Crystal structure of a DNA Holliday junction.

DNA recombination is a universal biological event responsible both for the generation of genetic diversity and for the maintenance of genome integrity. A four-way DNA junction, also termed Holliday junction, is the key intermediate in nearly all recombination processes. This junction is the substrate of recombination enzymes that promote branch migration or catalyze its resolution. We have determined the crystal structure of a four-way DNA junction by multiwavelength anomalous diffraction, and refined it to 2.16 A resolution. The structure has two-fold symmetry, with pairwise stacking of the double-helical arms, which form two continuous B-DNA helices that run antiparallel, cross in a right-handed way, and contain two G-A mismatches. The exchanging backbones form a compact structure with strong van der Waals contacts and hydrogen bonds, implying that a conformational change must occur for the junction to branch-migrate or isomerize. At the branch point, two phosphate groups from one helix occupy the major groove of the other one, establishing sequence-specific hydrogen bonds. These interactions, together with different stacking energies and steric hindrances, explain the preference for a particular junction stacked conformer.     

Conformational model of the Holliday junction transition deduced from molecular dynamics simulations

Homologous recombination plays a key role in the restart of stalled replication forks and in the generation of genetic diversity. During this process, two homologous DNA molecules undergo strand exchange to form a four-way DNA (Holliday) junction. In the presence of metal ions, the Holliday junction folds into the stacked-X structure that has two alternative conformers. Experiments have revealed the spontaneous transitions between these conformers, but their detailed pathways are not known. Here, we report a series of molecular dynamics simulations of the Holliday junction at physiological and elevated (400 K) temperatures. The simulations reveal new tetrahedral intermediates and suggest a schematic framework for conformer transitions. The tetrahedral intermediates bear resemblance to the junction conformation in complex with a junction-resolving enzyme, T7 endonuclease I, and indeed, one intermediate forms a stable complex with the enzyme as demonstrated in one simulation. We also describe free energy minima for various states of the Holliday junction system, which arise during conformer transitions. The results show that magnesium ions stabilize the stacked-X form and destabilize the open and tetrahedral intermediates. Overall, our study provides a detailed dynamic model of the Holliday junction undergoing a conformer transition.     

Effect of Single-Strand Break on Branch Migration and Folding Dynamics of Holliday Junctions

The Holliday junction (HJ), or four-way junction, is a central intermediate state of DNA for homologous genetic recombination and other genetic processes such as replication and repair. Branch migration is the process by which the exchange of homologous DNA regions occurs, and it can be spontaneous or driven by proteins. Unfolding of the HJ is required for branch migration. Our previous single-molecule fluorescence studies led to a model according to which branch migration is a stepwise process consisting of consecutive migration and folding steps. Folding of the HJ in one of the folded conformations terminates the branch migration phase. At the same time, in the unfolded state HJ rapidly migrates over entire homology region of the HJ in one hop. This process can be affected by irregularities in the DNA double helical structure, so mismatches almost terminate a spontaneous branch migration. Single-stranded breaks or nicks are the most ubiquitous defects in the DNA helix; however, to date, their effect on the HJ branch migration has not been studied. In addition, although nicked HJs are specific substrates for a number of enzymes involved in DNA recombination and repair, the role of this substrate specificity remains unclear. Our main goal in this work was to study the effect of nicks on the efficiency of HJ branch migration and the dynamics of the HJ. To accomplish this goal, we applied two single-molecule methods: atomic force microscopy and fluorescence resonance energy transfer. The atomic force microscopy data show that the nick does not prevent branch migration, but it does decrease the probability that the HJ will pass the DNA lesion. The single-molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer approaches were instrumental in detailing the effects of nicks. These studies reveal a dramatic change of the HJ dynamics. The nick changes the structure and conformational dynamics of the junctions, leading to conformations with geometries that are different from those for the intact HJ. On the basis of these data, we propose a model of branch migration in which the propensity of the junction to unfold decreases the lifetimes of folded states, thereby increasing the frequency of junction fluctuations between the folded states.     

Direct evidence for spontaneous branch migration in antiparallel DNA Holliday junctions

The Holliday junction is a central intermediate in genetic recombination. It contains four strands of DNA that are paired into four double helical arms flanking a branch point. In naturally occurring Holliday junctions, the sequence flanking the branch point contains 2-fold (homologous) symmetry. As a consequence of this symmetry, the junction can undergo a conformational isomerization known as branch migration, which relocates the site of branching. In the absence of proteins and in the presence of Mg(2+), the four arms are known to stack in pairs, forming two helical domains whose orientations are antiparallel. Nevertheless, the mechanistic models proposed for branch migration are all predicated on a parallel alignment of helical domains. Here, we have used antiparallel DNA double crossover molecules to demonstrate that branch migration can occur in antiparallel Holliday junctions. We have constructed a DNA double crossover molecule with three crossover points. Two adjacent branch points in this molecule are flanked by symmetric sequences. The symmetric crossover points are held immobile by the third crossover point, which is flanked by asymmetric sequences. Restriction of the helices that connect the immobile junction to the symmetric junctions releases this constraint. The restricted molecule undergoes branch migration, even though it is constrained to an antiparallel conformation.     

p53 blocks RuvAB promoted branch migration and modulates resolution of Holliday junctions by RuvC

The Holliday junction is the central intermediate in homologous recombination. Branch migration of this four-stranded DNA structure is a key step in genetic recombination that affects the extent of genetic information exchanged between two parental DNA molecules. Here, we have constructed synthetic Holliday junctions to test the effects of p53 on both spontaneous and RuvAB promoted branch migration as well as the effect on resolution of the junction by RuvC. We demonstrate that p53 blocks branch migration, and that cleavage of the Holliday junction by RuvC is modulated by p53. These findings suggest that p53 can block branch migration promoted by proteins such as RuvAB and modulate the cleavage by Holliday junction resolution proteins such as RuvC. These results suggest that p53 could have similar effects on eukaryotic homologues of RuvABC and thus have a direct role in recombinational DNA repair.     

Structure of the three-way helical junction of the hepatitis C virus IRES element

The hepatitis C virus internal ribosome entry site (IRES) element contains a three-way junction that is important in the overall RNA conformation, and for its role in the internal initiation of translation. The junction also illustrates some important conformational principles in the folding of three-way helical junctions. It is formally a 3HS₄ junction, with the possibility of two alternative stacking conformers. However, in principle, the junction can also undergo two steps of branch migration that would form 2HS₁HS₃ and 2HS₂HS₂ junctions. Comparative gel electrophoresis and ensemble fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) studies show that the junction is induced to fold by the presence of Mg²⁺ ions in low micromolar concentrations, and suggest that the structure adopted is based on coaxial stacking of the two helices that do not terminate in a hairpin loop (i.e., helix IIId). Single-molecule FRET studies confirm this conclusion, and indicate that there is no minor conformer present based on an alternative choice of helical stacking partners. Moreover, analysis of single-molecule FRET data at an 8-msec resolution failed to reveal evidence for structural transitions. It seems probable that this junction adopts a single conformation as a unique and stable fold.     

A method for preparing genomic DNA that restrains branch migration of Holliday junctions

The Holliday junction is a central intermediate in genetic recombination. This four-stranded DNA structure is capable of spontaneous branch migration, and is lost during standard DNA extraction protocols. In order to isolate and characterize recombination intermediates that contain Holliday junctions, we have developed a rapid protocol that restrains branch migration of four-way DNA junctions. The cationic detergent hex-adecyltrimethylammonium bromide is used to lyse cells and precipitate DNA. Manipulations are performed in the presence of the cations hexamine cobalt(III) or magnesium, which stabilize Holliday junctions in a stacked-X configuration that branch migrates very slowly. This protocol was evaluated using a sensitive assay for spontaneous branch migration, and was shown to preserve both artificial Holliday junctions and meiotic recombination intermediates containing four-way junctions.     

RuvA is a sliding collar that protects Holliday junctions from unwinding while promoting branch migration

The RuvAB proteins catalyze branch migration of Holliday junctions during DNA recombination in Escherichia coli. RuvA binds tightly to the Holliday junction, and then recruits two RuvB pumps to power branch migration. Previous investigations have studied RuvA in conjunction with its cellular partner RuvB. The replication fork helicase DnaB catalyzes branch migration like RuvB but, unlike RuvB, is not dependent on RuvA for activity. In this study, we specifically analyze the function of RuvA by studying RuvA in conjunction with DnaB, a DNA pump that does not work with RuvA in the cell. Thus, we use DnaB as a tool to dissect RuvA function from RuvB. We find that RuvA does not inhibit DnaB-catalyzed branch migration of a homologous junction, even at high concentrations of RuvA. Hence, specific protein-protein interaction is not required for RuvA mobilization during branch migration, in contrast to previous proposals. However, low concentrations of RuvA block DnaB unwinding at a Holliday junction. RuvA even blocks DnaB-catalyzed unwinding when two DnaB rings are acting in concert on opposite sides of the junction. These findings indicate that RuvA is intrinsically mobile at a Holliday junction when the DNA is undergoing branch migration, but RuvA is immobile at the same junction during DNA unwinding. We present evidence that suggests that RuvA can slide along a Holliday junction structure during DnaB-catalyzed branch migration, but not during unwinding. Thus, RuvA may act as a sliding collar at Holliday junctions, promoting DNA branch migration activity while blocking other DNA remodeling activities. Finally, we show that RuvA is less mobile at a heterologous junction compared to a homologous junction, as two opposing DnaB pumps are required to mobilize RuvA over heterologous DNA.     

Parallel helical domains in DNA branched junctions containing 5',5' and 3',3' linkages

The Holliday junction is a central intermediate in genetic recombination. It contains four strands of DNA that are paired into four double helical arms that flank a branch point. In the presence of Mg2+, the four arms are known to stack in pairs forming two helical domains whose orientations are antiparallel but twisted by about 60 degrees. The basis for the antiparallel orientation of the domains could be either junction structure or the effect of electrostatic repulsion between domains. To discriminate between these two possibilities, we have constructed and characterized an analogue, called a bowtie junction, in which one strand contains a 3',3' linkage at the branch point, the strand opposite it contains a 5',5' linkage, and the other two strands contain conventional 3',5' linkages. Electrostatic effects are expected to lead to an antiparallel structure in this system. We have characterized the molecule in comparison with a conventional immobile branched junction by Ferguson analysis and by observing its thermal transition profile; the two molecules behave virtually identically in these assays. Hydroxyl radical autofootprinting has been used to establish that the unusual linkages occur at the branch point and that the arms stack to form the same domains as the conventional junction. Cooper-Hagerman gel mobility analyses have been used to determine the relative orientations of the helical domains. Remarkably, we find them to be closer to parallel than to antiparallel, suggesting that the preferred structure of the branch point dominates over electrostatic repulsion. We have controlled for the number of available bonds in the branch point, for gel concentration, and for the role of divalent cations. This finding suggests that control of branch point structure alone can lead to parallel domains, which are generally consistent with recombination models derived from genetic data.     

A histone octamer blocks branch migration of a Holliday junction.

The Holliday junction is a key intermediate in genetic recombination. Here, we examine the effect of a nucleosome core on movement of the Holliday junction in vitro by spontaneous branch migration. Histone octamers consisting of H2A, H2B, H3, and H4 are reconstituted onto DNA duplexes containing an artificial nucleosome-positioning sequence consisting of a tandem array of an alternating AT-GC sequence motif. Characterization of the reconstituted branch migration substrates by micrococcal nuclease mapping and exonuclease III and hydroxyl radical footprinting reveal that 70% of the reconstituted octamers are positioned near the center of the substrate and the remaining 30% are located at the distal end, although in both cases some translational degeneracy is observed. Branch migration assays with the octamer-containing substrates reveal that the Holliday junction cannot migrate spontaneously through DNA organized into a nucleosomal core unless DNA-histone interactions are completely disrupted. Similar results are obtained with branch migration substrates containing an octamer positioned on a naturally occurring sequence derived from the yeast GLN3 locus. Digestion of Holliday junctions with T7 endonuclease I establishes that the junction is not trapped by the octamer but can branch migrate in regions free of histone octamers. Our findings suggest that migration of Holliday junctions during recombination and the recombinational repair of DNA damage requires proteins not only to accelerate the intrinsic rate of branch migration but also to facilitate the passage of the Holliday junction through a nucleosome.     

A pivotal role for the structure of the Holliday junction in DNA branch migration.

Branch migration of a DNA Holliday junction is a key step in genetic recombination that affects the extent of transfer of genetic information between homologous DNA sequences. We previously observed that the rate of spontaneous branch migration is exceedingly sensitive to metal ions and postulated that the structure of the cross-over point might be one critical determinant of the rate of branch migration. Other investigators have shown that in the presence of divalent metal ions like magnesium, the Holliday junction assumes a folded conformation in which base stacking is retained through the cross-over point. This base stacking is disrupted in the absence of magnesium. Here we measure the rate of branch migration as a function of Mg2+ concentration. The rate of branch migration increases dramatically at MgCl2 concentrations below 500 microM, with the steepest acceleration occurring between 300 and 100 microM MgCl2. This increase in the rate of branch migration coincides with the loss of base stacking in the four-way junction over this same interval of magnesium concentration, as measured by the susceptibility of junction residues to modification by osmium tetroxide and diethyl pyrocarbonate. We conclude that at physiological concentrations of intracellular Mg2+, base stacking in the Holliday junction constitutes one kinetic barrier to branch migration and that disruption of base stacking at the cross-over relieves this constraint.     

Single molecule fluorescence analysis of branch migration of holliday junctions: effect of DNA sequence

The Holliday junction is a central intermediate in various genetic processes including homologous, site-specific recombination and DNA replication. Recent single molecule FRET experiments led to the model for branch migration as a stepwise stochastic process in which the branch migration hop is terminated by the folding of the junction. In this article, we studied the effect of the sequence on Holliday junction dynamics and branch migration process. We show that a GC pair placed at the border of the homologous region almost prevents the migration into this position. At the same time, insertion of a GC pair into the middle of the AT tract does not show this effect, however when the junction folds at this position, it resides at this position much longer time in comparison to the folding at AT pairs. Two contiguous GC pairs do not block migration as well and generally manifest the same effect as one GC pair—the junction when it folds resides at these positions for a relatively long time. The same elevated residence time was obtained for the design with the homology region that consists of only GC pairs. These data suggest a model for branch migration in which the sequence modulates the overall stochastic process of the junction dynamics and branch migration by the variability of the time that the junction dwells before making a migration hop.     

Stability of hairpin ribozyme tertiary structure is governed by the interdomain junction.

The equilibrium distributions of hairpin ribozyme conformational isomers have been examined by time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer. Ribozymes partition between active (docked) and inactive (extended) conformers, characterized by unique interdomain distance distributions, which define differences in folding free energy. The active tertiary structure is stabilized both by specific interactions between the catalytic and the substrate-binding domains and by the structure of the intervening helical junction. Under physiological conditions, the docking equilibrium of the natural four-way junction dramatically favors the active conformer, while those of a three-way and the two-way junction used in gene therapy applications favor the inactive conformer.     

Molecular recognition of DNA structure by proteins that mediate genetic recombination

The latter half of genetic recombination is mediated by proteins that recognise the structure of the four-way DNA junction, and manipulate this structure. In solution the four-way junction adopts a stacked X-structure in the presence of metal ions. The folding is brought about by the pairwise coaxial stacking of helices in a right-handed antiparallel X-shaped structure. The four-way junction is cleaved by structure-selective resolving enzymes that have been isolated from a wide variety of sources, from eubacteria and their phages through to mammals. In addition, another class of proteins accelerate the branch migration of the junction. These proteins all appear to be divisible into a component that recognises structure and another that carries out a reaction on the junction. Thus the ability of structure-selective binding to the four-way DNA junction is a key feature of enzymes important in genetic recombination.     

Structure of the Holliday junction intermediate in Cre-loxP site-specific recombination.

We have determined the X-ray crystal structures of two DNA Holliday junctions (HJs) bound by Cre recombinase. The HJ is a four-way branched structure that occurs as an intermediate in genetic recombination pathways, including site-specific recombination by the lambda-integrase family. Cre recombinase is an integrase family member that recombines 34 bp loxP sites in the absence of accessory proteins or auxiliary DNA sequences. The 2.7 A structure of Cre recombinase bound to an immobile HJ and the 2.5 A structure of Cre recombinase bound to a symmetric, nicked HJ reveal a nearly planar, twofold-symmetric DNA intermediate that shares features with both the stacked-X and the square conformations of the HJ that exist in the unbound state. The structures support a protein-mediated crossover isomerization of the junction that acts as the switch responsible for activation and deactivation of recombinase active sites. In this model, a subtle isomerization of the Cre recombinase-HJ quaternary structure dictates which strands are cleaved during resolution of the junction via a mechanism that involves neither branch migration nor helical restacking.     

Processing of DNA structures via DNA unwinding and branch migration by the S. cerevisiae Mph1 protein

The budding yeast Mph1 protein, the putative ortholog of human FANCM, possesses a 3' to 5' DNA helicase activity and is capable of disrupting the D-loop structure to suppress chromosome arm crossovers in mitotic homologous recombination. Similar to FANCM, genetic studies have implicated Mph1 in DNA replication fork repair. Consistent with this genetic finding, we show here that Mph1 is able to mediate replication fork reversal, and to process the Holliday junction via DNA branch migration. Moreover, Mph1 unwinds 3' and 5' DNA Flap structures that bear key features of the D-loop. These biochemical results not only provide validation for a role of Mph1 in the repair of damaged replication forks, but they also offer mechanistic insights as to its ability to efficiently disrupt the D-loop intermediate.     

Resolution of undistorted symmetric immobile DNA junctions by vaccinia topoisomerase I

Holliday junctions are intermediates in genetic recombination. They consist of four strands of DNA that flank a branch point. In natural systems, their sequences have 2-fold (homologous) sequence symmetry. This symmetry enables the molecules to undergo an isomerization, known as branch migration, that relocates the site of the branch point. Branch migration leads to polydispersity, which makes it difficult to characterize the physical properties of the junction and the effects of the sequence context flanking the branch point. Previous studies have reported two symmetric junctions that do not branch migrate: one that is immobilized by coupling to an asymmetric junction in a double crossover context, and a second that is based on molecules containing 5',5' and 3',3' linkages. Both are flawed by distorting the structure of the symmetric junction from its natural conformation. Here, we report an undistorted symmetric immobile junction based on the use of DNA parallelogram structures. We have used a series of these junctions to characterize the junction resolution reaction catalyzed by vaccinia virus DNA topoisomerase. The resolution reaction entails cleavage and rejoining at CCCTT/N recognition sites arrayed on opposing sides of the four-arm junction. We find that resolution is optimal when the scissile phosphodiester (Tp/N) is located two nucleotides 5' to the branch point on the helical strand. Covalent topoisomerase-DNA adducts are precursors to recombinant strands in all reactions, as expected. Kinetic analysis suggests a rate limiting step after the first-strand cleavage.     

Partial phase diagram of aqueous bovine carbonic anhydrase: analyses of the pressure-dependent temperatures of the low- to physiological-temperature nondenaturational conformational change and of unfolding to the molten globule state

At 1.0 atm pressure and in 150 mM sodium phosphate (pH = 7.0), bovine carbonic anhydrase undergoes a nondenaturational conformational change at 30.3 degrees C and an unfolding transition from the physiological conformer to the molten globule state at 67.4 degrees C. The pressure dependences of the temperatures of these transitions have been studied under reversible conditions for the purpose of understanding DeltaH degrees , DeltaS degrees , and DeltaV for each conformational change. Temperatures for the low-temperature to physiological-temperature conformational change T(L-->P) are obtained from physiologically relevant conditions using slow-scan-rate differential scanning calorimetry. Temperatures for the physiological-temperature conformation to molten globule state conversion T(P-->MG) are obtained from differential scanning calorimetry measurements of the apparent transition temperature in the presence of guanidine hydrochloride extrapolated to zero molar denaturant. The use of slow-scan-rate differential scanning calorimetry permits the calculation of the activation volume for the conversion of the low-temperature conformer to the physiological-temperature conformer DeltaV(double dagger)(L-->P). At 1.0 atm pressure, the transition from the low-temperature conformer to the physiological-temperature conformer involves a volume change DeltaV(L-->P) = 15 +/- 2 L/mole, which contrasts with the partial unfolding of the physiological-temperature conformer to the molten globule state (DeltaV(P-->MG) = 26 +/- 9 L/mole). The activation volume for this process DeltaV(double dagger)(L-->P) = 51 +/- 9 L/mole and is consistent with a prior thermodynamic analysis that suggests the conformational transition from the low-temperature conformation to the physiological-temperature conformation possesses a substantial unfolding quality. These results provide further evidence the structure of the enzyme obtained from crystals grown below 30 degrees C should not be regarded as the physiological structure (the normal bovine body temperature is 38.3 degrees C). These results should therefore have implications in any area that seeks to correlate the crystal structure of bovine carbonic anhydrase to physiological function.     

Functional interactions between the holliday junction resolvase and the branch migration motor of Escherichia coli.

Homologous recombination generates genetic diversity and provides an important cellular pathway for the repair of double-stranded DNA breaks. Two key steps in this process are the branch migration of Holliday junctions followed by their resolution into mature recombination products. In E.coli, branch migration is catalysed by the RuvB protein, a hexameric DNA helicase that is loaded onto the junction by RuvA, whereas resolution is promoted by the RuvC endonuclease. Here we provide direct evidence for functional interactions between RuvB and RuvC that link these biochemically distinct processes. Using synthetic Holliday junctions, RuvB was found to stabilize the binding of RuvC to a junction and to stimulate its resolvase activity. Conversely, RuvC facilitated interactions between RuvB and the junction such that RuvBC complexes catalysed branch migration. The observed synergy between RuvB and RuvC provides new insight into the structure and function of a RuvABC complex that is capable of facilitating branch migration and resolution of Holliday junctions via a concerted enzymatic mechanism.     

Exploring rare conformational species and ionic effects in DNA Holliday junctions using single-molecule spectroscopy

The four-way DNA (Holliday) junction is an essential intermediate in DNA recombination, and its dynamic characteristics are likely to be important in its cellular processing. In our previous study we observed transitions between two antiparallel stacked conformations using a single-molecule fluorescence approach. The magnesium concentration-dependent rates of transitions between stacking conformers suggested that an unstacked open structure, which is stable in the absence of metal ions, is an intermediate. Here, we sought to detect possible rare species such as open and parallel conformations and further characterized ionic effects. The hypothesized open intermediate cannot be resolved directly due to the limited time resolution and sensitivity, but our study suggests that the open form is achieved very frequently, hundreds of times per second under physiologically relevant conditions. Therefore despite being a minority species, its frequent formation raises the probability that it could become stabilized by protein binding. By contrast, we cannot detect even a transient existence of the junctions in a parallel form, and the probability of such forms with a lifetime greater than 5 ms is less than 0.01%. Stacking conformer transitions are observable in the presence of sodium or hexammine cobalt (III) ions as well as magnesium ions, but the transition rates are higher for lower valence ions at the same concentrations. This further supports the notion that electrostatic stabilization of the stacked structures dictates the interconversion rates between different structural forms.