Cellular Interrelationships during in vitro Granulopoiesis

Long-term production of fully differentiated granulocytes can be maintained in vitro in a liquid system of cultured bone marrow. Marrow is cultured in medical flasks and allowed to form an adherent layer over a three-week period, and then recharged with fresh marrow resulting in continued mature granulocyte production for several months.
During the initial establishment of the adherent layer, three attached populations become apparent: phagocytic monocytes, an attached epithelial cell type, and aggregations of epithelial cells swollen to enormous proportions by the presence of numerous lipid-containing vacuoles. Without the formation of these aggregations, granulocyte production is not maintained beyond an initial period and the culture converts to phagocytic mononuclear cell production alone. Thus not only is the presence of the fat-containing aggregations necessary for continued granulopoiesis, but cultures in full granulocyte production show a characteristic clumping of granulocytes around these aggregates. Electron microscopy has shown that the epithelial cells from the adherent layer form a layer covering some of the attached cells in these areas and thus may provide the necessary in vitro microenvironment for granulopoiesis to occur. Pinocytotic vesicles and gap junctions have been observed between the adjacent membranes of the undifferentiated granulocytes (possibly stem cells) and the epithelial cells themselves.     

An in vitro clonal assay of adherent stem cells (ASC) in mouse marrow

Hematopoietic stem cells with high proliferative capacity can be assayed when stromal bone marrow cultures are overlaid with limiting dilutions of marrow samples. This leads to hematopoietic growth after 4 weeks in a fraction of cultures, consistent with expectations based on Poisson statistics. It will be shown that monoclonal cultures are obtained that last from 2 to 15 weeks and that can generate up to several million mature granulocytes. The originating clone-forming cell is named adherent stem cell (ASC) because of its adherence to plastic or stromal surfaces. The ASC is comparable to the CFU-S in frequency, proliferative capacity and in its ability to give rise to CFU-S. As an unexpected additional finding we report that a mode of "clonal succession" was apparent in cultures which expressed more than one clone.     

REGULATION OF BONE MARROW CELL GROWTH IN DIFFUSION CHAMBERS: THE EFFECT OF GRANULOCYTE EXTRACTS

Hypotonic lysis of mature human blood granulocytes yielded an extract which reduced granulopoiesis and enhanced macrophage formation of mouse bone marrow cells cultured for 7 days in diffusion chambers (DC). The low molecular weight fraction (MW < 15,000–25,000 Daltons) obtained by Amicon filtration of the extract, reduced granulopoiesis without affecting macrophage formation. The high molecular weight fraction (MW > 15,000–25,000 Daltons) reduced the number of granulocytes and increased the number macrophages. Erythrocyte extract increased the macrophage formation in DC but did not alter the number of granulocytes. The spleen colony assay showed that the granulocyte extract increased the number of CFU-S in DC. It is suggested that the granulocyte extract contain an inhibitor of stem cell differentiation to myeloid cells thereby reducing the number of proliferative granulocytes in DC 7 days later. The inhibitor of differentiation may lead to an increased self renewal of the stem cell in the DC system.     

Ultrastructural Aspects of Erythropoietic Differentiation in Long-term Bone Marrow Culture

Long-term liquid cultures of mouse bone marrow produce stem cells (CFU-S) and differentiated granulocytes for many months. Addition of AMS (anaemic mouse serum) to the cultures almost entirely eliminates the granulopoietic activity and stimulates erythropoiesis, with full erythroid maturation and the production of adult haemoglobin. Ultrastructural analsysis of in situ fixed material reveals the cell shape and surface morphology of the erythroid maturation series, and the generation of erythroblastic islands in vitro. Each erythroblastic island consists of one or more synchronously maturing cohorts of erythroid cells undergoing four or five divisions between proerythroblast and normoblast. Each island is centered on a macrophage, which interacts with the developing erythroid population in several ways. Expelled nuclei are phagocytosed by the macrophage, which also has large areas of closely apposed membrane with the erythroid cells, gap junctions, and possible reciprocal vesicular activity. Changes in the adherent layer (stromal cells) also occur with the transition from granulopoiesis to erythropoiesis. There is a reduction in the endothelial cell cover, and mobilisation of lipid from the granulopoietic associated apidocytes.     

In vitro hemopoiesis within a microenvironment created by MC3T3-G2/PA6 preadipocytes

The clonal preadipose cell line, MC3T3-G2/PA6, has the capacity to differentiate into adipocytes in response to glucocorticoids and to support in vitro growth of hemopoietic stem cells (CFU-S). To study the relationship between these capacities, we precultured the MC3T3-G2/PA6 cells for varying days in the presence or absence of dexamethasone and then cocultured them with mouse bone marrow cells. Logarithmically growing cultures contained no detectable adipocytes and showed the highest growth-supporting activity for CFU-S, whereas cultures containing the largest number of adipocytes showed the lowest activity. When bone marrow cells were seeded onto 3-day-old MC3T3-G2/PA6 preadipocyte layers at 1 X 10(5) cells/35-mm dish, day 12 CFU-S grew with a population doubling time of about 37 hr, and at least 75% of them were associated with the cell layer between days 2 and 7. In the absence of the preadipocytes, CFU-S were not detected in the adherent cell fraction and decreased with a half-life of about 18 hr. More than 80% of CFU-C were also found to be associated with the preadipocyte layer, and they increased about 24-fold in number during 7 days in culture. Morphologically, hemopoietic cells developing into mature granulocytes and macrophages were distributed between the layers of preadipocytes. Dendritic processes of preadipocytes were frequently in close alignment with the hemopoietic cells. However, adipocytes failed to show such an intimate association with hemopoietic cells. These results indicate that MC3T3-G2/PA6 cells in the preadipocyte stage, but not in the adipocyte stage, have the capacity to support CFU-S growth, and that hemopoiesis in our cocultivation system proceed within the microenvironmental milieu provided by MC3T3-G2/PA6 preadipocytes.     

The kinetics of hematopoietic stem cells during and after hypoxia. A model analysis

A previously described mathematical model of the hematopoietic stem cell system has been extended to permit a detailed understanding of the data during and after hypoxia. The model includes stem cells, erythroid and granuloid progenitors and precursors. Concerning the intramedullary feedback mechanisms two basic assumptions are made: 1) The fraction "a" of CFU-S in active cell cycle is regulated. Reduced cell densities of CFU-S, progenitors or precursors lead to an accelerated stem cell cycling. Enlarged cell densities suppress cycling. 2) The self renewal probability "p" of CFU-S is also regulated. The normal steady state is described by p = 0.5, indicating that on statistical average each dividing mother stem cell is replaced by one daughter stem cell, while the second differentiates. Diminished cell densities of CFU-S or enlarged densities of progenitors and precursors induce a more intensive self renewal (p greater than 0.5), such that the stem cell number increases. The self renewal probability declines (p less than 0.5) if too many CFU-S or too few progenitors and precursors are present. The model reproduces bone marrow data for CFU-S, BFU-E, CFU-C, CFU-E, 59 Fe-uptake and nucleated cells in hypoxia and posthypoxia. Although the ratio of differentiation into the erythroid and granuloid cell lines is kept constant in the model, a changing ratio of CFU-E and CFU-C results. The model suggests that stem cells and progenitor cells are regulated by a regulatory interference of erythropoiesis and granulopoiesis.     

Effect of src infection on long-term marrow cultures: increased self-renewal of hemopoietic progenitor cells without leukemia

Long-term marrow cultures prepared from mice have been infected with a molecular recombinant of Rous sarcoma virus and murine amphitropic leukemia virus. This resulted in introduction of the src gene into the cultured cells and expression of its protein kinase function. The infected cultures displayed an altered balance in the accumulation of cells in different compartments of granulocyte differentiation. There was a dramatic increase in the stem cell (CFU-S) compartment and the committed progenitor cell (GM-CFC) compartment and a decrease in mature granulocytes. The altered balance appears to be caused by intrinsic alterations in the CFU-S and GM-CFC themselves, which increase their "self-renewal" capacity at the expense of cell differentiation. Remarkably, unlike its effects in other systems, src did not produce a neoplastic transformation of the hemopoietic cells.     

Infection of bone marrow cells in vitro with FLV: Effects on stem cell proliferation,differentiation and leukemogenic capacity

Long-term cultures of proliferating hematopoietic stem cells derived from bone marrow permit the study of the interaction between murine leukemia virus (MuLV) infection and the proliferation and differentiation of stem cells. We have used this system to analyze the replication of different biological variants of MuLV in bone marrow cells; the effect of MuLV infection upon pluripotent stem cell (CFU-S) proliferation; and the effect of MuLV on differentiation of CFU-S along different hematopoietic pathways. Two MuLV variants were studied in detail: the Moloney strain of lymphatic leukemia virus (Mol-MuLV) and the erythroleukemic Friend virus complex (FLV) consisting of the lymphoid leukemia helper virus and the defective spleen focus-forming virus (SFFV). Mol-MuLV and its sarcoma virus pseudotype, MSV(Mol-MuLV), replicate efficiently in the bone marrow cultures; however, CFU-S are lost more readily than in uninfected cultures, and the cultures are soon represented by a majority population of mononuclear macrophages. On the other hand, infection with FLV produces a prolonged survival of the spleen colony-forming cells, CFU-S, and CFU-C (the committed granulocytic precursor cells). Production of erythroleukemogenic SFFV is maintained in these cultures for more than 40 weeks. No erythroblastic differentiation was observed in vitro, however, neither erythroblast precursor cells (CFU-E) nor hemoglobin-producing cells could be detected. This suggests that the target cell for FLV is an earlier precursor cell.     

Regulation of haemopoiesis in long-term bone marrow cultures. IV. Glycosaminoglycan synthesis and the stimulation of haemopoiesis by beta- D-xylosides

Sulfated glycosaminoglycans (GAGs) are distributed in consistent and distinctive patterns between the cell surface and the growth medium of haemopoietically active long-term bone marrow cultures. Heparan sulfate is the main cell surface component and chondroitin sulfate is the major sulfated species in the medium. When the cultures are supplemented with beta-D-xylosides a significant increase in chondroitin sulfate synthesis is observed but no stimulation of heparan sulfate synthesis occurs. The chondroitin sulfate accumulates in the culture medium in beta-D-xyloside-treated cultures but the composition of sulfated GAGs in cell-surface derived material is unaffected. beta-D-xylosides also stimulate the production of haemopoietic cells without any apparent alteration in the adherent stromal cells of the marrow cultures. Equivalent increases are obtained in cells at all stages of development so that a fivefold increase in pluripotent stem cells (CFU-S) is matched by fivefold increase in the granulocyte-macrophage progenitors (GM-CFC) and in mature granulocytes. The stimulation persists for many weeks in beta-D-xyloside-treated cultures. These results indicate that the sulfated GAGs may play an important role in the regulation of haemopoiesis.     

Modulation of myelopoiesis by different bacterial cell-wall components: induction of colony-stimulating activity (by pure preparations, low-molecular-weight degradation products, and a synthetic low-molecular analog of bacterial cell-wall components) in vitro.

Chemically pure preparations of three structurally unrelated components of the cell wall of gram-negative bacteria (BCWC), lipid A, outer-membrane lipoprotein, and murein, were tested for lymphocyte mitogenicity and the ability to induce colony-stimulating activity (CSA) in various serum-free tissue-culture systems. All three components were B-cell mitogens and induced CSA in spleen-cell cultures. However, in lymphnode-cell cultures the concentrations of these agents required for either mitogenicity or CSA induction differed markedly. Moreover, in contrast to thymidine incorporation, CSA induction was not influenced by pre-irradiation of the cells. Conversely, after removal of phagocytic cells with the iron-magnet technique, CSA was no longer inducible by BCWC, while lymphocyte proliferation was barely impaired. All three BCWC readily induced CSA release in cultures of adherent peritoneal cells without influencing the release of a cytoplasmic enzyme. BCWC-dependent CSA release from adherent peritoneal cells was not influenced by pretratment of the cultures with anti-immunoglobulin, but completely suppressed by preincubation with anti-macrophage-1.2 alloantiserum and complement. CSA induction in macrophage cultures was also achieved with a low-molecular-weight synthetic muramyldipeptide and degradation products of lipoprotein. The results suggest that the induction of CSA is not directly related to the mitogenic, immunogenic, or antigenic properties of the BCWC, but that BCWC-mediated CSA production is caused by a direct “hormone-like” interaction of the agents with mature macrophages.     

Residual radiation injury exhibited in long-term bone marrow cultures

Residual radiation injury was demonstrated in long-term primary cultures of mouse bone marrow. Control cultures underwent three phases of hematopoietic activity as distinguished by initial establishment, steady high (plateau) production of granulocytes, and gradual decline. Irradiation with 50, 300, or 550 rads, given at the end of the initial phase, did not prevent any culture flasks from entering the plateau phase. However, actual production levels and the time they were maintained varied inversely with the radiation dose so that the accumulated postradiation cell production corresponded to an exponential dose-response relationship at any time after treatment. The accumulated cell productions were found to be similar in all groups when expressed by the number of stem cell doublings necessary to produce them. The findings cannot be explained by reproductive cell death and are consistent with the notion of a limited division capacity in hematopoietic stem cells.     

A stochastic model of self-renewal and commitment to differentiation of the primitive hemopoietic stem cells in culture

We recently identified a murine hemopoietic stem cell colony which consists of undifferentiated (blast) cells and appears to be more primitive than CFU-GEMM in the stem cell hierarchy. The progenitors for the colony which we termed “stem cell colony” possess an extensive self-renewal capacity and the ability to generate many secondary multipotential hemopoietic colonies in culture. We replated a total of 68 stem cell colonies from cultures of murine spleen cells and analyzed the number of stem cell–and granulocyte(neutrophil)-erythrocyte-macrophage-megakaryocyte (GEMM) colony-forming cells in individual stem cell colonies. Of the 68 stem cell colonies, 35 contained progenitors (abbreviated as “S”-cells) for stem cell colonies. The distributions of S-cells and CFU-GEMM in individual stem cell colonies were extremely heterogeneous. Neither the frequency distributions of S-cells nor CFU-GEMM in stem cell colonies could be fitted well by Poisson distribution. Rather, the frequency distribution of the s-cells could be approximated by a geometric distribution and that of CFU-GEMM by an exponential distribution, both of which are variates of the gamma distribution. Our observations are in agreement with those on the distributions of CFU-S in individual spleen colonies and provided support for a stochastic model for stem cell self-renewal and commitment in culture. Application of the theory of the branching process to the distribution of S-cells revealed a distributional parameter “p” of 0.589 which is also in agreement with the earlier report on the p value for reproduction of CFU-S.     

Influence of a fibroblastoid cell line derived from murine bone marrow (H-1 cells) on stem cell proliferation

A murine fibroblastoid cell line (H-1) with properties similar to those of adventitial reticular cells can support granulopoiesis and the development of mononuclear phagocytes in vitro. In the current study the effect of these cells on stem cell maintenance in vitro was assessed. The H-1 cells were unable to support CFUs replication in liquid culture, while treatment of some stem cells with H-1 conditioned medium appeared to inhibit their proliferation.     

Novel peripheral blood-derived human cell lines with properties of megakaryocytes

For 18 mo, we derived 18 cell lines from 11 donors with various clinical profiles ranging from normal to leukemic. Suspension cultures were initiated with 1 X 10(6) mononuclear blood cells/ml of nutrient medium containing 10% human serum and 10% lectin-stimulated human lymphocyte conditioned medium. The cultures were monitored weekly by morphological analyses of Wright-Giemsa-stained cell preparations. All successful cultures showed a significant decline in viability during the first 3-4 wk with rate "lymphoid" cells observed in mitosis. Within the next 2 wk, the proliferating cells gave rise to a rapidly expanding population of mononuclear cells. As the cultures expanded, cell morphology became heterogeneous with respect to cell size and nuclear ploidy, with an accumulation of giant multinuclear cells that were suggestive of megakarocytes. Even though the cells did not have the classical morphology of mature platelet-forming megakaryocytes, 90% of the cells within a cell line were positive by direct or indirect immunofluorescence for the platelet membrane glycoproteins IIb and IIIa; for surface markers HLA-Dr and B2-microglobulin; for intracellular platelet-derived growth factor and platelet factor IV; and for membrane affinity or binding with serum platelet-derived growth factor and platelet factor IV. These results suggest that a blood precursor cell, most likely a primitive megakaryoblast, was isolated from the peripheral blood and was provided with an optimal culture environment for sustained growth. These cells did not mature to a more differentiated stage, perhaps owing to regulatory factor deficiencies in this in vitro system. The remarkable frequency of obtaining cell lines with megakaryocyte properties from normal peripheral blood and the capacity of some normal donors to repeatedly yield these cell lines make this cell culture system indeed unique by being selective for putative megakaryocyte precursors.     

Immunohistochemical and ultrastructural evidence for myelopoiesis in the scid/scid mouse thymus

The ultrastructure of scid mouse thymus (a small encapsulated epithelial mass within the precardial fat pad) is described. The epithelium did not form cortex or medulla and hence remained relatively undifferentiated. Small unmyelinated nerves innervated the capsule, the major blood vessels and were distributed between the epithelial cells. Fenestrated blood vessels were common. Thymocytes were not identified but numeous granulocytes, mast cells and some fibroblasts, macrophages and interdigitating cells were present. All stages of granulopoiesis were observed in scid thymus. A very small number of immunoreactive ER-MP58 cells indicated bone marrow derived myeloid precursor cells, and low numbers of ER-MP12⁺ and ER-MP20⁺ mononuclear cells indicated stages of myeloid cells committed to the granulocyte/macrophage lineage. Cells containing proliferating nuclear cell antigen (cells in G1, S and G2-M stage) were present throughout the thymic mass. BALB/c thymuses contained cortical foci of p53⁺ cells whereas in scid mice, p53 positive cells were scattered singly throughout the thymus. This study indicates that the presence of moderately extensive myelopoiesis within the scid mouse thymus has potential for the study of extramedullary hematopoiesis, and also is important to bear this function in mind when using the scid mouse as an immunological model for thymus reconstitution and for creating organoid cultures.     

Induction of splenic granulopoiesis in vitro.

Murine spleen cells were cultured in vitro to study the induction of committed granulopoietic stem cell (CFU-C) proliferation and maturation. Marbrook-type diffusion cultures were established with and without the addition of colony-stimulating activity (CSA) and harvested at intervals up to 14 days for viable and differential cell counts, [3H]TdR autoradiography, and quantitation of CFU-C by the agar plate method. Without CSA there was poor cell viability and little proliferative capacity. In CSA-stimulated cultures there was a prominent rise in viable cell counts and [3H]TdR labeling indices rose from a mean of 2% at 0 time to 47% after 5 days in vitro. CFU-C increased by 70-fold in these cultures. Peak numbers of CFU-C, immature cells, and [3H]TdR-labeled cells occurred at about 7 days. Thereafter, mature granulocytes and macrophages predominated in culture. Because the liquid spleen cell culture system begins in a resting state and undergoes a wave of proliferative activity in response to CSA, it can provide a useful model system for studying phenomena associated with stem cell activation and differentiation in vitro.     

Multi-lineage potential of human mesenchymal stem cells following clonal expansion

Bone marrow contains mesenchymal cells that can be isolated and grown in vitro. Using appropriate treatment protocols such cultures can be induced to differentiate to yield osteoblasts, adipocytes, and chondrocytes. However, previous experiments had not addressed the question whether single pluripotent stem cells exist and can give rise to these different cell lineages or whether bone marrow mesenchymal cell preparations represent a mixture of committed precursors. We have used human adult bone marrow-derived mesenchymal cells obtained from iliac crest biopsies to demonstrate clonal outgrowth after limiting dilution and we show that some clones can be expanded over more than 20 cumulative population doublings and differentiated to osteoblasts, adipocytes, and chondrocytes. Our data provide direct experimental evidence that cultures of bone marrow-derived mesenchymal cells contain individual cells that fulfil two essential stem cell criteria: (i) extensive self-renewal capacity and (ii) multi-lineage potential.     

OKT3 monoclonal antibody induces production of colony-stimulating factor(s) for granulocytes and macrophages in cultures of human T lymphocytes and adherent cells

OKT3 monoclonal antibody (mab) recognizes a membrane antigen associated with the T cell antigen recognition receptor, and is known to be mitogenic and to induce lymphokine production. Our studies demonstrate the ability of OKT3 mab to induce from cultures of human T lymphocytes supplemented with adherent cells the production of colony-stimulating factor(s) for granulocytes and macrophages (GM-CSF) and interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma), an inhibitor of clonal growth of hematopoietic progenitor cells. As has been shown for the mitogenic and IFN-gamma-inducing activity of OKT3 mab, the induction of GM-CSF release in cultures of T cells is strictly dependent on the presence of adherent cells. However, the concentrations of OKT3 mab required for optimal GM-CSF production (50 ng/ml) were found to be 80-fold higher than those sufficient for maximal IFN-gamma production, proliferation, and interleukin 2 production. IFN-gamma activity induced by OKT3 mab partially inhibited colony and cluster formation from progenitor cells of granulocytes and macrophages in vitro. Therefore, neutralization of the IFN-gamma by monoclonal anti-human-IFN-gamma antibody before assay of conditioned medium in bone marrow cultures significantly enhanced the detection of GM-CSF. Kinetic studies demonstrated maximal cumulative GM-CSF production in response to optimal OKT3 mab concentrations on days 4 through 6 in cultures of T cells supplemented with 15% adherent cells. Highly enriched OKT4+ and OKT8+ T cell subsets co-cultured with adherent cells in the presence of OKT3 mab both produced GM-CSF and IFN-gamma and showed similar dose-response curves to OKT3 mab. The requirement for the presence of adherent cells could not be overcome by the addition of purified interleukin 1 or macrophage supernatants. Studies using irreversible inhibitors of DNA (mitomycin C) or protein biosynthesis (emetine-HCl) revealed the necessity of intact DNA synthesis and translation in mononuclear cells to produce GM-CSF in response to OKT3 mab. Loss of GM-CSF production was observed when either adherent cells or T lymphocytes were treated with emetine before co-culture with untreated cells of the other population in the presence of OKT3 mab. In contrast, mitomycin C reduced GM-CSF production significantly when T cells, but not adherent cells, were pretreated. These results suggest that T lymphocytes and adherent cells closely cooperate in the production of GM-CSF induced by OKT3 mab.     

Limitation of macrophage production in long-term marrow cultures containing prostaglandin E

Addition of prostaglandin E₂ (PGE₂) significantly altered the cellular composition of murine long-term bone marrow cultures. After 4–5 weeks of culture, increased cellularity in the suspension phase was observed in all cultures containing prostaglandin. These suspension cells contained markedly higher proportions of differentiated neutrophils than did cells cultured in the absence of PGE₂. Granulocyte-macrophage progenitor cell levels in the suspension layer were increased 3–20 fold after five weeks in prostaglandin-containing cultures compared with control cultures. Fewer cells comprised the adherent layer in cultures containing prostaglandin. The number of macrophages in this layer was reduced 3–8 fold in these cultures compared with control cultures, while the number of granulocytes was increased 2–3 fold. The progenitor cells biased toward macrophage development were selectively inhibited in the cultures with PGE₂. There was no significant effect of PGE₂ on pluripotent stem cell levels or on the longevity of the cultures. It is concluded that excessive monopoiesis in bone marrow may be limited by PGE₂ without influencing either stem cell maintenance or the development of other marrow-derived cell types.     

Pre-irradiation of tissue culture flasks leads to diminished stem and progenitor cell production in long-term bone marrow cultures

Abstract. Empty plastic tissue culture flasks were exposed to X-irradiation doses of 0.3–10.0 Gy, prior to the establishment of long-term bone marrow cultures. During the course of a 10 week culture period, all irradiated plastic flasks exhibited a dramatic decrease in the number of both haemopoietic stem cells and myeloid progenitor cells, in the non-adherent layer, when compared with controls. This decrease was not due to a decrease in the number of non-adherent cells produced. Histological examination of non-adherent cells showed an increase in mature granulocytic cells with few blast cells. Morphologically, the adherent layers of irradiated flasks demonstrated a delay in appearance or absence of fat cell production. X-irradiation of glass tissue culture flasks had no deleterious effect.