Cardiolipin: Setting the beat of apoptosis

Cardiolipin (CL) is a mitochondria-specific phospholipid which is known to be intimately linked with the mitochondrial bioenergetic machinery. Accumulating evidence now suggests that this unique lipid also has active roles in several of the mitochondria-dependant steps of apoptosis. CL is closely associated with cytochrome c at the outer leaflet of the mitochondrial inner membrane. This interaction makes the process of cytochrome c release from mitochondria more complex than previously assumed, requiring more than pore formation in the mitochondrial outer membrane. While CL peroxidation could be crucial for enabling cytochrome c dissociation from the mitochondrial inner membrane, cytochrome c itself catalyzes CL peroxidation. Moreover, peroxy-CL directly activates the release of cytochrome c and other apoptogenic factors from the mitochondria. CL is also directly involved in mitochondrial outer membrane permeabilization by enabling docking and activation of pro-apoptotic Bcl-2 proteins. It appears therefore that CL has multiple roles in apoptosis and that CL metabolism contributes to the complexity of the apoptotic process.     

Interactions of Bax and tBid with Lipid Monolayers

The release of cytochrome c from mitochondria to the cytosol is a crucial step of apoptosis that involves interactions of Bax and tBid proteins with the mitochondrial membrane. We investigated Bax and tBid interactions with (i) phosphatidylcholine (PC) monolayer as the main component of the outer leaflet of the outer membrane, (ii) with phosphatidylethanolamine (PE) and phosphatidylserine (PS) that are present in the inner leaflet and (iii) with a mixed PC/PE/Cardiolipin (CL) monolayer of the contact sites between the outer and inner membranes. These interactions were studied by measuring the increase of the lipidic monolayer surface pressure induced by the proteins. Our measurements suggest that tBid interacts strongly with the POPC/DOPE/CL, whereas Bax interaction with this monolayer is about 12 times weaker. Both tBid and Bax interact moderately half as strongly with negatively charged DOPS and non-lamellar DOPE monolayers. TBid also slightly interacts with DOPC. Our results suggest that tBid but not Bax interacts with the PC-containing outer membrane. Subsequent insertion of these proteins may occur at the PC/PE/CL sites of contact between the outer and inner membranes. It was also shown that Bax and tBid being mixed in solution inhibit their insertion into POPC/DOPE/CL monolayer. The known 3-D structures of Bax and Bid allowed us to propose a structural interpretation of these experimental results.     

Changes in intramitochondrial cardiolipin distribution in apoptosis-resistant HCW-2 cells, derived from the human promyelocytic leukemia HL-60

Using a cytofluorimetric approach, we studied intramitochondrial cardiolipin (CL) distribution in HCW-2 cells, an apoptosis-resistant clone of human HL-60 cells. In HL-60, about 50% of total CL is distributed in the outer leaflet of mitochondrial inner membrane, while in HCW-2 a significantly higher amount of CL (about 65%) is in that site. In basal conditions, HSW-2 cells also show a reduced mitochondrial membrane potential even if they are able to proliferate as the parental line. Taking into account the complex functions that CL plays in the regulation of mitochondrial activity, it is likely that HCW-2 could produce ATP utilizing more glycolytic pathways rather than mitochondrial respiratory chain.     

Scott syndrome, a bleeding disorder caused by defective scrambling of membrane phospholipids

Normal quescent cells maintain membrane lipid asymmetry by ATP-dependent membrane lipid transporters, which shuttle different phospholipids from one leaflet to the other against their respective concentration gradients. When cells are challenged, membrane lipid asymmetry can be perturbed resulting in exposure of phosphatidylserine [PS] at the outer cell surface. Translocation of PS from the inner to outer membrane leaflet of activated blood platelets and platelet-derived microvesicles provides a catalytic surface for interacting coagulation factors. This process is dramatically impaired in Scott syndrome, a rare congenital bleeding disorder, underscoring the indispensible role of PS in hemostasis. This also testifies to a defect of a protein-catalyzed scrambling of membrane phospholipids. The Scott phenotype is not restricted to platelets, but can be demonstrated in other blood cells as well. The functional aberrations observed in Scott syndrome have increased our understanding of transmembrane lipid movements, and may help to identify the molecular elements that promote the collapse of phospholipid asymmetry during cell activation and apoptosis.     

Cardiolipin acts as a mitochondrial signalling platform to launch apoptosis

Cardiolipin (CL) is a unique anionic phospholipid specific to the mitochondria. CL influences the activity of electron transport chain enzyme complexes as well as members of the Bcl-2 family. Interactions between Bcl-2 family members and other pro-apoptotic enzymes have been shown to be crucial for the transduction of the apoptotic signalling cascades during programmed cell death. Targeting of tBid to the mitochondria, which is necessary for Bax/Bak oligomerization and cristae remodelling, is dependent on the exposure of CL at contact sites between the inner and outer mitochondrial membranes. Also, the mobilization of cytochrome c, another key apoptotic event, is tightly regulated by the oxidative state of cardiolipin. Moreover, CL has been shown to be essential for translocation and autoprocessing of caspase-8 on the mitochondria after death receptor stimulation. Deficiencies in CL inhibit the formation of tBid and prevent apoptosis by removing an essential activation platform for the autoprocessing of caspase-8. It is now apparent that CL acts as a crucial signalling platform from which it orchestrates apoptosis by integrating signals from a variety of death inducing proteins.     

Phosphatidylserine, a death knell

Virtually every cell in the body restricts phosphatidylserine (PS) to the inner leaflet of the plasma membrane by energy-dependent transport from the outer to the inner leaflet of the bilayer. Apoptotic cells of all types rapidly randomize the asymmetric distribution, bringing PS to the surface where it serves as a signal for phagocytosis. A myriad of phagocyte receptors have been implicated in the recognition of apoptotic cells, among them a PS receptor, yet few ligands other than PS have been identified on the apoptotic cell surface. Since apoptosis and the associated exposure of PS on the cell surface is probably over 600 million years old, it is not surprising that evolution has appropriated aspects of this process for specialized purposes such as blood coagulation, membrane fusion and erythrocyte differentiation. Failure to efficiently remove apoptotic cells may contribute to inflammatory responses and autoimmune diseases resulting from chronic, inappropriate exposure of PS.     

The human homologue of the Aspergillus nuclear migration gene nudC is preferentially expressed in dividing cells and ciliated epithelia

An early event in apoptosis is exposure of phosphatidylserine, an aminophospholipid normally present in the inner leaflet of the plasma membranes, at the outer leaflet of the plasma membrane facing the extracellular space. Annexin V (Anx-V) is a 35-kDa protein with high affinity for phosphatidylserine, which can be applied to detect apoptosis. We injected biotin-labelled Anx-V intravenously in adult mice and examined the tissue distribution of Anx-V-labelled cells in dental and periodontal tissues using ABC-peroxidase histochemistry. In the continuously erupting incisors, strong and frequent immunostaining was observed in transitional stage and late maturation stage ameloblasts with less frequent staining in preameloblasts. Frequency of staining in odontoblasts and pulp cells was low but increased slightly at older stages of dentinogenesis. Labelling was also seen in phagocytic or phagocytic-like cells in the enamel organ and pulp. A positive staining was furthermore found in fibroblasts of the periodontal ligament in continuously erupting incisors and in fully erupted molar teeth. Staining intensity and the number of positive cells were enhanced by antigen retrieval using high-pressure cooking. We conclude that Anx-V-biotin labels dental cells in early stages of cell death and indirectly cells that have ingested labelled apoptotic cells during the course of the experiment. The data confirm that during amelogenesis most cell death occurs in transitional stage and late maturation stage ameloblasts. Thus, labelling with Anx-V is a useful marker for studying cell death and the dynamics of clearance of apoptotic cells during tooth development.     

Phosphatidylserine exposure during early primary necrosis (oncosis) in JB6 cells as evidenced by immunogold labeling technique

Apoptotic cell death is characterized by the early exposure of phosphatidylserine (PS) at the outer surface of the plasma membrane. The aim of the present study was to examine whether PS exposure also occurs during oncosis (early primary necrosis) and to localize PS at the subcellular level, applying a pre-embedding immunogold labeling technique with biotin conjugated annexin V. The issue was addressed by using caspase-8 deficient, Bcl-2 overexpressing JB6 cells, which die by oncosis when stimulated with synthetic dsRNA. We observed by fluorescence microscopy that oncotic cells with preserved plasma membrane integrity showed PS exposure (annexin+/propidium iodide-). The data was confirmed on the ultrastructural level and PS was localized in oncosis at the outer leaflet of the continuous plasma membrane with preserved trilamellar structure. In postoncotic necrotic cells the immunogold labels were found on the plasma membrane and on the intracellular membranes of the cells, which underwent plasma membrane disruption. In conclusion, this study reveals that PS externalization occurs not only in apoptosis but also in oncosis at least in our cell model system.     

Phosphatidylserine directly and positively regulates fusion of myoblasts into myotubes

Cell membrane consists of various lipids such as phosphatidylserine (PS), phosphatidylcholine (PC), and phosphatidylethanolamine (PE). Among them, PS is a molecular marker of apoptosis, because it is located to the inner leaflet of plasma membrane generally but it is moved to the outer leaflet during programmed cell death. The process of apoptosis has been implicated in the fusion of muscle progenitor cells, myoblasts, into myotubes. However, it remained unclear whether PS regulates muscle cell differentiation directly. In this paper, localization of PS to the outer leaflet of plasma membrane in proliferating primary myoblasts and during fusion of these myoblasts into myotubes is validated using Annexin V. Moreover, we show the presence of PS clusters at the cell–cell contact points, suggesting the importance of membrane ruffling and PS exposure for the myogenic cell fusion. Confirming this conclusion, experimentally constructed PS, but not PC liposomes dramatically enhance the formation of myotubes from myoblasts, thus demonstrating a direct positive effect of PS on the muscle cell fusion. In contrast, myoblasts exposed to PC liposomes produce long myotubes with low numbers of myonuclei. Moreover, pharmacological masking of PS on the myoblast surface inhibits fusion of these cells into myotubes in a dose-dependent manner.     

Lipid topology and physical properties of the outer mitochondrial membrane of the yeast, Saccharomyces cerevisiae

The outer membrane of yeast mitochondria was studied with respect to its lipid composition, phospholipid topology and membrane fluidity. This membrane is characterized by a high phospholipid to protein ratio (1.20). Like other yeast cellular membranes the outer mitochondrial membrane contains predominantly phosphatidylcholine (44% of total phospholipids), phosphatidylethanolamine (34%) and phosphatidylinositol (14%). Cardiolipin, the characteristic phospholipid of the inner mitochondrial membrane (13% of total phospholipids) is present in the outer membrane only to a moderate extent (5%). The ergosterol to phospholipid ratio is higher in the inner (7.0 wt%) as compared to the outer membrane (2.1 wt.%). Attempts to study phospholipid asymmetry by selective degradation of phospholipids of the outer leaflet of the outer mitochondrial membrane failed, because isolated right-side-out vesicles of this membrane became leaky upon treatment with phospholipases. Selective removal of phospholipids of the outer leaflet with the aid of phospholipid transfer proteins and chemical modification with trinitrobenzenesulfonic acid on the other hand, gave satisfactory results. Phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylinositol are more or less evenly distributed between the two sides of the outer mitochondrial membrane, whereas the majority of phosphatidylethanolamine is oriented towards the intermembrane space. The fluidity of mitochondrial membranes was determined by measuring fluorescence anisotropy using diphenylhexatriene (DPH) as a probe. The lower anisotropy of DPH in the outer as compared to the inner membrane, which is an indication for an increased lipid mobility in the outer membrane, was attributed to the higher phospholipid to protein and the lower ergosterol to phospholipid ratio. The data presented here show, that the outer mitochondrial membrane, in spite of its close contact to the inner membrane, is distinct not only with respect to its protein pattern, but also with respect to its lipid composition and physical membrane properties.     

Mitochondrial release of apoptosis-inducing factor occurs downstream of cytochrome c release in response to several proapoptotic stimuli

Mitochondrial outer membrane permeabilization by proapoptotic Bcl-2 family proteins, such as Bax, plays a crucial role in apoptosis induction. However, whether this only causes the intracytosolic release of inducers of caspase-dependent death, such as cytochrome c, or also of caspase-independent death, such as apoptosis-inducing factor (AIF) remains unknown. Here, we show that on isolated mitochondria, Bax causes the release of cytochrome c, but not of AIF, and the association of AIF with the mitochondrial inner membrane provides a simple explanation for its lack of release upon Bax-mediated outer membrane permeabilization. In cells overexpressing Bax or treated either with the Bax- or Bak-dependent proapoptotic drugs staurosporine or actinomycin D, or with hydrogen peroxide, caspase inhibitors did not affect the intracytosolic translocation of cytochrome c, but prevented that of AIF. These results provide a paradigm for mitochondria-dependent death pathways in which AIF cannot substitute for caspase executioners because its intracytosolic release occurs downstream of that of cytochrome c.     

Inward relocation of exogenous phosphatidylserine triggered by IGF-1 in non-apoptotic C2C12 cells is concentration dependent

The plasma membrane is composed of two leaflets that are asymmetric with regard to their phospholipid composition with phosphatidylserine (PS) predominantly located within the inner leaflet whereas other phospholipids such as phosphatidylcholine (PC) are preferentially located in the outer leaflet. An intimate relationship between cellular physiology and the composition of the plasma membrane has been demonstrated, with for example apoptosis requiring PS exposure for macrophage recognition. In skeletal muscle development, differentiation also requires PS exposure in myoblasts to create cell-cell contact areas allowing the formation of multinucleate myotubes. Although it is clearly established that membrane composition/asymmetry plays an important role in cellular physiology, the role of cytokines in regulating this asymmetry is still unclear. When incubated with myoblasts, insulin-like growth factor I (IGF-1) has been shown to promote proliferation versus differentiation in a concentration dependent manner and therefore, may be a potential candidate regulating cell membrane asymmetry. We show, in non-apoptotic C2C12 cells, that relocation of an exogenous PS analogue, from the outer into the inner leaflet, is accelerated by IGF-1 in a concentration-dependent manner and that maintenance of membrane asymmetry triggered by IGF-1 is however independent of the PI3K inhibitor wortmannin.     

The "pro-apoptotic genies" get out of mitochondria: oxidative lipidomics and redox activity of cytochrome c/cardiolipin complexes

One of the prominent consequences of the symbiogenic origin of eukaryotic cells is the unique presence of one particular class of phospholipids, cardiolipin (CL), in mitochondria. As the product originated from the evolution of symbiotic bacteria, CL is predominantly confined to the inner mitochondrial membrane in normally functioning cells. Recent findings identified CL and its oxidation products as important participants and signaling molecules in the apoptotic cell death program. Early in apoptosis, massive membrane translocations of CL take place resulting in its appearance in the outer mitochondrial membrane. Consequently, significant amounts of CL become available for the interactions with cyt c, one of the major proteins of the intermembrane space. Binding of CL with cytochrome c (cyt c) yields the cyt c/CL complex that acts as a potent CL-specific peroxidase and generates CL hydroperoxides. In this review, we discuss the catalytic mechanisms of CL oxidation by the peroxidase activity of cyt c as well as the role of oxidized CL (CLox) in the release of pro-apoptotic factors from mitochondria into the cytosol. Potential implications of cyt c/CL peroxidase intracellular complexes in disease conditions (cancer, neurodegeneration) are also considered. The discovery of the new role of cyt c/CL complexes in early mitochondrial apoptosis offers interesting opportunities for new targets in drug discovery programs. Finally, exit of cyt c from damaged and/or dying (apoptotic) cells into extracellular compartments and its accumulation in biofluids is discussed in lieu of the formation of its peroxidase complexes with negatively charged lipids and their significance in the development of systemic oxidative stress in circulation.     

Mitochondrial membrane permeabilization: the sine qua non for cell death

Mitochondria are essential for maintaining cell life but they also play a role in regulating cell death, which occurs when their membranes become permeabilized. Mitochondria possess two distinct membrane systems including an outer membrane in close communication with the cytosol and an inner membrane involved in energy transduction. Outer membrane permeabilization is regulated by Bcl-2 family proteins, which control the release of proteins from the mitochondrial intermembrane space; these proteins then activate apoptosis. Inner membrane permeabilization is regulated by the mitochondrial permeability transition (MPT), which is activated by calcium and oxidative stress and leads to bioenergetic failure and necrosis. The purpose of this review is to discuss the biochemical mechanisms regulating mitochondrial membrane permeabilization; this is crucial to our understanding of the role of cell death in diseases such as cancer and the neurodegenerative diseases.     

Sphingomyelin hydrolysis to ceramide during the execution phase of apoptosis results from phospholipid scrambling and alters cell-surface morphology

Apoptosis is generally accompanied by a late phase of ceramide (Cer) production, the significance of which is unknown. This study describes a previously unrecognized link between Cer accumulation and phosphatidylserine (PS) exposure at the cell surface, a characteristic of the execution phase of apoptosis resulting from a loss of plasma membrane phospholipid asymmetry. Using a fluorescent sphingomyelin (SM) analogue, N-(N-[6-[(7-nitrobenz-2-oxa-1, 3-diazol-4-yl)amino]caproyl]-sphingosylphosphorylcholine (C(6)-NBD-SM), we show that Cer is derived from SM, initially located in the outer leaflet of the plasma membrane, which gains access to a cytosolic SMase by flipping to the inner leaflet in a process of lipid scrambling paralleling PS externalization. Lipid scrambling is both necessary and sufficient for SM conversion: Ca(2+) ionophore induces both PS exposure and SM hydrolysis, whereas scrambling-deficient Raji cells do not show PS exposure or Cer formation. Cer is not required for mitochondrial or nuclear apoptotic features since these are still observed in Raji cells. SM hydrolysis facilitates cholesterol efflux to methyl-beta-cyclodextrin, which is indicative of a loss of tight SM-cholesterol interaction in the plasma membrane. We provide evidence that these biophysical alterations in the lipid bilayer are essential for apoptotic membrane blebbing/vesiculation at the cell surface: Raji cells show aberrant apoptotic morphology, whereas replenishment of hydrolyzed SM by C(6)- NBD-SM inhibits blebbing in Jurkat cells. Thus, SM hydrolysis, during the execution phase of apoptosis, results from a loss of phospholipid asymmetry and contributes to structural changes at the plasma membrane.     

Correlated light and electron microscopy illuminates the role of mitochondrial inner membrane remodeling during apoptosis

In addition to their role in providing ATP for cellular functions via oxidative phosphorylation, mitochondria also play a critical role in initiating and/or regulating apoptosis through the release of proteins such as cytochrome c from intermembrane and intracristal compartments. The mechanism by which these proteins are able to cross the outer mitochondrial membrane has been a subject of controversy. This paper will review some recent results that demonstrate that inner mitochondrial membrane remodeling does occur during apoptosis in HeLa cells but does not appear to be a requirement for release of cytochrome c from intracristal compartments. Inner membrane remodeling does appear to be related to fragmentation of the mitochondrial matrix, and the form of the remodeling suggests a topological mechanism for inner membrane fission and fusion.     

Transbilayer lipid diffusion promoted by Bax: implications for apoptosis

It is known that the proapoptotic protein Bax facilitates the formation of pores in bilayers, resulting in the release of proteins from the intermitochondrial space. We demonstrate that another consequence of the interaction of Bax with membranes is an increase in the rate of lipid transbilayer diffusion. We use two independent assays for transbilayer diffusion, one involving the formation of asymmetric liposomes by placing a pyrene-labeled lipid into the outer monolayer of preformed vesicles and another assay based on the initial preparation of liposomes having an asymmetric transbilayer distribution of lipids. With both methods we find that oligomeric BaxDeltaC or full-length Bax in the presence of tBid, but not monomeric full-length Bax, strongly promotes the rate of transbilayer diffusion. Although biological membranes exhibit rates of lipid transbilayer diffusion of minutes or less, they are able to maintain an asymmetric distribution of lipids across the bilayer. In the case of mitochondria, cardiolipin is sequestered on the inner leaflet of the inner mitochondrial membrane. However, during apoptosis this lipid translocates to the outer surface of the outer mitochondrial membrane. This phenomenon must involve an increase in the rate of transbilayer diffusion. The results of the present paper demonstrate that an activated form of Bax can cause this increased rate.     

Cardiolipin and Its Different Properties in Mitophagy and Apoptosis

Cardiolipin (CL) is a unique dimeric phospholipid that exists almost exclusively in the inner mitochondrial membrane (IMM) in eukaryotic cells. Two chiral carbons and four fatty acyl chains in CL result in a flexible body allowing interactions with respiratory chain complexes and mitochondrial substrate carriers. Due to its high content of unsaturated fatty acids, CL is particularly prone to reactive oxygen species (ROS)-induced oxidative attacks. Under mild mitochondrial damage, CL is redistributed to the outer mitochondrial membrane (OMM) and serves as a recognition signal for dysfunctional mitochondria, which are rapidly sequestered by autophagosomes. However, peroxidation of CL is far greater in response to severe stress than under normal or mild-damage conditions. The accumulation of oxidized CL on the OMM results in recruitment of Bax and formation of the mitochondrial permeability transition pore (MPTP), which releases Cytochrome c (Cyt c) from mitochondria. Over the past decade, the significance of CL in the function of mitochondrial bioenergy has been explored. Moreover, approaches to analyzing CL have become more effective and accurate. In this review, we discuss the unique structural features of CL as well as the current understanding of CL-based molecular mechanisms of mitophagy and apoptosis.     

Insight into mitochondrial structure and function from electron tomography

In recent years, electron tomography has provided detailed three-dimensional models of mitochondria that have redefined our concept of mitochondrial structure. The models reveal an inner membrane consisting of two components, the inner boundary membrane (IBM) closely apposed to the outer membrane and the cristae membrane that projects into the matrix compartment. These two components are connected by tubular structures of relatively uniform size called crista junctions. The distribution of crista junction sizes and shapes is predicted by a thermodynamic model based upon the energy of membrane bending, but proteins likely also play a role in determining the conformation of the inner membrane. Results of structural studies of mitochondria during apoptosis demonstrate that cytochrome c is released without detectable disruption of the outer membrane or extensive swelling of the mitochondrial matrix, suggesting the formation of an outer membrane pore large enough to allow passage of holo-cytochrome c. The possible compartmentation of inner membrane function between the IBM and the cristae membrane is also discussed.     

Caspase-independent phosphatidylserine exposure during apoptosis of primary T lymphocytes

Exposure of phosphatidylserine (PS) on the outer leaflet of the plasma membrane is a key feature of apoptosis. As the signals underlying these phenomena are unknown, it is generally assumed that PS exposure is a consequence of caspase activation, another hallmark of apoptosis. In this study we investigated the role of caspases in PS externalization during apoptosis of activated PBL triggered by drugs (etoposide, staurosporine), CD95 engagement, or IL-2 withdrawal. Anti-CD95 mAb induces a rapid activation of caspases, followed by PS exposure and mitochondrial transmembrane potential (DeltaPsim) disruption. In contrast, etoposide (ETO), staurosporine (STS), or IL-2 withdrawal triggers concomitant caspase activation, PS exposure, and DeltaPsim disruption. Such kinetics suggest that PS exposure could be independent of caspase activation. As expected, in activated PBL treated by anti-CD95 mAb, the pan-caspase inhibitor Cbz-Val-Ala-Asp(OMe)-fluoromethylketone and the caspase-8 inhibitor Cbz-Leu-Glu-Thr-Asp(OMe)-fluoromethylketone, but not the caspase-9 inhibitor Cbz-Leu-Glu-His-Asp(OMe)-fluoromethylketone, inhibit PS externalization and DeltaPsim disruption. Surprisingly, during apoptosis induced by ETO, STS, or IL-2 withdrawal, none of those caspase inhibitors prevents PS externalization or DeltaPsim disruption, whereas they all inhibit DNA fragmentation as well as the morphological features of nuclear apoptosis. In Jurkat and H9 T cell lines, as opposed to activated PBL, PS exposure is inhibited by Cbz-Val-Ala-Asp(OMe)-fluoromethylketone during apoptosis induced by CD95 engagement, ETO, or STS. Thus, caspase-independent PS exposure occurs in primary T cells during apoptosis induced by stimuli that do not trigger death receptors.