Crucial Role for BAFF-BAFF-R Signaling in the Survival and Maintenance of Mature B Cells

Defects in the expression of either BAFF (B cell activating factor) or BAFF-R impairs B cell development beyond the immature, transitional type-1 stage and thus, prevents the formation of follicular and marginal zone B cells, whereas B-1 B cells remain unaffected. The expression of BAFF-R on all mature B cells might suggest a role for BAFF-R signaling also for their in vivo maintenance. Here, we show that, 14 days following a single injection of an anti-BAFF-R mAb that prevents BAFF binding, both follicular and marginal zone B cell numbers are drastically reduced, whereas B-1 cells are not affected. Injection of control, isotype-matched but non-blocking anti-BAFF-R mAbs does not result in B cell depletion. We also show that this depletion is neither due to antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity nor to complement-mediated lysis. Moreover, prevention of BAFF binding leads to a decrease in the size of the B cell follicles, an impairment of a T cell dependent humoral immune response and a reduction in the formation of memory B cells. Collectively, these results establish a central role for BAFF-BAFF-R signaling in the in vivo survival and maintenance of both follicular and marginal zone B cell pools.     

Transgenic expression of a human polyreactive Ig expressed in chronic lymphocytic leukemia generates memory-type B cells that respond to nonspecific immune activation

We generated transgenic mice, designated SMI, expressing unmutated H and L chain Ig genes encoding a low-affinity, polyreactive human (h)IgM/kappa rheumatoid factor. These animals were compared with control AB29 transgenic mice expressing a hIgM/kappa rheumatoid factor specific for human IgG, with no detectable reactivity with mouse proteins. SMI B cells expressed significantly lower levels of surface hIgM/kappa than did the B cells of AB29 mice, but still could be induced to proliferate by surface Ig cross-linking in vitro and could be deleted with anti-Id mAb in vivo. Transgene-expressing B cells of AB29 mice had a B-2 phenotype and were located in the primary follicle. In contrast, a relatively high proportion of hIgM-expressing B cells of SMI mice had the phenotype of B-1 B cells in the peritoneum or marginal zone B cells in the spleen, where they were located in the periarteriolar sheath, marginal zone, and interfollicular areas that typically are populated by memory-type B cells. Although the relative proportions of transgene-expressing B cells in both types of transgenic mice declined with aging, SMI mice experienced progressive increases in the serum levels of IgM transgene protein over time. Finally, SMI transgene-expressing B cells, but not AB29 transgene-expressing B cells, were induced to secrete Ab when cultured with alloreactive T cells. These results indicate that expression of polyreactive autoantibodies can allow for development of B cells that are neither deleted nor rendered anergic, but instead have a phenotype of memory-type or Ag-experienced B cells that respond to nonspecific immune activation.     

Impaired clearance of apoptotic cells induces the activation of autoreactive anti-Sm marginal zone and B-1 B cells

Since apoptotic cell Ags are thought to be a source of self-Ag in systemic lupus erythematosus, we have examined the role of apoptotic cells in the regulation and activation of B cells specific for Sm, a ribonucleoprotein targeted in human and murine lupus. Using Ig-transgenic mice that have a high frequency of anti-Sm B cells, we find that apoptotic cell injection induces a transient splenic B cell response, while simultaneously causing extensive splenic and peritoneal anti-Sm B cell death. In contrast, mice deficient in the clearance of apoptotic cells develop a chronic anti-Sm response beginning at 1-2 mo of age. These mice have expanded marginal zone and B-1 B cell populations and anti-Sm B cells of both types are activated to form Ab-secreting cells. This activation appears to be Ag-specific, suggesting that activation is due to increased availability of apoptotic cell Ags. Since marginal zone and B-1 cells are positively selected, these data suggest a loss of ignorance rather than a loss of tolerance.     

Influence of lymphocytes on the presence and organization of dendritic cell subsets in the spleen.

Studies were undertaken to clarify the roles of individual leukocyte populations in maintaining the presence and organization of splenic dendritic cells (DCs). Using Abs specific for DC subsets, we found that the distinct types of DC maintained appropriate compartmentalization within the white pulp of lymphocyte-deficient mice despite an unusual overall distribution of DCs. Even in mice lacking both B and T lymphocytes, the central arteriole remained the structure around which T area DCs were organized. Marginal zone area DCs remained in a peripheral sheath excluded from the T area DCs. Additionally, we revealed an important role for splenic B cells in the presence and organization of marginal zone cells. B-deficient or B- and T-deficient mice lacked sialoadhesin+ marginal zone macrophages and lacked MAdCAM-1 expression in marginal zone reticular endothelial cells. Adoptive transfer of B lymphocytes induced MAdCAM-1 expression but failed to recruit marginal zone macrophages. Taken together, our results demonstrate that the arrival, localization, and persistence of DCs in spleen are events not solely dependent upon signals from the mature B and T cells or marginal zone macrophages. We suggest that specific stromal elements in the vicinity of the central arteriole are primarily responsible for providing directional cues to the DC.     

Recirculating and marginal zone B cell populations can be established and maintained independently of primary and secondary follicles

In normal spleen, most recirculating na?ve IgM+IgDhi B cells are located within primary follicles and mantle zones of secondary follicles. By contrast, the marginal zone contains a heterogeneous population of IgMhiIgDlo/- B cells that are mostly non-recirculating. Although these are dynamic populations they are maintained at a constant size, the fundamental homeostatic mechanisms remain uncertain. One possibility is that the presence and turnover of each of the B cell populations is dependent on their location within discrete splenic compartments. To investigate this, we have characterized immature, non-recirculating, mature recirculating, marginal zone and B-1 cell populations in TNF-/- and TNF/lymphotoxin(LT)-alpha-/- mice that have disorganized splenic architecture. Labelling with 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine revealed that turnover of B cells in TNF-/- mice is normal, but is diminished in TNF/LT-alpha-/- mice. The recirculating B cell populations in both mutant strains are normal in proportion and phenotype. Marginal zone B cells are not seen in TNF/LT-alpha-/- mice, but this population appears normal in TNF-/- mice, even though they lack germinal centres. These findings indicate that peripheral B cell subsets can be established and maintained independently of normal follicular architecture.     

TLR stimulation modifies BLyS receptor expression in follicular and marginal zone B cells

Through their differential interactions with B lymphocyte stimulator (BLyS) and a proliferation-inducing ligand (APRIL), the three BLyS family receptors play central roles in B cell survival and differentiation. Recent evidence indicates BLyS receptor levels shift following BCR ligation, suggesting that activation cues can alter overall BLyS receptor profiles and thus ligand sensitivity. In this study, we show that TLR stimuli also alter BLyS receptor expression, but in contrast to BCR ligation, TLR9 and TLR4 signals, preferentially increase transmembrane activator calcium modulator and cyclophilin ligand interactor (TACI) expression. Although both of these TLRs act through MyD88-dependent mechanisms to increase TACI expression, they differ in terms of their downstream mediators and the B cell subset affected. Surprisingly, only TLR4 relies on c-Rel and p50 to augment TACI expression, whereas TLR9 does not. Furthermore, although all follicular and marginal zone B cells up-regulate TACI in response to TLR9 stimulation, only marginal zone B cells and a subset of follicular B cells respond to TLR4. Finally, we find that both BLyS and APRIL enhance viability among quiescent and BCR-stimulated B cells. However, although BLyS enhances viability among TLR stimulated B cells, APRIL does not, suggesting that TACI but not BLyS receptor 3 may share survival promoting pathways with TLRs.     

A catalytically inactive form of protein kinase C-associated kinase/receptor interacting protein 4, a protein kinase C beta-associated kinase that mediates NF-kappa B activation,interferes with early B cell development

Protein kinase C-associated kinase (PKK)/receptor interacting protein 4 (RIP4) is a protein kinase C (PKC) beta-associated kinase that links PKC to NF-kappaB activation. The kinase domain of PKK is similar to that of RIP, RIP2, and RIP3. We show in this study that PKK is expressed early during lymphocyte development and can be detected in common lymphoid progenitor cells. Targeting of a catalytically inactive version of PKK to lymphoid cells resulted in a marked impairment in pro-B cell generation in the bone marrow. Although peripheral B cell numbers were markedly reduced, differentiation into follicular and marginal zone B cells was not defective in these mice. B-1a and B-1b B cells could not be detected in these mice, but this might be a reflection of the overall defect in B cell production observed in these animals. In keeping with a possible link to PKCbeta, peripheral B cells in these mice exhibit a defect in anti-IgM-mediated proliferation. These studies suggest that PKK may be required early in B cell development and for BCR-mediated B cell proliferation.     

IgMhighCD21high lymphocytes enriched in the splenic marginal zone generate effector cells more rapidly than the bulk of follicular B cells.

Ag encounter will recruit Ag-specific cells from the pool of mature B lymphocytes in the spleen and activate them to perform effector functions: generation of Ab-forming cells (plasma cells) and presentation of Ag to T cells. We have compared the ability of mature follicular and marginal zone cells to develop into effector B cells. The generation of marginal zone B cells and their localization in the marginal sinus area are T cell and CD40 ligand independent, suggesting that they do not represent a postgerminal center population. Compared with mature recirculating follicular B cells, they express several characteristics of previous antigenic experience, including higher levels of B7.1 (CD80) and B7.2 (CD86) when freshly isolated and following in vitro stimulation. After a brief 6- to 8-h in vitro stimulation with LPS or anti-CD40 Abs, marginal zone B cells become potent APCs. In addition, their ability to proliferate and differentiate into plasma cells in response to low doses of T-independent polyclonal stimuli (LPS) is far greater than that of follicular B cells. These findings indicate a functional heterogeneity within splenic mature B lymphocytes, with marginal zone B cells having the capacity to generate effector cells in early stages of the immune response against particulate Ags scavenged efficiently in this special anatomical site.     

Negative selection by IgM superantigen defines a B cell central tolerance compartment and reveals mutations allowing escape

To analyze B lymphocyte central tolerance in a polyclonal immune system, mice were engineered to express a superantigen reactive to IgM of allotype b (IgM(b)). IgM(b/b) mice carrying superantigen were severely B cell lymphopenic, but small numbers of B cells matured. Their sera contained low levels of IgG and occasionally high levels of IgA. In bone marrow, immature B cells were normal in number, but internalized IgM and had a unique gene expression profile, compared with those expressing high levels of surface IgM, including elevated recombinase activator gene expression. A comparable B cell population was defined in wild-type bone marrows, with an abundance suggesting that at steady state ～20% of normal developing B cells are constantly encountering autoantigens in situ. In superantigen-expressing mice, as well as in mice carrying the 3H9 anti-DNA IgH transgene, or 3H9 H along with mutation in the murine κ-deleting element RS, IgM internalization was correlated with CD19 downmodulation. CD19(low) bone marrow cells from 3H9;RS(-/-) mice were enriched in L chains that promote DNA binding. Our results suggest that central tolerance and attendant L chain receptor editing affect a large fraction of normal developing B cells. IgH(a/b) mice carrying the superantigen had a ～50% loss in follicular B cell numbers, suggesting that escape from central tolerance by receptor editing from one IgH allele to another was not a major mechanism. IgM(b) superantigen hosts reconstituted with experimental bone marrow were demonstrated to be useful in revealing pathways involved in central tolerance.     

Transgenic expression of Bcl-xL or Bcl-2 by murine B cells enhances the in vivo antipolysaccharide, but not antiprotein, response to intact Streptococcus pneumoniae

IgG antipolysaccharide (PS) and antiprotein responses to Streptococcus pneumoniae (Pn) are both CD4(+) T cell dependent. However, the primary IgG anti-PS response terminates more quickly, uses a shorter period of T cell help, fails to generate memory, and is more dependent on membrane Ig (mIg) signaling. We thus determined whether this limited anti-PS response to Pn reflected a greater propensity of PS-specific B cells to undergo apoptosis. We used mice that constitutively expressed the antiapoptotic protein Bcl-x(L) or Bcl-2 as a B cell-specific transgene. Both transgenic (Tg) mice exhibited increased absolute numbers of splenic B-1 and peritoneal B-1b and B-2 cells, subsets implicated in anti-PS responses, but not in marginal zone B (MZB) cells. Both Tg mouse strains elicited, in an apparently Fas-independent manner, a more prolonged and higher peak primary IgM and IgG anti-PS, but not antiprotein, response to Pn, but without PS-specific memory. A similar effect was not observed using purified PS or pneumococcal conjugate vaccine. In vitro, both splenic MZB and follicular Tg B cells synthesized DNA at markedly higher levels than their wild-type counterparts, following mIg cross-linking. This was associated with increased clonal expansion and decreased apoptosis. Using Lsc(-/-) mice, the Pn-induced IgG response specific for the capsular PS was found to be almost entirely dependent on MZB cells. Collectively, these data suggest that apoptosis may limit mIg-dependent clonal expansion of PS-specific B cells during a primary immune response to an intact bacterium, as well as decrease the pool of PS-responding B cell subsets.     

A VH11V kappa 9 B cell antigen receptor drives generation of CD5+ B cells both in vivo and in vitro

B lymphocytes can be divided into different subpopulations, some with distinctive activation requirements and probably mediating specialized functions, based on surface phenotype and/or anatomical location, but the origins of most of these populations remain poorly understood. B cells constrained by transgenesis to produce an Ag receptor derived from a conventional (B-2) type cell develop a B-2 phenotype, whereas cells from mice carrying a B-1-derived receptor acquire the B-1 phenotype. In this study transgenic enforced expression of a B cell receptor (mu/kappa) originally isolated from a CD5+ (B-1a) B cell generates B-1 phenotype cells in bone marrow cultures that show a distinctive B-1 function, survival in culture. Despite their autoreactivity, we find no evidence for receptor editing or that the paucity of B-2 cells is the result of tolerance-induced selection. Finally, Ca2+ mobilization studies reveal a difference between transgenic B-1 cells in spleen and peritoneal cavity, with cells in spleen much more responsive to anti-B cell receptor cross-linking. We discuss these results in terms of specificity vs lineage models for generation of distinctive B cell subpopulations.     

The selection of marginal zone B cells differs from that of B-1a cells

Transgenic (Tg) L2 mice expressing high levels of the lambda2 (315) L chain contain only B cell populations involved in the first line of defense, i.e., B-1 and marginal zone (MZ) B cells. The strongly oligoclonal IgH chain repertoire of Tg B-1a cells in such mice was attributed to strong positive selection by autoantigens. In this study, we show that the MZ B cells of L2 mice correspond very closely to MZ B cells of normal mice, as revealed by surface marker expression and gene expression profiling. We demonstrate that the IgH chain repertoire of these Tg MZ B cells is extremely heterogeneous. This is in sharp contrast to the oligoclonality found in B-1a cells of the same mice, which was attributed to strong positive selection mediated by autoantigens. Therefore, the strong positive selection of the IgH chain repertoire in L2 mice is B-1a specific. Thus, our data demonstrate that despite common functional properties, MZ B and B-1a cells exhibit striking differences in their selection and/or maintenance requirements.     

Annexin V binds to positively selected B cells

Recombinant annexin V (rAnV) has been used in flow cytometry to identify cells undergoing apoptosis, based on its ability to bind to phosphatidylserine, a negatively charged lipid normally restricted to the cytoplasmic face of the plasma membrane but externalized early during apoptosis. When we stained murine bone marrow (BM) cells with fluorescently labeled rAnV, we found that a surprisingly large fraction of BM B cells bearing selectable transgenic Ag receptors bind significant amounts of rAnV, but that these cells are not apoptotic. Here, we show that binding of rAnV to developing B cells in normal mice correlates with B cell receptor-dependent selection events at several stages of development within both B-1 and B-2 cell subsets. In fact, nearly all B-1 B cells and splenic marginal zone B cells bind rAnV, suggesting that the externalization of phosphatidylserine occurs once mature B cells are selected through BCR-mediated signaling. However, this plasma membrane alteration is apparently not shared by all lymphocytes, because we did not find a parallel population of rAnV-binding viable T cells in vivo in normal or TCR transgenic mice. We also show that BM stromal cell lines can influence the extent of rAnV binding by viable BM B cells during coculture in vitro. We suggest that rAnV detects a potentially important membrane alteration that occurs as B cells develop in the BM and are readied for export to the peripheral lymphoid organs and again among mature B cells recruited to the marginal zone or the B-1 compartment.     

Association of B-1 B cells with follicular dendritic cells in spleen

Although CD5(+) B-1 B cells have been recognized as an infrequent B cell subset in mice for many years, attempts to identify their histologic location in normal mouse spleen have proven difficult due to both their paucity and low level expression of CD5. In this study we have studied V(H)11/D(H)/J(H) gene-targeted mice, V(H)11t, that develop elevated numbers of CD5(+) V(H)11/V(k)9 B cells with an anti-phosphatidylcholine (anti-PtC) autoreactive specificity, allowing B-1 B cell detection by anti-PtC Id-specific Abs in spleen section staining. Using this approach we found that anti-PtC B-1 cells first appear within the white pulp in neonates, expand in association with follicular dendritic cells (FDC), and localize more centrally than other (non-B-1) IgD(high) follicular B cells in adults. Among neonatal B cells, CD5(+) B-1 cells in both normal and V(H)11t mouse spleen and peritoneal cavity express the highest levels of CXCR5, which is important for FDC development. Injection of purified spleen or peritoneal B-1 cells into RAG knockout mice resulted in B-1 cell follicle formation in spleen, inducing FDC development and plasma cell generation. These results indicate that B-1 B cells are the first B cells to express fully mature levels of CXCR5, thereby promoting the development of FDC.     

Cutting Edge: Hormonal milieu, not antigenic specificity, determines the mature phenotype of autoreactive B cells

Although both marginal zone and follicular B cells produce anti-DNA Abs in murine models of systemic lupus erythematosus, it has been unclear whether these distinct B cell subsets make identical or different Abs. Single-cell analysis demonstrates that the same DNA-reactive B cells can mature to either subset, depending on the hormonal environment. Anti-DNA B cells in estradiol-treated mice become marginal zone cells while identical cells from prolactin-treated mice become follicular cells. The B cell receptor signaling pathway is influenced by hormonal milieu. Thus, hormonal milieu and perhaps B cell receptor signaling, but not antigenic specificity, correlates with the differentiation pathway. These observations have implications for the pathogenesis and treatment of autoimmune disease.     

The CD9 tetraspanin is not required for the development of peripheral B cells or for humoral immunity

The CD9 tetraspanin is known to be expressed at high levels on marginal zone (MZ) B cells, B-1 B cells, and plasma cells, and its expression is believed to be dependent on signals derived via Btk. In CD9 null mice, however, the development and survival of MZ B cells, B-1 B cells, and plasma cells all appear to be unaffected, and humoral immune responses to T-dependent and T-independent Ags are similar to those seen in wild-type littermate controls. In wild-type mice, CD9 levels may serve to distinguish between the presumed MZ precursor B cell population in the spleen and other IgD-expressing transitional B cells that express lower levels of CD21 and CD1d. These results suggest that CD9 is dispensable for B cell development and humoral immunity, but that this protein may serve as an additional marker for the presumed MZ precursor population of splenic B cells.     

B cell developmental requirement for the G alpha i2 gene

Null mutation of the Galphai2 trimeric G protein results in a discrete and profound mucosal disorder, including inflammatory bowel disease (IBD), attenuation of IL-10 expression, and immune function polarized to Th1 activity. Genetic and adoptive transfer experiments have established a role for B cells and IL-10 in mucosal immunologic homeostasis and IBD resistance. In this study, we addressed the hypothesis that Galphai2 is required for the development of IL-10-producing B cells. Galphai2(-/-) mice were reduced in the relative abundance of marginal zone (MZ), transitional type 2 (T2), and B-1a B cells and significantly increased in follicular mature and B-1b B cells. Reconstitution of RAG2(-/-) mice with Galphai2(-/-) bone marrow induced an IBD-like colitis and a deficiency in absolute numbers of MZ, T2, and B-1 B cells. Thus, the Galphai2(-/-) genotype in colitis susceptibility and B cell development involved a cis effect within the hemopoietic compartment. In vitro, the B cell population of Galphai2(-/-) mice was functionally deficient in LPS-induced proliferation and IL-10 production, consistent with the exclusive capacity of T2 and MZ cell subpopulations for LPS responsiveness. In vivo, Galphai2(-/-) mice were selectively impaired for the IgM response to T-independent type II, consistent with the relative depletion of MZ and peritoneal B-1 subpopulations. Collectively, these results reveal a selective role for Galphai2 in MZ and B-1 B cell development. Disorders of this Galphai2-dependent process in B cell development may represent a mechanism for IBD susceptibility.     

The radioprotective 105/MD-1 complex links TLR2 and TLR4/MD-2 in antibody response to microbial membranes

Low-affinity IgG3 Abs to microbial membranes are important for primary immune defense against microbes, but little is known about the importance of TLRs in their production. IgG3 levels were extremely low in mice lacking radioprotective 105 (RP105), a B cell surface molecule structurally related to TLRs. RP105(-/-) B cells proliferated poorly in response to not only the TLR4 ligand LPS but also TLR2 ligand lipoproteins, both of which mediate the immunostimulatory activity of microbial membranes. RP105(-/-) mice were severely impaired in hapten-specific Ab production against LPS or lipoproteins. CD138 (syndecan-1)-positive plasma cells were detected after lipid A injection in wild-type spleen but much less in RP105(-/-) spleen. RP105 ligation in vivo induced plasma cell differentiation. RP105 expression was approximately 3-fold higher on marginal zone B cells than on follicular and B1 cells and was down-regulated on germinal center cells. These results demonstrate that a signal via RP105 is uniquely important for regulating TLR-dependent Ab production to microbial membranes.     

Uncoupling of anergy from developmental arrest in anti-insulin B cells supports the development of autoimmune diabetes

Loss of tolerance is considered to be an early event that is essential for the development of autoimmune disease. In contrast to this expectation, autoimmune (type 1) diabetes develops in NOD mice that harbor an anti-insulin Ig transgene (125Tg), even though anti-insulin B cells are tolerant. Tolerance is maintained in a similar manner in both normal C57BL/6 and autoimmune NOD mice, as evidenced by B cell anergy to stimulation through their Ag receptor (anti-IgM), TLR4 (LPS), and CD40 (anti-CD40). Unlike B cells in other models of tolerance, anergic 125Tg B cells are not arrested in development, and they enter mature subsets of follicular and marginal zone B cells. In addition, 125Tg B cells remain competent to increase CD86 expression in response to both T cell-dependent (anti-CD40) and T cell-independent (anti-IgM or LPS) signals. Thus, for anti-insulin B cells, tolerance is characterized by defective B cell proliferation uncoupled from signals that promote maturation and costimulator function. In diabetes-prone NOD mice, anti-insulin B cells in this novel state of tolerance provide the essential B cell contribution required for autoimmune beta cell destruction. These findings suggest that the degree of functional impairment, rather than an overt breach of tolerance, is a critical feature that governs B cell contribution to T cell-mediated autoimmune disease.