characterization and HIV-1 fusion inhibitory properties of monoclonal Fabs obtained from a human non-immune phage library selected against diverse epitopes of the ectodomain of HIV-1 gp41

Using a human non-immune phage library comprising more than 10(9) functional human antibody specificities in Fab format, we have been able to select a set of eight monoclonal Fabs targeted against diverse epitopes of the ectodomain of gp41 from HIV-1. The antigens used for panning the antibodies comprised two soluble, disulfide-linked, trimeric polypeptides derived from gp41, N(CCG)-gp41 and N35(CCG)-N13. The former comprises an exposed trimeric coiled-coil of the N-helices of gp41 fused in helical phase to the minimal thermostable ectodomain of gp41, while the latter comprises only the trimeric coiled-coil of N-helices. The selected Fabs were probed by Western blot analysis against four antigens: N(CCG)-gp41, N35CCG-N13, N34CCG (a smaller version of N35CCG-N13), and the minimal thermostable ectodomain core of gp41 in its six-helix bundle conformation (6-HB). Three classes of Fabs were found: class A (two Fabs) interact predominantly with the 6-HB; class B (four Fabs) interact with both the 6-HB and the internal trimeric coiled-coil of N-helices; and class C (two Fabs) interact specifically with the internal trimeric coiled-coil of N-helices. The IC50 values for the Fabs, expressed as bivalent mini-antibodies, ranged from 6 microg/ml to 60 microg/ml in a quantitative vaccinia virus-based reporter gene assay for HIV-1 envelope-mediated cell fusion using the envelope from the HIV-1 T tropic strain LAV. The two most potent fusion inhibitors belonged to class B. This panel of Fabs provides a set of useful probes for studying HIV-1 envelope-mediated cell fusion and may serve as a basis for developing Fab-based anti-HIV-1 therapeutics.     

Membrane curvature and surface area per lipid affect the conformation and oligomeric state of HIV-1 fusion peptide: A combined FTIR and MD simulation study

Fourier-transformed infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) and molecular dynamics (MD) simulation results are presented to support our hypothesis that the conformation and the oligomeric state of the HIV-1 gp41 fusion domain or fusion peptide (gp41-FP) are determined by the membrane surface area per lipid (APL), which is affected by the membrane curvature. FTIR of the gp41-FP in the Aerosol-OT (AOT) reversed micellar system showed that as APL decreases from ∼ 50 to 35 Å² by varying the AOT/water ratio, the FP changes from the monomeric α-helical to the oligomeric β-sheet structure. MD simulations in POPE lipid bilayer systems showed that as the APL decreases by applying a negative surface tension, helical monomers start to unfold into turn-like structures. Furthermore, an increase in the applied lateral pressure during nonequilibrium MD simulations favored the formation of β-sheet structure. These results provide better insight into the relationship between the structures of the gp41-FP and the membrane, which is essential in understanding the membrane fusion process. The implication of the results of this work on what is the fusogenic structure of the HIV-1 FP is discussed.     

The HIV fusion peptide adopts intermolecular parallel beta-sheet structure in membranes when stabilized by the adjacent N-terminal heptad repeat: a 13C FTIR study

The HIV gp41 protein mediates fusion with target host cells. The region primarily involved in directing fusion, the fusion peptide (FP), is poorly understood at the level of structure and function due to its toxic effect in expression systems. To overcome this, we used a synthetic approach to generate the N70 construct, whereby the FP is stabilized in context of the adjacent auto oligomerization domain. The amide I profile of unlabeled N70 in membranes reveals prominent alpha-helical contribution, along with significant beta-structure. By truncating the N terminus (FP region) of N70, beta-structure is eliminated, suggesting that the FP adopts a beta-structure in membranes. To assess this directly, (13)C Fourier-transformed infra-red analysis was carried out to map secondary structure of the 16 N-terminal hydrophobic residues of the fusion peptide (FP16). The (13)C isotope shifted absorbance of the FP was filtered from the global secondary structure of the 70 residue construct (N70). On the basis of the peak shift induced by the (13)C-labeled residues of FP16, we directly assign beta-sheet structure in ordered membranes. A differential labeling scheme in FP16 allows us to distinguish the type of beta-sheet structure as parallel. Dilution of each FP16-labeled N70 peptide, by mixing with unlabeled N70, shows directly that the FP16 beta-strand region self-assembles. We discuss our structural findings in the context of the prevailing gp41 fusion paradigm. Specifically, we address the role of the FP region in organizing supramolecular gp41 assembly, and we also discuss the mechanism by which exogenous, free FP constructs inhibit gp41-induced fusion.     

Molecular dynamics simulations and conductance studies of the interaction of VP1 N-terminus from Polio virus and gp41 fusion peptide from HIV-1 with lipid membranes

Abstract

The icosahedral Polio virus capsid consists of 60 copies of each of the coat proteins VP1, VP2, VP3 and myristolyated VP4 (myrVP4). Catalyzed by the host cell receptor the Polio virus enters the host cell via externalization of myrVP4 and the N terminal part of VP1. There are several assumptions about the individual role of both of the proteins in the mechanism of membrane attachment and genome injection. We use the first 32 N terminal amino acids of VP1 and applied molecular dynamics simulations to assess its mechanism of function when attached and inserted into hydrated lipid membranes (POPC). Helical models are placed in various positions in regard to the lipid membrane to start with. As a comparison, the first 33 amino acids of the fusion peptide of gp41 of HIV-1 are simulated under identical conditions. Computational data support the idea that VP1 is not penetrating into the membrane to form a pore; it rather lays on the membrane surface and only perturbs the membrane. Furthermore, this idea is strengthened by channel recordings of both peptides showing irregular openings.     

The dominant-negative action of a fusion protein containing the cytoplasmic domain of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 transmembrane protein gp41 in virus replication

We previously described a novel mode of downregulation of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) Gag expression by a cytoplasmic domain fusion protein of the envelope (Env) transmembrane protein, β-galactosidase (β-gal)/706–856, which contains the cytoplasmic tail of gp41 fused at the C terminus of Escherichia coli β-gal. In the present study, we showed that this mediator conferred a dose-dependent dominant interference with virus infectivity. In the context of an HIV-1 provirus, this inhibitor downregulated steady-state Env expression. Paradoxically, Env overexpression suppressed β-gal/706–856-mediatd Gag downregulation. Sucrose gradient ultracentrifugation and confocal microscopy revealed that Gag, Env, and β-gal/706–856 had stable interactions and formed aggregated complexes in perinuclear regions. Moreover, Env overexpression hindered colocalization of Gag with β-gal/706–856 in the perinuclear region. Further cytoplasmic domain mapping analyses showed a correlation between the ability of cytoplasmic subdomains to downregulate Gag expression and the ability of these subdomains to stably interact with Gag. These studies show that redirection of Gag from its cytoplasmic synthesis site to a perinuclear compartment is a prerequisite for β-gal/706–856-mediated Gag downregulation. The results also illustrate that the dynamic interplay among Gag, Env, and β-gal/706–856 can modulate Gag and Env expression, thus controlling HIV-1 infection.     

Molecular dynamics simulations of the influenza hemagglutinin fusion peptide in micelles and bilayers: conformational analysis of peptide and lipids

Molecular dynamics simulations of the influenza hemagglutinin fusion peptide in two differently sized dodecylphosphocholine micelles and a palmitoyl oleoyl phosphatidylcholine bilayer were generated to analyze the influence of the environment. Four independent trajectories (5 ns each for the bilayer, and 2 ns each for the micelles) were generated for each system. The peptide lies at the surface of the micelles, while its N-terminal region inserts deeply in the bilayer. This leads to a substantial increase of the solvation and rigidity of the peptide in micelles as compared to the bilayer. The average structures, nevertheless, are similar in all three systems and agree reasonably with micelle-based NMR structures. When in the bilayer, the peptide increases the chain gauche population and area of adjacent lipids in the same binding leaflet, while it has the opposite effect for the nearby lipids of the other leaflet. These changes, which occur spontaneously to fill voids and defects, cause a decrease in the thickness of the membrane in the neighborhood of the peptide. They would be expected to promote positive curvature, as consistent with the formation of the convex bulge, or "nipple", in the initial stage of membrane fusion. An extension of the classical surfactant theory of Israelachvili based on shapes is proposed to introduce the concept of a "dynamically induced shape" of the membrane lipids by the peptide.     

Class I and class II viral fusion protein structures reveal similar principles in membrane fusion (Review)

Recent crystal structures of Flavivirus and Alphavirus fusion proteins (class II) confirm two major principles of protein machineries that mediate the merger of two opposing lipid bilayers. First, the fusion protein can bridge both membranes tethered by two membrane anchors. Second, refolding or domain rearrangement steps lead to the positioning of both anchors into close proximity at the same end of an elongated structure. Although these two steps are in principle sufficient to pull two opposing membranes together and initiate membrane fusion, accumulating evidence suggests that the process requires the concerted action of a number of fusion proteins at and outside the contact sites. This review will focus on the structures of viral class I and class II fusion proteins and their similarities in facilitating membrane fusion.     

Sphingolipids, cholesterol, and HIV-1: A paradigm in viral fusion

Our previous studies show that the depletion of cholesterol or sphingolipids (raft-associated lipids) from receptor-bearing adherent cell lines blocks HIV-1 entry and HIV-1 Env-mediated membrane fusion. Here we have evaluated the mechanism(s) by which these lipids contribute to the HIV-1 Env-mediated membrane fusion. We report the following: (1) GSL depletion from a suspension T lymphocyte cell line (Sup-T1) reduced subsequent fusion with HIV-1IIIB-expressing cells by 70%. (2) Cholesterol depletion from NIH3T3 cells bearing HIV-1 receptors (NIH3T3CD4R5/NIH3T3CD4X4) did not impair subsequent fusion with HeLa cells expressing the corresponding HIV-1 Envs. In contrast GSL depletion from these targets reduced fusion by 50% suggesting that GSL facilitate fusion in different ways. (3) GSL-deficient GM95 cells bearing high receptors fused with HIV-1 Env-expressing cells at 37°C with kinetics similar to that of GSL + NIH3T3 targets. Based on these observations, we propose that the plasma membrane cholesterol is required to maintain the integrity of receptor pools whereas GSLs are involved in stabilizing the coupling of inter-receptor pools.     

Viral Fusion Peptides: A Tool Set to Disrupt and Connect Biological Membranes

The structure and function of viral fusion peptides are reviewed. The fusion peptides of influenza virus hemagglutinin and human immunodeficiency virus are used as paradigms. Fusion peptides associated with lipid bilayers are conformationally polymorphic. Current evidence suggests that the fusion-promoting state is the obliquely inserted -helix. Fusion peptides also have a tendency to self-associate into -sheets at membrane surfaces. Although the conformational conversion between - and -states is reversible under controlled conditions, its physiological relevance is not yet known. The energetics of peptide insertion and self-association could be measured recently using more soluble second generation fusion peptides. Fusion peptides have been reported to change membrane curvature and the state of hydration of membrane surfaces. The combined results are built into a model for the mechanism by which fusion peptides are proposed to assist in biological membrane fusion.     

New carbohydrate specificity and HIV-1 fusion blocking activity of the cyanobacterial protein MVL: NMR, ITC and sedimentation equilibrium studies

Carbohydrate-binding proteins that bind their carbohydrate ligands with high affinity are rare and therefore of interest because they expand our understanding of carbohydrate specificity and the structural requirements that lead to high-affinity interactions. Here, we use NMR and isothermal titration calorimetry techniques to determine carbohydrate specificity and affinities for a novel cyanobacterial protein, MVL, and show that MVL binds oligomannosides such as Man(6)GlcNAc(2) with sub-micromolar affinities. The amino acid sequence of MVL contains two homologous repeats, each comprising 54 amino acid residues. Using multi-dimensional NMR techniques, we show that MVL contains two novel carbohydrate recognition domains composed of four non-contiguous regions comprising approximately 15 amino acid residues each, and that these residues make numerous intermolecular contacts with their carbohydrate ligands. NMR screening of a comprehensive panel of di-, tri-, and high-mannose oligosaccharides establish that high-affinity binding requires at least the presence of a discrete conformation presented by Manbeta(1-->4)GlcNAc in the context of larger oligomannosides. As shown by sedimentation equilibrium and gel-filtration experiments, MVL is a monodisperse dimer in solution, and NMR data establish that the three-dimensional structure must be symmetric. MVL inhibits HIV-1 Envelope-mediated cell fusion with an IC(50) value of approximately 30 nM.     

Hydrophobic-at-Interface Regions in Viral Fusion Protein Ectodomains

In this chapter we shall describe how to apply the hydrophobicity-at-interface scale, as proposed by Wimley and White [Wimley, W. C. and White, S. H. (1996) Nature Struct. Biol. 3:842–848], to the detection of amino acid sequences of viral envelope glycoproteins putatively engaged in interactions with the target membranes. In addition, a new approach will be briefly introduced to infer the bilayer location at equilibrium of membrane-partitioning sequences. The use of these new procedures may be important in describing the molecular mechanism leading to the formation of a fusion pore by viral glycoproteins.     

Chemical shift assignment and structural plasticity of a HIV fusion peptide derivative in dodecylphosphocholine micelles

A “HFPK3” peptide containing the 23 residues of the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) fusion peptide (HFP) plus three non-native C-terminal lysines was studied in dodecylphosphocholine (DPC) micelles with 2D ¹H NMR spectroscopy. The HFP is at the N-terminus of the gp41 fusion protein and plays an important role in fusing viral and target cell membranes which is a critical step in viral infection. Unlike HFP, HFPK3 is monomeric in detergent-free buffered aqueous solution which may be a useful property for functional and structural studies. H^α chemical shifts indicated that DPC-associated HFPK3 was predominantly helical from I4 to L12. In addition to the highest-intensity crosspeaks used for the first chemical shift assignment (denoted I), there were additional crosspeaks whose intensities were ∼ 10% of those used for assignment I. A second assignment (II) for residues G5 to L12 as well as a few other residues was derived from these lower-intensity crosspeaks. Relative to the I shifts, the II shifts were different by 0.01-0.23 ppm with the largest differences observed for H^N. Comparison of the shifts of DPC-associated HFPK3 with those of detergent-associated HFP and HFP derivatives provided information about peptide structures and locations in micelles.     

Properties and structures of the influenza and HIV fusion peptides on lipid membranes: implications for a role in fusion

The fusion peptides of HIV and influenza virus are crucial for viral entry into a host cell. We report the membrane-perturbing and structural properties of fusion peptides from the HA fusion protein of influenza virus and the gp41 fusion protein of HIV. Our goals were to determine: 1), how fusion peptides alter structure within the bilayers of fusogenic and nonfusogenic lipid vesicles and 2), how fusion peptide structure is related to the ability to promote fusion. Fluorescent probes revealed that neither peptide had a significant effect on bilayer packing at the water-membrane interface, but both increased acyl chain order in both fusogenic and nonfusogenic vesicles. Both also reduced free volume within the bilayer as indicated by partitioning of a lipophilic fluorophore into membranes. These membrane ordering effects were smaller for the gp41 peptide than for the HA peptide at low peptide/lipid ratio, suggesting that the two peptides assume different structures on membranes. The influenza peptide was predominantly helical, and the gp41 peptide was predominantly antiparallel beta-sheet when membrane bound, however, the depths of penetration of Trps of both peptides into neutral membranes were similar and independent of membrane composition. We previously demonstrated: 1), the abilities of both peptides to promote fusion but not initial intermediate formation during PEG-mediated fusion and 2), the ability of hexadecane to compete with this effect of the fusion peptides. Taken together, our current and past results suggest a hypothesis for a common mechanism by which these two viral fusion peptides promote fusion.     

Insertion selectivity of antimicrobial peptide protegrin-1 into lipid monolayers: Effect of head group electrostatics and tail group packing

The ability to selectively target the harmful microbial membrane over that of the host cell is one of the most important characteristics of the antimicrobial peptides (AMPs). This selectivity strongly depends on the chemical and structural properties of the lipids that make up the cell membrane. A systematic study of the initial membrane selectivity of protegrin-1 (PG-1), a β-sheet AMP, was performed using Langmuir monolayers. Constant pressure insertion assay was used to quantify the amount of PG-1 insertion and fluorescence microscopy was employed to observe the effect of PG-1 on lipid ordering. Charge and packing properties of the monolayer were altered by using lipids with different head groups, substituting saturated with unsaturated lipid tail group(s) and incorporating spacer molecules. PG-1 inserted most readily into anionic films composed of phosphatidylglycerol (PG) and lipid A, consistent with its high selectivity for microbial membranes. It also discriminated between zwitteranionic phospholipids, inserting more readily into phosphatidylcholine (PC) monolayers than those composed of phosphatidylethanolamine, potentially explaining why PG-1 is hemolytic for PC-rich human erythrocytes and not for the PE-rich erythrocytes of ruminants. Increased packing density of the monolayer by increased surface pressure, increased tail group saturation or incorporation of dihydrocholesterol diminishes the insertion of PG-1. Fluorescence microscopy shows that lipid packing is disordered upon PG-1 insertion. However, the presence of PG-1 can still affect lipid morphology even with no observed PG-1 insertion. These results show the important role that lipid composition of the cell membrane plays in the activity of AMPs.     

Structure and plasticity of the human immunodeficiency virus gp41 fusion domain in lipid micelles and bilayers

A thorough understanding of the structure of fusion domains of enveloped viruses in changing lipid environments helps us to formulate mechanistic models on how they might function in mediating viral entry by membrane fusion. We have expressed the N-terminal fusion domain of HIV-1 gp41 as a construct that is water-soluble in the absence of membranes, but that also binds with high affinity to lipid micelles and bilayers in their presence. We have solved the structure and studied the dynamics of this domain bound to dodecylphosphocholine micelles by homo- and heteronuclear NMR spectroscopy. The fusion peptide forms a stable hydrophobic helix from Ile(4) to Ala(14), but is increasingly more disordered and dynamic in a segment of intermediate polarity that stretches from Ala(15) to Ser(23). When bound to lipid bilayers at low concentration, the HIV fusion domain is also largely alpha-helical, as determined by CD and FTIR spectroscopy. However, at higher protein/lipid ratios, the domain is partially converted to form beta-structures in lipid bilayers. Controlled lipid mixing occurs at concentrations that support the alpha-helical, but not the beta-strand conformation.