Polymorphism at residue 129 modulates the conformational conversion of the D178N variant of human prion protein 90-231

One of the arguments in favor of the protein-only hypothesis of transmissible spongiform encephalopathies is the link between inherited prion diseases and specific mutations in the PRNP gene. One such mutation (Asp178 --> Asn) is associated with two distinct disorders: fatal familial insomnia or familial Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease, depending upon the presence of Met or Val at position 129, respectively. In this study, we have characterized the biophysical properties of recombinant human prion proteins (huPrP90-231) corresponding to the polymorphic variants D178N/M129 and D178N/V129. In comparison to the wild-type protein, both polymorphic forms of D178N huPrP show a greatly increased propensity for a conversion to beta-sheet-rich oligomers (at acidic pH) and thioflavine T-positive amyloid fibrils (at neutral pH). Importantly, the conversion propensity for the D178N variant is strongly dependent upon the M/V polymorphism at position 129, whereas under identical experimental conditions, no such dependence is observed for the wild-type protein. Amyloid fibrils formed by wild-type huPrP90-231 and the D178N variant are characterized by different secondary structures, and these structures are further modulated by residue 129 polymorphism. Although on the basis of only in vitro data, this study strongly suggests that polymorphism-dependent phenotypic variability of familial prion diseases may be linked to differences in biophysical properties of prion protein variants.     

The presence of valine at residue 129 in human prion protein accelerates amyloid formation

The polymorphism at residue 129 of the human PRNP gene modulates disease susceptibility and the clinico-pathological phenotypes in human transmissible spongiform encephalopathies. The molecular mechanisms by which the effect of this polymorphism are mediated remain unclear. It has been shown that the folding, dynamics and stability of the physiological, alpha-helix-rich form of recombinant PrP are not affected by codon 129 polymorphism. Consistent with this, we have recently shown that the kinetics of amyloid formation do not differ between protein containing methionine at codon 129 and valine at codon 129 when the reaction is initiated from the alpha-monomeric PrP(C)-like state. In contrast, we have shown that the misfolding pathway leading to the formation of beta-sheet-rich, soluble oligomer was favoured by the presence of methionine, compared with valine, at position 129. In the present work, we examine the effect of this polymorphism on the kinetics of an alternative misfolding pathway, that of amyloid formation using partially folded PrP allelomorphs. We show that the valine 129 allelomorph forms amyloids with a considerably shorter lag phase than the methionine 129 allelomorph both under spontaneous conditions and when seeded with pre-formed amyloid fibres. Taken together, our studies demonstrate that the effect of the codon 129 polymorphism depends on the specific misfolding pathway and on the initial conformation of the protein. The inverse propensities of the two allelomorphs to misfold in vitro through the alternative oligomeric and amyloidogenic pathways could explain some aspects of prion diseases linked to this polymorphism such as age at onset and disease incubation time.     

Methionine 129 variant of human prion protein oligomerizes more rapidly than the valine 129 variant: implications for disease susceptibility to Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease

The human PrP gene (PRNP) has two common alleles that encode either methionine or valine at codon 129. This polymorphism modulates disease susceptibility and phenotype of human transmissible spongiform encyphalopathies, but the molecular mechanism by which these effects are mediated remains unclear. Here, we compared the misfolding pathway that leads to the formation of beta-sheet-rich oligomeric isoforms of the methionine 129 variant of PrP to that of the valine 129 variant. We provide evidence for differences in the folding behavior between the two variants at the early stages of oligomer formation. We show that Met(129) has a higher propensity to form beta-sheet-rich oligomers, whereas Val(129) has a higher tendency to fold into alpha-helical-rich monomers. An equimolar mixture of both variants displayed an intermidate folding behavior. We show that the oligomers of both variants are initially a mixture of alpha- and beta-rich conformers that evolve with time to an increasingly homogeneous beta-rich form. This maturation process, which involves no further change in proteinase K resistance, occurs more rapidly in the Met(129) form than the Val(129) form. Although the involvement of such beta-rich oligomers in prion pathogenesis is speculative, the misfolding behavior could, in part, explain the higher susceptibility of individuals that are methionine homozygote to both sporadic and variant Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease.     

The amyloid state of proteins in human diseases

Amyloid fibers and oligomers are associated with a great variety of human diseases including Alzheimer's disease and the prion conditions. Here we attempt to connect recent discoveries on the molecular properties of proteins in the amyloid state with observations about pathological tissues and disease states. We summarize studies of structure and nucleation of amyloid and relate these to observations on amyloid polymorphism, prion strains, coaggregation of pathogenic proteins in tissues, and mechanisms of toxicity and transmissibility. Molecular studies have also led to numerous strategies for biological and chemical interventions against amyloid diseases.     

Rapid formation of amyloid from alpha-monomeric recombinant human PrP in vitro

The infectious agent of prion diseases is identified with PrP(Sc), a beta-rich, amyloidogenic and partially protease resistant isoform of the cellular glycoprotein, PrP(C). To understand the process of prion formation in vivo, we and others have studied defined misfolding pathways of recombinant PrP in vitro. The low-level infectivity of the in vitro misfolded murine PrP amyloid has recently been reported. Here we analyze the in vitro kinetics of amyloid formation from recombinant human PrP(90-231) in vitro in the context of two common allelic forms of PrP found in human populations that are associated with differences in prion disease susceptibility and pathological phenotype. We show that human PrP amyloid forms readily from its PrP(C)-like state in vitro, that the lag time of the reaction can be further shortened by the presence of a "seed" of pre-formed PrP amyloid, and that amyloid propagation is more complex than a simple crystallization process. We further show that the kinetics of amyloid formation do not differ between the Met129 and Val129 allelomorphs of human PrP, and that amyloid from each functions as an equally effective seed in heterologous, as in homologous amyloid reactions. The results could illuminate the process of amyloid formation in vivo as well as help understanding prion pathogenesis.     

Role of N-terminal familial mutations in prion protein fibrillization and prion amyloid propagation in vitro

A self-perpetuating conformational conversion of the prion protein (PrP) is believed to underlie pathology and transmission of prion diseases. Here we explore the effects of N-terminal pathogenic mutations (P102L, P105L, A117V) and the residue 129 polymorphism on amyloid fibril formation by the human PrP fragment 23-144, an in vitro conversion model that can reproduce certain characteristics of prion replication such as strains and species barriers. We find that these amino acid substitutions neither affect PrP23-144 amyloidogenicity nor introduce barriers to cross-seeding of soluble protein. However, the polymorphism strongly influences the conformation of the amyloid fibrils, as determined by infrared spectroscopy. Intriguingly, unlike conformational features governed by the critical amyloidogenic region of PrP23-144 (residues 138-139), the structural features distinguishing Met-129 and Val-129 PrP23-144 amyloid fibrils are not transmissible by cross-seeding. While based only on in vitro data, these findings provide fundamental insight into the mechanism of prion-based conformational transmission, indicating that only conformational features controlling seeding specificity (e.g. those in critical intermolecular contact sites of amyloid fibrils) are necessarily transmissible by cross-seeding; conformational traits in other parts of the PrP molecule may not be "heritable" from the amyloid template.     

Amyloid fibrils of mammalian prion protein are highly toxic to cultured cells and primary neurons

A growing body of evidence indicates that small, soluble oligomeric species generated from a variety of proteins and peptides rather than mature amyloid fibrils are inherently highly cytotoxic. Here, we show for the first time that mature amyloid fibrils produced from full-length recombinant mammalian prion protein (rPrP) were highly toxic to cultured cells and primary hippocampal and cerebella neurons. Fibrils induced apoptotic cell death in a time- and dose-dependent manner. The toxic effect of fibrils was comparable with that exhibited by soluble small beta-oligomers generated from the same protein. Fibrils prepared from insulin were not toxic, suggesting that the toxic effect was not solely due to the highly polymeric nature of the fibrillar form. The cell death caused by rPrP fibrils or beta-oligomers was substantially reduced when expression of endogenous PrP(C) was down-regulated by small interfering RNAs. In opposition to the beta-oligomer and amyloid fibrils of rPrP, the monomeric alpha-helical form of rPrP stimulated neurite out-growth and survival of neurons. These studies illustrated that both soluble beta-oligomer and amyloid fibrils of the prion protein are intrinsically toxic and confirmed that endogenously expressed PrP(C) is required for mediating the toxicity of abnormally folded external PrP aggregates.     

Is the prevalent human prion protein 129M/V mutation a living fossil from a Paleolithic panzootic superprion pandemic?

Prion diseases are consistently associated with prion protein (PrP^C) misfolding rendering a cascade of auto-catalytic self-perpetuation of misfolded PrP in an afflicted individual. The molecular process is intriguingly similar to all known amyloid diseases both local and systemic. The prion disease is also infectious by the transfer of misfolded PrP from one individual to the next. Transmissibility is surprisingly efficient in prion diseases and given the rapid disease progression following initial symptoms the prionoses stand out from other amyloidoses, which all may be transmissible under certain circumstances. The nature of the infectious prion as well as the genotype of the host is important for transmissibility. For hitherto unexplained reasons the majority of Europeans carry a missense mutation on one or both alleles of the PrP gene (PRNP), and hence express a variant of PrP with a substitution for valine (V) instead of methionine (M) in position 129. In fact the 129M/V variant is very common in all populations except for the Japanese. Sporadic Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease is a disease rarely striking people below the age of 60, where homozygosity especially 129MM is a very strong risk factor. Paradoxically, the 129M/V polymorphism suggestive of heterozygote advantage is one of the most clear cut disease associated traits of the human population, yet prion disease is extraordinarily rare. The genetic basis for how this trait spread with such prevalence within human populations is still target to investigations and deserves attention. This short essay represents a somewhat provocative hypothetical notion of a possible ancient significance of this polymorphism.     

Burial of the Polymorphic Residue 129 in Amyloid Fibrils of Prion Stop Mutants

Misfolding of the natively α-helical prion protein into a β-sheet rich isoform is related to various human diseases such as Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease and Gerstmann-Sträussler-Scheinker syndrome. In humans, the disease phenotype is modified by a methionine/valine polymorphism at codon 129 of the prion protein gene. Using a combination of hydrogen/deuterium exchange coupled to NMR spectroscopy, hydroxyl radical probing detected by mass spectrometry, and site-directed mutagenesis, we demonstrate that stop mutants of the human prion protein have a conserved amyloid core. The 129 residue is deeply buried in the amyloid core structure, and its mutation strongly impacts aggregation. Taken together the data support a critical role of the polymorphic residue 129 of the human prion protein in aggregation and disease.     

Copper has differential effect on prion protein with polymorphism of position 129

The pathology of human prion diseases is affected by polymorphism at amino acid residue 129 of the prion protein gene. Recombinant mouse prion proteins mimicking either form of the polymorphism were prepared to examine their effect on the conformation and the level of superoxide dismutase (SOD) activity of the prion protein. Following the binding of copper atoms to prion protein, antibody mapping and CD analysis detected conformational differences between the two forms of protein. However, neither the level of copper binding nor the level of SOD activity associated with this form of prion protein altered with the identity of codon 129. These results suggest that in the holo-metal binding form of the protein, prion structure but not its SOD activity is affected by polymorphism at codon 129.     

Conformation-dependent scFv antibodies specifically recognize the oligomers assembled from various amyloids and show colocalization of amyloid fibrils with oligomers in patients with amyloidoses

Increasing evidence indicates that amyloid aggregates, including oligomers, protofibrils or fibrils, are pivotal toxins in the pathogenesis of many amyloidoses such as Alzheimer's disease (AD), Parkinson's disease, Huntington's disease, prion-related diseases, type 2 diabetes and hereditary renal amyloidosis. Various oligomers assembled from different amyloid proteins share common structures and epitopes. Here we present data indicating that two oligomer-specific single chain variable fragment (scFv) antibodies isolated from a na?ve human scFv library could conformation-dependently recognize oligomers assembled from α-synuclein, amylin, insulin, Aβ1-40, prion peptide 106-126 and lysozyme, and fibrils from lysozyme. Further investigation showed that both scFvs inhibited the fibrillization of α-synuclein, amylin, insulin, Aβ1-40 and prion peptide 106-126, and disaggregated their preformed fibrils. However, they both promoted the aggregation of lysozyme. Nevertheless, the two scFv antibodies could attenuate the cytotoxicity of all amyloids tested. Moreover, the scFvs recognized the amyloid oligomers in all types of plaques, Lewy bodies and amylin deposits in the brain tissues of AD and PD patients and the pancreas of type 2 diabetes patients respectively, and showed that most amyloid fibril deposits were colocalized with oligomers in the tissues. Such conformation-dependent scFv antibodies may have potential application in the investigation of aggregate structures, the mechanisms of aggregation and cytotoxicity of various amyloids, and in the development of diagnostic and therapeutic reagents for many amyloidoses.     

Mechanism of prion propagation: amyloid growth occurs by monomer addition

Abundant nonfibrillar oligomeric intermediates are a common feature of amyloid formation, and these oligomers, rather than the final fibers, have been suggested to be the toxic species in some amyloid diseases. Whether such oligomers are critical intermediates for fiber assembly or form in an alternate, potentially separable pathway, however, remains unclear. Here we study the polymerization of the amyloidogenic yeast prion protein Sup35. Rapid polymerization occurs in the absence of observable intermediates, and both targeted kinetic and direct single-molecule fluorescence measurements indicate that fibers grow by monomer addition. A three-step model (nucleation, monomer addition, and fiber fragmentation) accurately accounts for the distinctive kinetic features of amyloid formation, including weak concentration dependence, acceleration by agitation, and sigmoidal shape of the polymerization time course. Thus, amyloid growth can occur by monomer addition in a reaction distinct from and competitive with formation of potentially toxic oligomeric intermediates.     

Elongated oligomers assemble into mammalian PrP amyloid fibrils

In prion diseases, the mammalian prion protein PrP is converted from a monomeric, mainly alpha-helical state into beta-rich amyloid fibrils. To examine the structure of the misfolded state, amyloid fibrils were grown from a beta form of recombinant mouse PrP (residues 91-231). The beta-PrP precursors assembled slowly into amyloid fibrils with an overall helical twist. The fibrils exhibit immunological reactivity similar to that of ex vivo PrP Sc. Using electron microscopy and image processing, we obtained three-dimensional density maps of two forms of PrP fibrils with slightly different twists. They reveal two intertwined protofilaments with a subunit repeat of approximately 60 A. The repeating unit along each protofilament can be accounted for by elongated oligomers of PrP, suggesting a hierarchical assembly mechanism for the fibrils. The structure reveals flexible crossbridges between the two protofilaments, and subunit contacts along the protofilaments that are likely to reflect specific features of the PrP sequence, in addition to the generic, cross-beta amyloid fold.     

The residue 129 polymorphism in human prion protein does not confer susceptibility to Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease by altering the structure or global stability of PrPC

There are two common forms of prion protein (PrP) in humans, with either methionine or valine at position 129. This polymorphism is a powerful determinant of the genetic susceptibility of humans toward both sporadic and acquired forms of prion disease and restricts propagation of particular prion strains. Despite its key role, we have no information on the effect of this mutation on the structure, stability, folding, and dynamics of the cellular form of PrP (PrP(C)). Here, we show that the mutation has no measurable effect on the folding, dynamics, and stability of PrP(C). Our data indicate that the 129M/V polymorphism does not affect prion propagation through its effect on PrP(C); rather, its influence is likely to be downstream in the disease mechanism. We infer that the M/V effect is mediated through the conformation or stability of disease-related PrP (PrP(Sc)) or intermediates or on the kinetics of their formation.     

Inter-oligomer interactions of the human prion protein are modulated by the polymorphism at codon 129

The common polymorphism at codon 129 in the human prion protein (PrP) has been shown in many studies to influence not only the pathology of prion disease but also the misfolding propensity of PrP. Here we used NMR, CD and atomic force microscopy in solution to investigate differences in β-oligomer (β^O) formation and inter-oligomer interaction depending on the polymorphism at codon 129. NMR investigations assigned the observable amide resonances to the β^O N-terminal segments, showing that it is the core region of PrP (residues 127-228) that is involved in β^O formation. Atomic force microscopy revealed distinctive 1.8 × 15 × 15-nm disk-like structures that form stacks through inter-oligomer interactions. The propensity to form stacks and the number of oligomers involved depended on the polymorphism at codon 129, with a significantly lower degree of stacking for β^O with valine at position 129. This result provides evidence for conformational differences between the β^O allelic forms, showing that the core region of the protein including position 129 is actively involved in inter-oligomer interactions, consistent with NMR observations.     

Structural characterization of beta-sheeted oligomers formed on the pathway of oxidative prion protein aggregation in vitro

The pathology of transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSEs) is strongly associated with the structural conversion of the cellular prion protein (PrPC) into a misfolded isoform (PrPSc) that assembles into amyloid fibrils. Since increased levels of oxidative stress have been linked to prion diseases, we investigated the metal-induced oxidation of human PrP (90-231). A novel in vitro conversion assay based on aerobic incubation of PrP in the presence of elemental copper pellets at pH 5 was established, resulting in aggregation of highly beta-sheeted prion proteins. We show for the first time that two discrete oligomeric species of elongated shape, approx. 25 mers and 100 mers, are formed on the pathway of oxidative PrP aggregation in vitro, which are well characterized regarding shape and size using small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS), dynamic light scattering (DLS), and electron microscopy (EM). Considering that small oligomers of highly similar size have recently been reported to show the highest specific infectivity within TSE-infected brain tissues of hamsters, the novel oligomers observed in this study are interesting candidates as agent causing neurodegenerative and/or self-propagating effects. Moreover, our results significantly strengthen the theory that oxidative stress might be an influence that leads to substantial structural conversions of PrP in vivo.     

Soluble oligomers are sufficient for transmission of a yeast prion but do not confer phenotype

Amyloidogenic proteins aggregate through a self-templating mechanism that likely involves oligomeric or prefibrillar intermediates. For disease-associated amyloidogenic proteins, such intermediates have been suggested to be the primary cause of cellular toxicity. However, isolation and characterization of these oligomeric intermediates has proven difficult, sparking controversy over their biological relevance in disease pathology. Here, we describe an oligomeric species of a yeast prion protein in cells that is sufficient for prion transmission and infectivity. These oligomers differ from the classic prion aggregates in that they are soluble and less resistant to SDS. We found that large, SDS-resistant aggregates were required for the prion phenotype but that soluble, more SDS-sensitive oligomers contained all the information necessary to transmit the prion conformation. Thus, we identified distinct functional requirements of two types of prion species for this endogenous epigenetic element. Furthermore, the nontoxic, self-replicating amyloid conformers of yeast prion proteins have again provided valuable insight into the mechanisms of amyloid formation and propagation in cells.     

Prion proteins as genetic material in fungi

Prions are infectious proteins. Several prions have been identified in fungi where they behave as non-Mendelian cytoplasmic genetic elements. Most of these prions propagate as self-perpetuating amyloid aggregates thus providing an example of structural heredity. In yeast, prion propagation requires the Hsp104 disaggregase presumably to sheer amyloid assemblies and generate more fiber ends. Recent work in yeast shows that amyloid structure polymorphism underlies the prion strain phenomenon and influences species barriers. Structural models for the amyloid form of several fungal prion proteins are now available. All propose a cross beta-organization with parallel beta-sheets. Whether or not some of the fungal prions might be beneficial to their host is still a debated issue.     

Hierarchical organization in the amyloid core of yeast prion protein Ure2

Formation of amyloid fibrils is involved in a range of fatal human disorders including Alzheimer, Parkinson, and prion diseases. Yeast prions, despite differences in sequence from their mammalian counterparts, share similar features with mammalian prions including infectivity, prion strain phenomenon, and species barrier and thus are good model systems for human prion diseases. Yeast prions normally have long prion domains that presumably form multiple β strands in the fibril, and structural knowledge about the yeast prion fibrils has been limited. Here we use site-directed spin labeling and electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy to investigate the structures of amyloid fibrils of Ure2 prion domain. We show that 15 spin-labeled Ure2 mutants, with spin labels at every 5th residue from position 5 to position 75, show a single-line or nearly single-line feature in their EPR spectra as a result of strong spin exchange interactions. These results suggest that a parallel in-register β structure exists at these spin-labeled positions. More interestingly, we also show that residues in the segment 30-65 have stronger spin exchange interactions, higher local stability, and lower solvent accessibility than segments 5-25 and 70-75, suggesting different local environment at these segments. We propose a hierarchical organization in the amyloid core of Ure2, with the segment 30-65 forming an inner core and the segments 5-25 and 70-75 forming an outer core. The hierarchical organization in the amyloid core may be a structural origin for polymorphism in fibrils and prion strains.     

Frequency distribution of PRNP polymorphisms in the Pakistani population

Prion diseases are neurodegenerative conditions caused by misfolding of a normal host-encoded prion protein (PrP^C) into pathogenic scrapie prion protein (PrP^Sc). In human prion diseases, the M129V prion protein polymorphism is known to confer susceptibility to the disease, determines PrP^Sc conformation and alters clinicopathological phenotypes. To date, all clinicopathologically confirmed cases of a variant form of Cruetzfeldt-Jacob disease (vCJD) have been 129MM homozygotes. There is also predominance of 129MM homozygotes in sporadic CJD (sCJD). No information regarding prion disorders is available from Pakistan. Although only invasive procedures like brain biopsy can confirm the diagnosis of prion disorders, testing a corresponding human population for variation in the prion protein gene (PRNP) may provide some insights into the presence of these disorders in a locality. The current study therefore aimed at exploring the genetic susceptibility of Pakistani population to CJD. A total of 909 unrelated individuals including 221 hemophiliacs representing all 4 major provinces of Pakistan were screened for M129V polymorphism and insertions or deletions of octapeptide repeats (OPRIs/OPRDs) using Polymerase Chain Reaction coupled with Restriction Fragment Length Polymorphism (PCR-RFLP). Concordance of the results of some PCR-RFLP reactions was also confirmed by dideoxy automated Sanger sequencing. The frequencies of M129V alleles (129M and 129V) and genotypes (129MM, 129MV and 129VV) were found in all 909 individuals to be 0.7101, 0.2899, 0.5270, 0.3663 and 0.1067, respectively. Deletion of 1 octapeptide repeat (1-OPRD) was detected in heterozygous state in PRNP of 10 individuals and in homozygous state in 1 individual. An insertion of 3 octapeptide repeats (3-OPRI) was found in 1 individual and an insertion of 1 octapeptide repeat (1-OPRI) in two individuals. Both 3-OPRI and 1-OPRI were present in heterozygous state and were linked to 129M allele. There were no significant χ² differences between M129V allelic and genotypic frequencies of healthy individuals and hemophiliacs. However, M129V allelic and genotypic frequencies differed significantly between Pakistani population and East Asian and Western populations. Non-significant χ² differences between M129V frequencies of healthy individuals and hemophiliacs suggest that individuals manifesting single gene disorders may provide naturally randomized samples for studies aiming at surveying the genetic variation. The combined excess of 129MM and 129VV homozygosity and the presence of 3-OPRI in 1 individual imply that Pakistani population is susceptible to prion disorders. Cases of prion disorders may exist in Pakistan, albeit at lower annual prevalence than other countries where life expectancy is greater than 65 years.