Wheat tissues freeze-etched during exposure to extracellular freezing: distribution of ice

Pieces excised from leaf bases and laminae of seedlings of Triticum aestivum L. cv. Lennox were slowly frozen, using a specially designed apparatus, to temperatures between 2° and 14° C. These treatments ranged from non-damaging to damaging, based on ion-leakage tests to be found in the accompanying report (Pearce and Willison 1985, Planta 163, 304–316). The frozen tissue pieces were then freeze-fixed by rapidly cooling them, via melting Freon, to liquid-nitrogen temperature. The tissue was subsequently prepared for electron microscopy by freeze-etching. Ice crystals formed during slow freezing would tend to be much larger than those formed during subsequent freeze-fixation. Ice crystals surrounding the excised tissues were much larger in the frozen than in the control tissues (the latter rapidly freeze-fixed from room temperature). Large ice crystals were present between cells of frozen laminae and absent from controls. Intercellular spaces were infrequent in control leaf bases and no ice-filled intercellular spaces were found in frozen leaf bases. Intracellular ice crystals were smaller in frozen tissues than in controls. It is concluded that all ice formation before freeze-fixation was extracellular. This extracellular ice was either only extra-tissue (leaf bases), or extra-tissue and intercellular (laminae). Periplasmic ice was sometimes present, in control as well as slowly frozen tissues, and the crystals were always small; thus they were probably formed during freeze-fixation rather than during slow freezing. The plasma membrane sometimes showed imprints of cell-wall microfibrils. These were less abundant in leaf bases at 8° C than in controls, and were present on only a minority of plasma membranes from laminae. Therefore, extracellular ice probably did not compress the cells substantially, and changes in cell size and shape were possibly primarily a result of freezing-induced dehydration. Fine-scale distortions (wrinkles) in the plasma membrane, while absent from controls, were present, although only rarely, in both damaged and non-damaged tissues; they were therefore ice-induced but not directly related to the process of damage.     

Freeze-fixation at high subzero temperatures.

Previous attempts to determine the distribution of ice in frozen tissues at high sub-zero temperatures generally called for the further cooling of the tissues in question to facilitate freeze-drying, freeze-substitution, and freeze-fracture replication. Direct cryomicroscopic determinations, free from uncertainties stemming from changes in sample temperature could, it seemed, only be made in certain special cases. We have presented an isothermal “freeze-fixation” procedure designed to permit, instead, the postthaw retention of the freezing pattern and the conventional processing, afterward, of the thawed specimen. The method demands the exposure of the frozen tissues to fixative solutions incapable of dissolving ice. Frozen specimens are immersed in aqueous fixative solutions prepared in each instance (1) to freeze at a temperature equal to that at which fixation is to be conducted, (2) to contain quantities of finely divided ice sufficient to guarantee the maintenance of a constant water activity. Frozen frog and rat hearts and skeletal muscle tissues were exposed to formaldehyde, formaldehyde/ glutaraldehyde, and glutaraldehyde solutions at ?2, ?5, and ?10 °C, the temperatures being maintained in each case to ± 0.1 °C, or better. Tissues withdrawn at intervals were thawed, postfixed, dehydrated, embedded, and sectioned. The sections demonstrated the retention, after thawing, of structural features characteristic of the frozen state. The small hearts we exposed to formaldehyde were fixed throughout in 3 hr at ?2 ° and in 20 hr at ?5 °C. The action of osmium tetroxide was investigated. The method appears to be well-suited to numerous experimental applications.     

Vitrification of large tissues with dielectric warming: biological problems and some approaches to their solution

If large pieces of tissue and organs are to be successfully stored at low temperatures, some means must be found to minimize the disruption of extracellular structures by the ice that develops during conventional cryopreservation methods. The use of sufficiently high concentrations of cryoprotectant (CPA) to vitrify rather than freeze the tissue is a possible solution to this problem, and the retention of function of embryos and elastic arteries after vitrification suggests that some cells and tissues at least can withstand exposure to the high concentrations of CPA necessary for this process to occur. There are, however, additional problems in applying vitrifying techniques to bulky tissues and organs. These are related to the additional time required for tissue equilibration of CPA to occur and the consequences for toxic injury, the difficulty in achieving sufficiently rapid and uniform cooling rates to produce the required glassy state, and the even more rapid and uniform warming rates that are necessary to avoid devitrification. Non-uniformity of temperature will increase the risk of mechanical stresses and fractures developing in the glass during rapid warming. This paper reviews possible strategies and the progress that has been made in overcoming these problems. This will include the permeation of CPA mixtures into whole tissues and possibilities for reducing their toxicity by the inclusion of adjuncts such as ice inhibitors and sugars. The warming of tissues by dielectric heating is currently the only practical means by which sufficiently rapid rates can be achieved in bulky tissues given that the tolerable limits of CPA concentration will most likely be insufficient to prevent the development of ice nuclei during cooling. The biological effects of microwaves are reviewed and their effectiveness in producing the required uniformity in warming of tissue models of various shapes are discussed.     

The formation and distribution of ice within dormant and deacclimated peach flower buds

Abstract A freeze-fixation technique was used to examine the distribution of ice crystals and the pattern of freezing in peach flower buds. In dormant buds, ice crystals formed at localized sites within the bud axis and scales. Ice crystal formation disrupted tissues and mechanical injury from repetitive freezethaw cycles was apparent. There was evidence of ice formation in the floral organs of dormant buds exposed to ?25°C but none observed in buds exposed to either ?5 or ?10°C. The distribution of ice crystals was different in deacclimated buds. In addition to large ice crystals within the subtending bud axis and scales, evidence of large crystals within the developing floral organs was noted. These crystals were most prominent in the lower portions of the developing flower and peduncle, and caused a separation of the epidermal layer from adjacent cells. The distribution of ice crystals within both dormant and deacclimated peach flower buds corroborated the results of previous thermal analysis experiments.     

The effect of ice formation on the function of smooth muscle tissue stored at −21 or −60 °C

The mechanisms by which single cells are injured during freezing are relatively well understood, but it is likely that additional factors apply to tissues and organs, factors that may be responsible for the poor suecess of attempts to cryopreserve complex multicellular systems. One such factor may be the formation of extracellular ice.

This study was designed to discover whether ice formation as such is detrimental to the contractile recovery of pieces of mammalian smooth muscle after storage at subzero temperatures. Strips of taenia coli muscle were equilibrated with 2.56 M Me₂SO in a buffered solution, cooled at either 0.3 or 2 °C/min to ?21 °C and then held at this temperature in the frozen state. Other muscle strips were bathed in a solution the composition of which mimicked that of the unfrozen phase of the previous solution at ?21 °C; it contained 4.49 M Me₂SO and 1.75 times the normal concentration of salts, and muscles equilibrated with this solution were also cooled at either 0.3 or 2 °C/min to ?21 °C, and then held unfrozen for the same length of time.It was shown that exposure to ?21 °C and the increased concentration of solutes had little effect on the contractile recovery of the muscles, whereas ice formation was damaging. Furthermore, the rate of cooling had a marked effect upon functional recovery in the frozen muscles, and this could be correlated with the known effect of these cooling rates on the pattern of ice formation in the tissue. The effect was also seen in muscles frozen at ?60 °C. Improved buffering increased the functional recovery of all groups, but the effect of ice, and of cooling rate in the presence of ice, was confirmed. These findings may have significant implications for attempts to cryopreserve complex tissues and organs.     

Tissue subcellular fractionation and protein extraction for use in mass-spectrometry-based proteomics

We have shown that sample fractionation is an effective method for increasing the detection coverage of the proteome of complex samples, such as organs, by mass-spectrometric techniques. Further fractionating a sample based on subcellular compartments can generate molecular information on the state of a tissue and the distribution of its protein components. Although many methods exist for fractionating proteins, the method described here can capture the majority of subcellular fractions simultaneously at reasonable purity. The scalability of this method makes it amenable to small samples, such as embryonic tissues, in addition to larger tissues. The protocol described is for the general fractionation and extraction of proteins from organs or tissues for subsequent analysis by mass spectrometry. It uses differential centrifugation in density gradients to isolate nuclear, cytosolic, mitochondrial and mixed microsomal (Golgi, endoplasmic reticulum, other vesicles and plasma membrane) fractions. Once the fractions are isolated, they are extracted for protein and the samples can then be frozen for processing and analysis at a later date. The procedure can typically be completed in 5 h.     

A mathematical model for the freezing process in biological tissue

A mathematical model has been developed to study the process of freezing in biological organs. The model consists of a repetitive unit structure comprising a cylinder of tissue with an axial blood vessel (Krogh cylinder) and it is analysed by the methods of irreversible thermodynamics. The mathematical simulation of the freezing process in liver tissue compares remarkably well with experimental data on the structure of tissue frozen under controlled thermal conditions and the response of liver cells to changes in cooling rate. The study also supports the proposal that the damage mechanism responsible for the lack of success in attempts to preserve tissue in a frozen state, under conditions in which cells in suspension survive freezing, is direct mechanical damage caused by the formation of ice in the vascular system.     

Ultrastructural and thermocouple evaluation of rapid freezing techniques

The quality of freeze-fixation for electron microscopy is dependent upon the size of intracellular ice crystals. In the absence of cryoprotectants, ice crystal growth is thought to be related to the speed with which the specimen is cooled. The purpose of this study was to investigate the relationship between the cooling rate and ultrastructural preservation in commonly used freezing techniques. The techniques studied included immersion in stirred and unstirred forms of five quenching fluids: liquid nitrogen, isopentane, Freon 12, Freon 22, and propane. Also studied were freezing in a flowing stream of coolant using liquid nitrogen and liquid helium and freezing on a metal surface using cooper and mercury chilled to liquid nitrogen temperature. For each technique a cooling curve was obtained with a 0.360-mm thermocouple which was dropped into the quenching fluids or brought into contact with the metal surfaces. From oscilloscope tracings, the cooling rates were determined in degrees centigrade per second to −100 °C. To evaluate ultrastructural preservation 0.5-mm-thick slices of rat kidney were frozen by each of the techniques and dried in an all glass freeze-drier. The final evaluation was made from electron micrographs of the best morphological preservation yielded by each technique. The results indicate that the copper and mercury surfaces and propane gave the highest cooling rates and the best morphological preservation. The other techniques cooled at decreasing rates and correspondingly showed decreasing abilities to preserve ultrastructure. This work demonstrates that the preservation of cellular ultrastructure by freezing is dependent upon the cooling rate and that as the cooling rate is increased, ultrastructural preservation is enhanced.     

Physical and biological aspects of renal vitrification

Cryopreservation would potentially very much facilitate the inventory control and distribution of laboratory-produced organs and tissues. Although simple freezing methods are effective for many simple tissues, bioartificial organs and complex tissue constructs may be unacceptably altered by ice formation and dissolution. Vitrification, in which the liquids in a living system are converted into the glassy state at low temperatures, provides a potential alternative to freezing that can in principle avoid ice formation altogether. The present report provides a brief overview of the problem of renal vitrification. We report here the detailed case history of a rabbit kidney that survived vitrification and subsequent transplantation, a case that demonstrates both the fundamental feasibility of complex system vitrification and the obstacles that must still be overcome, of which the chief one in the case of the kidney is adequate distribution of cryoprotectant to the renal medulla. Medullary equilibration can be monitored by monitoring urine concentrations of cryoprotectant, and urine flow rate correlates with vitrification solution viscosity and the speed of equilibration. By taking these factors into account and by using higher perfusion pressures as per the case of the kidney that survived vitrification, it is becoming possible to design protocols for equilibrating kidneys that protect against both devitrification and excessive cryoprotectant toxicity.     

Physical and biological aspects of renal vitrification

Cryopreservation would potentially very much facilitate the inventory control and distribution of laboratory-produced organs and tissues. Although simple freezing methods are effective for many simple tissues, bioartificial organs and complex tissue constructs may be unacceptably altered by ice formation and dissolution. Vitrification, in which the liquids in a living system are converted into the glassy state at low temperatures, provides a potential alternative to freezing that can in principle avoid ice formation altogether. The present report provides a brief overview of the problem of renal vitrification. We report here the detailed case history of a rabbit kidney that survived vitrification and subsequent transplantation, a case that demonstrates both the fundamental feasibility of complex system vitrification and the obstacles that must still be overcome, of which the chief one in the case of the kidney is adequate distribution of cryoprotectant to the renal medulla. Medullary equilibration can be monitored by monitoring urine concentrations of cryoprotectant, and urine flow rate correlates with vitrification solution viscosity and the speed of equilibration. By taking these factors into account and by using higher perfusion pressures as per the case of the kidney that survived vitrification, it is becoming possible to design protocols for equilibrating kidneys that protect against both devitrification and excessive cryoprotectant toxicity.     

Theoretical analysis of the ice crystal size distribution in frozen aqueous specimens.

To estimate theoretically how suited different freezing techniques are for freezing of freeze-etch specimens, it is necessary to know the relationship between specimen cooling rate and the resulting average ice crystal size. Using a somewhat simplified theoretical analysis, we have derived the approximate ice crystal size distribution of nonvitrified frozen aqueous specimens frozen at different cooling rates. The derived size distribution was used to calculate the relationship between relative change in average ice crystal size, (delta l/l), and relative change in specimen cooling rate delta (dT/dt)/(dT/dt). We found this relationship to be (delta l/l) = -k X delta (dT/dt)/(dT/dt) where k = 1.0 when specimen solidification takes place at about -6 degrees C, and k congruent to 1.3 when it takes place at about -40 degrees C.     

Vitreous cryopreservation maintains the function of vascular grafts

Avoidance of ice formation during cooling can be achieved by vitrification, which is defined as solidification in an amorphous glassy state that obviates ice nucleation and growth. We show that a vitrification approach to storing vascular tissue results in markedly improved tissue function compared with a standard method involving freezing. The maximum contractions achieved in vitrified vessels were >80% of fresh matched controls with similar drug sensitivities, whereas frozen vessels exhibited maximal contractions below 30% of controls and concomitant decreases in drug sensitivity. In vivo studies of vitrified vessel segments in an autologous transplant model showed no adverse effects of vitreous cryopreservation compared with fresh tissue grafts.     

Glassy State and Cryopreservation of Mint Shoot Tips

Vitrification refers to the physical process by which a liquid supercools to very low temperatures and finally solidifies into a metastable glass, without undergoing crystallization at a practical cooling rate. Thus, vitrification is an effective freeze‐avoidance mechanism and living tissue cryopreservation is, in most cases, relying on it. As a glass is exceedingly viscous and stops all chemical reactions that require molecular diffusion, its formation leads to metabolic inactivity and stability over time. To investigate glassy state in cryopreserved plant material, mint shoot tips were submitted to the different stages of a frequently used cryopreservation protocol (droplet‐vitrification) and evaluated for water content reduction and sucrose content, as determined by ion chromatography, frozen water fraction and glass transitions occurrence by differential scanning calorimetry, and investigated by low‐temperature scanning electron microscopy, as a way to ascertain if their cellular content was vitrified. Results show how tissues at intermediate treatment steps develop ice crystals during liquid nitrogen cooling, while specimens whose treatment was completed become vitrified, with no evidence of ice formation. The agreement between calorimetric and microscopic observations was perfect. Besides finding a higher sucrose concentration in tissues at the more advanced protocol steps, this level was also higher in plants precultured at 25/?1°C than in plants cultivated at 25°C. © 2013 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 29:707–717, 2013     

Avoidance of intracellular freezing by the freezing-tolerant New Zealand Alpine weta Hemideina maori (Orthoptera: Stenopelmatidae)

Calorimetric analysis indicates that 82% of the body water of Hemideina maori is converted into ice at 10 degrees C. This is a high proportion and led us to investigate whether intracellular freezing occurs in H. maori tissue. Malpighian tubules and fat bodies were frozen in haemolymph on a microscope cold stage. No fat body cells, and 2% of Malpighian tubule cells froze during cooling to -8 degrees C. Unfrozen cells appeared shrunken after ice formed in the extracellular medium. There was no difference between the survival of control tissues and those frozen to -8 degrees C. At temperatures below -15 degrees C (lethal temperatures for weta), there was a decline in survival, which was strongly correlated with temperature, but no change in the appearance of tissue. It is concluded that intracellular freezing is avoided by Hemideina maori through osmotic dehydration and freeze concentration effects, but the reasons for low temperature mortality remain unclear. The freezing process in H. maori appears to rely on extracellular ice nucleation, possibly with the aid of an ice nucleating protein, to osmotically dehydrate the cells and avoid intracellular freezing. The lower lethal temperature of H. maori (-10 degrees C) is high compared to organisms that survive intracellular freezing. This suggests that the category of 'freezing tolerance' is an oversimplification, and that it may encompass at least two strategies: intracellular freezing tolerance and avoidance.     

Improved vitrification solutions based on the predictability of vitrification solution toxicity

Long-term preservation of complex engineered tissues and organs at cryogenic temperatures in the absence of ice has been prevented to date by the difficulty of discovering combinations of cryoprotectants that are both sufficiently non-toxic and sufficiently stable to allow viability to be maintained and ice formation to be avoided during slow cooling to the glass transition temperature and subsequent slow rewarming. A new theory of the origin of non-specific cryoprotectant toxicity was shown to account, in a rabbit renal cortical slice model, for the toxicities of 20 vitrification solutions and to permit the design of new solutions that are dramatically less toxic than previously known solutions for diverse biological systems. Unfertilized mouse ova vitrified with one of the new solutions were successfully fertilized and regained 80% of the absolute control (untreated) rate of development to blastocysts, whereas ova vitrified in VSDP, the best previous solution, developed to blastocysts at a rate only 30% of that of controls. Whole rabbit kidneys perfused at -3 degrees C with another new solution at a concentration of cryoprotectant (8.4M) that was previously 100% lethal at this temperature exhibited no damage after transplantation and immediate contralateral nephrectomy. It appears that cryoprotectant solutions that are composed to be at the minimum concentrations needed for vitrification at moderate cooling rates are toxic in direct proportion to the average strength of water hydrogen bonding by the polar groups on the permeating cryoprotectants in the solution. Vitrification solutions that are based on minimal perturbation of intracellular water appear to be superior and provide new hope that the successful vitrification of natural organs as well as tissue engineered or clonally produced organ and tissue replacements can be achieved.     

Calorimetric studies of freeze-induced dehydration of phospholipids.

Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) was used to determine the amount of water that freezes in an aqueous suspension of multilamellar dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC) liposomes. The studies were performed with dehydrated suspensions (12-20 wt% water) and suspensions containing an excess of water (30-70 wt% water). For suspensions that contained > or = 18 wt% water, two ice-formation events were observed during cooling. The first was attributed to heterogeneous nucleation of extraliposomal ice; the second was attributed to homogeneous nucleation of ice within the liposomes. In suspensions with an initial water concentration between 13 and 16 wt%, ice formation occurred only after homogeneous nucleation at temperatures below -40 degrees C. In suspensions containing < 13 wt% water, ice formation during cooling was undetectable by DSC, however, an endotherm resulting from ice melting during warming was observed in suspensions containing > or = 12 wt% water. In suspensions containing < 12 wt% water, an endotherm corresponding to the melting of ice was not observed during warming. The amount of ice that formed in the suspensions was determined by using an improved procedure to calculate the partial area of the endotherm resulting from the melting of ice during warming. The results show that a substantial proportion of water associated with the polar headgroup of phosphatidylcholine can be removed by freeze-induced dehydration, but the amount of ice depends on the thermal history of the samples. For example, after cooling to -100 degrees C at rates > or = 10 degrees C/min, a portion of water in the suspension remains supercooled because of a decrease in the diffusion rate of water with decreasing temperature. A portion of this supercooled water can be frozen during subsequent freeze-induced dehydration of the liposomes under isothermal conditions at subfreezing storage temperature Ts. During isothermal storage at Ts > or = -40 degrees C, the amount of unfrozen water decreased with decreasing Ts and increasing time of storage. After 30 min of storage at Ts = -40 degrees C and subsequent cooling to -100 degrees C, the amount of water associated with the polar headgroups was < 0.1 g/g of DPPC. At temperatures > -50 degrees C, the amount of unfrozen water associated with the polar headgroups of DPPC decreased with decreasing temperature in a manner predicted from the desorption isotherm of DPPC. However, at lower temperatures, the amount of unfrozen water remained constant, in large part, because the unfrozen water underwent a liquid-to-glass transformation at a temperature between -50 degrees and -140 degrees C.     

Visualization of freezing damage. II. Structural alterations during warming

There is a growing amount of indirect evidence which suggests that the loss in viability of rapidly cooled cells is due to recrystallization of intracellular ice. This possibility was tested by an evaluation of the formation of morphological artifacts in rapidly cooled cells to determine whether this process can account for the loss in viability. Samples of the common yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae were frozen at 1.8 or 1500 °C/min, and the structure of the frozen cells was examined by the use of freeze-fracturing techniques. Other cells cooled at the same rate were warmed to temperatures ranging from ?20 ° to ?50 °C and then rapidly cooled to ?196 °C, a procedure that should cause small ice crystals to coalesce by the process of migratory recrystallization. Cells cooled at 1500 °C/min and then warmed to temperatures above ?40 °C formed large intracellular ice crystals within 30 min, and appreciable recrystallization occurred at temperatures as low as ?45 °C. Cells cooled at 1.8 °C/min and warmed to temperatures as high as ?20 °C underwent little structural alteration. These results demonstrate that intracellular ice can cause morphological artifacts. The correlation between the temperature at which rapid recrystallization begins and the temperature at which the cells are inactivated indicates that recrystallization is responsible for the death of rapidly cooled cells.     

The process of freezing and the mechanism of damage during hepatic cryosurgery

Experiments were performed to correlate the structures of liver tissue frozen during cryosurgery, liver frozen at various constant cooling rates, and unfrozen, dried normal liver. The results show that during freezing of tissue ice forms and propagates along the vascular system, expanding during freezing at low cooling rates. This expansion occurs over most of the region frozen during cryosurgery and may be one of the mechanisms of damage to tissue during cryosurgery.     

Freezing behaviours in wintering Cornus florida flower bud tissues revisited using MRI

How plant tissues control their water behaviours (phase and movement) under subfreezing temperatures through adaptative strategies (freezing behaviours) is important for their survival. However, the fine details of freezing behaviours in complex organs and their regulation mechanisms are poorly understood, and non‐invasive visualization/analysis is required. The localization/density of unfrozen water in wintering Cornus florida flower buds at subfreezing temperatures was visualized with high‐resolution magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). This allowed tissue‐specific freezing behaviours to be determined. MRI images revealed that individual anthers and ovules remained stably supercooled to ?14 to ?21 °C or lower. The signal from other floral tissues decreased during cooling to ?7 °C, which likely indicates their extracellular freezing. Microscopic observation and differential thermal analyses revealed that the abrupt breakdown of supercooled individual ovules and anthers resulted in their all‐or‐nothing type of injuries. The distribution of ice nucleation activity in flower buds determined using a test tube‐based assay corroborated which tissues primarily froze. MRI is a powerful tool for non‐invasively visualizing unfrozen tissues. Freezing events and/or dehydration events can be located by digital comparison of MRI images acquired at different temperatures. Only anthers and ovules preferentially remaining unfrozen are a novel freezing behaviour in flower buds. Physicochemical and biological mechanisms/implications are discussed.     

Methods and Principles of Fixation by Freeze-Substitution

Freeze-substitution is based on rapid freezing of tissues followed by solution ("substitution") of ice at temperatures well below O°C. A 1 to 3 mm. specimen was thrown into 3:1 propane-isopentane cooled by liquid nitrogen to -175°C. (with precautions). The frozen tissue was placed in substituting fluid at -70°C. for 1 week to dissolve ice slowly without distorting tissue structure. Excess substituting agent was washed out, and the specimen was embedded, sectioned, and stained conventionally. For best morphological and histochemical preservation, substituting fluids should in general contain both chemical fixing agent and solvent for ice, e.g., 1 per cent solutions of osmium tetroxide in acetone, mercuric chloride in ethanol, and picric acid in ethanol. Preservation of structure was poorer after substitution in solvent alone. Evidence was obtained that the chemical agent fixes tissue at low temperatures. The chemical mechanisms of fixation are probably similar to those operating at room temperature: new chemical cross-linkages, which contain the fixing agent, join tissue constituents together. This process is distinguished from denaturation by pure solvents. Freeze-substitution has many advantages, particularly the preservation of structure to the limit of resolution with the light microscope, and the accurate localization of many soluble and labile substances.