RuvAB-directed branch migration of individual Holliday junctions is impeded by sequence heterology

The Holliday junction, the key intermediate of recombination, is generated by strand exchange resulting in a covalent connection between two recombining DNA molecules. Translocation of a Holliday junction along DNA, or branch migration, progressively exchanges one DNA strand for another and determines the amount of information that is transferred between two recombining partners. In Escherichia coli, the RuvAB protein complex promotes rapid and unidirectional branch migration of Holliday junctions. We have studied translocation of Holliday junctions using a quantitative biochemical system together with a 'single-molecule' branch migration assay. We demonstrate that RuvAB translocates the junctions through identical DNA sequences in a processive manner with a broad distribution of individual branch migration rates. However, when the complex encounters short heterologous sequences, translocation of the Holliday junctions is impeded. We conclude that translocation of the junctions through a sequence heterology occurs with a probability of bypass being determined both by the length of the heterologous region and the lifetime of the stalled RuvAB complex.     

Single Holliday junctions are intermediates of meiotic recombination

Crossing-over between homologous chromosomes facilitates their accurate segregation at the first division of meiosis. Current models for crossing-over invoke an intermediate in which homologs are connected by two crossed-strand structures called Holliday junctions. Such double Holliday junctions are a prominent intermediate in Saccharomyces cerevisiae meiosis, where they form preferentially between homologs rather than between sister chromatids. In sharp contrast, we find that single Holliday junctions are the predominant intermediate in Schizosaccharomyces pombe meiosis. Furthermore, these single Holliday junctions arise preferentially between sister chromatids rather than between homologs. We show that Mus81 is required for Holliday junction resolution, providing further in vivo evidence that the structure-specific endonuclease Mus81-Eme1 is a Holliday junction resolvase. To reconcile these observations, we present a unifying recombination model applicable for both meiosis and mitosis in which single Holliday junctions arise from single- or double-strand breaks, lesions postulated by previous models to initiate recombination.     

Resolving Holliday junctions with Escherichia coli UvrD helicase

The Escherichia coli UvrD helicase is known to function in the mismatch repair and nucleotide excision repair pathways and has also been suggested to have roles in recombination and replication restart. The primary intermediate DNA structure in these two processes is the Holliday junction. UvrD has been shown to unwind a variety of substrates including partial duplex DNA, nicked DNA, forked DNA structures, blunt duplex DNA and RNA-DNA hybrids. Here, we demonstrate that UvrD also catalyzes the robust unwinding of Holliday junction substrates. To characterize this unwinding reaction we have employed steady-state helicase assays, pre-steady-state rapid quench helicase assays, DNaseI footprinting, and electron microscopy. We conclude that UvrD binds initially to the junction compared with binding one of the blunt ends of the four-way junction to initiate unwinding and resolves the synthetic substrate into two double-stranded fork structures. We suggest that UvrD, along with its mismatch repair partners, MutS and MutL, may utilize its ability to unwind Holliday junctions directly in the prevention of homeologous recombination. UvrD may also be involved in the resolution of stalled replication forks by unwinding the Holliday junction intermediate to allow bypass of the blockage.     

Solution formation of Holliday junctions in inverted-repeat DNA sequences

The structure of Holliday junctions has now been well characterized at the atomic level through single-crystal X-ray diffraction in symmetric (inverted-repeat) DNA sequences. At issue, however, is whether the formation of these four-stranded complexes in solution is truly sequence dependent in the manner proposed or is an artifact of the crystallization process and, therefore, has no relevance to the behavior of this central intermediate in homologous recombination and recombination-dependent cellular processes. Here, we apply analytical ultracentrifugation to demonstrate that the sequence d(CCGGTACCGG), which crystallizes in the stacked-X form of the junction, assembles into four-stranded junctions in solution in a manner that is dependent on the DNA and cation concentrations, with an equilibrium established between the junction and duplex forms at 100-200 microM DNA duplex. In contrast, the sequence d(CCGCTAGCGG), which has been crystallized as B-DNA, is seen to adopt only the double-helical form at all DNA and salt concentrations that were tested. Thus, the ACC trinucleotide core is now shown to be important for the formation of Holliday junctions in both crystals and in solution and can be estimated to contribute approximately -4 kcal/mol to stabilizing this recombination intermediate in inverted-repeat sequences.     

Construction and analysis of parallel and antiparallel Holliday junctions

The Holliday junction is a four-stranded DNA intermediate that arises during recombination reactions. We have designed and constructed a set of Holliday junction analogs that model each of the ideal conformations available to a 2-fold symmetric four-arm junction. The strategy used is to connect two arms of a junction molecule with a short tether of thymidines. These DNA molecules share a common core sequence but have different arms that are connected so that each molecule is constrained in either an antiparallel or a parallel structure. For tethered antiparallel molecules the identity of the crossover strands is determined by which arms are connected. Different arm connections gave molecules representing each of the two antiparallel crossover isomers. Two parallel molecules that differ in the length and position of the tether exhibit opposite biases in their choice of crossover strands. Thus, a physical constraint applied at a distance from the branch point can determine the conformation of a junction.     

Enzymatic formation and resolution of Holliday junctions in vitro

E. coli RecA protein promotes homologous pairing and reciprocal strand exchange reactions between duplex DNA molecules in vitro. Reaction intermediates contain Holliday junctions that are driven along the DNA at a maximal rate approaching 1000 bases per minute. T4 endonuclease VII cleaves Holliday junctions in vitro, and its inclusion in RecA-mediated reactions leads to the rapid formation of heteroduplex products. Product analysis indicates patch and splice recombinant molecules similar to those expected from in vivo recombination events. The combined formation and resolution of Holliday junctions has led us to propose a model for resolution based on the structure of RecA-DNA helices. One feature of this model is that resolution, which gives rise to the two types of recombinant product, may occur without need for isomerization of the junction.     

No braiding of Holliday junctions in positively supercoiled DNA molecules

The Holliday junction is a prominent intermediate in genetic recombination that consists of four double helical arms of DNA flanking a branch point. Under many conditions, the Holliday junction arranges its arms into two stacked domains that can be oriented so that genetic markers are parallel or antiparallel. In this arrangement, two strands retain a helical conformation, and the other two strands effect the crossover between helical domains. The products of recombination are altered by a crossover isomerization event, which switches the strands fulfilling these two roles. It appears that effecting this switch from the parallel conformation by the simplest mechanism results in braiding the crossover strands at the branch point. In previous work we showed by topological means that a short, parallel, DNA double crossover molecule with closed ends did not braid its branch point; however, that molecule was too short to adopt the necessary positively supercoiled topology. Here, we have addressed the same problem using a larger molecule of the same type. We have constructed a parallel DNA double crossover molecule with closed ends, containing 14 double helical turns in each helix between its crossover points. We have prepared this molecule in a relaxed form by simple ligation and in a positively supercoiled form by ligation in the presence of netropsin. The positively supercoiled molecule is of the right topology to accommodate braiding. We have compared the relaxed and supercoiled versions for their responses to probes that include hydroxyl radicals, KMnO4, the junction resolvases endonuclease VII and RuvC, and RuvC activation of KMNO4 sensitivity. In no case did we find evidence for a braid at the crossover point. We conclude that Holliday junctions do not braid at their branch points, and that the topological problem created by crossover isomerization in the parallel conformation is likely to be solved by distributing the stress over the helices that flank the branch point.     

TRF2 promotes,remodels and protects telomeric Holliday junctions

The ability of the telomeric DNA‐binding protein, TRF2, to stimulate t‐loop formation while preventing t‐loop deletion is believed to be crucial to maintain telomere integrity in mammals. However, little is known on the molecular mechanisms behind these properties of TRF2. In this report, we show that TRF2 greatly increases the rate of Holliday junction (HJ) formation and blocks the cleavage by various types of HJ resolving activities, including the newly identified human GEN1 protein. By using potassium permanganate probing and differential scanning calorimetry, we reveal that the basic domain of TRF2 induces structural changes to the junction. We propose that TRF2 contributes to t‐loop stabilisation by stimulating HJ formation and by preventing resolvase cleavage. These findings provide novel insights into the interplay between telomere protection and homologous recombination and suggest a general model in which TRF2 maintains telomere integrity by controlling the turnover of HJ at t‐loops and at regressed replication forks.     

The X philes: structure-specific endonucleases that resolve Holliday junctions

Genetic recombination is a critical cellular process that promotes evolutionary diversity, facilitates DNA repair and underpins genome duplication. It entails the reciprocal exchange of single strands between homologous DNA duplexes to form a four-way branched intermediate commonly referred to as the Holliday junction. DNA molecules interlinked in this way have to be separated in order to allow normal chromosome transmission at cell division. This resolution reaction is mediated by structure-specific endonucleases that catalyse dual-strand incision across the point of strand cross-over. Holliday junctions can also arise at stalled replication forks by reversing the direction of fork progression and annealing of nascent strands. Resolution of junctions in this instance generates a DNA break and thus serves to initiate rather than terminate recombination. Junction resolvases are generally small, homodimeric endonucleases with a high specificity for branched DNA. They use a metal-binding pocket to co-ordinate an activated water molecule for phosphodiester bond hydrolysis. In addition, most junction endonucleases modulate the structure of the junction upon binding, and some display a preference for cleavage at specific nucleotide target sequences. Holliday junction resolvases with distinct properties have been characterized from bacteriophages (T4 endo VII, T7 endo I, RusA and Rap), Bacteria (RuvC), Archaea (Hjc and Hje), yeast (CCE1) and poxviruses (A22R). Recent studies have brought about a reappraisal of the origins of junction-specific endonucleases with the discovery that RuvC, CCE1 and A22R share a common catalytic core.     

Parallel and antiparallel Holliday junctions differ in structure and stability

Two Holliday junction analogs, JA and JP, containing identical base-paired arms have been constructed from oligonucleotides. The former is constrained to adopt an antiparallel Sigal-Alberts structure, and the latter a parallel structure, by means of single strand d(T)9 tethers. We evaluate here the free energy difference between JA and JP using two different methods. One is a direct measurement of the ratio of the equilibrium constants for formation of branched structures from intact duplexes using one labeled strand and a competition assay. The second method estimates the difference in stability from the difference in thermal denaturation temperatures of JA and JP, using urea to shift the tm of the complexes. Both methods reveal a small free energy difference between the two complexes: JA is more stable than JP by -1.1(+/- 0.4) kcal (mol junction)-1, at 25 degrees C, 5 mM-Mg2+, from the first method, and by -1.6(+/- 0.3) kcal (mol junction)-1, according to the second. DNase I and the resolvase, endonuclease I from phage T7, cleave JA differently from JP in the vicinity of the branch, indicating that the structures of these two models differ at this site. Diethyl pyrocarbonate also reveals a difference in the major grooves. Comparison of the scission patterns of JA and JP by the reactive chemical probes methidium-propyl-EDTA..Fe(II), [MPE.Fe(II)] and Cu(I)-[o-phenanthroline]2,[(OP)2Cu(I)], indicates that in both cases the branch point is a site of enhanced binding for drugs, as it is in the untethered four-arm junction containing the same core sequence at the branch.     

Spermidine biases the resolution of Holliday junctions by phage lambda integrase

Holliday junctions are a central intermediate in diverse pathways of DNA repair and recombination. The isomerization of a junction determines the directionality of the recombination event. Previous studies have shown that the identity of the central sequence of the junction may favor one of the two isomers, in turn controlling the direction of the pathway. Here we demonstrate that, in the absence of DNA sequence-mediated isomer preference, polycations are the major contributor to biasing strand cleavage during junction resolution. In the case of wild-type phage λ excision junctions, spermidine plays the dominant role in controlling the isomerization state of the junction and increases the rate of junction resolution. Spermidine also counteracts the sequence-imposed bias on resolution. The spermidine-induced bias is seen equally on supercoiled and linear excisive recombination junction intermediates, and thus is not just an artefact of in vitro recombination conditions. The contribution of spermidine requires the presence of accessory factors, and results in the repositioning of Int's core-binding domains on junctions, perhaps due to DNA-spermidine–protein interactions, or by influencing DNA conformation in the core region. Our results lead us to propose that spermidine together with accessory factors promotes the formation of the second junction isomer. We propose that this rearrangement triggers the activation of the second pair of Int active sites necessary to resolve Holliday junctions during phage λ Int-mediated recombination.     

Human Mus81-associated endonuclease cleaves Holliday junctions in vitro.

Mus81, a protein with homology to the XPF subunit of the ERCC1-XPF endonuclease, is important for replicational stress tolerance in both budding and fission yeast. Human Mus81 has associated endonuclease activity against structure-specific oligonucleotide substrates, including synthetic Holliday junctions. Mus81-associated endonuclease resolves Holliday junctions into linear duplexes by cutting across the junction exclusively on strands of like polarity. In addition, Mus81 protein abundance increases in cells following exposure to agents that block DNA replication. Taken together, these findings suggest a role for Mus81 in resolving Holliday junctions that arise when DNA replication is blocked by damage or by nucleotide depletion. Mus81 is not related by sequence to previously characterized Holliday junction resolving enzymes, and it has distinct enzymatic properties that suggest it uses a novel enzymatic strategy to cleave Holliday junctions.     

Xer-mediated site-specific recombination at cer generates Holliday junctions in vivo.

Normal segregation of the Escherichia coli chromosome and stable inheritance of multicopy plasmids such as ColE1 requires the Xer site-specific recombination system. Two putative lambda integrase family recombinases, XerC and XerD, participate in the recombination reactions. We have constructed an E. coli strain in which the expression of xerC can be tightly regulated, thereby allowing the analysis of controlled recombination reactions in vivo. Xer-mediated recombination in this strain generates Holliday junction-containing DNA molecules in which a specific pair of strands has been exchanged in addition to complete recombinant products. This suggests that Xer site-specific recombination utilizes a strand exchange mechanism similar or identical to that of other members of the lambda integrase family of recombination systems. The controlled in vivo recombination reaction at cer requires recombinase and two accessory proteins, ArgR and PepA. Generation of Holliday junctions and recombinant products is equally efficient in RuvC- and RuvC+ cells, and in cells containing a multicopy RuvC+ plasmid. Controlled XerC expression is also used to analyse the efficiency of recombination between variant cer sites containing sequence alterations and heterologies within their central regions.     

Direct evidence for spontaneous branch migration in antiparallel DNA Holliday junctions

The Holliday junction is a central intermediate in genetic recombination. It contains four strands of DNA that are paired into four double helical arms flanking a branch point. In naturally occurring Holliday junctions, the sequence flanking the branch point contains 2-fold (homologous) symmetry. As a consequence of this symmetry, the junction can undergo a conformational isomerization known as branch migration, which relocates the site of branching. In the absence of proteins and in the presence of Mg(2+), the four arms are known to stack in pairs, forming two helical domains whose orientations are antiparallel. Nevertheless, the mechanistic models proposed for branch migration are all predicated on a parallel alignment of helical domains. Here, we have used antiparallel DNA double crossover molecules to demonstrate that branch migration can occur in antiparallel Holliday junctions. We have constructed a DNA double crossover molecule with three crossover points. Two adjacent branch points in this molecule are flanked by symmetric sequences. The symmetric crossover points are held immobile by the third crossover point, which is flanked by asymmetric sequences. Restriction of the helices that connect the immobile junction to the symmetric junctions releases this constraint. The restricted molecule undergoes branch migration, even though it is constrained to an antiparallel conformation.     

Influence of minor groove substituents on the structure of DNA Holliday junctions

The inosine-containing sequence d(CCIGTACm(5)CGG) is shown to crystallize as a four-stranded DNA junction. This structure is nearly identical to the antiparallel junction formed by the parent d(CCGGTACm(5)()CGG) sequence [Vargason, J. M., and Ho, P. S. (2002) J. Biol. Chem. 277, 21041-21049] in terms of its conformational geometry, and inter- and intramolecular interactions within the DNA and between the DNA and solvent, even though the 2-amino group in the minor groove of the important G(3).m(5)C(8) base pair of the junction core trinucleotide (italicized) has been removed. In contrast, the analogous 2,6-diaminopurine sequence d(CCDGTACTGG) crystallizes as resolved duplex DNAs, just like its parent sequence d(CCAGTACTGG) [Hays, F. A., Vargason, J. M., and Ho, P. S. (2003) Biochemistry 42, 9586-9597]. These results demonstrate that it is not the presence or absence of the 2-amino group in the minor groove of the R(3).Y(8) base pair that specifies whether a sequence forms a junction, but the positions of the extracyclic amino and keto groups in the major groove. Finally, the study shows that the arms of the junction can accommodate perturbations to the B-DNA conformation of the stacked duplex arms associated with the loss of the 2-amino substituent, and that two hydrogen bonding interactions from the C(7) and Y(8) pyrimidine nucleotides to phosphate oxygens of the junction crossover specify the geometry of the Holliday junction.     

Dissociation of synthetic Holliday junctions by E. coli RecG protein.

The RecG protein of Escherichia coli is needed for normal levels of recombination and for repair of DNA damaged by ultraviolet light, mitomycin C and ionizing radiation. The true extent of its involvement in these processes is masked to a large degree by what appears to be a functional overlap with the products of the three ruv genes. RuvA and RuvB act together to promote branch migration of Holliday junctions, while RuvC catalyses the resolution of these recombination intermediates into viable products by endonuclease cleavage. In this paper, we describe the overproduction and purification of RecG and demonstrate that the overlap extends to the biochemistry. We show that the 76 kDa RecG protein is a DNA-dependent ATPase, like RuvB. Using gel retardation assays we demonstrate that it binds specifically to a synthetic Holliday junction, like RuvA and RuvC. Finally, we show that in the presence of ATP and Mg2+, RecG dissociates these junctions to duplex products, like RuvAB. We suggest that RecG and RuvAB provide alternative activities than can promote branch migration of Holliday junctions in recombination and DNA repair.     

Atomic force microscopic measurement of the interdomain angle in symmetric Holliday junctions

The Holliday junction is a key intermediate in genetic recombination. It consists of four DNA strands that associate by base pairing to produce four double helices flanking a junction point. In the presence of multivalent cations, the four helices, in turn, stack in pairs to form two double-helical domains. The angle between these domains has been shown in a number of solution studies to be approximately 60 degrees in junctions flanked by asymmetric sequences. However, the recently determined crystal structure of a symmetric junction [Eichman, B. F., Vargason, J. M., Mooers, B. H. M., and Ho, P. S. (2000) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 97, 3971-3976] finds an angle closer to 40 degrees, possibly because of sequence effects. From the crystal structure alone, one cannot exclude the possibility that this unusual angle is a consequence of crystal packing effects. We have formed two-dimensional (2D) periodic arrays of DNA parallelograms with the same junction-flanking sequence used to produce the crystals; these parallelograms are free to adopt their preferred interdomain angle. Atomic force microscopy can be used to establish the interdomain angle in this system. We find that the angle in this junction is 43 degrees, in good agreement with the results of crystallography. We have used hydroxyl radical autofootprinting to establish that the branch point is at the same migratory position seen in the crystals.