Why are orchid flowers so diverse? Reduction of evolutionary constraints by paralogues of class B floral homeotic genes

Background

The nearly 30 000 species of orchids produce flowers of unprecedented diversity. However, whether specific genetic mechanisms contributed to this diversity is a neglected topic and remains speculative. We recently published a theory, the ‘orchid code’, maintaining that the identity of the different perianth organs is specified by the combinatorial interaction of four DEF-like MADS-box genes with other floral homeotic genes.

Scope

Here the developmental and evolutionary implications of our theory are explored. Specifically, it is shown that all frequent floral terata, including all peloric types, can be explained by monogenic gain- or-loss-of-function mutants, changing either expression of a DEF-like or CYC-like gene. Supposed dominance or recessiveness of mutant alleles is correlated with the frequency of terata in both cultivation and nature. Our findings suggest that changes in DEF- and CYC-like genes not only underlie terata but also the natural diversity of orchid species. We argue, however, that true changes in organ identity are rare events in the evolution of orchid flowers, even though we review some likely cases.

Conclusions

The four DEF paralogues shaped floral diversity in orchids in a dramatic way by modularizing the floral perianth based on a complex series of sub- and neo-functionalization events. These genes may have eliminated constraints, so that different kinds of perianth organs could then evolve individually and thus often in dramatically different ways in response to selection by pollinators or by genetic drift. We therefore argue that floral diversity in orchids may be the result of an unprecedented developmental genetic predisposition that originated early in orchid evolution.Key words: Orchidaceae, orchid evolution, evo-devo; perianth, class B genes, DEFICIENS, subfunctionalization, neofunctionalization, gene duplication, peloria, modularization     

The PI/GLO-like locus in orchids: duplication and purifying selection at synonymous sites within Orchidinae (Orchidaceae)

Positive selection and relaxation of purifying constraints after duplication events have driven the functional diversification of gene families involved in development. One example of this occurred within the plant MADS-box genes. The evolution of the orchid flower was driven by duplication events followed by sub- and neo-functionalization of class B DEF-like MADS-box genes, which are present at three to four copies in the orchid genome. In contrast, the orchid PI/GLO-like class B MADS-box genes have been reported thus far as single-copy loci, with the only exception of Habenaria radiata.We isolated a novel PI/GLO-like gene (OrcPI2) in Orchis italica, which is different than the previously characterized OrcPI locus. The presence of two functional paralogs of PI/GLO-like genes in orchids is detectable only within the tribe Orchidinae. Evolutionary analyses revealed an apparent relaxation of purifying selection acting on the two PI/GLO-like paralogs of the Orchidinae when compared to the single-copy PI/GLO-like genes found in other orchid species. Furthermore, by measuring dN/dS (ω) ratios, we show that a high percentage of sites between the two PI/GLO-like paralogs have different evolutionary pressures. Interestingly, the apparent relaxation of selective constraints on the two PI/GLO-like paralogs is due to strong purifying selection at synonymous sites rather than to a high value of nonsynonymous substitution rate. This peculiar evolutionary pattern might be related to molecular processes such as mRNA folding and/or translational efficiency control. These processes could potentially be involved in or predate the functional diversification of the two PI/GLO-like paralogs within Orchidinae.     

AGL6-like MADS-box genes are sister to AGL2-like MADS-box genes

AGL6-like genes form one of the major subfamilies of MADS-box genes and are closely related to the AGL2 (Eclass) and SQUA (A-class) subfamilies. In Arabidopsis, AGL6 and AGL13 have been reported from the AGL6 subfamily, and AGL6 controls lateral organ development and flowering time. However, little is known about homologs of these genes in basal angiosperms. We identified new AGL6-like genes from several taxa from gymnosperms, basal angiosperms, monocots, and eudicots. These genes were analyzed together with previously reported AGL6-like genes. Structural analyses showed 1) a one-aa (amino acid) gap in the I-domain in all AGL6-like genes relative to AGL2-like and SQUA-like genes, 2) a seven-aa insertion in the C-domain of genes from asterids, and 3) a one-aa insertion in the C-domain of genes from gymnosperms. Broad phylogenetic analyses strongly showed that AGL6-like genes are sister to AGL2-like genes, and SQUA-like genes are sister to these two groups. The phylogenetic tree of AGL6-like genes generally tracks organismal phylogeny as inferred from multigene data sets; several gene duplications were detected in angiosperms (e.g., within Magnoliales), and one duplication was detected in gymnosperms. We hypothesize that the split between AGL6-like and AGL2-like genes occurred at least 290–309.2 mya based on our phylogenetic tree and the fossil record.     

Host tree utilization by epiphytic orchids in different land-use intensities in Kathmandu Valley, Nepal

We studied the influence of site conditions on epiphytic orchids under a subtropical climate in the Kathmandu Valley, Nepal. We analysed 96 systematically distributed grid points situated in Kathmandu Valley across a land-use intensity gradient (national park to urbanised city area). Geographical Information System (GIS) and remote sensing were used for classification of land-use types. We identified 23 species of epiphytic orchids, within 13 genera, from 42 different host tree species. Host preference is obvious for some orchid species (e.g., Dendrobium nobile), with certain tree species (e.g., Schima wallichii, Ficus religiosa) hosting more orchid species than others. The orchid Rhynchostylis retusa was the most common species found on many different host tree species across the land-use intensity gradient. Host species and host bark characteristics (e.g., rugosity, pH and exposure to wind) played a vital role for orchid distribution, with lower abundance in areas of higher impact. Under strong human impact (urban city area), F. religiosa was the dominant host tree, with large individual trees (mean diameter in breast height, dbh?=?1.3?m) providing the habitat for considerable populations of R. retusa individuals. In general, epiphytic orchids were found on larger host trees in urban areas than in areas of lower human impact. We found that some hosts are more likely to harbour orchid species, especially native host species. Older larger trees with rougher bark, low pH, exposed to wind and reduced human impact provided better habitats for orchids. We suggest these characteristics should be considered in urban planning to reduce human impact on the associated orchid epiphytic community.     

The duplicated B-class MADS-box genes display dualistic characters in orchid floral organ identity and growth

Orchidaceae are an excellent model to examine perianth development because of their sophisticated floral architecture. In this study, we identified 24 APETALA3 (AP3)-like and 13 PISTILLA (PI)-like genes from 11 species of orchids and characterized them into four AP3- and two PI-duplicated homologs. The first duplication event in AP3 homologs occurring in the early evolutionary history of the Orchidaceae gave rise to AP3A and AP3B clades. Further duplication events resulted in four subclades, namely AP3A1, AP3A2, AP3B1 and AP3B2, during the evolution of Orchidaceae. The AP3 paralogous genes were expressed throughout inflorescence and floral bud development. From the in situ hybridization results, we noticed that the transition timings from ubiquitous to constrained expression in floral organs for both clades are different. The transition point of expression of the AP3A clade (clades 3 and 4) was at the late floral organ primordia stage. In contrast, that for the AP3B clade (clades 1 and 2) was not observed until the late inflorescence and floral bud stages. In addition, the AP3 orthologous genes revealed diverse expression patterns in various species of orchids, whereas the PI homologs were uniformly expressed in all floral whorls. AP3A2 orthologs play a noticeable role in lip formation because of their exclusive expression in the lip. Further evidence comes from the ectopic expression of AP3A2 detected in the lip-like petals extending from the lip in four sets of peloric mutants. Finally, a Homeotic Orchid Tepal (HOT) model is proposed, in which dualistic characters of duplicated B-class MADS-box genes are involved in orchid perianth development and growth.     

Evolution and function of MADS‐box genes involved in orchid floral development

Orchids are known for their beauty and complexity of flower and ecological strategies. The evolution in orchid floral morphology, structure, and physiological properties has held the fascination of botanists for centuries, from Darwin through to the present. In floral studies, MADS‐box genes contributing to the now famous ABCDE model of floral organ identity control have dominated conceptual thinking. The sophisticated orchid floral organization offers an opportunity to discover new variant genes and different levels of complexity to the ABCDE model. Recently, several remarkable research reports on orchid MADS‐box genes, especially B‐class MADS‐box genes, have revealed the evolutionary track and important functions on orchid floral development. Diversification and fixation of both paleoAP3 gene sequences and expression profiles might be explained by subfunctionalization and even neofunctionalization. Knowledge about MADS‐box genes encoding ABCDE functions in orchids will give insights into the highly evolved floral morphogenetic networks of orchids.     

Genomic organization and evolution of actin genes in the amphioxus Branchiostoma belcheri and Branchiostoma floridae

We previously described the cDNA cloning and expression patterns of actin genes from amphioxus Branchiostoma floridae (Kusakabe, R., Kusakabe, T., Satoh, N., Holland, N.D., Holland, L.Z., 1997. Differential gene expression and intracellular mRNA localization of amphioxus actin isoforms throughout development: implications for conserved mechanisms of chordate development. Dev. Genes Evol. 207, 203–215). In the present paper, we report the characterization of cDNA clones for actin genes from a closely related species, Branchiostoma belcheri, and the exon–intron organization of B. floridae actin genes. Each of these two amphioxus species has two types of actin genes, muscle and cytoplasmic. The coding and non-coding regions of each type are well-conserved between the two species. A comparison of nucleotide sequences of muscle actin genes between the two species suggests that a gene conversion may have occurred between two B. floridae muscle actin genes BfMA1 and BfMA2. From the conserved positions of introns between actin genes of amphioxus and those of other deuterostomes, the evolution of deuterostome actin genes can be inferred. Thus, the presence of an intron at codon 328/329 in vertebrate muscle and cytoplasmic actin genes but not in any known actin gene in other deuterostomes suggests that a gene conversion may have occurred between muscle and cytoplasmic actin genes during the early evolution of the vertebrates after separation from other deuterostomes. A Southern blot analysis of genomic DNA revealed that the amphioxus genome contains multiple muscle and cytoplasmic actin genes. Some of these actin genes seem to have arisen from recent duplication and gene conversion. Our findings suggest that the multiple genes encoding muscle and cytoplasmic actin isoforms arose independently in each of the three chordate lineages and that gene duplications and gene conversions established the extant actin multigene family during the evolution of chordates.     

Identity and Specificity of Rhizoctonia-Like Fungi from Different Populations of Liparis japonica (Orchidaceae) in Northeast China

Mycorrhizal association is known to be important to orchid species, and a complete understanding of the fungi that form mycorrhizas is required for orchid ecology and conservation. Liparis japonica (Orchidaceae) is a widespread terrestrial photosynthetic orchid in Northeast China. Previously, we found the genetic diversity of this species has been reduced recent years due to habitat destruction and fragmentation, but little was known about the relationship between this orchid species and the mycorrhizal fungi. The Rhizoctonia-like fungi are the commonly accepted mycorrhizal fungi associated with orchids. In this study, the distribution, diversity and specificity of culturable Rhizoctonia-like fungi associated with L. japonica species were investigated from seven populations in Northeast China. Among the 201 endophytic fungal isolates obtained, 86 Rhizoctonia-like fungi were identified based on morphological characters and molecular methods, and the ITS sequences and phylogenetic analysis revealed that all these Rhizoctonia-like fungi fell in the same main clade and were closely related to those of Tulasnella calospora species group. These findings indicated the high mycorrhizal specificity existed in L. japonica species regardless of habitats at least in Northeast China. Our results also supported the wide distribution of this fungal partner, and implied that the decline of L. japonica in Northeast China did not result from high mycorrhizal specificity. Using culture-dependent technology, these mycorrhizal fungal isolates might be important sources for the further utilizing in orchids conservation.     

Cloning and Characterization of FLOWERING LOCUS T-Like Genes from the Perennial Geophyte Saffron Crocus (Crocus sativus)

The transition to flowering is one of the most important developmental decisions made by plants. At the molecular level, many genes coordinate this transition. Among these, genes encoding for phosphatidylethanolamine-binding proteins (PEBPs) play important roles in regulating flower time and the fate of inflorescence meristem. To investigate the role of PEBPs in an industrially important crop cultivated for its nutritional and medicinal properties, the monocotyledonous species Crocus sativus L., we have isolated three FLOWERING LOCUS T (FT)-like genes designated as CsatFT1-like, CsatFT2-like, and CsatFT3-like. The isolated genes maintain the exon/intron organization of FT-like genes and encode proteins similar to the members of the PEBP family. Phylogenetic and amino acid analysis at critical positions confirmed that the isolated sequence belongs to the FT clade of the PEBP family phylogeny distinctly from the TERMINAL FLOWER 1 (TFL1) and MOTHER OF FT AND TFL1 clades. Expression analysis indicated differences in the expression of the three FT-like genes in different organs and different expressions during the day–night diurnal clock. Additionally, analysis of isolated promoter sequences using computational methods reveals the preservation of common binding motifs in FT-like promoters from other species, thus suggesting their importance among plant species.     

Divergence of TERMINAL FLOWER1-like genes in Rosaceae

Rosaceae is a large family, however, our understanding of its phylogeny is based largely on morphological observations. To understand the relationship between subfamilies Rosoideae, Amygdaloideae, Maloideae and Spiraeoideae at a molecular level, we isolated and compared the plant phosphatidyl ethanolamine-binding protein-like genes TERMINAL FLOWER1 (TFL1)-like and CENTRORADIALIS (CEN)-like, which are involved in the control of shoot meristem identity and flowering time. A comparison of gene structures and phylogenetic tree analyses by the Neighbor-Joining method showed that each of the two TFL1-like (MdTFL1-1 and MdTFL1-2) and CEN-like genes (MdCENa and MdCENb) in Maloideae were classified into two distinct clades. The TFL1-like and CEN-like genes of Gillenia in Spiraeoideae belonged to monophyletic Maloideae groups, suggesting that Gillenia and Maloideae have a common near ancestor. However, the Gillenia TFL1-like gene does not contain the insertion sequence of the third intron that is found in MdTFL1-2-like genes of the members of Maloideae such as apple, Korean whitebeam, quince, and Siberian mountain ash. Therefore, after the Maloideae ancestor genome became polyploid through hybridization between Gillenia-like species or genome doubling, an insertion sequence of the third intron of MdTFL1-2-like genes was generated.     

Seven New Complete Plastome Sequences Reveal Rampant Independent Loss of the ndh Gene Family across Orchids and Associated Instability of the Inverted Repeat/Small Single-Copy Region Boundaries

Earlier research has revealed that the ndh loci have been pseudogenized, truncated, or deleted from most orchid plastomes sequenced to date, including in all available plastomes of the two most species-rich subfamilies, Orchidoideae and Epidendroideae. This study sought to resolve deeper-level phylogenetic relationships among major orchid groups and to refine the history of gene loss in the ndh loci across orchids. The complete plastomes of seven orchids, Oncidium sphacelatum (Epidendroideae), Masdevallia coccinea (Epidendroideae), Sobralia callosa (Epidendroideae), Sobralia aff. bouchei (Epidendroideae), Elleanthus sodiroi (Epidendroideae), Paphiopedilum armeniacum (Cypripedioideae), and Phragmipedium longifolium (Cypripedioideae) were sequenced and analyzed in conjunction with all other available orchid and monocot plastomes. Most ndh loci were found to be pseudogenized or lost in Oncidium, Paphiopedilum and Phragmipedium, but surprisingly, all ndh loci were found to retain full, intact reading frames in Sobralia, Elleanthus and Masdevallia. Character mapping suggests that the ndh genes were present in the common ancestor of orchids but have experienced independent, significant losses at least eight times across four subfamilies. In addition, ndhF gene loss was correlated with shifts in the position of the junction of the inverted repeat (IR) and small single-copy (SSC) regions. The Orchidaceae have unprecedented levels of homoplasy in ndh gene presence/absence, which may be correlated in part with the unusual life history of orchids. These results also suggest that ndhF plays a role in IR/SSC junction stability.     

Improvement of the Coprinopsis cinerea molecular toolkit using new construct design and additional marker genes

This paper describes the optimisation of an existing basidiomycete molecular toolkit through the development of new versatile vectors. These vectors enable the straightforward and rapid construction of gene expression and silencing cassettes by allowing the easy exchange of promoters, coding regions and terminator elements. The constructs contain multiple cloning sites (MCS) allowing any gene to be inserted using a range of restriction sites, with the option of a 5′ integral intron for efficient gene expression. We describe the testing of these vectors through marker gene expression in Coprinopsis cinerea. This work also extends the range of marker genes available for use in C. cinerea with the first report of DsRed and monomeric red fluorescent protein (mRFP) expression in C. cinerea and further demonstrates the requirement for an intron in the expression cassette for some marker genes. However, analysis of transformants containing either β-glucuronidase (GUS) or luciferase (LUC) genes, with and without an intron revealed no detectable marker gene expression. The inclusion of an intron does therefore not guarantee expression and other genetic factors may be involved.     

Isolation and Characterization of an AGAMOUS-Like Gene from Magnolia wufengensis (Magnoliaceae)

The floral homeotic C function gene AGAMOUS (AG) plays crucial roles in Arabidopsis development by specifying stamen and carpel identity, repressing A-class genes, as well as regulating floral meristem determination. Although the function of AG homologs from other core eudicots appears highly conserved, the role of AG orthologs in the design of floral architecture in basal angiosperm remains unknown. We isolated and identified an AG ortholog from Magnolia wufengensis, a woody basal angiosperm belonging to the Magnoliaceae. Sequence and phylogenetic analyses revealed that it is a clade member of the euAG lineage, and hence, the gene is referred to as MAwuAG (M. wu fengensis AGAMOUS). Moreover, two highly conserved motifs specific to C proteins, AG motifs I and II, are found in the C-terminal regions of the MAwuAG protein, but the N-terminal extensions that usually appear in euAG lineage members from eudicots were not found in MAwuAG. The cDNA has the first in-frame ATG immediately preceding the MADS domain. A semi-quantitative PCR analysis showed that the expression of MAwuAG was restricted to reproductive organs of stamens and carpels. The transgenic Arabidopsis containing 35S::MAwuAG displayed extremely early flowering, bigger stamens and carpels, and homeotic conversion of petals into staminoid organs, but ectopic expression of MAwuAG in the first whorls failed to convert the sepals into carpeloid structures that are usually observed in the overexpression transgenic Arabidopsis of AG orthologs from other core eudicots. In addition, the phenotype of the transgenic 35S::MAwuAG Arabidopsis revealed that the abscission of the outer three floral whorls (sepals, petals, and stamens) was inhibited.     

Expression pattern of two paralogs of the <Emphasis Type="Italic">PI</Emphasis>/<Emphasis Type="Italic">GLO</Emphasis>-like locus during <Emphasis Type="Italic">Orchis italica</Emphasis> (Orchidaceae,Orchidinae) flower development

The class B MADS-box genes belong to two distinct functional groups: the AP3/DEF-like and the PI/GLO-like sub-families. In orchids, AP3/DEF-like genes are present in four copies, each with a different role in floral organ formation, which is described in the “orchid code” model. Interestingly, the orchid PI/GLO-like genes are present in two copies in Orchidinae, whereas they are described as single copy in the other orchid lineages. The two PI/GLO-like paralogs have site-specific different selective constraints; in addition, they show relaxation of purifying selection when compared to the single-copy lineages. In this study, we present a comparative analysis of the expression patterns of the two PI/GLO-like paralogs, OrcPI and OrcPI2, in floral tissues of Orchis italica in different developmental stages using real-time PCR. The two genes show similar expression profiles in the tissue examined, with differences detectable between immature and mature inflorescence. In all cases, OrcPI2 is expressed at a higher level than OrcPI. Real-time PCR results reveal that the co-expression of the two duplicated loci could have a fully or partially redundant function. The possible evolutionary fate of OrcPI and OrcPI2 is discussed as well as their involvement in ovary development.