Specificity of mutations induced in transfected DNA by mammalian cells

DNA transfected into mammalian cells is subject to the high mutation frequency of approximately 1% per gene. We present data bearing on the derivation of the two main classes of mutations detected, base substitutions and deletions. The DNA sequence change is reported for nearly 100 independent base substitution mutations that occurred in shuttle vectors as a result of passage in simian cells. All of the mutations occur at G:C base pairs and involve either transition to A:T or transversion to T:A. To identify possible mutational intermediates, various topological forms of the vector DNA were introduced separately. Supercoiled and relaxed DNA are mutated at equal frequencies. However, linearized DNA leads to a greatly elevated frequency of deletions. Nicked and gapped templates stimulate both deletions and base substitutions. We discuss a model involving intracellular degradation of the transfected DNA which explains these observations.     

Development of a yeast system to assay mutational specificity

We have developed a system wherein DNA alterations occurring in a target gene in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae can be determined by DNA sequencing. The target gene, SUP4-o, an ochre suppressor allele of a yeast tyrosine tRNA gene, has been inserted into a shuttle vector (YCpMP2) which is maintained in yeast at a copy number of one per cell Mutations in SUP4-o are selected by virtue of their inactivation of suppressor activity. Rapid DNA preparations from these mutants are used to transform an appropriate bacterial strain. Since YCpMP2 also carries the M13 phage replication origin, superinfection of bacterial cells containing the plasmid with wild-type M13 phage yields single stranded YCpMP2 DNA suitable for dideoxynucleotide chain termination sequencing. We have used this system to examine mutations arising spontaneously in the SUP4-o gene. The spontaneous mutants occurred at a frequency of 3.2 X 10(-6)/viable cell, corresponding to a rate of 2.7 X 10(-7) events/cell division. Following bacterial transformation, 16% of the recovered plasmids tested displayed altered gel mobility consistent with loss of significant portions of the plasmid. Hybridization analysis of total yeast DNA and use of purified YCpMP2 revealed that these very large deletions were not generated in yeast but were associated with bacterial transformation. Among the SUP4-o mutants analyzed by DNA sequencing, we identified each type of single base pair substitution (transitions and transversions), small deletions of varying length (1-32 base pairs) and more extensive deletions of undetermined size. These results demonstrate that the SUP4-o system can be used to detect various types of mutation at numerous sites in a single eukaryotic gene and to characterize the DNA sequence changes responsible for the mutations selected.     

Transfected DNA is mutated in monkey, mouse, and human cells.

Papovavirus-based shuttle vectors containing the bacterial lacI gene were used to show that a mutation frequency in the range of 1% occurs in lacI when such vectors are transfected into COS7 and CV-1 simian cells, NIH 3T3, 3T6, L, and C127 mouse cells, and human 293 and HeLa cells. This frequency is approximately four orders of magnitude higher than the spontaneous mutation frequency in either mammalian or bacterial cells. The mutations are predominantly base substitutions and deletions and also include insertions from the mammalian genome. Time course experiments argue that mutagenesis occurs soon after arrival of the DNA into the nucleus. However, replication of the vector is not required since mutations occur even when the vector lacks all viral sequences. The high mutation frequency appears to be the characteristic outcome of transfection of DNA into mammalian cells.     

Published data on mutagenesis by ionizing radiation of plasmids in solution probably reflect in part the specificity of adventitious transition metal ions complexed to the DNA

A number of recent papers show that single base changes induced by mutagenesis with ionizing radiation of genes on plasmids in solution, followed by transfection into mammalian or bacterial cells for assay, are mostly at G:C base pairs, with mutagenic hot spots. Genes irradiated in mammalian or bacterial cells, on the other hand, have comparable numbers of base changes at all sites, with no evidence for hot spots. The differences are ascribed to induction of many base change mutations in vitro by reactions catalyzed by adventitious transition metal ions complexed to the DNA. Reasons are given why this process should play a much smaller role in vivo.     

Effect of double-strand breaks on homologous recombination in mammalian cells and extracts.

We examined the effect of double-strand breaks on homologous recombination between two plasmids in human cells and in nuclear extracts prepared from human and rodent cells. Two pSV2neo plasmids containing nonreverting, nonoverlapping deletions were cotransfected into cells or incubated with cell extracts. Generation of intact neo genes was monitored by the ability of the DNA to confer G418r to cells or Neor to bacteria. We show that double-strand breaks at the sites of the deletions enhanced recombination frequency, whereas breaks outside the neo gene had no effect. Examination of the plasmids obtained from experiments involving the cell extracts revealed that gene conversion events play an important role in the generation of plasmids containing intact neo genes. Studies with plasmids carrying multiple polymorphic genetic markers revealed that markers located within 1,000 base pairs could be readily coconverted. The frequency of coconversion decreased with increasing distance between the markers. The plasmids we constructed along with the in vitro system should permit a detailed analysis of homologous recombinational events mediated by mammalian enzymes.     

Published data on mutagenesis by ionizing radiation of plasmids in solution probably reflect in part the specificity of adventitious transition metal ions complexed to the DNA.

A number of recent papers show that single base changes induced by mutagenesis with ionizing radiation of genes on plasmids in solution, followed by transfection into mammalian or bacterial cells for assay, are mostly at G:C base pairs, with mutagenic hot spots. Genes irradiated in mammalian or bacterial cells, on the other hand, have comparable numbers of base changes at all sites, with no evidence for hot spots. The differences are ascribed to induction of many base change mutations in vitro by reactions catalyzed by adventitious transition metal ions complexed to the DNA. Reasons are given why this process should play a much smaller role in vivo.     

Nonviable mutants of simian virus 40 with deletions near the 3'' end of gene A define a function for large T antigen required after onset of viral DNA replication

Deletion mutants of simian virus 40 (SV40) with lesions at the three DdeI sites near the 3' end of the early region were constructed. Mutants with deletions at 0.203 and 0.219 map units (mu) which did not change the large T antigen reading frame were viable. This extends slightly the upstream boundary for the location of viable mutants with deletions in the 3' end of the A gene. Mutants with frameshift deletions at 0.193 and 0.219 mu were nonviable. These are the first nonviable mutants with deletions in this portion of the A gene. None of the three nonviable mutants with deletions at 0.219 mu produced progeny viral DNA. These three mutants all used the alternate reading frame located in this portion of the SV40 early region. The mutant with a deletion at 0.193 mu, dlA2459, was positive for viral DNA replication and was defective for adenovirus helper function. All of these mutations were located in the portion of the SV40 large T antigen which has no homology to the polyoma T antigens. These results indicate that this portion of large T antigen is required for some late step in the viral growth cycle and suggest that adenovirus helper function is required for productive infection by SV40.     

DNA methylation: evolution of a bacterial immune function into a regulator of gene expression and genome structure in higher eukaryotes

The amino acid sequence of mammalian DNA methyltransferase has been deduced from the nucleotide sequence of a cloned cDNA. It appears that the mammalian enzyme arose during evolution via fusion of a prokaryotic restriction methyltransferase gene and a second gene of unknown function. Mammalian DNA methyltransferase currently comprises an N-terminal domain of about 1000 amino acids that may have a regulatory role and a C-terminal 570 amino acid domain that retains similarities to bacterial restriction methyltransferases. The sequence similarities among mammalian and bacterial DNA cytosine methyltransferases suggest a common evolutionary origin. DNA methylation is uncommon among those eukaryotes having genomes of less than 10(8) base pairs, but nearly universal among large-genome eukaryotes. This and other considerations make it likely that sequence inactivation by DNA methylation has evolved to compensate for the expansion of the genome that has accompanied the development of higher plants and animals. As methylated sequences are usually propagated in the repressed, nuclease-insensitive state, it is likely that DNA methylation compartmentalizes the genome to facilitate gene regulation by reducing the total amount of DNA sequence that must be scanned by DNA-binding regulatory proteins. DNA methylation is involved in immune recognition in bacteria but appears to regulate the structure and expression of the genome in complex higher eukaryotes. I suggest that the DNA-methylating system of mammals was derived from that of bacteria by way of a hypothetical intermediate that carried out selective de novo methylation of exogenous DNA and propagated the methylated DNA in the repressed state within its own genome.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Malondialdehyde,a product of lipid peroxidation,is mutagenic in human cells

Malondialdehyde (MDA) is an endogenous genotoxic product of enzymatic and oxygen radical-induced lipid peroxidation whose adducts are known to exist in DNA isolated from healthy human beings. To evaluate the mutagenic potential of MDA in human cells, we reacted MDA with pSP189 shuttle vector DNA and then transfected them into human fibroblasts for replication. MDA induced up to a 15-fold increase in mutation frequency in the supF reporter gene compared with untreated DNA. Sequence analysis revealed that the majority of MDA-induced mutations occurred at GC base pairs. The most frequent mutations were large insertions and deletions, but base pair substitutions were also detected. MDA-induced mutations were completely abolished when the adducted shuttle vector was replicated in cells lacking nucleotide excision repair. MDA induction of large deletions and the apparent requirement for nucleotide excision repair suggested the possible involvement of a DNA interstrand cross-link as a premutagenic lesion. Indeed, MDA formed interstrand cross-links in duplex plasmids and oligonucleotides. Substrates containing the sequence 5'-d(CG) were preferentially cross-linked, consistent with the observation of base pair substitutions in 5'-d(CG) sites in the MDA-induced mutation spectrum. These experiments provide biological and biochemical evidence for the existence of MDA-induced DNA interstrand cross-links that could result from endogenous oxidative stress and likely have potent biological effects.     

Formation of deletions after initiation of simian virus 40 replication: influence of packaging limit of the capsid.

Transfected DNA is frequently broken and rejoined in mammalian cells by recombination processes that depend on minimal nucleotide sequence homology. Although measurements of breakage and joining account reasonably well for the frequent formation of deletions during transfection, they are inadequate to explain the high frequency of deletion formation by simian virus 40 (SV40) genomes that are slightly larger than the packaging limit of the capsid. To investigate this anomaly, we constructed and transfected into CV-1 cells a series of modified SV40 genomes containing 136, 284, 460, and 656 extra base pairs in the intron of the gene encoding T antigen. These experiments indicate that the effective packaging limit of an SV40 capsid lies between 284 and 460 extra base pairs. Further analysis of these transfections suggests that molecules just above the effective packaging limit may be encapsidated and transmitted between cells at low efficiency, thereby allowing multiple rounds of replication and multiple opportunities to generate and package genomes that contain deletions. The junctional sequences in several such deletions were determined; they were similar to the junctions in deletions that were formed before replication began, suggesting that the enzymatic machinery responsible for both types of deletion may be similar.     

Characterization of carbadox-induced mutagenesis using a shuttle vector pSP189 in mammalian cells

Carbadox, a quinoxaline 1,4-dioxide derivative, is a known mutagen with its functional mechanism yet to be well defined. In the present study we used a shuttle vector assay in vitro to uncover the functional details of carbadox-induced mutagenesis in mammalian cells. The plasmid DNA of a shuttle vector pSP189 was treated with different doses of carbadox at 37 degrees C for 1 or 2h with or without the presence of S9. The target gene SupF in the plasmid was sequenced after replication in Vero cells followed by amplification in Escherichia coli MBM7070 to evaluate mutation frequency. DNA sequencing analysis of recovered carbadox-induced mutations revealed 76.3% single base substitution, 7.9% single base insertion, 10.5% single base deletion and 5.3% large fragments deletion. All single base substitutions occurred at G:C base pairs, among which transversion and transition occurred at a 2:1 ratio. The mutations did not occur randomly in the supF gene, but had sequence specificity and hotspots instead: most substitutions were detected at the nucleotide N in a 5'-NNTTNN-3' sequence; 75% of base insertions were seen in the 5'-TCC-3' sequence; whereas all large fragments deletions occurred in the 5'-ANGGCCNAAA-3' sequence. Nucleotide 129, 141 and 155 in the supF gene of plasmid pSP189 were identified as the hotspots for carbadox-induced mutations that accounted for 65% of all single base substitutions. We conclude that carbadox and its metabolites induce sequence-specific DNA mutations at high frequencies, therefore its safe usage in animal husbandry should be seriously considered.     

Kinds and spectrum of mutations induced by 1-nitrosopyrene adducts during plasmid replication in human cells.

1-Nitropyrene has been shown in bacterial assays to be the principal mutagenic agent in diesel emission particulates. It has also been shown to be mutagenic in human fibroblasts and carcinogenic in animals. To investigate the kinds of mutations induced by this carcinogen and compare them with those induced by a structurally related carcinogen, (+/-)-7 beta,8 alpha-dihydroxy-9 alpha,10 alpha-epoxy-7,8,9,10-tetra-hydrobenzo [a]pyrene (BPDE) (J.-L. Yang, V. M. Maher, and J. J. McCormick, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 84:3787-3791, 1987), we treated a shuttle vector with tritiated 1-nitrosopyrene (1-NOP), a carcinogenic mutagenic intermediate metabolite of 1-nitropyrene which forms the same DNA adduct as the parent compound, and introduced the plasmids into a human embryonic kidney cell line, 293, for DNA replication to take place. The treated plasmid, pZ189, carrying a bacterial suppressor tRNA target gene, supF, was allowed 48 h to replicate in the human cells. Progeny plasmids were then rescued, purified, and introduced into bacteria carrying an amber mutation in the beta-galactosidase gene in order to detect those carrying mutations in the supF gene. The frequency of mutants increased in direct proportion to the number of DNA-1-NOP adducts formed per plasmid. At the highest level of adduct formation tested, the frequency of supF mutants was 26 times higher than the background frequency of 1.4 X 10(-4). DNA sequencing of 60 unequivocally independent mutant derived from 1-NOP-treated plasmids indicated that 80% contained a single base substitution, 5% had two base substitutions, 4% had small insertions or deletions (1 or 2 base pairs), and 11% showed a deletion or insertion of 4 or more base pairs. Sequence data from 25 supF mutants derived from untreated plasmids showed that 64% contained deletions of 4 or more base pairs. The majority (83%) of the base substitution in mutants from 1-NOP-treated plasmids were transversions, with 73% of these being G . C --> T . A. This is very similar to what we found previously in this system, using BPDE, but each carcinogen produced its own spectrum of mutations. Of the five hot spots for base substitution mutations produced in the supF gene with 1-NOP, two were the same as seen with BPDE-treated plasmids. However, the three other hot spots were cold spots for BPDE-treated plasmids. Conversely, four of the other five hot spots seen with BPDE-treated plasmids were cold spots for 1-NOP-treated plasmids. Comparison of the two carcinogens for the frequency of supF mutants induced per DNA adduct showed that 1-NOP-induced adducts were 3.8 times less than BPDE adducts. However, the 293 cell excised 1-NOP-induced adducts faster than BPDE adducts.     

Description of a new amplifiable shuttle vector for mutagenesis studies in human cells: application to N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine-induced mutation spectrum.

In order to analyze the mechanisms of mutagenesis in human cells, we have established a human 293 cell-derived line containing a permanent mutagenesis target, the bacterial lacZ' gene, on an episomal EBV/SV40-based shuttle vector. This plasmid was maintained at a low copy number per cell which rendered it closer to an endogenous gene as compared to the usual transient shuttle vectors. Transient amplification of vectors, inside the host cell due to expression of the SV40 T-antigen, allowed the recovery of a large number of bacterial colonies transformed by plasmids extracted from human cells. Mutations produced in human host cells on the lacZ' locus were easily and rapidly scored and identified in bacteria using the blue/white color assay. Over a 6-month period in culture, we have shown that the lacZ' gene exhibited a low background frequency of point mutations (< 4.8 x 10(-6)). The efficiency of our system for detecting genotoxic-induced mutations was investigated by treating cells with a potent mutagen, the direct alkylating agent N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine (MNNG). A significant increase (< 230-fold) in the frequency of single-base substitutions was observed after MNNG treatment. In total, 63 MNNG-induced independent mutations were characterized. All substitutions but one involved G:C base pairs with 89% being G:C to A:T transitions which is consistent with the MNNG mutagenic specificity already reported in bacteria and mammalian cells. Mutations were distributed along the two strands of the lacZ' gene and there was no obvious influence of either the 5' or the 3' flanking base near the G:C to A:T transition sites. The low spontaneous point mutation frequency on the mutagenesis locus and the ability to detect induced point mutations indicate that this system could be readily used in human mutagenesis studies at the molecular level.     

Structures of spontaneous deletions in Caenorhabditis elegans.

We have investigated the structural features of spontaneous deletions in Caenorhabditis elegans. We cloned and sequenced the junctions of 16 spontaneous deletions affecting the unc-54 myosin heavy-chain gene and compared their sequences with those of the wild type. We analyzed these sequences in an attempt to identify structural features of the gene that are consistently involved in the spontaneous deletion process. Most deletions (15 of 16) removed a single contiguous region of DNA, with no nucleotides inserted or rearranged at the deletion junctions; one deletion was more complex. unc-54 deletions were small, averaging 600 base pairs in length, and were randomly distributed throughout the gene. Unlike deletions that occur in Escherichia coli, spontaneous unc-54 deletions did not contain statistically significant direct or inverted repeats at or near their termini. Except for their small average size, we have not identified any distinguishing features of their sequence or structure. We discuss these results with regard to the mechanisms for spontaneous deletion in eucaryotic and procaryotic cells.     

Mutational specificity of benzo[a]pyrene diolepoxide in monkey cells

Benzo[a]pyrene diolepoxide (BPDE) is thought to be the major mutagenic and carcinogenic intermediate in benzo[a]pyrene metabolism in mammalian cells. In order to test the mutagenic specificity of this compound in mammalian cells, we have used the pZ189 shuttle vector system to identify and analyze point mutations induced when DNA treated in vitro with BPDE is replicated in monkey cells. We find that point mutations occur almost exclusively at G.C base pairs; G.C----T.A and G.C----C.G transversions and single base pair deletions occur most frequently. This pattern is consistent with the known preferential covalent binding of BPDE to G residues.     

The mutagenic spectrum of acridine-linked aniline nitrogen mustards in AS52 cells: implications of DNA targeting with high selectivity for adenine or guanine bases

The mutational spectra generated in AS52 cells at the gpt gene locus by aniline mustards were studied by the isolation of resistant clones and sequencing of the altered gene. A set of four aniline mustards (both mono- and bifunctional) linked to a DNA-affinic 9-aminoacridine (9-AA) carrier was used, together with the untargeted mustards chlorambucil (CHL) and its half-mustard, and the DNA binding carrier, 9-AA. Both 9-AA and CHL were weak cytotoxins, with the DNA-targeted mustards being markedly (10-40-fold) more dose potent, and the bifunctional ones somewhat more toxic than the monofunctional ones. 9-AA produced a different spectrum of mutations to the spontaneous background, with more minor addition events and less base pair substitutions, and showing for the first time that frameshift events so characteristic of 9-AA in bacteria or bacteriophage also occur in mammalian cells. The mutational spectra of the DNA-targeted mustards were quite different both from this and from the lesions caused by the untargeted mustards, which cause largely transition mutations at AT sites (despite a clear preference for formation of N(7)-guanine adducts). There were very few transition mutations, suggesting that the initial O(6)-alkylguanine/O(4)-alkylthymine lesions considered to give rise to these are relatively rare. There was also a lower incidence of complete deletions, usually attributed to DNA cross-links. For the short chain length targeted mustards, which form initial stable adducts largely (95%) at guanine N(7) sites, base pair substitution mutations, predominantly transversions, involved AT and GC base pairs equally. In contrast, the longer chain length targeted mustards, which form >90% of initial adducts at adenine N(1) sites, generated also formed transversion mutations, but these overwhelmingly (24/27) involved AT base pairs.     

Targeted gene repair directed by the chimeric RNA/DNA oligonucleotide in a mammalian cell-free extract.

Chimeric oligonucleotides consisting of RNA and DNA residues have been shown to catalyze site-directed genetic alteration in mammalian cells both in vitro and in vivo. Since the frequency of these events appears to be logs higher than the rates of gene targeting, a process involving homologous recombination, we developed a system to study the mechanisms of chimera-directed gene conversion. Using a mammalian cell-free extract and a genetic readout in Escherichia coli, we find that point mutations and single base deletions can be corrected at frequencies of approximately 0.1% and 0.005%, respectively. The reaction depends on an accurately designed chimera and the presence of functional hMSH2 protein. The results of genetic and biochemical studies reported herein suggest that the process of mismatch repair functions in site-directed gene correction.     

Efficient correction of mismatched bases in plasmid heteroduplexes injected into cultured mammalian cell nuclei.

Heteroduplexes were prepared from two plasmids, pRH4-14/TK and pRH5-8/TK, containing different amber mutations in the neomycin resistance gene (Neor). The Neor gene was engineered to be expressed in both bacterial and mammalian cells. A functional Neor gene conferred kanamycin resistance to bacteria and resistance to the drug G418 to mammalian cells. In addition, the plasmids contained restriction site polymorphisms which did not confer a selectable phenotype but were used to follow the pattern of correction of mismatched bases in the heteroduplexes. In a direct comparison of the efficiency of transforming mouse LMtk- cells to G418r, the injection of heteroduplexes of pRH4-14/TK-pRH5-8/TK was 10-fold more efficient than the coinjection of pRH4-14/TK and pRH5-8/TK linear plasmid DNA. In fact, injection of 5 to 10 molecules of heteroduplex DNA per cell was as efficient in transforming LMtk- cells to G418r as the injection of 5 to 10 molecules of linear plasmid DNA per cell containing a wild-type Neor gene. To determine the pattern of mismatch repair of the injected heteroduplexes, plasmids were "rescued" from the G418r cell lines. From this analysis we conclude that the generation of wild-type Neor genes from heteroduplex DNA proceeds directly by correction of the mismatched bases, rather than by alternative mechanisms such as recombination between the injected heteroduplexes. Our finding that a cell can efficiently correct mismatched bases when confronted with preformed heteroduplexes suggests that this experimental protocol could be used to study a wide range of DNA repair mechanisms in cultured mammalian cells.