THE CILIARY NECKLACE : A Ciliary Membrane Specialization

Cilia, primarily of the lamellibranch gill (Elliptio and Mytilus), have been examined in freeze-etch replicas. Without etching, cross fractures rarely reveal the 9 + 2 pattern, although suggestions of ninefold symmetry are present. In etched preparations, longitudinal fractures through the matrix show a triplet spoke alignment corresponding to the spoke periodicity seen in thin sections. Dynein rows can be visualized along the peripheral microtubules in some preparations. Fracture faces of the ciliary membrane are smooth with few membrane particles, except in the regions adjacent to the basal plate. In the transition region below the plate, a unique particle arrangement, the ciliary necklace, is found. In the Elliptio gill, on fracture face A the necklace is comprised of three well-defined rows or strands of membrane particles that encircle the ciliary shaft. The rows are scalloped and each scallop corresponds to a peripheral doublet microtubule. In thin sections at the level of these particles, a series of champagne-glass structures link the microtubular doublets to the ciliary membrane. The ciliary necklace and this "membrane-microtubule" complex may be involved in energy transduction or the timing of ciliary beat. Comparative studies show that these features are present in all somatic cilia examined including those of the ameboflagellate Tetramitus, sea urchin embryos, rat trachea, and nonmotile cilia of cultured chick embryo fibroblasts. The number of necklace strands differs with each species. The necklace has not been found in rat or sea urchin sperm.     

The sensory cilium of retinal rods is analogous to the transitional zone of motile cilia

The connecting cilium of rat retinal rods was studied by freeze-fracture and thin-sectioning techniques. Transverse strands of intramembranous particles could be observed on fracture face B on the ciliary plasma membrane. The strands were essentially similar to those found at the transitional zone of motile cilia ("ciliary necklace"). The larger number of intramembranous particles obscured the pattern on fracture face A of the membrane. On longitudinal sections of the cilia, beads showing a periodicity similar to the necklace strands were observed. Each bead consisted of two structures apposed to both sides of the plasma membrane. Transverse sections of the cilia revealed radial Y-shaped structures that connected each ciliary doublet with the plasma membrane. Axial tubules, central sheath, radial spokes and dynein arms were missing in the connecting cilium. Comparing the fine structure of the retinal cilia with that of motile cilia it becomes evident that the connecting cilium is analogous in structure with the transitional zone of motile cilia. The present observations suggest that periodic membrane beads along the plasma membrane on thin sections correspond to strands of necklace particles as observed on freeze-fractured membranes. The arrangement of the particles in transverse strands is probably ensured by the radial connecting structures.     

Intercellular connections in rabbit heart as revealed by quick-frozen, deep-etched, and rotary-replicated papillary muscle

Rabbit papillary muscles were ultrarapidly frozen, fractured, deep-etched, and rotary shadowed. These techniques revealed the interstitial space where the complex network of fine microthreads that connect myocytes to each other and to collagen fibrils can be seen in a three-dimensional array similar to scanning electron micrographs but at a resolution attainable in freeze-fracture microscopy.     

Walsby's square bacterium: fine structure of an orthogonal procaryote.

The "square" bacterium, first described by Walsby from brine collected at the Red Sea shore [A. E. Walsby, Nature (London) 283:69-71, 1980] was examined by electron microscopy. The cells appeared as flat rectangular boxes in scanning electron micrographs. In sections and freeze-fracture preparation, the edges looked more rounded. The thickness apparently remains constant as the cells grow and divide. Their sides were a few micrometers long, but the cells were only 0.25 micrometers thick. They showed typical procaryote structure, with a regular cell wall and a gas vacuole fine structure similar to that of other halophilic procaryotes. The inner fracture faces of the cell membrane showed a much denser population of intramembrane particles than the outer fracture faces, but no patches of purple membrane, despite the presence of bacteriorhodospin-like pigment in the cell suspension. Morphologically identical cells have been found in brine from Baja California, Mexico.     

Mechanical sensitivity and cell coupling in the ciliated epithelial cells ofMytilus edulis gill

Summary Transmission electron microscopy has not provided strong evidence for gap junctions inMytilus edulis gill tissue, in spite of extensive physiological evidence for coupled ciliary arrest in lateral cells and coupled activation in abfrontal cells. To investigate the kinds and relative distribution of cell junctions and also to determine whether ciliary membrane particle differences exist in these two types of oppositely mechanically sensitive cells, we analyzed the structure of these and two other ciliated cell types (frontal and laterofrontal) by freeze-fracture replication. Gap junctions occur in all four ciliated cell types, but they are relatively small and of variable morphology, often consisting of elongate, winding complexes of membrane particles. Statistically, such structures rarely would be recognized as gap junctions in thin sections. Gap junctions appear to be most abundant between the highly coupled abfrontal cells, minimal between laterofrontal cells, and not evident in the epithelial cells that separate coupled ciliated cell types. The ciliary necklaces of the mechanically activated abfrontal cilia are typically 4- or 5-stranded while those of the remaining three cell types are mainly 3-stranded. In developing gill tips, ciliated cells have abundant gap junctions and newly formed cilia have a full complement of necklace particles. Nascent lateral cilia are not mechanically sensitive, indicating that the acquisition of mechanosensitivity does not correlate with the presence of ciliary necklace or other membrane particles. Lateral and laterofrontal cells become sensitive to neurotransmitters soon after the appearance of the latter during development, but mechanosensitivity of both lateral and abfrontal cells arises substantially later.     

Evidence for a vertical displacement of intramembranous particles on the plasma membrane of Tetrahymena cells by a local anesthetic

We examined the effect of a local anesthetic, dibucaine, on the plasma membrane of Tetrahymena pyriformis strain NT-1 using freeze-fracture electron microscopy. Intramembranous particles (IMPs) were distributed homogeneously on the plasma membrane of untreated cells. But, when Tetrahymena cells had been treated with 1.3 mM dibucaine for 5 min at growth temperature, freeze-fracture micrographs of the plasma membrane showed marked alterations. Although IMPs showed an almost homogeneous distribution, their density was elevated markedly on the protoplasmic fracture (PF) face but greatly reduce on the exoplasmic fracture (EF) face. Areas around deciliated portions had a reverse IMP density distribution for the PF and EF faces. These results suggest that dibucaine induced vertical displacement of the IMPs in the plasma membrane.     

The external limiting membrane in developing normal and dysplastic canine retina

Development of the external limiting membrane of the retina in English springer spaniel fetuses and neonates with incipient stages of retinal dysplasia and in normal mongrel fetuses and neonates was examined using transmission electron microscopy and the freeze-fracture technique. The external limiting membrane of the retina of normal canine fetuses was composed of zonulae adherentes in which there were focal areas of apparent apposition between adjacent ventricular cell membranes. Freeze-fracture examination revealed gap junctions within the external limiting membrane that were composed of 8-10 nm P-face particles in aggregates of variable size and shape. These junctions corresponded to areas of focal membrane apposition. Tight junction strands were also identified in deep E-face grooves which were located perpendicular to the external limiting membrane. At day 46 of gestation in incipiently dysplastic English springer spaniel fetal eyes, there was a marked decrease in the size and area occupied by gap junctions within the external limiting membrane as compared with retinas of mongrel control fetuses at the same age and of other age groups. This apparent loss of gap junctions, coincident with the incipient onset of histologically detectable dysplastic events in the sensory retina, may contribute to the morphogenesis of the defect.     

Spinous extensions on ciliary necklaces in ependymal cells

Summary In ependymal cells of the mouse the neck region of all cilia examined by means of transmission electron microscopy exhibited rows of electron-dense spines. These structures correspond to the ciliary necklace reported from freeze-etch studies, a structure presumed to serve as an energy-regulating system in motile cilia. Send offprint requests to: Institute of Neuropathology, Free University Berlin, Hindenburgdamm 30, 1 Berlin 45     

Ultrastructural localization of microtubule-associated proteins (MAP) 1 in cilia of the respiratory tract

The presence and localization of high molecular weight microtubule-associated proteins of the MAP 1 class in ciliated cells of porcine and rat respiratory tract was studied by immunoblotting and immunoelectron microscopy. Ciliary shafts of the porcine tracheal epithelium were isolated using a method that minimizes contamination of the preparation by other cellular fragments and fat. Immunoblotting with rabbit antibodies to bulk MAP 1 from hog brain clearly revealed the presence of anti-MAP 1-immunoreactive high molecular weight proteins of the MAP 1 size in these preparations. To localize MAP 1 proteins at the ultrastructural level, rat and porcine tracheal epithelia were embedded in LR White and subjected to immunogold electron microscopy. Anti-MAP 1-immunoreactive material was found at ciliary shafts and basal bodies, but not at basal feet or ciliary rootlets. Interestingly, the necklace region between the shaft and the basal body of the cilium was hardly reactive with anti-MAP 1 antibodies. This may indicate a reduced stability of ciliary microtubules in this region and could be an explanation why ciliary shafts in general break more easily there than elsewhere.     

Ultrastructure of cilia and flagella - back to the future!

Eukaryotic cilia and flagella perform motility and sensory functions which are essential for cell survival in protozoans, and to organism development and homoeostasis in metazoans. Their ultrastructure has been studied from the early beginnings of electron microscopy, and these studies continue to contribute to much of our understanding about ciliary biology. In the light of the progress made in the visualization of cellular structures over the last decade, we revisit the ultrastructure of cilia and flagella. We briefly describe the typical features of a 9+2 axoneme before focusing extensively on the transition zone, the ciliary necklace, the singlet zone, the ciliary cap and the ciliary crown. We discuss how the singlet zone is linked to sensory and/or motile function, the contribution of the ciliary crown to ovocyte and mucosal propulsion, and the relationship between the ciliary cap and microtubule growth and shortening, and its relation to ciliary beat. We further examine the involvement of the transition zone/the ciliary necklace in axonemal stabilization, autotomy and as a diffusion barrier.     

Occluding junctions and cytoskeletal components in a cultured transporting epithelium

To study the size and structure of the Na,K-pump molecule, the ultrastructure of phospholipid vesicles was examined after incorporation of purified Na,K-ATPase which catalyzes active coupled transport of Na+ and K+ in a ratio close to 3Na/2K. The vesicles were analyzed by thin sectioning and freeze-fracture electron microscopy after reconstitution with different ratios of Na,K-ATPase protein to lipid, and the ultrastructural observations were correlated to the cation transport capacity. The purified Na,K-ATPase reconstituted with phospholipids to form a very uniform population of vesicles. Thin sections of preparations fixed with glutaraldehyde and osmium tetroxide showed vesicles limited by a single membrane which in samples stained with tannic acid appeared triple-layered with a thickness of 70 A. Also, freeze-fracture electron microscopy demonstrated uniform vesicles with diameters in the range of 700-1,100 A and an average value close to 900 A. The vesicle diameter was independent of the amount of protein used for reconstitution. Intramembrane particles appeared only in the vesicle membrane after introduction of Na,K-ATPase and the frequency of intramembrane particles was proportional to the amount of Na,K-ATPase protein used in the reconstitution. The particles were evenly distributed on the inner and the outer leaflet of the vesicle membrane. The diameter of the particles was 90 A and similar to our previous values for the diameter of intramembrane particles in the purified Na,K-ATPase. The capacity for active cation transport in the reconstituted vesicles was proportional to the frequency of intramembrane particles over a range of 0.2-16 particles per vesicle. The data therefore show that active coupled Na,K transport can be carried out by units of Na,K-ATPase which appear as single intramembrane particles with diameters close fo 90 A in the freeze-fracture micrographs.     

Cultured peritoneal mesothelial cells exhibit apical primary cilia

This study examined primary cilia on cultured human and rabbit peritoneal mesothelial cells (PMC) and investigated factors that influence ciliary expression. Primary cilia were examined with indirect immunocytochemistry, laser scanning confocal microscopy and scanning electron microscopy. Ciliary expression was evaluated in cultures with or without l-cysteine (0.25 mM) or exposure to Ca(2+)-free Krebs-Ringer solution supplemented with EGTA, 0.5 mM. This treatment disrupted cell monolayer integrity. Cilia were counted and normalized to total cell counts using NIH image. Primary cilia were identified on both human and rabbit PMC. Cells treated with l-cysteine expressed significantly more cilia compared with monolayers deprived of l-cysteine. Exposure to Ca(2+)-free Krebs-Ringer solution significantly reduced cilia (5.9+/-1.0%, n=7). Although ciliary expression could be augmented with l-cysteine, approximately 60% of human PMC and 84% of rabbit PMC did not exhibit cilia. Together, these data show that monolayers of PMC express apical cilia that can be augmented with l-cysteine, independently of increased cell density.     

Determination of ciliary polarity precedes differentiation in the epithelial cells of quail oviduct.

In quail oviduct epithelium, as in all metazoan and protozoan ciliated cells, cilia beat in a coordinated cycle. They are arranged in a polarized pattern oriented according to the anteroposterior axis of the oviduct and are most likely responsible for transport of the ovum and egg white proteins from the infundibulum toward the uterus. Orientation of ciliary beating is related to that of the basal bodies, indicated by the location of the lateral basal foot, which points in the direction of the active stroke of ciliary beating. This arrangement of the ciliary cortex occurs as the ultimate step in ciliogenesis and following the oviduct development. Cilia first develop in a random orientation and reorient later, simultaneously with the development of the cortical cytoskeleton. In order to know when the final orientation of basal bodies and cilia is determined in the course of oviduct development, microsurgical reversal of a segment of the immature oviduct was performed. Then, after hormone-induced development and ciliogenesis, ciliary orientation was examined in the inverted segment and in normal parts of the ciliated epithelium. In the inverted segment, orientation was reversed, as shown by a video recording of the direction of effective flow produced by beating cilia, by the three-dimensional bending forms of cilia immobilized during the beating cycle and screened by scanning electron microscopy, and by the position of basal body appendages as seen in thin sections by transmission electron microscopy. These results demonstrate that basal body and ciliary orientation are irreversibly determined prior to development by an endogenous signal present early in the cells of the immature oviduct, transmitted to daughter cells during the proliferative phase and expressed at the end of ciliogenesis.     

Filipin-sterol complexes in molluscan gill ciliated epithelial cell membranes: intercalation into ciliary necklaces and induction of gap junctional particle arrays

Summary Freeze-fracture electron microscopy has been used in conjunction with the antibiotic filipin to investigate possible differences in the distribution of sterols in ciliary and somatic cell membranes of scallop and mussel gill epithelial cells. Contrary to previous reports, we find that filipin-sterol lesions can occur among the strands of the ciliary necklace but they are partially excluded from the smooth neck region above the necklace where the membrane is tightly apposed to the axonemal microtubules. No obvious differences in filipin-sterol lesions occur in the membranes of mussel gill cilia of varying mechanical sensitivity. Although abundant in the apical plasma membrane, filipin-sterol complexes are rare within the membranes of microvilli. Filipin-sterol lesions form outside the loosely parallel particle strands of septate junctions, sometimes increasing their relative orderliness. At sufficiently high density, filipin-sterol protrusions within the plasma membrane result in mass aggregation of gap junctions, possibly through recruitment of unorganized connexons.     

Ultrastructure of gill cilia and ciliary rootlets of Chaetoderma nitidulum Lovén 1844 (Mollusca, Chaetodermomorpha)

Cilia and associated structures on the gill lamellae on the ctenidum of Chaetoderma nitidulum were studied. The gill cilia are very long and have a whip-like narrow portion distally, where only three microtubule doublets continue to the distal tip. In the transition zone between the cilium and the centriolar triplet section of the basal body there is a dense plate, an aggregation of granules and a ciliary necklace with four strands. Further down there is a short cross-striated basal foot and two conical cross-striated ciliary rootlets. The first rootlet is flattened and directed forward. It connects distally with the basal feet of other adjacent cilia. The second rootlet is rounded in cross-section and vertically directed. The epithelial structures of Chaetoderma show similarities with other Mollusca. We found no structural characters that could support the current hypothesis of a close relationship of Xenoturbella to the Mollusca.     

Colocalization of tight junction proteins, occludin and ZO-1, and glucose transporter GLUT1 in cells of the blood-ocular barrier in the mouse eye

 The facilitative glucose transporter GLUT1 is abundant in cells of the blood-ocular barrier and serves as a glucose transport mechanism in the barrier. To see the relationship between the glucose transfer function and junctional proteins in the barrier, we examined the localization of GLUT1 and the tight junction proteins, occludin and ZO-1, in the mouse eye. Their localization in the retina, ciliary body, and iris was visualized by double-immunofluorescence microscopy and immunogold electron microscopy. Occludin and ZO-1 were colocalized at tight junctions of the cells of the barrier: retinal pigment epithelial cells, non-pigmented epithelial cells of the ciliary body, and endothelial cells of GLUT1-positive blood vessels. Occludin was restricted to these cells of the barrier. ZO-1 was found, in addition, in sites not functioning as a barrier: the outer limiting membrane in the retina, in the cell border between pigmented and non-pigmented epithelial cells in the ciliary body, and GLUT1-negative blood vessels. These observations show that localization of occludin is restricted to tight junctions of cells of the barrier, whereas ZO-1 is more widely distributed. Accepted: 7 September 1998     

Immunocytochemical localization of tubulin with colloidal gold in cilia of rabbit tracheal epithelial cultures

Ciliated tracheal epithelia cell cultures were investigated immunocytochemically with anti-tubulin and colloidal gold. When rabbit tracheal cultures were fixed in paraformaldehyde, treated with acetone, anti-tubulin and a second antibody coupled to FITC, fluorescence was associated with cytoskeletal and axonemal microtubules. Cilia covering the apical surface of the ciliated tracheal cells fluoresced very brightly thus facilitating identification of this cell type. Electron microscopy of tracheal cultures fixed as above, treated with Triton-X 100 and incubated in anti-tubulin and protein A coupled to colloidal gold resulted in the highly specific localization of tubulin in ciliary axonemes and basal bodies. Omission of primary or secondary antibody resulted in extremely low levels of fluorescence while no colloidal gold particles could be detected in cultures at the electron microscopy level when rabbit anti-tubulin was omitted.     

Cholesteryl hemisuccinate exhibits pH sensitive polymorphic phase behavior

Cholesteryl hemisuccinate (CHEMS) is an acidic cholesterol ester that self-assembles into bilayers in alkaline and neutral aqueous media and is commonly employed in mixtures with dioleoylphosphatidylethanolamine (DOPE) to form 'pH sensitive' fusogenic vesicles. We show here that CHEMS itself exhibits pH sensitive polymorphism. This is evident from the fusogenic properties of large unilamellar vesicles (LUV) composed of CHEMS and direct visualization employing freeze-fracture electron microscopy. Below pH 4.3, LUV composed of CHEMS undergo fusion as monitored by lipid mixing assays and freeze-fracture electron micrographs reveal the characteristic striated signature of H( parallel) phase lipid. It is suggested that the pH dependent phase preferences of CHEMS contribute to the pH sensitivity of LUV composed of mixtures of CHEMS and DOPE.     

The essential role of specific Halobacterium halobium polar lipids in 2D-array formation of bacteriorhodopsin.

The mechanism whereby bacteriorhodopsin (BR), the light driven proton pump from the purple membrane of Halobacterium halobium, arranges in a 2D-hexagonal array, has been studied in bilayers containing the protein, 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DMPC) and various fractions of H. halobium membrane lipids, by freeze fracture electron microscopy and examination of optical diffractograms of the micrographs obtained. Electron micrographs of BR/DMPC complexes containing the entire polar lipid component of H. halobium cell membranes or the total lipid component of the purple membrane, with a protein-to-total lipid molar ratio of less than 1:50 and to which 4 M NaCl had been added, revealed that trimers of BR formed into an hexagonal 2D-array similar to that found in the native purple membrane, suggesting that one or more types of the purple membrane polar lipids are required for array formation. To support this suggestion, bacteriorhodopsin was purified free of endogenous purple membrane lipids and reconstituted into lipid bilayer complexes by detergent dialysis. The lipids used to form these complexes are 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycerol-phosphocholine (DMPC) as the major lipid and, separately, each of the individual lipid types from the H. halobium cell membranes, namely 2,3-di-O-phytanyl-sn-glycero-1-phosphoryl-3'-sn-glycerol 1'-phosphate (DPhPGP), 2,3-di-O-phytanyl-sn-glycero-1-phosphoryl-3'-sn-glycerol 1'-sulphate (DPhPGS), 2,3-di-O-phytanyl-sn-glycero-1-phosphoryl-3'-sn-glycerol (DPhPG) and 2,3-di-O-phytanyl-1-O-[beta-D-Galp-3-sulphate-(1----6)-alpha-D- Manp-(1----2)-alpha-D-Glcp]-sn-glycerol (DPhGLS). When examined by freeze-fracture electron microscopy, only the complexes containing 2,3-di-O-phytanyl-sn-glycero-1-phosphoryl-3'-sn-glycerol- 1'-phosphate or 2,3-di-O-phytanyl-sn-glycero-1-phosphoryl-3'-sn-glycerol-1'-sulphate, at high protein density (less than 1:50, bacteriorhodopsin/phospholipid, molar ratio) and to which 4 M NaCl had been added, showed well defined 2D hexagonal arrays of bacteriorhodopsin trimers similar to those observed in the purple membrane of H. halobium.     

Organization of calcium pump protein dimers in the isolated sarcoplasmic reticulum membrane.

The arrangement of the calcium pump protein in the isolated sarcoplasmic reticulum (SR) membrane was examined by optical diffraction of freeze-fracture electron micrographs. Several states of protein particle organization were observed: random, hexagonal and tetragonal packing, and a mixture of hexagonal and tetragonal packing. This suggests that the time-averaged positions of protein particles in the plane of the SR membrane are weakly defined. In addition, there appears to be a greater degree of local or short-range order compared to long-range order within the field of freeze-fracture particles. We utilized measurements from tetragonally or hexagonally packed arrays to determine a unit cell area occupied by each freeze-fracture particle and its associated lipid matrix. When these unit cell areas and the stereologically determined area per freeze-fracture particle were compared to the cross-sectional area occupied by a single calcium pump protein and its associated lipid, obtained by x-ray and neutron diffraction methods, we concluded that each freeze-fracture particle probably represents a dimer of pump protein molecules in the plane of the SR membrane.