Cytolysis and karyopyknosis in postmenopausal vaginal smears as markers of endometrial cancer, diabetes and obesity. Studies based on a ten-year follow-up

The vaginal cytology of 507 postmenopausal women was followed prospectively for ten years. Of the subjects, the 207 with cytolytic or karyopyknotic vaginal smears constituted the study group and the 300 with atrophic smears (indicating an absence of estrogenic activity) constituted the control group at the beginning of the follow-up. A woman whose initial smear was cytolytic usually had a cytolytic smear ten years later, which implies that high postmenopausal estrogenic activity is constitutional. Both at the beginning of the study and ten years later, the mean body weights were higher in the study group than in the control group. The mean karyopyknotic index and the prevalence of cytolytic smears were significantly higher among women with impaired glucose tolerance than among subjects with a normal glucose tolerance test. During the follow-up period, 3.6% of the women in the study group and 0.7% of the women in the control group developed endometrial cancer (P less than .02). The incidence of 3.6% of endometrial cancer is significantly higher than the corresponding age-specific incidence (P less than .001). We conclude that obese and/or diabetic postmenopausal women with cytolytic or markedly karyopyknotic vaginal smears exhibit a high intrinsic estrogen activity and may thus be at risk for endometrial cancer.     

Value of histiocyte detection in Pap smears for predicting endometrial pathology. An institutional experience

OBJECTIVE: To determine the clinical implications of the finding of histiocytes in Pap smears in 1 patient population. STUDY DESIGN: The medical records and Pap smears which the presence of histiocytes was mentioned in the diagnosis between August 1996 and August 2001 were reviewed in conjunction with follow-up surgical findings. The positive predictive value (PPV) for significant endometrial pathology for the isolated finding of histiocytes on Pap smear was determined. RESULTS: Of the 238,225 women screened over a 60-month period, 325 were reported to have histiocytes in their Pap smears. Of them, 238 (73.2%) had subsequent endometrial sampling, hysterectomy or both, and follow-up Pap smears. Two hundred seven smears (87%) failed to disclose endometrial pathology. Thirty-one cases (13%) resulted in significant histopathologic findings, including 12 uterine malignancies, 8 endocervical polyps, 7 endometrial polyps, 2 submucosal leiomyomata, 1 simple hyperplasia without atypia and 1 case of tamoxifen-related changes. Upon review of the clinical records, 58% (18/31) of those patients had other significant clinical and/or cytologic findings. Five of the 18 patients (27.8%) had associated postmenopausal bleeding, 11 had additional abnormal Pap smear findings (atypical glandular cells, 6/18, or 33.3%; endometrial cells, 5/18, or 27.8%), and another 2 had both postmenopausal bleeding and atypical glandular cells (2/18, or 11.1%). The PPV for significant uterine pathology for women with the isolated finding of histiocytes on a Pap smear was 5.5% and 60% with additional clinical and/or Pap smear findings. The PPV for endometrial cancer was 1.3% in women with the isolated finding of histiocytes on a Pap smear but 20% for women with histiocytes and additional clinical/or Pap smear findings. CONCLUSION: Based on the findings of this study and recently published data, we conclude that the isolated finding of increased histiocytes in the absence of postmenopausal bleeding, endometrial cells or atypical glandular cells on a Pap smear is a poor indicator of uterine disease.     

Review of cervical smears from 76 women with invasive cervical cancer: cytological findings and medicolegal implications

OBJECTIVE: To review cervical smears from 76 women which were taken prior to the diagnosis of invasive cervical cancer and to determine the appropriateness of the cytology reports issued on the smears. METHODS: Cervical smears, clinical records, cervical smear history and cytology reports from 76 women with invasive cervical cancer were reviewed. After microscopic review of the cervical smears, the cases were divided into two groups: Group 1 comprised 50 women who were found to have had at least one false-negative (F/N) smear report prior to the diagnosis of invasive cervical cancer. Group 2 comprised 26 women for whom no evidence of F/N reporting was found. RESULTS: A total of 209 cervical smears from the 50 women in group 1 were available for review (range 2-12 smears per woman); 100 of the 209 smears were considered to have been reported appropriately. Ninety-seven smears which had been reported originally as negative or inadequate were found, on review, to contain numerous severely dyskaryotic cells and were reclassified as F/N smears. All of the 50 women had at least one F/N smear and 29 had two or more. Twelve smears from eight women contained only a few (<200 severely dyskaryotic cells). Forty women developed invasive squamous carcinoma and 10 developed invasive adenocarcinoma. The stage at diagnosis ranged from 1A to stage 4. Seventy-one smears from the 24 women in group 2 were available for review (range 1-15 smears per woman). In two cases included in group 2, no smears were provided for review as the smears had been lost or mislaid. Review of the 71 smears confirmed the accuracy of the original cytological classification of the smear. Nineteen women were diagnosed with squamous cancer, two microinvasive cancer, one glassy cell, two adenocarcinomas, and one with adenosquamous carcinoma. One women was found to have an embryonal rhabdomyosarcoma of the corpus uteri involving the cervix. DISCUSSION/CONCLUSION: The medicolegal implications are discussed in the light of the above findings. Evidence of breach of duty of care was presented in all 50 cases in group I although causation was not established in every case. There was no evidence of failure of duty of care in terms of the standard of the cervical cytology reports issued or standard of clinical management in 17 of the 26 cases in group 2. However, in seven of the 26 cases in group 2, clinical management of the case was substandard due to failure to investigate symptoms of irregular bleeding regardless of a negative cytology report (two cases), failure to act upon a suspicious smear report or consecutive inadequate smear reports (two cases), failure of follow-up after treatment of CIN3 (two cases) and histological misdiagnosis (one case).     

A comparative study of the estrogenic potential of two synthetic estrogens (mestranol and ethinylestradiol)

The purpose of this study was to establish the relative estrogenicity of ethinylestradiol and mestranol and to establish .05 and .1 mg of mestranol as standard reference preparations for the comparative study of other compounds. Patients were selected from a large group of primary amenorrhea, secondary amenorrhea, and postmenopausal women. All required hormonal replacement therapy. Patients with chromosomal abnormalities or those with diminished or abnormal response were excluded. Vaginal cytology was used as the main method for the assessment of the response. Before treatment all had either an atrophic pattern (Maturation Index = 50-50-0) or a hypertrophic pattern (MI=5-95-0) with a mean value of 10-87-3 for patients with primary amenorrhea and 18-79-3 in the other 2 groups. Patients with a proliferative intermediate cell pattern and postmenopausal women thought to have continuing endogenous estrogen activity were omitted. Ethinylestradiol or mestranol were given orally in doses of .025, .05, and .1 mg for a period of 10 days during which frequent vaginal smears were made. When cell patterns showed extremely marked cytolysis of the glycogen-containing intermediate cells and a low percentage of karyopyknotic superficial cells these patients were excluded. 40 women were finally included. The effects of estrogen on the vaginal epithelium in all 40 women after 10 days therapy were quite uniform. In those cases showing delayed regression of estrogenic effects 4 mg of chlormadinone acetate was given daily for 10 days. These patients then showed a reduction in the superficial cell percentage accompanied by a shift to the left in the maturation index such as 0-40-60 before to 0-95-5 after treatment. A few women had an insignificant reduction in the superficial cell percentages. Changes in the percentages of the intermediate type of cells were not significant. The regression was considered to be complete when the smear contained mainly small intermediate cells and parabasal cells with numerous leukocytes and some necrotic debris. Both estrogen preparations produced the same vaginal response at .05 mg doses. Tablets of .05 and .1 mg mestranol were chosen for further study. The increase in the superficial cell index to 30 (SD plus or minus 18.5) following treatment with .05 mg and the increase to 54.1 (SD plus or minus 26.7) following .1 mg have been adopted as standard vaginal responses. The term estrogenic effect used in vaginal cytology is taken to mean the local vaginal effect induced by estrogens.     

Evaluation of p16INK4a in cervical lesion of premenopausal and postmenopausal women

Pap smears of postmenopausal women are often misdiagnosed because of the difficulty in distinguishing atrophic epithelial cells groups only by morphological criteria. In this study we investigated the diagnostic application of immunocytochemical staining of p16INK4a on conventional Pap smear. A total of 137 cervical specimens were enrolled in this study, of which 77 and 60 cervical smears were taken from premenopausal and postmenopausal women, respectively. Two cervical smears were taken simultaneously in 68 women, one for conventional cytology and the other for immunostaining. Additional 69 cervical smears were taken from the archive, decolorized and then used for immunostaining. In premenopausal women 1 out of 14 (7.1%) with negative cytology, 7 out of 24 (29.2%) with low grade squamous intra-epithelial lesion (LSIL), all 35 (100%) with high grade squamous intraepithelial lesion (HSIL) and all 4 (100%) with squamous cell carcinoma (confirmed by histopathology) had positive staining to p16INK4a. In postmenopausal women p16INK4a positivity was observed in 4 out of 7 (57.1%) cases of LSIL, 12 out of 14 (85.7%) cases of HSIL and all 4 out of 5 (80%) different cases of carcinoma (1 cervical adenosquamous carcinoma and 3 cervical squamous cell carcinoma in situ confirmed by histopathology), but none of 34 smears with normal cytology. Twenty smears with normal cytology chosen for the negative control in this study were from the group of postmenopausal women and were as expected negative for p16INK4a immunostaining. In the group of postmenopausal women, 16 out of 60 (26.7%) cases the cytological diagnosis was established on the basis of pl6lNK4a immunostaining as being HSIL. From our preliminary study on a limited number of samples, we can however conclude that pl6INK4a immunostaining is a very useful tool for cytological diagnosis enabling to distinguish HSIL from normal, reactive or inflammatory changes.     

Atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance in women over 55. Comparison with the general population and implications for management.

OBJECTIVE: To determine the significance of atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance (ASCUS) in patients 55 years or older. STUDY DESIGN: From January 1994, to January 1997, 8,175 cervicovaginal smears were obtained from patients 55 years or older (mean age, 64.8; range, 56-84) at University Hospitals of Cleveland. Ninety-six of these patients were diagnosed with ASCUS only or ASCUS with a qualifying statement on the smear. Patient records, follow-up cervicovaginal smears and biopsies were reviewed for a period of one to four years following the diagnosis of ASCUS. RESULTS: The incidence of ASCUS only or ASCUS with a qualifying statement for patients 55 years or older was 1.8%. The ASCUS:SIL ratio was 2.6:1. An estrogen stimulation test was recommended in two cases. Women older than 55 with ASCUS were three times more likely to be receiving hormonal replacement therapy than similar-aged women with normal cervicovaginal smears. Follow-up cervicovaginal smears or biopsies were obtained on 93 (80 cervicovaginal smears, 13 biopsies). The results were the following: LSIL (13), squamous carcinoma in situ (1) and ASCUS (53); the remainder of the cases were normal. In the patients who received a second diagnosis of ASCUS, follow-up cervi covaginal smears or biopsies revealed low grade dysplasia in six. CONCLUSION: Although the incidence of ASCUS and the frequency of underlying dysplasia is lower in postmenopausal women than the general population, there is still a real risk that a postmenopausal woman with ASCUS has underlying intraepithelial neoplasia. Therefore, these patients should be managed as is the general population.     

An Audit of Cervical Cancer Deaths In Nottingham

Death certificates were reviewed and 57 women were identified whose primary cause of death was cervical cancer. Their cervical smear records were reviewed from laboratory files. Only nine had participated in the cervical cancer screening programme before the diagnosis of cervical cancer was made. One woman had an abnormal smear as a result of cervical screening but failed to attend for follow-up.
The problem of false negative smears is also addressed and the value of review of negative smears for the purposes of cytology audit is emphasized.     

The use of screening episodes linked to CIN3 and invasive cancer registrations to study outcomes from the NHS Cervical Screening Programme

Objective: To examine how NHS cervical screening data can be collected and analysed in order to evaluate women’s screening histories as episodes rather than as individual smears. Design: Analysis of routine cervical screening data grouped into screening episodes for a cohort of women regarding episodes starting in a given year. Setting: NHS Cervical Screening Programme. Population: Data from four Health Authorities (now eight Primary Care Trusts) from the NHS Cervical Screening Programme with primary smears (first in an episode) taken between 1 April 1999 and 31 March 2000. Methods: Cytology information obtained from the call/recall (‘Exeter’) computer system was linked to cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) 3 and invasive cancer outcome information obtained from cancer registries. Screening histories were divided into episodes, each starting with a primary smear that was followed up to episode closure or, for episodes still open followed for an average 4.25 years, from the primary smear. The episode was divided into two parts (up to referral to colposcopy and following the referral). The outcomes of the episodes are described including referral rate to colposcopy and CIN3 and invasive cancer rates by factors such as age. Main outcome measures: Episode histories and rates of referral to colposcopy, CIN3 and invasive cancer. Results: There were 176 923 episodes from 176 319 women (1.003 episodes per woman) followed up to March 2004, the date at which the first phase of information accrual ceased. Of these episodes, 172 100 (97.3%) were closed either by a negative smear referring the woman back to routine recall or by default (defined as no smear recorded within 21 months following a smear requiring an action of repeat or refer to colposcopy). The remaining 4823 (2.7%) of episodes were still open, of which in 3121 (1.8%) the woman had been referred to colposcopy and in 1702 (1.0%) no referral decision had been made. Referral rates to colposcopy varied by age from 5.7% in women aged 20–24 years down to 0.9% in women aged 60–64 years. The overall efficiency of screening was highest for woman aged about 30 years, with a CIN3 detection rate of eight per 1000 women and a positive predictive value (for CIN3 or worse) of referral to colposcopy of 21%. Conclusion: The study has shown that routinely collected NHS cervical screening data can be combined to give information on complete episodes, allowing important performance measures to be studied. We suggest that in future information in the NHS screening system should be structured to facilitate such analysis and to allow cytology and histology information to be readily linked.     

Management of women with mild and moderate cervical dyskaryosis.

OBJECTIVE--To compare the outcomes in women with mild and moderate dyskaryosis after increasing periods of surveillance and thereby to define a rational protocol for managing such women. DESIGN--Prospective study with randomisation of women to one of four treatment groups, each with a different period of surveillance; one group in which the women were given immediate treatment and three other groups in which the women were under surveillance for six, 12, and 24 months. SETTING--A dedicated colposcopy clinic in Aberdeen, Scotland. SUBJECTS--902 women who presented with a mildly or moderately dyskaryotic smear for the first time. INTERVENTIONS--Cytological and colposcopic examinations at intervals of six months until the allocated period of surveillance was completed, at which time biopsy was performed. Women with severe dyskaryosis were withdrawn from surveillance and a biopsy was performed. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES--The histological findings after punch biopsy or large loop excision of the transformation zone, and the trends in cytological appearances of serial cervical smears. RESULTS--793 women completed the study. In all, 769 women had an adequate final smear, of which 197 were normal cytologically, 328 were still mildly or moderately dyskaryotic, and 244 were severely dyskaryotic. Seventeen of the 67 (25%) women with one repeat smear showing non-dyskaryosis had cervical intraepithelial neoplasia grade III compared with only one of the 31 (3%) women with no dyskaryosis in four repeat cervical smears (P < 0.0001). None of the women had invasive cancer. Of 158 women whose index smear showed mild dyskaryosis and who were allocated to the group under surveillance for two years, only 40 had not defaulted or still had dyskaryotic smears by the end of the two years. CONCLUSION--Cytological surveillance, although safe, is not an efficient strategy for managing women with mildly abnormal smears. Women with any degree of dyskaryosis in a smear should be referred for colposcopy.     

Follow up of women with a history of mildly abnormal cervical smears which have returned to normal without treatment

The progress of 124 women with at least two negative cervical smears following a history of mildly abnormal smears for which no treatment had been given was compared with 106 women with negative smears and a clinical history of genital warts or herpes virus infection and 460 age-matched controls. After 4 years, excluding those for whom there was no follow up, 5.8% of those with a history of abnormal smears, none of those with a clinical history of genital warts or herpes virus and 1.1% of controls had developed histological evidence of at least cervical intraepithelial neoplasia grade III (CINIII) when referred for investigation of subsequent abnormal smears; one woman, from the control group, had developed invasive cervical cancer. Women with two negative smears after a history of abnormal smears who subsequently developed CINIII were more likely to have had a previous smear reported as moderate or mild-moderate dyskaryosis (2/6) compared with those whose follow up was negative (2/89). the results suggest that two negative cervical smears may not necessarily indicate that a lesion has regressed, but that a clinical history of genital warts or herpes virus infection should not be an indication for increased surveillance.     

Quinquennial cervical smears: every woman's right and every general practitioner's responsibility.

Out of 558 women aged 16 to 64 who were registered with one general practitioner, 459 were eligible to be screened for cervical cancer. Even though the practice had been taking cervical smears for many years, they were predominantly from women under 35. Of the eligible women between 35 and 64, 111 (37%) had never had a smear. After short term intensive screening the uptake rates, defined by a smear done within the past five years, rose to 100% for women under 35, 94% for those aged 35 to 64, and 96% for all eligible women. Screening was rewarding both in its clinical yield and in the income generated by item of service payment. The success of screening was largely due to the participation of practice nurses in taking smears, and to a new method of recording smear results and claims for them. Some women, however, refused to have cervical smears.     

The Cardiff Cervical Cytology Study: prevalence of cytological grades and initial histological findings.

Among 45 266 women in the Cardiff Cervical Cytology Survey the peak prevalence of suspicious or positive smears was 11.2/1000 at age 45-50 years and of dyskaryosis 10.2/1000 at age 25-29. A suspicious or positive cytological picture at prevalence testing was associated with occult or clinical invasion in 24% of cases, and only 4% of patients with suspicious or positive smears were normal histologically. When dyskaryosis was detected in the prevalence test 20% had carcinoma in situ or microinvasion and 3% had occult or clinically invasive carcinoma. One hundred and twenty-nine (51%) women with dyskaryotic smears did not have a biopsy initially (that is, within two years of the prevalence test), but they were followed up at regular intervals. Subsequently 15 of the 129 gave smears consistently dyskaryotic or worse cytologically and were subjected to biopsy. Of these, two showed dysplasia, 12 carcinoma in situ, and one clinically invasive carcinoma. These findings emphasise the need for repeat cytological or histological examination in any woman with evidence of dyskaryosis in a cervical smear.     

The presence of endometrial cells in cervical smears in relation to the day of the menstrual cycle and the method of contraception

The presence of endometrial cells in cervical smears was studied in a large series of women participating in a population screening program for cervical cancer, in relation to different time periods of the menstrual cycle and to the method of contraception practiced. In the total group of women studied, endometrial cells were present in an average of 12% of the cervical smears. In women who were menstruating cyclically, the percentage of cervical smears containing endometrial cells was not age dependent. Only in women over 52 years was a lower number of endometrium-positive cervical smears found: in postmenopausal women, 0.6% of smears were found to contain endometrial cells. In menstruating women, the frequency of endometrial cells in cervical smears was highest during the menses. After day four, through the proliferative phase, the percentages of cervical smears containing endometrial cells markedly decreased. During the secretory phase, an average of 2% of the smears contained endometrial cells; in the premenstrual phase (after day 25), the percentages of endometrial cell-positive smears rose again. When related to the method of contraception practiced, significant differences in the percentages of cervical smears with endometrial cells appeared. In women using oral hormonal contraceptives, the average numbers of smears containing endometrial cells for the whole cycle as well as for each period of the cycle were significantly lower. This phenomenon might be due to endometrial atrophy on the basis of prolonged use of oral hormonal contraceptives. In women wearing an intrauterine device, at any moment the frequencies of smears with endometrial cells present were significantly higher than the values found in women using any other method of contraception or not using contraceptives. The evaluation of cells originating from the endometrium requires considerable experience. The identification of endometrial cells can be made with greater confidence when the cytologist is aware of the exact date of the menstrual cycle and of the impact on the presence of endometrial cells in cervical smears caused by different methods of contraception.     

Comparison of cytohormonal status of postmenopausal women with cancer to age-matched controls

To determine whether the cytohormonal status of postmenopausal women with cancer involving the uterus and vagina differs from that of women free of cancer, 100 women 60 years of age or older with positive cervicovaginal smears were compared with an age-matched control group without malignant neoplasms. Epidermoid carcinoma was identified in 64 patients (average age: 67 years) and adenocarcinoma in 34 patients (average age: 69 years). One patient had leiomyosarcoma, and another had bladder carcinoma. The paucity of benign squamous cells in the smears precluded hormonal evaluation in 32% of the index cases; the smears from 10% of the controls were also indeterminate. Of the evaluable cases with epidermoid carcinoma of the cervix, a high maturation was noted in 46% as compared to 11% for the matched controls. In addition, high maturation was noted in 69% of those patients with endometrial adenocarcinoma as compared to 19% for the matched controls. None of the index cases were atrophic; 31% of the controls were. A history of exogenous estrogen usage was obtained in three patients with endometrial adenocarcinoma, all with high maturation, and in five controls, none with high maturation. These data appear to indicate a difference in the cytohormonal status of patients with cervical or endometrial carcinoma as compared to those without; consequently, cytologists should be especially attentive to smears showing high maturation from postmenopausal women.     

P‐26CONVENTIONAL V THIN LAYER TECHNIQUES: A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF BRONCHIAL SPECIMENS USING CONVENTIONAL AND TWO LBC METHODS,THINPREP AND SUREPATH

Introduction: There is ongoing debate about the terminology used in the classification of dyskaryosis, including whether BNA smears should be classified according to whether koilocytes are present or not. We explored the effect of koilocytosis in the management experiences and clinical outcomes of women with a single BNA smear. Methods: This study includes 410 women aged 20–59 years, resident in Tayside who had an ‘baseline’ BNA smear between 31/10/1999 and 31/10/2002 who were eligible for the TOMBOLA trial but who did not participate. Recommended follow‐up for these women was a repeat smear in six months. Up to three‐years follow‐up data was collected on subsequent cytological smears, colposcopy examinations and any related histology. The baseline smear was re‐read for the presence or absence of koilocytes. Women were classified according to their clinical outcomes during their three years. Results: 47% (192/410) of women were classified as having koilocytosis at baseline. The mean age was lower among these women (25 years) compared to those without koilocytosis (35 years). 55% (105/192) of women with koilocytosis at baseline had one or more negative smears and no further abnormal smears, compared to 63% (137/218) of those without koilocytosis, the difference was not statistically significant. 28% (53/192) of women with koilocytosis at baseline were referred to colposcopy after subsequent low‐grade or high‐grade smears compared to 19% (42/218) of those without koilocytosis; the difference was statistically significant. 14% (27/192) of women with koilocytosis at baseline were diagnosed with CIN2/3 or worse during follow‐up compared to 10% (21/218) of women without koilocytosis; the difference was not statistically significant. Discussion: Our results suggest that the presence or absence of koilocytosis has little impact on the clinical outcomes of women with a BNA smear.     

Cervical screening in Perth and Kinross since introduction of the new contract.

OBJECTIVE--To determine changes in the cervical screening service since the introduction of the new general practitioner contract on 1 April 1990. DESIGN--Analysis of computerised records of cervical screening both before and after introduction of the new contract. SETTING--General practices in Perth and Kinross Unit, Tayside. PATIENTS--A total of 30,071 women aged 21-60 on 26 general practitioner partnership lists. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES--Percentage average of target population for cervical screening in each practice for first three quarters on introduction of the contract. RESULTS--Perth and Kinross Unit completed a computerised cervical screening call programme in July 1989, which produced an increase from 71% to 78% in the mean percentage of women aged 20-60 who had had cervical smear tests within 5.5 years. Six months after the introduction of the new general practitioner contract the mean population coverage was increased to 85% in women aged 21-60 and only four practices had not attained the 80% upper target compared with 10 on 1 April 1990. Detailed examination of randomly selected practices immediately before the new contract was introduced showed an average artificial list inflation of 4.3% in health board records when compared with practice records, a hysterectomy rate of 6.2%, and an additional 3% of women who were considered to be ineligible for smear testing due to putative virginity or illness or infirmity, or both. There was a considerable shift away from use of well woman clinics (2.7% of smears in 1990 compared with 5.6% in 1988) for taking cervical smears, potentially threatening the long term viability of the clinics. CONCLUSION--The introduction of the new contract for general practitioners has brought about a further sustained increase in population coverage for cervical screening in a small Scottish unit with a stable population, well motivated general practitioners, and a fully integrated computerised call and recall system based on the community health index. To optimise the screening service revision of the targets levels is necessary.     

The inadequate smear: does it matter?

The objective of this study was to quantify the incidence of underlying cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) among women referred for colposcopy with three consecutive inadequate smears. The design was a retrospective cohort study analysing data from a regional colposcopy database at Cervical Screening Wales. Women who were referred to all the colposcopy clinics in Wales with three consecutive inadequate smears, the third inadequate smear being taken between 1 April 2001 and 31 March 2002 constituted the study population. The results of the fourth smear taken at the colposcopy clinic after three consecutive inadequate smears, the worst biopsy results from any of the subsequent colposcopies and the relationship between the result of the fourth smear taken at colposcopy clinic and any histology result were the main outcome measures. The accuracy of the colposcopic opinion was also examined. Of the 433 women identified as having been referred because of three consecutive inadequate smears, 302 were linked to either a subsequent smear and/or a biopsy result. An adequate smear result was available for 85% of these women when the smear was taken in the colposcopy clinic; 77% were reported as negative and 8% were abnormal. Of the 347 women seen in the colposcopy clinic, high-grade CIN was seen in 3% and low-grade lesion in 8%. The sensitivity and specificity of the fourth inadequate smear test in predicting underlying CIN were 15% and 84% respectively, with a positive predictive value of 8%. The sensitivity and specificity of colposcopy in predicting histological CIN among patients with three inadequate smears was 70% and 49%, respectively, and the positive predictive value was 44%. This study raises the question as to whether three consecutive inadequate smears should be considered as an indication for colposcopy, or merely for a further smear to be taken in circumstances where there is a greater likelihood getting an adequate result.     

CIN 2/3 and cervical cancer after an ASCUS pap smear. A 7-year, prospective study of the Norwegian population-based, coordinated screening program

OBJECTIVE: To estimate the risk of being diagnosed with cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) 2/3 or invasive cervical cancer (ICC) based on diagnostic and screening procedures performed after a diagnosis of atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance (ASCUS) and to compare this risk to that in women with a normal Pap smears. STUDY DESIGN: A 7-year, prospective, cohort study was performed in the Norwegian population-based, coordinated screening program. After excluding women in the midst of follow-up of an abnormal Pap smear or with a history of CIN 2/3 or ICC, the study population consisted of women 25-69 years of age with a normal (n = 526,661) or ASCUS Pap smear (n = 10,037) in 1995-1996. Risk estimates were calculated by logistic and parametric survival regression. RESULTS: Within 7 years of an ASCUS smear, 1,017 women (10.1%) were diagnosed with CIN 2/3 and 62 (0.62%) with ICC. Women with an ASCUS index Pap smear had a relative risk of 15-30 of being diagnosed with histologically verified CIN 2/3 or ICC within the first 2 years of follow-up as compared to women with a normal index smear. In long-term follow-up, women with an ASCUS index smear followed by a normal smear, which cancelled further clinical follow-up, were at > 3.5 times higher risk of both CIN 2/3 and invasive cancer as compared to women with a normal index smear. CONCLUSION: Pap smear follow-up of women with an ASCUS smear does not identify all women at higher risk of CIN 2/3 and ICC. Other diagnostic procedures should be implemented to improve the screening program.     

Survey of Cervical Cytology in General Practice

In a practice in an industrial area a cervical cytology service was offered to women, and in the years 1967-70 280 cervical smears were carried out. In 1971 all women born between 1 January 1920 and 31 December 1935 who had not had a cervical smear taken in the preceding four years were sent a letter explaining the service and inviting them to attend. Those who did not attend received a second letter and, if necessary, a visit by a nurse in an effort to persuade them to do so.Eventually 88·4% of the women in this age group who could be traced attended, and 16 abnormal cervical smears were reported. As a result of cone biopsy 12 women were found to have carcinoma in situ.     

Achievable standards, Benchmarks for reporting, and Criteria for evaluating cervical cytopathologySecond edition including revised performance indicators

Endocervical cells are not essential for an adequate smear, except where the previous abnormality was seen in endocervical cells. When three consecutive smears are reported as inadequate, the recommendation for colposcopy should be made at the discretion of the pathologist in the light of a review of the relevant slides and the clinical history of the woman concerned. The cellularity of previous sequential smears should not be combined in order to judge the present smear test as negative. There should be no more than three abnormal smears (including borderline) over any 10-year period without a recommendation for colposcopy. At least three negative smears, at least 6 months apart, should be reported before a woman is returned to routine recall following a smear showing mild dyskaryosis or borderline nuclear change. There is no evidence that demonstrates that selective double screening is any more effective in preventing false-negatives than rapid review and this practice cannot therefore be justified. Sensitivity should be based on all abnormalities detected on primary screening rather than on moderate dyskaryosis or worse. Ranges for reporting rates are based on the 10-90th percentiles of the range for laboratories reporting over 10000 screening smears per year in KC61 returns, but apply to all laboratories reporting screening smears.