An internal water-retention site in the rhomboid intramembrane protease GlpG ensures catalytic efficiency

Rhomboid proteases regulate key cellular pathways, but their biochemical mechanism including how water is made available to the membrane-immersed active site remains ambiguous. We performed four prolonged molecular dynamics simulations initiated from both gate-open and gate-closed states of Escherichia coli rhomboid GlpG in a phospholipid bilayer. GlpG was notably stable in both gating states, experiencing similar tilt and local membrane thinning, with no observable gating transitions, highlighting that gating is rate-limiting. Analysis of dynamics revealed rapid loss of crystallographic waters from the active site, but retention of a water cluster within a site formed by His141, Ser181, Ser185, and/or Gln189. Experimental interrogation of 14 engineered mutants revealed an essential role for at least Gln189 and Ser185 in catalysis with no effect on structural stability. Our studies indicate that spontaneous water supply to the intramembrane active site of rhomboid proteases is rare, but its availability for catalysis is ensured by an unanticipated active site element, the water-retention site.     

Conformational surveillance of Orai1 by a rhomboid intramembrane protease prevents inappropriate CRAC channel activation

1. Download : Download high-res image (151KB)
2. Download : Download full-size image

     

Catalytic mechanism of rhomboid protease GlpG probed by 3,4-dichloroisocoumarin and diisopropyl fluorophosphonate

Rhomboid proteases have many important biological functions. Unlike soluble serine proteases such as chymotrypsin, the active site of rhomboid protease, which contains a Ser-His catalytic dyad, is submerged in the membrane and surrounded by membrane-spanning helices. Previous crystallographic analyses of GlpG, a bacterial rhomboid protease, and its complex with isocoumarin have provided insights into the mechanism of the membrane protease. Here, we studied the interaction of GlpG with 3,4-dichloroisocoumarin and diisopropyl fluorophosphonate, both mechanism-based inhibitors for the serine protease, and describe the crystal structure of the covalent adduct between GlpG and diisopropyl fluorophosphonate, which mimics the oxyanion-containing tetrahedral intermediate of the hydrolytic reaction. The crystal structure confirms that the oxyanion is stabilized by the main chain amide of Ser-201 and by the side chains of His-150 and Asn-154. The phosphorylation of the catalytic Ser-201 weakens its interaction with His-254, causing the catalytic histidine to rotate away from the serine. The rotation of His-254 is accompanied by further rearrangement of the side chains of Tyr-205 and Trp-236 within the substrate-binding groove. The formation of the tetrahedral adduct is also accompanied by opening of the L5 cap and movement of transmembrane helix S5 toward S6 in a direction different from that predicted by the lateral gating model. Combining the new structural data with those on the isocoumarin complex sheds further light on the plasticity of the active site of rhomboid membrane protease.     

Solution structure and dynamics of the N-terminal cytosolic domain of rhomboid intramembrane protease from Pseudomonas aeruginosa: insights into a functional role in intramembrane proteolysis

Rhomboids are ubiquitous integral membrane proteases that release cellular signals from membrane-bound substrates through a general signal transduction mechanism known as regulated intramembrane proteolysis (RIP). We present the NMR structure of the cytosolic N-terminal domain (NRho) of P. aeruginosa Rhomboid. NRho consists of a novel alpha/beta fold and represents the first detailed structural insight into this class of intramembrane proteases. We find evidence that NRho is capable of strong and specific association with detergent micelles that mimic the membrane/water interface. Relaxation measurements on NRho reveal structural fluctuations on the microseconds-milliseconds timescale in regions including and contiguous to those implicated in membrane interaction. This structural plasticity may facilitate the ability of NRho to recognize and associate with membranes. We suggest that NRho plays a role in scissile peptide bond selectivity by optimally positioning the Rhomboid active site relative to the membrane plane.     

Bioinformatics perspective on rhomboid intramembrane protease evolution and function

Endopeptidase classification based on catalytic mechanism and evolutionary history has proven to be invaluable to the study of proteolytic enzymes. Such general mechanistic- and evolutionary- based groupings have launched experimental investigations, because knowledge gained for one family member tends to apply to the other closely related enzymes. The serine endopeptidases represent one of the most abundant and diverse groups, with their apparently successful proteolytic mechanism having arisen independently many times throughout evolution, giving rise to the well-studied soluble chemotrypsins and subtilisins, among many others. A large and diverse family of polytopic transmembrane proteins known as rhomboids has also evolved the serine protease mechanism. While the spatial structure, mechanism, and biochemical function of this family as intramembrane proteases has been established, the cellular roles of these enzymes as well as their natural substrates remain largely undetermined. While the evolutionary history of rhomboid proteases has been debated, sorting out the relationships among current day representatives should provide a solid basis for narrowing the knowledge gap between their biochemical and cellular functions. Indeed, some functional characteristics of rhomboid proteases can be gleaned from their evolutionary relationships. Finally, a specific case where phylogenetic profile analysis has identified proteins that contain a C-terminal processing motif (GlyGly-Cterm) as co-occurring with a set of bacterial rhomboid proteases provides an example of potential target identification through bioinformatics. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Intramembrane Proteases.     

Proteolytic action of GlpG, a rhomboid protease in the Escherichia coli cytoplasmic membrane

We characterized Escherichia coli GlpG as a membrane-embedded protease and a possible player in the regulated intramembrane proteolysis in this organism. From the sequence features, it belongs to the widely conserved rhomboid family of membrane proteases. We verified the expected topology of GlpG, and it traverses the membrane six times. A model protein having an N-terminal and periplasmically localized beta-lactamase (Bla) domain, a LacY-derived transmembrane region, and a cytosolic maltose binding protein (MBP) mature domain was found to be GlpG-dependently cleaved in vivo. This proteolytic reaction was reproduced in vitro using purified GlpG and purified model substrate protein, and the cleavage was shown to occur between Ser and Asp in a region of high local hydrophilicity, which might be located in a juxtamembrane rather than an intramembrane position. The conserved Ser and His residues of GlpG were essential for the proteolytic activities. Our results using several variant forms of the model protein suggest that GlpG recognizes features of the transmembrane regions of substrates. These results point to a detailed molecular mechanism and cellular analysis of this interesting class of membrane-embedded proteases.     

Influence of hydrophobic mismatch on the catalytic activity of Escherichia coli GlpG rhomboid protease

Rhomboids comprise a broad family of intramembrane serine proteases that are found in a wide range of organisms and participate in a diverse array of biological processes. High-resolution structures of the catalytic transmembrane domain of the Escherichia coli GlpG rhomboid have provided numerous insights that help explain how hydrolytic cleavage can be achieved below the membrane surface. Key to this are observations that GlpG hydrophobic domain dimensions may not be sufficient to completely span the native lipid bilayer. This formed the basis for a model where hydrophobic mismatch Induces thinning of the local membrane environment to promote access to transmembrane substrates. However, hydrophobic mismatch also has the potential to alter the functional properties of the rhomboid, a possibility we explore in the current work. For this purpose, we purified the catalytic transmembrane domain of GlpG into phosphocholine or maltoside detergent micelles of varying alkyl chain lengths, and assessed proteolytic function with a model water-soluble substrate. Catalytic turnover numbers were found to depend on detergent alkyl chain length, with saturated chains containing 10–12 carbon atoms supporting maximal activity. Similar results were obtained in phospholipid bicelles, with no proteolytic activity being detected in longer-chain lipids. Although differences in thermal stability and GlpG oligomerization could not explain these activity differences, circular dichroism spectra suggest that mismatch gives rise to a small change in structure. Overall, these results demonstrate that hydrophobic mismatch can exert an inhibitory effect on rhomboid activity, with the potential for changes in local membrane environment to regulate activity in vivo.     

Structural analysis of a rhomboid family intramembrane protease reveals a gating mechanism for substrate entry

Intramembrane proteolysis regulates diverse biological processes. Cleavage of substrate peptide bonds within the membrane bilayer is catalyzed by integral membrane proteases. Here we report the crystal structure of the transmembrane core domain of GlpG, a rhomboid-family intramembrane serine protease from Escherichia coli. The protein contains six transmembrane helices, with the catalytic Ser201 located at the N terminus of helix alpha4 approximately 10 A below the membrane surface. Access to water molecules is provided by a central cavity that opens to the extracellular region and converges on Ser201. One of the two GlpG molecules in the asymmetric unit has an open conformation at the active site, with the transmembrane helix alpha5 bent away from the rest of the molecule. Structural analysis suggests that substrate entry to the active site is probably gated by the movement of helix alpha5.     

The intramembrane active site of GlpG, an E. coli rhomboid protease, is accessible to water and hydrolyses an extramembrane peptide bond of substrates

Escherichia coli GlpG is an orthologue of the rhomboid proteases that catalyse intramembrane proteolysis of specific membrane proteins. We previously showed that it can cleave a type I model membrane protein, Bla-LY2-MBP, having the second transmembrane region of lactose permease (LY2) in vivo and in vitro at the predicted periplasm-membrane boundary region of LY2. Here we investigated the environment of the active site regions of GlpG in the membrane-integrated state by examining the modifiability of Cys residues introduced into the regions around the catalytic residues with membrane-permeable and -impermeable alkylating reagents. The results indicate that the enzyme active site is fully open to the external aqueous phase. GlpG also cleaved a similar fusion protein, Bla-GknTM-MBP, having the transmembrane region of Gurken (GknTM), a physiological substrate of Drosophila rhomboids. Engineered Cys residues in the cleavage site regions of the LY2 and GknTM sequences were efficiently modified with a membrane-impermeable alkylating reagent, showing that these regions are exposed to the periplasm. These results suggest that GlpG cleaves an extramembrane region of substrates, unlike the currently prevailing view that this class of membrane proteases acts against a membrane-embedded polypeptide segment after its lateral entrance into the enzyme's active site.     

Conformational change in rhomboid protease GlpG induced by inhibitor binding to its S' subsites

Rhomboid protease conducts proteolysis inside the hydrophobic environment of the membrane. The conformational flexibility of the protease is essential for the enzyme mechanism, but the nature of this flexibility is not completely understood. Here we describe the crystal structure of rhomboid protease GlpG in complex with a phosphonofluoridate inhibitor, which is covalently bonded to the catalytic serine and extends into the S' side of the substrate binding cleft. Inhibitor binding causes subtle but extensive changes in the membrane protease. Many transmembrane helices tilt and shift positions, and the gap between S2 and S5 is slightly widened so that the inhibitor can bind between them. The side chain of Phe-245 from a loop (L5) that acts as a cap rotates and uncovers the opening of the substrate binding cleft to the lipid bilayer. A concurrent turn of the polypeptide backbone at Phe-245 moves the rest of the cap and exposes the catalytic serine to the aqueous solution. This study, together with earlier crystallographic investigation of smaller inhibitors, suggests a simple model for explaining substrate binding to rhomboid protease.     

Sequence features of substrates required for cleavage by GlpG, an Escherichia coli rhomboid protease

Rhomboids are a family of serine proteases belonging to intramembrane cleaving proteases, which are supposed to catalyse proteolysis of a substrate protein within the membrane. It remains unclear whether substrates of the rhomboid proteases have a common sequence feature that allows specific cleavage by rhomboids. We showed previously that GlpG, the Escherichia coli rhomboid, can cleave a type I model membrane protein Bla-LY2-MBP having the second transmembrane region of lactose permease (LY2) at the extramembrane region in vivo and in vitro, and that determinants for proteolysis reside within the LY2 sequence. Here we characterized sequence features in LY2 that allow efficient cleavage by GlpG and identified two elements, a hydrophilic region encompassing the cleavage site and helix-destabilizing residues in the downstream hydrophobic region. Importance of the positioning of helix-destabilizers relative to the cleavage site was suggested. These two elements appear to co-operatively promote proteolysis of substrates by GlpG. Finally, random mutagenesis of the cleavage site residues in combination with in vivo screening revealed that GlpG prefers residues with a small side chain and a negative charge at the P1 and P1' sites respectively.     

Structure and mechanism of intramembrane protease

Many functionally important membrane proteins are cleaved within their transmembrane helices to become activated. This unusual reaction is catalyzed by a group of highly specialized and membrane-bound proteases. Here I briefly summarize current knowledge about their structure and mechanism, with a focus on the rhomboid family. It has now become clear that rhomboid protease can cleave substrates not only within transmembrane domains, but also in the solvent-exposed juxtamembrane region. This dual specificity seems possible because the protease active site is positioned in a shallow pocket that can directly open to aqueous solution through the movement of a flexible capping loop. The narrow membrane-spanning region of the protease suggests a possible mechanism for accessing scissile bonds that are located near the end of substrate transmembrane helices. Similar principles may apply to the metalloprotease family, where a crystal structure has also become available. Although how the GxGD proteases work is still less clear, recent results indicate that presenilin also appears to clip substrate from the end of transmembrane helices.     

Involvement of the second extracellular loop and transmembrane residues of CCR5 in inhibitor binding and HIV-1 fusion: insights into the mechanism of allosteric inhibition

C-C chemokine receptor 5 (CCR5), a member of G-protein-coupled receptors, serves as a coreceptor for human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1). In the present study, we examined the interactions between CCR5 and novel CCR5 inhibitors containing the spirodiketopiperazine scaffolds AK530 and AK317, both of which were lodged in the hydrophobic cavity located between the upper transmembrane domain and the second extracellular loop (ECL2) of CCR5. Although substantial differences existed between the two inhibitors—AK530 had 10-fold-greater CCR5-binding affinity (K_d = 1.4 nM) than AK317 (16.7 nM)—their antiviral potencies were virtually identical (IC₅₀ = 2.1 nM and 1.5 nM, respectively). Molecular dynamics simulations for unbound CCR5 showed hydrogen bond interactions among transmembrane residues Y108, E283, and Y251, which were crucial for HIV-1-gp120/sCD4 complex binding and HIV-1 fusion. Indeed, AK530 and AK317, when bound to CCR5, disrupted these interhelix hydrogen bond interactions, a salient molecular mechanism enabling allosteric inhibition. Mutagenesis and structural analysis showed that ECL2 consists of a part of the hydrophobic cavity for both inhibitors, although AK317 is more tightly engaged with ECL2 than AK530, explaining their similar anti-HIV-1 potencies despite the difference in K_d values. We also found that amino acid residues in the β-hairpin structural motif of ECL2 are critical for HIV-1-elicited fusion and binding of the spirodiketopiperazine-based inhibitors to CCR5. The direct ECL2-engaging property of the inhibitors likely produces an ECL2 conformation, which HIV-1 gp120 cannot bind to, but also prohibits HIV-1 from utilizing the “inhibitor-bound” CCR5 for cellular entry—a mechanism of HIV-1's resistance to CCR5 inhibitors. The data should not only help delineate the dynamics of CCR5 following inhibitor binding but also aid in designing CCR5 inhibitors that are more potent against HIV-1 and prevent or delay the emergence of resistant HIV-1 variants.     

Allosteric regulation of rhomboid intramembrane proteolysis

Proteolysis within the lipid bilayer is poorly understood, in particular the regulation of substrate cleavage. Rhomboids are a family of ubiquitous intramembrane serine proteases that harbour a buried active site and are known to cleave transmembrane substrates with broad specificity. In vitro gel and Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET)‐based kinetic assays were developed to analyse cleavage of the transmembrane substrate psTatA (TatA from Providencia stuartii). We demonstrate significant differences in catalytic efficiency (k_cat/K_0.5) values for transmembrane substrate psTatA (TatA from Providencia stuartii) cleavage for three rhomboids: AarA from P. stuartii, ecGlpG from Escherichia coli and hiGlpG from Haemophilus influenzae demonstrating that rhomboids specifically recognize this substrate. Furthermore, binding of psTatA occurs with positive cooperativity. Competitive binding studies reveal an exosite‐mediated mode of substrate binding, indicating allostery plays a role in substrate catalysis. We reveal that exosite formation is dependent on the oligomeric state of rhomboids, and when dimers are dissociated, allosteric substrate activation is not observed. We present a novel mechanism for specific substrate cleavage involving several dynamic processes including positive cooperativity and homotropic allostery for this interesting class of intramembrane proteases.     

In vivo analysis reveals substrate-gating mutants of a rhomboid intramembrane protease display increased activity in living cells

Intramembrane proteases hydrolyze peptide bonds within cell membranes. Recent crystal structures revealed that rhomboid intramembrane proteases contain a hydrated active site that opens to the outside of the cell, but is protected laterally from membrane lipids by protein segments. Using Escherichia coli rhomboid (GlpG) structures as a guide, we previously took a mutational approach to identify the GlpG gating mechanism that allows substrates to enter the active site laterally from the membrane. Mutations that weaken contacts keeping the gate closed increase enzyme activity and implicate transmembrane segment 5 as the substrate gate. Since these analyses were performed in vitro with pure proteins in detergent micelles, we have now examined GlpG in its natural environment, within the membrane of live E. coli cells. In striking congruity with in vitro analysis, gate-opening mutants in transmembrane segment 5 display up to a 10-fold increase in protease activity in living cells. Conversely, mutations in other parts of the protease, including the membrane-inserted L1 loop previously thought to be the gate, decrease enzyme activity. These observations provide evidence for the existence of both closed and open forms of GlpG in cells, and show that inter-conversion between them via substrate gating is rate limiting physiologically.     

The mitochondrial rhomboid protease: Its rise from obscurity to the pinnacle of disease-relevant genes

The Rhomboid proteases belong to a highly conserved family of proteins that are present in all branches of life. In Drosophila, the secretory pathway-localized rhomboid proteases are crucial for epidermal growth factor (EGF) signaling. The identification of a mitochondrial-localized rhomboid protease shed light on other functions of rhomboid proteases including the maintenance of mitochondrial morphology and the regulation of apoptosis. More recent work has revealed other functions of the mitochondrial rhomboid protease in mitochondrial and cellular biology, failure of which have been implicated in human diseases. In this review, we will summarize the current knowledge and disease relevance of the mitochondrial-localized rhomboid protease. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Intramembrane Proteases.     

Functional Transfer of an Essential Aspartate for the Ion-binding Site in the Stator Proteins of the Bacterial Flagellar Motor

Rotation of the bacterial flagellar motor exploits the electrochemical potential of the coupling ion (H⁺ or Na⁺) as its energy source. In the marine bacterium Vibrio alginolyticus, the stator complex is composed of PomA and PomB, and conducts Na⁺ across the cytoplasmic membrane to generate rotation. The transmembrane (TM) region of PomB, which forms the Na⁺-conduction pathway together with TM3 and TM4 of PomA, has a highly conserved aspartate residue (Asp24) that is essential for flagellar rotation. This residue contributes to the Na⁺-binding site. However, it is not clear whether residues other than Asp24 are involved in binding the coupling ion. We examined the possibility that loss of the negative charge of Asp24 can be suppressed by introduction of negatively charged residues in TM3 or TM4 of PomA. The motility defect associated with the D24N substitution in PomB could be rescued only by a N194D substitution in PomA. This result suggests that there must be a negatively charged ion-binding pocket in the stator complex but that the presence of a negatively charged residue at position 24 of PomB is not essential. A tandemly fused PomA dimer containing the N194D mutation either in its N-terminal or C-terminal half with PomB-D24N was functional, suggesting that PomB-D24N can form an ion-binding pocket with either subunit of PomA dimer. The findings obtained in this study provide important clues to the mechanism of ion binding in the stator complex.     

The rhomboid protease family: a decade of progress on function and mechanism

Rhomboid proteases are the largest family of enzymes that hydrolyze peptide bonds within the cell membrane. Although discovered to be serine proteases only a decade ago, rhomboid proteases are already considered to be the best understood intramembrane proteases. The presence of rhomboid proteins in all domains of life emphasizes their importance but makes their evolutionary history difficult to chart with confidence. Phylogenetics nevertheless offers three guiding principles for interpreting rhomboid function. The near ubiquity of rhomboid proteases across evolution suggests broad, organizational roles that are not directly essential for cell survival. Functions have been deciphered in only about a dozen organisms and fall into four general categories: initiating cell signaling in animals, facilitating bacterial quorum sensing, regulating mitochondrial homeostasis, and dismantling adhesion complexes of parasitic protozoa. Although in no organism has the full complement of rhomboid function yet been elucidated, links to devastating human disease are emerging rapidly, including to Parkinson's disease, type II diabetes, cancer, and bacterial and malaria infection. Rhomboid proteases are unlike most proteolytic enzymes, because they are membrane-immersed; understanding how the membrane immersion affects their function remains a key challenge.     

Mechanism of intramembrane proteolysis investigated with purified rhomboid proteases

Intramembrane proteases have the unusual property of cleaving peptide bonds within the lipid bilayer, an environment not obviously suited to a water-requiring hydrolysis reaction. These enzymes include site-2 protease, gamma-secretase/presenilin, signal peptide peptidase and the rhomboids, and they have a wide range of cellular functions. All have multiple transmembrane domains and, because of their high hydrophobicity, have been difficult to purify. We have now developed an in vitro assay to monitor rhomboid activity in the detergent solubilised state. This has allowed us to isolate for the first time a highly pure rhomboid with catalytic activity. Our results suggest that detergent-solubilised rhomboid activity mimics its activity in biological membranes in many aspects. Analysis of purified mutant proteins suggests that rhomboids use a serine protease catalytic dyad instead of the previously proposed triad. This analysis also suggests that other conserved residues participate in subsidiary functions like ligand binding and water supply. We identify a motif shared between rhomboids and the recently discovered derlins, which participate in translocation of misfolded membrane proteins.     

Emerging role of rhomboid family proteins in mammalian biology and disease

From proteases that cleave peptide bonds in the plane of the membrane, rhomboids have evolved into a heterogeneous superfamily with a wide range of different mechanistic properties. In mammals 14 family members have been annotated based on a shared conserved membrane-integral rhomboid core domain, including intramembrane serine proteases and diverse proteolytically inactive homologues. While the function of rhomboid proteases is the proteolytic release of membrane-tethered factors, rhomboid pseudoproteases including iRhoms and derlins interact with their clients without cleaving them. It has become evident that specific recognition of membrane protein substrates and clients by the rhomboid fold reflects a spectrum of cellular functions ranging from growth factor activation, trafficking control to membrane protein degradation. This review summarizes recent progress on rhomboid family proteins in the mammalian secretory pathway and raises the question whether they can be seen as new drug targets for inflammatory diseases and cancer. This article is part of a special issue entitled: Intramembrane Proteases.